Questions and Replies
18 December 2018 - NW2882
Gardee, Mr GA to ask the Minister of Finance
With reference to the reply to question 2362 on 14 September 2018, what is the (a) name of each and (b) number of private security services companies that have contracts with the State?
Reply:
The following information was accessed from the Central Supplier Database system by the Office of the Chief Procurement Officer:
a) A list of companies with open orders that are linked to private security services either via the industry they are active in or the commodities they supply to government, in an Excel format (ANNEXURE A); and
b) The list indicates a total number of 2879 companies.
18 December 2018 - NW3038
Mileham, Mr K to ask the Minister of Finance
(1) Whether KPMG was involved in auditing any (a)(i) national and (ii) provincial departments and (b) state-owned entities in the past three financial years; if so, in each case, (i) which (aa) department and (bb) entity did the specified company audit, (ii) what are the details of the audit outcomes and findings and (iii) what amount was paid to the audit company for the auditing services rendered; (2) whether there were any incidents where the specified audit outcomes were found to have been (a) falsified, (b) misleading and/or (c) irregular in any way; if so, what are the relevant details in each case?
Reply:
1. (a) (i) and (ii) The audit of National and Provincial departments are done by the office of the Auditor General (AGSA), therefore this question should be referred to the AGSA.
(b) State-owned entities appoints their auditors in concurrence with Auditor General for final approval, through their boards or accounting authorities, therefore the information should be requested from the Auditor-General
2. The response on the incidents of the audit outcome should be requested from the Office of the Auditor General for all national, provincial departments and for the State-Owned entity.
18 December 2018 - NW2969
Lees, Mr RA to ask the Minister of Finance
What are the details of the appointment of a certain person (name furnished) in terms of the (a) qualifications required for the position, (b) qualifications that the specified person possesses, (c) process that was followed to attract applicants for the position, (d) applicants who applied for the position and (e) reasons the specified person was appointed to the position?
Reply:
a) An appropriate postgraduate qualification.
b) PhD: Management, Administration and Policy;
Masters in Management, Administration and Policy; and
Bachelor of Social Science.
c) The position for Chairperson of the Financial and Fiscal Commission was advertised in national newspapers during September 2016. The closing date for applications was 7 October 2016.
d) Thirteen applications were received. see the link:
http://pmg-assets.s3-website-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/RNW2969_Applications.pdf
e) The Chairperson of the Financial and Fiscal Commission is appointed by the President together with a member of Cabinet, i.e. in this instance, the Minister of Finance. Prof Plaatjies was recommended by the Minister of Finance prior to his appointment by the President. In addition to his qualifications, Prof Plaatjies has held the following positions:
1.Part-time Commissioner of the Financial and Fiscal Commission;
2.Executive Director: Democracy, Governance and Service at the Human Rights Research Council;
3.Adviser to the Minister for Public Service and Administration;
4. Head of Performance and Evaluation in the Office of the Premier for the Free State Provincial Government;
5. Deputy Director-General at the South African Social Security Agency.
18 December 2018 - NW2883
Gardee, Mr GA to ask the Minister of Finance
With reference to the reply of the Minister of Public Service and Administration to question 2361 on 17 September 2018, what (a) number of government employees on (i) national and (ii) provincial level on the PERSAL system are over the age of 60 years and (b) is the breakdown of the specified government employees in terms of (i) age, (ii) department and (iii) salary level?
Reply:
a) Number of employees aged 60 and older per sphere of government as at September 2018 for all the departments (South African National Defence Force data extracted from September 2017:
Sphere |
Number of employees aged 60 and older |
Eastern Cape |
6 458 |
Free State |
2 788 |
Gauteng |
8 329 |
Kwa-Zulu Natal |
7 309 |
Limpopo Province |
5 303 |
Mpumalanga |
2 908 |
National Departments |
6 221 |
North West |
2 762 |
Northern Cape |
1 257 |
Western Cape |
4 873 |
Notes:
1) Data presented as at end September 2018. South African National Defence Force data as at September 2017
b) Breakdown of specified government employees in terms of:
(i) Age
Age |
Number of employees aged 60 and older |
60 |
14 734 |
61 |
10 436 |
62 |
8 429 |
63 |
6 481 |
64 |
5 373 |
65 |
568 |
66 |
254 |
67 |
174 |
68 |
137 |
69 |
120 |
70 |
121 |
71 |
89 |
72 |
79 |
73 |
49 |
74 |
61 |
75 |
40 |
76 |
32 |
77 |
36 |
78 |
45 |
79 |
27 |
80 |
23 |
81 |
18 |
82 |
21 |
83 |
19 |
84 |
19 |
85 |
12 |
86 |
12 |
87 |
9 |
88 |
12 |
89 |
7 |
90 |
6 |
91 |
1 |
92 |
2 |
94 |
1 |
95 |
1 |
97 |
1 |
999 |
759 |
Notes:
1) Data presented as at end September 2018. South African National Defence Force data as at September 2017
(ii) Department
Sphere |
Department |
Age 60 and older |
Eastern Cape |
Vote 01: Office Of The Premier |
15 |
Eastern Cape |
Vote 02: Eastern Cape Provincial Legislature |
25 |
Eastern Cape |
Vote 03: Health |
2 183 |
Eastern Cape |
Vote 04: Social Development And Special Programmes |
57 |
Eastern Cape |
Vote 05: Public Works |
101 |
Eastern Cape |
Vote 06: Education |
3 071 |
Eastern Cape |
Vote 07: Cooperative Governance And Traditional Affairs |
591 |
Eastern Cape |
Vote 08: Rural Development And Agrarian Reform |
147 |
Eastern Cape |
Vote 09: Economic Development Environmental Affairs And Tourism |
14 |
Eastern Cape |
Vote 10: Transport |
182 |
Eastern Cape |
Vote 11: Human Settlements |
15 |
Eastern Cape |
Vote 12: Provincial Treasury |
9 |
Eastern Cape |
Vote 14: Sport Recreation Arts And Culture |
44 |
Eastern Cape |
Vote 15: Safety And Liaison |
4 |
Free State |
Vote 01: Premier |
17 |
Free State |
Vote 03: Economic And Small Business Development Tourism And Environmental |
32 |
Free State |
Vote 04: Provincial Treasury |
4 |
Free State |
Vote 05: Health |
875 |
Free State |
Vote 06: Education |
1 394 |
Free State |
Vote 07: Social Development |
70 |
Free State |
Vote 08: Cooperative Governance And Traditional Affairs |
27 |
Free State |
Vote 09: Public Works And Infrastructure |
104 |
Free State |
Vote 10: Police Roads And Transport |
168 |
Free State |
Vote 11: Agriculture And Rural Development |
49 |
Free State |
Vote 12: Sport Arts Culture And Recreation |
44 |
Free State |
Vote 13: Human Settlements |
4 |
Gauteng |
Vote 01: Office Of The Premier |
12 |
Gauteng |
Vote 03: Economic Development |
3 |
Gauteng |
Vote 04: Health |
2 947 |
Gauteng |
Vote 05: Education |
4 827 |
Gauteng |
Vote 06: Social Development |
132 |
Gauteng |
Vote 07: Co Operative Governance and Traditional Affairs |
30 |
Gauteng |
Vote 08: Human Settlements |
46 |
Gauteng |
Vote 09: Roads And Transport |
95 |
Gauteng |
Vote 10: Community Safety |
25 |
Gauteng |
Vote 11: Agriculture And Rural Development |
22 |
Gauteng |
Vote 12: Sport Arts Culture And Recreation |
19 |
Gauteng |
Vote 13: eGovernment |
16 |
Gauteng |
Vote 14: Provincial Treasury |
20 |
Gauteng |
Vote 15: Infrastructure Development |
135 |
KwaZulu Natal |
Vote 01: Office Of The Premier |
39 |
KwaZulu Natal |
Vote 03: Agriculture And Rural Development |
117 |
KwaZulu Natal |
Vote 04: Economic Development Tourism And Environmental Affairs |
14 |
KwaZulu Natal |
Vote 05: Education |
3 686 |
KwaZulu Natal |
Vote 06: Finance |
7 |
KwaZulu Natal |
Vote 07: Health |
2 906 |
KwaZulu Natal |
Vote 08: Human Settlements |
34 |
KwaZulu Natal |
Vote 09: Community Safety And Liaison |
4 |
KwaZulu Natal |
Vote 10: Sport And Recreation |
2 |
KwaZulu Natal |
Vote 11: Cooperative Governance And Traditional Affairs |
135 |
KwaZulu Natal |
Vote 12: Transport |
177 |
KwaZulu Natal |
Vote 13: Social Development |
77 |
KwaZulu Natal |
Vote 14: Public Works |
97 |
KwaZulu Natal |
Vote 15: Arts And Culture |
14 |
Limpopo Province |
Vote 01: Office Of The Premier |
25 |
Limpopo Province |
Vote 02: Provincial Legislature |
10 |
Limpopo Province |
Vote 03: Education |
2 294 |
Limpopo Province |
Vote 04: Agriculture And Rural Development |
285 |
Limpopo Province |
Vote 05: Provincial Treasury |
27 |
Limpopo Province |
Vote 06: Economic Development Environment And Tourism |
112 |
Limpopo Province |
Vote 07: Health |
1 548 |
Limpopo Province |
Vote 08: Transport |
114 |
Limpopo Province |
Vote 09: Public Works Roads And Infrastructure |
624 |
Limpopo Province |
Vote 10: Community Safety |
4 |
Limpopo Province |
Vote 11: Cooperative Governance Human Settlements And Traditional Affairs |
196 |
Limpopo Province |
Vote 12: Social Development |
49 |
Limpopo Province |
Vote 13: Sport Arts And Culture |
15 |
Mpumalanga |
Vote 01: Office Of The Premier |
14 |
Mpumalanga |
Vote 03: Finance |
12 |
Mpumalanga |
Vote 04: Co Operative Governance And Traditional Affairs |
28 |
Mpumalanga |
Vote 05: Agriculture Rural Development And Land Administration |
113 |
Mpumalanga |
Vote 06: Economic Development And Tourism |
13 |
Mpumalanga |
Vote 07: Education |
1 695 |
Mpumalanga |
Vote 08: Public Works Roads And Transport |
205 |
Mpumalanga |
Vote 09: Community Safety Security And Liaison |
27 |
Mpumalanga |
Vote 10: Health |
745 |
Mpumalanga |
Vote 11: Culture Sport And Recreation |
17 |
Mpumalanga |
Vote 12: Social Development |
29 |
Mpumalanga |
Vote 13: Dept Of Human Settlements |
10 |
National Departments |
Civilian Secretariat |
6 |
National Departments |
Government Communication And Information System |
11 |
National Departments |
Military Veterans |
7 |
National Departments |
National Defence Force |
1 167 |
National Departments |
National Prosecuting Authority |
111 |
National Departments |
National School of Government |
6 |
National Departments |
Public Service Commission |
19 |
National Departments |
Traditional Affairs |
3 |
National Departments |
Vote 01: The Presidency |
14 |
National Departments |
Vote 03: Communications |
3 |
National Departments |
Vote 04: Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs |
8 |
National Departments |
Vote 05: Home Affairs |
154 |
National Departments |
Vote 06: International Relations And Cooperation |
188 |
National Departments |
Vote 07: National Treasury |
30 |
National Departments |
Vote 08: Planning Monitoring and Evaluation. |
6 |
National Departments |
Vote 09: Public Enterprises |
3 |
National Departments |
Vote 10: Public Service And Administration |
17 |
National Departments |
Vote 11: Public Works |
15 |
National Departments |
Vote 12: Statistics South Africa |
71 |
National Departments |
Vote 13: Women |
1 |
National Departments |
Vote 14: Basic Education |
51 |
National Departments |
Vote 15: Higher Education And Training |
1 417 |
National Departments |
Vote 16: Health |
69 |
National Departments |
Vote 17: Social Development |
34 |
National Departments |
Vote 18: Correctional Services |
47 |
National Departments |
Vote 20: Independent Police Investigative Directorate |
4 |
National Departments |
Vote 21: Justice And Constitutional Development |
699 |
National Departments |
Vote 22: National Office of the Chief Justice |
385 |
National Departments |
Vote 23: Police |
726 |
National Departments |
Vote 24: Agriculture Forestry And Fisheries |
313 |
National Departments |
Vote 25: Economic Development |
4 |
National Departments |
Vote 26: Energy |
12 |
National Departments |
Vote 27: Environmental Affairs |
41 |
National Departments |
Vote 28: Labour |
162 |
National Departments |
Vote 29: Mineral Resources |
34 |
National Departments |
Vote 30: Science And Technology |
11 |
National Departments |
Vote 31: Small Business Development |
2 |
National Departments |
Vote 32: Telecommunications and Postal Services |
7 |
National Departments |
Vote 33: Tourism |
8 |
National Departments |
Vote 34: Trade And Industry |
41 |
National Departments |
Vote 35: Transport |
24 |
National Departments |
Vote 36: Water and Sanitation |
169 |
National Departments |
Vote 37: Arts And Culture |
11 |
National Departments |
Vote 38: Human Settlements |
19 |
National Departments |
Vote 39: Rural Development And Land Reform |
79 |
National Departments |
Vote 40: Sport And Recreation South Africa |
12 |
North West |
Vote 01: Office Of The Premier |
21 |
North West |
Vote 03: Health |
828 |
North West |
Vote 04: Culture Arts And Traditional Affairs |
36 |
North West |
Vote 05: Community Safety And Transport Management |
52 |
North West |
Vote 06: Economy And Enterprise Development |
12 |
North West |
Vote 07: Finance |
16 |
North West |
Vote 08: Education And Sports Development |
1 390 |
North West |
Vote 09: Loc Gov And Human Settlements |
40 |
North West |
Vote 10: Tourism |
10 |
North West |
Vote 11: Public Works and Roads |
212 |
North West |
Vote 12: Social Development |
26 |
North West |
Vote 13: Rural Environment And Agriculture Development |
119 |
Northern Cape |
Vote 01: Office Of The Premier |
12 |
Northern Cape |
Vote 02: Provincial Legislature |
4 |
Northern Cape |
Vote 03: Transport Safety And Liaison |
2 |
Northern Cape |
Vote 04: Education |
748 |
Northern Cape |
Vote 05: Roads And Public Works |
63 |
Northern Cape |
Vote 06: Economic Development And Tourism |
5 |
Northern Cape |
Vote 07: Sport Arts And Culture |
16 |
Northern Cape |
Vote 08: Provincial Treasury |
6 |
Northern Cape |
Vote 09: Cooperative Governance Human Settlements And Traditional Affairs |
31 |
Northern Cape |
Vote 10: Health |
317 |
Northern Cape |
Vote 11: Social Development |
20 |
Northern Cape |
Vote 12: Agriculture Land Reform And Rural Development |
29 |
Northern Cape |
Vote 13: Environment And Nature Conservation |
4 |
Western Cape |
Vote 01: The Premier |
34 |
Western Cape |
Vote 03: Provincial Treasury |
5 |
Western Cape |
Vote 04: Community Safety |
13 |
Western Cape |
Vote 05: Education |
3 129 |
Western Cape |
Vote 06: Health |
1 372 |
Western Cape |
Vote 07: Social Development |
67 |
Western Cape |
Vote 08: Human Settlements |
17 |
Western Cape |
Vote 09: Environmental Affairs And Development Planning |
9 |
Western Cape |
Vote 10: Transport And Public Works |
120 |
Western Cape |
Vote 11: Agriculture |
49 |
Western Cape |
Vote 12: Economic Development And Tourism |
6 |
Western Cape |
Vote 13: Cultural Affairs And Sport |
36 |
Western Cape |
Vote 14: Local Government |
16 |
Notes:
1) Data presented as at end September 2018. South African National Defence Force data as at September 2017
(iii) Salary Level
Salary Level |
Age 60 and older |
0 |
2 018 |
1 |
53 |
2 |
2 629 |
3 |
7 132 |
4 |
1 374 |
5 |
2 503 |
6 |
3 451 |
7 |
5 939 |
8 |
5 944 |
9 |
6 908 |
10 |
4 849 |
11 |
1 922 |
12 |
2 132 |
13 |
639 |
14 |
290 |
15 |
98 |
16 |
327 |
Notes:
1) Data presented as at end September 2018. South African National Defence Force data as at September 2017
18 December 2018 - NW2968
Lees, Mr RA to ask the Minister of Finance
What (a) total number of consent orders did the Independent Regulatory Board for Auditors make in the 2017-18 financial year, (b) number of the specified consent orders were finalised, (c) is the detailed breakdown of the number of orders that were made and finalised against each audit firm and registered auditor, (d) are the details of any fines and penalties imposed on each (i) audit firm and (ii) registered auditor, (e) are the dates in each case and (f) are the details of the transgressions on which the consent orders were issued in each case?
Reply:
IRBA News Edition 38 – April - June 2017 |
|
|
|
|
|
No Disciplinary Advisory Committee meetings convened in this period. |
|
|
|
|
|
IRBA News Edition 39 – July - Sept 2017 |
|
|
|
|
|
Consent order |
Matter 1 - Audit |
Fine of R200 000 with R50 000 suspended for 3 years, R20 000 costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 2 - Audit |
Fine of R200 000 with R50 000 suspended for 3 years, R20 000 costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 3 - Audit |
Fine of R100 000 with R50 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 4 -Audit |
Fine of R100 000 with R20 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 5 - Audit |
Fine of R150 000 with R50 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 6 - Audit |
Fine of R100 000 with R50 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 7 - Audit |
Fine of R100 000 with R50 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 8 - Audit |
Fine of R40 000 with R20 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 9 - Audit |
Fine of R80 000 with R40 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 10 - Audit |
Fine of R150 000 with R75 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 11 - Audit |
Fine of R80 000 with R40 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 12 -Audit |
Fine of R80 000 with R40 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 13 -Audit |
Fine of R80 000 with R40 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication. In addition the imposition of a previously suspended fine of R50,000 relating to a previous matter became payable. |
Consent order |
Matter 14 - Audit |
Fine of R100 000 with R50 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 15 - Audit |
Fine of R60 000 with R30 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 16 - Companies Act |
Fine of R80 000 with R40 000 suspended for 3 years, R5 000 costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 17 - Companies Act |
Fine of R80 000 with R40 000 suspended for 3 years, R5 000 costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 18 - Companies Act |
Fine of R80 000 with R40 000 suspended for 3 years, R5 000 costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 19 - Companies Act |
Fine of R80 000 with R40 000 suspended for 3 years, R5 000 costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 20 - Companies Act |
Fine of R80 000 with R40 000 suspended for 3 years, R5 000 costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 21 - Companies Act |
Fine of R80 000 with R40 000 suspended for 3 years, R5 000 costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 22 - Companies Act |
Fine of R80 000 with R40 000 suspended for 3 years, R5 000 costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 23- Audit |
Fine of R150 000 with R75 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 24 - Audit |
Fine of R150 000 with R75 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 25- Audit |
Fine of R150 000 with R75 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 26 - Audit |
Fine of R150 000 with R75 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Referred to Disciplinary hearing |
Matter 27 - Audit |
In progress |
Referred to Disciplinary hearing |
Matter 28 -Tax |
In progress |
|
|
|
IRBA News Edition 40 – Oct- Dec 2017 |
|
|
Consent order |
Matter 1- Audit |
Fine of R100 000 with R50 000 suspended for 3 years, R25 000 costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 2-Audit |
Fine of R100 0000 with R50 000 suspended for 3 years, R25 000 costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 3- Audit |
Fine of R100 000 with R50 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 4- Audit |
Fine of R100 000 with R50 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 5- Tax |
Fine of R150 000 with R50 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 6 - Audit |
Fine of R100 000 with R20 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 7 -Audit |
Fine of R60 000 with R30 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Referred to Disciplinary hearing |
Matter 8 -Audit |
In progress |
|
|
|
IRBA News Edition 41 – Jan - Mar 2018 |
|
|
Discharge |
Rule 3.5.1.1 |
3 matters |
Discharge |
Rule 3.5.1.3 |
1 matter |
Consent order |
Matter 1 - Audit |
Fine of R180 000 with full amount suspended until re-registration, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 2 - Auditing Profession Act |
Fine of R50 000 with R40 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 3 - Audit |
Fine of R100 000 with R50 000 suspended for 3years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 4 - Audit, Companies Act |
Fine of R150 000 with R75 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 5 - Assurance |
Fine of R80 000 with R40 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Consent order |
Matter 6 - Assurance |
Fine of R120 000 with R40 000 suspended for 3 years, no costs, general publication |
Referred to Disciplinary hearing |
Matter 7 - Audit, Code |
In progress |
Referred to Disciplinary hearing |
Matter 8 - Assurance |
In progress |
18 December 2018 - NW2603
Mente-Nkuna, Ms NV to ask the Minister of Finance
With reference to the reply to question 168 on 24 May 2018, and in light of the fact that the central supplier database captures each company registration number of all suppliers, the directors and their identity numbers, what are the details of the directors of each consultant company that was hired from 1 January 2012 to 31 December 2016?
Reply:
Information regarding the companies and their directors is attached. Given the constitutional right to privacy, the identity numbers of the directors are not furnished.
