Questions and Replies

Reply:

The Public Investment Corporation (PIC) has policies and procedures in place to ensure that at all times procurement processes are fair, equitable, transparent and competitive as required by the Public Finance Management Act, Act 1 of 1999. However, during the audit for the 2019/20 financial year it was found that certain contracts have led to irregular expenditure. There were two main reasons for that:

1. The PIC Management was of the view that Treasury Regulations in instruction note 3 is silent on deviations against internal processes, therefore the internal PIC Delegation of Authority was applicable and was duly applied. Subsequent to this audit finding, National Treasury and the PIC Management had discussions and agreed that this view was of a technical nature. The PIC Management has also engaged National Treasury through the State Owned Enterprises Procurement Forum (SOEPF) on concerns with instruction note 3. However, to avoid any recurrence, all procurement that is not explicit in the applicable regulations or legislation, is discussed with National Treasury to avoid any misinterpretation.
2. In another instance the PIC Management approved a deviation as an emergency but due to the time frame taken to conclude the contract with the supplier, the audit opinion was that it should have been submitted to National Treasury for approval since it did not qualify as an emergency deviation that falls within the delegated authority of the Accounting Officer.

The PIC has improved its processes and procedures to prevent any recurrence.

Reply:

The Minister of Public Works and Infrastructure:

1) (a) I have been informed by the Department that DPWI is not aware of damages caused by a farmer and repairs done to the pipeline. However, a complaint was logged by the Hoedspruit Airforce Base for the repairs at the Essex pump station. This complaint was attended to on 30 May 2019 by Poppe Maphori JV Microzone and the job card was signed off accordingly by the client representative (FSGT Koekemoor) on 31 May 2019 for the amount of R51 06.00.

(b) No, the repairs were not on the main pipeline which is maintained by the Blyde River Water Utility Company (Pty) Ltd, but were at the Essex raw water pump station which is an alternative pipeline used when the mainline is not working. The main pipeline is a gravity line that supplies water to the Hoedspruit Air Force Base without the use of a pump station, whereas the Essex pump station is an alternative line that pumps water to the Air Force Base when the main line is not working.

2) Yes, Hoedspruit Air Force Base sources water from the Blyde River on a daily basis. The main pipeline that draws water to Hoedspruit Air Force Base is linked to the farmers (Parma) irrigation system. Parma is the farm where the main water pipeline runs through the agricultural irrigation system to the base.

The Essex station is the responsibility of DPWI and it pumps water much faster than the gravity line (main pipeline). Essex pump station is used as an alternative when the base experiences challenges with main pipeline (Blyde).

Reply:

(1) The Public Investment Corporation (PIC) has policies and procedures in place to ensure that at all times procurement processes are fair, equitable, transparent and competitive as required by the Public Finance Management Act, Act 1 of 1999. During the 2019/20 financial year there were instances where the PIC Management were of the view that the PIC’s Delegation of Authority should apply during the procurement process, but assurance providers took a different view, as they believed that approval should have been sought from National Treasury.

(2) There are two main reasons:

• The PIC Management was of the view that Treasury Regulations in instruction note 3 is silent on deviations against internal processes, therefore the internal PIC Delegation of Authority was applicable and was duly applied. Subsequent to this audit finding, National Treasury and the PIC Management had discussions and agreed that this view was of a technical nature. To avoid any recurrence, all procurement that is not explicit in the applicable regulations or legislation, is discussed with National Treasury to avoid any misinterpretation. The PIC Management has also engaged National Treasury through the State Owned Enterprises Procurement Forum (SOEPF) on concerns with instruction note 3.
• In another instance the PIC Management approved a deviation as an emergency but due to the time frame taken to conclude the contract with the supplier, the audit opinion was that it should have been submitted to National Treasury for approval since it did not qualify as an emergency deviation that falls within the delegated authority of the Accounting Officer.

The PIC has improved its processes and procedures to prevent any recurrence.

Reply:

The Director-General of the National Treasury attended the ANC NEC on the 23rd and 24th January 2021 in his personal capacity.

Reply:

NATIONAL TREASURY

1. Yes

1. The appointed Security company is Excellent Security
2. Rendering of security guarding services for the National Treasury buildings
3. The contract amount for the services is R28 467 243.60
4. The contract is for 3 years (January 2021-December 2023)

ASB

(i) NATIONAL SECURITY AND FIRE

(ii) Armed response and monitoring services

(iii) R645.84 per month

(iv) Contract commenced on 01 March 2020 – 1 month notice period, no specified contract length, but contract reviewed annually and request for quotations issued every three years.

DBSA

NO- The DBSA does not use private security firms, it has insourced security services. The personnel in that unit are all DBSA employees.

FIC

FINANCIAL INTELLIGENCE CENTRE, CENTURION

1. Raite Security
2. Providing physical security services
3. R 2 126 840.27
4. 01 April 2019 to 30 November 2023

FINANCIAL INTELLIGENCE CENTRE, CAPE TOWN

1. Striving Mind
2. Providing physical security services
3. R 1 401 512.16
4. 01 April 2020 to 31 March 2023

GEPF

The GEPF does not utlise private security firms as the landlord provides security services as part of the contract.

GPAA

The Government Employees Pension Agency (GPAA) does make use of private security firms for the sole purpose of protecting the employees and assets in respect of all of the GPAA’s 16 offices, which includes Head office, 15 regional and satellite office across the country in all nine provinces.

All procurement at the GPAA is in line with Public Finance Management Act prescripts. Therefore, the GPAA acquired the services after following an open tender process inviting bids to provide security services.

The details set out in Annexure A attached.

ANNEXURE A

Name of Company	Region (s)	Total value across multiple years	Duration of Service Agreement
			Start	End
Peuloane (Pty) Ltd	Security Services to GPAA HQ & Traven	R 39 386 603,75	2019/08/01	2022/07/31
Peuloane (Pty) Ltd	Security Services to GPAA DBN, PMB	R 3 878 152,14	2019/08/01	2022/07/31
Peuloane (Pty) Ltd	Security Services to GPAA Polokwane, Nelspruit, Thohoyandou	R 11 417 272,73	2019/08/01	2022/07/31
Peuloane (Pty) Ltd	Security Services to GPAA JHB, Rustenburg, Mafikeng	R 8 733 493,76	2019/08/01	2022/07/31
Peuloane (Pty) Ltd	Security Services to GPAA BFN, Phuthadichaba, Kimberley	R 8 320 608,14	2019/08/01	2022/07/31
Peuloane (Pty) Ltd	Security Services to GPAA PE, Bisho, Mthatha	R 8 971 897,34	2019/08/01	2022/07/31

IRBA

1. Fidelity – ADT
2. Armed response for building security
3. R926.72 per month
4. The term of the building lease

LAND BANK

(b) The Land and Agricultural Development Bank of South Africa as an entity under the National Treasury uses private security firms for the following purposes:

• Monitoring and Armed Response
• Static or Physical Guarding of Property

(b)(i) The following is a list of all service providers being uses:

BUILDING	SERVICE PROVIDER NAME
Bloemfontein	Fidelity Security
Bethlehem	Wulfe Alarms
Kroonstad	CSS
Cape Town	Fidelity ADT
Beaufort West	Beaufort-Alarms
Worcester	Capital Security
East London	Chubb – National Security (Pty)Ltd
Cradock	Cradock Sekuriteit
Port Elizabeth	Atlas Security
Nelspruit	ADT Security
Ermelo	ASCU Security
Ermelo	Bethal Security
Pietermaritzburg	PMB Security
Vryheid	Link Up Security
Polokwane	Salute Security
Tzaneen	Northern Security - Kloof Alarms
Upington	Fidelity Security
Vredendal	Fidelity Security
Vredendal	BAI Security
Vryburg	Ravens Security
Lichtenburg	Golden Eye Security
Rustenburg	ARS Security
Rustenburg	Fidelity Security
Potchefstroom	Fidelity Security
Head Office	Fidelity Security
Head Office	ADT Security

 

(b)(ii) Purpose of the services, is to protect people and assets in the case of Monitoring and Armed Response. Additional to this, it is to exercise access control, in the case of Static Guarding.

(b)(iii) Contract values differ significantly and can be expressed in the following manner:

BUILDING	SERVICE PROVIDER NAME	Contract value p/a, ex VAT	Type of Service
Bloemfontein	Fidelity Security	R5,520.00	Monitoring & Armed response
Bethlehem	Wulfe Alarms	R5,060.76	Monitoring & Armed response
Kroonstad	CSS	R3,798.24	Monitoring & Armed response
Cape Town	Fidelity ADT	R8,263.20	Monitoring & Armed response
Beaufort West	Beaufort-Alarms	R3,005.16	Monitoring & Armed response
Worcester	Capital Security	R4,219.80	Monitoring & Armed response
East London	Chubb – National Security (Pty)Ltd	R7,074.36	Monitoring & Armed response
Cradock	Cradock Sekuriteit	R2,473.68	Monitoring & Armed response
Port Elizabeth	Atlas Security	R2,869.56	Monitoring & Armed response
Nelspruit	ADT Security	R6,758.52	Monitoring & Armed response
Ermelo	ASCU Security	R5,791.32	Monitoring & Armed response
Ermelo	Bethal Security	R5,530.44	Monitoring & Armed response
Pietermaritzburg	PMB Security	R6,125.16	Monitoring & Armed response
Vryheid	Link Up Security	R5,263.20	Monitoring & Armed response
Polokwane	Salute Security	R5,980.32	Monitoring & Armed response
Tzaneen	Northern Security - Kloof Alarms	R5,739.12	Monitoring & Armed response
Upington	Fidelity Security	R7,014.12	Monitoring & Armed response
Vredendal	Fidelity Security	R3,856.56	Monitoring & Armed response
Douglas	BAI Security	R2,784.00	Monitoring & Armed response
Vryburg	Ravens Security	R3,130.44	Monitoring & Armed response
Lichtenburg	Golden Eye Security	R3,394.44	Monitoring & Armed response
Rustenburg	ARS Security	R10,643.52	Monitoring & Armed response
Rustenburg	Fidelity Security (Static Guarding)	R163,428.72	Physical Guards
Potchefstroom	Fidelity Security (Static Guarding)	R307,527.60	Physical Guards
Head Office	Fidelity Security (Static Guarding)	R2,122,054.56	Physical Guards
Head Office	ADT Security	R8,133.60	Monitoring & Armed response

(b)(iv) Duration or expiry of each Contract:

BUILDING	SERVICE PROVIDER NAME	Contract Expiry Date/Duration
Bloemfontein	Fidelity Security	08 July 2022
Bethlehem	Wulfe Alarms	Month to month
Kroonstad	CSS	Month to month
Cape Town	Fidelity ADT	01 April 2021
Beaufort West	Beaufort-Alarms	Month to month
Worcester	Capital Security	Month to month
East London	Chubb – National Security (Pty)Ltd	Month to month
Cradock	Cradock Sekuriteit	Month to month
Port Elizabeth	Atlas Security	Month to month
Nelspruit	ADT Security	Month to month
Ermelo	ASCU Security	Month to month
Ermelo	Bethal Security	Month to month
Pietermaritzburg	PMB Security	Month to month
Vryheid	Link Up Security	Month to month
Polokwane	Salute Security	Month to month
Tzaneen	Northern Security - Kloof Alarms	Month to month
Upington	Fidelity Security	01 April 2021
Vredendal	Fidelity Security	01 April 2021
Douglas	BAI Security	17 December 2022
Vryburg	Ravens Security	Month to Month
Lichtenburg	Golden Eye Security	Month to month
Rustenburg	ARS Security	Month to month
Rustenburg	Fidelity Security (Static Guarding)	Contract is Expiring 30 March 2021
Potchefstroom	Fidelity Security (Static Guarding)	Contract is Expiring 30 March 2021
Head Office	Fidelity Security (Static Guarding)	Contract is Expiring 30 March 2021
Head Office	ADT Security	Month to month

PFA

The Office of the Pension Funds Adjudicator does make use of private security firms. Its offices are rented and situated inside a secure office park.

PIC

(i) Bidvest Protea Coin (Pty) Ltd

(ii) Provision of security services at PIC’s head office at Central Square; Menlyn Maine.

(iii) R13 754 696 inclusive of VAT

(iv) 3 August 2018 to 31 August 2021

SARS

(i)(ii)(iii)(iv) SARS has contracted security service providers to render a service on four categories,

in terms of the normal procurement processes.

