Questions to Ministers

09 November 2016 - NW2360

Waters, Mr M to ask the Minister of Home Affairs

(1)Whether a certain person (names and details furnished) has been granted permanent citizenship; if not, (a) what is the current status of her permanent residence application and (b) by which date will the application be finalised; if so, (i) who issued the specified person’s permanent residence permit, (ii) on which date was the permit issued and (iii) by which home affairs office; 2) (a) what is the specified person’s identification number and (b)(i) where and (ii) on what date can the specified person receive her certificate

Source
Link

Reply:

(1)(a-b) The applicant was granted permanent residence on 2 December 2013. She already has permanent residence, Permit number is GER1044/2011 issued by Department’s Head Office.

(2)(a-b) The specified person does not have an identity number. If she applied for one then proof of application must be submitted.

09 November 2016 - NW1959

Boshoff, Ms SH to ask the Minister of Basic Education

(1)How many female learners dropped out of schools due to falling pregnant in the (a) 2013, (b) 2014 and (c) 2015 academic years in each district in each province; (2) how many of the specified pregnancies were (a) reported by the respective principals to the relevant provincial departments of education, (b) referred to the SA Council for Educators and (c) classified as statutory rape cases in each district and province in the specified academic years?

Source
Link

Reply:

(1)The question of learner pregnancy must be reviewed in light of overall learner drop-out as pregnancy is one of the various self-reported reasons for learner drop-out.

(1a-c) The Annual School Survey administered by the DBE collects information on learner pregnancy by asking the school principal for: the number of learners that they are aware of who fell pregnant during the academic year. The data is disaggregated by grade and province but not by district.

Note: This data is preliminary and should be treated with caution (i) the figure may be under-reported as principals may not be made aware of all learners that leave the schooling system due to pregnancy; (ii) it does not account for learners that return to schools after pregnancy.

Table 1: Number of learners who fell pregnant, by grade and province, between 2013 and 2015 see the link:

http://pmg-assets.s3-website-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/RNW1959TABLE-161109.pdf

Source: 2013-2015 Annual School Survey

Note 1: The ASS question on learner pregnancy asks the school principal for: “the number of learners (That they are aware of) who got pregnant the previous academic year”.

Note 2: The data, as received from the provinces, are preliminary and must be treated with caution, since it has not been published in this format.

Based on the caveats in interpreting the ASS data, the General Household Survey (GHS) 2002-2015 conducted by Statistics South Africa, may be a better source of data on the specific question of learner pregnancy in relation to learner drop-out. The table below provides the GHS response for 2013-2015 on the number of learners that indicated pregnancy as the reasons for not attending an educational institution. The information collected is disaggregated by province but not by district.

Note: the number in the bracket ( ) is the number of observation in the sample while the other value is the weighted estimate. The weighted estimates from the sampled households are constructed so that the responses could be properly expanded to represent the entire civilian population of South Africa.

Please also note that the table below provides information on learners between 7-18 years, noting that the compulsory schooling age is 7-15 years.

Number of 7 -18 year old who self-reported not attending educational institutions because of pregnancy

Province	2013	2014	2015
Western Cape	1 837	0	1 039
	(4)	(0)	(1)
Eastern Cape	3 382	3 931	5 212
	(5)	(7)	(7)
Northern Cape	471	1 057	1 696
	(3)	(4)	(4)
Free State	1 666	1 489	0
	(5)	(4)	(0)
KwaZulu-Natal	9 009	2 389	4 645
	(15)	(4)	(7)
North West	2 148	0	2 709
	(3)	(0)	(4)
Gauteng	1 442	1 473	1 005
	(2)	(1)	(2)
Mpumalanga	1 234	1 662	2 270
	(4)	(4)	(4)
Limpopo	675	1 736	842
	(1)	(3)	(1)
South Africa	21 864	13 737	19 418
	(42)	(27)	(30)

Source: Statistics South Africa, General Household Survey, 2013 – 2015, DBE own calculations

Compiler Question 1

(2) (a) See response on (1) (c) above.

(b) The DBE has not referred any learner pregnancy cases to the South African Council of Educators.

(c) The DBE has not undertaken classification of learner pregnancy cases. Currently, the DBE is developing a protocol for the Prevention and Management of Learner Pregnancy, which intends to guide all stakeholders and custodians with this classification exercise and the course of action.

09 November 2016 - NW2191

Kopane, Ms SP to ask the Minister of Basic Education

How many (a) educators who are foreign nationals taught at each (i) school for learners with special educational needs, (ii) school for the visually impaired and (iii) school for the hearing impaired in each district of each province in the (aa) 2013-14, (bb) 2014-15 and (cc) 2015-16 financial years and (b) of the specified educators were appropriately trained in the respective fields of expertise for each of the specified schools?

Source
Link

Reply:

How many (a) educators who are foreign nationals taught at each (i) school for learners with special educational needs, (ii) school for the visually impaired and (iii) school for the hearing impaired in each district of each province in the (aa) 2013-14, (bb) 2014-15 and (cc) 2015-16 financial years and (b) of the specified educators were appropriately trained in the respective fields of expertise for each of the specified schools?

(a) (i) Refer to Annexures A, B and C.

(ii) No foreign educator at schools for the visually impaired.

(iii) Refer Annexures A, B and C.

(aa) Refer to Annexure A.

(bb) Refer to Annexure B.

(cc) Refer to Annexure C.

(b) The information requested is currently not available at national level. A request for information has been sent to all Provincial Education Departments and it will be provided as soon as it is received.

Annexure A- (i), (iii), (aa) 2013/14

DISTRICT	SCHOOL	(iii) HEARING IMPAIRED	(i) SPECIAL EDUCATION NEEDS
EASTERN CAPE	0	7
BIZANA DISTRICT OFFICE	ZAMOKUHLE SPECIAL		1
EAST LONDON	VUKUHAMBE SPECIALCAP		1
MALUTI	SIVE SPECIAL SCHOOL		1
MTHATHA	EFATA SCHOOL FOR THE BLIND : UMTATA*	2
	IKWEZI LOKUSA SPECIAL SCHOOL*	1
KWAZULU-NATAL		0	21
AMAJUBA DISTRICT : CLUSTER A	YWCA SPEC 298220		1
PINETOWN DISTRICT : CLUSTER A	KWATHINTWA DEAF SPEC 183853	2
	RP MOODLEY SPEC 306101		1
PORT SHEPSTONE DISTRICT : CLUSTER A	ST MARTIN DEPORRES SPEC 276131	1
UMLAZI DISTRICT : CLUSTER A	DURBAN DEAF SPEC 125467		2
	INANDA SPEC 161838		3
	VN NAIK DEAF SPEC 290783		3
UMLAZI DISTRICT : CLUSTER B	KWAVULINDLEBE SPEC 183890		1
	NINGIZIMU SPEC 230880		2
	OPEN AIR SPEC 244089		1
UMZINYATHI DISTRICT : CLUSTER B	UKUKHANYA KOMSINGA SPECIAL 440152	4
WESTERN CAPE		3	3
METRO EAST EDUCATION DISTRICT	CENTRE OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY	2
	NOLUTHANDO SKOOL VIR DOWES	1
METRO NORTH EDUCATION DISTRICT	CAREL DU TOIT CENTRE	1
METRO SOUTH EDUCATION DISTRICT	CAPE ACADEMY FOR MATHS/SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY	1
	DOMINICAN DEAF	1
NATIONAL TOTAL	3	30

Annexure B- (i), (iii), (bb) 2014/15

DISTRICT	SCHOOL	(iii) HEARING IMPAIRED	(i) SPECIAL EDUCATION NEEDS
EASTERN CAPE		0	4
BIZANA DISTRICT OFFICE	ZAMOKUHLE SPECIAL		1
EAST LONDON	VUKUHAMBE SPECIALCAP		1
MTHATHA	EFATA SCHOOL FOR THE BLIND : UMTATA*	2
FREE STATE		0	3
FREE STATE: EDUCATION	BARTIMEA SPECIALISED SCHOOL	1
	FAKKEL SPECIAL SCHOOL		1
	LETTIE FOUCHE SPECIAL SCHOOL	1
GAUTENG		0	31
GW: GAUTENG WEST INSTITUTIONS	GW: ITIRELENG SCHOOL		2
	GW: ITUMELENG SCHOOL		3
	GW: WEST RAND SCHOOL		1
JE: JOHANNESBURG EAST INSTITUTIONS	JE: ALEXANDRA SECONDARY SCHOOL	1
	JE: JOHANNESBURG HOSPITAL SCHOOL	2
	JE: ST VINCENT SCHOOL		2
JN: JOHANNESBURG NORTH INSTITUTIONS	JN: DELTAPARK SKOOL		2
	JN: GOUVELD VAARDIGHEIDSSKOOL	1
	JN: NEW NATION SCHOOL		5
JS: JOHANNESBURG SOUTH INSTITUTIONS	JS: FRANCES VORWERGSKOOL	1
	JS: JISWA TRAINING CENTRE		2
	JS: MC KHARBAI SCHOOL		6
TS: TSHWANE SOUTH INSTITUTIONS	TS: TSHEGOFATSONG SCHOOL	3
KWAZULU-NATAL		0	13
AMAJUBA DISTRICT : CLUSTER A	YWCA SPEC 298220		1
PINETOWN DISTRICT : CLUSTER A	KWATHINTWA DEAF SPEC 183853	2
	THE BROWN'S SPEC 112702		1
UGU DISTRICT : CLUSTER A	ST MARTIN DEPORRES SPEC 276131	1
UMGUNGUNDLOVU DISTRICT : CLUSTER B	PETER PAN SPEC 247123		1
UMLAZI DISTRICT : CLUSTER A	DURBAN DEAF SPEC 125467		1
	INANDA SPEC 161838		1
	VN NAIK DEAF SPEC 290783		1
UMLAZI DISTRICT : CLUSTER B	KWAVULINDLEBE SPEC 183890		1
	NINGIZIMU SPEC 230880		1
UMZINYATHI DISTRICT : CLUSTER B	UKUKHANYA KOMSINGA SPECIAL 440152	2
LIMPOPO PROVINCE		0	2
BOCHUM WEST CIRCUIT OFFICE	HELENE FRANZ SECONDARY		1
SOUTPANSBERG EAST CIRCUIT OFFICE	RIVONI SCHOOL FOR THE BLIND	1
MPUMALANGA		0	3
MDE EHLANZENI INSTITUTIONS	SILINDOKUHLE SCHOOL: SEVERELY MENTALLY HANDICAPPED	1
MDE NKANGALA INSTITUTIONS	THANDUXOLO SCHOOL: SEVERELY MENTALLY HANDICAPPED	1
	WOLVENKOP SCHOOL FOR SEVERELY MENTALLY HANDICAPPED	1
NORTH WEST		0	28
GREATER DELAREYVILLE AREA OFFICE (DR RSM)	LILLIAN LEHETLA SPECIAL SCHOOL___________________*	6
GREATER TAUNG AREA OFFICE (DR RSM)	MM SEBITLOANE SPECIAL SCHOOL_____________________*	1
KAGISANO MOLOPO AREA OFFICE (DR RSM)	TEMOSO SPECIAL SCHOOL____________________________*	1
KGETLENG RIVER AREA OFFICE (NGAKA MODIRI MOLEMA)	RORISANG SPECIAL SCHOOL__________________________*	1
LETLHABILE AREA OFFICE (BOJANALA)	OBED MORE SPECIAL SCHOOL_________________________*	2
LICHTENBURG AREA OFFICE (NGAKA MODIRI MOLEMA)	REATLEGILE SPECIAL SCHOOL		5
MADIBENG AREA OFFICE (BOJANALA)	REKGONNE-BAPO SPECIAL SCHOOL (BAKWENA BAPO)______*	2
MAFIKENG AREA OFFICE (NGAKA MODIRI MOLEMA)	BOPHELONG SPECIAL SCHOOL_________________________*	3
MAQUASSI HILLS AREA OFFICE (DR KK)	NORTH WEST SPECIAL SCHOOL________________________*	2
MOSES KOTANE EAST AREA OFFICE (BOJ)	REOLEBOGE SPECIAL SCHOOL_________________________*	2
REKOPANTSWE AREA OFFICE (NGAKA MODIRI MOLEMA)	RETLAMETSWE SPECIAL SCHOOL_______________________*	1
ZEERUST AREA OFFICE (NGAKA MODIRI MOLEMA)	DP MOLOTO SPECIAL SCHOOL_________________________*	1
	RESOMARETSE SPECIAL SCHOOL_______________________*	1
WESTERN CAPE		3	2
METRO EAST EDUCATION DISTRICT	CENTRE OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY	1
	NOLUTHANDO SKOOL VIR DOWES	1
METRO NORTH EDUCATION DISTRICT	CAREL DU TOIT CENTRE	1
METRO SOUTH EDUCATION DISTRICT	CAPE ACADEMY FOR MATHS/SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY	1
	DOMINICAN DEAF	1
TOTAL	3	86