Company name |
Directors of company |
21st Century Pay Solutions Group |
Christopher Francis Blair, Mark Herber Raymond Bussin, Nasreen Banu Dawood, Dumisani Khanyile, Mbulelo Joel Mayikana, Ian Patrick Mcgorian, Morag Phillips, Craig Andrew Raath, Bryden Jason Morton, Ntombizone Feni |
360 Currency |
Annelies Nel |
Akhile Management and Consulting (Pty) Ltd |
Aneel Kumar Radhakrishna, Fongumusa Nhlanhleni Brian Hadebe, Aditi Radhakrishna |
Apex Advisory Services |
Natasha Reema Sing-Ally |
Bain And Company South Africa |
Stuart Kevin Min, Winston Keith Wilton |
Belay Managed Services Pty Ltd |
Johannes Groeneveld, John Ramatsui |
Bigen Africa Services Pty Ltd |
Anton Boshoff, Carolus Johannes Venter, Jacob Henry de Villiers Botha, Snowy Joyce Khoza, Zandile Nangamso Mankai, Deon Fabel, Otto Scharfetter, Salome Sengani, Ian Joseph Harford Bettesworth, Leon Boshoff, William Hohn Bosman, Jacques Leslie Bredenkamp, Pieter Abraham Cilliers, Anesta Henriette de Klerk, Pieter Willem du Plessis, Louis Gerhardus Gertenbach, Kesvin Govender, Daniel Jacobus Grabe, Johann Hooper, Johannes Jurie Human, Alex du Plessis Le Grange, Jacob Genis Louw, Henrik Fredrik Maree, Robert Albert Moffat, Tafadzwa Mukwena, Rineshree Naicker, Michael Jacobus Nel, Phinda Joseph Ngozo, Johan Henri Pieters, Kevindran Pillay, Dane Robin Poggenpeol, Ian Timothy Pollard, Marthinus Wessel Pretorius, Philippus Jacobus Johannes Reyneke, Hendrik Conrnelius Rossouw, Daniel Smit, Dieter Owen Storbeck, Jacobus Nicolaas Johannes Swart, Gilliam Swiegers, Johannes Steyn van Blerk, Jan Louis van den Berg, Hayley Ann van der Merwe, Jeremia Jesaja van der Walt, Sulett Goncalves van Graan,Terence Clint van Rensburg Francois Jacobus Viljoen, Carel Rudolph West, Andries Philippus Olivier, Hendrik Jakobus Bester, Carina Cox, Leon Rens Els, Victor Letsoejane Litlhakanyane, Henri Siebert, Rhulani Daphney Matshidze, Bongani Blessing Mabizela, Kelepile Anthony Dintwe, Ruan Werner Minnaar |
Bitz Technologies (Trading as Abacus Advisory) |
Mohamed Amin Cassim |
Bowman Gilfillan Inc |
Partick Anthony Hirsh, Adam Gordon Anderson, David Peter Anderson, Anton Mark Barnes-Webb, Claire Louise Reidy, Tammy Lynn Beira, Roger Edgar Westley Burman, Robin Moncrieff Carr, Patrick Miles Carter, Lloyd Arthur Chater, Robert Anton Cohen, Craig Neil Cunningham, Graham Hugh Damant, Mzuwandile Ezra Clavis, Heather Dean Duffey, Lance Fleiser, Karen Anne Fulton, David John Geral, Timothy James Gordon Grant, Ashleigh Hale, Paul Hart-Davies, Ineke Louise Brink, Jeremy David Prain, Cornelia Maria Bouwer, Jeremia Ramasela Kaapu, Alan James Keep, Talita Laubscher, Robert Andrew Legh, Derek Andrew Lötter, Penuell Mpapa Maduna, Anne Mc Kinnell. James Michael Mc Kinnell, Gordon Ian Rushton, Beatrix Gertruida Magdalena Strydom, Christopher Frances Neale Todd, Claire Elizabeth Tucker, Daryn Stuart, Peter Eugene Whelan, Shelley Gaye Wilson, Tamara Carmela Oates, Charles Robert Douglas, Adam Simon Harris, Craig Patrick Kennedy, Randall John van Voore, Rosalind Ann Davey, Barry John Garven, Henry Bonginkosi Ngcobo, David Drummond Yuill, Livia Smith, Casper Louis van Heerden, Virusha Nannoolal, Fahdia Bhayat, Matthew Adkisson Purchase, Deon de Klerk, Johannes George Kruger, Rudolph Johannes Labuschagne, Richard Ze'ev Shein, Iona Duduzile Leshaba, Helen Jane Schoeman, Mandisi Selwin Rusa, Johathan Westley Sahli, Donna Gewer, Lusanda Vuyelwa Raphulu, Lucinda Verster, Jan Petrus Kruger, Dirk Cornelius Wessels, Nendel Yriel Sass, Lischa Herta Mary Gerstle, Craig Gerald Schäfer, Maria Anna Julie Osborne, Dana Edith Mclean, Michael George Vermaak, Peruscha Pillay, Charles Esward Cameron Smith, Trudie Hayley Mandy, Andrew John Pike, Maryanne Angumuthoo, Tholinhlanhla monde Gcabashe, Christopher Bernard Green, Kirsten Michelle Kern, Joanne Barbara Ripley-Evans, Mark Robert van Velden, James William Lynton Westgate, John Meredith Bellew, Warren Hamer, Joshua Ricky Janks, Mvisiswano Clement Mkiva, Happy Wandisile Mandlana, Lyndal Joan Anderson, Ian D'aguilar Kirkman, Tumisang Lesego Mongae, Charles Zanokuthula Nduli, Yashveer Ram, Elizabeth Cecilia Basson, Patricia Williams, Jane Andropoulos, Shamilah Grimwood, Khomotso Standley Makapane, Judd Lurie, Luway Mongie, Timothy Partick Mcdougall, Samir Ellary, Phetole Ivan Modika, Samantha Saffy, Spencer Patrick Naicker, Andrew van Niekerk, Ulrike Erika Brigette Ursula Naumann, Kelly Susan Wright, Xolani Nyali, Heidi Taylor, Misty Keep, Lital Avivi, Melissa Strydom, Amanda Arumugam Shakti Ann Wood. |
Business Connexion (Pty) Ltd |
Deon Jeftha Fredericks, Penuell Cornwell Sibusiso Luthuli, Regilwe Sakgeya Nkabinde, Sipho Nkosinathi Maseko, Sibusiso Sibisi, Faith Nondumiso Khanyile, Thabo Dloti, Michael Ettling, Jonas Poriki Bogoshi |
Casucceed Training Pty Ltd |
Thabiso Raymond Madiba, Monique Keevy |
CIPS SA |
Duncan Philip Brock, Jannine Rosanne Griffiths, Amanda Susan O'brien, Hemant Harrielall |
Clarity Editorial Cc |
Gregory Jon Rosenberg, Martha Palesa Morudu |
Comsel Eighteen |
Kanaga Vittee, Cheryl Jane Kujenga |
Cool Ideas (Pty)Ltd |
Ashen Rajah, John William King, Ebrahim Aboobaker Laher |
Creative Consulting And Development Works Cc |
Lindy Jane Briginshaw |
Deloitte and Touche |
Nazeer Ahmed Essop, Lerato Bacela, Mmaboshadi Chauke, Pearl Zama Dlamini, Egnes Macheve, Pulane Delia Ndlovu, Rachel Nkgodi, Lwazikazi Nomavo Nopece, Ntombenhle Bridget Radebe, Vuyelwa Sangoni, Faith Tumelo Seaketso, Gladys Sebatha, Lerato Millicent Sithole, Lwazi Loyiso Bam, Vonani Justice Chauke, Siviwe Zolisile Arthur Dongwana, Phaphmani Alex Thabani Gwala, Sandile Aubrey Zolani Gwala, Twalizidanga Mlondolozi Mgcinisihlalo Jordan, Charles Kweku Larbi-Odam, Mthokozisi Raymond Luthuli, Thabang Elvis Magare, Mandisi Mantyi, Wiseman Victor Musawenkosi Manyathi, Andrew Walter Mashifane, Sonwabo Mateyisi, Lector Arthur Matsho, Siwa Langton Mautsa, Slingsby Wonga Mda, Patrick Ndlovu, Kgomotso Pule Ramoitshudi Ngakane, Bongani Nkasana, Lungelo Christopher Nomvalo, Sisa Oswald Ntlango, Bongisipho Nyembe, Nkululeko Praise-God Oliphant, Emmanuel Ramasodi, Gregory Molefe Rammego, Lufuno Ravhuhali, Gabaiphiwe Ebenezer Daniel Tabane, Moroa Lehlohonolo Eric Tshabalala, Puledi George Tshesane, Joseph Zitha, Anthea Karen Scholtz, Mogamat Zahid Bardien, Randall Cupido, Justin Diedericks, Daniel Mark Flanagan, Reyaaz Jacobs, Peter Christian Present, Julian Sam, Muhammad Rushdi Solomons, Fatima Abba, Fathima Bibi Ally, Nerashni Dharamlall, Nazrien Banu Kader, Kasurthrie Justine Mazzocco, Shazia Moola, Carmeni Bester, Sudasha Naidoo, Nita Ranchod, Sharoda Rapeti, Ruwayda Redfearn, Li,esjmee Bigwandeen, Thrisha Soni, Kavita Vanmali, Arun Mappilaparambil Babu, Pramesh Bhana, Yusaf Bhula, Mohamed Saleem Cassim, Lallchand Dharamlall, Abubakr Essack, Mohammed Ferhet Gause, Praveck Geeanpersadh, Shaunapragasen Govender, Wesley Nallan Govender, Trushar Kalan, Shahil Manilal Kanjee, Haroon Ahmed Loonat, Thegarajan Marriday, Hoosain Mayet, Gitesh Baloobhai Mistry, Reshagan Angamuthoo Moodley, Dinesh Munu, Magendren Naidoo, Prashanth Naidoo, Sumendra Naidoo, Muhammad Taahir Osman, Riaz Anver Ebrahim Osman, Karthigasen Pillay, Thiruvasan Paranthaman Pillay, Sudheer Ishwarlal Rajcoomar, Kamal Singh Ramsingh, Mohammed Yacoob Shaikh, Navin Sing, Shamal Sivasanker, Chetan Chhagan Vaghela, Ismail Vawda, Bernadette Marie Abbott, Anneke Andrews, Chetan Chhagan Vaghela, Penelope Binnie, Anne Wilhelmina Casey, Jean Adrianne Cooper, Hildegarde Cronje, Christina Petronella Dippenaar, Leana du Plessis, Liezl du Plessis, Cathryn Robyn Emslie, Jennifer Lynn Erskine, Kerry-Anne Forster, Cathy Ann Gibson, Jolandi Grace, Igna Gray, Leonie Henderson, Karin Lynn Hodson, Gillian Elizabeth Hofmeyer, Candice Holland, Camilla Howard-Browne, Claire Frances Hoy, Zuleka Jasper, Diana Fernandes Jorge, Glen Suzanne Krynauw, Anne-Marie Liebenberg, Helena Sevasti Martins, Caarke Nel, Shelly Joy Nelson, Kim Peddie, Corinne Leigh Ringwood, Stephanie Louise Ronander, Annemarie Schroeder, Hermine Smit, Wendy Ann Smith, Catherine Elizabeth Stretton, Ashleigh Pauline Theophanides, Michele Nicola Townsend, Meredith van den Barselaar, Claudette van der Merwe, Suzanne van der Merwe, Ronel van Graan, Louise Vosloo, Lesley Karin Wallace, Jaqueline Wiezbowshi, Angelique Worms, Valter Domingos Adao, Coenrad Johannes Alberts, Marius Nicholas Alberts, Marc James Anley, Reinhard Hanns Arndt, Marcus Emmanuel Bardopoulos, Luke Geoffrey Vermaak Barlow, Christoper Lawrence Beneke, Graeme Micheal Berry, Johannes Marthinus Bierman, Kevin William Black, Antonie Johannes Jurgens Botes, Xavier Botha, Guy Campbell Brazier, Allan William Brown, Trevor Johathan Brown, Matthys Johannes Bruwer, Francois Alewyn Burger, Roy Charlton Campbell, Sebastian Benedikt Field Carter, Mark Antony Casey, Dean Aubrey Chivers, Newton Conradie Cockcroft, Michael John Comber, Lester Peter Cotten, Daniel Francois Crowther, Martyd John Davies, Graham David Dawes, Jurie Hendrik Wessels de Kock, Lino Ascensao de Ponte, Leonard Alexander de Rooij, Andre Juan Dennis, Trevor Austin Derwin, Murray Glenn Dicks, Ryan Lee Dogon, Michael Wilfred Du Toit, Akiva Ehrlich, Jacobus Adriaan Eksteen, Johannes Erasmus, Mark Alexander Freer, Bester Ebersohn Greyling, Mark Johathan Harrison, Mark Hugh Holme, Neville Patrick Hounsom, Michael John Jarvis, Mark Gerard Joseph, Beyers Gideon Joubert, William Edward Joubert, Andrew Robertson Kilpatrick, Wiebe Klaassen, Patrick Michael Kleb, Dirk Albertus Kotze, Geoffrey Brian Kroon. |
Desto Pty Ltd |
Hendrika Johanna Meyer, Marthinus Jacobus Meyer |
Edward Nathan Sonnenbergs |
Mziwozuko Mgudlwa, Chevan Daniels, Ilse du Plessis, Alexandre Filipe Morgado Ferreira, Senzo lloyd Mbatha, Nicola Hazel Nolan, Leonard Joseph Bilchitz, Theo Buchler, Julia Suzana Andrade Ferraz-Cardoso, James Thomas Peter Haydock, Johannes Daneel Loubser, Elizabeth Louw, Brian George Patterson, Gaelyn Clare Scott, Andre Willem Symington, Clinton van Loggerenberg, Ross John Alcock, Justin Balkin, Peter John Dachs, Mohamed Sajid Darsot, Paul Vivian Descroizilles, Hanneke Farrand, Joao Bernardino Andrade Ferraz, Robert Mendel Gad, Mark John Garden, Michael Warren Gradidge, Stuart William Harrison, Susan Beth Hayes, Lawrence Helman, Adriaan Cornelis Hoeben, Doron Joffe, Sanjay Kassen, Michael Mervyn, Leonard Charles Katz, Jocelyn Katz, Juliette Marion de Hutton, Eric Smith, Sean Craig Lederman, Stephen Barry Levetan, Natalia Dos Santos Lopes, Khuzamula Witness Makhubele, George Frederik Malan, Kevin Markman, Yonit Ariella Mendelsohn, Matthew George Morrison, Gary James Oertel, Jacobus Petrus Pretorius, Philippa Reyburn, Roger Brian Rudolph, Nicolette Smit, Hester Madgalena Snyckers, Robyn Tanya Stein, Joson Michael Valkin, Vanessa Louise van Coppenhagen, George Morrison van Niekerk, Jan Daniel Viviers, Stephen Robert von Schirnding, Hermann Wessels, Cecil Leon Wulfsohn, John Michael Zieff, Edwin Ellis, Motleu Douglas Molepo, Julius Theodore Oosthuizen, Bradley jason Serebro, Deborah Helen Carmichael, Armando de Sousa Aguiar, Philip Franz Lothar Geromont, Modisaotsile William Matlou, Anthony John Louis Norton, Irvin Bradley Wayne Lawrence, Catherine Vivien Pitman, Marthinus Theunis Steyn, Kaanit Abarder, Lloyd Christie, Zahida Ebrahim, Shafeeka Hartley, Helyn Margaret Herholdt, Deon Mark Lambert, Antony Lee, Michael Sinclair Tucker, Rowan Ian Forster, Derek Andrew Wanblad, Andrew Francis Bembridge, Loren Tibshraeny, Len Vorster, Sasha Singh, Suemeya Essack Mahomed Hanif, Itayi Daniel Gwaunza, Hendrik Belsazar Senekal, Vusimuzi Magubane, Jason Rusch, Derushka Chetty, Dion Harry Masher, Darren Band, Gordon William Reid, Ian Keith Hayes, Lydia Shadrach-Razzino, Paul Alan Winer, Willem Petrus le Roux, Kirsty Leigh Simpson, Pieter Gabriel Hendrik Colyn, Celeste Lynne Coles, Ridwaan Boda, Isaac Phayane Fenyane, Pareen Rogers, Richardt van Rensburg, Ruan Goodman, Willem Schalk Burger van der Colff, Elsie Audrey Johnson, Andries Johannes Myburgh, Timothy Mark Desmond, Lorica Elferink, Jessica Lee Blumenthal, Leigh Sedice, Fritz Dieter Schulz, Warren Ross Hendricks, Racheal Nantale Sikwane, Zeyn Bhyat, Tiaan Francois de Wit, Carlyn Brittany Frittelli, Lee-Ann Fiona Hopley, Adam Lombard, Lisa May Melis, Kumeshnie Naidoo, Lauren Jill Peterson, Balindile Theodorah Samkelisiwe, Waldo Steyn, Brian Peter Lee Jennings, Isaivan Naidoo, Lebusa Meso, Nkosingiphile Bhekumuzi Knoza, Deon Beachen, Ntlhane Josiah Lehlogonolo, Manisha Bugwandeen, Carmen Irene Gers, Kristel van Rensburg, Nzame-Bulungisa Ntembeko Qokweni, Nontsikelelo Adonisi-Kgame, Joseph Mothibi, Wilmari Strachan, Wade Jermaine Graaff, Sanushka Chetty, Tyla Foster, Heinrich Meiring, Michelle Smit, Tracey-Jane van Wyk, Letitia Field, Era Cecilia Gunning, Gerhardt Ehlers, Venetia Melissa Govender, Raashmi Myuri Govender, Monique Maree, Vusumuzi Sakhile Mathebula, Wandile Veronica Ndabambi, Megan Rossouw, Bradley Browne, Kelle Elizabeth Gagne, Melanie le Roux |
Eighty Twenty Consulting (Pty)Ltd |
Andrew Kerr Fulton, Steven Edward Burnstone, William Kirsh, Isaac Kirsh, Peter Ressell |
EOH Abantu |
John William King, Zunaid Mayet |
ESOH Consulting Cc |
Vinolia Rikhotso, Joseph Esoh Bezeng |
Exactitude Consulting (Pty) Ltd |
Clinton van Winkel, Penelope Moerane, Hermanus Adriaan Lombard |
Exponant (Pty) Ltd |
Leon Truter, Sibusiso Henry Maphatiane, Raynard van Nieuwenhuizen, Thys Tjaart Fourie, Philippus Rudolph de Wet, Sheilla Mlalazi, Selvan Naidoo, Nomsa Olivia Nteleko, Valerie Megasperee Naidoo, Ashley Kenneth Pillay, |
Fanyana Ntuli Trading Cc |
Leanett Fanyana Ntuli |
Finmark Trust |
Pakeereesamy Prega Ramsany, Cassim Coovadia, Ethel Gothatamodimo Matenge-Sebesho, Ishmael Mkhabela, Esau Nebwe |
Genesis Analytics |
Stephanus van Niekerk Malherbe, Richard Peter Tom Ketley, James William Hodge |
GJ Cronje Consulting & Management |
Gysbert Johannes Cronje, Karin Louise Cronje |
Gobodo Forensic And Investigative Accounting Pty Ltd |
Mareasele John Peter Mokae, Grant Buchler, Alberto Torres |
H&P IT Empowerment (Pty)Ltd |
Harold Mathabethe, Lodewikus Andries van der Merwe |
HR Computek |
Harry Tremorio Chakhala |
ICD Consultancy |
Thabang Simon Motshopi, Clemence Chiduwa |
ID1 Consulting Projects |
James Sydney de Jager |
Infinitum Software Solutions Pty Ltd |
Jan Hendrik Kruger, Hendrik Marthinus Daniel Underhay, Emmett Anderssen du Toit |
Infobuild |
Twanette Ann Jurd, Johan Nicolaas Jurd, Lauriane Stamer, Johannes Wilhelmus Louw de Preez, Jethro Lloyd Funck, Clayton Erick Peacock, Mashilo Refilwe Motia, Dina Nontuthumbo Saleni |
Institute for Performance Management |
Gerfina Johanna Rossouw Janse van Rensburg, Hector Makhubele |
Jumpco (Pty) Ltd |
Edgar Noel Maistry, Graham Bruce Bingham, John Stephen Mahony |
Kanagamurthi Reddy |
Kanagamurthi Reddy |
Koor Dindar Mothei Gauteng (Pty) Ltd |
Riaz Koor, Yusuf Mahomed Iqbal Dindar, Aslam Dukander, Ismail Agjee, Bonakelo Kenneth Mothei, Zenobia Dasoo, Allimia Ismail Koor, Moonira Bagum Koor, Tariq koor, Numan Koor, Luqman Koor, Aadilla Dindar, Adnaan Dindar, Tasneem Dindar, Imaan Dindar |
KPMG Services (Pty) Ltd |
