Questions and Replies

Reply:

Yes. However it should be noted that the amount specified was not spent on paying monthly stipend to participants only. The expenditure included payment of tuition fees to various TVET Colleges, meals and transport costs.

 a) 4765 youth registered as at 31 August 2017.

 b) 4765.

 c) Please refer to the table below.

PROVINCE	PARTICIPANTS PAID R1320 STIPEND	PARTICIPANTS PAID R2180 ADDITIONAL ALLOWANCE AND R1320 STIPEND	TOTAL
Eastern Cape	490	90	580
Free State	390	156	546
Gauteng	100	146	246
Kwa Zulu Natal	647	275	922
Limpopo	566	27	593
Mpumalanga	392	122	514
Northern Cape	240	60	300
North West	418	96	514
Western Cape	348	202	550
TOTAL	3591	1174	4765

Reply:

1. Yes. However the report was returned to the Department for development of definitive proposals.

2. Details of the report will be made available as soon as approved by Cabinet.

3. Yes. The report will be brought to Parliament as soon as approved by cabinet.

Reply:

1. The estimated date after the cabinet process is 31Octo 2017

2. The report was considered by Cabinet in June and was returned to the Department for the development of definitive proposal.

2. No.

Reply:

(a),(b) There are no applications for boards/councils .Members are appointed by the Minister

Reply:

(a) 4345. Please refer to the table below for breakdown per province.

PROVINCE	YEAR	NO. OF LEASE AGREEMENTS
EASTERN CAPE	1999	5
	2000	6
	2001	3
	2002	3
	2003	3
	2004	7
	2005	4
	2006	4
	2007	14
	2008	42
	2009	37
	2010	24
	2011	26
	2012	25
	2013	27
	2015	5
	2016	12
EASTERN CAPE TOTAL		247
FREE STATE	2008	1
	2009	3
	2010	4
	2011	64
	2012	163
	2013	43
	2014	9
	2016	81
	2017	20
FREE STATE Total		388
GAUTENG	2004	1
	2006	2
	2007	59
	2008	29
	2009	24
	2010	101
	2011	31
	2012	36
	2013	44
	2015	23
	2016	13
	2017	2
GAUTENG Total		365
KWAZULU-NATAL	1995	1
	2003	15
	2005	1
	2006	6
	2007	27
	2008	26
	2009	18
	2010	29
	2011	21
	2012	11
	2013	6
	2016	15
KWAZULU-NATAL Total		176
LIMPOPO	1998	4
	2002	1
	2004	34
	2005	10
	2006	6
	2007	4
	2008	26
	2009	71
	2010	67
	2011	36
	2012	79
	2013	25
	2014	1
	2015	7
	2016	34
	2017	5
LIMPOPO Total		410
MPUMALANGA	1997	2
	2000	12
	2006	4
	2007	121
	2008	76
	2009	137
	2010	274
	2011	130
	2012	157
	2013	132
	2014	1
	2015	7
	2016	7
	2017	5
MPUMALANGA Total		1065
NORTH WEST	2002	3
	2003	1
	2004	1
	2005	5
	2006	13
	2007	68
	2008	62
	2009	141
	2010	167
	2011	239
	2012	158
	2013	108
	2014	11
	2015	48
	2016	82
	2017	42
NORTH WEST Total		1149
NORTHERN CAPE	2006	1
	2007	2
	2008	13
	2009	53
	2010	47
	2011	74
	2012	43
	2013	46
	2015	42
	2016	89
	2017	20
NORTHERN CAPE Total		430
WESTERN CAPE	2007	2
	2008	8
	2009	18
	2010	12
	2011	6
	2012	26
	2013	14
	2014	2
	2015	6
	2016	19
	2017	2
WESTERN CAPE Total		115
Grand Total		4345

(b) Rental amount collected by State Land Lease Debtors on specified Leases
	2011/2012	2012/2013	2013/2014	2014/2015	2015/2016	2016/2017	TOTAL
EC	89 071.07	123 996.34	178 248.40	94 396.00	48 779.90	249 056.60	783 548.31
FS	355 863.14	349 063.88	363 273.59	544 373.97	525 502.13	569 537.64	2 707 614.35
GP	90 831.91	109 548.38	121 140.40	29 012.20	271 444.94	451 614.52	1 073 592.35
KZN	112 129.50	14 383.75	152 107.73	144 233.39	153 913.33	198 573.08	775 340.78
LP	177 497.15	189 998.14	126 870.37	1 050 649.68	28 225.04	307 280.39	1 880 520.77
MP	64 666.99	55 931.29	68 657.62	13 112.54	446 701.19	7 210 705.23	7 859 774.86
NC	159 347.59	106 231.44	130 539.66	60 085.30	220 250.00	703 271.85	1 379 725.84
NW	1 304 415.45	1 390 498.52	1 164 881.64	381 455.01	549 388.42	1 285 256.43	6 075 895.47
Total	2 353 822.80	2 339 651.74	2 305 719.41	2 317 318.09	2 244 204.95	10 975 295.74	22 536 012.73

(b) (i )Rental amount collected by ALHA on specified Leases
Province	2011	2012	2013	2014	2015	2016	2017	TOTAL
EC	121 173	885 218	1 391 593	362 877	158 643	552 977	838 502	4 310 983
FS	-	53 157	505 285	725 981	263 345	838 905	1 008 345	3 395 018
GP	25 000	108 000	643 003	346 813	-	127 688	191 328	1 441 832
KZN	1 623 241	4 171 773	5 340 746	1 014 388	467 844	312 302	1 547 229	14 477 523
LP	-	77 795	414 162	196 552	142 068	97 012	244 406	1 171 995
MP	774 692	7 125 631	10 396 864	1 261 190	266 605	618 871	2 693 299	23 137 152
NW	87 087	509 699	1 029 662	753 918	680 688	169 996	1 309 277	4 540 327
NC	117 001	1 004 231	400 721	478 145	453 242	113 388	242 406	2 809 134
WC	603 561	323 119	354 009	1 021 715	193 747	599 801	862 972	3 958 924
Total	3 351 755	14 258 623	20 476 045	6 161 579	2 626 182	3 430 940	8 937 764	59 242 888

Reply:

Department / Entity	Period	(i) Name of transaction advisors	(ii) Tenders appointed for	(iii) Pricing for tenders	(iv) Amount paid to transaction advisors from 01 Jan 2012 to 31 Dec 2016
(a) DRDLR	2004 to date	SPP Project Solutions Pty (Ltd)	Appointment of transactional advisor for the procurement of a suitable and sustainable services working environment (new head office) through a public private partnership	PPP project value R1 772 327 000 Transactional advisor contract value R10 585 443.00 (Including VAT excluding disbursements	R5 534 878.50
(b) Entities	None

Reply:

(1)(a) Yes.

  (i) DRDLR entered into a MoA with Okhahlamba Local Municipality on 20 December 2016.

  (ii) DRDLR has funded similar projects in previous financial years like the The Beaufort West Youth Hub in Western Cape; and the Jacobsdal Sport Complex and Community facility in the Free State province. The agreement stipulates that an amount of R20m will be made available over the 2016-2017 and 2017-2018 financial years based on invoices submitted; and based on physical progress onsite.

  (iii) Cabinet approved the Comprehensive Rural Development Programme (CRDP) in 2009 that provides the statutory grounds for supporting this project.

(b) Falls away

(2)   Yes. The Municipality requested project support directly from the DRDLR.

  (a) The Mayor of Okhamhlamba, formally requested support for the project on the 24 February 2016.

   (b) Falls away, answered in section 1(a)(ii) above.

(3) DRDLR signed the agreement with the Okhahlamba Local Municipality, not with a third party.