Category A: Armed Guarding, Close Protection and Tactical Response Security Services for a period of twelve (12) months

• • Tshedza Protective Services CC : contract value R 16 386 785

Category B: Armed Response and Alarm Monitoring Services for a period of three (3) years

• • Maxi Phumelela Security: contract value R 1 827 355.75
  • Royal Security CC: contract value R 678 670.20
  • Fidelity Security Services (Pty) Ltd : contract amount R 574 259.40

Category C: National Guarding Security Services for a period of twelve (12) months

• • Royal Security CC: contract value R 33 605 282.70
  • Fidelity Security Services (Pty) Ltd : contract value R 35 638 716.30
  • Wenzile Phaphama Security Services : contract value R 36 092 011.71

Category D: Secure transport of high value goods for a period of 5 years

• • Fidelity Security Services (Pty) Ltd: R 54 058 010.61

SASRIA

Name: Mavee Security (Pty) Ltd - 2012/033849/07

Purpose: To provide 24-hour security to the premises

Value: R847 800.00

Duration: 36 Months (Commencement Date 01 January 2021)

TAX OMBUD

• The Office of the Tax Ombud (OTO) uses physical security services for the Office building.
• The Fidelity security services are contracted to provide the physical security services to the OTO.
• The security company is contracted by the South African Revenue Service (SARS).
• The physical security expenses relating to OTO is paid centrally by SARS.

Reply:

The Minister of Public Works and Infrastructure:

a) I have been informed by the Department that the lessee can apply to renew the lease as per the conditions of the lease agreement.

b) Yes. If the decision is made to follow an open tender process, the lessee can apply when the property is advertised.

i) In terms of clause 2.2 of the Lease Agreement dated 15 November 2013 which is due to expire on 31 July 2022; this Department will facilitate a request for consideration for the relevant approval as to whether option a or b are to be followed. This process is anticipated to take approximately 3 months and expected to be finalized on or before 31 July 2021.

ii) The lessee will be advised of the outcome at the beginning of August 2021.

Reply:

1. There is no prospecting right that has been cancelled for not having met their approved EMP.
2. Section 31L of NEMA notices were issued to Right Holders, for non-compliance with the terms and conditions of the Environmental Authorisations as well as the provisions of the National Environmental Management Act (Act 107 of 1998), including but not limited to failure to submit environmental audit reports, annual financial provision assessment/review and excessive dust emission amongst others. In instances where there was a significant Environmental degradation or pollution directives were issued in terms of section 28 of NEMA.

(3)(a) Yes, please see the list for 2020/201 financial year

Seq No.	Reference Number	Actions taken
1	KZN10652PR	S31L (NOI): Financial Provision for a renewal
2	KZN10635PR	S31L (NOI): Financial Provision for a renewal
3	KZN544PR	S29(b): Closure Directive
4	KZN543PR	S29(b): Closure Directive
5	KZN495PR	S29(b): Closure Directive
6	KZN491PR	S29(b): Closure Directive
7	KZN10708PR	S31L (NOI): Financial Provision for a renewal
8	KZN196PR	S29(b): Closure Directive
9	KZN601PR	S29(b): Closure Directive
10	KZN204PR	S29(b): Closure Directive
11	KZN37PR	S31L (NOI): Financial Provision for a renewal
12	KZN10338PR	S31L (NOI): Financial Provision for a renewal

13	FS 10454 PR	Section 31L Pre-compliance notice was issued
14	FS 10453 PR	Section 31L Pre-compliance notice was issued
15	FS 10236 PR	Section 31L Pre-compliance notice was issued
16	FS 10235 PR	Section 31L Pre-compliance notice was issued
17	FS 10230 PR	Section 31L Pre-compliance notice was issued
18	FS 10205 PR	Section 31L Pre-compliance notice was issued
19	FS 10320 PR	Instruction in terms of section 93 was issued
20	FS 10433 PR	Instruction in terms of section 93 was issued
21	FS 10411 PR	Instruction in terms of section 93 was issued
22	FS 449 PR	Instruction in terms of section 93 was issued
23	NC 11703 PR	31L Notice of NEMA Act 1998
24	NC 11815 PR	31L Notice of NEMA Act 1998
25	NC 12787 PR	31L Notice of NEMA Act 1998
26	NC 11699 PR	31L Notice of NEMA Act 1998
27	LP 11828 PR	31L Notice of NEMA Act 1998
28	LP 13490 PR	31L Notice of NEMA Act 1998
29	LP 11844 PR	31L Notice of NEMA Act 1998

30	WC 10262PR	Sect 31L NEMA
31	WC 10261PR	Sect 31L NEMA
32	NW 12258 PR	Sect 31L NEMA
33	NW 12230 PR	Sect 31L NEMA
34	NW 12703 PR	Sect 31L NEMA

Reply:

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

WRITTEN REPLY

THE MINISTER OF AGRICULTURE, LAND REFORM AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT:

The community referred to herein is Ncanywa Grain Crop Cooperative based in the Matatiele Local Municipality. The reasons for non-delivery of seeds and fertiliser to the smallholder farmers are that Ncanywa Grain Crop Cooperative did not apply for support in the 2020/21 cropping season. A different project by the name of Qhobosheaneng Maize Project applied and was approved for the 2020/21 cropping season for 15 ha of inputs under food security.

Qhobosheaneng Maize Project entered into an agreement to exchange the inputs with Ncanywa Grain Crop Cooperative without informing the Eastern Cape Department of Rural Development and Agrarian Reform (EC DRDAR). It became a challenge to implement this exchange, because the EC DRDAR was already in the phase of distributing inputs to beneficiaries that were approved initially. Ncanywa Grain Crop Cooperative did not form part of the EC DRDAR approved plans for inputs support as they had not applied for the 2020/21 cropping season.

The Department had an agreement with Qobosheaneng and the inputs were given to Qhobosheaneng Maize Project that formed part of the initial departmental plan. Ncanywa Grain Crop Agricultural Cooperative has applied for support in August 2020 which is the application process for the 2021/22 cropping season. The application will undergo all the relevant processes for approval.

Reply:

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

WRITTEN REPLY

THE MINISTER OF AGRICULTURE, LAND REFORM AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT:

1. Thirty-one (31) “state” farms, which are located in Limpopo, Mpumalanga and North West are currently leased to mining companies.

1. The context to the second part of the question is that:

• • The existing mining leases are generally a combination of old order mining rights that were known as Mineral Leases or Notarial Lease of Mineral Rights, and surface leases that have since April 1994 been concluded in terms of the State Land Disposal Act, 1961, read together with the Interim Protection of Informal Land Rights Act, 1996.

• • The Mineral Leases or Notarial Lease of Mineral Rights were concluded in circumstances where there was no statutory requirement for consultation of people who utilise the land in the event of such land being earmarked for mining. The details of the people who were utilising the land or were entitled to utilise the land were therefore never collected at the time of the conclusion of the leases.

• • On the post April 1994 surface leases, neither the State Land Disposal Act nor the Interim Protection of Informal Rights Act require that the names and locations of the people who reside on the farms that are leased to mining companies should be collected. The Interim Protection of Informal Land Rights Act requires the decision to make land available for mining or any other form of land development to be taken by the majority of the holders of rights who are present or represented in a meeting that has been convened to take a resolution on that matter. This requirement implies that the list of people who attended a land rights holders resolution meeting must at least be recorded. This is consequently the only list that generally gets recorded at the time the land rights holders resolve to make the land available for mining or any other land development purpose.

• • The leased land also tends to be a common asset of large numbers of people that are spread over many villages. The necessity for recording personal information of all the people who occupy some components of leased land has just never been considered hence such information has never been collected.

Reply:

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

WRITTEN REPLY

THE MINISTER OF AGRICULTURE, LAND REFORM AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT:

1. (a) R 9 640 943

1. Please refer to the table below:

Eastern Cape	Free State	Gauteng	KwaZulu Natal	Limpopo	Mpumalanga	North West	Northern Cape	Western Cape	Total
187	249	180	120	139	260	143	268	59	1 605

1. The Proactive land Acquisition Strategy bank account.

1. (a) Yes, the Agricultural Land Holding Account is administered by the Department of Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

1. No, in terms of clause 16, of the State Land Lease and Disposal policy. maintenance is a lessee responsibility

Reply:

The Department is currently developing an Exploration Implementation Plan to enhance exploration attractiveness and will position the country to at least 3% share of the global exploration expenditure in the next 3 to 5 years.

Reply:

The information to respond to this question was obtained from the North West Provincial Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

1. Financial Management - The implementation of Municipal Property Rates Act (MPRA)
   1. The Rustenburg Local Municipality was behind with the processes to comply with compilation and implementation of the General Valuation Roll (GVR) to be implemented on 1st July 2020. The North West Provincial Department of COGTA intervened and advised the Municipality to request for the extension of the validity period of the GVR, which was complied with and granted. The MEC responsible for local government in the North West Provnice further initiated and advised that the process plan be adopted which the Municipality did and the Steering Committee was appointed by the Municipal Council.

• 1. The Steering Committee meetings were held on a monthly basis from August 2020 with the support of the North West Provincial Department of COGTA discussing the progress in relation to the processes, procedures of the MPRA, including the importance of honouring the time-frames to ensure the smooth implemention of the new General Valuation roll with effect from 1 July 2021. Moreover, on the 28th of August 2020 a special council meeting was held regarding the determination on date of valuation as per section 31 of Municipal Property Rates Act no. 4 of 2006.

• 1. The Rustenburg LM received their new valuation roll at the end of January 2021 for implementation on the 1st July 2021 as prescribed by the MPRA.

• 1. On the 2 February 2021, the North West Provincial Department compiled Section 49 (1) (a) (b) and (c) letter to advising the Municipality on compliance thereof and the consequences of non-compliance as stipulated in terms of MPRA, which was subsequently followed by Sections 8, 9 and 20 letter on the 17 March 2021 advising on the categories of rates policy and limits on annual increase of rate to be properly aligned with the property categories.

1. 2021/22 Intervention Measures:
   1. The North West Provincial Department to continue to monitor the process to ensure smooth implementation of the General Valuation Roll on the 1st July 2021.
   2. The North West Provincial Department will closely monitor the completeness of Section 49 of the MPRA process, which also includes Chapter 4 of the Municipal Systems Act, i.e. public participation.
   3. The North West Provincial Department to ensure that the inputs to the Rates Policy of the Municipality finds expression in line with the new valuation roll to be implemented on the 1st July 2021.
   4. There are continuous engagement session with Government Departments on debts owed to the Municipality for improved cash flow.
   5. The Rustenburg LM has been identified as one of the big city in the North West Province to be monitored and supported on the ‘Responsible Citizenry Campaign’ initiative by Government. To this end, the Municipality was engaged to start with the launch of the Campaign.

1. Governance
   1. A Section 154 of the Constitution support package was developed for Rusternburg Municipality in 2018 when Section 100(1)(a) was invoked, currently the North West Provincial Department is in a process of reviewing the Section 154 support package that will be integrated into the draft DDM One Plan for the Bojanala District Municpality.
   2. The Provincial Department developed a dummy oversight report, together with the Municipality and provided guidance on the usage of the dummy oversight report.
   3. The Provincial Department monitored and supported the Municipality on the drafting and submission of the oversight report to the legislature, in compliance with Section 132 of the MFMA. The Municipality managed to develop the oversight report before the national lockdown. A meeting to table the report to council was scheduled for 31 March 2020, but the report only served in the council after the regulations for level 3 on Covid-19 were issued out, which lead to the Municipality submitting its oversight report as well as annual report on the 12th June 2020. Feedback on the assessment of the oversight report was issued to the Municipality.
   4. Training on how to address the Unathorised, Irregular, Fruitless and Wasteful (UIF&W) expenditure was conducted to support staff of the Municipality, as well as to the members of the MPAC, members of the Disciplinary Board and Finance Committees in collaboration with SALGA, National and Provincial Treasuries.

Reply:

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

WRITTEN REPLY

 

THE MINISTER OF AGRICULTURE, LAND REFORM AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT:

1. (a) There are 09 Strategic Partnership that the Commission on Restitution of Land Rights (CRLR) is aware of, however we are unable to provide a comprehensive number as some partnership are facilitated directly by the claimants themselves without the involvement of the Commission.