Alan Dax Barr, Alison Elizabeth Margaret Beck, Edward Albert Belstead, Anthony Barry Berrange, Naresh Nresee Bhoola, John ronald Bowen, Yusuf Mahomed Abed, Carol Batchelor, Maria Magdalena De Wet, Marcelle Fouche, Kobus Henning, Bronvin Roy Heuvel, Abraham Venter Labuschagne, Jacob Le Roux, Maylee Deidre Lubbe, Antoinette Malherbe, Henning Johannes Opperman, Stefanus Christiaan Smith, Aspasia Anastasia Vaidanis, Roy Arthur Waligora, Heather Jean Berrange, Ahmed Bulbulia, Pierre Johannes Conradie, Mark Anthony Craddock, Paul Mark Daly, Jawaharlal Datadin, Frederik Anton De Bruyn, Sergio Luis Santos De Castro, Johannes Lodewikus De La Rey, Gavin Leslie De Lange, Gerhardus Dixon, Henry Visser Du Plessis, Devon Clive Duffield, Michael George Evans, Alan Brett Field, Dawid Jacobus Fouche, Pierre Fourie, Riana Fourie, Daniel Jacobus Fourie, Louis Pierre Fourie, Irma Fourie, Dean Friedman, Gavin Cecil Gainsford, Zaharati Roula Hadjipaschalis, Mahommed Hassan, Johan Heydenrych, Glenn HO, Marl Cecil Anthony Hoffman, Diana Jean Saunders, Kerry Claire Jenkins, Narvindchand Lala Keshav, Riaan Dalton Kok, Gabriel Stephanus Kolbe, Paresh Amratlal Hira Lalla, Mpheduseni Edson Magondo, Heinrich Mans, John Alistair Martin, Nichola John Matthews, John Scott MC Intosh, Tracy Ann Middlemiss, Andreas Bartholomeus Meyburgh, Walter Robert Carrington Palk, Gary Frederick Parker, Gary Mark Pickering, Ockert pornelius Potgieter, David Stratfold Read, Gordon francis Richardson, Steven Grant Robinson, Tersia Rossouw, John Michael Saker, Richard John David Samson, Johannes Christoffel Scheepers, De Buys Scott, Jan Scheltema (Johan) Smith, Ashley Magnus Smith, Nicolas Harry Southon, Garry Graham Stanier, Ron Eugene Stuart, Dwight Domenque Thompson, Gary Thompson, Shaun Van Den Boogaard, Alwyn willem Van Der Lith, Jeremy Richard Van Niekerk, Cornelis Van Niekerk, Cornelius Jacobus Venter, Jan Vliegenthart, Friedrich Hans Carl Freiherr Von Eckardstein, Dean Ivan Wallace, Warren Watkins, Mandy lynn Watson, Vanessa tracy Mans, Coenraad Hendrik Basson, Tanya Engels, Carolyn Boudina Chambers, Makgotso Letsitsi, Ugendran Moodley, Boitumelo Motumiseng Ngutshane, Jaques Johannes Pienaar, Heidi Volschenk, Kashmira Bhana, Martin Chvostek, Hanlie Dennis, Ivan Minnaar Engeles, Clasina Sophia Erasmus, Joelene Nicolette Perce, Imraan Jeewa, Eugene Quentin Pfister, Gary Martin Simms, Granville Craig Cole Smith, Tara-Lynn Smith, Oswold Theodore Wentworth, Abraham johannes Joubert Botha, Terence Grant Cheadle, Farouk Ebrahim, Nosisa Fubu, Alida louise Jordaan, Neil Gregory Morris, Marlene Pappas, Thinlemony Pather, Willem Sterrenberg Pretorius, Maureen senekal, Lance Maurice September, Mphikma Alfred Sithole, frans Jacobus Trigaardt, Antonio Miguel Gomes De Almeida Vicente, Tanja Ferreira, Modise Ishmael Maseng, Yasmeen Suliman, Zola Aubrey Beseti, Mark George Gardner Danckwerts, Zohra De Villiers, Nhlamulo Marcia Dlomu, Shamit Givind, Thomas Carel Gouws, Daniel Timothy Hooijer, Mohammed Younus Jada, Cuma Limekaya, Thato Matome Malakalaka, Farzanah Mall, Wayne Gerald Elton Pretorius, Neo Frangeni Shabalala, Delarey Kanfer, Riegert Gerhardus Stoltz, Premilla Devi Naidoo, Michael Grant Fortmann, Madelein Van Zyl, Kgomotso Vernon Monnakgotla, Malcolm Robert Jewell, Sipho Ndaba, Olivia Maria Makhetha, Heather Tracy De Jongh, Justin Michael Chait, Omera hylda Naiker, Werner Roetz, Kevin Shawn Hoff, Mahomed Riaz Muradmia, Heather Carswell, Candice Lee-Andra Padayachee, Heidi Lyn Streicher, Keshava Manosivan Naidu, Zaheer Wadee, Neelan Jina, Andrew Joseph Mckeaveney, Yacoob Jaffar, Vian Strydom, Melissa Joyce Duffy, Kamban Vythilingum, Giuseppina Aragona, Carel Albert Tecumseh Smit, Anthony Hugh Graham Wright, Pierre Johan Jacobs, Carmen Botha, Shirley Ivason-Wagener, Pieter Roy Naude, Bavhana Govender, Matsobane Frans Tleana, Safeera Mahomed Khan, Tamara Carol Isaacs, Lumkile Wiseman Nkhuhlu, Anna Francina Ramalho, Melanie Miller, Erina cooper, Mapoteng Ferdinand Mashaba, Martin John Vipond, Maria Van Der Valk, Jared Lyndon Mitri, Shandhir Anand Lachman, Nishen Bikhani, Derek John Vice, Shaaheen Tar-Mahomed, Breanda Koliwe Pumeza Jajula, |
Limco Qs Arbitration And Project Management |
Elre Van Der Walt |
Manto Management (Pty) Ltd |
John Gary Moonsammy |
Mark Manley Associates |
Mark Stevens Manley |
Mckinsey Incorporated |
Veronica Nomfanelo Magwentshu, Prakash Parbhoo, Georges Jean Pierre Desvaux, Tebogo Mapula Skwambane, |
MJ Acres Computer Consultants |
Not registered on the Central Supplier Database. |
MJ Mafunisa Consulting Pty Ltd |
John Mutuwafhetu Mafunisa |
Mogwariepa Consulting Cc |
Peter John Klynhans |
Mubesko Africa (Pty) Ltd |
Iaan gregory Morris, Martina De Kock, Nico johan De Cock, Russell Bryan Dick, Dylan Lester Strydom, |
Nexus Forensic Services Pty Ltd |
Werner bouwer, Francois Johannes Labuschagne, Mary-Anne Lizette Whittles |
Ngubane and Company (Johannesburg) Inc |
Zepi Thomas Brian Nkomo, Ephraem Sibanda, Nqabisa Ravele, Shaheen Mohamed Jogee, Marble Marvel Ndlovu, Edwin Tinashe Chapanduka, Nomathamsanqa Langelihle Ashom, |
Nkonki Incorporated |
Mitesh Mohanlal Patel, Thuto Margaret Masasa, Mzintsha Vizia Nkonki, Brian Mungofa, Nyarai Gamuchirai Margaret Muzarewetu, Kiran Bhika, Steven Ronald Firer, Sangeeta Ishwarlal Kallen, Yongama Madolo, Thetele Emmarancia Mashilwane, Ahmed mohammed Pandor |
Norton Rose Fulbright South Africa Inc |
Carina Van Vuuren, Shawn barnett, Zaida Sadrudine Kathrada, Murray Hudson Alexander, Gerrit Gauche Bouwer, Patrick Alan Bracher, Anthony John Chappel, Kevin Richard Cron, Michael Otto Dale, Brian Michael Denny, Alastair George Spencer Dixon, Jeffrey Maurice Kron, andrew Peter Moncrieff Robinson, Andrew Kenneth Strachan, Craig Woolley, Hugh Ian Bisset, Rohan Barry Isaacs, Malcom Charles Hartwell, Ross donald Ernest Lomax, Harmina Jeanette Janse Van Rensburg, Maria Mijatovic, Loris Rech, Marelise Van Der Westhuizen, Sibusiso William Mavela Gule, Aslam Abdul Samad Moosajee, Andre Pieter Vos, Liesel Kok, David Simon Kapelus, Jacqueline Ellen Midlane, Mohamed Chavoos, Elizabeth Johanna MC Caul, Karen Ainslie, Brent Etienne Botha, Pieter Hugo Niehaus, Likonelo Magagula, Georg Carl Kahle, Rosalind Elizabeth Lake, Sandra Sithole, Vanashree David, Stephen Leonard Chemaly, Christiana Costas, Sandile Senzo Khoza, Ismail Saied Hanif Laher, Christina Johanna Pretorius, Jason Glen Van Dijk, Douglas Spence Tatham, Lize Nadine Louw, Daniel Laurence MC Connell, Lizel Oberholzer, Deniro ravikumaran Pillay, Gary MacDonald Rademeyer, Verushka Reddy, Desiree Reddy, Caroline Katarina Theodosiou, Liesl Erica Williams, Johathan Jones, Stephen James Kenndy Good, Lee Anthony Astfalck, Wilhelmina Petronella Le Roux, Gregory Antony Nott, Heather Leigh Manson, Mark Philip Griffiths, Thato Reuben Seroto, Anton Pierre Schelhase, Lauren Fine, Andrea Patricia Keller, Jason John Whyte, Riccardo Peter Petersen, Raynold Tlhavani, Peter Edgcumbe Lamb, Daniel Robert Breier, Malibuye Dumani Cossie, Nicki-Ann Van't Riet, Richard Andrew De La Harpe, Isla Swart, Michael Bruce Mclaren |
Oxford Policy Management Limited |
Simon Paul Crisp Hunt, Kevin Carr |
PGE Brook |
Not registered on the Central Supplier Database. |
PricewaterhouseCoopers |
Stefan Maria Henri Beyers, Alexandra Muller, Johannes Jesaias Grove, Chantal Marais Roux, Chumani Sizwe Masondo, Tanya Rae, Deon Storm, Cornelis Tertius Van dijk, Zuhdi Abrahams, Lorka Kay Hayman, Brett Stephen Humphreys, Hendrik Jacobus Jansen Van Rensburg, Andrew Graham Taylor, Constantinos Natsaa, Gert Allen, Nezira Ayob, Steven Gayton Ball, John Paul Bennett, Tom Blok, Hein Boegman, Chris Jacobus Bredenhann, Isak Buys, BrendanMichael Deegan, Chantel Van Den Heever, Charles G De Wet, Nicolaas Hendrik Doman, JAmes Hart De Preez, Charl Petrus Du Toit, Anton Esterhuizen, Jacques Eybers, Desmond Robert Peter Fourie, Martha Maria Crafford, Ebenezer Johannes Gerryts, Hemant Narsai Govind, Johannes Friedrich Wilhelm Grosskopf, Stephanuss Grove, Cornelius Jocobus Hertzog , Pieter Constant Hough, Kishore Nagar Kooverjee, Charlotte Fay Lane, Jocobus Gideon Shin Louw, Daniel Gerhardus Malan, Peter Graeme MC Crystal, Pule Joseph Mothibe, Vasiliki Spirou Myburgh, Berno Waldemar Niebuhr, Hendrik Petrus Odendaal, Andries Johannes Oosthuizen, Rajainlall Dhanlall, Jan Frederik Daniel Labuschagne, Nishan Kemraj Pershad, Andrea Franco Puggia, Binesh Kumar Rajkaran, Navin Ramlagan, Harish Ramsumer, Johannes Lodewikus Roos, Louis Rossouw, Gerald Michael Seegers, Anita Stemmet, Louis strydom, Mark Henry Telfer, Fulvio Tonelli, Johannes Nicolaas Boshoff, Philip Johan Muller, Stefanus Beyers Botha, Etienne Van Niekerk, Jean-Pierre Van Staden, Simon Lawrence Venables, Linda Voges, Corlia Volschenk, Frans Hermanus Stephannus Weilbach, Anton Wentzel, Craig Richard West, Trevor Sean White, Verwey Wiese, John louis Wilinson, Millicent Loretta Williams, Hugo Zeelie, Hermanus Barend Zulch, Malcolm Neil Campbell, Ahmed Ebrahim Chohan, Leon De Wet, Alsue De Preez, Petrus Johannes Eksteen, Nicholas Johannes Ganz, Thomas Jacobus Howatt, Jean Anton Hugo, Rodney Duane Klute, Jakobus Frederick Michal Kotze, Shirley Livhuwani Machaba, Thomas Magill, Michael Meyer, Victor Muguto, Johan Potgieter, Frans frederik Prinsloo, Paul Phillip Prinsloo, Sharalene Francine Randelhoff, Johan Rudolph Van Huyssteen, Tertius Scholtz Bruwer, Kali Joseph Dikana, Jan Marthinus Groenewald, Marthinus Christof Hamman, Jacqueline Mary Mauer, Osman Mollagee, Kevan Moodley, Ian Olls, Peta-lynn Pope, Keeran Ramnarian, Andries jacobus Rossouw, Gert Odendaal, Keith David Ackerman, Duncan Andriaans, Jorge Manuel Goncalves, Ranesh Premlall Hariparsad, Nicolette Algene Jocobs, Francois Johannes Kruger, Mogamat Tape Marlie, Megandra Naidoo, Coenraad Richardson, Tebogo Dion Shango, Zubair Wadee, Pieter jacobus Crafford, Angus Virgill Du Preez, Viresh Parhotam Harri, Matthew David George Human, Suleman Haroon Jhavary, Dilshad Khalfey, Paul John liedeman, Kyle Eric Mandy, Jayshila Ramanlal Mistri, Asanda Myataza, Nqaba Ndiweni, Sibabalwe Nangamso Madikane, Bhimchand Soorajdin, Ndivhuwo Vincent Tshikhovhokhovho, Marthinus Jacobus Van Tonder, Sunette Williams, Pietro Calicchio, Gert Petrus Coetzee, Irwin Tech Lim AH Tock, Clinton Joseph Mitchelson, Ashwanth Rathan, Jacqueline Rossouw, Ryan david Stanham, Dewald Theo Van Den Berg, Pieter Du Preez Vermeulen, Irene Dulcie Allen, Brendan Stuart Carshagen, Barend Stephanus Eicker, Ryan Jethro Rodkin, Andrew John Calderwood Dale, Gary Berchowitz, Arno Van Wyk Bester, Karen Classen, Dawid De Jager, Shane Murugen, Robert Alexander Oudhof, Taruna Naidoo, Charl Du Toit, Busisiwe Sharon Mathe, Roshan Ramdhany, Solomon Pienaar Zietsman, Ncedisizwe Baba Thabang Mtetwa, Ebrahim Ahmed Saeed Mulla, Jabulani Steven Masondo, Julanie Basson, Yusuf Bismilla, Melanie Fivaz, dirk Hendrik Holl, Zulfah Solomons, Shenaaz Peer, Alwina Brand, Philani Jetro Maphanga, Muhammad ebrahim Chohan, Werner De Bruin, Craig Du Plessis, Shiraz Hassim, Nthato Makhetha, Alinah Maqueen Motaung, Martin Donald Siemers, Matome Anastacia Tshsane, Denis Balthasar Von Hoesslin, Herman Badenhorst Eksteen, Luyanda Mngadi, Maserame Marcia Mokone, Jacques Ettienne Muller, Fatima Rajah, Ricardo Jose Correia Rosa, Deaon Sarel Heydenrych, Gino Earl Fraser, Pravitha Deonarain, Lihor libero Spazzoli, Jayne Carol Rushton, GFrans Jacobus Murray, Wayne Errol Jansen, Wean Strydom, Ryan theophilus Adrew, erasmus Petrus Vermaak Bergh, Roeloff Alexander Botha, Jakobus Renier De Villiers, Renitha Koosialee, Mogamat Rashaad Fortune, Richard JAmes jocobs, Maria Sophia Labuschagne, Rika Mare labuschaigne, Laetitia Hough Le roux, Linda Pieterse, Langanani Mmbaiseni Rashamuse, Charles Alistair Stuart, Sharon Taylor, Natalie Terblanche |
Procurement Dynamics Pty Ltd |
Tjiamogale eric Manchidi |
Rede Engineering & Management Solutions |
Leslie Van Zyl-Smit, David Pieter Van Der Westhuijzen, Christiaan Francois Theron, pozisa Shumikazi Nkunzi, Johannes Hendricus Coetzee, Endlane Ashley Nyambi, Mpafana Deyi |
Regenesys Management Pty Ltd |
Marko Saravanja, Penelope Karen Law, William Tonas Vivian, Lebogang Reginald Kamohi, Sibongiseni Daniel Kumalo, Wayne Song, Richa Arora, Tshilidzi Ronald Nemukula |
Revworth Management Consultants Cc |
David Reevell |
S24 Business Group (Pty) Ltd |
Casisa Mutisi |
SBDS Construction Consultants Pty Ltd |
Leonardus Jacobus Messerschmidt, Stuart John Williamson |
Sekela Xabiso (Pty) Ltd |
Lindani Lorna Dhlamini, Pulafela Raymond Mokgalagadi, Zolile Abel Dlamini, Tlamelo Joshua Ramantsi, Thato Mahlamvu, Immaculate Balungile Phili, Zoliswa Portia Ntombela |
Siyakha Quantity Surveyors (Pty) Ltd |
John Bernard Dill, Timothy Mohlalefi Madisha, Joseph Sauders, Anet Nagel |
Sizwe Africa IT Group Pty Ltd |
Stephen phillip Naude, Hanno Van Dyk, Vukile charles Mehana, Sibongile Patricia Radebe, Minderd Spoelstra, Chih-Hsing Kan, Geraldine Melita Mokgethi |
SizweNtsalubaGobodo Advisory(Pty) Ltd |
Cynthia Ntombeningi Mbili, Altaf Fajandar, Darshen Govender, Alexandros Philippou, Natalie Roseline Arendse, Pieter Ignatius Du Plessis De Villiers, Pravesh Hiralall, Suleman Yusuf Lockhat, Dumisani Herbert Manana, Neridha Moodley, Selvin Dhanasagaran Moodley, Aaron Buyiswa Mthimunye, Mxolisi Wiseman Mthimkhulu, Anooshkumar Rooplal, Don Luthando Saunders, Victor Masitha Sekese, Nhlanhla Mfundo Sigasa, Donovan Andre Simpson, Pudula Collins Mashishi, Nkanyiso Percival Ngobese, Ronald Ncube,Agnes Gomolemo Dire, Yvonne Kgoedi, Nditsheni Dylan Tshithavhani, Lourenz Josephus De Jager, Dirk Johannes Fouche, Gulam Mohammed Hafiz, Pontsho Rethabiseng Nyathi, Ntshikelelo Mzamane, Adebukola Mutiat Adewuyi, Gerdileen Taylor, KhanyisaCingo, Yugendrin Pillay, Fana Allboy Manana, Mnwana Remington Kambule, Godfrey Itumeleng Serithi, Kudakwashe Charandura, Alfred Tawanda Sambaza, Azwinndini Stanley Magadani, Tumelo Tsotetsi, Deepak Dalpat Nagar, Ahmed Timol, Ebrahim Youssuf Lakhi, Robin Levisohn, Catherine Mae Tillard, Johannes Cornelus Blignaut, Ntokozo Busisiwe Mojapelo, Nico Costas Kryiancous, Phillipa Symington, Cornelis Van Niekerk |
SMEC South Africa (Pty) Ltd |
Nakedi Mathews phosa, Kresen Manicum, Tumelo Molope, Nyameka Mqikela, Konstantinos Rontris, Sri Hari Poologasundram |
Soma Initiative |
Douglas Carl Baard, Christopher David Shone, Lee-Ann Gloria Hector |
String Communication Cc |
Sarah Lucy Hetherington, Katharine Mary Mckenzie, Nishendra Moodley |
TMDG Consulting Pty Ltd |
Hastings Tambo |
Tshepega Engineering (Pty) Ltd |
Gerrit Jacobus Jordaan |
Tsubila Business Solutions Cc |
Sebonyane Paul Theletsane |
University Of Cape Town |
Rohithall Dharamdev |
University Of Johannesburg |
Jacobus Andries Van Schoor |
Waldo Consultants Cc |
Marirtjie Badenhorst, |
Yasmin Coovadia Development Consulting Pty Ltd |
Yasmin Yusuf Coovadia |
Young Blood Consultants |
Patrick Dennis Wilson, Johannes Hendrik Janse van Renburg |
Zenande Leadership (Pty) Ltd |
Pamela Bulelwa Yako, Ziyanda Yako, Sandiswa Sweetness Yako |
ZN Mncwango |
Nhlanhla Zanele Mncwango |
18 December 2018 - NW2753
Lees, Mr RA to ask the Minister of Finance
Whether any forensic investigations were conducted into the operations of the Financial and Fiscal Commission in the period 1 January 2014 to 30 June 2018; if so, what are the details of (a) the person(s) who conducted each forensic investigation, (b) the costs of conducting each forensic investigation, (c) each forensic investigation, (d) the reports produced for each forensic investigation, (e) the recommendations made in each report, (f) all action taken to implement the recommendations and (g) all disciplinary action taken against any person employed by the commission?
Reply:
Yes, one forensic investigation was conducted into the operations of the Financial and Fiscal Commission in the period 1 January 2014 to 30 June 2018.
a) The forensic investigation was conducted by the Special Audit Services of the National Treasury together with a private firm called Bowman Gilfillan.
b) The total forensic investigation fees paid by the National Treasury to Bowman Gilfillan amounted to R1,3 Million.
c) See b) above
d) One report on the Investigation into the allegation of fraud, corruption, fruitless and wasteful expenditure and maladministration at the Financial and Fiscal Commission was produced.
e) Recommendations contained in the report covered the following matters:
- Disciplinary action to be taken against employees
- Matters to be referred to law enforcement agencies to initiate criminal investigation
- Recovery of monies from the implicated employees.
f) (i) Disciplinary action has begun against affected employees. Two of the employees have resigned
(ii) Criminal matters were referred to the South African Police Services on 26 July 2017 by the National Treasury.
g) Recovery of monies process will be initiated once the disciplinary actions have been finalized
h) See( f) (i) above
18 December 2018 - NW3156
Dlamini, Mr MM to ask the Minister of Finance
With reference to the Minister of Energy’s reply to question 2344 on 15 October 2018, what (a) is the annual salary of a certain person (name furnished) and (b) are the relevant details of the time period of the specified person’s employment or contract?
Reply:
a) The annual salary of the indicated person is R3 812 280.00.
b) The official was appointed by the Development Bank of Southern Africa on 31 March 2016 on a three year contract which ends on 28 February 2019. Prior to that she was seconded to the IPP office by the National Treasury.
18 December 2018 - NW2826
Lees, Mr RA to ask the Minister of Finance
Whether the Independent Regulatory Board for Auditors (IRBA) received any reports of reportable irregularities, in terms of section 45 of the Auditing Profession Act, Act 26 of 2005, in respect of each major public entity as outlined in Schedule 2 of the Public Finance Management Act, Act 1 of 1999, since 3 August 2017; if not, why not; if so, (a) on what date was each report received, (b) what is the name of the auditor from which each such report was received, (c) what are the details of the matters addressed in each report and (e) what action was taken following receipt of each such report by the IRBA?