Reply:

(a) The farm owners have sued for the eviction of long term occupiers and cited the National Governments (represented by the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform (DRDLR) and Provincial Government (represented by Department of Human Settlement) and Local Government (both District and Local Municipality for the provision of alternative accommodation and land for the re-settlement of the occupiers. DRDLR had an engagement with the farm owners and the offer for acquisition of a portion of the farm for settlement of the occupiers was not accepted by the farm owners who further advised that they further needed the property for development of citrus and other benefits where the occupier’s houses are. The municipality made an offer to the farm owners to make land available and develop same for human settlement and would give preference to the long term occupiers. The Court has required the Department to provide reports in terms of Extension of Security of Tenure Act 62 of 1997 (ESTA) has been submitted and the Municipality to submit a report on the availability of land as promised. The report from the Municipality is still outstanding. DRDLR has engaged the Land Rights Management Facility and a lawyer (Siyabonga Cokile) was appointed to represent the occupiers.

(b) The matter is in the Port Elizabeth Regional Court. The matter is still pending, awaiting the report from the Municipality before the Court further decides on the application. There is no solution yet because the matter is still at Court. And the court has instructed the Local Municipality to provide a report on the availability of suitable alternative accommodation.

Reply:

1. No.

2. (a),(b),(i), (ii) Falls away.

3. (a), (b), (c) Falls away.

4. None.

Reply:

1. (a) Zero. The LRAD Programme resulted in beneficiaries receiving freehold title.

(b)(i),(ii) Falls Away

(2) (a),(b) Falls Away

(3) (a) Information on cash and non-cash contribution by LRAD beneficiaries was not kept centrally in each Province.

(b)(i),(ii) Please refer to Annexure A.

ANNEXURE A TO NA-QUES 2124 OF 2017

CONTRIBUTIONS TO LAND PURCHASE

	2000	2000/2001	2001/2002	2002/2003	2003/2004	2004/2005	2005/2006	2006/2007	2007/2008	2008/2009
EC	R 0	R 276 950	R 9 365 000	R 24 442 997	R 46 955 893	R 44 371 045.28	R 45 465 611	R 23 556 286	R 17 367 825.94	R 31 123 570
FS	R 0	R 125 650	R 5 379 615	R 15 569 071	R 21 173 777	R 11 235 320.46	R 23 306 327	R 19 431 269	R 9 274 445.74	R 16 256 325
GP	R 400 000	R 901 000	R 375 000	R 6 025 733	R 13 728 222	R 3 817 338.39	R 6 979 509	R 3 265 000	R 1 631 930.00	R 0
KZN	R 0	R 4 297 378	R 20 688 054	R 5 976 840	R 17 507 302	R 85 929 385.24	R 83 952 219	R 40 957 187	R 41 473 367.96	R 143 343 228
LP	R 0	R 6 000 000	R 665 000	R 8 031 870	R 4 224 054	R 4 721 278.00	R 8 408 160	R 19 159 784	R 3 241 000.00	R 174 433 910
MP	R 315 000	R 80 000	R 14 422 790	R 56 053 054	R 21 392 975	R 32 848 320.00	R 29 847 549	R 1 292 000	R 5 829 792.37	R 15 934 431
NC	R 0	R 0	R 8 573 127	R 10 293 080	R 2 640 309	R 18 178 000.00	R 21 019 974	R 25 918 662	R 2 848 550.00	R 7 093 321
NW	R 0	R 830 000	R 1 636 040	R 21 040 458	R 26 700 664	R 29 404 323.27	R 36 212 721	R 12 044 406	R 13 140 876.00	R 3 638 341
WC	R 0	R 0	R 16 639 890	R 35 493 861	R 35 690 152	R 16 581 304.94	R 61 130 635	R 53 339 495	R 64 353 043.89	R 672 221 898
TOTALS	R 715 000	R 12 510 978	R 77 744 516	R 182 926 964	R 190 013 347	R 247 086 316	R 316 322 705	R 198 964 088	R159 160 831.90	R 1 064 045 023

	2009/2010	2010/2011	2011/2012
EC	R 46 967 671	R 5 052 032	R 0
FS	R 75 865 621	R 8 515 629	R 0
GP	R 7 392 560	R 1 060 000	R 0
KZN	R 171 305 994	R 19 275 000	R 5 900 000
LP	R 176 323 460	R 48 894 000	R 1 500 000
MP	R 44 378 021	R 14 862 000	R 3 460 000
NC	R 7 310 294	R 0	R 0
NW	R 38 374 015	R 30 390 453	R 0
WC	R 99 113 896	R 75 317 842	R 0
TOTALS	R 667 031 533	R 203 366 956	R 10 860 000

Reply:

Yes.

   (a) Mr Evgueni Victorovich Zakharov of 8 Mile Investments 483 (Propriety) Limited.

   (b) 28 years and 10 months.

2. Yes.

(a) ,(b) The beneficiaries benefit through the lease rental of R2.5 million per annum which is renewable after 5 years. There is 10% rental escalation every 5 years (effective on the 6th year). There is a 50% profit on class 1 and 2 exports that comes to the CPA for the benefit of the CPA members. Class 3 profits go to operations. Please refer to Annexure A (signed contract).

3. Yes. There are 253 permanent workers who are unionised under FAWU and their minimum wage is R3 600.00. There are also temporary workers who earn R15.39/hour.

4. (a) Yes; though it is not the competency of the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform, we established that the workers are registered for UIF.

(b) Yes, there is an annual increment every March as per the standing agreement with the Union.

5. (a) 108 beneficiaries.

   (b) 108 (same as above) beneficiaries work on the Bjatladi CPA property. The 108 workers are part of the 253 permanent workers.

Reply:

(a),(b) No.

(i),(ii)(aa),(aa)(aaa),(bbb),(bb),(cc) Falls away.

Reply:

1. According to the court order, the community land claim has been deconsolidated into family constituent land claims as per the original land claim forms. These claims are currently being investigated individually.

2. Yes, matter has been remitted to the Commission to degazette the community land claim, and conduct further investigation of individual family claims.

3. Yes, community land claim is degazetted, and we are currently investigating them individually.

Reply:

Yes. Both policy frameworks; the Strengthening of Relative Rights for People Working the Land and One Household One Hectare 1 Hectare 2 Dairy Cows are attached as Annexures A and B.

 

Reply:

The Department has not attempted to force Ndabeni claimants to dissolve the community trust, but impressed upon claimants that their needs and aspirations would be optimized much better through a democratic and accountable legal entity like a Communal Property Association than by a Trust where consultations with beneficiaries are not as focussed and or required. Trusts are under the oversight of the Master of the High Court, whereas Communal Property Associations are under the oversight of the Department.

Reply:

a) The land claimant verification for the Kwandabeni claim was conducted on three occasions in 2012, 2013 and 2015. It has to be noted that the final verification list was to be taken to the community for objection and comments. However, this could not materialize due to conflicts experienced within the Kwandabeni claimant community.

b) The lack of continuity is the reason why there have been many verifications as new Trustees after elections would not continue with the verification that was conducted during the tenure of the erstwhile Trustees.

c) The verification was done internally by the Office of the Regional Land Claims Commissioner.

d) No amount was spent by the Department.

Reply:

(a) The main cause of the delays have been two litigation matters before the High Court of South Africa, Western Cape which were brought by the applicants “Trustees Elect Ndabeni” and “Ms Fikiswa Fesi” as a member of the Trust respectively .

(b)(i) The Department has opposed the action brought by the Trustee elect to compel the Master of the High Court to formally appoint them as trustees because of irregular processes leading up to such elections and has supported Ms Fesi in her application to have the sale agreement of restituted land parcels set aside because such agreement had not been resolved in a properly constituted community meeting.

(ii) The Department has ensured that alienation of the restituted land could not be registered at the Deeds Office which would have resulted in gross injustice and substantial prejudice to all Ndabeni claimants and beneficiaries since the intended sale would have been for a third of the actual market value of the said land.