(b)

CLAIMANTS/ BENEFICIARIES	STRATEGIC PARTNER
Riemvasmaak Claim – BONO	Bono Trust
Steinroof-hom – Establishment of the Schamboua CPA	Steinroof-Hom Partners
Khutso Naketsi Agri	NHP Pretorius
Nietverdiendt Game Farming Project involving four Bahurutshe Communities	Mike Engelzakis
Ebenhaeser Land Claim	VINPRO; STELLAR CELLARS; LUTZVILLE CELLARS; TYGER BRANDS; S.A.D (PEPSICO)
Emakhasaneni Community Trust	South African Farmers Development Association (SAFDA) and Manzini Estate
Ntembeni Community Trust	South African Farmers Development Association (SAFDA)
Ntembeni Royal House Community Trust	South African Farmers Development Association (SAFDA)
Isizwe sakwaDludla Community Trust	South African Farmers Development Association (SAFDA)

(2) There has not been a unit within the department that does assessment of strategic partners. However, in developing a fit-for-purpose structure a unit dealing with post-settlement support will undertake this task.

END

Reply:

Honourable Stubbe, the requested information was finally obtained. Find below the reply to question 193, which is constituted of responses to previous four questions (176, 177, 178 and 179) with outstanding replies. Some of these questions, especially the electricity related questions, were comprehensively responded to at a Portfolio Committee meeting held in December 2019, when Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality was summoned to respond orally. Previous responses are attached as annexures A, B, C and D.

 

Background:

As indicated above the reply to PQ 193 is constituted of annexures A, B, C and D. With regards to the reply to PQ 176, answers for the question are contained in annexure A. In annexure B, PQ 177 is addressed. For the reply to PQ 178, answers are contained in annexure C. Finally, annexure D provides the response to PQ 179.

 

MINISTRY FOR COOPERATIVE GOVERNANCE AND TRADITIONAL AFFAIRS

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

QUESTION FOR WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NUMBER 2020/176

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 21 FEBRUARY 2020

Mr M Waters (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

Whether, with reference to her replies to questions (a) 185 on 22 March 2019, (b) 186 on 22 March 2019, (c) 187 on 25 March 2019 and (d) 598 on 22 March 2019, she will furnish Mr M Waters with copies of all (i) correspondence in which her department requested the said information and (ii) the responses from the City of Ekurhuleni; if not, why not? NW197E

The information used to respond to this question was provided by the Gauteng Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.

Reply:

(i) Correspondence concerning PQ 185, PQ 186, PQ 187 and PQ 598 is attached.

(ii) Please see responses to PQ 185, PQ 186, PQ 187, and PQ 598 below.

The response to question PQ 185 is as follows:

1. The City of Ekurhuleni’s Energy Department, implemented an approved Maintenance Plan guided by and aligned with the Department’s Maintenance Philosophy, Maintenance Strategy, NRS047, NRS048, NRS082, NRS089, Occupation Health and Safety Act and Regulations and NERSA license conditions.

1. In terms of the above-mentioned Maintenance Plan, the Electricity Distribution Assets are inspected and maintained on a weekly, monthly, six monthly, yearly and two yearly basis.

1. Please refer to (b) above.

(d) The Department utilizes a Computerized Maintenance Management System (CMMS) on which all maintenance activities are generated and maintained.

The response to question PQ 186 is as follows:

1. The approved repairs and maintenance budget for Energy Department is as follows

2018/2019

Estimated Budget: Estimated Expenditure:

R840 million 100%

2017/2018

Estimated Budget Estimated Expenditure

R979 million 84%

2016/2017

Estimated Budget Estimated Expenditure

R943 million 92%

It should be noted that the vote number structure was changed during above mentioned financial years in order to comply with mSCOA requirements and hence the variations in the amounts indicated.

1. The approved Operation Expenditure budget was not reduced but funding was transferred from one vote number to another in order to address specific requirements.

The response to question PQ 187 is as follows:

1. There were two contracts in total that were awarded during 2017/18; 2018/19 and 2019/20 with winning bidders and the estimate values are specified below:

A-EE 11/2017	Appointment of a service providers for supply, delivery and off-loading of metal clad switchgear on an as when required basis for period from date of award until REDUCED period until 30 June 2018	9-Oct-17	Ampcor Khanyisa (Pty) Ltd	R 100,000,000.00
			Stateway Switchboards (Pty) Ltd	R 100,000,000.00
			Tgood Africa (Pty) Ltd	R 100,000,000.00
			Edison Power Ltd	R 100,000,000.00

A-EE 07/2017	Supply, delivery, off-loading, sampling, analyzing, purification, regeneration, management and disposal of insulating oil (uninhibited) for transformers, control gear and switchgear - as and when - until 30 June 2019	19-Feb-18	Silver Solutions 435 CC	R 13,428,593.33
			Jas Engineering CC	R 6,007,666.67
			Only-J Electrical & Construction CC	R 4,195,666.67
			Accolade Engineers (Pty) Ltd	R 4,901,926.67
			Wegezi Power Holdings (Pty) Ltd	R 3,089,926.67

1. Yes, contract number A-EE 07/2017 was reduced until 30 June 2018. The attached minutes of the BAC do not specify reasons for reduction of the period.

The names of the companies that benefited from these reductions are:

• Ampcor Khanyisa (Pty) Ltd
• Stateway Switchboards (Pty) Ltd
• Tgood Africa (Pty) Ltd
• Edison Power Ltd

The response to question PQ 598 is as follows:

1. 49 cases

(b) See table below

(c) See table below

Alleged Offence	SAPS Station	SAPS CAS number	Outcome
Assault	Edenvale	120/08/2017	Criminal matter withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
Corruption	Thokoza	42/09/2017	Criminal matter withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
Assault	Primrose	76/09/2017 and 56/09/2017	Both criminal matters withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
House breaking	Bedfordview	100/09/2017	Criminal matter in court
Culpable Homicide	Springs	105/09/2017	Still under investigation by SAPS
Corruption	Tembisa	253/09/2017	Still under investigation by SAPS
Drunk and Driving Loss of firearm	Springs Springs	303/09/2017 and 304/09/2017	Still under investigation by SAPS Still under investigation by SAPS
Armed robbery, corruption and Defeating the ends of justice	Benoni	33/10/2017	Criminal matter in court
Corruption	Duduza	112/11/2017	Criminal matter in court
Unlicensed firearm	Emondle KZN	115/11/2017	Still under investigation by SAPS
Unlicensed firearm	Norkem Park	05/12/2017	Still under investigation by SAPS
Corruption	Alberton	280/12/2017	Criminal matter in court
Drink and driving	Germiston	356/12/2017	Still under investigation by SAPS
Discharge of firearm	Tsakane	406/12/2017	Criminal matter withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
Corruption	Kempton Park	697/12/2017	Still under investigation by SAPS
Reckless driving	Thokoza	19/01/2018	Criminal matter withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
Trespassing	Actonville	47/01/2018	Still under investigation by SAPS
Crimen Injuria	Katlehong	48/01/2018	Still under investigation by SAPS
Assault	Nigel	07/02/2018	Criminal matter withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
Corruption	Mondeor	455/02/2018	Criminal matter in court
Discharge of firearm	Benoni	04/03/2018	Criminal matter withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
Murder	Daveyton	18/03/2018	Matter finalised guilty – sentence imprisonment
Pointing of Firearm	Katlehong	238/03/2018	Still under investigation by SAPS
Murder	Tsakane	415/03/2018	Criminal matter in court
Trading in precious metals (Gold)	Springs	370/04/2018	Still under investigation by SAPS
Corruption	Welbekend	42/05/2018	Still under investigation by SAPS
Corruption	Katlehong North	62/05/2018	Criminal matter in court
Corruption	Vosloorus	420/05/2018	Criminal matter in court
Fraud and corruption	Mtubatuba KZN	26/07/2018	Still under investigation by SAPS
Corruption	Brakpan	11/08/2018	Still under investigation by SAPS
Pointing of firearm	Springs	99/08/2018	Still under investigation by SAPS
Corruption (Selling of Jobs)	Brakpan	156/08/2018	Criminal matter withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
Assault	Vosloorus	06/10/2018	Still under investigation by SAPS
Use vehicle without permission	Primrose	142/10/2018	Still under investigation by SAPS
Assault	Etwatwa	183/10/2018	Still under investigation by IPID
Corruption	Tembisa	473/10/2018	Criminal matter in court
Assault	Alberton	201/11/2018	Still under investigation
Domestic Violence	Crystal Park	275/11/2018	Criminal matter withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
Attempted murder	Tembisa	300/01/2019	Still under investigation by SAPS
Possession of stolen vehicle	Springs	453/02/2019	Criminal matter withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
Discharge firearm in residential area	Boksburg	43/03/2019	Still under investigation by SAPS
Attempted Murder	Springs	531/03/2019	Still under investigation by SAPS
Armed robbery	Kempton Park	685/03/2019	Still under investigation by SAPS
Pointing of firearm	Kempton Park	291/04/2019	Still under investigation by SAPS
Domestic violence	Springs	264/05/2019	Criminal matter withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
Loss of firearm	Vosloorus	30/07/2019	Still under investigation by SAPS
Corruption	Tembisa	238/07/2019	Still under investigation by SAPS

Summary

Period 01 August 2017 to 31 August 2019 (2 years)

Type of criminal case Total number

Corruption 14

Assault 07

Discharge of firearm 03

Crimen injuria 01

Possession of unlicensed firearm 02

Pointing of firearm 03

Murder 02

Drunk driving 02

Attempted murder 02

Armed robbery 02

Domestic violence 02

Reckless and Negligence driving 01

Trading in precious metal (Gold) 01

Possession of stolen vehicle 01

Culpable homicide 01

House breaking 01

Loss of firearm 02

Trespassing 01

Use vehicle without owner permission 01

TOTAL 49

MINISTRY FOR COOPERATIVE GOVERNANCE AND TRADITIONAL AFFAIRS

REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

QUESTION FOR WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NUMBER 2020/177

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 21 FEBRUARY 2019

Mrs A M Waters (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

Whether, with reference to her replies to questions (a) 604 on 22 March 2019, (b) 605 on 22 March 2019, (c) 607 on 22 March 2019, (d) 32 on 5 July 2019 and (e) 129 on 5 July 2019, she will furnish Mr M Waters with copies of all (i) correspondence in which her department requested the said information and (ii) the responses from the City of Ekurhuleni; if not, why not? NW198E

The information used to respond to this question was provided by the Gauteng Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.

Reply:

(i) Correspondence concerning PQ 129, PQ 604, PQ 605 and PQ 607 is attached.

(ii) Please see responses to PQ 129, PQ 503, PQ 504 and PQ 505 below.

The response to question PQ 129 is as follows:

(1) (a) There is no legal prescript to conduct an audit on the armoury.  In terms of the Firearms Control Act 60 of 2000 an annual stock register must be provided to the Central Firearm Registrar at the end of each year.

The South African Police Service (SAPS), Division FLASH (Firearms, Liquor & 2nd Goods) & CFR (Central Firearm Registry) conduct annual random inspections to confirm full compliance to the Firearms Control Act 60 of 2000.

(b) Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Police Department conducted the current audit. However, the SAPS also conduct formal random inspections every year. The last SAPS Inspection took place during September 2019.

(2) (a) The audit was conducted over a lengthy period to cater for officers on shifts, leave, study- & sick leave. After the audit was completed there were no officers that did not report for the audit.

(b) No action was needed.

(3) (a) The National Police Commissioner has been informed and a national subcommittee to resolve Official Institution Firearm related issues has been established and is meeting on a regular basis. The meeting is chaired by Brig Bopape, SAPS CFR and co-chaired by Brig Spies (EMPD) on behalf of all Metro Police Depts.

(b) No action was needed against individuals as it is a National SAPS CFR Official Institution Firearm register that needs to be updated and corrected by SAPS.

(4) The EMPD is currently updating and modernising its firearm policy in order to align with various legislative prescripts.

The response to question PQ 503 is as follows:

1. What are the reasons that residents in the (a) Kempton Park and (b) Germiston areas within the Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality are experiencing constant sporadic and unreliable refuse collection services;

• Waste management services are transport reliant and dependent largely on mechanical workshop for repairs and maintenance to ensure availability of vehicles when breakdowns are experienced. It is thus imperative to have maximum vehicle availability at all times in order to effect seamless service to the community, which unfortunately due to turnaround times to repairs, sometimes it becomes a challenge to be on schedule owing to shortage of trucks.

1. (a) in what number of instances has the municipality transgressed the National Environmental Management Act, Act 107 of 1998, by failing to collect refuse once a week within seven days this calendar year,

• Twice

(b) which areas were affected,

• Kempton Park

(c) what are the reasons for each transgression

• Shortage of vehicles due to breakdowns

(d) what steps is the municipality taking to ensure that it provides basic services to residents according to applicable legislation?

• That it be mentioned that it is the endeavor of the department to ensure that residents receive at least one service per week in accordance with the National Domestic Waste Collection Standards. Whenever backlogs are created the City re-allocate resources within the next day or same week to deal with the existing backlogs. In such instances, residents are informed about the challenges experienced and when to take out their bins for collection.