Annexure C- (i), (iii), (cc) 2015/16

DISTRICT	SCHOOL	(iii) HEARING IMPAIRED	(i) SPECIAL EDUCATION NEEDS
EASTERN CAPE		0	7
GRAHAMSTOWN	GRAHAMSTOWN AMASANGO CAREER SCHOOL	1
MTHATHA	EFATA SCHOOL FOR THE BLIND : UMTATA*	3
FREE STATE
FREE STATE: EDUCATION	FAKKEL SPECIAL SCHOOL		1
	PHOLOHO SPECIAL SCHOOL		1
	ROSENHOF SPECIAL SCHOOL		1
GAUTENG
EN: EKURHULENI NORTH INSTITUTION	EN: EAST RAND SCHOOL OF ARTS	1
	EN: ELANDSPARKSKOOL		2
	EN: ITHEMBALIHLE SCHOOL		2
ES: EKURHULENI SOUTH INSTITUTION	ES: ZIMELENI SCHOOL		1
GE: GAUTENG EAST INSTITUTIONS	GE: FELICITAS SCHOOL		1
	GE: KWA-THEMA SKILLS SCHOOL	1
GW: GAUTENG WEST INSTITUTIONS	GW: ITIRELENG SCHOOL FOR SEVERLY MANTALLY HANDICAP	3
	GW: ITUMELENG SCHOOL FOR SEVERLY MENTALLY HANDICAP	3
	GW: ROTARA SKOOL		1
JC: JOHANNESBURG CENTRAL INSTITUTIONS	JC: ADELAIDE TAMBO SCHOOL		4
	JC: FUNDA UJABULE SCH INST FOR CHILDHOOD EDUCATION	1
	JC: FUTURASKOOL		2
	JC: PACE SECONDARY SCHOOL		3
	JC: PUMELELA TRAINING CENTRE	4
	JC: RANDEORSKOOL		1
JE: JOHANNESBURG EAST INSTITUTIONS	JE: FOREST TOWN SCHOOL		1
	JE: JOHANNESBURG HOSPITAL SCHOOL	4
	JE: ST VINCENT SCHOOL		2
JN: JOHANNESBURG NORTH INSTITUTIONS	JN: DELTAPARK SKOOL		2
	JN: GOUVELD VAARDIGHEIDSSKOOL	2
	JN: HOPE SCHOOL.		1
	JN: NEW NATION SCHOOL		2
	JN: ST BARNABAS COLLEGE		1
JS: JOHANNESBURG SOUTH INSTITUTIONS	JS: DUZENENDLELA SPECIAL SCHOOL	8
	JS: MC KHARBAI SCHOOL		5
	JS: NATIONAL SCHOOL OF THE ARTS	1
TN: TSHWANE NORTH INSTITUTIONS	TN: TSOSOLOSO SCHOOL		1
TS: TSHWANE SOUTH INSTITUTIONS	TS: TSHEGOFATSONG SPECIAL SCHOOL	2
TW: TSHWANE WEST INSTITUTIONS	TW: FILADELFIA		4
	TW: MEDICOS		1
	TW: PRINSHOFSKOOL		1
KWAZULU-NATAL
BAMBANANI CIRCUIT MANAGEMENT	UKUKHANYA KOMSINGA SPECIAL 440152	4
DANHAUSER CIRCUIT MANAGEMENT	YWCA SPEC 298220		1
DURBAN CENTRAL CIRCUIT MANAGEMENT	VN NAIK DEAF SPEC 290783		1
DURBAN NORTH-WEST CIRCUIT MANAGEMENT	KWATHINTWA DEAF SPEC 183853	2
NDWEDWE CIRCUIT MANAGEMENT	AM MOOLLA NOVA SPEC 101232	1
PAULPIETERSBURG CIRCUIT MANAGEMENT	MYEKENI PRIM 343286		2
PHUMELELA CIRCUIT MANAGEMENT	KWAVULINDLEBE SPEC 183890		1
	NINGIZIMU SPEC 230880		1
UBUMBANO CIRCUIT MANAGEMENT	PETER PAN SPEC 247123		1
LIMPOPO PROVINCE		0	4
BOCHUM WEST CIRCUIT OFFICE	HELENE FRANZ SECONDARY		1
HLOGOTLOU CIRCUIT OFFICE	BOSELE SCHOOL		1
SOUTPANSBERG EAST CIRCUIT OFFICE	RIVONI SCHOOL FOR THE BLIND	2
MPUMALANGA		0	2
MDE NKANGALA INSTITUTIONS	THANDUXOLO SPECIAL SCHOOL (SMH)	2
	WOLVENKOP SPECIAL SCHOOL (SMH)	2
NORTH WEST		0	9
GREATER DELAREYVILLE AREA OFFICE (DR RSM)	LILLIAN LEHETLA SPECIAL SCHOOL___________________*	2
LETLHABILE AREA OFFICE (BOJANALA)	OBED MORE SPECIAL SCHOOL_________________________*	1
LICHTENBURG AREA OFFICE (NGAKA MODIRI MOLEMA)	REATLEGILE SPECIAL SCHOOL		1
MADIBENG AREA OFFICE (BOJANALA)	REKGONNE-BAPO SPECIAL SCHOOL (BAKWENA BAPO)______*	2
MAQUASSI HILLS AREA OFFICE (DR KK)	NORTH WEST SPECIAL SCHOOL________________________*	1
MOSES KOTANE EAST AREA OFFICE (BOJ)	REOLEBOGE SPECIAL SCHOOL_________________________*	2
NORTHERN CAPE		0	1
FRANCIS BAARD	RE TLAMELENG SCHOOL-FOR-PHYSICAL HANDICAPPED	1
WESTERN CAPE		2	0
METRO SOUTH EDUCATION DISTRICT	DOMINICAN DEAF	2
NATIONAL TOTAL	2	107

09 November 2016 - NW2010

Maimane, Mr MA to ask the Minister of Finance

Has he been approached regarding the financing of the leasing of an intercontinental VVIP aircraft for the SA Air Force by (a) the Minister of Defence and Military Veterans and/or (b) any other government (i) entity and/or (ii) official; if so; what are the relevant details in each case?

Source
Link

Reply:

The National Treasury has been informed in terms of section 43 of the Public Finance Management Act (PFMA) that a virement of R95.97 million has been effected by the Department of Defence towards the leasing of Presidential VIP air transport.

09 November 2016 - NW2150

Mileham, Mr K to ask the Minister of Finance

Whether any municipalities have (a) deposited funds with and/or (b) made loans to VBS Mutual Bank in the past five municipal financial years; if not, in each case, what is the position in this regard; if so, in each case, (i) which municipality (aa) deposited funds with and/or (bb) made loans to the specified bank, (ii) when was each (aa) deposit and/or (bb) loan made and (iii) what was the amount in each case?

Source
Link

Reply:

(a) According to National Treasury’s database of Section 71 reports submitted by the municipality as at 30 June 2016, investments with VBS Mutual Bank were made by the following municipalities:

(i) West Rand District Municipality

(ii) Capricorn District Municipality

(b) Municipalities do not make loans to financial institutions and /or banks as a standard practice as they are not allowed to lend money to financial institutions. There is also no municipality that has a primary bank account with VBS Mutual Bank.

(c) There are no other municipalities that have invested with VBS Mutual Bank according to the National Treasury’s database.

(d) According to National Treasury’s database of Section 71 reports submitted by the municipality as at 30 June 2016, investments with VBS Mutual Bank were made by the following municipalities:

Name of Municipality	Start Date	End Date	Amount	Balance
West Rand Municipality	24/02/2015	23/08/2015	R21 million	R0
West Rand Municipality	22/03/2016	23/09/2016	R10 million	R10 million
West Rand Municipality	30/03/2016	23/04/2016	R15 million	R0
West Rand Municipality	08/04/2016	07/06/2016	R15 million	R0
Capricorn District Municipality	01/04/2016	30/06/2016	R120 million	R0

09 November 2016 - NW2297

Tarabella - Marchesi, Ms NI to ask the Minister of Home Affairs

Whether any (a) internal and/or (b) external forensic reports pertaining to (i) his department and/or (ii) each entity reporting to him were completed from 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what is the (aa) name, (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of each of the specified forensic reports?

Source
Link

Reply:

Responses provided by the Department of Home Affairs, Electoral Commission and Government Printing Works are tabulated below:

Department of Home Affairs

	(aa) - Name	(bb) Subject Matter	(cc) Conclusion date
(a)(i)	1. Tender DHA22-2013	Allegations of the alterations of the price after closing date of the tender	30 June 2015
	2. Tender DHA07-2014	Complaint from member of the public on the awarding of a tender	24 August 2015
	3. Interest on overdue accounts	Interest charged on overdue accounts submitted by Refugee Ministries Centre for interpretation services	26 September 2016
(a)(ii)	No	N/A	N/A

According to the Electoral Commission

	(aa) - Name	(bb) Subject Matter	(cc) Conclusion date
(a)(ii)	No	N/A	N/A
(b)(ii)	1. Forensic Investigation: Electoral Commission – Riverside Office Park	The lease agreement entered into for the Electoral Commission’s national office accommodation	14 December 2013

According to the Government Printing Works

	(aa) - Name	(bb) Subject Matter	(cc) Conclusion date
(a)(ii)	1. Government Printing Works (GPW)	Unauthorised and confidential information shared with external parties relating to the physical security and guarding services tender at GPW Head and Regional Offices	30 September 2016
(b)(ii)	No	N/A	N/A

09 November 2016 - NW2192

Kopane, Ms SP to ask the Minister of Basic Education

What is the total number of (a) overaged learners who were enrolled at each (i) school for learners with special educational needs, (ii) school for the visually impaired and (iii) school for the hearing impaired in each district of each province in the (aa) 2013-14, (bb) 2014-15 and (cc) 2015-16 financial years, (b) learners who were incorrectly placed at each specified school because mainstream schools did not have space to accommodate the learners and (c) learners who were placed on waiting lists in each case in each specified financial year?

Source
Link

Reply:

(a)(i)(aa)(bb)(cc)

The detailed response on overaged learners who were enrolled at each school for learners with special educational needs in the 2013/14; 2014/15 and 2015/16 is attached as Annexure A.

(a)(ii)(aa)(bb)(cc)

The detailed response on overaged learners who were enrolled at each school for the visually impaired in the 2013/14; 2014/15 and 2015/16 is attached as Annexure A.

(a)(iii)(aa)(bb)(cc)

The detailed response on overaged learners who were enrolled at each school for the school for the hearing impaired in each district of each province in the 2013/14; 2014/15 and 2015/16 is attached as Annexure A.

(b) Response attached at Annexure B.

(c) Response attached at Annexure C.

ANNEXURE A

(a)(i)(aa)(bb)(cc)

Table 1: Number of over-aged (19 and above) learners in special schools, by district, in between 2013 and 2015

Province	District	2013/14	2014/15	2015/16
EC	EAST LONDON	128	100	82
	GRAHAMSTOWN	27	35	30
	KING WILLIAMS TOWN	202	176	166
	LUSIKISIKI	21	18	30
	MALUTI	6	16	13
	MBIZANA	124	126	120
	MT FRERE	55	120	136
	MTHATA	202	260	208
	NGCOBO	51	39	38
	PORT ELIZABETH	183	112	92
	QUEENSTOWN	0	4	0
	QUMBU	50	59	58
	STERKSPRUIT	25	34	38
	UITENHAGE	326	99	115
	Total	1 400	1 198	1 126
FS	FEZILE DABI	103	100	91
	LEJWELEPUTSWA	98	117	133
	MOTHEO	321	305	271
	THABO MOFUTSANYANA	98	81	59
	Total	620	603	554
GT	EKURHULENI NORTH	405	364	378
	EKURHULENI SOUTH	211	256	270
	GAUTENG EAST	624	522	581
	GAUTENG NORTH	47	61	41
	GAUTENG WEST	243	250	213
	JOHANNESBURG CENTRAL	223	289	346
	JOHANNESBURG EAST	211	196	186
	JOHANNESBURG NORTH	264	281	314
	JOHANNESBURG SOUTH	173	237	204
	JOHANNESBURG WEST	135	158	179
	SEDIBENG EAST	94	94	91
	SEDIBENG WEST	113	202	173
	TSHWANE NORTH	60	58	14
	TSHWANE SOUTH	218	196	152
	TSHWANE WEST	330	352	328
	Total	3 351	3 516	3 470
KZ	AMAJUBA	317	385	277
	EMPANGENI	132	168	144
	ILEMBE	75	41	67
	OBONJENI	0	43	0
	OTHUKELA	105	131	136
	PINETOWN	213	196	171
	PORT SHEPSTONE	0	19	0
	SISONKE	20	37	35
	UGU	29	0	30
	UMGUNGUNDLOVU	264	257	239
	UMKHANYAKUDE	82	30	62
	UMLAZI	301	380	423
	UMZINYATHI	61	66	60
	UTHUNGULU	18	0	0
	VRYHEID	79	78	43
	Total	1 696	1 831	1 687
LP	CAPRICORN/Polokwane	876	954	777
	LEBOWAKGOMO	143	0	146
	MOGALAKWENA	4	0	8
	MOPANI	175	215	219
	SEKHUKHUNE	177	188	189
	TZANEEN	10	13	8
	VHEMBE	483	396	376
	WATERBERG	81	89	62
	Total	1 949	1 865	1 785
MP	BOHLABELA	241	253	5
	EHLANZENI	0	0	5
	GERT SIBANDE	0	0	111
	NKANGALA	0	0	94
	Total	241	253	215
NC	FRANCES BAARD	277	80	91
	JOHN TAOLO GAETSEWA	0	12	21
	JOHN TAOLO GAETSEWE	9	0	0
	NAMAQUA	0	0	0
	SIYANDA	0	2	2
	Total	286	94	114
NW	BRITS	0	24	0
	GREATER DELAREYVILLE	48	38	75
	GREATER TAUNG	75	69	73
	KAGISANO MOLOPO	20	23	18
	KGETLENG RIVER	23	12	11
	KLERKSDORP	0	6	0
	LETLHABILE	39	51	26
	LICHTENBURG	101	24	65
	MADIBENG	43	52	84
	MAFIKENG	85	88	0
	MAQUASSI HIILS	52	46	39
	MATLOSANA	11	3	9
	MORETELE	26	37	25
	MOSES KOTANE EAST	67	47	89
	POTCHEFSTROOM	115	76	126
	REKOPANTSWE	85	47	106
	RUSTENBURG	268	96	113
	ZEERUST	27	21	12
	Total	1 085	760	871
WC	CAPE WINELANDS	51	50	45
	EDEN AND CENTRAL KAROO	40	57	50
	METRO CENTRAL	118	142	176
	METRO EAST	161	116	92
	METRO NORTH	91	108	77
	METRO SOUTH	105	88	84
	OVERBERG	15	7	10
	WEST COAST	36	27	27
	Total	617	595	561
National		11 245	10 715	10 383

Source: 2013-15 SNAP survey for special schools

(a)(ii)(aa)(bb)(cc)

Table 2: Table 1: Number of over-aged (19 and above) learners in special schools with visually impaired, by district, in between 2013 and 2015

Province	District	2013/14	2014/15	2015/16
EC	KING WILLIAMS TOWN	0	1	2
	LUSIKISIKI	0	0
	MALUTI	0	0	2
	MBIZANA	41	38	39
	MTHATA	47	51	46
	PORT ELIZABETH	40	29	25
	STERKSPRUIT	0	0	1
	Total	128	119	115
	FEZILE DABI	1	0	0
	LEJWELEPUTSWA	1	3	2
	MOTHEO	30	27	30
FS	THABO MOFUTSANYANA	15	16	11
	Total	47	46	43
	EKURHULENI NORTH	9	2	0
	EKURHULENI SOUTH	0	0	1
	GAUTENG EAST	6	6	12
	GAUTENG WEST	6	5	4
	JOHANNESBURG CENTRAL	3	2	2
	JOHANNESBURG EAST	2	3	5
	JOHANNESBURG NORTH	1	1	0
GT	JOHANNESBURG SOUTH	0	1	1
	JOHANNESBURG WEST	7	3	2
	SEDIBENG EAST	7	6	4
	TSHWANE NORTH	1	1	0
	TSHWANE SOUTH	2	1	1
	TSHWANE WEST	91	102	99
	Total	135	133	131
KZN	AMAJUBA	5	6	4
	EMPANGENI	3	0	1
	OTHUKELA	2	3	3
	PINETOWN	3	1	1
	UGU	0	0
	UMGUNGUNDLOVU	23	21	30
	UMLAZI	13	12	10
	UMZINYATHI	1	2	1
	VRYHEID	1	1	1
	Total	51	46	51
LP	CAPRICORN	84	73	46
	LEBOWAKGOMO	5	0	5
	SEKHUKHUNE	2	4	5
	VHEMBE	40	38	36
	WATERBERG	0	0	0
	Total	131	115	92
MP	GERT SIBANDE	1	1	2
	NKANGALA	2	0	0
	Total	3	1	2
	FRANCES BAARD	4	13	17
NC	JOHN TAOLO GAETSEWA	0	1	0
	Total	4	14	17
	BRITS	0	1	0
	GREATER TAUNG	40	38	30
	KAGISANO MOLOPO	1	3	3
	LETLHABILE	0	0	1
	LICHTENBURG	14	1	0
NW	MADIBENG	0	4	3
	MOSES KOTANE EAST	3	0	0
	REKOPANTSWE	0	10	0
	RUSTENBURG	10	0	5
	ZEERUST	0	0	1
	Total	68	57	43
	CAPE WINELANDS	7	9	11
WC	METRO NORTH	32	30	24
	Total	39	39	35
National	606	570	529

Source: 2013-15 SNAP survey for special schools

(a)(iii)(aa)(bb)(cc)

Table 3: Table 1: Number of over-aged (19 and above) learners in special schools with hearing impaired, by district, between 2013 and 2015

Province	District	2013/14	2014/15	2015/16
EC	EAST LONDON	0	1	0
	KING WILLIAMS TOWN	108	97	88
	LUSIKISIKI	0	0	1
	MALUTI	6	16	10
	MTHATA	59	81	89
	PORT ELIZABETH	2	3	4
	STERKSPRUIT	0	1	0
	Total	175	199	192
FS	LEJWELEPUTSWA	0	0	1
	MOTHEO	40	35	27
	THABO MOFUTSANYANA	48	37	31
	Total	88	72	59
GT	EKURHULENI NORTH	6	1	2
	EKURHULENI SOUTH	6	8	7
	GAUTENG EAST	6	6	6
	GAUTENG WEST	9	4	3
	JOHANNESBURG CENTRAL	1	4	4
	JOHANNESBURG EAST	38	29	31
	JOHANNESBURG NORTH	1	2	0
	JOHANNESBURG SOUTH	6	20	29
	JOHANNESBURG WEST	31	41	37
	SEDIBENG EAST	3	1	2
	TSHWANE NORTH	27	23	6
	TSHWANE SOUTH	34	34	31
	TSHWANE WEST	79	96	81
	Total	247	269	239
KZ	AMAJUBA	7	7	3
	EMPANGENI	93	104	90
	ILEMBE	4	3	3
	OTHUKELA	1	0	1
	PINETOWN	77	51	56
	PORT SHEPSTONE	0	18	0
	UGU	22	0	27
	UMGUNGUNDLOVU	16	15	17
	UMLAZI	26	15	49
	UMZINYATHI	0	2	1
	VRYHEID	3	0	0
	SISONKE	1	0	0
	Total	249	215	247
LP	CAPRICORN/POLOKWANE	185	179	171
	GREATER SEKHUKHUNE	12	15	7
	TZANEEN	4	13	4
	VHEMBE	1	5	6
	WATERBERG	2	4	6
	Total	204	216	194
MP	BOHLABELA	1	0	1
	EHLANZENI	6	0	1
	GERT SIBANDE	1	1	0
	NKANGALA	6	4	0
	Total	14	5	2
NC	FRANCES BAARD	4	17	16
	JOHN TAOLO GAETSEWA	0	0	1
	Total	4	17	17
NW	GREATER TAUNG	0	2	1
	KAGISANO MOLOPO	2	0	0
	LETLHABILE	0	1	2
	LICHTENBURG	6	0	1
	MADIBENG	0	0	3
	MAFIKENG	1	0	0
	MAQUASSI HIILS	47	43	39
	MOSES KOTANE EAST	1	0	0
	POTCHEFSTROOM	0	1	0
	RUSTENBURG	17	19	19
	Total	74	66	65
WC	CAPE WINELANDS	13	15	16
	METRO CENTRAL	6	4	8
	METRO EAST	6	8	5
	METRO NORTH	0	1	1
	METRO SOUTH	27	20	33
	OVERBERG	0	1	0
	Total	52	49	63
National		1 108	1 279	1 078

Source: 2013-15 SNAP survey for special schools

Annexure B

(b) Number of learners that were incorrectly placed because mainstream schools did not have space to accommodate them

Provinces	Districts	Number of incorrectly placed learners in Special Schools (SSs)	Number of incorrectly placed learners in Special Schools (SSs) for Visual Impairment	Number of incorrectly placed learners in Special Schools (SSs) for Hearing Impairment
GP	15	All learners placed in Special Schools in Gauteng are placed in line with provincial admissions circular for learners with barriers to learning (Circular 31 of 2009)	0	0
EC	23	Nil report	Nil report	Nil report
FS	5	25	0	0
KZN	12	150	0	0
LP	1/5	5	106	0
MP	4	68	0	0
NC	1/5	0	0	0
NW	3/4	6	0	0
WC	8	0	0	0
TOTALS		98	106	0

Source: Provincial Reporting

Annexure C

c) Learners on Waiting Lists

Provinces	Districts	Number of Learners on waiting lists in Special Schools (SSs)	Number of Learners on waiting lists in Special Schools (SSs) for Visual Impairment	Number of Learners on waiting lists in Special Schools (SSs) for Hearing Impairment
		2013/14	2014/15	2015/16	2013/14	2014/15	2015/16	2013/14	2014/15	2015/16
GP	15	3902	3338	1785	0	0	46	0	0	45 not all hearing impaired, school has an MID section
EC	23	-	3691	3244	Nil report	Nil report	Nil report	Nil report	Nil report	Nil report
FS	5	266	452	621	0	0	0	0	0	0
KZN	12	3091	2190	1636	110	76	37	255	183	138
LP	4/5	582	508	568	203	1	2	9	15	10
MP	4	699	1022	850	4	10	8	20	18	17
NC	1/5	119	67	87	1	101	0	1	4	1
NW	3/4	573	658	803	-	7	-	-	11	1
WC	8	-	-	-	0	0	0	0	0	0
TOTALS	63	9232	11926	9606	419	195	47	285	231	167

Source: Provincial Reporting

09 November 2016 - NW2190

Kopane, Ms SP to ask the Minister of Basic Education

(a) How many (i) schools for learners with special educational needs, (ii) schools for the visually impaired and (iii) schools for the hearing impaired received a budget for the National School Nutrition Programme in each district of each province in the (aa) 2013-14, (bb) 2014-15 and (cc) 2015-16 financial years and (b) what amounts were allocated in each case?

Source
Link

Reply:

(a) (i) The NSNP Directorate does not have the data according to the request in (ii) and (iii). The only data available is recorded on the table below, is aggregated as provincial data.

(b) Information not available.

The Department of Basic Education (DBE) will work with the provinces to compile the requested information.

Special schools
Province	(a)(i)(ii)(iii) Number of schools	(b) Budget allocated (R)
	2013-14 (aa)	2014-15 (bb)	2015-16 (cc)	2013-14	2014-15	2015-16
Eastern Cape	12	27	27	2 494 688	2 307 704	2 121 906
Free State	10	10	10	1 686 792	1 519 145	1 262 558
Gauteng	39	56	57	4 992 896	6 975 762	7 957 786
KwaZulu-Natal	46	46	47	4 546 098	4 670 570	5 186 905
Limpopo	34	34	32	3 600 261	3 236 899	3 435 227
Mpumalanga	11	13	11	480 690	614 901	907 221
Northern Cape	7	7	9	622 802	662 848	925 120
North West	23	25	25	1 193 954	1 284 956	1 515 864
Western Cape	43	44	44	4 951 936	5 437 634	5 677 963
	225	262	262	24 570 117	26 710 419	90 550

09 November 2016 - NW2215

Carter, Ms D to ask the Minister of Finance

With regard to the current conjecture and speculation on the future of businesses linked to a certain family (name furnished), (a) what is the extent of exposure of the (i) Public Investment Corporation and (ii) Industrial Development Corporation to companies linked to the specified family and (b) what steps have been taken or will be taken to ensure that this exposure will not lead to potential losses?

Source
Link

Reply:

The following information was submitted by the Public Investment Corporation (PIC):

(a)(i) The PIC has no direct exposure to any business linked to the Gupta family.

(a)(ii) The Industrial Development Corporation queries should be directed to the Minister of Economic Development.

(b) Not applicable.

.

09 November 2016 - NW1968

Maimane, Mr MA to ask the Minister of Finance

Whether the VBS Mutual Bank has ever defaulted on its payment of dividends to the Public Investment Corporation; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, (a) on what dates, (b) what was the value of each dividend pay-out defaulted on and (c) what are the further relevant details?

Source
Link

Reply:

The following information was submitted by the Public Investment Corporation (PIC):

The VBS Mutual Bank has never defaulted on its payment of dividends to the PIC. The decision to pay dividends rests with the board of a company after taking into account factors such as capital required for growth, capital for precautionary purposes and capital adequacy requirements as well as compliance with the provisions of the Companies Act, Act 71 of 2008.

09 November 2016 - NW1887

Lees, Mr RA to ask the Minister of Finance

(1)Whether any additional vehicles form part of the security detail of the current Chair of the SA Airways Board, Ms Dudu Myeni, when she travels; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details of the vehicles with regard to the (a)(i) make and (ii) model and (b) costs of (i) purchasing and/or (ii) leasing, (iii) maintaining and (iv) running each of the specified vehicles in each month since the specified person’s appointment in 2012; (2) whether any road accidents have occurred involving (a) the person’s vehicle and/or (b) the additional vehicles in the period since the person’s appointment in 2012; if so, what are the relevant details in each such case?

Source
Link

Reply:

The following information was submitted by the South African Airways (SAA) Board:

1. The Chairperson of the SAA Board is not entitled to a security detail and none has been provided by the company. No additional vehicles are provided for the Chairperson’s travelling.

2. No vehicles have been allocated to the Chair by the company.

The National Treasury cannot verify the above information.

09 November 2016 - NW2055

Gqada, Ms T to ask the Minister of Finance

(1)Whether each Head of Department (HOD) of the National Treasury signed a performance agreement since their appointment; if not, (a) what is the total number of HODs who have not signed performance agreements, (b) what is the reason in each case, (c) what action has he taken to rectify the situation and (d) what consequences will the specified HOD face for failing to sign the performance agreements; if so, (i) when was the last performance assessment of each HOD conducted and (ii) what were the results in each case; (2) whether any of the HODs who failed to sign a performance agreement received a performance bonus since their appointment; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, (a) at what rate and (b) what criteria were used to determine the specified rate; (3) Whether any of the HODs who signed a performance agreement received a performance bonus since their appointment; if so, (a) at what rate and (b) what criteria were used to determine the rate?

Source
Link

Reply:

1. Yes, the Head of Department (HOD) of the National Treasury (NT) has signed a performance agreement since his appointment.

(a-d) Not applicable.

(i) The last performance assessment for the HOD of NT was conducted for the 2014/15 fiscal year; and

(ii) The results for the 2014/15 fiscal year was a B+ performance level in terms of NT’s performance management process.

2. The HOD signed performance agreements and has never received a performance bonus.

(a -b) Not applicable.

3. No, the HOD of NT has not received a performance bonus since his appointment.

(a -b) Not applicable.

09 November 2016 - NW2133

Lees, Mr RA to ask the Minister of Rural Development and Land Reform

With reference to Project DC23/KZ232/321, who is currently residing in the houses on the farms commonly referred to as the Charnaud Farms in the Emnambithi-Ladysmith Local Municipality in KwaZulu-Natal; (2) have any members of the (a) Sewpersad, (b) Armmarchand, (c) Roshen and/or (d) Nersha families benefitted in any way from the specified project; if so, what are the relevant details in each case with regard to benefits in (i) kind and/or (ii) cash; (3) what (a) has been the total cost of the specified project to his department and (b) is the detailed breakdown of the specified cost?

Source
Link

Reply:

(1) Currently there are two families of labour tenants that are occupying the farm houses namely, Mtshali and Mabaso families.

(2) (a), (b),(c) No, since the farm was returned to the state no members of the Sewpersad, Armmarchand, Roshen and/or Nersha families have benefited in any way.

(i),(ii) Falls away.

(3) (a) Total cost to the Department was R36 999 732.82

(b) Purchase price for land: R27 244 556.00

Total livestock cost: R6 136 400.00

Agricultural implements: R574 500.00

Developmental costs: R2 500 000.00

Conveyancing costs: R100 451.00

Assets Forfeiture Unit costs: R443 825.82

09 November 2016 - NW2148

Vos, Mr J to ask the Minister of Tourism

Whether he has made any progress on the conversion of underused state properties into tourist facilities as per the outcomes of a 2013 study to implement the budget report concept; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

Source
Link

Reply:

Following the study on the municipal owned resorts for the low budget market, the department and the Industrial Development Corporation are reviewing the outcomes so as to provide sound recommendations to the affected stakeholders on possible options going forward.

The department is further in the process of developing the Infrastructure and Investment Master Plan. The Master Plan will include catalytic projects with high impact and ensure fair provincial geographic spread.

The Infrastructure Master Plan will provide a national framework which will serve as a guideline for the development and maintenance of tourism infrastructure across the country. The framework will set out key objectives, identify and address the infrastructural challenges or gaps which exist in state owned underutilised properties in order to stimulate tourism growth.

The department is currently conducting consultations with provincial and local spheres to solicit inputs into the Master Plan.

The Department is also aware that successful implementation of the initiatives aimed at sustainability of some of these resorts rest with the owning municipalities as they would need to decide on the adoption of such proposed funding and operating models. The role of the department is to highlight such opportunities and where possible facilitate partnerships.

09 November 2016 - NW2256

Waters, Mr M to ask the Minister of Home Affairs

(a) Why does the Edenvale Home Affairs office service only 100 persons on Saturdays and (b) how many persons are turned away on average on Saturdays; (2) Whether any plans are being put in place to increase the number of persons serviced at the specified office on Saturdays; if not, why not; if so; what are the relevant details?

Source
Link

Reply:

(1)(a-b) It is not correct to state that Edenvale Home Affairs office services only 100 clients on Saturdays. The average statistics for the office on a Saturday is 120 for intake of applications for ID smart cards and passports only and 90 for collection of these documents ready for collection. This statistics excludes other legacy services rendered by the Department such as registration of births, deaths and marriages and related services required by clients over the weekend.

For your convenience I am attaching a copy of statistics for the previous three months (Aug – Oct 2016) marked Annexure A, B and C on services for ID smart card and passports excluding all other services.

2. The office is sufficiently capacitated over the weekend as there are 14 Front Office Clerks and 2 Supervisors on a weekend. Whilst the office is attending to all legacy and collection clients, the rate of processing clients applying for ID smart card and passport is due to clients’ particulars having to be captured on the live capture system.

09 November 2016 - NW2161

Waters, Mr M to ask the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services

Whether, with reference to the reply of the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs to question 1741 on 23 September 2016, he intends to introduce legislation to move the Matatiele Local Municipality back to KwaZulu-Natal from the Eastern Cape; if not, why not; if so, (a) by what date and (b) what are the further relevant details?

Source
Link

Reply:

I will introduce the relevant legislation in the event of Cabinet agreeing to move the Matatiele Local Municipality back to Kwazulu –Natal.

09 November 2016 - NW2004

Esau, Mr S to ask the Minister of Home Affairs

Whether the Burundian national, (name and details furnished), was allowed to enter the country with photocopies of her travel documents in 2014; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, (a) why was she allowed to enter the country with photocopies of her travel documents and (b) on what statutory grounds is this practice allowed?

Source
Link

Reply:

No, the passenger had no documents with her on entry into the Republic of South Africa (RSA) as it was reported to Immigration that she has been rescued and thereafter, intends to apply for asylum.

(a) She did not enter the RSA with photocopies of her travel document.

(b) In terms of the Immigration Act, 13 of 2002, as amended, as well as the Refugee Act, 130 of 1998, any person who enters the RSA with the intention to claim asylum is not required to have or produce any travel document.

The above is confirmed by the Supreme Court of Appeal Judgment in the matter of Bula & Others v Minister of Home Affairs & Others (589/11) [2011] ZASCA 209 (29 November 2011 in which the Court stated the following:

Ad Paragraph 59 “Most importantly, the provisions of Section 2 of the Refugee Act read as follows:

“Notwithstanding any provisions of this Act or any other law to the contrary, no person may be refused entry into the Republic, expelled, extradited or returned to any other country or be subject to any similar measure, if as a result of such refusal, expulsion, extradition, return or other measure, such person is compelled to return to or remain in a country where─

(a) he or she may be subjected to persecution on account of his or her race, religion, nationality, political opinion or membership of a particular social group; or

(b) his or her life, physical safety or freedom would be threatened on account of external aggression, occupation, foreign domination or other events seriously disturbing or disrupting public order in either part or the whole of that country.”

Ad Paragraph 61, the Supreme Court of Appeal further referred to one of its judgments in the matter of Abdi v Minister of Home Affairs 2011 (3) SA 37 (SCA) and stated the following:

“In Abdi v Minister of Home Affairs 2011 (3) SA 37 (SCA) paragraph 22, this court noted that the provisions of the Act referred to in the preceding paragraph mirror those of the 1951 United Nations Convention on the Status of Refugees and the 1969 Organisation of African Unity Convention. In paragraph 22 of Abdi this court went on to say that these provisions ‘patently prohibit the prevention of access to the Republic of any person who has been forced to flee the country of his or her birth because of any of the circumstances identified in Section 2 of the Act”.

It is evident from the above stated legislation and Court Judgments, including International Conventions that no one who is claiming asylum may be refused entry into the RSA.

09 November 2016 - NW2284

Van Dyk, Ms V to ask the Minister of Home Affairs

(1)What is the current status of the application for the renewal of the passport of a certain person (name and details furnished); (2) (a) why was the specified person’s application for the renewal of a passport blocked, (b) why was the person flagged for investigation, (c) what were the findings against the person and (d) what steps will he take to resolve the specified matter speedily?

Source
Link

Reply:

(1) There is no passport application lodged on the system. However, the client is eligible to apply.

(2)(a-b) The specified person’s application for the renewal of a passport was not blocked. Markers were set on her identity number for precautionary purposes (awaiting confirmation of naturalisation requirements/ prerequisites in accordance with Section 5(5)(a) of the South African Citizenship Act, (Act no. 88 of 1995) (“the Citizenship Act”). This process was not pursuing the specified person, as it is similarly done to all foreign nationals who had acquired permanent residency and whose naturalisation process was not yet entirely concluded.

(2)(c) The investigation concluded that the applicant complied with Section 5(5)(a) of the South African Citizenship Act, 1995 (Act no. 88 of 1995). Section 5(5)(a) of the Act stipulates that the husband/wife of the South African citizen who has been married to a South African citizen for a period of two years may apply for naturalisation as a South African citizen if he/she has been permanently resident in the Republic for a period of two years after the Permanent Residence was issued.

(2)(d) Markers have been lifted on the identity number and the specified person can lodge the application for the required document (passport).

08 November 2016 - NW2300

Mokgalapa, Mr S to ask the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services

Whether any (a) internal and/or (b) external forensic reports pertaining to (i) his department and/or (ii) each entity reporting to him were completed from 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what is the (aa) name, (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of each of the specified forensic reports?

Source
Link

Reply:

1.Department of Justice and Constitutional Development:

The Department of Justice and Constitutional Development does not have data of the forensic audit cases for the past four (4) financial years. However, the attached spreadsheet, attached as Annexure A, provides details of the forensic audit cases registered in the 2013/14, 2014/15, 2015/16 and 2015/16 financial years.

2. Entities:

2.1 National Prosecuting Authority (NPA):

The NPA has informed that there are no forensic reports pertaining to the NPA in the period from 1 January 2009 up to date.

2.2 Special Investigating Unit (SIU):

The SIU is not aware of any internal or external forensic reports pertaining to its affairs for the period specified.

2.3 Legal Aid South Africa:

(a) The Legal Aid SA‘s internal forensic reports completed from 1 January 2009 to September 2016 are tabulated below:

aa) Name	bb)Subject matter	cc) Date of conclusion
(A) 2010/11 financial year
1. Allegation on performing private work and utilising Legal Aid South Africa’s assets and stationery	Allegations against a Justice Centre Executive for performing private work. It was alleged the Executive used Legal Aid SA’s stationery, printers and personnel to run his private business.	4 October 2010
2. The alleged use of Ms. Martha Mbhele’s 3G by someone else	Alleged use of a 3G card allocated to Legal Aid SA employee by someone else.	27 September 2010
3. Half day leave review at Bloemfontein Justice Centre	Review of half days leave taken at justice centre	11 July 2011
4. Complaint by Ms Ntombikhona Emmaculate Dlamini	An investigation of circumstances relating to the legal services rendered by Judicare practitioner to a legal Aid Sa client in an eviction matter	February 2011
5. Fixed asset disposed off, but is still reflected in the asset Register	Investigation of a suspicious deposit slip submitted as proof of payment for a disposed asset.	8 October 2010
6. Break-in at second floor national office Finance Department and the conduct of the corporate services manager.	An investigation of a break-in at National Office Finance Department second floor during the 2010 December year end closure.	16 February 2011
7. Allegation on non-adherence to policies, theft, abuse of Power and conflict of interest	An alleged use of Legal Aid SA’s vehicle by an employee without authorisation; the sale/scrapping of assets without proper authorisation by an employee; and a suspected conflict of interest in awarding a contract to install burglar guards at a Justice Centre.	30 September 2010

aa) Name	bb)Subject matter	cc) Date of conclusion
(B) 2011/12 financial year
1. Thembisa Justice Centre receptionist’s cash stolen from her hand bag.	Investigation of circumstances in which cash was stolen from an employee’s hand bag at a Justice Centre.	23 September 2011
2. Fraud suspected invoices and quotations at Soweto Justice Centre.	Suspected fraudulent invoice and quotations at Justice Centre.	3 June 2011
3. Irregularities relating to the disposal of fixed asset and the management of petty cash at Ermelo Justice Centre.	Suspected irregularities relating to the disposal of fixed asset and the management of petty cash at a Justice Centre.	11 October 2011
4. Agency agreement practitioner MB Popo & company	Suspected fraudulent claim by an Agency Agreement practitioner.	30 November 2011
5. Stolen cellphones at Procurement department.	Disappearance of two cellphones from Procurement Manager’s office. The cellphones were delivered by Vodacom to be distributed to employees who had ordered the phones under the contract Legal Aid SA had with Vodacom	12 October 2011
6. Alleged Soshanguve JCE improper conduct and poor managerial skills	An alleged misconduct by Justice Centre Executive for ill-treating and undermining her subordinates.	3 October 2011
7. Legal Aid SA Principal Attorney suspected of trying to pass work of other practitioners as that of his own for quality assessment purposes.	An alleged attempted fraud by a Legal Aid SA Principal Attorney who tried to claim work of other practitioners as his for quality assessment purposes.	14 July 2011
8. Mr. Makgape Sophia Rammala received R2,000.00 cash from the client’s sister Ms. Fengie Masha	An allegation against a Legal Aid SA legal practitioner based at a Satellite Office for charging a member of public fees for legal assistance given to Legal Aid SA’s client.	25 November 2011

aa) Name	bb)Subject matter	cc) Date of conclusion
(C) 2012/13 financial year
1. Retrieving evidence on 3 hard drives from Pietermaritzburg Justice Centre	A complaint that alleged that a Legal Aid SA Principal Attorney’s computer hard drives contained pornographic files.	9 May 2012
2. Interview questions sent to selected shortlisted job applicants.	A complaint that alleged that a Justice Centre Executive emailed interview questions to the applicant.	4 December 2012
3. Cover quoting from Creative Office Furniture and Impilo Lifestyle	A suspected cover quoting by external bidders for Legal Aid SA work or contract.	14 December 2012
4. Irregularities relating to the disposal of a Toyota Yaris at Ermelo Justice Centre	An allegation that a Legal Aid SA pool vehicle was disposed at a value below the original reserve price.	5 March 2013
5. Description of goods not specified on the invoices for procurement at Nelspruit Justice Centre.	An alleged circumvention and or violation of Legal Aid SA Supply Chain policy and procedures in procuring office grocery.	25 January 2013
(D) 2014/15 financial year
Financial irregularities and conflict of interest at the Pretoria Justice Centre	A suspected existence of conflict of interest when a contract was awarded.	29 July 2014
(E) 2015/16 financial year
1. Forensic investigation on the missing computer at the Kwa-Zulu Natal regional office	Investigation of circumstances in which a laptop computer got missing while it was allocated to and in custody of a Legal Aid employee,	26 May 2015
2. Forensic potential conflict of interest at the Ermelo Justice Centre, Piet Retief satellite office	A suspicion of existence of conflict of interest when a cleaning contract at Justice Centre was awarded.	23 July 2015
3. Forensic report suspected irregular expenditure at Modimolle Justice Centre	A suspicion of occurrence of irregularities in awarding a contract for office refurbishment at Justice Centre.	22 January 2016
4. Forensic potential conflict of interest at the Soweto Justice Centre	A suspected conflict of interest by a legal practitioner.	28 September 2015
5. Alleged conflict of interest at Bloemfontein justice centre	A Legal Aid SA Justice Centre Executive was alleged to owning a company that was doing with Legal Aid SA resulting in conflict of interest.	29 March 2015
(F) 2016/17 financial year
1. Alleged abuse of legal Aid resources	A Legal Aid SA employee was accused of abusing Legal Aid SA resources (computer and photocopying facility) for private matters.	2 June 2016
2. Alleged payment requested by a justice practitioner for legal representation services	A former Legal Aid SA employee was accused of having requested payment for his services in representing a client on behalf of Legal Aid SA. The employee had retired when the accusations were made.	6 June 2016
3. suspected overstatement of claims by a Judicare Practitioner at Vryheid Justice Centre	A Judicare Practitioner was suspected to have submitted fraudulent and overstated claim for work that was done on behalf of Legal Aid SA.	15 June 2016
4. Suspected use of pool vehicle without authorization at the Queenstown Justice Centre	A Legal Aid SA employee was alleged to have used a pool vehicle for private business.	27 June 2016
5. Client money received by a paralegal and not paid over to the client at Musina satellite office	A Legal Aid SA Paralegal was alleged to have taken money that was meant for the client in the sale of an RDP house.	15 August 2016

(b) There were no external forensic reports in the period 2009 to date.

3. Department of Correctional Services:

BOSASA contract investigation done by SIU and former CFO was criminally charged and during disciplinary hearing he resigned.

Medical Aid fraud (MEDCOR) investigation against 702 officials done by Special Investigation Unit. Officials were criminally charged and internally they were given final written warnings. The money fraudulently obtained was recovered from the doctors.

Social grant investigation against SASSA beneficiaries against the officials was done by SIU. Officials failed to cancel grant benefits from SASSA when employed by the department or SASSA failed to stop the grant immediately after the employment of the officials. All the money owed to SASSA was paid back and disciplinary steps were taken against the involved officials.

Fraudulent matric certificates. The SIU completed investigations of 22 Department of Correctional Services officials who submitted fraudulent matric certificates. Twenty of the said officials have been dismissed.

Electronic monitoring investigation was done by KPMG. The KPMG investigation report was forwarded to SIU for further investigation. The SIU is still pursuing the matter further.

The Masetlaoka Scott and Wilson (MSW) contract still under investigation. The investigation is in progress. SIU is pursuing the matter. One official is internally charged.

08 November 2016 - NW2249

Hunsinger, Dr CH to ask the Minister of Transport

(1)Whether her department has complied with all court orders that were issued in respect of the Tasima matter; if not, (a) why not, in each case and (b) which court orders did her department not comply with; if so, what is the position in this regard; (2) (a) what amount did her department pay to Tasima since the last court order was issued, (b) on what date were the specified payments made and (c) what were the reasons for each payment made?

Source
Link

Reply:

(1) The Department has complied with all court orders in the Tasima matter.

(2) (a) The Department has paid the total amounts of R55 769 058.44.

(b) They were paid on 2 September 2016, 29 September 2016 and 26 October 2016.

(c) It was payment for services rendered by Tasima on the eNatis including payments to third parties amongst those Telkom and the South African Post Office.

08 November 2016 - NW2366

Steyn, Ms A to ask the Minister of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries

Whether, in light of the severe drought that the country is currently experiencing, his department (a) drilled and/or (b) refurbished any boreholes since 1 October 2015; if not, why not; if so, (i) how many boreholes did his department (aa) drill and/or (bb) refurbish during the specified period, (ii) what is the exact GPS location of each of the specified boreholes, (iii) what were the costs of (aa) drilling per meter and/or (bb) refurbishment in each case and (iv) was water found at each of the boreholes?

Source
Link

Reply:

DAFF Directorate Infrastructure Support from Food Security and Agrarian Reform has since 1 October 2015:

(a) The Department drilled 120 boreholes as of 1st October 2015 up to date

(b) The exact sub meter GPS locations can be viewed in the table below.

(c) The average cost per meter for boreholes amounted to R550 per meter

and

(d) Of the 120 boreholes drilled 70 were successful. A success rate of 58.33%.

(e) DAFF did not refurbish any boreholes as this is the mandate of the Provinces.


Farm Name	DoA Number	Latitude	Longitude	Depth	Cost/m in R	Succes/ Unsuccesful
Dr Ruth Segmotsi Mompati
Morna	DoA 5073	-26.650079921	23.796603772	144	550	Dry
Neuham	DoA 5075	-26.680274337	23.873168729		550	Dry
Eska	DoA 5069	-26.653706954	23.825118906		550	Dry
Eska	DoA 5070	-26.658269451	23.826967198	210	550	Dry
Eska	DoA 5068	-26.657604287	23.826321731	204	550	Dry
Eska	DoA 5065	-26.658474593	23.840929778		550	Dry
Eska	DoA 5066	-26.658456770	23.841196252	234	550	Dry
Neuham	DoA 5102	-26.680421980	23.873204860	204	550	Dry
Ethol	DoA 5099	-26.808474606	23.837137083	156	550	Succesful
Pouval	DoA 5094	-26.831714061	23.839084155	150	550	Succesful
Pouval	DoA 5096	-26.829568787	23.848539999	180	550	Dry
Eureka	DoA 5063	-26.712948568	23.900974894	156	550	Dry
Vergenoeg	DoA 5086	-26.815468303	23.865724802		550	Dry
Vergenoeg	DoA 5090	-26.827669954	23.865023390		550	Succesful
Vergenoeg	DoA 5088	-26.792569022	23.876514232	156	550	Succesful
Vragas	DoA 5082	-26.828892918	23.933892324	192	550	Succesful
Pouval	DoA 5097	-26.831070961	23.849042165	150	550	Succesful
Vragas	DoA 5083	-26.829004532	23.934347927	156	550	Succesful
Itereleng	DoA 5080	-26.820922979	23.955469208		550	Dry
Vragas	DoA 5085	-26.848112540	23.921937375	150	550	Succesful
Bulrand	DoA 5111	-26.77390181	23.76560372	204	550	Dry
Vragas	DoA 5084	-26.848397305	23.921492775	162	550	Succesful
Bulrand	DoA 5113	-26.78775915	23.74059376	138	550	Succesful
Bulrand	DoA 5112	-26.77621059	23.76528867	90	550	Succesful
Eckron	DoA 5110	-26.81123583	23.75461683	198	550	Dry
Eckron	DoA 5109	-26.81597758	23.75843921	150	550	Dry
Esdale	DoA 5117	-26.77650574	23.69665331	150	550	Succesful
Rusten	DoA 5128	-26.81064048	23.77345716	85	550	Dry
Rusten	DoA 5129	-26.81107648	23.77349169	136	550	Succesful
Esdale	DoA 5116	-26.78475334	23.67516436	150	550	Succesful
Rusten	DoA 5106	-26.84617027	23.79236971		550	Dry
Rusten	DoA 5107	-26.84625568	23.79242892	90	550	Succesful
Bulrand	DoA 5114	-26.78765992	23.74012861	90	550	Succesful
Southey	DoA 5056	-26.804041686	23.994869627	78	550	Succesful
Itireleng	DoA 5143	-26.82077272	23.95555459	204	550	Succesful
Morna	DoA 5072	-26.651524251	23.804120100	204	550	Dry
Eureka	DoA 5060	-26.735488981	23.869412964	150	550	Succesful
Magabue	DoA 5133	-26.61780292	24.08917723	90	550	Succesful
Austrey	DoA 5152	-26.4627293	24.21066246	180	550	Succesful
Austrey	DoA 5153	-26.46247188	24.2115749	150	550	Dry
Ainsley	DoA 5119	-26.62521069	23.81533263	204	550	Succesful
Austrey	DoA 5144	-26.45091378	24.21182613	150	550	Succesful
Goodwood	DoA 5148	-26.43313475	24.27674439	90	550	Succesful
Goodwood	DoA 5150	-26.45614722	24.26238743	120	550	Dry
Ainsley	DoA 5121	-26.62267812	23.82093823	240	550	Succesful
Goodwood	DoA 5151	-26.45584175	24.26357312	60	550	Succesful
Conningham	DoA 5166	-26.55095302	23.62371483	252	550	Dry
Conningham	DoA 5163	-26.567222381	23.592646880	240	550	Dry
Weddel	DoA 5164	-26.552624342	23.622589299	210	550	Dry
Weddel	DoA 5165	-26.560766962	23.616546545	252	550	235
Neuham	DoA 5152	-26.668230000	23.884420000	114	550	Dry
Derdeplaas	DoA 5168	-26.543892826	23.629693807	252	550	Dry
Koeksebrake	DoA 5162	-26.517433743	23.597726773	240	550	Succesful
Derdeplaas	DoA 5167	-26.547494873	23.628114028	252	550	Dry
Ludick	DoA 5159	-26.547914352	23.565951512	246	550	Succesful
Vorster	DoA 5180	-26.527859864	23.543749841	228	550	Succesful
Koudslaap	DoA 5172	-26.405470000	23.599070000	312	550	Dry
Koudslaap	DoA 5171	-26.418883810	23.596502880	192	550	Succesful
marettlwa	DoA 5175	-26.519317923	23.803126777	252	550	Dry
Vierdeplaas	DoA 5169	-26.451251060	23.577725110	180	550	Succesful
Bardenhorst	DoA 5186	-26.387954797	23.654847457	252	550	507
Horstbarden	DoA 5173	-26.449082200	23.634378970	252	550	Succesful
Maretllwa	DoA 5176	-26.521721107	23.806226802	222	550	Succesful
Horstbarden	DoA 5174	-26.450246480	23.639113340	240	550	Succesful
Lucas	DoA 5177	-26.418862917	23.829789363	222	550	Dry
Pepane	DoA 5184	-26.302727947	23.781908369	252	550	Succesful
lucas	DoA 5178	-26.416875009	23.831787152	252	550	Succesful
Groblersvreugde	DoA 5188	-26.289152130	23.608805820	150	550	Succesful
Pepane	DoA 5185	-26.360336248	23.774762015	252	550	Succesful
Serurubele	DoA 5190	-26.536172430	23.001518680	252	550	Dry
Ditsobotla
Monamaladi	DoA 5043	-26.295045211	26.460779478	40	550	Succesful
Monamaladi	DoA 5044	-26.289680260	26.462716825	57	550	Succesful
Mafikeng
Lokaleng	DoA 5029	-25.809860698	25.558570584	60	550	Succesful
Miga	DoA 5031	-25.651711027	25.561691056	60	550	Succesful
Mmagotsholwang	DoA 5006	-25.756390678	25.051964380	150	550	Dry
Mmagotsholwang	DoA 5007	-25.756128397	25.051675960	150	550	Dry
Mmutla Mogolo - Lokgaleng Village	DoA 5026	-25.717673668	25.526186582	60	550	Succesful
Mogosane	DoA 5024	-25.748117056	25.556002152	42	550	Succesful
Six Hundred	DoA 5034	-25.705053337	25.599952106	72	550	Succesful
Tlapeng Village	DoA 5027	-25.718198066	25.474160861	48	550	Dry
Tlapeng Village	DoA 5053	-25.71845424	25.47407141	72	550	Succesful
Tshunyane	DoA 5022	-26.060761782	25.523186773	120	550	Succesful
Ratlou
Disaneng	DoA 4998	-25.785158624	25.270704388	78	550	Succesful
Garagetsalwe - Makgobistad	DoA 4989	-25.743691753	25.084662531	86	550	Dry
Garagetsalwe - Makgobistad	DoA 5051	-25.74381601	25.08467642	90	550	Succesful
Logagane Village	DoA 4994	-25.831681183	24.860653399	44	550	Dry
Logagane Village	DoA 4995	-25.823182164	24.861857917	98	550	Succesful
Logagane Village	DoA 5050	-25.83168263	24.86087121	120	550	Dry
Mabule Village	DoA 5008	-25.797258152	24.553098543	156	550	Dry
Phiring	DoA 5001	-25.778942901	25.166288529	84	550	Succesful
Sehatlhane Farm	DoA 5002	-25.810451914	25.109651404	120	550	Dry
Sehatlhane Farm	DoA 5003	-25.810110378	25.109757055	120	550	Dry
Sethatlhong Farm	DoA 5004	-25.819885330	25.106905831	90	550	Succesful
Logageng (Kingslope)	DoA 5019	-25.925482921	24.727657816	42	550	Succesful
Makgokgwane	DoA 5039	-25.732788786	25.604598165	48	550	Succesful
Ngaka Modiri Molema
Disaneng	DoA 4998	-25.785158624	25.270704388	78	550	Succesful
Garagetsalwe - Makgobistad	DoA 4989	-25.743691753	25.084662531	86	550	Dry
Garagetsalwe - Makgobistad	DoA 5051	-25.743816010	25.084676420	90	550	Succesful
Logagane Village	DoA 4994	-25.831681183	24.860653399	44	550	Dry
Logagane Village	DoA 4995	-25.823182164	24.861857917	98	550	Succesful
Logagane Village	DoA 5050	-25.831682630	24.860871210	120	150	Dry
Logageng (Kingslope)	DoA 5019	-25.925482921	24.727657816	121	550	Dry
Lokaleng	DoA 5029	-25.809860698	25.558570584	60	550	Succesful
Mabule Village	DoA 5008	-25.797258152	24.553098543	156	550	Dry
Makgokgwane	DoA 5039	-25.732788786	25.604598165	68	550	Succesful
Miga	DoA 5031	-25.651711027	25.561691056	60	550	Succesful
Mmagotsholwang	DoA 5006	-25.756390678	25.051964380	150	550	Dry
Mmagotsholwang	DoA 5007	-25.756128397	25.051675960	150	550	Dry
Mmutla Mogolo - Lokgaleng Village	DoA 5026	-25.717673668	25.526186582	60	550	Succesful
Mogosane	DoA 5024	-25.748117056	25.556002152	42	550	Succesful
Monamaladi	DoA 5043	-26.295045211	26.460779478	60	550	Succesful
Monamaladi	DoA 5044	-26.289680260	26.462716825	77	550	Succesful
Phiring	DoA 5001	-25.778942901	25.166288529	84	550	Succesful
Sehatlhane Farm	DoA 5002	-25.810451914	25.109651404	120	550	Dry
Sehatlhane Farm	DoA 5003	-25.810110378	25.109757055	120	550	Dry
Sethatlhong Farm	DoA 5004	-25.819885330	25.106905831	90	550	Succesful
Six Hundred	DoA 5034	-25.705053337	25.599952106	72	550	Succesful
Tlapeng Village	DoA 5027	-25.718198066	25.474160861	68	550	Dry
Tlapeng Village	DoA 5053	-25.718454240	25.474071410	72	550	Succesful
Tshunyane	DoA 5022	-26.060761782	25.523186773	120	550	Succesful

08 November 2016 - NW1977

Maynier, Mr D to ask the President of the Republic

Whether he has received any petitions concerning the Financial Intelligence Centre Amendment Bill [B33B-2015] sent to him for assent; if so, for each specified petition so received, (a) who furnished him with the specified petition, (b) when was the specified petition furnished and (c) what was the purpose of the petition?

Source
Link

Reply:

The Presidency continues with the processing of the Financial Intelligence Centre Amendment (FICA) Bill which has been passed by Parliament and referred to me for assent and signing into law.

Yes, I have received formal objections to the signing of the Bill from the Progressive Professionals Forum and the Black Business Council. When I am petitioned not to sign a bill, I have an obligation to consider the merits of such objection focusing mainly on whether the interested parties raise valid constitutional issues.

I have also received formal correspondence in support of the Bill from Honourable Floyd Shivambu, Economic Freedom Fighters Deputy President and Chief Whip and Mr Lawson Naidoo, Executive Secretary of CASAC, the Council for the Advancement of the South African Constitution.

08 November 2016 - NW2424

Macpherson, Mr DW to ask the Minister of Trade and Industry

(1)Whether any application was made for a Special Economic Zone in the Ugu District Municipality in KwaZulu-Natal; if so, what are the relevant details; if not, (2) Whether any (a) formal and/or (b) informal interactions have taken place between (i) the specified district municipality, (ii) the Ugu South Coast Development Agency and (iii) his department in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details in each case?

Source
Link

Reply:

1. The Department of Trade and Industry has not received any application for a Special Economic Zone from the Ugu District Municipality in KwaZulu-Natal,

2. There has not been any interaction, formal or informal, between the dti and the Ugu District Municipality or with Ugu South Coast Development Agency.

08 November 2016 - NW2285

Bergman, Mr D to ask the Minister of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries

Whether any (a) internal and/or (b) external forensic reports pertaining to (i) his department and/or (ii) each entity reporting to him were completed from 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what is the (aa) name, (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of each of the specified forensic reports?

Source
Link

Reply:

KPMG conducted a forensic investigation in 2010 into the following allegations:

Forensic investigations by KPMG Services (Pty) Ltd. at DAFF.

Investigations into the following focus areas were conducted by KPMG Services (Pty) Ltd.:

Female Farmer of the Year (Supply Chain Management process),
Media World,
Staff appointments,
Land Care,
Disaster Management,
Disease Management,
Debt Management,
Female Farmer of the Year (Awards Event),
Fruitless and Wasteful expenditure,
Venue hire,
CASP,
Durban Quarantine Station,
Knowledge Bank,
Ilima/Letsema,
Vehicle and Travel and Subsistence Claims, and
3P Consulting.

Each focus area has its own report and conclusion and documents can be made available on request.

08 November 2016 - NW2244

De Freitas, Mr MS to ask the Minister of Transport

(a) How many tenders were awarded by her department for scholar transport in the past three financial years to date, (b) to whom was each of the specified tenders awarded, (c) when was each tender awarded, (d) what were the time frames in each case, (e) what was the value of each tender, (f) what conditions were attached to each tender and (g) what mechanisms were put in place to ensure that the conditions of each tender were met by the successful tender recipients?

Source
Link

Reply:

The Department of Transport is not responsiblefor the procurement of scholar transport services. The responsibility to procure scholar transport services resides with provincial Departments of Transport and Education as contracting authorities.

No tenders were awarded by this department for scholar transport in the past three financial years

07 November 2016 - NW2299

Tarabella - Marchesi, Ms NI to ask the MINISTER OF INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS AND COOPERATION:

(1) Whether any (a) internal and/or (b) external forensic reports pertaining to (i) her department and/or (ii) each entity reporting to her were completed from 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what is the (aa) name, (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of each of the specified forensic reports?

Source
Link

Reply:

1. No. Neither (a) an internal nor (b) an external forensic investigation pertaining to either (i) the department and/or (ii) entity were conducted during the said period. As a result, there is no report to that effect.

UNQUOTE

07 November 2016 - NW2319

Robinson, Ms D to ask the Minister in the Presidency

Whether any (a) internal and/or (b) external forensic reports pertaining to (i) her department and/or (ii) each entity reporting to her were completed from 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what is the (aa) name, (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of each of the specified forensic reports?

Source
Link

Reply:

(b) External forensic report.

(i) Department of Women.

(aa) Forensic investigation into various allegations of misconduct within the department.

(bb) Forensic investigation into various allegations of misconduct and irregularities relating to:

the TIRISANO contract;
performance contract of the Director-General; and
procurement of Women’s Day goods and services.

(cc) 01 April 2016.

________________________

Approved by the Minister on

Date………………………..

07 November 2016 - NW2200

Chance, Mr R to ask the Minister of Small Business Development

(1)With reference to the contract signed between her department and a certain company (name furnished) for the provision of services to a group of agricultural co-operatives in KwaZulu-Natal, (a) how many of the specified co-operatives are receiving services from the specified company and (b) what amount has been allocated to (i) each of the co-operatives and (ii) the company from (aa) the Co-operatives Incentive Scheme and/or (bb) any of her department’s other budgets since 1 April 2015;

Source
Link

Reply:

The department does not have a contract with Kohwa Holdings but a memorandum of understanding (a) All 12 Cooperatives have received services from Kohwa Holdings at various levels and (b) Each Cooperative has received grant funding to the tune of (i) R 350 000 and (ii) the company received R35 000 per cooperative which is R35 000 X 12 = R 420 000-00 from (aa) the Cooperatives Incentive Scheme and/or (bb) No support from other budgets since 1 April 2015

(2) what is the (a) detailed breakdown of the costs of implementing the agricultural plans for each of the co-operatives and (b) company’s fees for providing services to the co-operatives;

Reply,

For each of the 12 Cooperatives the total amount of R350 000 per cooperative was spent as follows:

Wayhans Group which supplied Irrigation Scheme
Description and Deliverables	Qty	Excl	Total Amount
Main pump diesel pump/generator combo	1	96 150	96 150
PVC main line, elbow,t-fittings, PVC cement	1	30 700	30 700
Fertigation unit and 20 foot container with	1	42 167.2	42 167.2
Galvanised steel 50m3 resevoir tank	1	47 624	47 624
Drip network	1	44 341	44 341
Valves links	1	10 495	10 495
Transport	1	3760	3760
Installation and engineering supervision	1	-	-
	Sub Total	275 237.7	275 237.7


Wayhans Group which supplied fencing material
Description and Deliverables	Qty	Excl	Total Amount
110m x 110 x 1.8m high bonnax fencing roll	5	4 700	4 700
100mm gum poles & accessories included	159	9 620	9 620
Gumpoles stays 75/100/1.8m	18	990	990
Fence U-tack	9	1 170	1 170
Rolls of fence wire galvanised 2.5mm 130m	9	2 430	2 430
Bags cement & balast	62	3 952	3 952
Gate	1	3 500	3 500
Labour	1	10 500	10 500
Transport	1	2 900	2 900
	Sub Total	39 762	39 762


Kohwa Holdings
Sweet corn seed	1	1210		1210
Spinach seedling	1	515		515
Beetroot seedling	1	1246.7		1246.7
Cabbage seedling	1	650		650
Soil preparation	3	1500		1500
Fertilisers	3	1950		1950
Chemicals	3	3759		3759
Lime treatment	3	9 171		9 171
Project Management	1	14 998		14 998
	Sub Total	35 000		35 000


	Grand Total	350 000		350 000

(3) whether the company has provided her department with a full breakdown of (a) monies spent and (b) services delivered to each of the co-operatives during the specified period; if not, in each case, why not; if so, in each case, what are the relevant details?NW2522E

Reply

The department has undertaken a post disbursement inspection as per the standard procedure to follow up and verify if all approved items have been delivered to applicants and are in order and functional. During the follow up visits, it was established that most of the items approved and paid for by the department were not delivered to almost all the 12 cooperatives. The department is in the process of commissioning a full investigation into the 12 cooperatives to ascertain the reasons for the non-delivery of the items referred to above.

07 November 2016 - NW2230

Lorimer, Mr JR to ask the Minister of Mineral Resources

(1)(a) What were the detailed outcomes of the discussions on Mining Operation Phakisa held in 2015, (b) how long did the specified discussions take, (c) where were the specified discussions held, (d) who attended the specified discussions and (e) what did the specified discussions cost; (2) whether the specified outcomes were published in a report; if not, why not; if so, (a) on what date was the specified report published and (b) will he furnish Mr J R B Lorimer with a copy of the specified report? NW2560E

Source
Link

Reply:

1. The Mining Operation Phakisa is a programme of the President assigned to the Department of Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation (DPME) as a lead department with the Department of Mineral Resources providing substantive support. The DPME would be better placed to respond to these questions.

(a– (e) – Refer to (1)

2. Refer to (1)

Mr MJ Zwane, MP

Minister of Mineral Resources

Date Submitted:-………………/………………/2016

07 November 2016 - NW2214

Carter, Ms D to ask the Minister of Mineral Resources

Whether, in light of the approval that he granted for the transfer of funds from the Optimum Mine Rehabilitation Trust, he will provide details of (a) the request made to him, (b) the rationale which he applied in giving favourable consideration to the request, (c) details of the approval granted and (d) any conditions attached thereto; if not, why not?

Source
Link

Reply:

As the question relates to a matter which is now the subject of ongoing legal proceedings, the Minister is constrained from providing any details or information in this regard.

In view of the above, paragraphs (a) to (d) falls away.

Mr MJ Zwane, MP

Minister of Mineral Resources

Date Submitted:-………………/………………/2016

07 November 2016 - NW2199

Chance, Mr R to ask the Minister of Small Business Development

(1)Does a certain person (name furnished) have any shares in a certain company (name furnished), which is a service provider of the National Gazelles Programme; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what percentage shareholding does the specified person have in the specified service provider; (2) what amount did her department pay to the service provider for consulting fees in the (a) 2014-15 and (b) 2015-16 financial years?

Source
Link

Reply:

Yes the person (name furnished) has shares in the company mentioned and the company is the service provider of the Gazelles Programme. The person concerned has 40% shares in the company concerned which are in the process of being disposed.
There was no expenditure for 2014-15 financial year. For 2015-16 financial year the department incurred the costs to the tune of R22 085 000.00 towards the implementation of the programme, broken down into the following expenditure items:

07 November 2016 - NW2201

Chance, Mr R to ask the Minister of Small Business Development

(a) What is the line item breakdown of all goods and services above R500 000 that were procured without inviting competitive bids as required by Treasury Regulation 16A6.1, as identified on page 89 of her department’s 2015-16 annual report and (b) who were the suppliers in each case?

Source
Link

Reply:

The goods and services above R500 000 that were procured without inviting competitive bids for the Bavumile Skills Development Project are broken down as follows:

SUPPLIER NAME	Date of training	Service area	R(Total amount of contract/quotation)	R(Amount paid)
Aranda Learnership College	16/02 to 19/03/2015	Hammanskraal, Gauteng	293 742,66	44 061,00
	16/02 to 19/03/2015	Mamelodi, Gauteng	277 782,66	41 667,00
	16/02 to 19/03/2015	Mamelodi, Gauteng		138 992,66
	16/02 to 19/03/2015	Kimberly, Northern Cape	360 008,58	180 004,58
Total			931 533,90	404 725,24
Kaoz Afric Design	15/02 to 11/03/2016	Lephanane, Limpopo	339 000,00	339 000,00
	15/02 to 11/03/2016	Nelspruit, Mpumalanga	349 000,00	349 000,00
Total			688 000,00	688 000,00
Injiya Trading and Projects	29/02 to 26/03/2016	Khayelitsha, Western Cape	376 000,00	376 000,00
	20/07 to 14/08/2015	Harrismith, Free State	364 725,00	364 725,00
Total			740 725,00	740 725,00
Grand total			2 360 258.90	1 833 450 .24

07 November 2016 - NW2302

Mokgalapa, Mr S to ask the Minister of Mineral Resources

Whether any (a) internal and/or (b) external forensic reports pertaining to (i) his department and/or (ii) each entity reporting to him were completed from 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what is the (aa) name, (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of each of the specified forensic reports?

Source
Link

Reply:

	Department of Mineral Resources	aa)	bb)	cc)
	1	Mining permit application	Objection of mining permit application	11/10/2016
i)Dept	2	Prospecting right application	Unfair administrative procedures in processing mining right application	11/10/2016
	3	Corruption on the issuing of mining permit	Investigation into allegations of corruption on the issuing of mining permit	23/02/2016
	4	Stationery procurement	Irregular expenditure relating to procurement of stationery	15/12/2015
	5	Mining permit	Incorrectly allocated mining permit	13/10/2015
	6	Mining permit application	Irregular proof of submission of documents	13/10/2015
	7	Mining permit application	Alleged conflict of interest	13/10/2015
	8	Fraud and corruption	Fraudulent blasting certificates.	28/07/2015
	9	Mine Managers Certificate of Competency (MMCC)	Allegations of irregularities in the issuing of MMCC. Allegations pertaining to Principal inspector.	07/11/2014
	10	Corruption	Allegations of irregular appointment	10/06/2014
	11	Corruption	Abuse of GG vehicles	12/05/2014
	12	Theft	Theft and loss of cash	12/03/2014
	13	Irregular award of ICT Infrastructure	Allegations of irregular award of ICT Infrastructure	20/01/2012
		aa)	bb)	cc)
ii)Entities	Council for Geoscience	Fraud	Recruitment process (mispresentation of qualifications)	30/10/2014
		Contravention of Supply Chain Management regulations	Procurement irregularities	28/02/2014
		Contravention of Supply Chain Management Practice Note	Collusion of suppliers	18/05/2016
	South African Diamond and Precious Metal Regulator	Report on the contravention of ICT policy	Misconduct	31/12/2011
		Corruption/fraud investigation	Alleged misconduct	24/03/2014
		Disclosure of confidential information	Misconduct	28/05/2015
	Mine Health and Safety Council	N/A	N/A	N/A
	MINTEK	N/A	N/A	N/A
	South African Diamond Trader	N/A	N/A	N/A

Mr MJ Zwane, MP

Minister of Mineral Resources

Date Submitted:-………………/………………/2016

04 November 2016 - NW2262

Rabotapi, Mr MW to ask the Minister of Communications

With reference to her reply to question 2002 on 6 October 2016, did her department pledge an amount of R3 million to support the Thank You SABC music concert held at the Orlando Stadium on 10 September 2016; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details?

Source
Link

Reply:

The Department of Communications did not pledge any amount to support the Thank You SABC music concert held at the Orlando Stadium on 10 September 2016.

MR NN MUNZHELELE

DIRECTOR GENERAL [ACTING]

DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATIONS

DATE:

MS AF MUTHAMBI (MP)

MINISTER OF COMMUNICATIONS

DATE

04 November 2016 - NW2282

Van Dyk, Ms V to ask the Minister of Communications

(1)(a) On what date was Mr Hlaudi Motsoeneng reappointed as the Group Executive of Corporate Affairs of the SA Broadcasting Corporation, (b) who held the specified position before the reappointment of the specified person, (c) to which position was the former group executive of corporate affairs moved and (d) what are the full details of all processes followed to make both of the specified appointments; (2) Whether the position of group executive of corporate affairs was advertised prior to the person’s reappointment; if not, why not; if so, will she furnish Ms V van Dyk with a copy of all advertisements in this regard? NW2614E

Source
Link

Reply:

The questions relate to questions that are part of the terms of reference into the parliamentary hearing in terms of section 15A (b) and therefore dealing with the question now will be tantamount to anticipating the said inquiry which is led by Parliament.

MR NN MUNZHELELE

DIRECTOR GENERAL [ACTING]

DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATIONS

DATE:

MS AF MUTHAMBI (MP)

MINISTER OF COMMUNICATIONS

DATE

04 November 2016 - NW2281

Van Damme, Ms PT to ask the Minister of Communications

Whether the (a) Chief Financial Officer, (b) Chief Operations Officer and (c) Chief Executive Officer of the SA Broadcasting Corporation received performance bonuses in the (i) 2013-14, (ii) 2014-15 and (iii) 2015-16 financial years; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what amount did each of the specified officers receive in each of the specified financial years?

Source
Link

Reply:

The information regarding the performance bonuses can be referred to the Annual Reports for the respective years.

Note that the SABC has not yet implemented the performance management review therefore would not be in a position to pay performance bonuses.

MR NN MUNZHELELE

DIRECTOR GENERAL [ACTING]

DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATIONS

DATE:

MS AF MUTHAMBI (MP)

MINISTER OF COMMUNICATIONS

DATE

04 November 2016 - NW2288

Cassim, Mr Y to ask the Minister of Communications

Whether any (a) internal and/or (b) external forensic reports pertaining to (i) her department and/or (ii) each entity reporting to her were completed from 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what is the (aa) name, (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of each of the specified forensic reports?

Source
Link

Reply:

(i) Department of Communications (DoC)

(a) N/A

(b) External forensic audit initiated in the 2015/16 financial year.

(bb) The DoC commissioned an investigation through the National Treasury on the procurement processes of set top boxes.

(cc) The investigation has been concluded in March 2016.

Government Communications and Information System

(a) Internal audit investigation into subsistence and travel claims for one of its employees, June 2011.

(b) National Treasury (external to GCIS), forensic investigation into the appointment of a service providers for the census 2011 campaign, November 2012.

(ii) Entities

Brand South Africa (BSA)

(a) N/A

(b) External forensic audit in the 2014/15 financial year.

(aa) N/A

(bb) To investigate whether any fraudulent activities took place on the reported irregular expenditure of R10 738 735.

(cc) 11 November 2014.

Film and Publication Board (FPB)

(a) N/A

(b) N/A

(aa) N/A

(bb) N/A

(cc) N/A

Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (ICASA)

(a) N/A

(b) An external forensic investigator was appointed.

(aa) N/A

(bb) To investigate the bid administration functions and processes followed at ICASA in the 2011/12 and 2012/13 financial years.

(cc) The report was successfully concluded and adopted by Council of the Authority on 31 March 2015.

Media Development and Diversity Agency (MDDA)

(a) No

(b) Yes

(aa) N/A

(bb) Corruption and Maladministration

(cc) 2013

South African Broadcasting Corporation (SABC)

The SABC is unfortunately not at liberty to disclose such information as it either refers to personal information of the SABC employees and or commercial transactions of third parties.

MR NN MUNZHELELE

[A] DIRECTOR GENERAL

DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATIONS

DATE:

MS AF MUTHAMBI (MP)

MINISTER OF COMMUNICATIONS

DATE

04 November 2016 - NW2250

Shinn, Ms MR to ask the Minister of Communications

Whether any criminal charges have been laid against any (a) employee and/or (b) former employee of the Universal Service Access Agency of South Africa for (i) supply chain management irregularities and/or (ii) any other irregularity in the procurement process of government subsidised set-top boxes; if not, why not; if so, what are the (aa) names of each person charged to date and (bb) charges in each case?

Source
Link

Reply:

The Department of Communications commissioned an investigation conducted by the National Treasury on the procurement process of Set Top Boxes (STBs) and other associated accessories. No criminal charges have been laid against any employee and/or former employee of the Universal Service Access Agency of South Africa as the report is being processed. The department is, however, working with the Department of Telecommunications and Postal Services (DTPS), as USAASA reports to Parliament via the DTPS, in considering actions to be taken based on the recommendations entailed in the report. .

MR NN MUNZHELELE

DIRECTOR GENERAL [ACTING]

DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATIONS

DATE:

MS AF MUTHAMBI (MP)

MINISTER OF COMMUNICATIONS

DATE:

04 November 2016 - NW2226

Kohler-Barnard, Ms D to ask the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services

(a) How many Special Investigating Unit investigations are currently being conducted into the Department of Public Works in each province, (b) what is the reason for each of the specified investigations and (c) by what date is each of the specified investigations expected to be finalised?

Source
Link

Reply:

The Special Investigating Unit (SIU) is currently conducting investigations authorised under four (4) proclamations involving the Department of Public Works (DPW). Details of the investigations are provided in the table below:

PROCLAMATION	PROVINCE	REASONS FOR THE INVESTIGATIONS	EXPECTED DATE TO BE FINALISED
Proclamation No. R.54, 2014. There are seventeen (17) matters listed as well as an additional thirteen (13) matters listed in the amendment to the abovementioned Proclamation, amended to Proclamation No. R44 of 2015.	Western Cape	The Investigation relates to the refurbishment of ministerial homes in and around Cape Town at allegedly vastly inflated costs. The Proclamation concerned confines the investigation to: (i) the procurement of goods and services; and (ii) unauthorized, irregular and/or fruitless and wasteful expenditure incurred in relation to the DPW projects listed in the two (2) Proclamations.	31 March 2017
2. Proclamation No. R59 of 2014 dated 27 August 2014	National Department of Public Works	1. Procurement and Administration of leases which is not fair, competitive, transparent, equitable or cost effective; 2. Irregularities, malpractices or mal-administration in the affairs of DPW; 3. Any related unauthorized, irregular or fruitless and wasteful expenditure; 4. Theft, fraud and/or corruption by private individuals/landlords; and 5. Procurement irregularities relating to service providers. Currently, 649 leases are under investigation out of a total of 2 176 leases. The provincial breakdown is as follows: (i) Eastern Cape – 142; (ii) Western Cape – 48; (iii) Mpumalanga – 105; (iv) Free State – 100; (v) Kwa-Zulu Natal – 54; (vi) Gauteng – 136; (vii) North-West – 37; and (viii) Mthatha – 27.	March 2018
3.Proclamation No. R38 of 2010	Gauteng	(i) Allegations of irregular Supply Chain Management award in terms of Section 217 of the Constitution as well as fruitless and wasteful expenditure; and (ii) A lease investigation where we are in negotiations with the current landlord and DPW on overpayments to the landlord both in Gauteng.	Based on these matters (civil proceedings), SIU cannot anticipate the end date.
4. Proclamation No. R27 of 2015	Kwa-Zulu Natal	(i) Allegations of irregular appointment of service provider - 4 matters; (ii) Allegations of fruitless and wasteful expenditure - 1 matter; (iii) Allegations of fraud and corruption - 3 matters; and (iv) Allegations of conflict of interest - 420 matters.	September 2017
	Western Cape	(i) Allegations of fraud and corruption - 2 matters; and (ii) Allegations of conflict of interest - 230 matters.
	Eastern Cape	Allegations of conflict of interest - 344 matters
	Pretoria Office	(i) Allegations of "cover quoting" - 7 matters; (ii) Allegations of irregularities in the Security Project - 1 matter; (iii) Allegations of irregular expenditures during the 2014/15 regularity audit - 1 matter; (iv) Allegations of fraud and corruption - 2 matters; and (v) Allegations of conflict of interest – 2 705 matters.
	Bloemfontein Office	(i) Allegations of poor service and non-delivery by service providers - 23 matters; (ii) Fraud and corruption - 1 matter; (iii) Allegations of conflict of interest - 677 matters; and (iv) Assisting the Hawks on 6 matters.

04 November 2016 - NW2279

Van Damme, Ms PT to ask the Minister of Communications

Whether she has met with the (a) board of the SA Broadcasting Corporation (SABC) and/or (b) senior executives of the SABC to discuss the (i) redeployment of the former chief operating officer of the SABC, Mr H Motsoeneng, to the position of Group Executive of Corporate Affairs and (ii) current affairs of the SABC; if not, why not; if so, what was the (aa) date and (bb) contents of the specified meetings?

Source
Link

Reply:

No, the Minister has not met with the Board of the SABC to discuss the redeployment of Mr Motsoeneng.

MR NN MUNZHELELE

DIRECTOR GENERAL [ACTING]

DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATIONS

DATE:

MS AF MUTHAMBI (MP)

MINISTER OF COMMUNICATIONS

DATE

04 November 2016 - NW2251

Shinn, Ms MR to ask the Minister of Communications

Has her department concluded drawing up a comprehensive budget for submission to the National Treasury of all the anticipated costs to be incurred by (a) her department and (b) (i) government entities and (ii) their suppliers for the completion of the digital migration process until analogue switch-off; if not, what is the reason for the delay in the completion of the specified budget; if so, (aa) on what date was it submitted to the National Treasury and (bb) what are the further relevant details?

Source
Link

Reply:

(a) The department has together with entities, namely, Universal Service Access Agency of South Africa (USAASA) and South African Post Office (SAPO) accompanied by the Department of Telecommunications and Postal Services (DTPS) in August and September 2016 approached National Treasury to discuss the funding issues of the project. Funding is required for the Programme Management Office (PMO), Public and Consumer Awareness, Contact Centre, Dual Illumination, Set-top-boxes and related accessories such as antennae and satellite dishes as well as for installations. The department is in the process of facilitating the compilation of funding requirements with entities to submit to National Treasury in November 2016.

(b) (ii) Suppliers are not involved in the submission of funding requirements to National Treasury.

MR NN MUNZHELELE

DIRECTOR GENERAL [ACTING]

DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATIONS

DATE:

MS AF MUTHAMBI (MP)

MINISTER OF COMMUNICATIONS

DATE

04 November 2016 - NW2253

Hunsinger, Dr CH to ask the Minister of Communications

a) How many government-sponsored set-top boxes have been installed since her reply to question 685 on 24 May 2016 to date, and (b) what is the detailed breakdown of the (i) municipal areas and (ii) provinces where the specified set-top boxes were installed; (2) Whether all of the specified set-top boxes that were installed are Direct to the Home set-top boxes; if not, what is the total number of the specified set-top boxes that are Digital Terrestrial Television set-top boxes; if so, what are the relevant details?

Source
Link

Reply:

(1)

(a) A total of 22,387 STBs have been issued, installed and service activated as at 31 October 2016

(b) (i) (ii) Attached is a spreadsheet showing the municipal areas and provinces.

(2) A total of Direct To Home (DTH) STBs installed as at 31 October 2016 is 14,143 and Digital Terrestrial Television (DTT) are 8,244. Refer to attached spreadsheet for details.

MR NN MUNZHELELE

DIRECTOR GENERAL [ACTING]

DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATIONS

DATE:

MS AF MUTHAMBI (MP)

MINISTER OF COMMUNICATIONS

DATE

04 November 2016 - NW2252

Shinn, Ms MR to ask the Minister of Communications

Whether, with reference to her reply to question 126 on 27 February 2016, any plans have been put in place to issue a regulation to amend the Broadcasting Act, Act 4 of 1999, as amended, to waive the requirement for recipients of government set-top boxes to be in possession of valid television licences; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details of the specified plans?

Source
Link

Reply:

I would like to draw your attention, honourable Shinn, to my Budget Vote speech where I mentioned that “together with the SABC management we have since resolved to delink the TV license requirement from the STB subsidy registration process”. No mention was made of a decision to waive the law.

MR NN MUNZHELELE

DIRECTOR GENERAL [ACTING]

DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATIONS

DATE:

MS AF MUTHAMBI (MP)

MINISTER OF COMMUNICATIONS

DATE:

04 November 2016 - NW2292

Vos, Mr J to ask the Minister of Energy

Whether any (a) internal and/or (b) external forensic reports pertaining to (i) her department and/or (ii) each entity reporting to her were completed from 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what is the (aa) name, (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of each of the specified forensic reports?

Source
Link

Reply:

(a)(b)(i)(ii) Since 1 January 2009 to date the Department and all its entities with the exception of CEF reported no forensic investigation conducted for both internally and externally.

(ii) CEF, Yes

(aa) Name	(bb) Subject Matter	(cc) Date of Conclusion
PetroSA	i. Forensic Accounting Investigation into alleged irregular activities or misconduct by certain top ranking officials which include allegations about irregular tender practices at PetroSA.	4 March 2010
	ii. Forensics Investigation into possible irregularities and/or fraud within the Corporate Social Investment (“CSI”) department.	18 October 2010
	iii. Probity final report PetroSA.	April 2013
	iv. Review of a possible fruitless and wasteful and/or irregular expenditure	October 2013
	v. Scope extension: Review of a possible fruitless and wasteful and/or irregular expenditure.	June 2013
	vi. Investigation into allegations of irregularities regarding the acquisition by PetroSA of the shares of Sabre Oil and Gas.	November 2013
	vii. Forensic Investigation into the circumstances behind the decision to continue drilling the FO-12 pilot well in the Ikhwezi field development plan.	September 2015
	viii. Independent investigation into the performance of PetroSA for the financial year ended 31 March 2015; and more specifically PetroSA’s R14.5 billion impairment charge.	November 2015
Petroleum Agency of South Africa (PASA)	ix. Forensic Investigation into allegations arising from a whistle blower report	11 November 2010

03 November 2016 - NW2315

Kopane, Ms SP to ask the Minister of Tourism

Whether any (a) internal and/or (b) external forensic reports pertaining to (i) his department and/or (ii) each entity reporting to him were completed from 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what is the (aa) name, (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of each of the specified forensic reports?

Source
Link

Reply:

(i) Department of Tourism

(a) None

(b) External forensic reports as indicated below:

(aa) Investigated Project Name	(bb)Subject Matter	(cc) Date of Conclusion
Tshakuma Heritage and Conference Centre	Forensic and Financial Investigation	19 July 2011; further bank account analysis report issued on 2 September 2013
Wild Coast Tourism Development	Forensic and Financial Investigation	25 July 2011
KZN King Matiwane	Forensic and Financial Investigation	19 July 2011
Free State and Northern Cape training	Forensic and Financial Investigation	7 July 2011
FS- Guest House Building in Qwaqwa	Forensic and Financial Investigation	28 November 2014
FS- Information and Business Centre Project	Forensic and Financial Investigation	28 November 2014
EC-Lake Gariep Development Project	Forensic and Financial Investigation	9 October 2014
EC-Lake Gariep and PK Le Roux dam	Forensic and Financial Investigation	9 October 2014
EC- Rock Art Tourism	Forensic and Financial Investigation	9 October 2014
EC- Motherwell Eco Tourism Development Project	Forensic and Financial Investigation	9 October 2014
LP-Mnisi Resort project	Forensic and Financial Investigation	9 October 2014
Vha Tsonga Cultural Village Project	Forensic and Financial Investigation	9 October 2014

(ii) South Africa Tourism

(a) None

(b) External forensic report as indicated below:

(aa) Name	(bb) Subject Matter	(cc)Date of Conclusion
Fraud India Office Case	Fraud case against Country Manager and Finance Manager in India Office	25 May 2011
Local and International South African Tourism Warehouses Case	Exhibition Stands and Warehouses	24 May 2012
Fraud and Corruption Case	Irregularities in awarding the Lead Agency Tender in 2010	14 January 2015
Fraud and Corruption Case	Possible collusion between suppliers in Nigeria	6 July 2016

03 November 2016 - NW2377

Mulder, Dr CP to ask the Minister of Trade and Industry

Whether, given the sluggish South African economy and low projected growth, he will consider collecting evidence-based data around economic models that work and that do not work, from some special economic zones, in collaboration with the Minisiter of Labour, attempting to relax labour regulations and in that limited geographic space to determine whether it does not result in more job opportunities; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

Source
Link

Reply:

Since the introduction of the new Special Economic Zones Policy and the introduction of a new package of incentives for SEZ investments; the overall investment performance of South Africa’s special economic zones has improved significantly. For example, total secured investments in the 4 operational IDZs increased from R19, 7 billion at the beginning of the 2016 to R41, 2 billion at the end of October 2016. In addition, the total investment commitments from the not yet operational zones (including the newly designated) stands at over R70 billion. The dti is confident that this improved investment performance of South Africa’s special economic zones will soon translate into a stronger contribution to GDP, value-added exports and employment.

In implementing the SEZ Programme, the dti is aware that continuous learning and innovation have to be, and are; central to our efforts to improve the performance of all special economic zones. Therefore, there are lessons from both the domestic and international experiences in the planning, design, development, management and operations of special economic zones. When the time is right, department will review both the SEZ Policy and its instruments; taking into account all the lessons from both the domestic and international experiences.

However, the dti does not have any intention to introduce a different labour market policy in special economic zones. There are no indications that the current labour market policy has negative impact on the performance of our special economic zones.

02 November 2016 - NW2304

Mhlongo, Mr TW to ask the Minister in the Presidency

Whether any (a) internal and/or (b) external forensic reports pertaining to (i) his department and/or (ii) each entity reporting to him were completed from 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what is the (aa) name, (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of each of the specified forensic reports?

Source
Link

Reply:

The Department of Planning Monitoring and Evaluation did not have (a) internal or (b) external forensic investigations from the period 1 January 2009 to date. There were no cases that required forensic investigations and therefore there is no (aa) name (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of forensic reports.

SekelaXabiso Consulting (Pty) Ltd was appointed by National Treasury on 12 September 2013 to do Forensic Investigation into the tender process and subsequent appointment of the successful bidder pertaining to tender number 12/09 for Statistics South Africa (Stats SA). The response in regard to NYDA is as follows:

Forensic Report - Nature	Internal / External	(aa) Name of the Investigation	(bb) Subject Matter	(cc) Date of Conclusion of the Forensic Report
During the 2011 financial year, an investigation was initiated by the Public Protector to probe whether the hosting of the World Festival of Youth and Students held in December 2010 had been within the NYDA’s mandate, whether the allocated funds had not been misappropriated and whether the relevant supply chain management prescripts had been followed.	External	World Festival of Youth and Students	Hosting of the World Festival of Youth and Students event had been within the NYDA’s mandate, whether the allocated funds had not been misappropriated and whether the relevant supply chain management prescripts had been followed.	To date, a final report had not been released by the Public Protector.
Account Payable Manager Fraud	Internal	Account Payable Fraud	Diverting funds to her accounts – fraud detection and funds recovery done.	30 September 2016 Case closed
Economic Development DJ project	Internal	DJ project	Supply of young DJ’s with DJ equipment, working capital and related branding	31 December 2013 Case closed
Qualification review	Internal	Qualification Audit	Review of qualification listed on employees CVs	31 December 2015 Case closed
Fraudulent activity in the Group Lending Programme at the East London Branch Office. The report named two specific group loans (Masiqandane and Khanya Group Loans).	Internal	Group Loan	Fraudulent loan	05 November 2013 Case closed

02 November 2016 - NW2172

Maimane, Mr MA to ask the Minister in the Presidency

What was the total financial cost to the State for all litigation involving the non-security upgrades at the President, Mr Jacob G Zuma’s, private homestead in Nkandla in KwaZulu-Natal?

Source
Link

Reply:

The total financial cost to the State for all litigation involving the non-security upgrades at the President, Mr Jacob G Zuma’s, private homestead in Nkandla in KwaZulu-Natal is R3 915 625.03

01 November 2016 - NW2159

De Freitas, Mr MS to ask the Minister of Transport

What (a) were the gross annual salaries of each chief executive officer (CEO) of each entity reporting to her, (b) (i) benefits of any description and (ii) monetary value in each case that the specified CEOs enjoyed and (c) increases in (i) gross annual salary and (ii) benefits awarded in the past three financial years?

Source
Link

Reply:

PORTS REGULATOR OF SOUTH AFRICA (PRSA)

Chief Executive Officer	Earnings	2013/14 (000)	2014/15 (000)	2015/16 (000)
Mahesh Fakir (appointed 01 May 2014)	Basic salary	-	1568	1591
	Taxable allowance	-	565	668
	Performance bonus	-	-	334
	Total		2133	2593
Marissa Damons (Acting CEO effective August 2013 to 30 April 2014)	Basic salary	524	691	-
	Taxable allowance	204	250	-
	Performance bonus		253	-
	Medical aid allowance*	28	38	-
	Acting allowance	255	33	-
	Total	1 011	1265	-
Riad Khan (CEO contract expired on 15 July 2013)	Basic salary	594	-	-
	Leave pay	362	-	-
	Total	956	-	-

(a) The table above details the gross remuneration that was paid to each CEO for the past three financial years. Note that Mr Khan and Ms Damons were only employed for part of the year in 2013/14 and 2014/15 respectively.

(b) (i) In terms of the conditions of service of the Ports Regulator, senior employees do not get any benefits except for the UIF, (ii) which is included in gross income and not paid over and above the amounts in the table.

(c) (i) The salary increases that were received by the CEO’s were in line with the PSCBC resolutions for sms employees. (ii) there were no increases in benefits awarded as there were no benefits awarded.

*The medical aid allowance for Marissa Damons was not a benefit but rather part of her gross remuneration based on how she structured her package.

RAILWAY SAFETY REGULATOR (RSR)

Year	Basic Salary (R)	Performance bonus (R)	Allowances (R)	Other: Pension & Medical Aid (R)	Total (R)
2013/14	1 688 133	-	16 945	45 701	1 750 779
2014/15	2 126 729	112 800	36 675	66 409	2 342 613
2015/16	3 227 874	313 594	36 646	72 659	3 650 773
Total	7 042 736	426 394	90 266	184 768	7 744 164

ROAD ACCIDENT FUND (RAF)

In the past three financial years,	the gross annual salary of the chief executive officer (CEO) of the Road Accident Fund was,	(b) (i) which included the following benefits enjoyed by the CEO,	and (ii) with the following monetary value in each case,	and was awarded the following increases in(c)(i) gross annual salary,	and (c)(ii), benefits
2013-2014	R4 170 044.00	Medical Aid Momentum Funeral Scheme Cellphone Allowance Performance Bonus awarded after annual audits and a review of performance against an approved scorecard	R75 840.00 R0 R60 000 per financial year R1 849 414.51	Mid increase 8.76% Annual increase 6%	Medical Aid: 9%
2014-2015	R4 703 247.00	Medical Aid Momentum Funeral Scheme Cellphone Allowance Performance Bonus awarded after annual audits and a review of performance against an approved scorecard	R82 818.00 R0 R60 000 per financial year R1 900 706.07	6.4%	Medical Aid: 9% Performance Bonus: 2.77%
2015-2016	R4 985 331.00	Medical Aid Momentum Funeral Scheme Cellphone Allowance Performance Bonus awarded after annual audits and a review of performance against an approved scorecard	R90 831.00 R0 R60 000 per financial year R1 918 882.13	6%	Medical Aid: 9% Performance Bonus: 0.95%

AIRPORTS COMPANY SOUTH AFRICA (ACSA)

What:

(a) were the gross annual salaries of your chief executive officer (CEO) of each entity reporting to her,

Answer: The annual gross salary for Airports Company South Africa CEO is R3,929,502

(b) (i) benefits of any description; and

Answer: The CEO qualified for medical aid and pension fund benefits. These benefits are included in the above mentioned gross annual salary of R 3,929,520

(ii) monetary value in each case that the specified CEOs enjoyed and

Answer: There is no additional monetary value that the CEO received

(c) increases in

(i) gross annual salary and

2014: Answer: The CEO received a 5.4% (new salary R3,478,212) salary increase as approved by the Board of ACSA and the decision was implemented with effect from the 1st of September 2014.

2015: Answer: The CEO received a 6,58% (new salary R 3,707,078) salary increase as approved by the Board of ACSA and the decision was implemented with effect from the 1st of September 2015.

2016: Answer: The CEO received a 6% (new salary R3,929,502) salary increase as approved by the Board of ACSA and the decision was implemented with effect from the 1st of September 2016.

(ii) benefits awarded in the past three financial years?

2014: Answer: No additional benefits were awarded other than the above mentioned benefits, i.e medical aid and pension fund.

A variable performance bonus amounting to R1,570,573 was paid to the CEO in 2014.

2015: Answer: No additional benefits were awarded other than the above mentioned benefits, i.e medical aid and pension fund.

A variable performance bonus amounting to R1,826,061 was paid to the CEO in 2015. Further in lieu of closed Long Term Incentive Scheme (LTIS), the Board approved the deferred accumulated LTI amounting to R1,723,534 to be paid to the CEO in 2015.

2016: Answer: No additional benefits were awarded other than the above mentioned benefits, i.e medical aid and pension fund. No performance bonus was paid to the CEO in 2016.

AIR TRAFFIC AND NAVIGATION SERVICES (ATNS)

What:

(a) were the gross annual salaries of your chief executive officer (CEO) of each entity reporting to her,

- 2013/14 - R3,000,000-00

- 2014/15 - R3,201,000-00

- 2015/16 - R3,457,080-00

- 2016/17 - R3,699,076-00

(b) (i) Benefits of any description; and

- Pension Fund; Medical Aid; 25 working days annual leave; R2500-00 cellphone allowance and Business Class Travel

- Performance Bonus

(ii) Monetary value in each case that the specified CEOs enjoyed.

2015/16 Statutory Benefits R452,358.1
Performance Bonus R841,695-00

(c) Increases in

(i) Gross annual salary; and

2014/15 - 6,7%

2015/16 - 8%

2016/17 - 7%

(ii) Benefits awarded in the past three financial years?

Pension Fund; Medical Aid; Performance Bonus; 25 working days annual leave; R2500-00 cellphone allowance and Business-Class Travel

ROAD TRAFFIC MANAGEMENT CORPORATION (RTMC)

Period	Basic Salary	Non Pensionable Allowance	Package	Increase Percentage	Performance Bonus	Total
2016/2017	2700 000.00	1800 000.00	4 500 000.00	0%		4 500 000.00
2015/2016	2700 000.00	1800 000.00	4 500 000.00	55%	1 450 000.00	5 950 000.00
2014/2015	1 740 000.00	1 160 000.00	2 900 000.00	0%	208 634.00	3 108 634.00
2013/2014	435 000.00	233 450.00	2 900 000.00		-	668 450.00
Response	(b) (ii)	(b) (i), (b) (ii)	(a) @(i)	@	(b) (ii)

Narrative :

2013/2014

Pro rata payment for the fourth quarter (Date of assumption of duties 1st of January 2014.)

2014/2015

Package was subject to performance and re-determination pending Negotiations.

2015/2016

Included the re-determination of the salary negotiations and performance as per employment contract.

2016/2017

Awaiting performance assessment and salary increment/negotiations.

SOUTH AFRICAN CIVIL AVIATION AUTHORITY (SACAA)

1. Gross Annual salaries

The Gross annual salaries paid to the Director of Civil Aviation A for the past 3 financial years were as follows

2013/14 Financial Year: R2,500,000.00

2014/15 Financial Year: R2,500,000.00

2015/16 Financial Year: R2,677,500.00

The above salaries includes basic salary, provident fund and medical aid.

2. Salary Increase

The DCA was appointed on 1 December 2013 and there was no increase paid for the financial year ending 2014/2015. The DCA received her first increase of 7% in 2015/2016 Financial year.

3. Performance Bonus

The performance bonus was paid as follows

2013/14 Financial Year : R290,969.00

2014/15 Financial Year : R585,109.60

2015/16 Financial Year : R840,779.99

SOUTH AFRICAN NATIONAL ROADS AGENCY SOC LIMITED (SANRAL)

SANRAL CEO: Mr Nazir Alli – Annual Remuneration

(a) and (b): SANRAL operates on a cost to company (CTC) basis. The gross amount paid includes the company’s contribution to medical aid and provident fund. The table below gives a breakdown as reported in the Annual Reports for the respective financial years:

REMUNERATION	Gross Salary	Performance Payments & long service awards	Other contributions (Travel and medical allowances)	Pension contributions	Total R ‘000
FY 2013/14	2 016	1 067	121	405	3 609
FY 2014/15	2 214	1 270	103	445	4 032
FY 2015/16	2 502	1 280	46	185	4 013

(c) The CEO’s salary has not been adjusted for the financial years 2015/2016 and 2016/2017

ROAD TRAFFIC INFRINGEMENT AGENCY (RTIA)

(a)

2013/2014 Gross Annual salaries –R894 045
2014/2015 Gross Annual salaries –R939 248
2015/2016 Gross Annual salaries –R1 010 121

(b)

(i) Benefits –Non pensionable allowance, Car Allowance, Housing Allowance, Pension Fund, Medical Aid, Bonus.

(ii)

2013/2014 Total Benefits R742 923
2014/2015 Total Benefits R780 758
2015/2016 Total Benefits R2 370 076

(c) (i)

2013/2014 Increase in gross annual salary R26 994
2013/2014 Increase in gross annual salary R45 203
2013/2014 Increase in gross annual salary R70 873

(ii)

2013/2014 Total increase benefits R49 519
2014/2015 Total increase benefits R37 835
2015/2016 Total increase benefits R1 589 318

SOUTH AFRICAN MARITIME SAFETY AUTHORITY (SAMSA)

(a) The annual salaries of the SAMSA CEO were as follows:

2013/14 R2 858 000

2014/15 R3 040 912

2015/16 R3 199 544

(b) i.The benefits for the SAMSA CEO were as follows:

Benefits

13th cheque

Provident Fund

Travel Allowance

Bonus

b.ii Monetary value in each case that the specified CEOs enjoyed

Benefit	2013/14	2014/15	2015/16
13th cheque	218 000	238 000	267 000
Provident Fund	417 000	446 000	493 000
Travel Allowance	0	0	22 000
Bonus	1 089 000	0	0

NB: The bonus amount paid in the 2013/14 financial year was for two financial years (2011/12 and 2012/13)

(c) i.The following increases were awarded to the SAMSA CEO over the period:

Year	Percentage Increase
2014/15	6.4%
2015/16	5.2%

ii. Benefits awarded in the past three financial years

Benefit	2013/14	2014/15	2015/16
13th cheque	218 000	238 000	267 000
Provident Fund	417 000	446 000	493 000
Travel Allowance	0	0	22 000
Bonus	1 089 000	0	0

NB: The bonus amount paid in the 2013/14 financial year was for two financial years (2011/12 and 2012/13)

CROSS-BORDER ROAD TRANSPORT AGENCY (C-BRTA)

For the Cross-Border Road Transport Agency, (a) the gross annual salaries for the Chief Executive Officer with (b) benefits, (ii) monetary values and (c) increases in (i) gross annual salary and benefits awarded in the past three financial years (2015/2016; 2014/2015 and 2013/2014) are depicted in the table below:

Year	Increase Date	(a) Gross Annual Salary	(b) (i) Annual Cellphone Allowance	(b) (ii) Performance Bonus	(c) (i) Increase %	(c)(ii) Reimbursive Expenditure	(c)(ii) 5 Year Long Service Award	Total
2015 / 2016	01-Apr-16	2 366 117,16	65 316,00	155 681,33	5,90%	86 382,46	2 542,45	2 676 039,40

2014 /2015	01-Apr-14	2 234 293,92	65 316,00	144 149,39	7,90%	29 268,80	-	2 473 028,11

2013 / 2014	01-Apr-13	2 070 708,04	65 316,00	-	8,00%	47 199,94	-	2 183 223,98

PASSENGER RAIL AGENCY OF SOUTH AFRICA (PRASA)

(a) PRASA pays Total Guaranteed Pay Packages inclusive of all benefits:

Entity	Name	2013	2014	2015	2016 (Prorata)	Comments
PRASA Group	TL Montana	R5 343 063	R5 623 531	R5 903 999	0	The GCEO has been with PRASA for the past 10 years and thus enjoyed annual increases over the period.
	N Khena				R2 753 902	Received an Acting allowance as the Acting Group CEO following the resignation of the GCEO

RAIL	EM Mofi	R3 159 000	R3 348 540	R3 542 755	R1 877 659
CRES	PT Ngubane	R116 883	R2 500 000	R2 650 000	R1 324 999
TECH	S Zamxaka	R2 527 200	R2 678 832	R2 839 561	0
	D Kekana				R2 640 942	Is the Acting CEO, but has not yet been paid the Acting Allowance
Intersite	M Ngoye	R2 448 600
	PA Gombert		R1 855 927	R1 967 793
	NC Molepo				R3 901 027
Autopax	TR Kgaboesele	R2 893 800
	N Khena		R2 316 600	R2 455 596
	BB Kupe				R2 337 200

(b)(i)(ii) Mr Nathi Khena was the Acting Group CEO from July 2015 – July 2016 and received an acting allowance of R277 920 for 2015 and R294 671 for 2016.

Ms Tara Ngubane was appointed the CEO of PRASA CRES and received a 28% increase on her salary. David Kekana is the Acting CEO of PRASA Tech, but is not yet receiving an allowance for his acting.

Mr Patrick Gombert was the Acting CEO from 2015 – 2016 and received an acting allowance of R222 711 for 2015 and R236 135 for 2016.

(c)(i)

Entity	Name	2013	2014	2015	2016 (Prorata)	Comments
PRASA Group	TL Montana	320,583.78 6%	R280 468 5%	R280 468 5%	0	The GCEO had been with PRASA for the past 10 years and thus enjoyed annual increases over the period.
	N Khena				R2 753 902	Received an Acting allowance as Acting Group CEO following the resignation of the CEO
RAIL	EM Mofi	R189 540 6%	R183 222 5.8 %	R200 912 6%	R212 565 6%
CRES	PT Ngubane 6%	R116 883 6%	R551 950 5.8%	R150 000 6%	R159 000 6%
TECH	S Zamxaka	R151 632	R 151 632	R160 577	0
Intersite	M Ngoye	R146 916 6%
	NC Molepo				R1 300 342
Autopax	TR Kgaboesele	R173 628 6%
	BB Kupe				R1 188 600

(ii) There were no additional benefits that the CEOs enjoyed except the annual increases that are specified above.

01 November 2016 - NW2176

Mazzone, Ms NW to ask the Minister of Public Enterprises

Whether she will provide Ms N W A Mazzone with Eskom’s detailed strategic plan of action to generate R15 billion in cash reserve revenue for each of the next 10 years to be utilised for Government’s nuclear build programme; if not, why not; if so, by when; (2) how will Eskom manage to generate the total R 150 billion cash reserve revenue in the next 10 years to fund Government’s nuclear build programme, given that Eskom’s current and non-current borrowings is R 322 billion?

Source
Link

Reply:

ESKOM has not finalised its strategic plan for each of the next ten years. However, it is expected that its EBITDA margins will continue to improve, capital expenditure will decrease over the next ten years as the current built programme winds down, costs continue to be reduced and debt repayments become lower.
The measures mentioned in (1) will result in an increase in available free cash.

Questions and Replies

09 November 2016 - NW2360

Waters, Mr M to ask the Minister of Home Affairs

Reply:

09 November 2016 - NW1959

Boshoff, Ms SH to ask the Minister of Basic Education

Reply:

09 November 2016 - NW2191

Kopane, Ms SP to ask the Minister of Basic Education

Reply:

09 November 2016 - NW2010

Maimane, Mr MA to ask the Minister of Finance

Reply:

09 November 2016 - NW2150

Mileham, Mr K to ask the Minister of Finance

Reply:

09 November 2016 - NW2297

Tarabella - Marchesi, Ms NI to ask the Minister of Home Affairs

Reply:

09 November 2016 - NW2192

Kopane, Ms SP to ask the Minister of Basic Education

Reply:

09 November 2016 - NW2190

Kopane, Ms SP to ask the Minister of Basic Education

Reply:

09 November 2016 - NW2215

Carter, Ms D to ask the Minister of Finance

Reply:

09 November 2016 - NW1968

Maimane, Mr MA to ask the Minister of Finance

Reply:

09 November 2016 - NW1887

Lees, Mr RA to ask the Minister of Finance

Reply:

09 November 2016 - NW2055

Gqada, Ms T to ask the Minister of Finance

Reply:

09 November 2016 - NW2133

Lees, Mr RA to ask the Minister of Rural Development and Land Reform

Reply:

09 November 2016 - NW2148

Vos, Mr J to ask the Minister of Tourism

Reply:

09 November 2016 - NW2256

Waters, Mr M to ask the Minister of Home Affairs

Reply:

09 November 2016 - NW2161

Waters, Mr M to ask the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services

Reply:

09 November 2016 - NW2004

Esau, Mr S to ask the Minister of Home Affairs

Reply:

09 November 2016 - NW2284

Van Dyk, Ms V to ask the Minister of Home Affairs

Reply:

08 November 2016 - NW2300

Mokgalapa, Mr S to ask the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services

Reply:

08 November 2016 - NW2249

Hunsinger, Dr CH to ask the Minister of Transport

Reply:

08 November 2016 - NW2366

Steyn, Ms A to ask the Minister of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries

Reply:

08 November 2016 - NW1977

Maynier, Mr D to ask the President of the Republic

Reply:

08 November 2016 - NW2424

Macpherson, Mr DW to ask the Minister of Trade and Industry

Reply:

08 November 2016 - NW2285

Bergman, Mr D to ask the Minister of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries

Reply:

08 November 2016 - NW2244

De Freitas, Mr MS to ask the Minister of Transport

Reply:

07 November 2016 - NW2299

Tarabella - Marchesi, Ms NI to ask the MINISTER OF INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS AND COOPERATION:

Reply:

07 November 2016 - NW2319