Reply:

(a) The farm Papkuilfontein 469 JR was acquired by the then South African Development Trust during 1989 to be incorporated into the former Homeland of KwaNdebele, and is held vide Title Deed No T32900/1985. The farm Papkuilfontein 469 JR (including Unit 2 of the farm Papkuilfontein No: 469 JR has been under the management and control of Government since 1985 until the date of transfer to the claimants. These properties have not been valued since registration in the name of the Republic of South Africa during 1985. As a cost cutting measure the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform’s Mpumalanga Regional Land Claims Commission conducted “comparable sales” to establish the comparable value of the farm in question.

(b) The comparable sale done was with the farm Wolvenkop 192 JR where a valuation report was done in 2012. According to the valuation report done, the price of the farm Wolvenkop was between R4100 to R9000 per hectare at that time. The conclusion of the independent valuer was at R2 970 000.00 for the farm Wolvenkop 192 JR, in extent of 762.2389 hectares of natural grazing. Another farm in the same area of Papkuilfontein 469 JR, where comparable sales value was used, was the farm Waterval 34 JS, where the independent valuer arrived at a value of R2500 to R5000 per hectare. The conclusion of the independent valuer was at R400 000.00 for 137.8533 hectares in extent.

Reply:

(1) 4024 land claims settled in Limpopo as at 31 March 2017

(2) (a) 4095 land claims finalised as of 31 March 2017 in Limpopo

(b) 507 land claims outstanding as at 31 March 2017 in Limpopo

(c) 16349 new land claims lodged as at 27 June 2016 in Limpopo

(3) (a),(b) The information is currently not available.

Reply:

1. Yes.

 (a) Land Claims were lodged through Restitution of Land Rights Act of 1994 by both Makgasa CPA and Dalamuzi CPA.

 (b) The property has been transferred to Makgasa CPA and Dalamuzi CPA.

2. (a) Agriculture.

   (b) Makgasa CPA & Dalamuzi CPA.

   (c) Please refer to Annexure A.

   (d) Under the existing lease agreements.

   (e) Please refer to Annexure A.

   (f) Expired contracts will not be renewed until an amicable solution has been reached with concerned parties, namely the new owners (Communal Property Associations) and the occupiers.

3. No. Arbitrary evictions cannot be effected in the current constitutional dispensation.

(a) The Department will conduct a land rights enquiry in the next two weeks to determine the rights that any affected party might have. A report on such should therefore be available for consideration on Monday 24th September 2017. Engagements with the aim of resolving the matter will be engaged in as soon as report on land rights is available, taking into consideration such rights and interests of parties affected. Solutions to be explored may include notarial servitude in favour of occupiers, suitable alternative land and or excising of affected portions. Guidance on how such matters should be dealt with has been provided in law namely by the Constitutional Court in the matter of Occupiers of erven 87 & 88 of Berea v Christiaan Frederick De Wet N.O (2017) 18, where the Court found that eviction that lead to homelessness are unlawful, even if agreed to by those who stand to be evicted. There is a duty therefore for the Department to act within the parameters set by law.

(b) Investigation on developments effected whilst on the land will form part of the enquiry.

UNIT NO	PROPERTY DESCRIPTION	PORTION	EXTENT IN HECTARES	CLAIMSNTS IN OWNERSHIP OF PROPERTIES	REGISTRATION DATE	(C) LESSEES	(e) Duration	CONTRACT START DATE	CONTRACT END DATE
							Started	End
203	Papkuilfontein 469 JR	3	342.6128 H	Makgasa CPA	26 July 2016	Boitumelo Thabea Mokwena	2012/01/10	31/09/2015	2012/01/10	31/09/2015
204	Papkuilfontein 469 JR			Makgasa CPA	26 July 2016	Mdlakakhe Letta Mtsweni,	2013/01/04	31/03/2018	2013/01/04	31/03/2018
206	Papkuilfontein 469 JR	0	605.6095 H	Dalamuzi CPA	04 December 2015	Makhahamola George Maluleka,	2010/01/04	31/03/2013	2010/01/04	31/03/2013
207				Dalamuzi CPA	04 December 2015	Vumela Petrus Skosana,	2010/01/04	31/03/2013	2010/01/04	31/03/2013
208				Dalamuzi CPA	04 December 2015	Buti January Ndluli	2010/01/02	31/01/2013	2010/01/02	31/01/2013
208	Papkuilfontein 469 JR	4	187.6172 H	Makgasa CPA	26 July 2016	Buti January Ndluli	2010/01/02	31/01/2013	2010/01/02	31/01/2013
206						Makhahamola George Maluleka,	2010/01/04	31/03/2013	2010/01/04	31/03/2013
210
209	Papkuilfontein 469 JR	9	382.8403 H	Makgasa CPA	26 July 2016	Never leased	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A
210				Makgasa CPA	26 July 2016	Never leased	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A
211	Papkuilfontein 469 JR	2	570.4574 H	Makgasa CPA	26 July 2016	Magale Joana Mahlangu	2010/01/02	31/01/2013	2010/01/02	31/01/2013
212	Papkuilfontein 469 JR	1	570.4574 H	Makgasa CPA	26 July 2016	Babhalile Zelda Ntuli	2012/01/04	31/03/2017	2012/01/04	31/03/2017
213	Papkuilfontein 469 JR	5	155.2186 H	Makgasa CPA	26 July 2016	Boy Josias Mabena	2013/01/04	31/03/2018	2013/01/04	31/03/2018
		6	150.0794 H
		7	150.0794 H
		8	150.0794 H
167	Papkuilfontein 469 JR	3	96.0000ha	Makgasa CPA	26 July 2016	Johannes Niniwe Skhosana	2010/01/04	31/03/2013

ANNEXURE A OF NA-QUESTION 2376 OF 2017

Reply:

Since inception of Land Redistribution for Agricultural Development (LRAD) programme
(b)(i)(ii) (aa)	(a)	(b)(i)	(b)(ii) and (c)
Province	Number of Beneficiaries	Number of Farms	Totals Hectares purchased and transferred
EC	7117	506	191171
FS	4027	466	125899
GP	2832	148	7262
KZN	22501	343	187772
LP	3921	222	45352
MP	8891	187	92900
NC	1215	122	120656
NW	4840	255	164852
WC	14254	165	229593
TOTALS	69598	2414	1165458

(aa)(aaa),(bbb) Please refer to Annexure A for provincial breakdown per annum since inception.

(bb) None; the programme provides for full ownership by beneficiaries.

(aaa),(bbb) Falls Away.

Reply:

a) A complaint was lodged with the Office of the Deputy Minister Skwatsha by beneficiaries about the trust selling the land.

b) Mr Max Ozinsky was chief of staff in the office of Deputy Minister Skwatsha.

Reply:

(a),(b),(c) No.

(i),(ii),(iii),(aa),(bb),(cc) Falls away.

Reply:

1. (a) The Ingonyama Trust Board and Deeds Registration Branch with [ Deeds Registries Regulations Board and Sectional Titles Regulation Board ].

 (b) Falls away,

(i),(aa) Ingonyama Trust Board a board in place comprising of 9 members. The term of office of the Board is 4 years. Of these 9 members of the Board 3 are female.

The board members are as follows with their designations and appointment dates.

NAME & SURNAME	DESIGNATION	APPOINTMENT DATE
Hon Mr Justice S J Ngwenya	Chairperson – Royal nominee	01 July 2016
Ms J T J Bhengu	Vice Chairperson	01 July 2016
Adv W E R Raubenheimer	Member	01 July 2016
Mr B L Shabalala	Member	01 July 2016
Inkosi T W Mavundla	Member	01 July 2016
Inkosi Z T Gumede	Member	01 July 2016
Inkosi P R Bele	Member	01 July 2016
Inkosi S E Shabalala	Member	01 July 2016
Dr M S Mbatha	Member	01 July 2016

(i),(aa), (bb) Members of the Deeds Registries Regulation Board and Sectional Titles Regulation Board were appointed with effect from 08 March 2017 to 31 December 2019.