The response to question PQ 504 is as follows:

(1) Please see the attached document for more information on the vehicles that were budgeted for and purchased. The number of refuse collection trucks that were budgeted for corresponds to the number of trucks that were actually purchased.

(2)  There were no variances between what was budgeted for and what was actually purchased.

The response to question PQ 505 is as follows:

1. (a) Ten

(b) Where is each depot situated?

DEPOT	ADDRESS	CONTACT DETAILS
Alberton	Swartkoppies Complex, Swartkoppies Road, Randhart, Alberton	011 999 2598
Bedfordview	Cnr Van Vuuren and Skeen Boulevard, Bedfordview	011 999 0915
Benoni	4 Golden Drive, Morehill, Benoni	011 999 6827
Brakpan	C/o Lemmer and Denner Roads, Vulcania, Brakpan	011 999 7731
Boksburg	19 Reservoir Street, Boksburg South, Boksburg	011 999 5070
Edenvale	Cnr Lahla & Bahla rd, Sebenza, Edenvale	011 999 40/50
Germiston	Ostend Road (south of Jack Pienaar), Lower Germiston	011 999 5432
Kempton Park	Cnr H Lewis & Kelvin rd, Spartan , Kempton Park	011 999 4075
Nigel	Fred Wagener Street, Prosperitas, Nigel	011 999 9251
Springs	Stadium Road, Geduld Extention 4 Springs	011 999 8509

(c) Which geographical areas does each depot cover in relation to waste collection?

DEPOT	ADDRESS	CONTACT DETAILS
Alberton	Swartkoppies Complex, Swartkoppies Road, Randhart, Alberton	011 999 2598
Bedfordview	Cnr Van Vuuren and Skeen Boulevard, Bedfordview	011 999 0915
Benoni	4 Golden Drive, Morehill, Benoni	011 999 6827
Brakpan	C/o Lemmer and Denner Roads, Vulcania, Brakpan	011 999 7731
Boksburg	19 Reservoir Street, Boksburg South, Boksburg	011 999 5070
Edenvale	Cnr Lahla & Bahla rd, Sebenza, Edenvale	011 999 40/50
Germiston	Ostend Road (south of Jack Pienaar), Lower Germiston	011 999 5432
Kempton Park	Cnr H Lewis & Kelvin rd, Spartan , Kempton Park	011 999 4075
Nigel/ Duduza	Fred Wagener Street, Prosperitas, Nigel	011 999 9251
Springs/ Kwa-Thema	Stadium Road, Geduld Extention 4 Springs	011 999 8509

(d) What number of households and businesses are within the collection area of each depot?

The following areas are serviced by the City of Ekurhuleni internal staff:

DEPOT	SERVICE POINTS
Alberton	32307
Bedfordview	10659
Benoni	56561
Brakpan	23496
Boksburg	38823
Edenvale	18838
Germiston	50368
Kempton Park	59061
Nigel/ Duduza	30282
Springs/ Kwa-Thema	48177

 The following areas are serviced by the Service Providers:

AREA	SERVICE POINTS
Katlehong	54043
Thokoza	42759
Vosloorus/Boksburg South N17	57154
Tsakane/Langaville	46164
Daveyton/Etwatwa	56319
Tembisa 1 and Tembisa 2	74252

(2) 1:1000

(3)  

Vehicle Type	Depot	Mech. W/shop Responsible	Defect	Date of Breakdown	Days Out-standing	Workshop Remarks/Progress/ Comments
Compactor	Alberton	Alberton	Gears	2018/08/20	70	Department signed,DH signed documents were dropped off at CPO today 25.10.2018 for order number
Compactor	Alberton	Alberton	Control lever	2018/09/04	55	The report we received from the foreman was not correct, unfortunately he is on leave but we managed to get hold of the documents, compiled,signed and was sent to CPO for order number. 17.10.2018. Order outstanding
Compactor	Alberton	Alberton	Tail gate, lifter	2018/10/25	4	Qoutation outstanding
Compactor	Alberton	Alberton	Tailgate cover	2018/10/26	3	Booked in on 26 October 2018
Compactor	Alberton	Alberton	Service	2018/10/29	0	Booked in on 29 October 2018
Compactor	Alberton	Alberton	Gearbox	2018/08/31	59	Department signed,DH signed documents were dropped off at CPO today 25.10.2018 for order number
FEL	Boksburg	Boksburg	Overheating	2018/09/19	40	Strip & quote
REL	Boksburg	Boksburg	Packer blade cracked	2018/10/23	6	Awaiting official order
Lugger	Boksburg	Boksburg	Service & COF	2018/08/10	80	Awaiting official order
Lugger	Boksburg	Boksburg	Hydraulic Service	2018/08/15	75	14-4 signed by Manager to go to Fleet(At Keptonpark for signature)
REL	Boksburg	Boksburg	PTO Pump burned	2018/08/10	80	Strip & quote
Lugger	Boksburg	Boksburg	Hydraulic Service	2018/08/10	80	Awaiting official order
REL	Boksburg	Boksburg	COF & Service	2018/09/28	31	14-4 signed by Manager to go to Fleet
REL	Boksburg	Boksburg	Oil & Service	2018/07/23	98	Strip & quote
REL	Boksburg	Boksburg	Mian cylinder damaged	2018/06/14	137	Awaiting official order
REL	Boksburg	Boksburg	Damaged sweeper cylinder	2018/09/28	31	14-4 Initialed, must be signed by acting DH: Waste
REL	Boksburg	Boksburg	COF & Service	2018/10/15	14	14-4 signed by Manager to go to Fleet(At Keptonpark for signature)
REL	Boksburg	Boksburg	Check Hydraulics	2018/10/19	10	14-4 signed by Manager to go to (At signature for signature)
Roll On	Boksburg	Boksburg	Clutch	2018/10/22	7	Awaiting official order
Compactor	Germiston	Germiston	TRANSMISSION	2018/09/19	40	GERMISTON DEPOT
Compactor	Germiston	Germiston	BIN LIFTERS	2018/10/25	4	GERMISTON DEPOT
Compactor	Germiston	Germiston	SWITCH LINK BROKEN	2018/10/25	4	SWITCH LINK BROKEN
Compactor	Germiston	Germiston	BIN LIFTERS	2018/02/05	266	BIN LIFTERS/AWAITING TENDER
Compactor	Germiston	Germiston	CYLINDER MOUNTINGS	2018/06/14	137	CYLINDER MOUNTING
Compactor	Germiston	Germiston	COMPACT SPEED SLOW	2018/10/12	17	COMPACT SPEED SLOW
Compactor	Germiston	Germiston	OVERHEAT	2018/09/12	47	OVERHEAT/TRANSMISSION
Compactor	Germiston	Germiston	SERVICE	2018/10/01	28	SERVICE
Compactor	Germiston	Germiston	HYDRAULIC OIL LEAKS	2018/07/24	97	HYDRAULIC OIL LEAKS
Compactor	Benoni	Benoni	Hydrolic Pipe Leak	2018/07/13	108	papers for last signature/at DH Fleet
Compactor	Benoni	Benoni	Service & C.O.F	2018/10/01	28	order received/awaiting for spares
Compactor	Benoni	Benoni	Sweeper Blade Broken	2018/07/30	91
Compactor	Benoni	Benoni	No Power	2018/04/23	189
D/Diff Lift On	Benoni	Benoni	Leaking from Gear Box	2018/08/06	84
Compactor	Benoni	Benoni	P.T.O Pump Problem	2018/08/21	69
Compactor	Benoni	Benoni	Bin Lifters Broken	2018/10/02	27
Compactor	Benoni	Benoni	Hydrolic Oil Leak	2018/04/05	207
Lift-On	Benoni	Benoni	Overheating	2018/10/05	24
Compactor	Brakpan	Brakpan	COF	2018/09/19	40	VEHICLE CAME BACK FROM COF. WAS THEN REPORTED FOR GEARS. GEO ATTENDING TO PROBLEM AT PRESENT.
Load Lugger	Brakpan	Brakpan	Hydraulic pipe leaks on both Jack	2018/10/02	27
Compactor	Brakpan	Brakpan	Tail gate open half,head light and dash board,rear lights not working.	2018/10/10	19
Load Lugger	Brakpan	Brakpan	COF	2018/09/17	42
Skip	Springs	Springs	brake lights	2018/10/04	25
Compactor	Springs	Springs	Hydraulic leak	2018/10/26	3	Awaiting order
Compactor	Springs	Springs	Work in Kemptonpark	2018/10/08	21
Skip	Springs	Springs	Repair rediator	2018/10/22	7	Awaiting order
Lugger	Nigel	Nigel	Gearbox ,COF	2018/04/11	201
REL	Nigel	Nigel	Vehicle damaged by protesters	2018/07/09	112	Vehicle damaged during civil unrest
LDV	Nigel	Nigel	Oil seals	2018/08/20	70	Order submitted
REL	NIGEL	Nigel	Head gasket, radiator, turbo	2018/08/28	62	Awaitng order
Roro	Nigel	Nigel	Transmission problems	2018/10/23	6
REL	Kempton Park	Kempton Park	Hydraulics	2018/10/16	13	Busy with repairs
REL	Kempton Park	Kempton Park	Bin lifter arm broken	2018/10/03	26	Awaiting a quotation, Hydrapump sent vehicle back to Depo while waiting for quotation
REL	Kempton Park	Kempton Park	COF	2018/10/03	26	Busy with repairs
SKIP	Kempton Park	Kempton Park	Gearbox	2018/07/16	105	Busy with repairs
REL	Kempton Park	Kempton Park	Service	2018/07/16	105	Busy with service
REL	Kempton Park	Kempton Park	Hydraulic Pipe Burst	2018/10/18	11	Busy with repairs
ROLL ON	Kempton Park	Kempton Park	Boom Arm Sensors	2018/10/16	13	Awaiting order
Mec-Benz	Edenvale	Kempton park	C.O.F and Service	2018/09/19	40
Nissan	Edenvale	Kempton park	Engine oil leak	2018/08/20	70
Nissan	Edenvale	Kempton park	Lifting boom cracked	2018/07/30	91
Isuzu	Edenvale	Kempton park	Clutch blade to be replaced	2018/10/05	24
Nissan	Edenvale	Mopedi	Air Leak and hydro oil pump	2018/10/24	5
Nissan	Edenvale	Panel Beater	Front Panel Gril	2018/10/29	0
Nissan	Edenvale	W/SHOP	C.O.F and Service	2018/10/29	15
Compactor	BEDFORD	KEMPTON	GEARBOX	2018/07/19	102	We received the quotation on the 16.08.2018
Skiploader	BEDFORD	KEMPTON	GEARBOX	2018/08/31	59	GEO ENGINEERING TO RE-INSPECT THE TRUCK
Compactor	BEDFORD	KEMPTON	GEARBOX OIL LEAK	2018/10/18	11
					43402

MINISTRY FOR COOPERATIVE GOVERNANCE AND TRADITIONAL AFFAIRS

REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

QUESTION FOR WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NUMBER 2020/178

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 21 FEBRUARY 2019

Mrs A M Waters (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

Whether, with reference to her replies to questions (a) 130 on 5 July 2019, (b) 131 on 5 July 2019, (c) 187 on 5 July 2019 and (d) 239 on 1 August 2019, she will furnish Mr M Waters with copies of all (i) correspondence in which her department requested the said information and (ii) the responses from the City of Ekurhuleni; if not, why not? NW199E

The information used to respond to this question was provided by the Gauteng Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.

Reply:

The response to question 178 consists of replies to the following questions, PQ 130, 131 and 187, which are attached for ease of reference.

MINISTRY FOR COOPERATIVE GOVERNANCE AND TRADITIONAL AFFAIRS

REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

QUESTION FOR WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NUMBER 2020/179

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 21 FEBRUARY 2020

Dr A Lotriet (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

Whether, with reference to her replies to questions (a) 240 on 1 August 2019, (b) 503 on 16 September 2019, (c) 504 on 16 September 2019, (d) 505 on 16 September 2019 and (e) 506 on 16 September 2019, she will furnish Dr A Lotriet with copies of all (i) correspondence in which her department requested the said information and (ii) the responses from the City of Ekurhuleni; if not, why not? NW200E

The information used to respond to this question was provided by the Gauteng Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.

Reply:

1. Correspondence concerning PQ 240 is attached.
2. Please see responses to PQ 240, PQ 503, PQ 504, PQ 505 and PQ 506 below.

The response to question PQ 240 is as follows:

(1) (a) Yes, the City has this facility, and (b) Yes, the mobile unit is fully functional.