Reply:
The IRBA hereby declares that the following RI’s were declared to us:
IRBA Reference Number |
Public Entity |
Date of 1st RI report |
Date of 2nd RI report |
Name of Registered Auditor |
Firm |
Particulars of matters addressed in report |
Status of RI |
Action(s) undertaken by the IRBA - if any |
2018/0240 |
Eskom Pension and Provident Fund |
03-Aug-17 |
03-Aug-17 |
Clinton Mitchelson |
PWC |
A trustee shared confidential information that was solicited by the fund's Board with the trade union to which the said trustee is affiliated, which the fund alleged to be a breach of the fiduciary duties owed by the particular trustee to the fund. |
RI not continuing |
None |
2018/0429 |
Servcon Housing Solutions (Pty) Ltd |
16-Oct-17 |
15-Nov-17 |
NC Soopal |
Nexia SAB&T |
Annual financial statements for the financial years ending 31 March 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016 and 2017 have not been prepared |
RI continuing |
RI report onwards sent to the CIPC and to SARS. |
2018/0686 |
Eskom Holdings SOC Limited |
29-Nov-17 |
27-Dec-17 |
Aaron Mthimunye |
SNG |
RI involves multiple unlawful activities, including: |
RI continuing |
RI report onwards sent to the AG, the CIPC, the Department of Public Enterprises and the JSE. |
2019/0057 |
Eskom Holdings SOC Limited |
11-May-18 |
21-Jun-18 |
Aaron Mthimunye |
SNG |
RI involves multiple unlawful activities, including: |
RI continuing |
RI report onwards sent to the AG, CIPC, the Department of Public Enterprises, the JSE, the DPCI, the FIC and National Treasury. |
2019/0110 |
Eskom Finance Company SOC Limited |
04-Jun-18 |
03-Jul-18 |
K Hlajoane |
SNG |
CIPC records are outdated |
RI not continuing |
None |
2019/0111 |
Transnet SOC Limited |
04-Jun-18 |
04-Jul-18 |
Alex Philippou |
SNG |
Multiple instances of alleged unlawful activities involving contraventions of the PFMA, the Companies Act, Transnet's Procurement Procedure Manual, National Treasury Instruction Notes etc. |
RI continuing |
RI report onwards sent to the AG, CIPC, the Department of Public Enterprises, the JSE and National Treasury. |
2019/0232 |
Alexkor SOC Limited |
11-Jul-18 |
08-Aug-18 |
Luvo Mvinjwa |
SNG |
Multiple instances of alleged unlawful activities involving contraventions of the PFMA, the Companies Act, National Treasury Instruction Notes etc. |
RI continuing |
RI report onwards sent to the AG, CIPC, the Department of Public Enterprises and National Treasury. |
2019/0318 |
Transnet Ontspanningsklub Groeppensionfonds |
13-Aug-18 |
13-Aug-18 |
I Potgieter |
PKF |
Various statutory valuations for the fund are outstanding. |
RI continuing |
RI report onwards sent to the FSCA (old FSB) |
2019/0356 |
Trans-Caledon Tunnel Authority |
30-Aug-18 |
29-Sep-18 |
E van Rooyen |
E&Y |
A forensic investigation concluded that the selection of a particular contractor on a single-source base was flawed and that the CEO at the time was suspected of colluding with the said contractor. A criminal investigation was ongoing at the time of RI reporting and the contentious contract was cancelled. |
RI not continuing |
None |
18 December 2018 - NW2970
Lees, Mr RA to ask the Minister of Finance
What (a) is the total cost of legal expenses incurred by the Financial and Fiscal Commission (FFC) (i) in the 2017-18 financial year and (ii) since 1 April 2018, (b) percentage of the total expenses incurred by the FCC is constituted of legal expenses in each case and (c)(i) is the total number of cases, (ii) are the details of the legal matters covered in each case and (iii) is the total cost incurred for each case?
Reply:
(a) (i) The total cost of legal expenses during 2017-18 financial year amounted to R198 800
(ii) The total cost of legal expenses since 1 April 2018 amounted to R139 955
(b) Percentage of each case in 2017-18 financial year see below link:
http://pmg-assets.s3-website-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/RNW2970_Percentage_2017-18..pdf
Percentage of each case since 1 April 2018 see below link:
http://pmg-assets.s3-website-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/RNW2970_Percentage_2018-19.pdf
(c) (i) Total number of cases in 2017/18 financial year - 2
Total number of cases since 1 April 2018 – 1
(ii) All cases dealt with labour matters
(iii) Refer to table in b above
18 December 2018 - NW2945
Rawula, Mr T to ask the Minister of Finance
With reference to the reply to question 2494 on 9 October 2018, by what date will the payment to a certain person (name furnished) in recognition of life partnership application be finalised and (b) by what date will the specified person start receiving payment?
Reply:
The life partner was paid on the 7 September 2018, the monthly pension arrears and will receive a monthly pension on the 31st of every month.
18 December 2018 - NW2850
Mileham, Mr K to ask the Minister of Finance
(1)Whether the section 71 reports from any municipalities indicated that they had invested funds with VBS Mutual Bank, or any other mutual bank, prior to October 2016; if so, what are the relevant details; (2) in each case where such indications were found, was any action was taken by the National Treasury; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details in each case?
Reply:
1. Yes - As part of the quarterly Section 71 publications municipalities are required to submit the status of their investment register together with the detail of each investment made. These investment lists are published per municipality as part of the quarterly Section 71 results and can be accessed at:
http://mfma.treasury.gov.za/Media_Releases/s71/Pages/default.aspx
2. The Section 71 publication consists of the financial and conditional grant information of 257 municipalities. The publication also covers 21 different conditional grants and additional information in different dimensions to cater for a wide variety of stakeholders such as Parliament, Municipal councils, lenders, rating agencies and the general public. With respect to investments, municipalities reported on 2 563 investment instruments with various banks.
While the National Treasury collects, consolidates and publishes quarterly summaries in various financial dimensions for all municipalities, in terms of Section 151(3) of the Constitution, the municipal council remains the final accountable institution. This is to ensure that the information reported is used for management purposes and account to the respective municipal councils.
Considering the amount of data lines reported, the investments associated with the VBS Mutual Bank got absorbed in the national aggregation process. Section 13 of the MFMA empowers the Minister of Finance to prescribe a framework within which municipalities may, amongst others, invest money not immediately required. Such a framework was provided in the Municipal Investment Regulations which sets out a list of permitted investments municipalities may invest municipal funds. In terms of Regulation 6, municipalities may invest funds only in banks registered in terms of the Banks Act. The Venda Building Society Mutual Bank (VBS) is not registered under the Banks Act of 1990, it was never envisaged that municipalities (Municipal managers and CFOs) would deliberately break the law in their choices of where they invest. To address this issue, the National Treasury has now, as part of the mSCOA reform improved the reporting on investment information to only be linked to registered banks aligned to Regulation 6.
18 December 2018 - NW2849
Robertson, Mr K to ask the Minister of Finance
Whether the Government received the € 30 million pledged by the Kingdom of Belgium for land reform purposes; if not, what are the relevant details; if so, (a) for which land reform projects will the Government utilise the funds and (b) what amount in Rand did the Government receive from the pledged amount?
Reply:
In response to this question, it should be noted that the National Treasury has not been involved in any recent negotiation with the Kingdom of Belgium for further support within the land sector; no commitments for this sector have been discussed, negotiated or received from the Government has been to the amount €18 150 000M from 2004-2015 for land reform programmes in South Africa. These constituted three programmes managed by the then Department of Agriculture and Land Affairs and the current Department of Rural Development and Land Reform.
18 December 2018 - NW2825
Lees, Mr RA to ask the Minister of Finance
Whether the (a) foreign borrowing limits, (b) further foreign borrowing limits, (c) domestic borrowing limits and (d) further domestic borrowing limits were granted to any public entity (i) in the 2017-18 financial year and (ii) since 1 April 2018; if not, in each specified case, why not; if so, in each specified case, (aa) what is the name of the public entity, (bb) what was the value of the (aaa) foreign and/or domestic borrowing limit and (bbb) extension of the foreign and/or domestic borrowing limit and (cc) what is the current total foreign and/or domestic borrowing limit?
Reply:
(a), (b), (c) and (d)
In the 2017/18 financial year, foreign borrowing limits were granted to the Central Energy Fund (CEF), the Development Bank of Southern Africa (DBSA), Denel and Transnet.
- CEF’s foreign borrowing limit was for R3 billion and this is set to expire in the 2021/22 financial year. The foreign borrowing limit was for the holding company and its subsidiaries for working capital purposes given the high working capital requirements of the industry.
- DBSA’s foreign borrowing limit was for the entity to access more funds from foreign lenders to extend loans and advances in SA and the SADC region to execute its mandate of facilitating and supporting infrastructure development in Southern Africa. The amounts approved for the DBSA was R19.7 billion for the 2017/18 financial year, R22.6 billion for the 2018/19 financial year and R26 billion for the 2019/20 financial year.
- Denel’s foreign borrowing limit was approved at R535.3 million for the 2017/18 financial year, with the amount reducing by R100 million every year. The limit is valid for 3 years from the 2017/18 financial year. The approval for a foreign borrowing limit for Denel was to allow the company’s subsidiary (Denel Aerostructures) to continue executing a major contract given the high working capital requirements of the project.
- Transnet’s foreign borrowing limit was approved for 1 year up to 31 March 2019 for a total amount of R81 billion. The approval of the limit was to enable Transnet to execute its funding plan as proposed in its corporate plan to execute its market demand strategy, which entailed sourcing funds from domestic and foreign lenders.
Since 1 April 2018 up to 30 September 2018, Rand Water’s borrowing limit request (domestic and foreign) and Eskom’s foreign borrowing limit request were granted.
- Rand Water’s borrowing limit was approved to accommodate the high capital expenditure requirements over the next three years, which will be funded through internally generated cash and borrowings. The approved limit for Rand Water was for R6.3 billion for the 2018/19 financial year, R8.3 billion for the 2019/20 financial year and R11.6 billion for the 2020/21 financial year.
- Eskom’s foreign borrowing limit was granted to enable the company to raise debt for its capital expenditure programme and liquidity. Eskom’s foreign borrowing limit was granted for one financial year, expiring on 31 March 2019, for a total amount of R308 billion.
Since 1 April 2018, a borrowing authority and the corresponding limit was approved for the National Housing Finance Corporation (NHFC) for R450 million for the 2018/19 financial year, R351 million for the 2019/20 financial year and R331 million for the 2020/21 financial year. The application was approved for purposes of transferring liabilities (including borrowings) from the National Urban Reconstruction and Housing Agency (NURCHA) and the Rural Housing Loan Fund (RHLF) to NHFC to facilitate the merger of the three entities.
On 1 April 2018, South African Airways’ foreign borrowing limit request was rejected. In addition, Trans-Caledon Tunnel Authority’s (TCTA) borrowing limit for a project was rejected.
- SAA’s foreign borrowing limit was rejected due to the entity’s high debt levels, which are unsustainable. In the interest of prudent financial management, the request was reject. The amount requested was R18 billion.
- TCTA’s request for a borrowing limit on one of its projects (Berg River-Voelvlei Augmentation Scheme (BRVAS)) was rejected on the basis that more work needed to be undertaken by both the TCTA and the Department of Water and Sanitation in respect of preparatory work and the due diligence. The two parties were encouraged to finalise the preparatory work for National Treasury to consider the application again. The amount requested was R581 million.
Total borrowing limits and authority granted that are applicable for the 2018/19 financial year amount to R620.44 billion (please note that the Minister of Finance is only required to approve foreign borrowing limits in terms of the PFMA).
18 December 2018 - NW3071
Maynier, Mr D to ask the Minister of Finance
Whether an illicit economy unit has been and/or will be established in the SA Revenue Service; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
Reply:
The re-establishment of the Illicit Economy unit (IEU) at SARS is currently in progress and will be implemented in two phases. The 1st phase will be an interim IEU solution, which is scheduled to be functional by November 2018.
This two pronged approach to establish the specialized enforcement capability and capacity is being pursued, first an interim capacity and capability to immediately respond to the current illicit economic activities, and second, developing and implementing the organisational design to build the full functioning IEU of the future. Given the current limited capability and capacity, the focus of the Interim IEU relate to organised tax, Customs and Excise evasion schemes inter-alia in the following industries: Tobacco, Cash and Carry, Textiles, Alcohol and Fuel. In addition, abusive practices such as advanced import payments and currency smuggling, phoenixism, abusive liquidation and business rescue practices and Syndicated refund fraud, including organised VAT fraud such as carousel structures will also be addressed as per the IEU mandate.
Currently SARS have identified 58 potential cases that fall within the illicit IEU mandate. A new conceptual design and interim structure for the illicit economy Unit has been developed and approved.
The 2nd phase will involve the compete operationalisation of the IEU. The anticipated completion of the 2nd phase will be June 2019."
18 December 2018 - NW2897
Mulaudzi, Adv TE to ask the Minister of Finance
With reference to the reply to question 2495 on 4 October 2018, did any metropolitan municipality in the past five financial years outsource a function which was previously insourced; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, (a) what function was outsourced, (b) on what date, (c) to whom and (d) what was the total monetary value of the contract?
Reply:
According to the information at the disposal of National Treasury, the City of Tshwane Metropolitan Municipality is the only municipality that has outsourced a function which was previously insourced. The function outsourced is Waste Management Services and this has been outsourced for a period of more than five (5) years. The expenditure incurred is about R500 million per annum. This particular service is outsourced to a panel of contractors.
18 December 2018 - NW3087
Basson, Mr LJ to ask the Minister of Water and Sanitation
(1)Whether a certain person (name and details furnished) was placed on suspension because the specified person refused to allow other projects of his department to access the R12 billion fund of the unit of the specified person; if not, why was the specified person placed on suspension; if so, (2) whether he supports the suspension of the specified person based on the specified person’s refusal to allow other departmental projects to misappropriate funds from the specified person’s unit; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details; (3) whether he has taken any steps to prevent the units of his department from misappropriating funds from each other; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
Reply:
1. No.
2. Falls away.
3. Yes, compliance with the PFMA is encouraged by the Accounting Officer.
---00O00---
18 December 2018 - NW3061
Lees, Mr RA to ask the Minister of Finance
(1)Whether a certain official of the SA Revenue Services (Sars) was authorised to participate in an interview with the SA Broadcasting Corporation on 17 October 2018; if so, who authorised the specified person to participate in the specified interview; (2) whether the statements made by the person during the interview were authorised by the Commissioner of Sars; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details; (3) whether the statements made by the person during the interview are an accurate reflection of the status of the information technology (IT) systems at Sars; if not, (a) why are they not accurate and (b) what is the real status of Sars’ IT systems; (4) whether any disciplinary action has been instituted against the specified person due to the statements made during the interview; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
Reply:
1. The certain official was duly authorised by the Acting Commissioner of SARS to participate in the said interview. Aside from the Commissioner, Chief Officers comprise the top rung of SARS leadership. Historically, when the appointed Commissioner is unavailable, a Chief Officer is appointed to act as the Commissioner. A Chief Officer is expected to represent SARS at the highest levels, including at international events and in interviews with the media particularly when the subject matter falls within the Chief Officer’s mandate. The authority given by the Acting Commissioner was based on the understanding that a SARS Chief Officer and member of EXCO should be competent and able to fully address any matter of SARS culture, vision, strategy, policy and operations that arises in an interview and particularly when the issues relate to his/her portfolio of accountability.
2. Statements made by the SARS official during the interview were not authorised by the Commissioner of SARS in any event there are no means of ensuring that representations by SARS executives are approved by the Commissioner prior to any interview as interviews in their very nature are dynamic and not preemptive. Chief Officers of SARS are expected to be able to handle any matter relating to their area of accountability.
(3)(a) The statements made by the person during the interview did not describe the state of SARS IT and what is required to enhance the IT systems.
3(b) Although SARS IT systems are ageing and require continuous maintenance, they are currently stable, operative and serving our clients well. The SARS technical IT teams have the necessary skills to ensure we modernize our systems and SARS is committed to providing the required resources to enable us to eventually have the ideal technology offering. SARS is on record on the need to refresh its ageing ICT infrastructure and plans in this regard are underway.
(4) The contents of the interview have impacted on SARS and the issue of disciplinary proceedings is being considered. The most appropriate steps will be taken once a preliminary opinion has been formulated and formal discussions have taken place.
18 December 2018 - NW3058
McLoughlin, Mr AR to ask the Minister of Finance
(1)With reference to the Auditor-General’s latest Annual Report, how does the National Treasury intend to cover the budgetary shortfall that will be created by the proposed writing off of R58 million in unpaid audit fees; (2) does the National Treasury intend to obtain a refund of the sum of R150 million assistance to be provided to the Auditor-General (AG), from those municipalities who have failed to settle their audit accounts and which have caused the need for such assistance to be given to the AG; (3) whether he intends to set up some form of mediation committee to attempt to find resolutions in the cases where disputes arise between the AG and his auditees to prevent the unacceptable situation that ensues when two government departments or entities employ the services of private legal practitioners to argue their respective cases before the courts of the country, such as recently happened between the SA Revenue Service and the AG and the Department of Water and Sanitation and the AG; (4) (a) what has so far been the total cost to the AG’s office for all legal fees and disbursements relating to litigation conducted by auditees against the AG in each of the past five financial years and (b) to which firms of attorneys were these costs paid; (5) (a) on what legislative basis did he rely to settle the accounts of municipalities who owe the AG’s office unpaid audit fees and (b) does he intend to now also pay other debts owed by municipalities to other debtors from the National Revenue Fund?
Reply:
1. The Auditor-General (AGSA) accepted the National Treasury’s offer for a full and final settlement of the accumulated outstanding fees in terms of section 23(6) of the Public Audit Act (PAA), Act no.25 of 2004, as at 2017/18. The AGSA does not receive direct funding from the National Treasury and as such, the National Treasury will not cover any budgetary shortfall arising from the write-off of unpaid audit fees.
2. In terms of section 23(6) of PAA, if the audit fee exceeds one percent of the total current and capital expenditure of such an auditee for the financial year, such excess must be defrayed from the National Treasury’s vote, provided that, the National Treasury is of the view that the auditee has financial difficulty to settle the cost. This excludes national and provincial departments. Therefore, based on these provisions PAA above, the National Treasury does not intend obtaining a refund for the R150 million assistance given to the AGSA on behalf of the municipalities.
3. The National Treasury (NT) and AGSA has well documented dispute resolution mechanisms in place to deal with technical and accounting cases where an entity disagrees with an audit finding of the AGSA. A situation that is occurring more frequently is where the AG and NT agrees on a case, but the auditee refuses to accept the final resolution and continues to challenge both the final opinion of AGSA and NT. The NT agrees that in most cases, state funds should not be used to litigate against the audit opinions of the AGSA, as these cases can be solved in the normal process.
4. The National Treasury does not have the information available, these costs and legal firms used must be obtained from the individual departments and public entities that have pursued the legal action.
5. The National Treasury has since the effective date of the approval of the Public Audit Act, Act No. 25 of 2004 (PAA), been assisting with the payment of audit fees of applicable entities and municipalities that, based on the view of National Treasury, are in financial difficulty. These payments are done in accordance with section 23(6) of the PAA, and are only done for audit fees that exceeds one percent of the total current and capital expenditure of auditees in financial distress. It must be mentioned that National Treasury has a specific amount appropriated in the budget for settling audit fees of struggling entities. Unfortunately, the budgeted amount is not always adequate to cover all the amounts owed to the AGSA. For this reason, the National Treasury has put forward measures to improve the payment of outstanding audit fees for auditees in financial distress in the amendments to the Public Audit Act.
14 December 2018 - NW3899
Mulaudzi, Adv TE to ask the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services
Whether, with reference to the reply of the Minister of Public Service and Administration to question 141 for oral reply on 7 September 2018, his department and the entities reporting to him implemented the Public Service Coordinating Bargaining Council resolution that all persons employed in the Public Service as Assistant Directors must have their salary level upgraded from level 9 to level 10, and that all Deputy Directors must have their salary level upgraded from level 11 to level 12; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
Reply:
1. The Department of Justice and Constitutional Development implemented Resolution 3 of 2009. In implementing the Resolution, the Department confined itself to the condition set in paragraph 3.6.3 which deals with accelerated grade progression for salary levels 9-10 and 11-12 respectively. To this end, all employees from salary levels 9-10 and 11-12 who meet the below mentioned qualifying criteria are accordingly progressed/upgraded:
a) Twelve (12) years continuous service and should have at least obtained above satisfactory rating on his performance assessment; and
b) Fifteen (15) years of continuous service and should have at least obtained above satisfactory rating on his performance assessment
2. The National Prosecuting Authority implemented PSCBC Resolution 1 of 2012 in conjunction with the Department of Public Service and Administration (DPSA) Circular 16/P dated 25 February 2013. All posts that were filled on salary levels 9 and 11 after the implementation of PSCBC, Resolution 3 of 2009 were re-graded according to the DPSA’s Implementation Directive. All employees who occupied those posts were thus upgraded into the salary levels 10 and 12 respectively.
3. Employees of Legal Aid South Africa are not appointed under the Public Service Act, 1994 but are employed in terms of Legal Aid SA Act 39 of 2014. Persons who are employed at salary level 9 and those employed at salary level 11 can be progressed to salary level 10 and salary level 12 respectively subject to the scope of pay progression of the job grading of a position and on condition that an employee’s annual performance review is good and scored at 80% and above.
4. Neither PSCBC Resolution 3 of 2009 nor Resolution 1 of 2012 has been implemented in the Special Investigating Unit (SIU). The pay progression model being referred to is not in use in the SIU as the SIU has its own grading system in place.
14 December 2018 - NW3902
Tshwaku, Mr M to ask the Minister of Basic Education
Whether, with reference to the reply of the Minister of Public Service and Administration to question 141 for oral reply on 7 September 2018, her department and the entities reporting to her implemented the Public Service Coordinating Bargaining Council resolution that all persons employed in the Public Service as Assistant Directors must have their salary level upgraded from level 9 to level 10, and that all Deputy Directors must have their salary level upgraded from level 11 to level 12; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
Reply:
The Department of Basic Education has implemented the Public Service Co-ordinating Bargaining Council resolution for the upgrading of Assistant Directors from salary level 9 to salary level 10 and the upgrading of Deputy Directors from salary level 11 to salary level 12. The implementation was effected in August 2014 and backdated to 1 August 2012.
14 December 2018 - NW3745
Van Der Walt, Ms D to ask the Minister of Basic Education
(1)With regard to Limpopo Department of Education Contract No. EDDP 182/142, Lebaka B Primary School in Mohlabaneng, was the school built within the contract period of 3 November 2010 to 3 October 2011; if not, what are the relevant details; (2) (a) what was the total monetary cost of the building project, (b) who was the contractor and (c) was the contractor paid in full; (3) (a) what are the full details of the (i) total cost of the furniture and (ii) furnishings delivered and dates of delivery of all furnishings, (b) why has this school been abandoned, (c) on what date was a security company appointed, (d) what is the cost of the security contract and (e) what is the name of the security company; (4) has any litigation process been instituted; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
Reply:
1. The school was not completed within the envisioned construction period of 11 months. The contract period started on 3 November 2010 as scheduled, but unfortunately the contractor fell behind schedule. The delays led to the situation whereby the contractor subsequently abandoned site. The project was re-activated in 2016 and Practical Completion was achieved on 11 September 2017.