(ii), (bb) There are five (5) members for the Deeds Registries Regulation Board. For every member of the board appointed there is an alternate member appointed. There are Two (2) female who are members and One (1) female who is an alternate member.

There are Nine (9) members for the Sectional Titles Regulation Board. For every member of the board appointed there is an alternate member appointed. There are Four (4) female who are members of the board.

(2) Falls away.

Reply:

(a),(b) (i) The Department of Rural Development and Land Reform does not have information relating to Traditional Councils.

(ii) Please refer to the table below.

Table 1: Land transferred to CPAs
PROVINCE	NO OF CPAs REGISTERED	TOTAL
Eastern Cape	218	188 504.5102
Free State	68	62 914.6750
Gauteng	31	11 900.8264
Kwazulu Natal	357	458 738.6090
Limpopo	183	241 991.6990
Mpumalanga	359	327 108.1962
Northern Cape	82	369 659.8675
North West	185	692 234.1796
Western Cape	30	30 240.9646
TOTAL	1513	2 383 293.5275

Reply:

(a)(i),(ii),(iii)(aa),(bb),(b)(i),(ii) The Department of Rural Development and Land Reform’s Communal Property Institutions (CPI) Directorate only maintains a database of CPAs according to provinces. The database does not contain information on specific location of a CPA, or whether they are located within areas governed and controlled by traditional councils. The Department has registered 1513 CPAs to date. Details are submitted with National Assembly, Question 1068 and are also published in the Annual Report on CPAs tabled in Parliament annually.

Reply:

(a) Our biggest challenge remains the answer to the question – Who owns South Africa? We have just concluded Phase Two: Land Audit in terms of land ownership by race, gender and nationality but still face further challenges as a result of the absence of information in respect of institutions, such as trusts, private and public organisations and companies, as well as sectional title holdings. The source of this enduring challenge is incoherent institutional transformation, both within and external to the DRDLR, for example:

• the absence of a dynamic, interactive relationship between the National Geomatics Management Services (NGMS) and the Deeds Registration system even though the former feeds into the latter; and,
• we have projectised the land claims process. This was a strategic error, which did not take into account fiscal constraints, complexities associated with verification/validation of claims, court challenges and internal capacity constraints.

A further challenge relates to water rights being allocated to individuals, not to the land. When an individual sells the land, he/she leaves with the water rights. Furthermore, subdivisions and changes of land use are happening at a rapid pace. An audit needs to be conducted in respect of both these issues, because they impact negatively on land reform farms. Although regulated by laws, compliance with and enforcement of such legislation needs to be strengthened

(b) The steps the Department is proposing, aligned with radical economic transformation, includes transforming the Land Claims Commission into a Chapter 9 Institution and the NGMS, Deeds Registries and Office of the Valuer-General will be listed as Schedule 2 entities in terms of the Public Finance Management Act, 1999.

DRDLR is also implementing the following measures in its efforts to enhance land reform:

• Introduction of the Regulation of Agricultural Landholdings Bill to Parliament which aims to obtain and access agricultural land as well as to incentivise “national economy responsibility” from farm-land owners, agro-business and primary agriculture magnates and their links to secondary, tertiary international business dimensions and partners. The Land Commission provided for in the Regulation of Agricultural Land Bill, will enforce disclosure of ownership of land and landed property.
• The Agri-Parks programme which aims at transforming the rural economy. It seeks to improve production by small holder farmers, access to markets, finance and research and engagement in the whole agriculture value chain. It is designed to promote cooperative efforts between government, private sector, and rural communities.
• The 1 Household 1 Hectare Programme and 1 Household 2 Dairy Cows Programme is intended to improve production and food security at household level to contribute to the increase in the number of small holder farmers.
• Strenghtening of relative rights of people working the land (50/50) seeks to secure the land rights and residential tenure of the farm-dweller/worker; empower people working the land to acquire majority equity-holdings in farming enterprises and bring about economic transformation of the agricultural sector. It enables farm workers/farm dwellers to sell labour-power across the fence, without fear of eviction; strengthen farmworkers’ bargaining power in advancing worker rights and improving his/her conditions of living; and, address socio-economic livelihood challenges faced by farm dwellers/workers and labour tenants. It will further address land hunger, extreme land concentration, associated poverty and inequity by fostering asset and enterprise equity that introduce fundamental changes to land relations and factors of production.

Reply:

a) R 33 billion.

b) Land Restitution.

Reply:

1. On 02 September 2002, the then Department of Land Affairs (DLA) appointed Mr J Benade as a Commissioner for designation of Farms No. 466 and 467 and Portion 1 of Farm No. 469 known as Thornham and currently registered in favour of HW Botha and others. On 29 November 2002 and 7 November 2003, Mr Benade advertised in a Jeffrey’s Bay newspaper (“Our Times”) calling for people who claimed to have an associated land right to make a submission to him in accordance with section 6(1) the Land Titles Adjustment Act, 1993 (Act No. 111 of 1993). In accordance with the above-mentioned section of the Act, the adverts gave a period of two months for people to register their claims.

On 23 July 2004 Mr Benade provided a written statement to the DLA as to whom the property should be registered. The statement declared that the property should be registered in the name of the Thornham Communal Property Association [CPA]. The CPA members would be comprised of those people Mr Benade had verified as landowners. The Thornham CPA was therefore registered on 13 November 2002 (Registration Number CPA/ 00/0487/A). Paragraph 6.1 of the CPA constitution limits the membership primarily to the descendants of the Cunningham and Thorn Families.

On 18 November 2004, Mr Benade passed away. The Department at the time assumed that the late Mr Benade had completed his responsibilities to the Department and claimants as he has made his transfer recommendations to the State Attorney.

In 2006, Mr Dennis Botha of the Thornham Property Owners Association approached the Department with an appeal against the allocation of a title deed to the Thornham Communal Property Association. Mr Botha claimed that the CPA formulation process was flawed and that CPA membership and ownership of the identified property was thus disputed. The Thornham Property Association is represented by Bennett Attorneys and Mr Bennett requested that an alternative Commissioner be appointed in terms of section 3(4) of the Land Titles Adjustment Act, 1993 which provides that another Title Adjustment Commissioner may be appointed if a Commissioner is unable to perform his/her duties.

The challenge in the Thornham case is that the formal function of the appointed Commissioner was already completed in November 2004 with transfer instructions being made to the State Attorney. Mr Bennett was advised that section 3(4) of the Land Titles Adjustment Act does not apply in this case because the Bennett appeal was submitted in September 2006 almost two years after the allocation of the land was done. The two month comment period as provided for in terms of in section 6(1) and advertised in 2002 and 2003 had long expired.

The Department was required to submit proof of this process to support the argument that Mr Bennett’s appeal is late but unfortunately the Department was unable to find any proof of advertisement in terms of section 7(1) of the Act which calls for the Commissioner to advertise his findings for comment by the larger community and the Commissioner had passed on. This meant that in terms of the Act, an alternative Commissioner would have to be appointed but the findings of the first Commissioner would have to be set aside.

The Thornham Property Association through Mr Bennett, filed papers on 13 December 2007 with the Grahamstown High Court seeking the reversal of the findings of the Title Adjustment Commissioner ie the late Mr Benade. The Department was cited as the second respondent and the papers were served to the State Attorney in Port Elizabeth. The Department did not oppose the application because the CPA had informed the Department of its decision not to oppose the application due to their dissatisfaction with the number of people who were left out of the process and those who were identified as beneficiaries.

The Court issued an order for the Land Title Adjustment process conducted and concluded by the late Mr Benade to be set aside; secondly, that another process to determine beneficiaries be opened afresh; and thirdly the Department should pay the costs. The Department facilitated the appointment of a new Commissioner and it was approved by the Minister on 9 June 2010. The Commissioner (Commissioner Bacela) began to work with the community thereafter and was required, in terms of the contract, to complete her work in two years. During her contract period there was a period when the Commissioner could not discharge her duties due to the fact that she was also appointed as an Acting Judge of the High Court. This contributed immensely to the delay in the finalisation of the facilitation process.

During 2016 the Department engaged the Commissioner on the progress of her work and found it unsatisfactory. The Department decided to terminate the contract with Commissioner Bacela. The Department is in the process of drafting Terms of Reference for the appointment of a new Commissioner.

2. (a) There is no registered Trust in Thornham; Trust beneficiaries of Thornham must still be determined once a Commissioner is appointed.

(b) Falls away; see (2)(a) above.

(c) (i),(ii) Falls away.

(d) Falls away.

(e) The Department is not aware of these allegations.

(f) (i) Falls away.

(ii) The Department is not aware of an interim committee.

 

Reply:

(i) The Department does not have records on information relating to Trusts. Such information can be obtained from the Master of High Court.

(ii) The Department has registered 1513 CPAs to date.

(aa),(bb),(b) Please refer to Annexure A for details of CPAs per province.

Reply:

a) 2 033 199 hectares.

b) 1 979 966 hectares.

c) 1 160 065 hectares.

(d),(e) 698 226 hectares. It is assumed that the honourable member is referring to the Settlement Land Acquisition Grant (SLAG).

Reply:

(a),(b),(c)(i),(ii),(iii)(aa),(bb),(cc) Please refer to the table below.

No	Details	(a) Travel Costs	(b) Accommodation Costs	(C) Subsistence Costs
(aa) 2014/15
(i)	Nkwinti Ernest Gugile Mr	R 508 090.67	R 14 840.53	R 0
(ii)	Dlamini-Mashego Candith Kwati Ms	R 536 209.34	R 8 514.64	R 0
(ii)	Skwatsha Mcebisi DM	R 547 219.60	R 65 687.71	R 0
(iii)	Page Linda Mrs	R 0	R 0	R 7 428.62
(iii)	Mxotwa Mtobeli Mr	R 40 239.44	R 12 076.40	R 47 295.11
TOTAL	R 1 631 759.05	R 101 119.28	R 54 723.73
(bb) 2015/16
(i)	Nkwinti Ernest Gugile Mr	R 2 300 280.38	R 31 208.47	R 0
(ii)	Dlamini-Mashego Candith Kwati Ms	R 390 033.32	R 18 962.57	R 0
(ii)	Skwatsha Mcebisi DM	R 984 548.03	R 80 442.91	R 0
(iii)	Page Linda Mrs	R 76 033.62	R 15 406.83	R 9 241.45
(iii)	Mxotwa Mtobeli Mr	R 10 568.48	R 0	R 35 444.00
TOTAL	R 3 761 463.83	R 146 020.78	R 44 685.45
(cc)2016/2017
(i)	Nkwinti Ernest Gugile Mr	R 3 502 895.00	R 25 540.00	R 0
(ii)	Dlamini-Mashego Candith Kwati Ms	R 398 023.00	R 16 295.00	R 0
(ii)	Skwatsha Mcebisi DM	R 1 162 377.00	R 110 016.00	R 0
(iii)	Page Linda Mrs	R 89 145	R 14 250.00	R 5 491.00
TOTAL	R 5 152 440.00	R 166 110.00	R 5 491.00

Reply:

(a),(b)(i),(ii),(aa),(bb),(cc),(dd),(ee),(ff) Please refer to the link table below.

http://pmg-assets.s3-website-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/RNW1501TABLE-170713.pdf

Reply:

(a) 

Province	Total Lodged
Eastern Cape	16,716
Free State	2,682
Gauteng	13,162
KwaZulu-Natal	16,394
Limpopo	3,489
Mpumalanga	3,400
North West	3,902
Northern Cape	3,852
Western Cape	16,099
TOTAL	79,696

(b)

Province	Total Finalised
Eastern Cape	17,489
Free State	3,239
Gauteng	11,164
KwaZulu-Natal	740
Limpopo	4,095
Mpumalanga	2,822
Northern Cape	2,887
North West	2,112
Western Cape	16,502
TOTAL	61,050

 

(c ) (i) 68 661, Annexure A

(ii) 7 478, Annexure B.

 

Reply:

( 1 ) (a) No role, the Trust run its own affairs.

(b) The Commission on Restitution of Land Rights together with the Trustees are currently in the process of verifying the beneficiaries again with the aim of organising an election AGM to elect new Trustees.

( c ) No role, The Commission on Restitution of Land Rights responded to some questions and other questions were responded to by the Trustees.

( 2 ) Not to our knowledge

Reply:

(a),(b)(i),(ii),(iii),(aa),(bb),(aaa),(bbb) Please refer to the table below.

Financial Years	Department/ Entities	(aa)	(bb)
(i) 2014/15	(a) Department	(aaa) Names	(bbb) Professional Designation	(aaa) Detail of Contract Awarded	(bbb) Amounts
		Mr Johannes Siphamandla Mtonga	Registry Clerk	Supplier Name: Rhino JZ Catering and Projects State Entity: Gauteng PSSC Contract Description: Catering Services	R20 030.00
	(b) Entities	(aaa) Names	(bbb) Professional Designation	(aaa) Detail of Contract Awarded	(bbb) Amounts
	Deeds Trading Account	Mr Peter Rakoli Machika	Senior Deeds Registration Officer	Supplier Name: Machi-ra 73 Trading Enterprise CC State Entity: Tshwane Metropolitan Municipality Contract Description: Supply of Geysers	R 28,606.00
				Supplier Name: Machi-ra 73 Trading Enterprise CC State Entity: National Department of Public Works Contract Description: Supply of Office Furniture	R 61,392.00
		Ms Nancy Tebogo Mushi	Deeds Registration Clerk – Contract (lapsed 30.06.2015)	Supplier Name: Sinethamba Construction State Entity: Tshwane Metropolitan Municipality Contract Description: Could not be determined	R 39,004.50
		Mr Bongani Brian Sibuyi	Programmer - Resigned	Supplier Name: Optiflex Trading and Projects State Entity: South African Social Security Agency Contract Description: Could not be determined	R 700.00
		Mr Ziphozonke Professor Nkosi	Deeds Registration Clerk – Contract (lapsed 30.06.2015)	Supplier Name: Prosam Trading State Entity: eThekwini Metro Contract Description: Could not be determined	R 25,000.00
		Ms Sbongile Mpandana	Deeds Registration Clerk	Supplier Name: Bongiwe Majola Trading Enterprise State Entity: Eastern Cape Social Development and Special Programme Contract Description: Could not be determined	R 101,000.00
		Ms Nontokozo Renaisence Mhlongo	Deeds Registration Clerk – Contract (lapsed 30.06.2015)	Supplier Name: Malungi Multi Service State Entity: Kwazulu Natal Department of Education Contract Description: Could not be determined	R 308,252.72
		Mr Sibusiso Rhoda-Cathe Mpangane	Provisioning Clerk	Supplier Name: Praktkal-Con State Entity: Department of Defence Contract Description: Supply of Groceries	R 21,253.00
(ii) 2015/16	Department	N/A	N/A	N/A	R0
(iii) 2016/17	Entities	N/A	N/A	N/A	R0

Reply:

No. The Department of Rural Development and Land Reform did not pronounce that the agricultural production has decreased as result of land transfers.

a) Falls away.

b) Falls away.

Reply:

(a) No. Verification for the Zingcuka could not be completed due to the dispute between the Upper Zingcuka and Amakhuze communities, as there are overlapping boundaries of the claimed land. The Commission on Restitution of Land Rights (CRLR), Department of Agriculture Forestry & Fisheries and Amathole Forestry Company have jointly scheduled meetings during 2017/18 financial year in order to resolve the disputes. Upon resolving of the dispute, the CRLR will proceed with the finalization of the verification process, and the restitution processes will unfold in order for this claim to be settled.

 

Reply:

1. (a) No profit share agreement was signed between the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform (DRDLR), Bono Farm Management and the beneficiaries of Nirwanda Farm in the Hex River Valley.

   (b) The Department has no knowledge of the alleged compensation to beneficiaries since there is no agreement between the Department and the abovementioned parties.

2. (a) …

(b) …

3. (a) The Nirwanda Development Trust consists of the historically permanent workforce that is currently active in the operations of the farm.

    (b) No.

(4)

Name of Official	Designation/Rank	Status of disciplinary action
Ms Babalwa Magoda	Chief Director: Recapitalisation and Development	Official suspended. Disciplinary hearing commenced 17 February 2017 and is continuing.
Mr Vusi Mahlangu	Deputy Director General: Land Reform	Disciplinary Hearing finalised; Official dismissed with effect from 15 June 2016;

 

Reply:

(a) The SA Fruit Exporters (SAFE) doesn’t manage any state owned farm.

(b) Please refer to Annexure A.

2. (a) 30 March 2011.

(b) Please refer to Annexure B.

(c) At the National Department of Rural Development and Land Reform.

3. The database is both national and provincial.

4. (a) Falls Away.

     (b) 7 September 2010.

ANNEXURE A TO NA-QUES 1472 of 2017

Province	Project name	Property Description	Programme/Grant type	Hectares	Strategic Partner/ Mentor
Eastern Cape	Commando Kraal	COMMANDO KRAAL ESTATE - AGRI-VILLAGE COMMONAGE	PLAS	117.2778	Strategic Partner
Eastern Cape	Sunlands Farms	Sunlands Farms - Portion 15,16,18,20,21,23,24-27,150-1,156,159,171 and 195 Farm Selborne No.115;	PLAS	409.7492	Strategic Partner
Eastern Cape	Nebraska	Nebraska 558/15,33 (Buck Kraal)	PLAS	19.2720	Strategic Partner
Western Cape	Ronald Van Schalkwyk	Portion 55,56.58 of farm Bergvallei no 408	PLAS	286	Strategic Partner
Western Cape	Nirwanda	Ptn 53(Ptn of 28) of De La Haye No.92	PLAS	39.1	Strategic Partner
Western Cape	Rietkloof 2 PLAS	Portion 33 of the Farm Rietkloof No. 144	PLAS	320	Strategic Partner
Western Cape	Rietkloof - Mount Piguet	Portions 8, 15, 16, 21, 22 and 23 of Farm No 144, Rietkloof in Piketberg Registration Division	PLAS	981	Strategic Partner
Western Cape	Plateau Farms - Dassiesfontein	The Farms Dassiesfontein - Portion 6 of South, Portion 5 of North and Portion 1 of Farm No. 73	PLAS	3 281	Strategic Partner
Western Cape	Plateau Farms - Rondawel	The Farms Rondawel - Portion 1 & 2 of the Farm Grasplaats No. 113, Portion 2 of Farm Taaibosch Hoek No. 75 & Portion 5 of Farm Bok Poort No. 54 & Portion 4 of Dassiesfontein No. 73	PLAS	4 934	Strategic Partner
Western Cape	Plateau Farms - Melrose	The Farms Melrose- Portion 2 of Farm ADJ Driekop No. 48, Ptn 1 of Farm Taaibosch Hoek No. 75 and Rem Ext of Farm Bonkers Valei No. 76	PLAS	4 860	Strategic Partner
Western Cape	Plateau Farms - Willemskraal	The Farms Willemskraal - Portion 1 of Farm Bonkers Valei No. 76	PLAS	1 662	Strategic Partner
Western Cape	Plateau - Matjieskloof	Portion 1 of the farm Bonkers Valei No. 76	PLAS	4 740	Strategic Partner

Reply:

(a)(i),(ii),(iii)(aa),(bb),(cc),(b),(c) Please refer to the table below.

Fruitless, wasteful and irregular expenditure detected by AGSA
(a)	(b)	(c)
No	Financial years	Description of expenditure	Number of cases	Amount (R000)	Recovered Amount /Remarks
(aa)	2014-15	(i) (ii) Fruitless and wasteful	None	N/A	N/A
		(iii) Irregular expenditure	2	492	Amount was condoned with warning and cautionary letter to officials.
(bb)	2015-16	(i) (ii) Fruitless and wasteful	None	N/A	N/A
		(iii) Irregular expenditure	None	N/A	N/A
(cc)	2016-17	(i) (ii) Fruitless and wasteful	1	2 304	Under investigation.
		(iii) Irregular expenditure	None	N/A	N/A
Total	3	2 796	-

Reply:

(a) 5 farms. This number, however, refers only to farms that were controlled by the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform. It is therefore possible that farms controlled by provincial governments and other national departments were transferred during the same period.

(b) 1 in the Eastern Cape and 4 in the Free State.

(c) See the table below.

Name	Surname
Kheki Jerry	Makhalemele
Robert Lekhooa	Thekiso
Tsepiso Izak	Mokoena
Molehi Richard	Kodisang
Nelson Rolihlahla	Mandela

(d)(i) 5 individuals

(d)(ii)(aa) 1

(d)(ii)(bb) 1

Reply:

(1) (a) R120.7 million.

(b) During the 2015/2016 and 2016/17 FY the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform (DRDLR) spent R93.5 million.

(c) The budget was spent on, production inputs (seeds, fertiliser, chemicals and fuel), Mechanisation inclusive of (tractors, planters, disk harrows, cultivators, boom sprayers) and a harvester, planting support and the physical infrastructure development at Springbokpan Agrihub site.

(d) (i) R 35,4 million was spent on infrastructure implements (Mechanisation and a Harvester) in the 2015/16 and 2016/17 financial years.

(ii) R 46, 6 million was spent on production capacity over the 2015/16 and 2016/17 financial years.

(2) (a) In 2015/16 financial year 5450 ha was planted and in the 2016/17 financial 3050 ha was planted.

(b) Officials from the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform worked with officials from North West Department of Agriculture and Rural Development.

(c) Rural Enterprise and Industrial Development (REID) programme.

(d) In the 2015/16 FY the cost per hectare was R 6 128.00, in the 2016/17 FY the cost per hectare was R4 332.00.

(e) The main crops planted were sunflower and maize.

Reply:

1. The Department of Rural Development and Land Reform has referred this matter for criminal investigation by the relevant law enforcement agencies. As such, the report will not be made public yet.

2. The Minister of Rural Development and Land Reform instructed the recommendations as per the forensic report be implemented and as such:

 a) Please refer to part (1) above.

 b) Disciplinary action has been instituted against the implicated official who is still in the employ of the Department.

c) The Department has instituted preliminary investigations as per the recommendations of the forensic investigation report.

d) A Senior Counsel opinion is being obtained in this regard.

 e) Please refer to part (2)(d) above.

3. Please refer to part (2)(b) above.

Reply:

(a)(i),(aa),(bb),(cc),(ii),(b)(i),(ii),(iii) Due to the nature and volume of information requested, the Department will collate the information and submit to Parliament by 31 July 2017.

Reply:

a) The Mpumalanga Province did not recruit youth into National Rural Youth Service Corps Programme (NARYSEC) during the 2012 financial year. As a result the number of youth currently in the NARYSEC Programme in Mpumalanga Province is lower than other provinces. During the 2017/18 financial year the province will recruit about 300 youth.

The budget is allocated based on the number of participants/students currently in the programme, number of participants/students to be recruited during the financial year and amounts to be paid for training. The budget allocated to Mpumalanga Province was calculated on the same principles.

(b) The budget allocation for Mpumalanga Province has not been reduced but increased by 27.8% in the current financial year from R25.196 m to R32.169 m.