(2) It was in use in another area.

(3) (a) N/A, (b) Our procurement process requires that we utilise the cheapest of a minimum of three quotations, and (C) The turn-around time.

(4) N/A

The response to question PQ 503 is as follows:

1. Waste management services are transport reliant and dependent largely on mechanical workshop for repairs and maintenance to ensure availability of vehicles when breakdowns are experienced. It is thus imperative to have maximum vehicle availability at all times in order to effect seamless service to the community, which unfortunately due to turnaround times to repairs, sometimes it becomes a challenge to be on schedule owing to shortage of trucks.

(2) (a) Twice

(b) Kempton Park

(c) Shortage of vehicles due to breakdowns

(d) That it be mentioned that it is the endeavour of the department to ensure that residents receive at least one service per week in accordance with the National Domestic Waste Collection Standards. Whenever backlogs are created the City re-allocate resources within the next day or same week to deal with the existing backlogs. In such instances, residents are informed about the challenges experienced and when to take out their bins for collection.

 

The response to question PQ 504 is as follows:

1. Please see the attached document for more information on the vehicles that were budgeted for and purchased. The number of refuse collection trucks that were budgeted for corresponds to the number of trucks that were actually purchased.

1. There were no variances between what was budgeted for and what was actually purchased.

The response to question PQ 505 is as follows:

1. (a) Ten

(b) Where is each depot situated?

DEPOT	ADDRESS	CONTACT DETAILS
Alberton	Swartkoppies Complex, Swartkoppies Road, Randhart, Alberton	011 999 2598
Bedfordview	Cnr Van Vuuren and Skeen Boulevard, Bedfordview	011 999 0915
Benoni	4 Golden Drive, Morehill, Benoni	011 999 6827
Brakpan	C/o Lemmer and Denner Roads, Vulcania, Brakpan	011 999 7731
Boksburg	19 Reservoir Street, Boksburg South, Boksburg	011 999 5070
Edenvale	Cnr Lahla & Bahla rd, Sebenza, Edenvale	011 999 40/50
Germiston	Ostend Road (south of Jack Pienaar), Lower Germiston	011 999 5432
Kempton Park	Cnr H Lewis & Kelvin rd, Spartan , Kempton Park	011 999 4075
Nigel	Fred Wagener Street, Prosperitas, Nigel	011 999 9251
Springs	Stadium Road, Geduld Extention 4 Springs	011 999 8509

(c) Which geographical areas does each depot cover in relation to waste collection?

DEPOT	ADDRESS	CONTACT DETAILS
Alberton	Swartkoppies Complex, Swartkoppies Road, Randhart, Alberton	011 999 2598
Bedfordview	Cnr Van Vuuren and Skeen Boulevard, Bedfordview	011 999 0915
Benoni	4 Golden Drive, Morehill, Benoni	011 999 6827
Brakpan	C/o Lemmer and Denner Roads, Vulcania, Brakpan	011 999 7731
Boksburg	19 Reservoir Street, Boksburg South, Boksburg	011 999 5070
Edenvale	Cnr Lahla & Bahla rd, Sebenza, Edenvale	011 999 40/50
Germiston	Ostend Road (south of Jack Pienaar), Lower Germiston	011 999 5432
Kempton Park	Cnr H Lewis & Kelvin rd, Spartan , Kempton Park	011 999 4075
Nigel/ Duduza	Fred Wagener Street, Prosperitas, Nigel	011 999 9251
Springs/ Kwa-Thema	Stadium Road, Geduld Extention 4 Springs	011 999 8509

(d) What number of households and businesses are within the collection area of each depot?

The following areas are serviced by the City of Ekurhuleni internal staff:

DEPOT	SERVICE POINTS
Alberton	32307
Bedfordview	10659
Benoni	56561
Brakpan	23496
Boksburg	38823
Edenvale	18838
Germiston	50368
Kempton Park	59061
Nigel/ Duduza	30282
Springs/ Kwa-Thema	48177

 The following areas are serviced by the Service Providers:

AREA	SERVICE POINTS
Katlehong	54043
Thokoza	42759
Vosloorus/Boksburg South N17	57154
Tsakane/Langaville	46164
Daveyton/Etwatwa	56319
Tembisa 1 and Tembisa 2	74252

(2) 1:1000

(3)

Vehicle Type	Depot	Mech. W/shop Responsible	Defect	Date of Breakdown	Days Out-standing	Workshop Remarks/Progress/ Comments
Compactor	Alberton	Alberton	Gears	2018/08/20	70	Department signed,DH signed documents were dropped off at CPO today 25.10.2018 for order number
Compactor	Alberton	Alberton	Control lever	2018/09/04	55	The report we received from the foreman was not correct, unfortunately he is on leave but we managed to get hold of the documents, compiled,signed and was sent to CPO for order number. 17.10.2018. Order outstanding
Compactor	Alberton	Alberton	Tail gate, lifter	2018/10/25	4	Qoutation outstanding
Compactor	Alberton	Alberton	Tailgate cover	2018/10/26	3	Booked in on 26 October 2018
Compactor	Alberton	Alberton	Service	2018/10/29	0	Booked in on 29 October 2018
Compactor	Alberton	Alberton	Gearbox	2018/08/31	59	Department signed,DH signed documents were dropped off at CPO today 25.10.2018 for order number
FEL	Boksburg	Boksburg	Overheating	2018/09/19	40	Strip & quote
REL	Boksburg	Boksburg	Packer blade cracked	2018/10/23	6	Awaiting official order
Lugger	Boksburg	Boksburg	Service & COF	2018/08/10	80	Awaiting official order
Lugger	Boksburg	Boksburg	Hydraulic Service	2018/08/15	75	14-4 signed by Manager to go to Fleet(At Keptonpark for signature)
REL	Boksburg	Boksburg	PTO Pump burned	2018/08/10	80	Strip & quote
Lugger	Boksburg	Boksburg	Hydraulic Service	2018/08/10	80	Awaiting official order
REL	Boksburg	Boksburg	COF & Service	2018/09/28	31	14-4 signed by Manager to go to Fleet
REL	Boksburg	Boksburg	Oil & Service	2018/07/23	98	Strip & quote
REL	Boksburg	Boksburg	Mian cylinder damaged	2018/06/14	137	Awaiting official order
REL	Boksburg	Boksburg	Damaged sweeper cylinder	2018/09/28	31	14-4 Initialed, must be signed by acting DH: Waste
REL	Boksburg	Boksburg	COF & Service	2018/10/15	14	14-4 signed by Manager to go to Fleet(At Keptonpark for signature)
REL	Boksburg	Boksburg	Check Hydraulics	2018/10/19	10	14-4 signed by Manager to go to (At signature for signature)
Roll On	Boksburg	Boksburg	Clutch	2018/10/22	7	Awaiting official order
Compactor	Germiston	Germiston	TRANSMISSION	2018/09/19	40	GERMISTON DEPOT
Compactor	Germiston	Germiston	BIN LIFTERS	2018/10/25	4	GERMISTON DEPOT
Compactor	Germiston	Germiston	SWITCH LINK BROKEN	2018/10/25	4	SWITCH LINK BROKEN
Compactor	Germiston	Germiston	BIN LIFTERS	2018/02/05	266	BIN LIFTERS/AWAITING TENDER
Compactor	Germiston	Germiston	CYLINDER MOUNTINGS	2018/06/14	137	CYLINDER MOUNTING
Compactor	Germiston	Germiston	COMPACT SPEED SLOW	2018/10/12	17	COMPACT SPEED SLOW
Compactor	Germiston	Germiston	OVERHEAT	2018/09/12	47	OVERHEAT/TRANSMISSION
Compactor	Germiston	Germiston	SERVICE	2018/10/01	28	SERVICE
Compactor	Germiston	Germiston	HYDRAULIC OIL LEAKS	2018/07/24	97	HYDRAULIC OIL LEAKS
Compactor	Benoni	Benoni	Hydrolic Pipe Leak	2018/07/13	108	papers for last signature/at DH Fleet
Compactor	Benoni	Benoni	Service & C.O.F	2018/10/01	28	order received/awaiting for spares
Compactor	Benoni	Benoni	Sweeper Blade Broken	2018/07/30	91
Compactor	Benoni	Benoni	No Power	2018/04/23	189
D/Diff Lift On	Benoni	Benoni	Leaking from Gear Box	2018/08/06	84
Compactor	Benoni	Benoni	P.T.O Pump Problem	2018/08/21	69
Compactor	Benoni	Benoni	Bin Lifters Broken	2018/10/02	27
Compactor	Benoni	Benoni	Hydrolic Oil Leak	2018/04/05	207
Lift-On	Benoni	Benoni	Overheating	2018/10/05	24
Compactor	Brakpan	Brakpan	COF	2018/09/19	40	VEHICLE CAME BACK FROM COF. WAS THEN REPORTED FOR GEARS. GEO ATTENDING TO PROBLEM AT PRESENT.
Load Lugger	Brakpan	Brakpan	Hydraulic pipe leaks on both Jack	2018/10/02	27
Compactor	Brakpan	Brakpan	Tail gate open half,head light and dash board,rear lights not working.	2018/10/10	19
Load Lugger	Brakpan	Brakpan	COF	2018/09/17	42
Skip	Springs	Springs	brake lights	2018/10/04	25
Compactor	Springs	Springs	Hydraulic leak	2018/10/26	3	Awaiting order
Compactor	Springs	Springs	Work in Kemptonpark	2018/10/08	21
Skip	Springs	Springs	Repair radiator	2018/10/22	7	Awaiting order
Lugger	Nigel	Nigel	Gearbox ,COF	2018/04/11	201
REL	Nigel	Nigel	Vehicle damaged by protesters	2018/07/09	112	Vehicle damaged during civil unrest
LDV	Nigel	Nigel	Oil seals	2018/08/20	70	Order submitted
REL	NIGEL	Nigel	Head gasket, radiator, turbo	2018/08/28	62	Awaitng order
Roro	Nigel	Nigel	Transmission problems	2018/10/23	6
REL	Kempton Park	Kempton Park	Hydraulics	2018/10/16	13	Busy with repairs
REL	Kempton Park	Kempton Park	Bin lifter arm broken	2018/10/03	26	Awaiting a quotation, Hydrapump sent vehicle back to Depo while waiting for quotation
REL	Kempton Park	Kempton Park	COF	2018/10/03	26	Busy with repairs
SKIP	Kempton Park	Kempton Park	Gearbox	2018/07/16	105	Busy with repairs
REL	Kempton Park	Kempton Park	Service	2018/07/16	105	Busy with service
REL	Kempton Park	Kempton Park	Hydraulic Pipe Burst	2018/10/18	11	Busy with repairs
ROLL ON	Kempton Park	Kempton Park	Boom Arm Sensors	2018/10/16	13	Awaiting order
Mec-Benz	Edenvale	Kempton park	C.O.F and Service	2018/09/19	40
Nissan	Edenvale	Kempton park	Engine oil leak	2018/08/20	70
Nissan	Edenvale	Kempton park	Lifting boom cracked	2018/07/30	91
Isuzu	Edenvale	Kempton park	Clutch blade to be replaced	2018/10/05	24
Nissan	Edenvale	Mopedi	Air Leak and hydro oil pump	2018/10/24	5
Nissan	Edenvale	Panel Beater	Front Panel Gril	2018/10/29	0
Nissan	Edenvale	W/SHOP	C.O.F and Service	2018/10/29	15
Compactor	BEDFORD	KEMPTON	GEARBOX	2018/07/19	102	We received the quotation on the 16.08.2018
Skiploader	BEDFORD	KEMPTON	GEARBOX	2018/08/31	59	GEO ENGINEERING TO RE-INSPECT THE TRUCK
Compactor	BEDFORD	KEMPTON	GEARBOX OIL LEAK	2018/10/18	11
					43402

The response to question PQ 506 is as follows:

1. 49 cases
2. See the table below
3. See the table below

Alleged Offence	SAPS Station	SAPS CAS number	Outcome
Assault	Edenvale	120/08/2017	Criminal matter withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
Corruption	Thokoza	42/09/2017	Criminal matter withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
Assault	Primrose	76/09/2017 and 56/09/2017	Both criminal matters withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
House breaking	Bedfordview	100/09/2017	Criminal matter in court
Culpable Homicide	Springs	105/09/2017	Still under investigation by SAPS
Corruption	Tembisa	253/09/2017	Still under investigation by SAPS
Drunk and Driving Loss of firearm	Springs Springs	303/09/2017 and 304/09/2017	Still under investigation by SAPS Still under investigation by SAPS
Armed robbery, corruption and Defeating the ends of justice	Benoni	33/10/2017	Criminal matter in court
Corruption	Duduza	112/11/2017	Criminal matter in court
Unlicensed firearm	Emondle KZN	115/11/2017	Still under investigation by SAPS
Unlicensed firearm	Norkem Park	05/12/2017	Still under investigation by SAPS
Corruption	Alberton	280/12/2017	Criminal matter in court
Drink and driving	Germiston	356/12/2017	Still under investigation by SAPS
Discharge of firearm	Tsakane	406/12/2017	Criminal matter withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
Corruption	Kempton Park	697/12/2017	Still under investigation by SAPS
Reckless driving	Thokoza	19/01/2018	Criminal matter withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
Trespassing	Actonville	47/01/2018	Still under investigation by SAPS
Crimen Injuria	Katlehong	48/01/2018	Still under investigation by SAPS
Assault	Nigel	07/02/2018	Criminal matter withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
Corruption	Mondeor	455/02/2018	Criminal matter in court
Discharge of firearm	Benoni	04/03/2018	Criminal matter withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
Murder	Daveyton	18/03/2018	Matter finalised guilty – sentence imprisonment
Pointing of Firearm	Katlehong	238/03/2018	Still under investigation by SAPS
Murder	Tsakane	415/03/2018	Criminal matter in court
Trading in precious metals (Gold)	Springs	370/04/2018	Still under investigation by SAPS
Corruption	Welbekend	42/05/2018	Still under investigation by SAPS
Corruption	Katlehong North	62/05/2018	Criminal matter in court
Corruption	Vosloorus	420/05/2018	Criminal matter in court
Fraud and corruption	Mtubatuba KZN	26/07/2018	Still under investigation by SAPS
Corruption	Brakpan	11/08/2018	Still under investigation by SAPS
Pointing of firearm	Springs	99/08/2018	Still under investigation by SAPS
Corruption (Selling of Jobs)	Brakpan	156/08/2018	Criminal matter withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
Assault	Vosloorus	06/10/2018	Still under investigation by SAPS
Use vehicle without permission	Primrose	142/10/2018	Still under investigation by SAPS
Assault	Etwatwa	183/10/2018	Still under investigation by IPID
Corruption	Tembisa	473/10/2018	Criminal matter in court
Assault	Alberton	201/11/2018	Still under investigation
Domestic Violence	Crystal Park	275/11/2018	Criminal matter withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
Attempted murder	Tembisa	300/01/2019	Still under investigation by SAPS
Possession of stolen vehicle	Springs	453/02/2019	Criminal matter withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
Discharge firearm in residential area	Boksburg	43/03/2019	Still under investigation by SAPS
Attempted Murder	Springs	531/03/2019	Still under investigation by SAPS
Armed robbery	Kempton Park	685/03/2019	Still under investigation by SAPS
Pointing of firearm	Kempton Park	291/04/2019	Still under investigation by SAPS
Domestic violence	Springs	264/05/2019	Criminal matter withdrawn – no prima facie evidence
Loss of firearm	Vosloorus	30/07/2019	Still under investigation by SAPS
Corruption	Tembisa	238/07/2019	Still under investigation by SAPS

SUMMARY

Period from 1 August 2017 to 31 August 2019 (2 years)

Type of criminal case Total number

Corruption 14

Assault 07

Discharge of firearm 03

Crimen injuria 01

Possession of unlicensed firearm 02

Pointing of firearm 03

Murder 02

Drunk driving 02

Attempted murder 02

Armed robbery 02

Domestic violence 02

Reckless and Negligence driving 01

Trading in precious metal (Gold) 01

Possession of stolen vehicle 01

Culpable homicide 01

House breaking 01

Loss of firearm 02

Trespassing 01

Use vehicle without owner permission 01

TOTAL 49

Reply:

(1) The South African Police Service (SAPS) is not in a position to respond at this stage, as the matter is currently under investigation by the Independent Police Investigative Directorate (IPID).
(2) In the event that the IPID recommends that steps be taken, the SAPS will consider implementing the recommendations.

Reply to question 415 recommended

GENERAL NATIONAL COMMISSIONER: SOUTH AFRICAN POLICE SERVICE
KJ SITOLE (SOEG)
Date: 2021-03-04

Reply to question 415 approved

 

MINISTER OF POLICE
GENERAL BH CELE, MP
DATE: 05/05/2021

Reply:

(1)(a) A total of R86 743 000,00 has been budgeted for the operation of the South African Police Service (SAPS) Air Wing .

(1)(b) Yes, the amount is sufficient to keep it operational.

1. Yes, the aircraft are maintained in accordance to applicable regulations. (2)(a) The relevant details of the aircraft, are as follows:
   • 13 x AS350B3 (H125) helicopters
   • 1 x BK 117 helicopter

a    1 x Beechcraft King Air 90

• 1 x Cessna Sovereign Citation 680
• 6 x Robinson R44 helicopters
• 2 x MD 500 helicopters
• 9 x Pilatus PC 6
• 1 x Pilatus PC 12

(2)(b) The relevant details of the maintenance plan for each aircraft, are as follows: o           13 x AS350B3 (H125) helicopters are maintained by SOFOMAR.

• 1 x BK 117 helicopter is maintained by Airbus Helicopter, Southern Africa.
• 1 x Beechcraft King Air 90 is maintained by Absolute Aviation.
• 1 x Cessna Sovereign Citation 680 is maintained by Absolute Aviation.
• 6 x Robinson R44 helicopters- currently no maintenance contract (Maintenance is done through a quotation process. The SAPS is in a process of putting a maintenance contract in place).
• 2 x MD 500 helicopters- currently no maintenance contract (Maintenance is done through a quotation process. The SAPS is in a process of putting a maintenance contract in place).

a 9 x Pilatus PC 6’s- currently no maintenance contract (Maintenance is done through a quotation process. The SAPS is in a process of putting a maintenance contract in place).

• 1 x Pilatus PC 12- currently no maintenance contract (Maintenance is done through a quotation process. The SAPS is in a process of putting a maintenance contract in place).

 

Reply to question 277 recommended/

 

GENERAL NATIONAL COMMISSIONER: SOUTH AFRICAN POLICE SERVICE
KJ SITOLE (SOEG)
Date: 2021-03-04

Reply to question 277 approved

 

MINISTER OF POLICE
GENERAL BH CELE, MP
DATE: 05/05/2021

Reply:

The Office of the Provincial Commissioner of Gauteng has record that the Ekurhuleni Metro Police Service submitted their annual plans, for the following financial years: 2014/2015, 2015/2016, 201s 2o1e, 2o19 2020 and 2020/2021.

Reply to question 541 recommended

GENERAL NATIONAL COMMISSIONER: SOUTH AFRICAN POLICE SERVICE
KJ SITOLE (SOEG)
Date: 2021-03-09

Reply to question 541 approved

MINISTER OF POLICE
GENERAL BH CELE, MP
DATE: 05/05/2021

Reply:

(a)(b)(c)

The training academies of the Municipal Police Services are regulated by the South African Qualifications Authority Act, 1995 (Act No. 58 of 1995) and do not resort under the responsibility or control of the South African Police Service (SAPS).

Reply to question 543 recommended

GENERAL NATIONAL COMMISSIONER: SOUTH AFRICAN POLICE SERVICE
KJ SITOLE (SOEG)
Date: 2021-03-09

Reply to question 543 approved

 

MINISTER OF POLICE
GENERAL BH CELE, MP
DATE: 05/05/2021

 

 

Reply:

a) The South African courts have extra-territorial jurisdiction to prosecute acts of trafficking committed outside its borders as per section 12 (1) of the said Act.

If a person adopt a child in South Africa for the purposes of exploitation of child in a foreign country, such person is guilty of an offence as stipulated in section 4 (2) (a) of the said Act. The person can be prosecuted in South Africa regardless of whether or not the acts (trafficking) constitute an offence in the country where they were committed.

b) The South African Central Authority have put measures in place to prevent trafficking of children adopted in foreign countries by entering into inter-country adoption working agreements with those countries. These measures include post adoption services that are expected to be rendered by the accredited foreign adoption agencies for a period of five years to the children and adoptive families.

The foreign accredited adoption agencies are expected to compile post adoption reports twice in the first year then annually which are forwarded to the SA child protection organisations and the SA Central Authority. Engagements on progress are in place on the wellbeing, adjustment and functioning of children and their families.

The Central Authority and the accredited child protection organisations do visit the foreign adoption agencies, Central Authorities and adoptive families to ensure compliance to post adoption measures. During the financial year 2019/2020, some of the officials from the Central Authority and accredited CPO visited Belgium and Denmark to monitor children who were adopted.

Reply:

No, the Department has not conducted such study. However, in collaboration with the relevant stakeholders, the Department developed an Emergency Response Plan to address the needs of vulnerable children who have been affected by the global COVID-19 pandemic. The plan complements other services to orphans and vulnerable children which include psychosocial support services and social assistance in a form of social grants.

It is important to point out to the Honourable Member that the Department renders services to orphans and vulnerable irrespective of the cause of orphanhood as guided by the provisions of the Children’s Act (Act No. 38 of 2005). This is to avoid stigma and discrimination.

The department further implements Community Based Prevention and Early intervention programme to ensure early identification of orphans and vulnerable children. Others include training and deployment of Child and Youth Care Workers at a community level who work in a space of a child and support and empower children who are vulnerable and those orphaned with life skills, home works and household chores. They refer and link these children with other resources where necessary.

Reply:

(1) The relevant details of the training, which has to be taken by members sf the South African Police Service (SAPS), involved in Public Order Policing (POP), is reflected below.

• Crowd Management for Platoon Commanders Learning Programme.
• Crowd Management for Platoon Members Learning Programme.
• Crowd Management on Section Level.
• RG-12 Nyala Operators Course.
• Video Operators Course.
• First Line Operational Manager Course, Module 2.
• Crowd Management Refresher Course.
• Crowd Conflict Management.
• First Responder to Crowd Gathering Workshop.
• Dangerous Weapons Act, 2013 (Act No. 15 of 2013).
• Water Cannon Operators Course.
• Crowd Conflict Management.

(2) Yes, all the training material, with regard to POP, has been revised. The details are reflected below:

Reply:

According to the information received from Denel

1. The employees’ salaries for the period May to July 2020 have not been paid in full. Even though the quantum of the outstanding payments has reduced, there is still an outstanding portion:

a) The reason for Denel’s failure to comply with the Court Order is that Denel does not have the money to comply with the outstanding financial obligations in terms of the court order.

b) The consequence of Denel being in contempt of court is that if it were to be found to be guilty of contempt, the court may impose a fine or imprisonment and/or both. The court has since given its judgement (dated 8 March 2021) and Denel and its directors have for now not been found to be in contempt of court.

c) The court has, however, not dismissed the application and has postponed these proceedings and to require Denel to file an affidavit on a date prior to the reconvened hearing to report further progress towards full compliance with the court order.

2. The salaries have not been paid in full.

a) The salaries have not been paid in full due to Denel’s financial inability to effect payment.

b) Please refer to the attached Spreadsheet marked Annexure A.

• The spreadsheet addresses outstanding salary payments and third party payments (money deducted to pay 3rd party beneficiaries) in respect of Solidarity and UASA’s members, for whom the court order applies and for the rest of employees excepted by the court order.

c) nRefer to point (b) above.

d) Solidarity and UASA have since obtained warrants of execution totaling an amount of R12,7 Million and for which Denel in proposing a stay of execution while the parties engage in finding an amicable solution.

There are constructive engagements taking place between the Board and management of Denel and the trades unions, with a view to obtaining consensus on resolving the crises faced by Denel due to state capture and to ensure the wellbeing of employees.

                                             

Reply:

Departmental information

a) Department of Public Enterprise is using a Private Security Firm

(a)(i) GMP Security Services

(a)(ii) To render security guarding service of office premises

(a)(iii) R 499 100

(a)(iv) 5 months

According to the information received from Alexkor

(i) Name of each firm

Revert Security

Matek Security

(ii) Purpose

Revert Security – Day to day security services for mine operations.

Matek Security – Specialised Task Team service to protect the mina against illegal miners

(iii) Value

Revert Security – R 1 245 350, 83 per month

Matek Security – R270, 749.85 per month

(iv) Duration of each specified contract?

Revert Security 5 years, extended with 2 years, start Feb 2018 end date Feb 2025

Matek Security 6 months, start 13 November 2020, end date 15 May 2021

According to the information received from Denel

a) Not applicable

b) Yes, Denel SOC Ltd makes use of private security firms. Some divisions (OTR and PMP) have security guards in their employ. Denel Dynamics is partially insourced (inner perimeter).