2. The initial contract amount was R 15 956 400.00. During the period when the contractor abandoned site the school was vandalised. Accordingly, when the project was re-activated, re-measurements were done to determine the cost to complete the project and a Variation Order was approved on 7 November 2016 increasing the contract amount to R 17 721 946.21. MPPJ Property Development was the Contractor. The contractor has not yet been paid in full as Final Completion has not yet been achieved.
3. (a) Total cost of Furniture is R930 491.000 and the furniture was delivered in 2012 and in 2018.
(b) Lebaka B was built as an offshoot of Lebaka A where the school buildings were dilapidated and no longer hospitable. Security was engaged and the repairs were effected. There are plans afoot to bring in Gr R –Gr 3 to the school in January 2019.
(c) The security company was appointed for Lebaka B School on 01 June 2018.
(d) The security service provider was initially appointed by the Limpopo Department of Education to do security services at Mamaila Circuit Office. A variation order was prepared and approved for the inclusion of Lebaka B School for an amount of R33 524.30 per month.
(e) Mathara Investment CC.
4. Yes, there is a litigation claim for the alleged exhumation of graves on the school site during the construction process. The matter is currently being handled by the state attorney.
14 December 2018 - NW3898
Mashabela, Ms N to ask the Minister of International Relations and Cooperation
Whether, with reference to the reply of the Minister of Public Service and Administration to question 141 for oral reply on 7 September 2018, her department and the entities reporting to her implemented the Public Service Coordinating Bargaining Council Resolution 3 of 2009 that all persons employed in the Public Service as Assistant Directors must have their salary level upgraded from level 9 to level 10, and that all Deputy Directors must have their salary level upgraded from level 11 to level 12; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
Reply:
Honourable Member, Clause 18.1 of PSCBC Resolution 1 of 2012 determines that; “clause 3.6.3.2 of PSCBC Resolution 3 of 2009 is hereby amended to allow employees whose posts are graded on salary levels 10 and 12; to be appointed and remunerated on salary levels 10 and 12 respectively”.
My department has informed me that it implemented Resolution 1 of 2012 and upgraded all employees serving in Assistant Director and Deputy Director posts in accordance with the grading system.
14 December 2018 - NW3740
Maynier, Mr D to ask the President of the Republic
(1)Whether he was made aware of the (a) attack on editors on social media and/or (b) meeting held with the SA National Editors Forum by the Minister of Finance, Mr T T Mboweni; if so, what is the position in this regard; (2) whether (a) he and/or (b) any person in his Office communicated (i) directly or (ii) indirectly with Mr T T Mboweni on this matter; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what are the relevant details in each case?
Reply:
(1) (a) No
(b) No. I am encouraged by the fact that the Minister of Finance reached out to the SA National Editors Forum and had a constructive discussion on matters that were of concern to both parties.
(2) (a) No
(b) No
14 December 2018 - NW3862
Mhlongo, Mr TW to ask the Minister of Women in ThePresidency
(1) Whether (a) her Office and/or (b) any entity reporting to her contracted the services of a certain company (name and details furnished), in each of the past 10 financial years; if so, what (i) number of contracts were signed, (ii) was the date on which each contract was signed, (iii) was the duration of each contract, (iv) services did the company render and (v) was the monetary value of each contract in each case; (2) whether any irregular expenditure relating to the contracts was recorded and/or condoned in each case; if so, what are the relevant details?
Reply:
14 December 2018 - NW3557
Mhlongo, Mr TW to ask the Minister of Sport and Recreation
(1 )With reference to her reply to question 2287 on 31 October 2018, did the Board of Athletics South Africa (ASA) follow a consultative process in issuing rule amendments to allow members of the Board to simultaneously serve as registered directors of the Nonprofit Company; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details; (2)whether ASA issues notices inviting comments from stakeholders before initiating amendments to its rules; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details; (3) do clubs belonging to ASA allow objections raised by its members to be minuted and recorded; (4)what are the details of ASA's mediation process for disciplinary hearings; (5)has ASA held a disciplinary hearing around the legal and procedural irregularities pointed out by a certain organisation (name furnished); if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?NW4133E
Reply:
The question by the he member has been forwarded to Athletics South Africa (ASA) for its response as it deals with operational details and internal institutional procedures of ASA.
MS. T. XASA, MP
MINISTER OF SPORT AND RECREATION
DATE:
14 December 2018 - NW3672
Alberts, Mr ADW to ask the Minister of Basic Education
(1) What number of schools in Gauteng in each year since 1 January 2014, (a) (i) were built and (ii) should have been built and (b) what are the relevant details for the specified results; (2) whether, if the results are negative, existing single-medium schools will be forced to include learners speaking other languages so that such schools will eventually become dual medium schools; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details?
Reply:
1. (a)(i) The table below indicates the number of planned schools and schools built since the 2014/15 financial year.
Financial Year |
Target |
Schools Built |
School Name |
2014/15 |
11 |
13 |
1. Munsieville Primary School 2. Iketleng Primary (Hammanskraal) School 3. Nellmapius Primary School 4. Phomolong Primary School 5. Oos Rand Secondary School 6. Buhle Park Primary School 7. Fochville Secondary School 8. Magaliesburg Secondary School 9. Freedom Park Secondary School 10. Naturena Primary No. 2 School 11. Slovoville Primary School 12. Imphendulo Primary School 13. Rosslyn Primary School |
2015/16 |
13 |
16 |
1. Chief A Luthuli Primary School No.2 2. Christiaanville (Montana Poort Primary School) 3. Doornkop (Obed Mosiane Primary School) 4. Etwatwa Primary School 5. Evans Park Primary School 6. Glen Vista Primary School 7. Kaalfontein Secondary School 8. Khutsong South Primary School 9. Mahareng Secondary School 10. Nellmapius Ext.6 Primary School 11. Palmridge Secondary School 12. Protea Glen Primary School 13. Ratanda Bertha Gxowa Primary School 14. Soshanguve East Secondary School 15. Soshanguve Primary School 16. Tswelapele (Andrew Mapheto Primary School) |
2016/17 |
13 |
08 |
1. Bophelong New Secondary School 2. Ga-Rankuwa Primary School 3. Mokone Marupeng Primary School 4. Moses Kotane Primary School 5. Nellmapius Secondary School 6. Nomzamo Madikizela Mandela Primary School 7. Sinenhlanhla Primary School 8. Wierdapark Primary School |
2017/18 |
05 |
06 |
1. Olievenhoutbosch Sec No.2/Seshegong Sec School 2. Everest Primary School 3. Menzi Primary school 4. Julius Sebolai Primary School 5. Marotola Primary School 6. Nokuthula Special School (LSEN school) |
(ii) Please see (i) above.
(b) The Department has a backlog in relation to the new and replacement schools, that is perpetuated by the constant influx of learners into the province. The Department has not achieved all its targets related to building schools, as indicated in (a) above, due to a number of reasons that have had an adverse impact on the delivery of schools. These include but not limited to:
• Budgetary Constraints;
• Under perfomance by contractors;
• Community disruptions; and
• Inclement weather.
2. The Department will not be forcing but engaging and encouraging the existing single-medium schools that have received a sufficiently large number of learner applications for admission, to offer additional languages and thereby become dual-medium schools. It must be noted that the process is guided by, amongst others, the number of applications to a school.
14 December 2018 - NW3895
Mulaudzi, Adv TE to ask the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services
With reference to his reply to question 3135 on 15 November 2018, (a) who are the interested parties that his department may further consult and (b) will further research be conducted; (2) will his department consult other government departments regarding the regulations; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details?
Reply:
1. (a) Various Constitutional Court cases have confirmed the principle that it is a constitutional imperative to facilitate public involvement in the legislative processes, which by implication includes the making of delegated legislation. If this important principle (which is sometimes referred to as participatory democracy), is not adhered to, the laws or regulations in question may be unconstitutional. Any proposed legislative proposal that gives effect to the South African Law Reform Commission Report on Adult Prostitution (Project 107) (the Report), will be subjected to a comprehensive and open public consultation process. By implication, all interested parties, who among others, will include organizations and establishments that represent persons involved in sex work as well as sex workers themselves, will be given an opportunity to raise their views. A public consultation process, because of its open and public character, ensures that everybody is given an equal opportunity to raise their views and acts as a counterweight to secret lobbying and influence-peddling.
(b) As indicated in the Reply to Question 3135, the Department is in the process of further researching aspects relevant to the Report in order to make legislative proposals that are best suited to our country.
2. The public consultation process discussed under paragraph (1)(a) above, will involve consultation with other Departments in the national, provincial and local sphere of Government due to the cross-cutting nature and implications of sex work. Any regulatory measure that deals with sex work and which may impact on the functions, resources or mandates of any other Department, will be drafted in consultation with the Department involved.
14 December 2018 - NW3876
Mokoena, Mr L to ask the Minister of Arts and Culture
What (a) number of (i) local music and (ii) art festivals have received funding from (aa) his department and/or (bb) entities reporting to him in each of the past five years, (b) was the name of each music and/or art festival and (c) amount did each receive in each case?
Reply:
In the past five years, my department has supported thirty five (35) Flagship Festivals and two hundred and thirty-eight (238) open call festivals.
The Entities reporting to my department, namely the National Arts Council supported fourteen (14) local music and art festivals.
The information below is a reflection of how we financially supported art festivals as well as amounts granted to each specified art festival.
1-a) Flagships
Name of festival |
Amount from 2014-2017 |
|
1 |
Marula Festival |
R8 000 000 |
2 |
Cape Town Carnival |
R10 000 000 |
3 |
Cape Town International Jazz Festival |
R40 259 000 |
4 |
Diamonds and Dorings Festival |
R8 000 000 |
5 |
Mine Dance Festival |
R3 000 000 |
6 |
Suiderooste fees |
R6 000 000 |
7 |
Sama Awards |
R 8 000 000 |
8 |
National Arts Festival |
R27 000 000 |
9 |
Ladysmith isicathamiya Festival |
R2 000 000 |
10 |
Okhahlamba |
R4 000 000 |
11 |
Ilembe Lifestyle Festival |
R6 000 000 |
12 |
Moretele Tribute Concert |
R7 000 000 |
13 |
Joy of Jazz |
R16, 500 000 |
14 |
Kalahari Desert Festival |
R6 000 000 |
15 |
Mpumalange Comes Alive |
R5 500 000 |
16 |
National Book Week |
R12 000 000 |
17 |
Taung Calabash |
R6 000 000 |
18 |
Indoni Youth Empowerment |
R38 000 000 |
19 |
Macufe Arts Festival |
R12 000 000 |
20 |
Buyel ekhaya |
R8 000 000 |
21 |
Gauteng Carnival ( Pale Ya Rona) |
R10 000 000 |
22 |
Mahika Mahikeng |
R7 000 000 |
23 |
Mapungubwe Arts Festival |
R10 000 000 |
24 |
Innibos |
R4 000 000 |
25 |
Moshito |
R15 500 000 |
26 |
Miami Winter Festival |
R11 540 000 |
27 |
Mbokodo Awards |
R15 000 000 |
28 |
SALA Awards |
R3 200 000 |
29 |
Tweede Nuwe Jaar |
R1 500 000 |
30 |
Go West |
R2 250 000 |
31 |
Jazz River Carnival |
R 2 250 000 |
32 |
Isinqisethu Cultural Festival |
R2 000 000 |
33 |
PE Opera House |
R4 000 000 |
34 |
Mpumalanga Cultural Experience |
R2 000 000 |
35 |
Discop |
R10 000 000 |
(1-b) Open Call projects
No. |
Event / Project Name |
Beneficiary |
Location / Municipality/ City /Town |
Province |
Total Grant Value |
2014/15 |
|||||
1 |
The Alfred Nzo Choral Festival |
Lint Industries T/A Lint Foods (Pty) Ltd: |
Umtata |
Eastern Cape |
R 1 000,000.00 |
2 |
Creative Arts talent: It’s our Art Conference |
Digimap Media Global PTY LTD/ T/A |
Qwaqwa |
Free State |
R500 000.00 |
3 |
Youth with Disability Development Arts and Culture |
Sechaba Advancement Enterprise PTY LTD: |
City of Johnnesburg |
Gauteng |
R300 000.00 |
4 |
Mzansi traditional and Cultural shows |
Ukhamba Communications PTY LTD: |
Soweto |
Gauteng |
R400 000.00 |
5 |
Siyafunda and training development |
Teboho Le Teboho Initiatives PTY LTD: |
Ekurhuleni |
Gauteng |
R150 000.00 |
6 |
The Secret |
Sibusisiwe Commuity Development PTY LTD: |
Ekurhuleni |
Gauteng |
R300 000.00 |
7 |
Two world apart |
Bala Brothers Productions PTY LTD: |
Durban |
Gauteng |
R800 000.00 |
8 |
Qhakaza Nathi Fashion Development Project |
SarageB Gal Fashion (PTY) LTD: |
Ethekwini |
Kwa-Zulu Natal |
R900 000.00 |
9 |
The Uzalo choir experience |
Stained Glass Productions (PTY) LTD: |
EThekwini Municipality |
Kwa-Zulu Natal |
R250 000.00 |
10 |
Bom Gospel Talent Search |
Bao Music Business Learnership CC: |
East London |
Kwa-Zulu Natal |
R750 000.00 |
11 |
Reggae Picnic festival |
Milla Communications CC: |
City of Johannesburg |
Eastern Cape |
R950 000.00 |
12 |
National Professional Choirs League |
National Professional Choirs League CC: |
East London |
Gauteng |
R300 000.00 |
13 |
Inhalanga Cultural Moods |
Keraway Investment CC: |
Eastern |
Gauteng |
R500 000.00 |
14 |
Blouberg Annual Festivals |
Mak Herp cc: |
Bloeberg |
Limpopo |
R800 000.00 |
15 |
Hihlurile Pot of Beads Exhibition |
Hihlurile Pot of Beads CC: |
Giyani |
Kwa-Zulu Natal |
R800 000.00 |
16 |
Vhuthihi African Music Extravaganza |
Contimental Entertainment CC: |
Vhembe |
Limpopo |
R600 000.00 |
17 |
Arts and Music live experience |
Rebone Brand Creation CC: |
Welkom |
Limpopo |
R800 000.00 |
18 |
Mzansi Raggae Unite |
Lioness Productions SA CC: |
City of Johannesburg |
Limpopo |
R700 000.00 |
19 |
Developing Young Film Makers |
The Ergo Company CC: |
City of Johannesburg |
Free State |
R500 000.00 |
20 |
Mamelodi Rondavels Campus |
Izipho Zethu Zezobuciko Arts CC: |
Mamelodi |
Gauteng |
R300 000.00 |
21 |
International Workers Day (May Day) Commemorations |
Splendor Trading and Projects CC: |
Johannesburg |
Gauteng |
R1 000 000.00 |
22 |
Project of the Year |
Zero to Hero Theatre production NPO: |
Johannesburg |
Gauteng |
R300 000.00 |
23 |
Performing arts development project |
Publik Kreativity Drama Krew NPO: |
Johannesburg |
Gauteng |
R600 000.00 |
24 |
Colour me human |
Colour me human NPC: |
City of Johannesburg |
Gauteng |
R350 000.00 |
25 |
Xibelani Music Festival |
Kenny Shibambu Talent Development Institute NPO: |
Giyani |
Limpopo |
R950 000.00 |
26 |
Soulbent Day Drama and Cultural Dance Show |
Soulbent Project NPO: |
Makhado/Tshiodzwe |
Limpopo |
R700 000.00 |
27 |
Swilombe Music Association |
Swilombe Music Association NPO: |
Giyani |
Limpopo |
R500 000.00 |
28 |
Performing Arts Workshop and Festivals |
Factory of the Arts and Production NPO: |
Siyabuswa |
Mpumalanga |
R180 000.00 |
29 |
Cape Town TV Arts Desk |
Cater bridge Music Academy NPI: |
Cape Town |
Mpumalanga |
R500 000.00 |
30 |
Ixopo Indigenous Dance and Music Festival |
Cape Town TV, Represented by Workers World Media Productions NPO: |
Khayelitsha |
Western Cape |
R300 000.00 |
31 |
Afrika Rize Reggae Festival |
Unyezi Theatre Organisation NPO: |
Richardsbay |
Kwa-Zulu Natal |
R00 000.00 |
32 |
Love and Hope Africa Gospel Music Festival |
Qhawes Entertainment Group NPO: |
Nkowankowa |
Limpopo |
R900 000.00 |
33 |
African Youth Theatre & Dance Festival |
To The Throne Music Production NPO: |
Cape Town |
Western Cape |
R400 000.00 |
34 |
Iqonga Creative Productions |
Assitej South Africa NPO: |
Cape Town |
Western Cape |
R400 000.00 |
35 |
BASA business breakfast and engagement in Mozambique |
Rainbow Arts Organisation NPO: |
Mozambique |
Gauteng |
R60 000.00 |
36 |
Paarl Festival |
Business and Arts SA Institution: |
Paarl |
Western Cape |
R800 000.00 |
37 |
Eden International Youth Festival & Exchange |
Enklyve Media Investments Section 21: |
City of Cape Town |
Western Cape |
R800 000.00 |
38 |
Building Creative and Cultural Entrepreneurs |
Kaos Projects T/A Suff Academy- Section 21 Film+Media&Arts: |
City of Cape Town |
Western Cape |
R700 000.00 |
39 |
3rd African Women Writers Symposium |
African Arts Institute Section 21: |
Johannesburg |
Western Cape |
R800 000.00 |
40 |
Beautiful Land |
Joburg city Theatres: |
Johannesburg |
Gauteng |
R200 000.00 |
41 |
Makgalakwena Cultural Dance Festival |
Malose Samuel Rasito: |
Polokwane |
Limpopo |
R250 000.00 |
2015/16 |
|||||
42 |
Annual Isi-Xhosa Music Festival |
Impact Leisure Investment (Pty) Ltd |
Buffalo City |
Eastern Cape |
R500 000.00 |
43 |
Eastern Cape Fashion Festival |
Elitt Technology Solutions (pty) Ltd |
Buffalo City |
Eastern Cape |
R750 500.00 |
44 |
Oppikoppi Festival |
Hillop Live performance promotions PTY LTD |
Johannesburg |
Limpopo |
R700 000.00 |
45 |
Madiba the African Opera |
Opera South Africa PTY LTD |
Lesedi municipality |
Gauteng |
R1 000 000.00 |
46 |
Anual Hlanganani and Traditional Music and Arts celebration |
Kincha Media PTY LTD |
Thulamahashe |
Mpumalanga |
R700 000.00 |
47 |
Summer Music Explosion |
MJM Promotions: PYT LTD |
Francis Baard |
Northern Cape |
R500 000.00 |
48 |
Nayanaya Pictures |
Nayanaya Pictures |
Chris Hani District |
Gauteng |
R900 000.00 |
49 |
Igqophamlando Multi-cultural traditional music festival and craft exhibition |
Ngqobhongqobho Contractors |
Nquthu |
Kwazulu-Natal |
R500 000.00 |
50 |
Ubuntu International Reggae Festival "Africa salute" |
Mosadi Mooka Empowerment Services CC |
Buffalo City |
Eastern Cape |
R400 000.00 |
51 |
Annual Ebubeleni Music Festival |
Mahambehlala Communications CC |
Nelson Mandela Bay |
Eastern Cape |
R800 000.00 |
52 |
A new Song |
Village Gossip Foudation CC |
Johannesburg |
Gauteng |
R500 000.00 |
53 |
Limpopo Royal Heritage Week |
Tsalena Media CC |
Thulamela |
Limpopo |
R800 000.00 |
54 |
Esiqelini Annual Cultural Event |
Masibonisanenisonke trading and Projects27CC |
JS Moroka |
Mpumalanga |
R700 000.00 |
55 |
Umthayi Marula festival |
Courtecy Marketing Services |
Ethekwini Municipality |
Kwazulu-Natal |
R800 000.00 |
56 |
Conference + Festival to bring together Africa's film sector leaders in South Africa 2015 and Cann |
Martin Cuff Consultancy |
City of Cape Town |
Western Cape |
R700 000.00 |
57 |
Moving Performing Arts |
Reliable Knowledge Theatre Club CC |
Dr Ruth Segomotsi |
Northwest |
R500 000.00 |
58 |
Camp and concerts |
Moribo Music development promotions NPO |
Johannesburg |
Gauteng |
R500 000.00 |
59 |
Mzansi Reggae Splash |
Zmele NPO |
Johannesburg |
Gauteng |
R300 000.00 |
60 |
Bohlabela School of Art Festival |
Tswelopele Performing Arts NPO |
Johannesburg |
Gauteng |
R200 000.00 |
61 |
Dance Umbrella festival 2016 |
Dance Forum NPO |
Johannesburg |
Gauteng |
R800 000.00 |
62 |
Azishe! Festival |
Jazzart Dance Theatre |
City of Cape Town |
Western Cape |
R400 000.00 |
63 |
South African Book Fair |
Publishers Association of South Africa |
City of Cape Town |
Western Cape |
R500 000.00 |
64 |
The Delft Big Band |
The Delft Big Band |
City of Cape Town |
Western Cape |
R300 000.00 |
65 |
4th Iternational Marimba and Stelpam festival |
Education Africa Section 21 |
Johannesburg |
Gauteng |
R400 000.00 |
66 |
Nthiyeng Martha Mabote |
N.M Mabote Craft & Development |
Johannesburg |
Gauteng |
R100 000.00 |
67 |
Mpho Ngwenya (individual) |
Funology |
Johannesburg |
Gauteng |
R300 000.00 |
68 |
Pulane Jantjies: Individual |
Matlakala |
Sol Plaatjie |
Northern Cape |
R250 000.00 |
2016/17 |
|||||
70 |
Sistaz With Soul |
Mkhonzeni tradings |
Ethekwini municipality |
KwaZulu Natal |
R500 000.00 |
71 |
Phuzushukela memorial Festival |
Mkhosi Busa |
Nkandla Local Municipality |
KwaZulu Natal |
R1 970 000.00 |
72 |
Ugu Jazz festival |
Cyassonnd Events management |
Ugu |
KwaZulu Natal |
R1 000 000.00 |
73 |
Umthayi marula Festival |
Courtesy Marketing services |
Ethekwini municipality |
Kwa Zulu Natal |
R800 000.00 |
74 |
The Pietermaritzburg Jazz festival |
Starlight Promotions |
Umgungundlovu - Msunduzi Municipality |
KwaZulu Natal |
R500 000.00 |
75 |
Rofhiwa annual Star Search |
Asikulibali Trading and Projects |
Vhembe Municipality |
Limpopo |
R400 000.00 |
75 |
Ke Nna Polelo |
Lamem Trading |
Capricorn Municipality |
R300 000.00 |