(c) Skills development is allocated 29.9% of the budget.

(d) The monetary value is R9.62 m.

Reply:

(a),(b)(i),(ii) No.

(aa),(bb),(cc),(dd),(ee),(ff) Falls away.

Reply:

(a) (i) Please refer to Annexure A.

(ii) Only 1 (one) borehole was refurbished at a cost of R 58 129.98. All other boreholes were drilled and equipped, as per annexure A.

(iii) Please refer to Annexure A.

(b) (i),(ii) Please refer to the Annexure A.

(c) (i) There were no service providers appointed for maintenance of boreholes. Boreholes were on completion handed over to the farmers (beneficiaries or communities).

(ii) No maintenance costs were incurred by the Department.

ANNEXURE A OF NA QUES 1049 OF 2017

No	Province	Local Municipality	Name	Total Cost per borehole	(a)(i) Drilling cost per metre	(a)(iii) Equipping cost per metre	(b)(i) Type of pump	(b)(ii) Type of equipment installed
1	Free State	Dihlabeng/Maluti a phofung	Bethlehem Camp 1	R 475 218.35	R 320.00	R 3 052.00	Mono	1x5000lt tank on 350mm thick concrete base & 4 drinking troughs and 1 windmill
2	Free State	Dihlabeng/Maluti a phofung	Bethlehem Camp 2	R 475 218.35	R 320.00	R 3 052.00	Mono	1x5000lt tank on 350mm thick concrete base & 4 drinking troughs and 1 windmill
3	Free State	Dihlabeng/Maluti a phofung	Gedachtenis	R 475 218.35	R 320.00	R 3 052.00	Mono	1x5000lt tank on 350mm thick concrete base & 2 drinking troughs and 1 windmill
4	Free State	Dihlabeng/Maluti a phofung	Mahlake 305	R 475 218.35	R 320.00	R 3 052.00	Mono	1x5000lt tank on 350mm thick concrete base & 4 drinking troughs and 1 windmill
5	Free State	Dihlabeng/Maluti a phofung	Mahlake 310	R 475 218.35	R 320.00	R 3 052.00	Mono	1x5000lt tank on 350mm thick concrete base & 4 drinking troughs and 1 windmill
6	KZN	Umkhanyakude	Mcakwini 1	R 526 184.52	R 3 960.51	R 3 892.99	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
7	KZN	Umkhanyakude	Ndombeni	R 526 184.52	R 3 960.51	R 3 892.99	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
8	KZN	Umkhanyakude	Bethangwe	R 526 184.52	R 3 960.51	R 3 892.99	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
9	KZN	Umkhanyakude	Mansiya	R 526 184.52	R 3 960.51	R 3 892.99	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
10	KZN	Umkhanyakude	Manaba	R 526 184.52	R 3 960.51	R 3 892.99	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
11	KZN	Umkhanyakude	Imanzibomvu (Mbazwana)	R 526 184.52	R 3 960.51	R 3 892.99	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
12	KZN	Umkhanyakude	Kwageorge dip	R 526 184.52	R 3 960.51	R 3 892.99	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
13	KZN	Umkhanyakude	Mabandleni dip	R 526 184.52	R 3 960.51	R 3 892.99	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
14	KZN	Umkhanyakude	Mkhumbikazane	R 526 184.52	R 3 960.51	R 3 892.99	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
15	KZN	Umkhanyakude	Thengane dip	R 526 184.52	R 3 960.51	R 3 892.99	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
16	KZN	Umkhanyakude	Bomvini Dip	R 526 184.52	R 3 960.51	R 3 892.99	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
17	KZN	Umkhanyakude	Genuka dip	R 265 354.15	R 3 960.51	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
18	KZN	Umkhanyakude	Mfanela	R 526 184.52	R 3 960.51	R 3 892.99	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
19	KZN	Umkhanyakude	Mthaleni	R 265 354.15	R 3 960.51	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
20	KZN	Umkhanyakude	Mthaleni 2	R 526 184.52	R 3 960.51	R 3 892.99	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
21	KZN	Umkhanyakude	Masakeni	R 265 354.15	R 3 960.51	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
22	KZN	Umkhanyakude	Masakeni 2 (Giba)	R 526 184.52	R 3 960.51	R 3 892.99	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
23	KZN	Umkhanyakude	Nqutshini	R 265 354.15	R 3 960.51	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
24	KZN	Umkhanyakude	Nqutshini 2 (Esimphondweni)	R 526 184.52	R 3 960.51	R 3 892.99	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
25	KZN	Zululand	Ntweni	R 420 891.75	R 736.60	R 2 816.89	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
26	KZN	Zululand	Nkweme	R 420 891.75	R 736.60	R 2 816.89	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
27	KZN	Zululand	Ndololwane	R 420 891.75	R 736.60	R 2 816.89	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
28	KZN	Zululand	Emfemfeni	R 420 891.75	R 736.60	R 2 816.89	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
29	KZN	Zululand	Dabhazi	R 87 246.73	R 736.60	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
30	KZN	Zululand	Dabhazi	R 87 246.73	R 736.60	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
31	KZN	Zululand	Dabhazi	R 420 891.75	R 736.60	R 2 816.89	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
32	KZN	Zululand	KwaMphothi	R 420 891.75	R 736.60	R 2 816.89	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
33	KZN	Zululand	Qanqathu Trust	R 420 891.75	R 736.60	R 2 816.89	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
34	KZN	Uthungulu	Thelumoyaphansi	R 483 218.87	R 1 214.29	R 2 826.97	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
35	KZN	Uthungulu	Matina	R 145 193.84	R 1 214.29	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
36	KZN	Uthungulu	Matina	R 145 193.84	R 1 214.29	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
37	KZN	Uthungulu	Siyangokuya	R 145 193.84	R 1 214.29	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
38	KZN	Uthungulu	Mpongose	R 483 218.87	R 1 214.29	R 2 826.97	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
39	KZN	Uthungulu	Dubeni Dip tank	R 483 218.87	R 1 214.29	R 2 826.97	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
40	KZN	Uthungulu	Ntshiweni Dip Tank	R 145 193.84	R 1 214.29	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
41	KZN	Uthungulu	Patane (Gcobashe)	R 483 218.87	R 1 214.29	R 2 826.97	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
42	KZN	Uthungulu	Mfanisa	R 483 218.87	R 1 214.29	R 2 826.97	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
43	KZN	Uthungulu	Ntuthunga	R 145 193.84	R 1 214.29	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
44	KZN	Uthungulu	eDayini	R 483 218.87	R 1 214.29	R 2 826.97	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
45	KZN	Uthungulu	Sabhuza	R 145 193.84	R 1 214.29	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
46	KZN	Uthungulu	Sabhuza	R 145 193.84	R 1 214.29	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
47	KZN	Uthungulu	Gegethe	R 483 218.87	R 1 214.29	R 2 826.97	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
48	KZN	Amajuba	Inkululeko Yomphakathi	R 407 185.65	R 716.48	R 3 210.10	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
49	KZN	Amajuba	Ndwakazane	R 292 295.64	R 716.48	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
50	KZN	Amajuba	Vaalbank-Esidakeni	R 292 295.64	R 716.48	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
51	KZN	Amajuba	Vaalbank-Esidakeni	R 292 295.64	R 716.48	R 3 210.10	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
52	KZN	Amajuba	Slagveld	R 292 295.64	R 716.48	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
53	KZN	Amajuba	AMAJUBA - OSIZWENI	R 292 295.64	R 716.48	R 3 210.10	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
54	KZN	Amajuba	Jiyane	R 292 295.64	R 716.48	R 3 210.10	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
55	KZN	Amajuba	Waaihoek	R 292 295.64	R 716.48	R 3 210.10	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
56	KZN	Amajuba	Esikhaleni	R 292 295.64	R 716.48	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
57	KZN	Amajuba	Reserve Farm	R 292 295.64	R 716.48	R 3 210.10	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
58	KZN	Amajuba	Bloodriver -Nzimane	R 292 295.64	R 716.48	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
59	KZN	Amajuba	Bloodriver -Nzimane	R 292 295.64	R 716.48	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
60	KZN	Amajuba	AMAJUBA BUFFALO RIVER	R 292 295.64	R 716.48	R 3 210.10	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
61	KZN	Amajuba	Steeling	R 292 295.64	R 716.48	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
62	KZN	Amajuba	Malonjane	R 292 295.64	R 716.48	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
63	KZN	Amajuba	GROOTHOEK	R 292 295.64	R 716.48	R 3 210.10	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
64	KZN	Amajuba	MANCAMANE	R 292 295.64	R 716.48	R 3 210.10	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
65	KZN	Amajuba	WAAIHOEK FARM 2 TRUST	R 292 295.64	R 716.48	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
66	KZN	Amajuba	GROOTVLEI	R 292 295.64	R 716.48	R 3 210.10	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
67	KZN	Amajuba	BEROUW	R 292 295.64	R 716.48	R 3 210.10	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
68	KZN	Umzinyathi	Ward 9	R 322 772.55	R 657.26	R 3 199.74	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
69	KZN	Umzinyathi	Ward 7	R 322 772.55	R 657.26	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
70	KZN	Umzinyathi	Ward 7 Replacement	R 322 772.55	R 657.26	R 3 199.74	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
71	KZN	Umzinyathi	Nquthu Ward 12 Jabuvu	R 322 772.55	R 657.26	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
72	KZN	Umzinyathi	Jabavu - alternate	R 322 772.55	R 657.26	R 3 199.74	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
73	KZN	Umzinyathi	Nquthu Ward 13 Hluleni	R 322 772.55	R 657.26	R 3 199.74	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
74	KZN	Umzinyathi	HLAZAKAZI	R 322 772.55	R 657.26	R 3 199.74	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
75	KZN	Uthukela	Emnambithi piggery	R 322 772.55	R 657.26	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
76	KZN	Uthukela	Mdlatswele -Cornfields	R 322 772.55	R 657.26	R 3 199.74	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
77	KZN	Uthukela	Mkholombe -Weenen	R 322 772.55	R 657.26	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
78	KZN	Uthukela	Khanjana (Nhlambamsoka)	R 322 772.55	R 657.26	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
79	KZN	Uthukela	Rosboom ( Goodhope)	R 322 772.55	R 657.26	R 3 199.74	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
80	KZN	Uthukela	RIETKUIL FARM	R 322 772.55	R 657.26	R 3 199.74	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
81	KZN	Uthukela	KLIP PORT FARM	R 322 772.55	R 657.26	R 3 199.74	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
82	KZN	Uthukela	MANGQATENI	R 322 772.55	R 657.26	R 3 199.74	Mono	3x5000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
83	Limpopo	Greater Giyani	Thomo	R 346 225.00	R 657.26	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
84	Limpopo	Thulamela	Tshifudi	R 415 663.38	R 657.26	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
85	Limpopo	Lephalale	Kgobagodimo	R 482 582.50	R 657.26	No information provided	No information provided	No information provided
86	Mpumalanga	Thembisile Hani	Gemsbokfontein	R 150 000.00	R 657.26	R 3 200.00	Mono	1x10 000lt tanks on 3m stands & 1 troughs on slab
87	Mpumalanga	Bushbuckridge	Welverdiend A	R 315 680.00	R 657.26	R 3 200.00	Mono	1x10 000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
88	Mpumalanga	Chief Albert Luthuli	Lekkerloop (section 2)	R 58 129.98	R 657.26	R 3 200.00	Mono	4x10 000lt tanks on 3m stands & 8 troughs on slab
89	Mpumalanga	Thaba Cheu	Pilgrimrest	R 160 000.00	R 657.26	R 3 200.00	Mono	4 x10 000lt tanks on 3m stands & 16 troughs on slab
90	Mpumalanga	Nkomazi	Strydomblok/Dludluma	R 202 000.00	R 657.26	R 3 200.00	Mono	1x10 000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
91	Mpumalanga	Nkomazi	Goba	R 189 720.00	R 657.26	R 3 200.00	Mono	1x10 000lt tanks on 3m stands & 2 troughs on slab
92	North West	Moses Kotane	DRIEFONTEIN FARM-MMEKWA	R 190 000.00	R 657.26	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill
93	North West	Moses Kotane	DRIEFONTEIN FARM-MONAGENG	R 190 000.00	R 657.26	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill
94	North West	Mahikeng	FARM LUCYDALE-STONE	R 190 000.00	R 657.26	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill
95	North West	Mahikeng	FARM LUCYDALE-MATSHEKA	R 190 000.00	R 657.26	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill
96	North West	Mahikeng	SUNNYSIDE-MOJIWA	R 220 000.00	R 657.26	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill
97	North West	Moses Kotane	VLAKFONTEIN FARM	R 220 000.00	R 0.00	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill
98	North West	Moses Kotane	Driefontein farm-Mabiletsa	R 220 000.00	R 0.00	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill
99	North West	Moses Kotane	Driefontein farm- ntshabele PJ	R 190 000.00	R 0.00	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill
100	North West	Moses Kotane	driefontein farm -Monageng	R 190 000.00	R 0.00	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill
101	North West	Moses Kotane	Donkerhoek farm-Ramokgadi	R 190 000.00	R 0.00	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill
102	North West	Moses Kotane	Driefontein farm-Pitse	R 190 000.00	R 0.00	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill
103	North West	Moses Kotane	Driefontein farm-Lekgotla PN	R 190 000.00	R 0.00	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill
104	North West	Moses Kotane	Donkerhoek farm- Maragel BJ	R 190 000.00	R 0.00	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill
105	North West	Moses Kotane	Donkerhoek farm - Matlapeng	R 190 000.00	R 0.00	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill
106	North West	Moses Kotane	Donkerhoek farm Moraka	R 190 000.00	R 0.00	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill
107	North West	Moses Kotane	Donkerhoek farm- Maragele TM	R 190 000.00	R 0.00	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill
108	North West	Moses Kotane	Driefontein farm-Molefe ES	R 190 000.00	R 0.00	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill
109	North West	Moses Kotane	Driefontein farm-Ntshabele NS	R 190 000.00	R 0.00	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill
110	North West	Rustenburg	Palmietfontein -Mokgatle	R 190 000.00	R 0.00	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill
111	North West	Rustenburg	Potgieters fontein-Motlhabane	R 190 000.00	R 0.00	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill
112	North West	Rustenburg	Palmietfontein -Rammutla	R 190 000.00	R 0.00	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill
113	North West	Mahikeng	Lucydale farm	R 220 000.00	R 0.00	R 300.00	windmill	water tank, elevated stand & windmill

Reply:

Response:

a) Yes

b) Yes

Response to (i), (ii), (aa), (aaa) (bbb) on table below.

PROGRAMME	ESTIMATED MARKET VALUE	OVG DETERMINED VALUE	DIFFERNCE
LAND REDISTRIBUTION AND DEVELOPMENT	R 116,866,011.00	R 98,264,000.00	R 18,602,011.00
STRENGTHENING OF RELATIVE RIGHTS	R 218,457,051.64	R 176,651,900.00	R 41,805,151.64
RESTITUTION	R 250,376,449.00	R 226,205,265.96	R 24,171,183.04
Total	R 585,699,511.64	R 501,121,165.96	R 84,578,345.68

Reply:

(i) (ii) see the link for reply: https://pmg.org.za/files/RNW1068Annexure-170522.docx

(aa) (bb) (b) (i) Attached as Annexure A

(ii) Attached as Annexure B