(b)

(i) name of each firm	(ii) purpose	(iii) value	(iv) duration
Mafoko Security	Provision of security services for NKP and non-NKP for Denel Campuses (Kempton Park)	R32,105,706.12	3 Years
Omega Wise JV	Physical Guarding and Patrol of NKP sites (DLS Centurion)	R24,986,000.00	3 Years
Omega Wise JV	Physical Guarding and Patrol of NKP sites (DVS Benoni & Alrode)	R14,828,354.28	3 Years
Wise Business and Risk Solution	Provision of physical security service on the Denel Dynamics (Irene Campus) premises-National Key Point( NKP)	R7,893,656,65	3 Years

According to the information received from Eskom

1. Not applicable
2. Yes, Eskom Security makes use of private security companies for physical guarding services rendered at NKP and other Eskom sites.

The physical security guarding services are procured as an outsourced service to supplement the in-house security capability. Services are procured on fixed, rates based contracts and contracts are awarded only to compliant and accredited private security companies.

1. (ii) and (iii) The name of each firm, purpose and the value of each contract are as set out in Annexure A.

(iv) The duration of the current security guarding contracts is 18 months, set to expire on 31 March 2021.

According to the information received from SAFCOL

(b) Yes, SAFCOL uses Private Security Firms as depicted in the table below:

According to the information received from South African Airways

a) Not applicable.

(b)(i)(ii) SAA is procuring security services from a service provider called Reshebile Aviation and Protection Service for securing the premises and access there to.

(b)(iii) The value is current about R1m a month.

(b)(iv) This contract expired on 31 March 2020. It is currently being extended on a month to month basis.

According to the information received from South African Express response:

Not relevant as the entity is under liquidation.

According to the information received from Transnet response:

a) Not applicable

b) Transnet does make use of private security firms which are listed as Annexure A.

(b)(iii) The total contract value on active Security firms is R 1, 864,952,665.99.

Remarks: Reply: Approved / Not Approved

Kgathatso Tlhakudi Pravin Gordhan, MP

Director-General Minister of Public Enterprises

Date: Date:

Reply:

According to the information received from Eskom:

1. (a) and (b)

The Wilge Residential Development contract was awarded at R 260.46 million for the completion of 336 unit-flats by December2013. Liviero Wilge Joint Venture (LWJV) was contracted to build the flats.

The cost incurred to date is R 632.64 million on the development of the flats paid to Liviero Wilge Joint Venture (LWJV) and an additional R 209.23 million on common infrastructure and related work paid to other service providers as set out in Table 1 below. The total amount that was paid to service providers was R 841.87 million.

Table 1: Other service providers for services and supporting infrastructure work

Service provider (a)	Contracted service	Total value (b)
BKS-PALACE CONSORTIUM	Engineering services	R   55 968 777.66
Emalahleni Planning	Municipality planning	R          28 377.72
ENSafrica	Legal services	R 7 248 484.67
Eskom Rotek Industries (ERI)	Kitchen and electrical network	R 16 935 475.64
Fabricated Steel Manufacturing Company	Kitchen building	R     4 525 945.94
Huntrex 116	Security	R     2 434 485.77
Liviero Wilge Accommodation	Accommodation during construction	R   40 632 852.63

Service Provider (a)	Contracted Service	Total Value (b)
Mbanga Trading Enterprise	Kitchen equipment	R     3 558 621.64
Moremantsa	Furniture	R 17 224 340.00
MRMS	Pump station and water/sewer pipelines	R 15 530 657.37
PricewaterhouseCoopers	Background checks	R 30 168.00
Sphilasethu Security Services	Security	R     1 719 999.60
Thabelo Personnel	Labour broker resources	R 3 826 293.96
Themba Consultants	Engineering services and labour broker resources	R   24 781 473.44
Thusanang Cast	Kitchen	R   11 572 419.18
Ukwazi	Electrical repairs to 22kV supply	R          58 495.29
Unyokane Trading Enterprise	Security	R     2 342 900.00
Zitholele Consulting	Water use licence for pipelines	R 808 042.80
Total		R 209 227 811.31

2 (a) and (b)

In 2019, Eskom instituted disciplinary action against the General Manager of Facilities of which the Wilge Project is part. The disciplinary process was concluded in January 2020 and the General Manager was found guilty and subsequently, Eskom terminated his employment.

Eskom has initiated a legal process recovering moneys from the General Manager concerned.

Eskom is currently concluding disciplinary process on an additional implicated employee, this process is at an advance stage

Reply:

According to the information received from Denel:

a)Denel does not have export partners.

b) Not applicable

c) This is commercially sensitive information. However, as part of the restructuring and transformation of Denel, the Board and management are making every effort to both improve marketing and production. This will take time to accomplish. The loss of Intellectual property, skilled staff to foreign interests and general negligence of previous boards have had a severe impact on Denel.

d) This is commercially sensitive information.

e) None

f) None

Reply:

According to the information received from Eskom

Eskom is in the process of quantifying the losses incurred and the parties against whom legal actions should be taken. Counsel has been engaged to advise on the merits of intended action.

Reply:

(1) The Department is unable to provide this information due to the industrially charged environment at SAA and the risk that such a disclosure could pose to employees concerned. However, DPE can confirm that the flight was operated by an experienced Captain, First officer, and Flight engineer.

(2) SAA has been utilized, as a 100% government-owned entity, at the request of government, on numerous occasions, in supporting the pandemic related efforts: repatriation of citizens, collection of PPEs etc. SAA has also assisted international organisations such as the World Food Program to distribute its aid to neighbouring countries in the continent.

(3) SAA complied with SAA requirements to operate the flight. The exemptions obtained were in relation to crew re-currency in the following areas:

• • External training facility.
  • External instructor qualification to conduct training for SAA pilots.
  • Pilots regaining recency.
  • Recurrent training:

Reply:

According to the information received from ALEXKOR

a) The four (4) frontline healthcare workers, employees at the Alexkor Occupational health Department, have been registered on the National Department of Health Electronic Vaccine Data System. Currently all vaccines are being coordinated and supplied by the NDOH.

Dr Vaughan was contacted on 13 March 2021 to inform him that the vaccination roll-out will start with the general practitioners in the district.

Dr Vic Vaughan

Occupational Medical Practitioner

Have been registered under Nababeep Clinic, Namaqua District.

George Richards

Occupational Health Nursing Practitioner

Have been registered under Alexanderbaai Clinic, Namaqua District.

SMS confirmation 02 March 2021

Karl Adams

Emergency Care Technician

Have been registered under Alexanderbaai Clinic, Namaqua District.

SMS confirmation 02 March 2021

Teschwill Matthys

Basic Ambulance Assistant

Have been registered under Alexanderbaai Clinic, Namaqua District.

SMS confirmation 02 March 2021

According to the information received from DENEL

Denel’s workers are not classified as frontline workers therefore, the SOC does not have a vaccine roll-out plan for this category of workers.

According to the information received from ESKOM

Eskom has a COVID-19 Vaccine strategy and roll-out plan that is aligned to the national vaccine strategy. As part of phase 1, Eskom frontline health care workers have registered on the Electronic Vaccine Data System (EVDS) and await to be vaccinated.

Attached is the Eskom COVID-19 vaccine strategy and roll-out plan. It outlines the process to vaccinate employees and contract workers.

According to the information received from SAFCOL

SAFCOL has 3 517 employees (including permanent employees, fixed term employees and contractors) as at February 2021. SAFCOL employees are not frontline workers and are therefore not affected in phase one of the national vaccine rollout process.

Subject to resolution of challenges, relating to financing of vaccines and medical skills constraints at the two clinics owned by SAFCOL, SAFCOL’s vaccine rollout plan is cognisant of the fact that Government will source, distribute and oversee the rollout of the vaccine. Furthermore, that Government, as the sole purchaser of vaccines, will distribute it to provincial governments and the private sector. Consequently, SAFCOL’s roll-out plan will be aligned to the Government roll-out plan as and when the relevant phases are announced. SAFCOL will implement the vaccination programme following a phased approach as detailed in the roll-out plan below.

Phase 1 - Rollout for SAFCOL. (Phase one for SAFCOL will be implemented when the Government implement its phase two. SAFCOL will include the following employees)	Phase 2 - Rollout for SAFCOL (Phase two for SAFCOL. For SAFCOL will be implemented when the Government implement its phase three. SAFCOL will include the following employees)
Every employee over 60 years and those over 18 years with co-morbidities.	Every employee older than 18 years, who were not covered during Phase 1, targeting the entire workforce.
Production workers and employees who cannot work from home.
Change and Stakeholder Management
SAFCOL employees are educated on the vaccine and are encouraged to be vaccinated to ensure the success of the programme. SAFCOL’s existing COVID-19 communications and wellness programmes have commenced with communications around vaccine rollout to the limited extent possible at this point in time. Clear communication will continuously emphasise the fact that all employees’ personal wishes to receive the vaccine (or not), will be respected with no adverse impacts in terms of the employment relationship. Onsite consultation with union and contractors will be encouraged.
Risk Management Strategy
The rollout plan will start gradually with small groups of employees, to manage implementation risk. Employee consent/participation forms will be implemented through the clinics to keep accurate records that will inform evaluation on the impact of the vaccine rollout programme and any improvement decisions required over time.

According to the information from SOUTH AFRICAN AIRWAYS

South African Airways does not have a roll-out strategy.

According to the information received from SOUTH AFRICAN EXPRESS

Not applicable. The SOC is under provisional liquidation.

According to the information received from TRANSNET

1. Transnet does not have any healthcare workers who are classified as 1a frontline health care workers as per Government’s classification and roll-out phases. However, Transnet does have healthcare workers who are classified as category 1b and has ensured that this category of employees are registered on the EVDS (Electronic Vaccine Data System) in preparation for their round of vaccinations.

2. Transnet does have an approach to ensure the roll-out of vaccinations for its employees and has segmented its employee’s according to Government’s Three (3) Phase roll-out plan. The Transnet Occupational Health Clinics are also being equipped for vaccinations to be administered to all Transnet employees.

Reply:

According to the information received from Eskom

(a) and (b)

The CPO, Solly Tshitangano, is suspended pending the finalisation of a disciplinary hearing. Broadly speaking, the CPO is facing the following charges:

• gross misconduct in the form of gross dereliction of duty and/or a failure to exercise due care;
• gross misconduct in the form of gross dishonesty;
• gross negligence in the performance of his duties;
• failure to carry out instructions;
• breaching the conditions of his suspension;
• distributing confidential Eskom documents to a third party;
• making any false statement or representation that relates to, or ensues from, his duties;
• disclosing confidential information obtained in the course of his duties to third parties;
• breaching Eskom’s procurement and supply chain management procedure; and
• breaching his fiduciary and statutory duties as set out in the Public Finance Management Act 1 of 1999.

Reply:

According to the information received from Denel:

(1)(a) Export and domestic contract for various product lines

(1)(b) Over R11 billion

(2) Denel has not entered into any strategic equity partnership in recent time. The last strategic equity partnership that Denel established was 9 years ago when it entered into strategic joint venture with Tawazun Dynamics of the United Arab Emirates. The Board is in the process of reviewing Denel overall strategy, which includes the position on strategic equity partnerships.

(3)(a) Denel does not have export partners. The entity exports according to its contractual obligations it has to its customers.

(3)(b) Not applicable.

 

Reply:

(a) The viability of the companies within the DPE portfolio would need to be assessed against a wider criterion of repurposing and rationalization of the SOE to make them fit for purpose. Once this exercise is completed then a definite answer can be provided which not only looks purely at financial viability but takes into account operational, strategic and national importance as well as responding to the economic reconstruction and recovery plan.

This work is currently being undertaken by the Presidential State-Owned Enterprises Council (“PSEC”) workstream on consolidation and rationalization.

(b) At an appropriate time, and once all the governance processes have been followed then appropriate steps will be communicated.

Reply:

According to the information received from Eskom:

(1)(a)

An open tender process was followed and twenty-four (24) companies submitted tenders.

(1)(b)

On 3 July 2012, Eskom Holdings SOC Limited awarded a contract (4600046997) to Liviero Wilge Joint Venture (LWJV) for the construction of 336 units on erf 165 Wilge Township (enquiry number PS(K)2011/UR/01). The duration of the contract was 18 months and the accepted contract price was R226 485 875.455 excluding value-added tax (VAT) and cost price adjustment (CPA).