|
76 |
African Fashion & Cultural Exhibition (AFACE) |
Roti Enterprise |
Makhado Municipality |
Limpopo |
R 400 000.00 |
77 |
Royal Heritage Celebration |
Tsalena Media |
Vhembe District |
Limpopo |
R800 000.00 |
78 |
Venda Nga |
The Branding House South Africa |
Vhembe District |
Limpopo |
R500 000.00 |
79 |
Esiqelini Annual Cultural event |
Masibonisane Sonke Trading and Project |
MPUMALANGA |
R500 000.00 |
|
80 |
7th Annual Mdantsane Summer Reunion |
Loudnoise Entertainment |
Buffalo City Metropolitan Municipality |
Eastern Cape |
R300 000.00 |
81 |
Abadala Music Festival |
Damilos MP |
OR Tambo District Municipality |
Eastern Cape |
R750 000.00 |
82 |
Annual O.R Tambo Homage Concert |
Win-Always Projects |
Mbizana Local Municipality |
Eastern Cape |
R550 000.00 |
83 |
Buyelembo Arts Festival |
Buyelembo Village |
City of CapeTown |
Western Cape |
R150 000.00 |
84 |
Mafube Arts Festival |
Sastown Entertainment |
Mafube Local Municipality |
Free Sate |
R500 000.00 |
85 |
Mapungubultural Landscape & Heritage Music Project - Limpopo |
Makotopong Sound Studios |
Limpopo |
Limpopo |
R700 000.00 |
86 |
Speak the Mind Festival |
LNM Entertainment |
Johannesburg Metro |
Gauteng |
R300 000.00 |
87 |
The KwaNdebele Cultural Imbizo |
Kushanda Consulting |
Bronkhorspruit |
Mpumalanga |
R500 000.00 |
88 |
Yanaya Gender Film and Dialogue Festival |
Nayanaya Pictures |
Ethekwini |
KwaZulu Natal |
R500 000.00 |
89 |
Abantu Book |
Abantu Book Festival |
Joburg Metro |
Gauteng |
R500 000.00 |
90 |
4th Annual Hlanganani Traditional Music and Arts Celebration |
Kincha Media |
Ekurhuleni |
Gauteng |
R700 000.00 |
91 |
100% Pure Kwaito |
Zuztainment |
City of Tshwane Metropolitan Municipality |
Gauteng |
R500 000.00 |
92 |
Graduate Arts Project (GAP) |
DOS Productions |
City of Tshwane |
Gauteng |
R800 000.00 |
93 |
Tshwane Fashion Project |
Black Plum Corporate Enterprise T/A Plum Creative Agency |
City of Tshwane (Pretoria) |
Gauteng |
R500 000.00 |
94 |
W.O.M.A.N experential Art Event |
Brainbow Consciences Creatives |
City of Johannesburg (Down Town) |
Gauteng |
R500 000.00 |
95 |
Creative Mzansi |
Target Expresss Computers T/A Morning Star Design |
City of Joburg (Market Theatre) |
Gauteng |
R300 000.00 |
96 |
Ukuhlanganisa - Trolley Pushers |
M and Z Theatre Productions |
Alexandra |
Gauteng |
R131 400.00 |
97 |
Saadjies: A flagship Cool Capital |
Cool Captain (implementation agent Mathews and Associates Architects) |
University of Pretoria |
Gauteng |
R300 000.00 |
98 |
Arts and Social Enterpreneurship Conference |
Grow Khula Multimedia Productions |
Durban |
KwaZulu Natal |
R500 000.00 |
99 |
Milodi Arts and Culture Festival |
Cybrobrite |
Jane Furse |
Limpopo |
R500 000.00 |
100 |
Seetseng Arts and Culture |
We- Dia Productions |
Modimolle |
Limpopo |
R500 000.00 |
101 |
Royal Night and Heritage Celebration |
Bold Move Foundation |
Polokwane |
Limpopo |
R300 000.00 |
102 |
Tshivenda Music Awards |
Dengetenge Marketing and Communications |
Vhembe District Municipality |
Limpopo |
R500 000.00 |
103 |
Munghana Lonene FM Xitsonga Music Awards |
GY Promotions |
Mopani District/ Greater Giyani Local Municipality |
Limpopo |
R500 000.00 |
104 |
Mayibuye Cultural Festival |
Mamba Investments cc |
Umlazi |
KwaZulu Natal |
R500 000.00 |
105 |
Annual Cultural Lifestyle Festival |
Grass Roots Music Productions cc |
Arconhoek |
Mpumalanga |
R900 000.00 |
106 |
Africa Converse |
Multi Minds Investments Holdings |
Ethekwini |
KwaZulu Natal |
R700 000.00 |
107 |
Africa Heritage Week |
African Business Leaders Forum |
Maboneng |
Gauteng |
R600 000.00 |
108 |
Dance Africa Dance |
Vision Faces |
Umlazi |
KwaZulu Natal |
R700 000.00 |
109 |
Traditional Fashion Show |
Lick'o Propeties |
Buffalo City |
Eastern Cape |
R 500 000.00 |
110 |
Just Chillin presents the September Issue |
Tshokoma Enterprise |
City of Tshwane |
Gauteng |
R500 000.00 |
111 |
Hello Summer Uitenhage Festival |
Stage Elements cc |
Uitenhage |
Eastern Cape |
R750 000.00 |
112 |
Melting Pot Arts Festival |
GCIE Communications |
Mount Ayliff |
Eastern Cape |
R1 500 000.00 |
113 |
The Segopotso Project |
Mehlo-Maya-(Eye to the Sun) |
Mangaung Municipality |
Free State |
R750 000.00 |
114 |
Africa Day and Xitsonga music festival |
Swilombe Music Association |
Thabo Mafutsanyane District |
Limpopo |
R500 000.00 |
115 |
Lejweleputswa Music Festival |
Ntho Ya Kasi Entertainment |
Ethekwini |
KwaZulu Natal |
R1 000 000.00 |
116 |
Matsoara Thebe Senior Citizens Co-operative. |
Matsoara Thebe Senior Citizens Co-operative |
Rustenburg Local Municipality |
NorthWest |
R133 000.00 |
117 |
Maskandi African Mix Festival 28 May 2016 |
Unique PR and Events |
Klerksdorp |
NorthWest |
R800 000.00 |
118 |
Africa unite Reggae Festival0 |
Bantu Media Production |
Nelson Mandela Bay Municipilaty |
Eastern Cape |
R400 000.00 |
119 |
Kopano Music Festival |
WMJ Productions and Events |
Dutywa |
Eastern Cape |
R900 000.00 |
110 |
Disabled Community Empowerment Initiative |
Southern African Disabled Musicians Association |
Nelson Mandela bay Metro |
Eastern Cape |
R750 000.00 |
111 |
Taleni Cultural Festival |
Taleni Cultural Festival |
City of Johannesburg |
Gauteng |
R400 000.00 |
112 |
Masibambane Music Festival |
Nobadula Trading Enterprise |
Buffalo City |
Eastern Cape |
R1 000 000.00 |
113 |
2nd Annual Motswako Fest |
Gateway Media PTY(LTD) |
Rustenburg |
NorthWest |
R1 000 000.00 |
114 |
Mtubatuba Youth Celebrations Arts Festival |
Isigqi Arts Development |
Umkhanyokude District municipality |
KwaZulu Natal |
R200 000.00 |
115 |
Imbokodo Arts Festival |
Nquthu Arts Development Programme |
Nquthu Local municipality |
KwaZulu Natal |
R300 000.00 |
116 |
Rural Women Empowerment Festival |
Dannhauser Active Rural Women Ensemble |
Amajuba district |
KwaZulu Natal |
R400 000.00 |
117 |
Isicathamiya Revival Festival |
Ladysmith Youth development Ensemble |
Umnambithi Municipality |
KwaZulu Natal |
R150 000.00 |
118 |
Musina Cultural Heritage Festival |
Limpopo Arts & Culture Youth Forum |
Vhembe Municipality |
Limpopo |
R500 000.00 |
119 |
Xibelani Music Festival |
Kenny Shibambu Talent Development Institute |
Mopani Distirct |
Limpopo |
R900 000.00 |
120 |
Masase |
Soulbent Project |
Makhado Municipality |
Limpopo |
R500 000.00 |
121 |
FOTAAP Performing Arts Festival |
The Factory of arts and production |
Kwandebele |
Mpumalanga |
R100 000.00 |
122 |
Words of wings Annual Storry Telling Maskandi festival |
Calabash Storytellers |
Calabash |
R300 000.00 |
|
123 |
Woodstock Live |
Kaggen Music And Film Trust |
City of Cape Town |
Western Cape |
R500 000.00 |
124 |
Bloekombos Arts and Culture Festival |
South African Youth Council |
City of Cape Town |
Western Cape |
R400 000.00 |
125 |
TE Radebe Arts Alive |
TE Radebe Theatre Production Free State |
Provincial |
R150 000.00 |
|
126 |
Access Art - 1 June 2016 - 1 June 2017 nationwide |
Shekinah Media (Pty) Ltd |
Joburg Metro |
Gauteng |
R2 000 000.00 |
127 |
Kusina Kudedelwane Cultural Festival - Gorton Hall, Estcourt |
Izigi Zendoda Sport & Culture Group |
Joburg Metro |
Gauteng |
R300 000.00 |
128 |
Mpumalanga Come Alive Theatre Development Project |
Publik Kreativeity Drama Krew |
Joburg Metro |
Gauteng |
R500 000.00 |
129 |
Artists Preserving Heritage Festival - 5-25 September 2016 Johannesburg |
Alexandra Youth in Action Ensemble |
Alexandra |
Gauteng |
R500 000.00 |
130 |
Dundee Battlefields Carnival 23-24 September 2016 - Dundee |
Doz Holdings |
Joburg Metro |
Gauteng |
R700 000.00 |
131 |
Neo Motsatse the Concert 2016 - 21 June to 10 July 2016 - National Arts Festival |
Fezeka Motsatse Activations (FMA) |
Joburg Metro |
Gauteng |
R300 000.00 |
132 |
5th International Women's Theatre Festival |
Olive Tree Theatre Productions |
City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality |
Gauteng |
R350 000.00 |
133 |
Mams Arts Festival |
Lamathonsi Entertainment |
City of Tshwane |
Gauteng |
R700 000.00 |
134 |
Dance Umbrella Festival |
Dance Forum |
City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality |
Gauteng |
R800 000.00 |
135 |
The Divas of Kofifi |
Phambili Siyaya Arts |
City of Johannesburg |
Gauteng |
R1 000 000.00 |
136 |
Digitizing the Soweto '76 & 1956 Woman March Books. |
Mutloatse Arts Heritage |
City of Johannesburg |
Gauteng |
R100 000.00 |
137 |
Naledi Theatre Awards |
The Naledi Theatre Awards |
Various Theatres |
Gauteng |
R500 000.00 |
138 |
Mabi Gabriel Thobejane with Madala Kunene & Trio SaRoy |
Forest Jam South Africa |
Umlazi |
KwaZulu Natal |
R500 000.00 |
2017/18 |
|||||
139 |
Mindset Concept Production House |
Africa Television Market |
Ethekwini Municipality |
KwaZulu Natal |
R500 000 |
140 |
One Foundation |
Eagle Eye Creative Project |
Rusternburg Local Municipality |
North West |
R350 000 |
141 |
Malengs Trading |
Mpumalanga Fashion and Craft Show |
Mbombela |
Mpumalanga |
R400 000 |
142 |
Blaq Maci's PR |
"Your rights" Music Festival |
Buffalo City |
Eastern Cape |
R600 000 |
143 |
Patben Projects |
Patben Projects |
City of Cape Town |
Western Cape |
R300 000 |
144 |
Dikgong Arts & Décor |
Art & Craft Design Exhibition Project |
Mgaka Modiri Molema |
North West |
R403 000 |
150 |
One Heart Music and Television Promotions |
Reggae Xplosion - State Theatre |
City of Tshwane |
Gauteng |
R600 000 |
151 |
AAA Entertainment |
Digital Market Access |
City of Johannesburg |
Gauteng |
R500 000 |
152 |
Fuse Africa Group |
Johannesburg Reggae Splash |
City of Johannesburg |
Gauteng |
R100 000 |
153 |
Lovemore ndou Tainments |
The Annual Tshwane Regional Dance |
City of Tshwane |
Gauteng |
R500 000 |
154 |
Durban Black Drifters |
15th High School Isicathamiya Summit |
Ethekwini Municipality |
KwaZulu Natal |
R300 000 |
155 |
Bagaka Ba Koma Dance Troupe |
Performing Arts Annual Youth Festival |
Ratlou Local Municipality |
North West |
R108 800 |
156 |
Tiego Creative Writers |
Tiego Creative Writers |
Lepelle Nkumpi Municipality |
Limpopo |
R100 000 |
157 |
Ditswantsho Zwifaniso Film |
Makhado Literary Fair |
Vhembe District |
Limpopo |
R200 000 |
158 |
Amatjathangubo Youth Arts and Culture Music Centre |
Fumana Ilemuko Skills Development |
Thembisile Hani |
R500 000 |
|
159 |
Komani Independent Artists |
Women who art in Crafts |
Chris Hani Queenstown |
Eastern Cape |
R300 000 |
160 |
Proud Youth South Africa |
KwaNxamalala Annual Heritage Celebrations |
Mthatha |
Kwazulu Natal |
R300 000 |
161 |
Team Community Development Centre |
Phaphama Cultural Events |
Buffalo City |
Eastern Cape |
R380 200 |
162 |
The Delft Big Band |
Gauteng Big Band Festival |
City of Johannesburg |
Gauteng |
R250 000 |
163 |
Forest Jam South Africa |
Mabi Gabriel Thobejane with Madala Kunene & Trio SaRoy |
Ethekwini |
KwaZulu Natal |
R500 000 |
164 |
Pule Mqhedlane |
Kopanang ma Africa Annual Youth Theatre Festival |
Bothaville |
Gauteng |
R200 000 |
165 |
Mr Israel Lebogo |
Now or Never |
City of Johannesburg |
Gauteng |
R250 000 |
167 |
CACPIR |
Boundless Africa: Heritage in Motion |
City of Johannesburg |
Gauteng |
R600 000 |
168 |
Accatones Vocal Blend Co-operative Limited |
31 Days - A Musical |
Mmabatho |
North West |
R150 000.00 |
169 |
Cyassound Holdings PTY LTD |
UGU Jazz Festival |
UGU District Municipality |
KwaZulu Natal |
R800 000 |
170 |
Madlosi Entertainment CC |
Southern African Music Conference/Miami Winter Music Conference |
Joburg Metro |
Gauteng |
R400 000 |
171 |
Unique PR and Events PTY |
2nd Imvunge Maskandi African Festival |
Ethekwini |
KwaZulu Natal |
R500 000 |
172 |
AML - PAZ Africa Group |
8th Annual Onkweni Royal Cultural Festival International (ORCFI) |
Ethekwini Municipality |
KwaZulu Natal |
800 000 |
173 |
Fashion Engagement PTY LTD |
Traditional Horse Racing Fashion Event |
Buffalo City |
R500 000 |
|
174 |
Alexandra Youth in Action Ensemble PTY LTD |
Emalahleni Artists Preserving Heritage Festival (UBUNTU)0 |
City of JHB |
Gauteng |
R500 000 |
175 |
Thiko Events Management PTY LTD |
Reconciliation Festival |
Ekurhuleni |
Gauteng |
R450 000 |
176 |
Phambili Siyaya Arts Section 21 |
DIVAS of Kofifi - Touring to Mbombela |
Tshwane |
Gauteng |
R500 000 |
177 |
Mpumalanga Choral Music Association NPO |
Mpumalanga Choral Eistedfod |
Gert Sibande District Municipality |
Mpumalanga |
R400 000 |
178 |
NEWLIBIX NPC |
DSTV I rock Legends and Talent search |
Capricorn district |
Limpopo |
R500 000 |
179 |
Damilos MP |
Abadals Cultural Project |
Mhlontlo |
Eastern Cape |
R500 000 |
180 |
A Creative Trading and Projects |
Kids, Arts and Craft Festival |
Nelson Mandela Bay |
Eastern Cape |
R500 000.00 |
181 |
Naleli M Holdings |
Second Chances Training Workshop |
Joburg |
Gauteng |
R300 000.00 |
182 |
Ndikho Events |
Battle Field Festival |
Nquthu Municipality |
Kwazulu Natal |
R500 000.00 |
183 |
LCP Concepts |
90'S Affair Festival September 2017 |
Mangaung |
Free State |
R500 000.00 |
184 |
AB Art Studio |
Vryburg Food, Art and Craft Market |
Vryburg |
Free State |
R500 000.00 |
185 |
Baitshepi Ba Thari Entertainment and Projects |
Re godisa ngwa ya setswana |
Dr Ruth Mompati District |
North West |
R 200,000.00 |
186 |
Bantu Media Production |
3rd Annual Africa Unite Reggae Concert |
Rusternburg |
North West |
R500 000.00 |
187 |
MIOWN |
Youth Day Reconciliation Expo Music Festival |
Vhembe |
Limpopo |
R300 000.00 |
188 |
Mkhonzeni Trading PTY Ltd |
Sistaz with Soul - 2nd |
EThekwini Municipality |
KwaZulu Natal |
R300 000.00 |
189 |
DOZ Holdings |
Dundee Battlefields Carnival |
Umzinyathi District Dundee |
KwaZulu Natal |
R300 000.00 |
190 |
Mkhosi Busa Pty Ltd |
Phuzushukela Memorial Maskandi Festival |
King Cetshwayo Municipality |
KwaZulu Natal |
R500 000.00 |
191 |
Milla House |
Polokwane Fashion Show 30 August 2017 |
Capricorn District |
Limpopo |
R278 604.00 |
192 |
Media Entertainment |
Arts Media Alive Young Script Writers Festival 01 - 30 July 2017 |
Capricorn Blouberg Municipality |
Limpopo |
R300 000.00 |
193 |
Are Berekeng IT Enterprise |
African Poetry with South African Children |
City of JHB |
Gauteng |
R150 000.00 |
194 |
Black Affirmations Creative Arts |
A Jewel in the Wilds- The Story of Pace College, Soweto 19/06/17-09/17 |
City of Joburg |
Gauteng |
R 151,000.00 |
195 |
Abantu Book Festival |
Abantu Book Festival |
Joburg Metro |
Gauteng |
R 700,000.00 |
196 |
Table Manners J and J Productions T/A Jack and Jull Productions |
Table Manners |
Joburg Metro |
Gauteng |
R500 000.00 |
197 |
New Life Foundation NPO |
Mbombela International Film Festival |
Nkomazi Local Municipality |
Mpumalanga |
R300 000.00 |
198 |
Matatiele Arts Development Organisation |
Matatiele Indigenous Dance Festival 30 April |
Matatiela |
Eastern Cape |
R200 000.00 |
199 |
Kwa Bhaca Kingdom |
Umkhosi Wokukhahlela |
Mthathe |
Eastern Cape |
R500 000.00 |
200 |
Head Boy Arts Production |
Badimo Ba Rona Ba Kae? (Musical Production) |
Kuruman |
Northen Cape |
R300 000.00 |
201 |
Namahadi Youth project |
Manyano Project |
Mafube Municipality |
North West |
R100 000.00 |
202 |
Free State Wombman in Theatre FSWT |
CAMAGU Theatre and Dance festival |
Mangaung Metro |
Free State |
R500 000.00 |
203 |
Ditlhodi Tsa Magagane Cultural |
Batsha le Setso Festival |
Vrischgewaagte |
North West |
R250 000.00 |
204 |
Mamama Trading & Projects |
Battle of Schools |
Atamelang |
North West |
R150 000.00 |
205 |
Kenny Shibanbo Talent Development institute |
Xibelani Music Festival 01 July |
Mopani |
Limpopo |
R400 000.00 |
206 |
Gay and Lesbian Network |
Pink Mynah Festival |
Pietermaritzburg |
KwaZulu Natal |
R50 000.00 |
207 |
Sakhisizwe Community Projects |
Cleremont Arts Festival |
EThekwini Municipality |
KwaZulu Natal |
R300 000.00 |
208 |
Isigqi Arts Development NPC |
2nd Annual Mtubatuba Youth Celebration Arts Festival |
Umkhanyakude District Municipality |
KwaZulu Natal |
R400 000.00 |
209 |
Nkungumathe Youth Development Forum |
Nkungumathe Arts |
King Cetshwayo District |
KwaZulu Natal |
R300 000.00 |
210 |
The Web NGO |
Bubula Praise Poetry |
Durban Metro |
KwaZulu Natal |
R250 000.00 |
211 |
Afropolitan Explosive |
SA Festival for Black-Centered Film |
Amajuba Disctrict Municipality |
KwaZulu Natal |
R300 000.00 |
212 |
Isiko FoundationNPC |
Annual Collins Chabane Cultural Heritage Festival |
Vhembe district |
Limpopo |
R500 000.00 |
213 |
1st Pati Glass and Fine Arts Project |
The Transparent Beauty of Ubuntu |
City of Tshwane |
Gauteng |
R300 000.00 |
214 |
Simon Moshiwadiba Foundation |
Siyaya Arts Development |
Lesedi Municipality |
Gauteng |
R250 000.00 |
215 |
Deep Ratanda Development Projects |
The Book of Love |
Ekurhuleni |
Gauteng |
R200 000.00 |
216 |
Soweto African Revolution |
Relukisa Bokamoso |
Ekurhuleni |
Gauteng |
R150 000.00 |
217 |
Batsumi Cultural Group |
Senzangakhona Arts, Culture and Heritage; |
City of Joburg |
Gauteng |
R200,000.00 |
218 |
Midvaal Arts Institution |
5TH Midvaal Arts Festival Tour |
Midvaal Municipality |
Gauteng |
R300,000.00 |
219 |
True Butterfly (Girl Programme) |
Pampiri Arts Programme |
City of Tshwane |
Gauteng |
R 150,000.00 |
220 |
Zanethemba Arts and Culture Project |
Ses' Fikile Arts Festival |
City of Joburg |
Gauteng |
R150,000.00 |
221 |
Refubish Project Development organisation |
Film Fest and Fashion |
Midrand |
Gauteng |
R400 000.00 |
222 |
The Maboneng Township Arts Experience |
The Annual 2017 Maboneng Township Arts Experience (MTAE) |
Alexandra Township |
Gauteng |
R600 000.00 |
223 |
South African National Youth Orchestra Foundation |
Orchestra Courses and Programmes |
City of Joburg |
Gauteng |
R 500,000.00 |
224 |
Moji Entertainment |
Africa Dance Festival |
Tlhabane; Rustenburg |
North West |
R150 000.00 |
225 |
BAO Music Business Leadership |
BOM Music Development Programmed |
Buffalo City |
Eastern Cape |
R400 000.00 |
226 |
Coalition Trading 1237T/A Creative Solutions |
Reconciliation Comedy Night 2016 |
Kimberly |
Northern Cape |
R150 000.00 |
227 |
Outrage Concept |
3rd Annual We can Arts Festival |
eThekwini |
KwaZulu Natal |
R800 000.00 |
228 |
Bardill Entertainment |
UP& Coming -Live Music Showcase February - November 2017 |
Sandton |
Gauteng |
R 400,000.00 |
229 |
Zuniza Investment Corporation CC T/A Nikis Oasis Restaurant |
Niki's Jazz Development Project May 2017 - April 2018 |
City of Joburg |
Gauteng |
R 500,000.00 |
230 |
Lamathonsi Entertainment |
Mams Arts Festival |
City of Tshwane |
Gauteng |
R 700,000.00 |
231 |
Errol Teddy Mattera T/A teddy Sometimes Productions CC Dungamanzi film |
Cinema From Within - Who are we Reall |
City of Joburg |
Gauteng |
R500 000.00 |
232 |
Pule Mqhedlane |
Kopanang Africa Annual Youth Theatre Festival |
Lejwe Le Putswa |
Free State |
R150 000.00 |
233 |
Beauty M Mlokoti |
ICAMAGU 24 April - 26 May 2017 |
Mangaung Metro Municipality |
Free State |
R100 000.00 |
234 |
Thabo Isaac Rapoo |
Workshops that end with a production |
Brits District |
North West |
R 156,000.00 |
235 |
Ms Sarah Nhlapo |
Ventersdorp / Tlokwe Africa Day Celebrations |
Potchestroom |
North West |
R300 000.00 |
236 |
Petrus Sello Lephotho |
LETS TAP |
Ekurhuleni |
Gauteng |
R100 000.00 |
237 |
Tebogo Edward Radebe |
Yes We Can Disability, Old Age & Orphan Dance Development); |
Ekurhuleni |
Gauteng |
R150 000.00 |
238 |
Gauteng Music Development |
Music Transcribing |
City of Joburg |
Gauteng |
R300,000.00 |
DAC ENTITY: NATIONAL ARTS COUNCIL (NAC)
MUSIC FESTIVALS Supported
Organisation Name |
Funding No |
Genre |
Province |
Amount |
EspAfrika |
MC/26/13 |
Jazz |
Western Cape |
R 1m (Development Programme) |
Drakensburg Promotions |
M/316/14 |
Jazz |
Gauteng |
R 250 000 |
The Jazz Foundation of SA |
MC/30/13 |
Jazz |
Gauteng |
R 750 000 |
Ekhoneni Production Trading Enterpise |
M/123/14 |
Hip Hop Music |
Gauteng |
R 150 000 |
Teb’s Management |
MC/61/13 |
Gauteng |
R 300 000 |
|
MULTI DISCIPLINARY FESTIVALS
Organisation Name |
Funding No |
Genre |
Province |
Amount |
National Arts Festival |
AC2013 |
Multi Discipline |
Eastern Cape |
R 3m |
Diamonds and Dorings |
F2013 |
Multi Discipline |
Northern Cape |
R 500 000 |
VryFees – Vryfestival |
AC5313 |
Multi Discipline |
Free State |
R 363 000 |
Bolotsa Letsema Holding |
AC20813 |
Multi Discipline |
North West |
R 600 000 |
Suidoodstefees |
AC4813 |
Multi Discipline |
Western Cape |
R 3000 000 |
Cape Town Festival |
AC7913 |
Multi Discipline |
Western Cape |
R 700 000 |
Cederbergfees |
AC21813 |
Multi Discipline |
Western Cape |
R 350 000 |
MACUFE |
F2017 |
Multi Discipline |
Free State |
R 500 000 |
ROUTE FORM
SUBMISSION TO THE MINISTER OF ARTS AND CULTURE
PROGRAMME |
2 |
FILE NO. |
|
SUBJECT |
QUESTION NO. 3876-2018: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY: MR L G MOKOENA (EFF): TO ASK THE MINISTER OF ARTS AND CULTURE: WHAT NUMBER OF LOCAL MUSIC AND ART FESTIVALS HAVE RECEIVED FUNDING FROM HIS DEPARTMENTAND ENTITIES REPORTING TO HIM IN EACH OF THE PAST FIVE YEARS |
||
SURNAME AND INITIALS |
ABBREVIATED DESIGNATION |
IGNATURE AND DATE |
SEE COMMENTS |
CHABALALA D |
DD/CD |
||
MABASO C |
CD/CD |
||
MABASO C |
ACT DDG/ACPD |
||
MKHIZE V |
DG |
||
HANI,N |
H/DM |
||
SOTYU, M |
DM |
||
BESANI, S |
CoS |
||
MTHETHWA, N |
MINISTER |
NAME AND DESIGNATION |
COMMENTS |
14 December 2018 - NW3701
Mashabela, Ms N to ask the Minister of International Relations and Cooperation
What are the details of the Government’s policy position regarding the voting structures and powers of the United Nations Security Council and General Assembly?
Reply:
Honourable Member, South Africa's participation in multilateral institutions is guided by the country's foreign policy objectives based on its vision of "a better South Africa, a better Africa and a better world". Our foreign policy is informed by our constitutional values and principles, national values and interests and strategic considerations based on domestic and international imperatives.
Our participation is further aligned with an understanding of the nexus that exists between peace, security and sustainable development. Consequently, South Africa's approach and voting patterns in the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) and the General Assembly (GA) resonates strongly with the African Union's (AUs) aspirational goals contained in the Agenda 2063 and its Ten (10) Year Implementation Plan of contributing to peace and security of "Silencing the Guns by the year 2020".
South Africa further upholds the principle that there could be no peace without development, thus the advancement of the 2030 Sustainable Development Agenda Goals adopted by UN Heads of State and Government in New York in September 2015 is essential requirement to continental efforts towards advancing the achievement of the African Union Agenda 2063.
Additional information on voting structures and powers in the United Nations Security Council and United Nations General Assembly is provided below:
Voting structures and powers of the United Nations Security Council
- Each member of the United Nations Security Council has one vote. There are two sets of decisions that are taken by voting, namely on procedural matters and non-procedural matters which the latter could be vetoed by the Permanent Five. The UNSC is the only organ of the United Nations which has been conferred with the power to take decisions with a binding force in line with the "Purposes and Principles of the United Nations" in discharging its duties of maintaining international peace and security.
Voting structures and powers of the General Assembly
The Government policy position regarding voting structures and powers of the United Nations General Assembly is guided by the following provisions of the United Nations General Assembly's Rules of Procedure, Rules 82 to 90 on Voting:
- Each member of the General Assembly have one vote. Decisions of the General Assembly on important questions shall be made by a two-thirds majority of the members present and voting, for instance in matters pertaining to international peace and security, the election of the non-permanent members of the Security Council, etc. On the other hand, decisions of the General Assembly on questions other than those considered important that requires a two thirds majority, shall be made by a simple majority of the members present and voting, i.e. affirmative and negative votes only; abstentions are considered as not voting.
14 December 2018 - NW3612
Cardo, Dr MJ to ask the Minister of Economic Development
Whether the Competition Commission purchased any motor vehicles since 1 April 2015; if so, what is the (a) make, (b), model, (c) price and (d) date on which each vehicle was purchased?
Reply:
Motor vehicles purchased since 1 April 2015
Yes, the Competition Commission purchased motor vehicles in each financial year since 1 April 2015. Expenditure has been disclosed in the relevant annual financial statements.
Details of the purchases are as follows:
2015/16 Financial year
- One Toyota Corolla was procured at a purchase price of R 271 566.
- One Audi A4 was procured, at a purchase price of R 430 212.
- One Toyota Hilux was procured at a purchase price of R242 012.
2016/17 Financial year
- Two Toyota Corolla vehicles were procured, at purchase prices of R 270 795; and R282 275 each.
2017/18 Financial year
- Two BMW 3-series vehicles were procured, at purchase prices of R420 800 and R425 700 each and two BMW 5-series vehicles were procured, at purchase prices of R621 501 each.
-END-
14 December 2018 - NW3618
Dreyer, Ms AM to ask the Minister of Environmental Affairs
Whether there are any plans in place to ban microbeads in the country; if not, why not; if so, by what date will the ban come into effect?
Reply:
The microbeads in cosmetics and disinfectants have been highlighted as having a negative environmental impact. The regulatory control of both cosmetics and disinfectants is administered by the Department of Health under regulations in the Foodstuffs, Cosmetics and Disinfectants Act, 1954
(Act 54 of 1972). The Department of Environmental Affairs is in engagement with both the Department of Health and South African Health Products Regulatory Authority, including providing comments on the amendment of cosmetics regulations to consider the phase-out of microbeads in cosmetics.
---ooOoo---
14 December 2018 - NW3831
Tarabella - Marchesi, Ms NI to ask the Minister of Basic Education
(1)Whether (a) her department and/or (b) any entity reporting to her contracted the services of a certain company (name and details furnished), in each of the past 10 financial years; if so, what (i) number of contracts were signed, (ii) was the date on which each contract was signed, (iii) was the duration of each contract, (iv) services did the company render and (v) was the monetary value of each contract in each case; (2) whether any irregular expenditure relating to the contracts was recorded and/or condoned in each case; if so, what are the relevant details? NW4408E
Reply:
1. (a)The Department was never engaged in any business with the service provider in question.
(i) N/A
(ii) N/A
(iii) N/A
(v) N/A
2. N/A
(b) UMALUSI
1. Umalusi has never engaged in any business with the service provider in question.
(i) N/A
(ii) N/A
(iii) N/A
(v) N/A
2. N/A
(b) SACE
1. SACE has never engaged in any business with the service provider in question.
(i) N/A
(ii) N/A
(iii) N/A
(v) N/A
2. N/A
14 December 2018 - NW3844
Robinson, Ms D to ask the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services
Whether (a) his department and/or (b) any entity reporting to him contracted the services of a certain company (name and details furnished), in each of the past 10 financial years; if so, what (i) number of contracts were signed, (ii) was the date on which each contract was signed, (iii) was the duration of each contract, (iv) services did the company render and (v) was the monetary value of each contract in each case; (2) whether any irregular expenditure relating to the contracts was recorded and/or condoned in each case; if so, what are the relevant details?
Reply:
1. (a) Yes, the Department of Justice and Constitutional Development has informed me that Bosasa was awarded with a contract in the past (ten) 10 financial years.
- One (1) contract was signed as RFB 2010 02B.
- The award was approved on 16 December 2010.
- The duration was from 1 January 2011 to 30 September 2013.
- The service provider was appointed to render security guarding and special services to the Department.
- The total amount spent was R535 330 659.
(b) I have also been informed by the entities reporting to me, i.e. the Legal Aid South Africa, National Prosecuting Authority and Special Investigating Unit that they never contracted Bosasa in the last ten (10) financial years.
2. No, the Department did not incur irregular expenditure since the departmental Supply Chain Management Policy and prescripts were followed.
14 December 2018 - NW3665
Dlamini, Mr MM to ask the Minister of Public Enterprises
(a) What number of public resorts were managed by Aventura Ltd before it was liquidated, (b) what were the specific reasons for the liquidation of Aventura Ltd and (c)(i) to whom were the public resorts that were managed by Aventura Ltd sold and (ii) at what price?
Reply:
DPE response
a) There were in total fourteen (14) public resorts that were managed by Aventura. Six of those resorts, which were seriously loss making were the first to be disposed of to different purchasers.
Then the remaining and better performing eight (8) situated at Badplaas, Blydepoort, Loskopdam, Swadini (Mpumalanga) Tshipise, Warmbath (Limpopo), Plettenburg Bay (Western Cape), Gariep (Free State) were sold to a single purchaser named Forever Siyonwaba Consortium.
b) Government had in 2001 as part of its restructuring policy taken a decision to dispose all the Aventura resorts. Hotel and leisure was regarded as non- core to Government. The decision to dispose was further underpinned by the fact that some of the resorts were seriously loss making. Aventura was disposed through a normal purchase and sale process however difficulties were encountered in concluding the process all together. The process was beset by land claims in some of the areas (e.g Blydepoort, Swadini and Tshipise) where the resorts were situated, incorrect description of the Aventura properties, e.g there were discrepancies in Aventura property description set out in the Deeds office and the inventory/schedule of those properties laid out in the Overvaal Resorts Limited Act 127 of 1993. These difficulties caused the disposal of Aventura to be protracted. Thus, against the background that the Aventura resorts were already sold even though difficulties in transferring some of them were encountered, in 2013 an optimal route to bring closure to the purchase and sale process was considered and liquidation was found to be appropriate. The Shareholder (Minister of Public Enterprises) then passed a resolution to liquidate Aventura.
(c) (i) the eight(8) resorts were sold to a company called Forever Siyonwaba Consortium
(ii) the Purchase Price for the eight was R200m.
14 December 2018 - NW3809
Chance, Mr R to ask the Minister of Small Business Development
Whether the forensic investigation into allegations of corruption and mismanagement in her department that was commissioned by the Auditor-General has been completed; if not, by what date is the investigation envisaged to be completed; if so, (a) on what date was the investigation completed and (b) what are the main findings of the investigation?”
Reply:
The investigation has not been completed. The Auditor-General has informed the Department of Small Business Development (DSBD) that the envisaged completion timeline for the investigation is early 2019.
a) The investigation was envisaged to be completed by 10 September 2018.
b) Findings will be known once the investigation report is issued.
14 December 2018 - NW3739
Maynier, Mr D to ask the President of the Republic
Whether, with reference to his reply to a supplementary question on question 20 on 6 November 2018, (a) he and/or (b) any person in his Office communicated (i) directly or (ii) indirectly with the Minister of Finance, Mr T T Mboweni the Government’s position on the future of the SA Airways; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what are the relevant details in each case?
Reply:
(a) & (b) (i) (ii): No. There is agreement in the Executive that the immediate priority for government is to stabilise SAA financially and through a rigorous process of cost-reduction and commercial re-orientation, to turn it into an airline that is financially and operationally sustainable.
14 December 2018 - NW3901
Mashabela, Ms N to ask the Minister of Arts and Culture
Whether, with reference to the reply of the Minister of Public Service and Administration to questions 141 for oral reply on 7 September 2018, his department and the entities reporting to him implemented the Public Service Coordinating Bargaining Council resolution that all person employed in the Public Service as Assistant Directors must have their salary level upgraded from level 9 to 10, and that all Deputy Directors must have their salaries level upgraded from level 11 to level 12;if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
Reply:
There is no Public Service Co-coordinating Bargaining Council (PSCC) resolution that provides for movement from one salary level to another. Grade progression is done in line with PSCBC Resolution 3 of 2009 upon meeting all the requirement. The department implements the provision of Resolution 3 of 2009 accordingly.
14 December 2018 - NW3893
Ntlangwini, Ms EN to ask the Minister of Trade and Industry
What was the total monetary value of textile (a) exports and (b) imports in each of the past five financial years?
Reply:
(a) Exports
Country’s textile exports per year |
|||||||||
2013 R' million |
2014 R' million |
2015 R' million |
2016 R' million |
2017 R' million |
|||||
Textile |
6 713 |
Textile |
7 175 |
Textile: |
7 837 |
Textile |
8 964 |
Textile |
10 201 |
(b) Imports
Country’s textile imports per year |
|||||||||
2013 R' million |
2014 R' million |
2015 R' million |
2016 R' million |
2017 R' million |
|||||
Textile |
12 975 |
Textile |
14 295 |
Textile |
15 967 |
Textile |
17 112 |
Textile |
17 169 |
14 December 2018 - NW3830
Tarabella - Marchesi, Ms NI to ask the Minister of Arts and Culture”
Whether (a) his department and/or (b) any entity reporting to him contracted the services of a certain company (name and details furnished), in each of the past 10 financial years; if so, (i) number of contracts were signed, (ii) was the date on which each contract was signed, (iii) was the duration of each contract, (iv) services did the company render and (v) was the monetary value of each contract in each case;
Reply:
My department and it’s entities reporting to me has not contracted the services of Bosasa, now known as African Global Operations, in the past 10 financial years.
14 December 2018 - NW3874
Mokoena, Mr L to ask the Minister of Arts and Culture
What (a) number of (i) local films and (ii) film producers have received funding from (aa) his department and (bb) each of the entities reporting to him in each of the past five years and (b)(i) was the name of each company and (ii) total amount did each company receive in each case?
Reply:
My department supported (i) twelve (12) local films and (ii) eleven (11) film producers in the past five years. The entity reporting to my department, namely, the National Film and Video Foundation (NFVF) supported 408 local films and 65 film producers.
In respect of each case: (a) (i)(ii); (aa) (bb), (b)(i)(ii), relevant details are outlined and included as Annexure A and B, below.
(a) Number Local Film |
(bb) YEAR |
(I) NAME OF FILM |
(ii) PRODUCER |
(ii) AMOUNT |
2014 |
None |
None |
None |
|
1 |
2015 |
Dinizulu |
Ms Khubu Zulu: Sakhuri Media |
R 500 000 |
2 |
2016 |
Mangoyi Mother of Black resistance |
Mr Nqaba Ngoyi: Fort Films |
R1 147 290 |
3 |
2016 |
Khalushi |
Mr Mandla Dube: Montage online |
R3 000 000 |
4 |
2017 |
Cinema from within: Who are we really |
Mr Teddy Mattera |
R 500 000 |
5 |
2017 |
Table Manners |
Ms Nkuli Sibeko & Mr Leli Maki: Jack & Jill Productions |
R 500 000 |
6 |
2017 |
Winnie |
Mr Steven Markovits: Big World Cinema |
R 800 000 |
7 |
2017 |
The Whale Caller |
Mr Zola Maseko: Black Roots Productions |
R 600 000 |
8 |
2017 |
Noem My Skolie |
Ms Motshidi & Mr David Maxbrown: Maxi D Productions |
R 300 000 |
9 |
2017 |
Visual Artists Living Legends: Documentary |
Mr Monna Mokoena: Momo Gallery Foundation |
R 800 000 |
10 |
2017 |
Mandela Man of Peace: Documentary |
Ms Xoliswa Sithole: Nayanaya Productions |
R 800 000 |
11 |
2017 |
Inkonyana yohlanga |
Imiliza Productions |
R 800 000 |
12 |
2018 |
Mandela Man of Peace: Documentary |
Ms Xoliswa Sithole: Nayanaya Productions |
R1 500 000 |
TOTAL |
12 x Local Films |
11 x Producers |
R11 247.290 |
Annexure A. Local Films and Producers as well as amount supported by my Department in the past five years:
ANNEXURE B. Films supported by the Department’s entity, National Film and Video Foundation (NFVF)
Approved Projects 2014- 2015
Cycle 1
Documentary Development
Project Name |
Applicant’s Name |
Production Company |
Amount Allocated |
Ocean Driven |
Chris Bertish |
CMB Agencies |
R100 000.00 |
Feature Length Development
Project Name |
Applicant’s Name |
Production Company |
Amount Allocated |
Break it Down |
Lorreal Ferris |
N/A |
R140 000.00 |
Collide |
Mpho Kgosana |
Virya Management |
R200 000.00 |
Strange Love |
Zuko Yafele |
Durban Motion Pictures |
R200 000.00 |
The Wasteland |
Mark Engels |
Blast Films |
R200 000.00 |
Production Documentaries
Project Name |
Applicant’s Name |
Production Company |
Amount Allocated |
A True Patriot? |
Kevin Harris |
Rainbow Independent Film & TV Productions |
R100 000.00 |
iAfrikaner |
Joanna Higgs |
Go Trolley Films |
R191 760.00 |
Wild Dog and Mrs Heart |
Riaan Hendricks |
A Season of Film |
R200 000.00 |
Project Name |
Applicant’s Name |
Production Company |
Amount Allocated |
Echo Beach |
Jyoti Mistry |
Blackboard Trust |
R600 000.00 |
Krotoa |
Roberta Durrant |
Penguin Films |
R1 200 000.00 |
The Umbrella Man |
Linda Bogle |
WE 3 Films |
R1 200 000.00 |
Production Short Films
Project Name |
Applicant’s Name |
Production Company |
Amount Allocated |
Into the Ring |
Francois Le Pere |
Allegoria |
R198 440.00 |
The Man with the Dragging Leg |
Janette De Villiers |
Groundglass |
R200 000.00 |
The Marriage of Heaven and Hell |
Cornel Rayners |
Saint Moonriver Productions |
R200 000.00 |
Female filmmaker project |
Carolyn Carew |
Female Filmmaker projects |
R176 800 |
Approved Projects 2014 –2015
Cycle 2
Documentary Development
Project Name |
Applicant’s Name |
Production Company |
Amount Allocated |
Double Lives of Children of Revolutionaries |
Khalo Matabane |
BFM Features (PTY)LTD |
R120 000.00 |
Skate |
Joe-Anne Mirosevic |
Alpha-Beta Project Management |
R91 200.00 |
Smoke and Thunder |
Malcom Macnaughton |
Malcom Macnaughton |
R100 000.00 |
The Sound Of Masks |
Kofi Zwana |
N/A |
R100 000.00 |
Wizard of Zim |
Samora Sekhukhune |
Away From Keyboard |
R120 000.00 |
Feature Length Development
Project Name |
Applicant’s Name |
Production Company |
Amount Allocated |
An anthology Film |
Feizel Mamdoo |
N/A |
R189 000.00 |
Harmony |
Tim Argall |
bugbox |
R250 000.00 |
Knock on |
John Volmink |
Diprente |
R120 000.00 |
Egypt’s Modern Pharaohs |
Rehad Desai |
Uhuru Productions |
R350 000.00 |
Hard Livings |
Jason Staggie |
Accidental Films and TV |
R350 000.00 |
When Buddah comes to Africa |
Nicole Schafer |
Thinking strings Media |
R100 000.00 |
The Fix |
Saskia Schiel |
Stage5 Films |
R199 100.00 |
The Legend of the Karoo |
Raffaella Delle Dome |
N/A |
R150 000.00 |
The Tree |
Adraan Louw Venter |
Urucu Media |
R200 000.00 |
Short Film Development
Project Name |
Applicant’s Name |
Production Company |
Amount Allocated |
Nyanga sky |
Rafeeqah Galant |
Echoledge |
R110 000.00 |
Production Archive
Project Name |
Applicant’s Name |
Production Company |
Amount Allocated |
The boy, The Blade , The man |
Mayenzeke Baza |
Mandela Bay Pictures |
R200 000.00 |
Production Documentaries
Project Name |
Applicant’s Name |
Production Company |
Amount Allocated |
- |
- |
- |
- |
Production Features
Project Name |
Applicant’s Name |
Production Company |
Amount Allocated |
Love The One You Love |
Jenna Bass |
Fox Fire Films |
R790 000.00 |
Production Short Films
Project Name |
Applicant’s Name |
Production Company |
Amount Allocated |
The Discovery of Fire |
Warren Ferreira |
Tin Toy Productions |
R200 000.00 |
The National Film and Video Foundation
14 December 2018 - NW3728
Hlonyana, Ms NKF to ask the Minister of Economic Development
Whether, his department subsidises any industries in the country; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, (a) which industries, (b) where is each industry located, (c) what does each industry produce and (d) what is the monetary value of each subsidy?
Reply:
No, the budget of the Economic Development Department is not used to subsidise any industries in the country.
The Industrial Development Corporation (“IDC”) does provide concessional funding to a number of industries and sectors, including its Black Industrialist Programme and Gro-E Youth Programme, to encourage youth entrepreneurship. This support is provided across the country. Further details of IDC programmes may be found in the Integrated Report on the IDC’s website: https://www.idc.co.za/images/2018/IDC-IR-2018-Final.pdf.
In the past EDD has raised R95 million for the Downstream Steel Competitiveness Fund utilising funds paid over to the National Revenue Fund as a result of penalties imposed on ArcelorMittal South Africa for its role in cartels in the steel industry. The funds raised by EDD has been used for concessional funding to provide support to qualifying smaller competitors and downstream players. Funding has been approved for companies in Gauteng, Eastern Cape, Mpumalanga, KwaZulu-Natal and North West.
Similarly, EDD has raised R250 million for the Agro Processing Competitiveness Fund utilising funds paid over to the National Revenue Fund as a result of penalties imposed on Pioneer Foods for its role in the bread cartel. Funding has been approved in 42 deals to provide concessional funding for companies in Eastern Cape, Western Cape, Free State, North West, Mpumalanga, Limpopo, Gauteng and KwaZulu-Natal.
The work of EDD in competition matters has resulted in R4.5 billion raised from private companies to support small and medium business and black-owned businesses in a number of industries including agriculture, construction, manufactured consumer goods and spaza shops. The impact of this support has been across the country.
-END-
14 December 2018 - NW3663
Yako, Ms Y to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training
What number of (a) nurses, (b) doctors, (c) social workers and (d) teachers have graduated from institutions of higher learning in each of the past five academic years?
Reply:
The table below reflects the number of nurses, doctors, social workers and teachers who graduated from public higher education institutions over the past five academic years.
Universities |
||||
Year |
(a) Nurses |
(b) Doctors |
(c) Social Workers |
(d) Teachers |
2013 |
2 817 |
1 346 |
2 546 |
16 808 |
2014 |
3 157 |
1 170 |
2 787 |
19 124 |
2015 |
3 242 |
1 454 |
2 875 |
20 698 |
2016 |
2 801 |
1 496 |
3 200 |
22 150 |
2017 |
3 154 |
1 574 |
3 288 |
25 212 |
14 December 2018 - NW3611
Cardo, Dr MJ to ask the Minister of Economic Development
What is the (a) total amount spent by the Competition Commission on the Market Inquiry into the Private Healthcare Sector since its establishment in 2013 and (b) detailed breakdown of the amount spent by the Competition Commission on services provided by external (i) economists, (ii) lawyers, (iii) expert consultants and (iv) a certain legal firm (name furnished)?
Reply:
The Competition Commission set up a Market Inquiry under the current provisions of the Competition Act, in 2014 to consider the state of competition in the private healthcare market, covering a large number of services across the value-chain.
An independent Panel was appointed by the Commissioner to preside over the market inquiry, chaired by ex Chief Justice Sandile Ngcobo, and it engaged Experts as panellists and a number of specialists to support the Chairperson and Panel of Experts.
The Commission decided that a mix of skills would ensure that the Panel oversees and evaluates both legal (administrative, procedural) and technical (healthcare, health and competition economics) aspects of the inquiry. In addition to the mix of skills, the Commission also had to consider the independence of the various panel members. In particular, the Commission had to seek experts with relevant sector-specific experience that would not result in a conflict of interest. Details of the individual panel members appointed by the Commission to oversee the HMI are reflected in greater detail in Table 1 below:
TABLE 1: Panel members
Panellist |
Reasons for selection |
Chief Justice Ngcobo (Rtd) |
|
Dr Cees van Gent (Netherlands) |
|
Professor Sharon Fonn |
|
Dr Ntuthuko Bhengu |
|
Dr Lungiswa Nkonki |
|
The total amount spent by the Competition Commission on the Market Inquiry into the Private Healthcare Sector since its establishment in 2013 amounts to R196 949 637.
The detailed breakdown is as follows (Table 2):
Table 2: cost breakdown
No |
Description |
Amount |
1 |
Legal Expertise & Litigation |
R12,537,881.16 |
2 |
Healthcare Sector Experts |
R5,627,139.65 |
3 |
Data Warehousing & Actuarial Services |
R13,486,040.63 |
4 |
Data De-Identification & Security |
R9,598,784.61 |
5 |
Economics Experts |
R38,959,579.39 |
6 |
Media and Communications |
R1,391,211.99 |
7 |
Panel Members |
R36,794,302.06 |
8 |
Human Resources and Operational costs |
R78,554,697.51 |
Total |
R196 949 637 |
In respect of the Panel Members, payments were made as follows (table 3):
Table 3: Payments made to Panel Members.
Panel Members |
Total |
Justice Sandile Ngcobo |
R5 929 016 |
Dr Ntuthuko Melusi Bhengu |
R9 716 935 |
Cees Van Gent |
R11 748 087 |
Dr Sharon Fonn |
R3 328 763 |
Dr Lungiswa Nkonki |
R6 071 501 |
In respect of the specific query in the Parliamentary Question regarding a certain law firm, I am advised that Ndzabandzaba Attorneys were not appointed to represent the Commission in the Market Inquiry and accordingly no monies were paid to them.
-END-
14 December 2018 - NW3743
Wana, Ms T to ask the Minister of Basic Education
What are the reasons that a sign was put up for Mahabaneng Primary School at the abandoned Lebaka B Primary School site in Mohlabaneng in Limpopo?
Reply:
Lebaka B was built as an offshoot of Lebaka A where the school buildings were dilapidated and no longer hospitable. Security was engaged and the repairs were effected. There are plans afoot to bring in Gr R –Gr 3 to the school in January 2019. The original name was supposed to be Mahabaneng Primary School instead of Lebaka B but the name was not registered at EMIS.
14 December 2018 - NW3559
Mhlongo, Mr TW to ask the Minister of Sport and Recreation
Whether she has been informed that the Vhembe Municipality in Limpopo has used R29 million to develop a sports facility and that the facility has to date not been developed allegedly due to irregularities at the VBS Bank; if not, (a) why not and (b) what steps will she take to rectify the situation; if so, what steps has she taken in this regard?NW4135E
Reply:
The matter had come to the attention of the Minister via media reports. It has to be pointed out that there is no legal requirement for the municipality to inform the Minister in respect of expenditures incurred on municipal accounts. Nevertheless the Minister had tasked the relevant Departmental officials to liaise with the Municipality and the Provincial Department of Sports and Recreation in Limpopo province to establish the facts on this matter and to recommend the appropriate action(s) to take. The engagements with the municipality are ongoing.
MS. T. XASA, MP
MINISTER OF SPORT AND RECREATION
DATE:
14 December 2018 - NW3920
Paulsen, Mr N M to ask the Minister of Science and Technology
Whether, with reference to the reply of the Minister of Public Service and Administration to question 141 for oral reply on 7 September 2018, her department and the entities reporting to her implemented the Public Service Coordinating Bargaining Council resolution that all persons employed in the Public Service as Assistant Directors must have their salary level upgraded from level 9 to level 10, and that all Deputy Directors must have their salary level upgraded from level 11 to level 12; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
Reply:
1. The Department implemented Public Service Coordinating Bargaining Council (PSCBC) resolution 3 of 2009, for employees that qualified. There was no one on salary level 9 and 11 who qualified for upgrade.
2. This resolution is not applicable to entities
14 December 2018 - NW3875
Mokoena, Mr L to ask the Minister of Arts and Culture
What are the details of the support that his Department offers to South African authors?
Reply:
My department has a unit which deals with Books and Publishing, focusing on promoting a culture of reading, writing and developing authors, supporting initiatives that provide public platforms for authors working with the book sector stakeholders including authors to engender wider audiences for South African literature and enhance the development of a dynamic book sector.
The Department provides funding to individuals, institutions, community groups and organizations, including literature. It also provides financial support for creative writing including biographies and autobiographies. In addition, in the case of international partnerships, funds are allocated to authors to travel to international literary events and attend international Book Fairs and Festivals.
The Department in partnership with the South African Literary Awards, pays tribute to South African authors who have distinguished themselves as ground-breaking producers and creators of literature. The Department is further committed to financially supporting activities of the Writers Guild, the National Writers Association of South Africa, the African Women Writers Network, the Abantu Book Festival, the Mthatha Word Festival and National Book Week, the latter of which takes place in every September and is held in all Provinces. A campaign aimed at stimulating a reading and writing culture in all South African languages and to promote easy access to books.
The Department also provides support to the National Library of South Africa for the activities of the Centre for the Books as well as National Library Week activities and related publishing and literary initiatives including the Funda Mzantsi National Reading Competition which promotes reading among book clubs from all over the country. Together with the National Library, the Department is finalizing a strategy and programme of rolling out writing grants to aspiring writers and authors.
14 December 2018 - NW3520
Kohler, Ms D to ask the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services
What is the total number of convictions secured in each province for the (a) possession, (b) sale, (c) manufacture and (d) use of drugs (i) in the (aa) 2014-15, (bb) 2015-16, (cc) 2016-17 and (dd) 2017-18 financial years and (ii) since 1 April 2018?
Reply:
The Department of Justice and Constitutional Development informed me that, according to the Integrated Case Management System (ICMS), the only reported matters are when a guilty verdict was imposed. The information is tabulated below according to each financial year.
A. 2014/15:
Region |
Dealing with Drugs |
Possession of Drugs |
Total |
Eastern Cape |
932 |
5 709 |
6 641 |
Free State |
368 |
1 983 |
2 351 |
Gauteng |
978 |
7 216 |
8 194 |
Kwa-Zulu Natal |
377 |
16 329 |
16 706 |
Limpopo |
76 |
802 |
878 |
Mpumalanga |
442 |
1 151 |
1 593 |
North West |
123 |
450 |
573 |
Northern Cape |
175 |
769 |
944 |
Western Cape |
1 397 |
22 552 |
23 949 |
Grand Total |
4 868 |
56 961 |
61 829 |
B. 2015/16:
Region |
Allowing sale; use or possession of drugs on premises in contravention of any law |
Dealing in Drugs |
Possession or using a dependence-producing drug or plant |
Possession/Use of Drugs |
Total |
Eastern Cape |
30 |
654 |
8 |
5 169 |
5 861 |
Free State |
1 |
179 |
3 |
2 204 |
2 387 |
Gauteng |
4 |
540 |
5 546 |
6 090 |
|
Kwa-Zulu Natal |
26 |
212 |
43 |
15 395 |
15 676 |
Limpopo |
46 |
2 |
793 |
841 |
|
Mpumalanga |
1 |
481 |
9 |
1 679 |
2 170 |
North West |
2 |
72 |
2 |
440 |
516 |
Northern Cape |
133 |
1 |
927 |
1 061 |
|
Western Cape |
2 |
870 |
2 |
21 714 |
22 588 |
Grand Total |
66 |
3 187 |
70 |
53 867 |
57 190 |
C. 2016/17:
Region |
Dealing with Drugs |
Possession or using a dependence-producing drug or plant |
Possession/Use of Drugs |
Total |
Eastern Cape |
287 |
1 |
3 092 |
3 380 |
Free State |
201 |
1 040 |
1241 |
|
Gauteng |
574 |
2 |
5 847 |
6 423 |
Kwa-Zulu Natal |
526 |
9 |
11 018 |
11 553 |
Limpopo |
67 |
1 |
786 |
854 |
Mpumalanga |
442 |
1 |
1 568 |
2 011 |
North West |
147 |
847 |
994 |
|
Northern Cape |
118 |
386 |
504 |
|
Western Cape |
530 |
7 |
13 406 |
13 943 |
Grand Total |
2 892 |
21 |
37 990 |
40 903 |
D. 2017/18:
Region |
Dealing in Drugs |
Possession or Use of Drugs |
Possession or using a dependence-producing drug or plant |
Grand Total |
Eastern Cape |
395 |
3 952 |
8 |
4 355 |
Free State |
235 |
1717 |
2 |
1 954 |
Gauteng |
611 |
6 030 |
7 |
6 648 |
Kwa-Zulu Natal |
515 |
13 067 |
54 |
13 636 |
Limpopo |
45 |
721 |
1 |
767 |
Mpumalanga |
522 |
1 558 |
3 |
2 083 |
North West |
115 |
947 |
1 062 |
|
Northern Cape |
141 |
737 |
878 |
|
Western Cape |
567 |
16 954 |
31 |
17 552 |
Grand Total |
3 146 |
45 683 |
106 |
48 935 |
E. 1 April 2018 – September 2018:
Region |
Dealing with Drugs |
Possession or Use of Drugs |
Possession or using a dependence-producing drug or plant |
Total |
Eastern Cape |
120 |
1 411 |
2 |
1 533 |
Free State |
84 |
724 |
808 |
|
Gauteng |
179 |
2 848 |
2 |
3 029 |
Kwa-Zulu Natal |
92 |
4 924 |
46 |
5 062 |
Limpopo |
21 |
216 |
237 |
|
Mpumalanga |
164 |
560 |
1 |
725 |
North West |
28 |
339 |
367 |
|
Northern Cape |
33 |
295 |
1 |
329 |
Western Cape |
209 |
5 970 |
28 |
6 207 |
Grand Total |
930 |
17 287 |
80 |
18 297 |
14 December 2018 - NW3610
Cardo, Dr MJ to ask the Minister of Economic Development
What (a) number of forensic service providers did the Competition Commission appoint to assist with dawn raids since 1 April 2015, (b) is the name of each forensic service provider, (c) number of dawn raids did each service provider conduct and (d) was the cost to the Competition Commission in each case?
Reply:
The Competition Act provides for the Competition Commission to enter and search premises of persons who may have information relating to an investigation in terms of the Act. These enter and search actions by the Commission are a vital part of the gathering of information on prohibited actions, including participation in cartel activities, price fixing and tender rigging and they constitute a highly specialised activity and hence trust in a service provider is essential.
The Commission therefore relies on proven expertise as the results of such actions in the form of the evidence gathered that are subject to challenge and scrutiny by the courts. I have been advised that the Commission has been trying to increase the number of potential providers and has been bringing in other service providers to ensure that there is adequate expertise.
Of the 12 enter and search actions that have been undertaken since 1 April 2015, three have been referred to the Tribunal for prosecution. Nine of the 12 are still under investigation by the Commission. In the case against the Furniture Removals Companies, 25 of the 30 respondents have already settled with the Commission for a total of R15 069 172.
Since 2008, enter and search actions have contributed to successful cartel investigations which have resulted in R463 million in settlements and penalties imposed by the Competition Tribunal.
Since 1 April 2015, there are five (5) forensic service providers that have been utilised, namely:
- Century Technical Solutions (Pty) Ltd,
- Exactech (Pty) Ltd,
- Matlama Consulting (Pty) Ltd,
- eCybersystems (Pty) Ltd, and
- Itsamaya Consulting.
Prior to 1 April 2015, the Commission had used the services of Exactech (Pty) Ltd, Matlama Consulting (Pty) Ltd, Cyanre, Computer LAB and Forensic Investigation Recovery Management (Pty) Ltd. Currently Century Technical and Exactect are still the preferred providers, given their expertise, but the other service providers are building their capacity.
A total of 12 enter and search actions have been undertaken since 1 April 2015.
Of these 12, each service provider participated in the following:
- Century Technical Solutions (Pty) Ltd - 12 of the 12 enter and search actions
- Exactech (Pty) Ltd - 11 of the 12 enter and search actions
- Matlama Consulting (Pty) Ltd - 4 of the 12 enter and search actions
- eCybersystems (Pty) Ltd - 3 of the 12 enter and search actions, and
- Itsamaya Consulting - 1 of the 12 enter and search actions.
(d) The costs per enter and search action are as follows:
No. |
Enter and search actions |
Date of action |
Service Provider/s |
Cost to CC |
Total per Raid |
1 |
CC v Human Communications and Others |
23 September 2015 |
Century Technical Solutions (Pty) Ltd |
R275 700,00 |
R275 700.00 |
2 |
CC v Furniture Removal Companies |
30 September 2015 |
Century Technical Solutions (Pty) Ltd |
R3 693 086,00 |
R5 131 767.04 |
Exactech (Pty) Ltd |
R1 309 295,70 |
||||
Matlama Consulting (Pty) Ltd |
R129 385,44 |
||||
3 |
CC v Totalgaz and Others |
14 October 2015 |
Century Technical Solutions (Pty) Ltd |
R397 176,00 |
R933 417.83 |
Exactech (Pty) Ltd |
R10 486,83 |
||||
Matlama Consulting (Pty) Ltd |
R525 755,00 |
||||
4 |
CC v Glassfit and Others |
23 March 2016 |
Century Technical Solutions (Pty) Ltd |
R2 690 273,01 |
R4 747 743.30 |
Exactech (Pty) Ltd |
R1 016 679,60 |
||||
Matlama Consulting (Pty) Ltd |
R1 040 790,69 |
||||
5 |
CC v PG Bison and Sonae |
31 March 2016 |
Century Technical Solutions (Pty) Ltd |
R2 225 250,00 |
R3 326 335.06 |
Exactech (Pty) Ltd |
R1 101 085,60 |
||||
6 |
CC v Mpact and Others |
26 May 2016 |
Century Technical Solutions (Pty) Ltd |
R1 005 700,00 |
R1 583 149.93 |
Exactech (Pty) Ltd |
R341 114,20 |
||||
Matlama Consulting (Pty) Ltd |
R236 335,73 |
||||
7 |
CC v Maersk and Others |
28 September 2016 |
Century Technical Solutions (Pty) Ltd |
R1 917 956,00 |
R4 130 992.54 |
Exactech (Pty) Ltd |
R2 213 036,54 |
||||
8 |
CC v Wilmar Continental Edible Oils and Fats (Pty) Ltd & Others |
08 December 2016 |
Century Technical Solutions (Pty Ltd |
R1 619 004,00 |
R3 017 837.08 |
Exactech (Pty) Ltd |
R1 398 833,08 |
||||
9 |
CC v Fresh Produce Market Agents |
23 March 2017 |
Century Technical Solutions (Pty Ltd |
R3 496 379,78 |
R8 966 439.38 |
Exactech (Pty) Ltd |
R5 470 059,60 |
||||
10 |
CC v Feedlots Association of South Africa and its Members |
14 June 2017 |
Century Technical Solutions (Pty Ltd |
R4 504 140,00 |
R11 574 533.60 |
Exactech (Pty) Ltd |
R3 693 011,60 |
||||
eCybersystems (Pty) Ltd |
R3 377 382,00 |
||||
11 |
CC v Automatic Sprinkler Inspection Bureau and its Members |
03 August 2017 |
Century Technical Solutions (Pty Ltd |
R5 487 504,00 |
R12 374 792.49 |
Exactech (Pty) Ltd |
R1 975 524,00 |
||||
eCybersystems (Pty) Ltd |
R4 777 680,00 |
||||
Itsamaya Consulting |
R134 084,49 |
||||
12 |
CC v Altech UEC South Africa (Pty) Ltd and Others |
16 November 2017 |
Century Technical Solutions (Pty Ltd |
R 659 893.96 |
R1 710 768.34 |
Exactech (Pty) Ltd |
R 536 603,68 |
||||
eCybersystems (Pty) Ltd |
R514 270,70 |
||||
Grant Total |
R57 773 476.59 |
-END-