(2)

The following modifications were approved by the relevant delegated authorities:

 

Modification No.	Approval Date	Approved Contract Value	Reasons for Change	Approval Authority
0	3 May 2012	R226 485 875	Initial approval	R300m Procurement Tender Committee (PTC)
1	8 May 2013	R264 795 470	Inclusion of project labour agreement	R300m PTC
2	10 December 2013	R264 795 470	Labour and design issues Extension of time, no cost	R50m – R300m PTC
3	25 July 2014	R264 795 470	Legal dispute, time extension, no cost	R50m – R300m PTC
4	25 March 2015	R388 249 150	First addendum condonation	Exco Procurement Sub-Committee (PSC)
5	28 June 2016	R447 749 277	Memorandum of understanding	Exco PSC
6	4 August 2017	R608 879 139	Termination cost	Board tender committee
Final	9 May 2018	R600 480 000 (excl. cost price adjustment)	Adjudication outcome

(3)(a)

Initially, the total contract monetary value was R226,5 million and the final monetary value at

adjudication was R600,48 million (excluding cost price adjustment).

(3)(b)

Mr. Reuben Mamorare, General Manager for Group Capital Division Facilities.

(3)(c)

Delay damages for sectional completion were included in the contract at 0.04% per day, calculated as a percentage of the prices at the date of contract award. The deadline for Section 1 that included blocks C, D, E and F was 30 September 2013 and the deadline for Section 2 that included blocks A, B, G, H and I was 13 December 2012. However, no penalties were imposed on the contractor.

(4)(a)

The required documents for the rezoning, and building permission was submitted to the Local authorities and approved.

(4)(b)

Final inspection for occupation certificates and electrical compliance by the local authority Was not completed due to termination of the contract.

(5)

The development was enrolled with the National Home Builders Registration Council (NHBRC) and certificates were issued. The development was suspended before final inspections for relevant certifications were done.

Reply:

According to the information received from Denel:

a) Denel SOC Ltd is the Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) of the Rooivalk Attack Helicopter (AH). The SOC has investigated with the South African Air Force (SAAF) through Armscor the potential to upgrade and or replacement of the current baseline.

b)Denel was commissioned by Armscor in 2015/16 financial year to develop a weapons and avionics obsolescence study of the Rooivalk AH. This study would form the basis for a Project Definition (PD) by the Department of Defence (DOD) which would map a path to reach an upgraded Rooivalk AH.

1. R10 million was allocated for the study by the DOD.
2. This study was completed in 2016 with an expectation of a further tasking for other major systems of the aircraft.

Reply:

According to the information received from Eskom

Eskom continues with its debt management processes which included the issuing of debt summons, attachment of assets and bank accounts if required. Eskom is also pursuing the dispute mechanisms as defined in the Intergovernmental Relations Framework Act and creates awareness of the role of various government departments in the resolution of the arrear debt. Eskom also engages stakeholders via the Eskom Political Task Team and Multi-disciplinary Revenue Committee in seeking resolution to the Municipal debt problem.

Eskom is also embarking on a municipal active partnering programme whereby services are offered to struggling municipalities to assist with electricity reticulation, distribution and revenue collection with the purpose of sustainably improving the electricity value chain, thereby securing payment for the electricity supplied to end consumers of the municipality. A focused intergovernmental approach is also being followed with special intervention in Maluti a Phofung by the Deputy President who has established a task team to track progress on the implementation of these initiatives in the municipality.

Reply:

The Department of Small Business Development (DSBD) currently leases accommodation from the Department of Trade Industry and Competition (the dtic). All security services are provided by the dtic and the landlord, therefore the Department does not make use of such services directly and also does not have party to appointment of such.

The following is information relating to security firms utilised by the agencies reporting the DSBD:

Agency	Name of firm	Purpose	Value	Duration (All are active contracts)
Small Enterprise Development Agency (Seda)	Fidelity Guarding Security Services	Guarding and Security Services	R1 139 061.00	1 year contract, where after, if needed it will continue on a month-to-month basis for a maximum period of 12 months
	Kerberg Services (PTY) LTD	Maintenance on existing system	R 430 836.00	1 year
Small Enterprise Finance Agency (sefa)	Bamogale Enterprise (Pty) Ltd	Security Service	R 1 686 217.68	2 years
	Bamogale Enterprise (Pty) Ltd	Security Service	R 153 146.88	1 year

______________________________________________________________________________

RESPONSE RECOMMENDED BY:

_______________________

MR LINDOKUHLE MKHUMANE

ACTING DIRECTOR GENERAL: DEPARTMENT OF SMALL BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT

DATE:

______________________________________________________________________________

RESPONSE RECOMMENDED BY:

________________________

MS ROSEMARY CAPA, MP

DEPUTY MINISTER OF SMALL BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT

DATE:

_______________________________________________________________________________

RESPONSE APPROVED BY:

_________________________

MS KHUMBUDZO NTSHAVHENI, MP

MINISTER OF SMALL BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT

DATE:

Reply:

The taxi industry is part of the small business sector. The industry is not only critical as a provider of transport but it also enables other small businesses throughout its value chain, for example informal traders, motor mechanics, panel beaters, auto spares and fitment centres. In 2019, the Minister interacted with the leadership of SANTACO on mechanisms to support the industry and the Department of Small Business Development (DSBD) also supported the Department of Transport towards the Taxi Indaba.

Given the mandate and programmes of the Department of Transport, the DSBD can only play a supporting role to those programmes agreed at the Taxi Indaba to avoid duplication of efforts by government. However, the DSBD is implementing programmes to support businesses in the taxi industry value chain to be geared to support a modernised taxi industry such as the Motor mechanics, panel beaters, auto spares and fitment centres.

______________________________________________________________________________

RESPONSE RECOMMENDED BY:

_______________________

MR LINDOKUHLE MKHUMANE

ACTING DIRECTOR GENERAL: DEPARTMENT OF SMALL BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT

DATE:

______________________________________________________________________________

RESPONSE RECOMMENDED BY:

________________________

MS ROSEMARY CAPA, MP

DEPUTY MINISTER OF SMALL BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT

DATE:

_______________________________________________________________________________

RESPONSE APPROVED BY:

_________________________

MS KHUMBUDZO NTSHAVHENI, MP

MINISTER OF SMALL BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT

DATE:

Reply:

(1)(a) The Department of Home Affairs is responsible for the admissions of persons in the Republic and granting business visas for foreign migrants.

1. Majority of the municipalities do not maintain database of businesses who are permit holders. Since the President re-assigned the administration of the Businesses Act to the Department of Small Business Development, the Department is working to support municipalities to establish the traceable database. These databases will be compared to the Home Affairs database.

(2)(a) In December 2019, the President has transferred the administration of the Businesses Act, no. 71 of 1991, from the Minister of Trade, Industry and Competition to the Minister for Small Business Development. The Department has started the process of amending this Act to also include provisions of how municipalities should regulate the issuing of business licenses and permits to non-South African citizens.

(b) The Department has included in its 2021/2022 legislative programme, the amendment of the Businesses Act no.71 of 1991. The processing of the amendments by Parliament will depend on the parliamentary programme of the Portfolio and Select Committees.

_______________________________________________________________________________

RESPONSE RECOMMENDED BY:

_______________________

MR LINDOKUHLE MKHUMANE

ACTING DIRECTOR GENERAL: DEPARTMENT OF SMALL BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT

DATE:

______________________________________________________________________________

RESPONSE RECOMMENDED BY:

________________________

MS ROSEMARY CAPA, MP

DEPUTY MINISTER OF SMALL BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT

DATE:

_______________________________________________________________________________

RESPONSE APPROVED BY:

_________________________

MS KHUMBUDZO NTSHAVHENI, MP

MINISTER OF SMALL BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT

DATE:

Reply:

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

WRITTEN REPLY

THE MINISTER OF AGRICULTURE, LAND REFORM AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT:

No. Whilst the change of land-use has in some instances resulted in the relocation of communal residents to alternative areas, such occurrences have not been largely attributed to the unilateral actions of traditional leaders and also have not been at such a scale as to warrant a study.

Reply:

(1)– (4): The Department of Small Business Development does not have the information requested as the scheme is jointly managed by National Treasury and the South African Reserve Bank. We will therefore request that this question be redirected to National Treasury.

_______________________________________________________________________________

RESPONSE RECOMMENDED BY:

_______________________

MR LINDOKUHLE MKHUMANE

ACTING DIRECTOR GENERAL: DEPARTMENT OF SMALL BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT

DATE:

______________________________________________________________________________

RESPONSE RECOMMENDED BY:

________________________

MS ROSEMARY CAPA, MP

DEPUTY MINISTER OF SMALL BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT

DATE:

_______________________________________________________________________________

RESPONSE APPROVED BY:

_________________________

MS KHUMBUDZO NTSHAVHENI, MP

MINISTER OF SMALL BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT

DATE:

Reply:

1(a)(i) As on 25 March 2021, the department had 24 vacancies.

(ii) Relevant details of vacant posts and vacant since:

Details	Duration
No	Post Job Title Description	Post Salary Level	Recruitment Status	Vacant since
1.	Director-General	16	Pending decision from Cabinet	2018-10-01	2 Years,5 Months
2.	Deputy Director-General: Enterprise Competitiveness Support	15	Advertisement Process	2018-08-01	2 Years, 7 Months
3.	Deputy Director-General: Integrated Cooperatives Development	15	Delayed – Pending Structure Consultation	2017-04-01	3 Years, 11 Months
4.	Chief Director: Blended Finance	14	To be re-Advertised	2018-09-20	2 Years,5 Months
5.	Media Liaison Officer	13	Pending decision from Minister	2021-02-05	1 Month
6.	Director: Blended Finance	13	Screening and reference checks	2020-04-01	11 Months
7.	MR6 Legal Administration Officer Senior	12	Candidate declined offer - Alternative recruitment methods proposed: Head-hunting	2020-12-01	3 Months
8.	Deputy Director: Blended Finance	11	Screening and reference checks	2019-11-01	1 Year,4 Months
9.	Deputy Director: Supplier Development	11	Competency assessment, screening and reference checks	2020-11-01	4 Months
10.	Assistant Director: Entrepreneurship Prog Development and Design	9	To be advertised	2021-01-01	2 Months
11.	Assistant Administrative Secretary	9	To be advertised	2019-0-701	1 Year, 8 Months
12.	Executive Assistant	9	Delayed – Pending consultation with MPSA	2016-11-01	4 Years, 4 Months
13.	Assistant Director: Human Resource Administration	9	Delayed – Pending consultation with MPSA	2019-06-01	1 Year, 9 Months
14.	Assistant Director: Enterprise and Supplier Development	9	Screening and reference checks	2019-03-01	2 Years
15.	Assistant Director: Local Economic Development and Informal Business	9	To be advertised	2021-03-25	1 day
16.	Business Development Officer	8	Advertised	2020-09-01	6 Months
17.	Business Development Officer	8	Advertised	2019-07--12	1 Year, 7 Months
18.	Enterprise & Supplier Development Officer	8	Screening and reference checks	2019-10-01	1 Year, 5 Months
19.	Logistics Officer	7	Screening and reference checks	2020-02-01	1 Year, 1 Month
20.	Human Resources Practitioner	7	Offer Made – Candidate will assume duty on 25 March	2019-01-01	2 Years, 2 Months
21.	Senior Personnel Officer	6	Screening and reference checks	2020-01-01	1 Year, 2 Months
22.	Administrator	6	Screening and reference checks	2019-10-01	1 Year, 5 Months
23.	Administrator	6	Screening and reference checks	2019-10-01	1 Year, 5 Months
24.	Domestic Worker	3	To assume duty 29 March	2021-02-23	23 Days

2.(a) Three (3) employees have been appointed in acting positions as follows:

(a) Details	(b) Time
No	Post Job Title Description	Post Salary Level	Recruitment Status	Vacant Since	Acting Period
1.	Director-General	16	Pending decision from Cabinet	2018-10-01	2018-10-01	2 Years, 5 Months
2.	Deputy Director-General: Enterprise Competitiveness Support	15	Advertisement Process	2018-08-01	2018-08-01	2 Years, 7 Months
3.	Director: Blended Finance	13	Screening and reference checks	2020-04-01	2020-04-01	11 Months

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Response Recommended By:

_______________________

MR LINDOKUHLE MKHUMANE

ACTING DIRECTOR GENERAL: DEPARTMENT OF SMALL BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT

DATE:

___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

RESPONSE RECOMMENDED BY:

________________________

MS ROSEMARY CAPA, MP

DEPUTY MINISTER OF SMALL BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT

DATE:

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

RESPONSE APPROVED BY:

_________________________

MS KHUMBUDZO NTSHAVHENI, MP

MINISTER OF SMALL BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT

DATE: