Reply:

No. We would be in a position to conduct an investigation upon receipt of a formal complaint.

Reply:

(1) The Honourable Member would be aware that the question he is asking is already in the public domain including the communication between my lawyers and the Judicial Commission of Inquiry c haired by Deputy Chief Justice Zondo. The Commission has also been on record to advise that the individuals who are somehow implicated by certain witnesses at the said inquiry would also be given an opportunity to testify and or to give their own account of events. The Honuorable Member is therefore advised to be patient until that particular opportunity surfaces.

(2) This particular question is also likely to form part of the evidence at the said inquiry.

 

 

---ooOoo---

Reply:

(i) DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING, MONITORING & EVALUATION
Held the following tender briefings:

Tender Ref	Tender briefing date & time	Venue
DPME 11/2018-2019 Implementation evaluation of corporate governance in South Africa’s State Owned Enterprises	22 November 2018 10:00 am	Department of Planning, Monitoring, and Evaluation, 330 Grosvenor Street, Hatfield, Pretoria, Flexi Room
DPME 06-2018/19 Implementation Evaluation of the South African Police Service Detective Service: Crime Investigation Service (CIS)	09 November 2018  10:00 am	Department of Planning, Monitoring, and Evaluation, 330 Grosvenor Street, Hatfield, Pretoria, Flexi Room
DPME 09-2018/19 Appointment of service provider to provide technical support for 25 year review	31 August 2018 10:00am	Department of Planning, Monitoring, and Evaluation, 330 Grosvenor Street, Hatfield, Pretoria, G01B Room
DP ME 04-2018/19 Implementation of the EPWP within the Environment and Culture Sector	23 August 2018 10:00am	Department of Planning, Monitoring, and Evaluation, 330 Grosvenor Street, Hatfield, Pretoria, Flexi Room
DPME 03-2018/19 Synthesis Evaluation of the relationship between government and Not for Profit Sector	13 August 2018 10:00am	Department of Planning, Monitoring, and Evaluation, 330 Grosvenor Street, Hatfield, Pretoria, Flexi Room
DPME 01-2018/19 Appointment of a Travel Management Agency for the Department of Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation for a period of Thirty-Six (36) Months.	06 July 2018 10:00am	Department of Planning, Monitoring, and Evaluation, 330 Grosvenor Street, Hatfield, Pretoria, Flexi Room
DPME 02-2018/19 Provision of Cleaning and Hygiene services for the Department of Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation for a period of 36 months.	11 May 2018 10:00am	Department of Planning, Monitoring, and Evaluation, 330 Grosvenor Street, Hatfield, Pretoria, Flexi Room

(ii_a) STATISTICS SOUTH AFRICA
Held the following tender briefings:

BID NUMBER	DESCRIPTION	COMPULSORY BRIEFING SESSION DATE
1. Stats SA 002/18	appointment of service provider/s to draft the 2019 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) reports, Thematic Reports and Country Report	07 September 2018
2. Stats SA 003/18	Appointment of service provider/s to provide physical security guarding services for North West provincial office, Vryburg, Klerksdorp, Rustenburg and Mabopane district offices for a period of twenty-four (24) months	03 December 2018
3. Stats SA 004/18	Appointment of service provider/s to provide physical security guarding services for Free State Provincial Office, Mangaung, Welkom, Kroonstad, Trompsburg and Bethlehem District Offices for a period of twenty-four (24) months	06 December 2018
4. Stats SA 005/18	Appointment of service provider/s to provide physical security guarding services for KwaZulu-Natal Provincial Office, Ethekwini, Ilembe, Uthungulu, Umkhanyakude, Umzinyathi, Zululand, Amajuba, Uthukela, Umgungundlovu, Harry Gwala and Ugu District Offices for a period of twenty-four (24) months	04 December 2018
5. Stats SA 006/18	Appointment of service provider/s to provide physical security guarding services for Mpumalanga Witbank and Siyabuswa District Offices for a period of twenty-four (24) months	06 December 2018
6. Stats SA 007/18	Appointment of service provider/s to provide physical security guarding services for Eastern Cape Provincial Office, Butterworth, Kokstad, Queenstown, Aliwal North, Bisho, Nelson Mandela District Offices for a period of twenty-four (24) months	04 December 2018
7. Stats SA 008/18	Appointment of service provider/s to provide physical security guarding services for Western Cape Provincial Office, Piketberg, Caledon, Metro 1 and Metro 2 District Offices for a period of twenty-four (24) months	05 December 2018
8. Stats SA 009/18	Appointment of service provider/s to provide physical security guarding services for Northern Cape Provincial Office, Kimberley, Kuruman, De Aar, Springbok, Calvinia and Upington District Offices for a period of twenty-four (24) months	05 December 2018
9. Stats SA 010/18	Appointment of service provider/s to provide physical security guarding services for Gauteng Provincial Office, Johannesburg, Sedibeng, Ekurhuleni & Westrand District Offices for a period of twenty-four (24) months	07 December 2018

(ii_b) NATIONAL YOUTH DEVELOPMENT AGENCY
Held the following briefings

Tender Number	Tender Description
NYDA 2018/05/PDD	Tender for Appointment of a panel for general preventative maintenance of NYDA Branches and District offices for a period of thirty-six (36) Months
NYDA2018/02/NYS	Request for Proposals for Institutions to deliver the National Youth Services Programme NQF Aligned short Skills Projects
NYDA2018/01/NYS	Request for Proposals for Institutions to deliver the National Youth Services Volunteer Programme.
NYDA2018/01/FAC-Cape Town	Tender for lease of corporate office space for Cape Town NYDA Branch over a period of five years
NYDA2018/02/ICT	SUPPLY AND SUPPORT NYDA ICT SERVICES FOR 40 NEW NYDA BRANCHES FOR THIRTY-SIX MONTHS (36)
NYDA2018/01/FAC-Kimberley	Tender for lease of corporate office space for Kimberley NYDA Branch over a period of five years
NYDA 2018/02/ICT	Appointment of service provider for provision of the telecommunication services and maintenance to the NYDA for a period of Sixty (60) Months:

(iii) Yes, the tender briefings were all compulsory.

		Approved	Not Approved	Approved as amended
		Comment:
Dr NC Dlamini-Zuma Minister in the Presidency: Planning Monitoring and Evaluation
Date:

Reply:

(1)(a) The total number of mines with a water use licence in each province authorized to use water are 712.

(1)(b) Refer to Annexure A for the total number of mines authorized but non- compliance.

(2) Refer to Annexure A for the action taken to address the deficiencies by authorized non-compliant mines and Annexure B for the technical and administrative conditions of a licence in terms of the National Water Act, 1998 (Act No 36 0f 1998) (NWA).

(3)(a) A total number of mines operating without authorisation in each province are 115.

(3)(b) The table below reflects the number and province in which each of those mines are located. Refer to Annexure C for list of mines operating without authorisation in each province.

Province	Number of mines	Steps to be taken to address
Gauteng	13	Administrative enforcement action
Limpopo	3	Administrative enforcement action
Mpumalanga	30	Administrative and criminal enforcement action
Kwa Zulu Natal	37	Administrative enforcement action
Free State	5	Administrative enforcement action
Northern Cape	25	Administrative enforcement action
Eastern Cape	1	Administrative enforcement action
North West	1	Administrative enforcement action
Total	115

(3)(c) It is not clear why transgressors resort to operation of mines without the requisite authorisation however; the Department continues to intensify activities to protect the water resource as mandated by the National Water Act, (Act No. 36 of 1998).

(3)(d) The Department investigates identified as well as reported non- compliances regularly. These non-compliances are dealt with in accordance with administrative, criminal and civil enforcement tools as prescribed by the National Water Act, (Act No. 36 of 1998).The Department also collaborates with other law enforcement agencies such as the South African Police Services and the National Prosecuting Authority in respect of non-compliance matters which require further criminal enforcement action.

---00O00---

Reply:

Requesting the Hounorable Member to note that water treatment facilities are the responsibility of the Department of Corporative Governance and Traditional Affairs and that the Department of Water and Sanitation only monitors compliance of the facilities.

Refer to the table below for the total number of water treatment facilities that were monitored by the Department in each province.

Province	Number of water treatment works per Province	(b)(i) Number of treatment works functional	(b)(ii) Number of treatment works dysfunctional	For how long have these been dysfunctional
Eastern Cape	224	224	0	N/A
Free State	87	83	4	One (1) Water Treatment Works has been dysfunctional for 3 years due to no raw water from the Lovedale Dam. One (1) Water Treatment Works has been dysfunctional for 3 years due to refurbishment of raw water pump station but is now complete. The Municipality is trying to fill up the Balancing dam with raw water in order to start operating the plant. One (1) Water Treatment Works has been dysfunctional for 6 years due to lack of raw water. One (1) Water Treatment Works has been dysfunctional for 4 years due to lack of raw water.
Gauteng	17	17	0	N/A
KwaZulu Natal	243	196	47	Thirty nine (39) Water Treatment Works has been dysfunctional for 2 years. Eight (8) Water Treatment Works has been dysfunctional for 4 years.
Limpopo	89	82	7	One (1) Water Treatment Works has been dysfunctional for 10 years. Two (2) Water Treatment Works has been dysfunctional for 11 years. Three (3) Water Treatment Works has been dysfunctional for 5 years. One (1) Water Treatment Works has been dysfunctional for 1 year.
Mpumalanga	105	98	7	Seven (7) Water Treatment Works has been dysfunctional for 1 year.
Northern Cape	166	165	1	One (1) Water Treatment Works has been dysfunctional for 2 years.
North West	126	126	0	N/A
Western Cape	136	132	4	One (1) Water Treatment Works has been dysfunctional for 5 years. One (1) Water Treatment Works has been dysfunctional for 2 years. Two (2) Water Treatment Works has been dysfunctional for 1 year.

---00O00---

Reply:

a) Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality has a total of eight hundred and nine (809) vacant funded posts in the Waste Management Department.

b) The Grade Levels of the positions range from Classic Scale 3 to Classic Scale 14.

c) All positions have been vacant since the approval of the organisational structure of the municipality in 2015.

1.1 A parliamentary question was received requesting the following:

(a) What number of vacant funded posts are in the waste management department within the Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality?

(b) What are the grading levels of the posts?

(c) How long has each position been vacant?

1.2 Section 66 of the Local Government: Municipal Systems Act, 32 (Act No.32 of 2000) (“Systems Act”) provides that:

1. “A municipal manager, within a policy framework determined by the municipal council and subject to any applicable legislation, must develop a staff establishment for the municipality and submit to the municipal council for approval.
2. No person may be employed in a municipality unless the post to which he or she is appointed, is provided for in the staff establishment of that municipality.
3. A decision to employ a person in a municipality, and any contract concluded between the municipality and that person in a municipality and that person in consequence of the decision, is null and void if the appointment was made in contravention of subsection (3)”.

1.3 The Regulations on Appointment and Conditions of Employment of Senior Managers, 2014 provides that:

(1) ”A municipal manager must, within 180 days of the promulgation of these regulations, review the municipality’s staff establishment having regard to the principles set out in these regulations, the functions and powers listed in Part B of Schedule 4, Part B of Schedule 5 to the Constitution, Chapter 5 of the Municipal Structures Act, and based on―

• (a) a municipality’s strategic objectives; and
• (b) a municipality’s core and support functions

(2) Notwithstanding subregulation (1), a municipality must at least provide for the following departments on the staff establishment to—

(a) provide development and town planning services;

(b) provide public works and basic services to communities;

(c) provide community services;

(d) manage the finances of a municipality; and

(e) render corporate support services.

(3) The municipal manager must review the municipality’s staff establishment within 180 days in any of the following instances:

(a) The election of a new municipal council;

(b) the adoption of the integrated development plan of the municipality as contemplated in section 25 of the Act;

(c) material changes to the functions of the municipality; or

(d) the determination of new municipal boundaries.

(4) The staff establishment must provide for―

(a) permanent posts; and

(b) fixed term posts.

(5) In the case of fixed term posts, the municipal manager must have due regard to the following:

(a) The financial implications of such post to the municipality;

(b) any existing contractual obligations of the incumbent manager and the financial implications thereof on the budget of the municipality;

(c) the need of the municipality to retain institutional memory and scarce skills, and to promote stability and continuity within the municipality; and

(d) the sustainability of the municipality.

(6) The municipal manager must, within 14 days of finalising the staff establishment, submit the staff establishment, a detailed report and recommendations on the draft staff establishment to the municipal council for approval.

(7) The report contemplated in subregulation (6) must outline the process followed in developing the staff establishment, which must include

a) a summary of the mandate and service delivery priorities of the municipality and how the proposed staff establishment addresses thes

b) a summary of the proposed posts that are envisaged to―

1. materially change;
2. change to a limited or non-material degree;
3. be abolished; and
4. not be affected by the changes;

(c) a motivation of the proposed changes, including an analysis of the strengths, weaknesses and limitations of the current staff establishment;

(d) job descriptions, duties, functions, competency requirements and responsibilities according to which one or more posts of the same grade are established, including the grading or relative size and value of a job;

(e) details of the financial implications of the changes including, but not limited to, the outcomes of job evaluation processes, remuneration costs for senior managers, costs for relocation, new facilities and equipment, if any;

(f) non-financial implications of the changes, including the impact on existing staff, key stakeholders and other processes within the municipality;

(g) a project plan that specifies the timeframes within which the implementation is envisaged take place; and

(h) the stakeholders and change management requirements.

(8) The municipal council must at its next meeting following receipt of the staff establishment, approve the staff establishment, with or without amendments, as proposed by the municipal manager”.

1.4 The following response was received from Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality:

(a) Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality has a total of eight hundred and nine (809) vacant funded posts in the Waste Management Department.

(b) The Grade Levels of the positions range from Classic Scale 3 to Classic Scale 14.

(c) All positions have been vacant since the approval of the organisational structure of the municipality in 2015.

Ends…

Reply:

a) 

	(i) Buildings	(ii) Properties	(iii) Facilities
(aa) Own	None	None	None
(bb) Rent	2	None	None

b)(ii) the values of the buildings are unknown. The two properties accommodate DPME staff.

	(i) how long	(ii) from whom	(iii) monthly rent
330 Grosvenor Street, Hatfield, Pretoria	1 December 2014 to 30 November 2019	Department of Public Works (AnchorProps 162 Pty Ltd)	R588,685.68
535 Johannes Ramokhoase Street, Arcadia, Pretoria	1 March 2018 to 31 March 2020	Department of Public Works (Erf 1214 Arcadia CC)	R436,074.25

 

 

		Approved	Not Approved	Approved as amended
		Comment:
Dr NC Dlamini-Zuma Minister in the Presidency: Planning Monitoring and Evaluation
Date:

Reply:

	(a) Make	(b) model	(c) price	(d) date
Minister NC Dlamini-Zuma1	BMW	530i	R 838 045.00	2018/08/14
Minister J Radebe2	None
Deputy Minister B Manamela3	AUDI	Q7 3.O TDI	R 971 432.76	2016/06/10

REPLY

1Minister in The Presidency for Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation since 27 February 2018

2Minister in The Presidency for Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation until 26 February 2018

3Deputy Minister in The Presidency for Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation until February 2017

 

		Approved	Not Approved	Approved as amended
		Comment:
Dr NC Dlamini-Zuma Minister in the Presidency: Planning Monitoring and Evaluation
Date:

Reply:

	a) Make of vehicle purchased for use	b) Model of vehicle purchased for use	c) Price of each vehicle purchased for use	d) (aaa) Date on which each vehicle was purchased for use in the 2016/17 FY	e) (bbb) Date on which each vehicle was purchased for use in the 2017/18 FY
Minister, Nkwinti G came with his vehicle from Rural Development	Audi	Q7	R1 039 872.66	January 2017	None
The former Minister, Mokonyane N moved with her vehicle to Environmental Affairs	Audi	Q7	R910 714.90	None	January 2018
The Deputy Minister, Tshwete P	Audi	Q7	R951 713.04	None	May 2017

---00O00---

Reply:

aaa. Details of the vehicles purchased for use by the Minister and Deputy Minister for 2016/2017

NO	ITEM	(i) MINISTER	(ii)DEPUTY MINISTER
a.	Make	Lexus	Volvo
b.	Model	GS350	XC90
c.	Price	R538 048.08	R659 728.51
d.	Date of purchase	17 September 2014	27 September 2011

NO	ITEM	(i) MINISTER	(ii)DEPUTY MINISTER
a.	Make	Lexus	Volvo
b.	Model	GS350	XC90
c.	Price	R542 458.74	R855 696.36
d.	Date of purchase	02 December 2014	24 January 2014

bbb. Details of the vehicles purchased for use by the Minister and Deputy Minister for 2017/2018

NO	ITEM	(i) MINISTER	(ii)DEPUTY MINISTER
a.	Make	BMW	BMW
b.	Model	540i	540i
c.	Price	R944 376.80	R874 876.80
d.	Date of purchase	20 December 2017	20 December 2017

bb. No vehicles were purchased for the Minister and Deputy Minister during the 2018/2019 financial

Reply:

The Department of Small Business Development (DSBD) does not own any buildings, properties and facilities, therefore:

(a)(i)(ii)&(iii) Not applicable.

(a)(aa) Not applicable.

(a)(bb) Two (2)

(b)(i) Not applicable.

(b)(ii) The DSBD is currently leasing office space in two buildings at the Department of Trade and Industry (the dti) Campus.

(c)(i) The Department has occupied the two buildings since April 2016 (3 years).

(c)(ii) Block A forms part of the dti’s Public-Private Partnerships (PPP) and Block G is owned by Delta Property Fund which is leased through the dti as the Landlord inclusive of services.

(c)(iii) The Ministry occupies 529 m² which costs an amount of R204 188.71 at Block A, the Department occupies 3966 m² which costs an amount of R1 324 655.12 at Block G. The total space is 4495 m² at R1 528 843.83, monthly.

Reply:

The information requested by the Honourable Member is not readily available in the Department. However, the Department has written a letter to the Provincial Department responsible for Local Government in Gauteng to obtain the relevant information from Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality. The information will be submitted to the Honourable Member as soon as it is available

Ends

Reply:

1. (a) (i) The Rail Enforcement unit was launched on the 27th October 2018 and has made 104 arrests since then till 31 March 2019.

(ii) See (i) above.

(b) Please refer to Annexure attached from Safety and Security Law Enforcement Services of the City of Cape Town for what crime was each individual arrested.

2. The rail enforcement unit is a jointly established and funded law enforcement pilot project for a period of 1 year between PRASA, Western Cape Department of Transport and the City of Cape Town. The agreement between the parties and the performance oversight is managed by the Rail Management Transport Task Team (RMTTT). This structure is constituted by core members that includes parties (PRASA, Western Cape Department of Transport and the City of Cape Town) to the collaborative agreement and the National Department of Transport. The RMTTT is chaired by the MEC for the Western Cape Department of Transport.

The success and effectiveness of the project will be evaluated by the RMTTT and a final decision to continue with the project will be made at the end of the 3rd quarter performance review and based on the funding availability and agreement by all three parties.

The decision to roll out of the project to other provinces is a decision that will be evaluated between PRASA and the respective local transport authorities and the provincial transport authorities based on the lessons learnt from Cape Town.

Reply:

A) Rail crash victims:

Date	Description	Injuries	Fatalities
2016/2017
2016/06/23	Merebank Head On Collision	165	0
2016/10/29	Kaalfontein Head On Collision	242	1
2017/02/20	Lynross Head On Collision	214	0
Total		621	1
2017/2018
2017/06/01	Elandsfontein Side Collision	152	1
201/01/09	Geldenhuys Rear End Collision	226	0
Total		378	1
2018/2019
2018/09/04	Booysens Head On Collision	112	0
2018/10/04	Van Riebeck Rear End Collision	320	0
2019/01/08	Mountain View Rear End Collision	817	3
Total		1,249	4

B) See table in (a).

(i) Compensation paid to crash victims and their families:

(II) The primary goal of the courts in enforcing commuters’ common law claims for damages caused, once liability of the rail agency has been established, is to compensate the person who has suffered harm. The courts function under this delictual action is to restore the claimants’ position, as far as is possible, to the position that they would have occupied had the wrongful act not been committed.

Money is considered the most appropriate form of compensation, for both patrimonial loss (including medical costs, loss of income, cost of repairs, which fall under the heading of special damages) or non-patrimonial loss (including pain and suffering, disfigurement, loss of amenities and injury to personality, which fall under the heading of general damages).

The quantification of the exact compensation to be made to a claimant is determined by the production of sufficient evidence to make an accurate assessment. The courts will not make arbitrary awards if sufficient evidence is not led as to how the quantification of the claimants’ damages were exactly computed.

The process of compensation is determined by medico-legal evaluation of the Plaintiff. The purpose of medico-legal evaluation is to determine the following:

1. The exact nature of the claimant’s injuries;
2. The extent and severity of the claimant’s injuries;
3. The sequelae and/or consequences that flow from the claimant’s injuries.

The medico-legal evaluations are carried out by medical professionals that specifically specialise in the field of personal injury litigation.

In personal injury matters against the rail agency litigants claim mainly the following heads of damages:

1. Past Medical Expenses;
2. Future medical expenses;
3. Loss of Earnings and/or Earning Capacity;
4. General damages.

A due diligence exercise on matters settled above R150,000-00 between 2006 and 2016 revealed that a sizeable amount of expenses are paid towards future medical expenses.

Once the medico-legal evaluation of the claimant has been completed, and the impact of the injuries on him has been assessed, the determination of the exact compensation due to him must be made.

In the case of past medical expenses specified medical vouchers delineating the exact nature of the medical treatment received, as well as showing that such medical treatment is accident related, must be provided.

Due to the once and for all rule in our common law of delict, all damages including potential future damages, sustained by the claimant must be calculated at the time the matter is settled. The future medical treatment required by the claimant as well as his loss of earnings and/or earning capacity must be calculated. This calculation is done by actuarial scientists who take into consideration factors such as medical inflation, earnings inflation, other applicable contingency deductions, life expectancy tables, etc.

General damages awards are awards made for the pain and suffering, loss of amenities, etc. that the claimant has suffered. These awards are made on the precedents set by awards handed down by the courts in previous cases. The courts make their award in the matter before them based on facts and circumstances that are considered analogous to the previous cases. All of the above is available for guidance and direction in the annually published Robert J Kock Quantum Year Book that is widely accepted as the general guide in claims settlement by the legal fraternity including the courts.

Reply:

1. The Office of the Minister, and all of the entities reporting to her have not contracted any services from the company in question, and in the period in question.
2. Not Applicable

 

		Approved	Not Approved	Approved as amended
		Comment:
Dr NC Dlamini-Zuma Minister in the Presidency: Planning Monitoring and Evaluation
Date:

Reply:

(a),(b) Farmers’ development commenced in 2009 not 1994. The table below provides the total amount per annum since 2009.

Year	Total Amount R“000
2009/2010	30 421
2010/2011	334 540
2011/2012	630 418
2012/2013	1 151 028
2013/2014	1 081 828
2014/2015	517 559
2015/2016	836 612
2016/2017	713 569
2017/2018	394 848
2018/2019 (Current)	162 525

Reply:

(a),(b),(c),(d)(i),(ii),(aa),(aaa),(bbb),(bb) Please refer to the table below.

(a) Make	(b) Model	(c) Price	(d) Date purchased	(i) Minister/ Former Minister	(ii) Deputy or Former Deputy Minister	(aa),(aaa), (bbb),(bb) Financial Year
Audi	2017	R1,039,872.66	19/01/2017	former Minister G Nkwinti	-	2016-2017
Mercedes Benz	2018	R1,293,000.01	13/03/2018	-	Deputy Minister: C Mashego-Dlamini	2017-2018
Mercedes Benz	2019	R1,209,955.10	11/02/2019	-	Deputy Minister M Skwatsha	Since April 2018
2 x Audi	2018	R1,211,995.98 and R1,087,173.25 (Pretoria and Cape Town)	23/05/2018 & 25/05/2018	Minister M Nkoana- Mashabane	-	Since April 2018

Reply:

The information requested by the Honourable Member is not readily available in the Department. However, the Department has written a letter to the Provincial Department responsible for Local Government in Gauteng to obtain the relevant information from Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality. The information will be submitted to the Honourable Member as soon as it is available

Ends

Reply:

(a)(i) The total number of building rented by the Department is 33 buildings and a total number of buildings owed by the Department are 4948 refer to the table below.

Row Labels	No. of Assets	Cost	Accumulative Depreciation	Book Value
Buildings	4889	2,173,677,966.77	(1,281,645,620.50)	892,032,346.27
Buildings Auxiliary	59	19,368,099.92	(9,456,665.67)	9,911,434.25
Grand Total	4948	2,193,046,066.69	(1,291,102,286.17)	901,943,780.52

NB Auxiliary Buildings relates to Boat Houses

(a)(ii) The Minister owns, manages and controls a total of 320 state own dams (government waterworks) country wide and a total of 1175 properties refer to the table below.

Row Labels	No. of Assets	Cost	Accumulative Impairment	Book Value
Land	1174	7,791,050,104.60	(245,160,780.58)	7,545,889,324.02
Grand Total	1174	7,791,050,104.60	(245,160,780.58)	7,545,889,324.02

 

In addition the following should be noted:

In terms of Section 1(1) (x) of the National Water Act, 1998 (Act no. 36 of 1998) (NWA) the Minister owns the land on which a government waterwork is situated. The extent of the land required is determined scientifically up to the dam boundary line of each dam which includes the full supply level, the 1:100 year flood line and a buffer line. In terms of Government Immovable Asset Management ACT No 19 of 2007 (GIAMA), the disposal policies of the Department of Water and Sanitation (DWS) and the National Department of Public Works (NDPW) all excess land must be transferred to NDPW. The Minister only acquires the minimum land required for the government waterwork in order to manage, operate and maintain the dams. In relation to ownership, the

Minister has exclusive rights on the land within the government waterworks and the water source is regarded as national assets which must be protected in terms of the NWA.

(a)(iii) Refer to (a)(i) above.

(b)(i) The Hounorable Member is requested to note the following. The Value of each property owned by the Minister of Water and Sanitation which falls within a Government Waterwork must be determined by a Professional Registered Valuer. The Department is not in a financial position to determine the value of each property as yet and will need to seek the assistance of the Office of the Valuer-General to assist with the determination of the market related value of each property. The purpose of each property falling within a dam boundary line is to store bulk raw water. Refer to Annexure A for the value and purpose of each owed property.

(b)(ii) The Department is renting a total of 33 buildings. Refer to the table below (c) for the value and purpose of the rented properties.

(c) Refer to the table below for the rented properties:

(c)(i) for how long has each property been rented	(c)(ii) from whom is each property rented and	(c)(iii) what is the monthly rental fee for each property
SPECTRUM HOUSE 1   8 years	Grey Jade Trade and Invest 85 (PTY) LTD	R 1 232 050.68
SPECTRUM HOUSE 2 5 years	Ascession Properties LTD	R 71 968.37
SIGMA HOUSE   9 years	Cape Horizon Properties (PTY) LTD	R 852 773.71
INTERPARK 5 years	Interpark	R 7 410.00
9&11 HIGH STREET  28 years	Quenprop Investment PTY LTD	R 17 345.33
9&11 HIGH STREET    28 years	Quenprop Investment PTY LTD	R 26 146.70
LIONN ROARS OFFICE PARK 9 years	Kuper Legh Property Management (PTY) LTD	R 229 751.86
SANPORT 23 years	Africorp International Properties (PTY) LTD	R 69 398.44
44 SPRIGG STREET 30 years	M.J Lombard	R 15 900.46
PARK HOMES 14 years	M. Projects CC	R 18 700.56
PRD2 19 years	Colliers RMS (PTY) LTD	R 351 581.37
2 HARGREAVES 16 years	Arrowhead Properties LTD	R 435 084.24
PROROM 26 years	Ascession Properties LTD	R 669 760.87
26 CENTRAL ROAD KIMBARLEY 8 years	Albasync (PTY) LTD	R 420 538.47
PRAETOR 11 years	Centpret Properties (PTY) LTD	R 284 095.98
SANLAM PLAZA EAST 18 years	Superbia Four (PTY) LTD	R 742 486.10
22 ROOTH STREET CANELLE BLDG 15 years	Ascession Properties LTD	R 42 690.16
TALANA 13 years	BASFOUR 3072 (PTY) LTD	R 54 240.38
SOUTHREN LIFE 19 years	Delta Property Fund (LTD)	R 674 900.55
SANLAM PLAZA 31 years	Gensec Property services Limited t/a JHB	R 313 964.06
MEGACITY WEST GALARY 4 years	Combia Falls Properties	R 712 317.29
(c)(i) for how long has each property been rented	(c)(ii) from whom is each property rented and	(c)(iii) what is the monthly rental fee for each property
FACTORY 40-12 15 years	Limpopo Economic Development Agency	R 42 643.70
OLD SABC 14 years	South African Broadcasting Corporation Coc limited	R 152 479.39
LEBOWAKGOMO GOV. COMPLEX 14 years	Department of Public Works	R 7 508.55
AZMO PLACE 23 years	Delta Properties Fund LTD	R 676 362.18
LIBRARY GARDENS 18 years	Changing Tides 132 (PTY) LTD	R 82 539.52
38-42 HOOGE STREET 18 years	Omtay Property Holding Trust	R 91 835.69
SEDIBENG 37 years	Summermania Seven (PTY) LTD	R 3 735 404.30
EMANZINI 40 years	Redefine Properties	R 1 200 273.83
ZWAMADAKA 40 years	Summermania Seven (PTY) LTD	R 1 695 729.48
WATERBRON 10 years	Dreamfair Properties (PTY) LTD	R 3 444 465.10
FINPARK 17 years	Servest (Finpark)	R 110 712.91
NDINAYE 2 3 years	Supperble Four (PTY) LTD	R 751 451.30
CORPORATE 66 7 years	Faerie Glen Waterpark (PTY) LTD	R 129 650.93
NDINAYE 1 4 years	Supperble Four (PTY) LTD	R 474 345.04
CONTINENTAL 11 years	Redefine Properties	R 490 173.29

---00O00---

Reply:

The information requested by the Honourable Member is not readily available in the Department. However, the Department has written a letter to the Provincial Department responsible for Local Government in Gauteng to obtain the relevant information from Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality. The information will be submitted to the Honourable Member as soon as it is available

Ends

Reply:

I am advised by the Competition Commissioner that the contract of the former CFO, Mr Molathlegi Kgauwe came to an end on 14 March 2019 and has not been renewed. The Competition Commission recruitment process is underway and the Commission will employ a new CFO in due course.

-END-

Reply:

The following table reflects the details in this regard.

Table 1.

NO.	PROVINCE	NUMBER OF STAFF STRIKES
1.	Eastern Cape Province	02 (two) staff strikes
2.	Free State Province	04 (four) staff strikes
3.	Gauteng Province	38 (thirty-eight) staff strikes
4.	KwaZulu- Natal Province	04 (four) staff strikes
5.	Limpopo Province	01 (one) staff strike
6.	Mpumalanga Province	04 (four) staff strikes
7.	Northern Cape Province	02 (two) staff strikes
8.	North West Province	29 (Twenty-nine) staff strikes
9.	Western Cape Province	0 (No staff strikes)

 

END.

Reply:

The National Department of Health does not own any properties or buildings. All properties and buildings used or occupied by the National Department of Health are either:

• State Owned and managed by the Department of Public Works as custodian, or;
• State Owned and rented directly from the Department concerned where the Department of Public Works is not the custodian, or;
• Rented from the private sector, using the Department of Public Works as procurement agent.

For this reason, records are not available within National Department of Health to respond directly to the Honorable Member’s question of 1 March 2019. All contract data is held by Department of Public Works, who invoice the Department of Health for payment as follows:

• Quarterly in advance for State Owned buildings, or;
• Monthly in arrears for privately owned properties leased by DPW on behalf of National Department of Health.

It is suggested that the question be referred to the Minister of Public Works for a comprehensive response.

END.

Reply:

Infomation has been requested from the Gauteng Department of Education and the response will be provided as soon as it is received.

Reply:

According to the information received from Eskom

Eskom directly owns one mine, called Kilbarchan Colliery[1]. Indirectly, the utility owns some equity[2] in the cost-plus mines as a result of ownership of a portion of the mine assets through the cost-plus coal supply agreements (CSA).

Mining houses have the statutory right to mine the coal, and the statutory obligation to rehabilitate the mine. Eskom, through the CSA has the financial obligation to pay for these costs. The reserves dedicated to Eskom, can only be sold to Eskom. In a case where the mining house intends to transfer its rights and obligations, Eskom would have to provide consent. It should be noted that the CSAs do not include BEE ownership requirements as the last cost-plus agreement was signed prior to Eskom’s current BEE Policy.

Eskom does not disclose the lifespan of the cost-plus mines due to the following reasons:

• Production at some of the cost-plus mines will end before the CSA end date.
• As part of the life-extension projects, ongoing efforts to recapitalize some of the cost-plus mines will result in the stated life of the mine changing
• Some reserves in the cost-plus mine complex are not dedicated to Eskom.

1. Kilbarchan Colliery is recorded in Eskom’s balance sheet under the subsidiary Natal Navigation Colliery. It is recorded at R1, while the associated rehabilitation liability has been fully raised in Eskom’s financial statements. ↑

2. Eskom’s balance sheet does not include the cost-plus mines because the direct ownership rests with the mining houses and their balance sheets. ↑

Reply:

(a)(i)(ii) (b)(i)(ii) (c) (d) (i) (ii)

Chapter 10 of the Ministerial Handbook, Handbook for Members of the Executive and Presiding Officers indicates that the Minister and Deputy Minister are considered former “on the first day following the date on which they relinquished their office”

The political leadership of the Department of Basic Education (DBE) has been constant in the past five financial years and since 1 April 2018 and therefore there is neither a former Minister nor Deputy Minister.

Reply:

Adults: Women – 41%

Men – 11%

Children: 2 to 14 years – Girls – 7.1%

2 to 14 years – Boys – 4.7%

END.

Reply:

A) The following table reflects the details in this regard

	January-December 2018	January 2019
Province	HIV test positives	HIV test positives
Eastern Cape	92,939	9,043
Free State	41,489	3,914
Gauteng	234,043	21,137
KwaZulu Natal	230,525	21,267
Limpopo	56,160	5,307
Mpumalanga	76,007	6,562
North West	47,602	4,278
Northern Cape	11,301	1,026
Western Cape	48,546	4,484
National	838,612	77,018

b) The following table reflects the details in this regard

Province	December 2018	January 2019
Eastern Cape	483,691	486,365
Free State	265,232	267,148
Gauteng	1,000,503	1,011,319
KwaZulu Natal	1,353,561	1,351,281
Limpopo	349,340	351,281
Mpumalanga	448,098	453,876
North West	268,465	262,985
Northern Cape	59,698	59,612
Western Cape	265,014	268,086
National	4,493,602	4,512,378

END.

Reply:

The following table reflects the details in this regard

Province	No of facilities	Type of facility	Comments
Eastern Cape	4	Gengqe clinic Rosedale clinic (12-20) February 2019 Gqeberha clinic	The clinic was under construction for the duration of 2018/19. It was just handed over in March 2019. It will be opened for services in the first quarter of 2019/20 Rosedale clinic was closed for few days by the community. Gqeberha was closed for few days and was later reopened community protest. Hellenvale clinic closed due to gangsterism in the area. The safety of the staff and the patients was taken into consideration
Gauteng	7	Orchards Clinic Florida Clinic 4th Avenue Clinic Jeppe Street Clinic 80th Albert Street Clinic Joubert Park Clinic Claremont Clinic	All these clinics in the City of Johannesburg are undergoing major renovations.
Free State	NIL	N/A
KwaZulu- Natal	NIL	N/A
Limpopo	2	Mogalakwena/Potgietersrus clinic Naboomspruit clinic	Both these clinics were operating from the houses that were offered by the Municipality. The services were discontinued when the Municipality took their houses back. The Department had to build Manyoga clinic to continue with the services in Mogalakwena/ Potgietersrus
Mpumalanga	NIL	N/A
Northern Cape	2	Olifant’s Hoek Community Health Centre Wrenchville Clinic	Olifant’s hoek CHC is under major renovation. Wrenchville clinic was burnt by the community during protests. The contractor is on site for repairs.
North West	5	Boitekong Community Health Centre Jouberton Community Health Centre Sun Rise Park clinic Ramokokastad clinic Tshiretso clinic	Boitekong is undergoing construction. It is due to be opened during the first quarter of 2019/20 Jouberton CHC is an old facility which is being replaced with a brand new CHC will be opened during the course of this year. Both Sunrise Park and Ramokoka were burned down during community protest respectively. Tshireletso clinic was closed by the Department of Labour in 2015 and since not been replaced or upgraded.
Western Cape	0	Still waiting for response	N/A
Total	20

END.

Reply:

No vehicles were purchased for the Minister or the Deputy Minister during the years 2016-17, 2017-18 and since 1 April 2018.

-END-

Reply:

Infomation has been requested from the Gauteng Department of Education and the response will be provided as soon as it is received.

Reply:

I am advised by the Competition Commission that the total amount paid to Mokwana Incorporated Attorneys is R 3 644 724,90 for the period from January 2015 to December 2018.

The scope and nature of the work is investigation and litigation.

Eight cases were involved, covering litigation (six cases); review of electronic data (one case) and work connected to a raid on the premises of an entity (one matter).

-END-

Reply:

The information has been requested from the Western Cape Education Department and will be provided as soon as it is received.

Reply:

As education is a concurrent function, the requested information must be sought from the provinces.

 

Reply:

(1) The continuation of the South African Police Service Non Statutory Forces (SAPS NSF) project is currently the subject of a review application which was brought against the South African Police Service by the Solidarity Union in the Gauteng North High Court. An interdict prohibits the South African Police Service to continue with the SAPS NSF project pending the outcome of Solidarity Union’s review application. Once the review application is finalised, a clear Judicial directive will be issued as a court order in this regard.

 

 

- , LIEUTENANT GENERAL D ISIONAL COMMISSIONER: PERSONNEL MANAGEMENT

NTSHIEA

Date: \ ’ ” ‘

Reply to question 422 recommended

BC MGWENYA

LIEUTENANT GENERAL MMISSIONER: HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

Reply to question 422 recommended d

AL

OLE (SOEG)

Date: › ‹J- 0 I

GENERAL SIO ?SOUTH AFRICAN POLICE SERVICE

Reply to question 422 approved/nopgeds

MINIST BH CELE

Date:

OLICE

Reply:

1. The Inquest docket, Randfontein, CAS 501/04/2017, was opened after an explosion at Wilmar Continental Oils, Randfontein, at the SalVent Plant, where one person succumbed to his injuries. The case docket was discussed with the Senior Public Prosecutor (SPP), who instructed that the case be referred to the Occupational Health and Safety Department, in Johannesburg, for a report. The case docket was sent to the Occupational Health and Safety Department, on 16 July 2018. The report from the Occupational Health and Safety Department is outstanding.

2. In the interest of the case being investigated without fear or favour, the particulars of the investigating officer cannot be divulged.

3. Yes, the investigation of the case docket was finalised by the South African Police Service (SAPS) and referred to the SPP for a decision. The SPP instructed that the incident must be referred to the Occupational Health and Safety Department, for a report. This report is still outstanding. As soon as the report is received, the case docket will be returned to the SPP at the Randfontein Magistrate’s Caurt. The date of the finalisation of this case cannot be provided, as the court process is managed by the Department of Justice and Constitutional Development.

 

Reply to question 86 recommended

OM

KJ 2E (SOEG)

Date: 201tl -0t- 0 t

Reply to question 86 approved/

MINI OF POLICE BH CELE, MP

Date:/ D

GENERAL H AFRICAN POLICE SERVICE

Reply:

(a) and (b) No.

Thus, (i) and (ii) fall away.

Reply:

(1) (a) Internally within the Department of Public Works, all deviations processed, approved and recorded are reported on a monthly basis to the Department’s Standing Accountability Management Committee (AMC).

(b) Deviations that are above the tender threshold of one million rand (R1 million) procured from a sole source supplier or arising out of an emergency and approved by the relevant delegated authority within the Department, are reported to the National Treasury and the Auditor General of South Africa (AGSA) within the prescribed 10 days of such approval per case.

Deviations other than sole source or arising out of an emergency are considered by the relevant delegated authority within the Department and then recommended to the National Treasury for approval/support. The National Treasury supported deviations are then reported to the AGSA within 10 days of approval.

All reported deviations of the Department are published in the National Treasury website after approval.

(c) Internally within the Department all deviations’ registers and reports are presented to the AMC. Deviations that are above the tender threshold procured either from a sole source supplier or arising out of an emergency are reported to the NT and AGSA. All NT supported deviations that are not a sole source transaction nor arising out of an emergency are provided to the AGSA

The Chief Director: Supply Chain Management (CD: SCM) or his/her delegate accounts for all deviations that are presented at the AMC. The deviation reports to National Treasury and AGSA for all sole source procurement and those arising out of emergencies and which were approved by the relevant authority are signed off by the CD: SCM. Reports to AGSA for deviations that are neither sole source nor arising out of emergencies that are supported by the National Treasury are signed off by the CD: SCM.

(d) There is currently no specific regulatory provision or stipulation that provides for the reporting of deviations to the National Assembly Portfolio Committee on Public Works. However, the Department of Public Works is always prepared to respond to any invitation from the Portfolio Committee on Public Works in order to report on the deviations as and when the Committee is able to find a slot to deliberate on such.

2. Yes, deviation reports to the AGSA for deviations that have been supported by the National Treasury are attached as Annexure A.

Reply:

(a)

(i) The Department of Transport and its managing entity, the Transnet National Ports Authority (TNPA), are responsible for all ports within South Africa.

(ii) The Department of Public Works is the custodian of public small harbours, public slipways and State coastal properties.

The Department of Public Works has not upgraded any of its existing harbours with respect to increasing the extent or size of these harbours. The Department is currently conducting a repair and maintenance programme to the Proclaimed Fishing Harbours in the Western Cape Province.

The Proclaimed Fishing Harbours comprise the following 13 harbours:

1. Lamberts Bay Harbour
2. Laaiplek Harbour
3. St Helena Bay Harbour
4. Saldanha Bay Harbour
5. Pepper Bay Harbour
6. Hout Bay Harbour
7. Kalk Bay Harbour
8. Gordon’s Bay Harbour
9. Hermanus Harbour
10. Gansbaai Harbour
11. Struisbaai Harbour
12. Arniston Harbour
13. Stilbaai Harbour

(b)

(i) and (ii)

 

Scope of Work	Cost
Removal of sunken vessels	R25 584 834
Dredging	R84 103 134
Slipways and marine infrastructure	R75 789 342
Electrical and security infrastructure	To be determined once the tender specifications have been finalised
Civil infrastructure repairs	To be determined once the tender specifications have been finalised

Reply:

Information on the total number of students who graduated with 3-year diplomas, 3-year degrees, Bachelor of Technology and 4-year degrees by institution from 1993 to 2017 are attached as Annexure A.

Annexure A: Number of students graduated with 3-year diplomas, 3-year degrees and 4-year degrees by institution from 1993 to 2017

3 Year Diploma Graduates (UNIVERSITIES)
Institution	1993	1994	1995	1996	1997	1998	1999	2000	2001	2002	2003	2004
University of Cape Town	120	76	115	83	67	65	169	102	64	324	441	356
University of Durban-Westville	1	2	2	1	0	1	0	3	2	2	20	n.a.
University of KwaZulu-Natal	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	870
University of Fort Hare	3	21	19	2	10	1	1	4	4	5	10	237
Medical Uni. of South Africa	29	21	22	26	11	10	5	3	36	5	39	6
University of Natal	161	163	184	232	273	246	0	505	248	436	1087	n.a.
University of the North	17	58	95	108	65	33	20	106	262	152	206	308
University of the Free State	10	18	26	9	6	6	5	5	13	224	475	371
University of Port Elizabeth	48	130	108	102	81	312	739	897	1012	526	1019	1627
Potchefstroom University	31	28	32	35	120	344	1443	898	1444	1093	1057	n.a.
North West University	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	2578
University of Pretoria	132	153	252	351	377	508	4461	3625	3002	2980	1751	2437
Rand Afrikaans University	27	867	2272	2390	2096	2823	1952	1574	1358	1099	1381	1596
Rhodes University	41	40	162	209	83	124	391	88	260	145	788	241
University of South Africa	600	536	497	525	668	835	2830	694	3079	4746	2297	4274
University of Stellenbosch	63	101	96	102	98	104	153	84	65	85	115	42
University of Western Cape	282	214	196	191	228	139	149	174	187	326	513	272
University of Witwatersrand	84	96	77	84	154	206	165	119	273	436	407	180
University of Zululand	204	152	221	237	261	176	187	72	193	173	387	126
Vista University	4970	4840	4783	4431	3337	3167	2033	2077	1384	883	373	n.a.
University of Transkei	n.a.	n.a.	124	199	121	n.a.	36	57	32	140	821	575
University of North West	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	46	202	231	333	n.a.
University of Venda	n.a.	n.a.	147	277	167	127	54	32	352	190	443	359
TOTAL	6823	7516	9430	9594	8223	9227	14793	11165	13472	14201	13963	16455

3 Year Diploma Graduates (TECHNIKONS)
Institution	1993	1994	1995	1996	1997	1998	1999	2000	2001	2002	2003	2004
Cape Technikon	1541	1483	1612	1630	1562	1540	1504	1539	1646	1740	2009	2220
Northern Gauteng Technikon	326	673	778	948	941	1078	1062	1051	1071	1225	1276	n.a.
Mangosuthu Technikon	234	29	430	481	706	817	860	874	845	865	856	926
M.L. Sultan Technikon	753	869	959	942	1069	908	1157	1156	1076	1270	n.a.	n.a.
Natal Technikon	1135	967	n.a.	n.a.	1073	n.a.	1053	1026	941	927	n.a.	n.a.
Technikon Free State	596	585	767	759	777	690	649	654	744	868	893	1041
Peninsula Technikon	798	n.a.	n.a.	918	777	1025	1081	1090	1428	1228	1392	1275
Port Elizabeth Technikon	867	924	1041	1063	1117	1124	1083	1067	1115	1088	1126	1225
Pretoria Technikon	2076	2032	2108	2056	1903	2288	2186	2043	2204	2476	2789	n.a.
Technikon SA	286	2248	3221	3746	4260	3285	4003	2478	1493	1317	1624	n.a.
Vaal Triangle Technikon	788	572	640	903	441	925	997	393	1290	1529	1775	1876
Witwatersrand Technikon	1273	1533	1434	1521	1477	1539	1433	1051	1170	1248	1211	1478
Border Technikon	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	117	162	353	n.a.	14	520	574	676	675
Technikon North West	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	187	36	71	407	287	339	451	622	n.a.
Eastern Cape Technikon	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	178	440	429	872	435	683	861	1309	1061
Durban Institute of Technology	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	2315	2629
Tshwane University of Technology	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	5133
TOTAL	10673	11915	12991	15449	16741	16072	18347	15158	16565	17667	19873	19539

3 Year Diploma Graduates (UNIVERSITIES POST MERGER)
Institution	2005	2006	2007	2008	2009	2010	2011	2012	2013	2014	2015	2016	2017
Cape Peninsula University of Technology	3496	3984	3933	3810	4112	3650	3921	4088	4141	4093	4127	4091	4177
Central University of Technology, Free State	1186	1360	1240	1392	1121	1209	1418	1492	1419	1378	1443	1498	1400
Durban University of Technology	2952	2928	3298	3008	3836	3297	3499	3936	4061	4207	3858	4148	4372
Mangosuthu University of Technology	1140	1779	1792	1732	1731	1530	1800	1858	2110	2203	2262	2082	2088
Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University	1410	1205	1121	1157	1631	1574	1534	2059	2261	1925	1835	1836	1756
North West University	334	520	586	825	743	886	1071	1272	1609	1874	2394	3738	3338
Tshwane University of Technology	4796	4922	5434	6120	6149	6293	6272	6522	6666	6611	7125	7469	8034
University of Cape Town	55	90	25	21	22	25	18	15	24	37	28	27	31
University of Fort Hare	267	419	13	82	156	93	53	106	126	85	42	45	27
University of Free State	544	480	18	69	165	158	158	136	148	196	395	509	532
University of Johannesburg	1886	2047	2113	2351	2485	2492	2852	3061	3227	3260	3052	3038	3042
University of KwaZulu Natal	8	9	14	18	11	7	30	17	10	9	13	1	3
University of Limpopo	868	910	1047	258	119	329	260	177	130	163	17	0	0
University of Pretoria	2911	12	4	15	4	10	8	9	2	3	9	5	3
University of South Africa	1938	1773	1862	2642	1541	3613	3755	3404	3958	4292	4624	4225	3442
University of Stellenbosch	0	0	0	0	0	47	11	10	19	22	13	4	8
University of Venda	487	14	214	103	96	154	171	91	106	172	100	102	112
University of Western Cape	4	0	2	1	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0
University of Witwatersrand	154	6	28	7	6	7	5	3	3	1	2		1
University of Zululand	115	4	8	41	225	320	361	410	335	271	296	290	257
Vaal University of Technology	1885	1890	2103	2410	2381	2221	2678	2875	2797	2947	2813	2747	2764
Walter Sisulu University	1664	1856	1554	1696	1248	1540	2048	2198	2211	2346	2097	2451	2505
Sol Plaatje University, Northern Cape	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	49	41
University of Mpumalanga	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	145	85
TOTAL	28100	26208	26409	27758	27784	29455	31923	33739	35363	36095	36545	38500	38018

B Tech Graduates
Institution	1993	1994	1995	1996	1997	1998	1999	2000	2001	2002	2003	2004
Cape Technikon	n.a.	n.a.	155	318	378	407	558	442	543	741	959	1031
Northern Gauteng Technikon	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	90	146	269	225	240	221	276	303	n.a.
Mangosuthu Technikon	n.a.	n.a.	8	7	5	10	2	3	4	9	21	26
M.L. Sultan Technikon	n.a.	n.a.	17	86	150	227	209	231	278	301	n.a.	n.a.
Natal Technikon	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	242	n.a.	249	374	494	377	n.a.	n.a.
Technikon Free State	n.a.	n.a.	12	99	116	166	188	172	271	366	442	701
Peninsula Technikon	66	n.a.	n.a.	104	236	373	340	380	473	514	592	761
Port Elizabeth Technikon	n.a.	n.a.	71	201	285	333	374	322	393	468	441	472
Pretoria Technikon	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	176	354	456	2192	3317	2178	1762	2364	n.a.
Technikon SA	n.a.	n.a.	51	174	221	254	644	916	672	719	1060	n.a.
Vaal Triangle Technikon	n.a.	n.a.	48	86	78	109	110	33	195	249	320	399
Witwatersrand Technikon	n.a.	n.a.	93	219	338	378	504	427	476	543	545	563
Border Technikon	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	10	n.a.	9	40	49	45	80
Technikon North West	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	7	2	18	33	30	n.a.
Eastern Cape Technikon	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	2	5	3	89	100	106
Durban Institute of Technology	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	642	925
Tshwane University of Technology	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	3662
TOTAL	66	n.a.	455	1560	2549	2992	5604	6873	6259	6496	7864	8726

B Tech Graduates (POST MERGER)
Institution	2005	2006	2007	2008	2009	2010	2011	2012	2013	2014	2015	2016	2017
Cape Peninsula University of Technology	1726	1952	2018	2175	1989	2172	2231	2351	2458	2639	2651	2706	2974
Central University of Technology, Free State	576	579	536	518	602	672	698	821	874	977	1005	1026	1084
Durban University of Technology	928	989	1118	1127	1545	1873	1790	1834	2162	2235	2149	2534	2712
Mangosuthu University of Technology	38	29	56	64	68	59	164	93	164	242	221	131	122
Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University	542	418	449	449	530	584	660	874	930	883	877	923	986
Tshwane University of Technology	2800	2417	2118	2224	2426	2434	2549	2627	2691	3050	3847	3900	4727
University of Johannesburg	682	719	798	926	1072	1106	1093	1252	1358	1435	1470	1727	1661
University of South Africa	764	612	795	1091	1278	1692	2005	2079	2008	1685	1379	1300	1488
Vaal University of Technology	372	478	523	547	699	830	895	1006	1268	1100	994	1123	1181
Walter Sisulu University	67	107	183	294	320	352	333	262	390	494	489	751	881
TOTAL	8495	8300	8594	9415	10529	11774	12418	13199	14303	14740	15082	16121	17816

3 Year Degree Graduates
Institution	1993	1994	1995	1996	1997	1998	1999	2000	2001	2002	2003	2004
University of Cape Town	1339	1303	1172	1170	1162	1220	1121	1089	1192	1258	1522	1646
University of Durban-Westville	829	936	1069	973	946	851	750	684	665	680	696	n.a.
University of KwaZulu-Natal	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	2757
University of Fort Hare	501	487	549	496	554	487	565	376	271	228	349	406
Medical Uni. of South Africa	131	147	149	142	147	120	128	130	111	101	120	105
University of Natal	1464	1652	1667	1645	1789	1823	0	1648	1662	1749	1984	n.a.
University of the North	293	1636	1811	2324	2378	1811	1360	1047	669	415	328	502
University of the Free State	737	752	652	643	730	730	810	702	688	777	943	1119
University of Port Elizabeth	604	582	555	490	519	511	475	435	408	460	524	848
Potchefstroom University	974	923	839	804	866	902	814	1124	1234	1262	1176	n.a.
North West University	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	2032
University of Pretoria	1737	1593	1553	1709	1950	1997	1874	2011	2062	2394	2687	2968
Rand Afrikaans University	1138	1005	1048	851	1030	1083	1129	1283	1391	1749	1929	2292
Rhodes University	658	570	510	507	491	507	570	596	610	711	720	635
University of South Africa	4077	5226	5920	6374	6586	6731	5482	5564	4792	4709	4232	4330
University of Stellenbosch	1199	1303	1190	1191	1168	1208	1311	1288	1263	1384	1503	1413
University of Western Cape	1239	1076	1264	1380	1484	903	759	714	498	462	575	630
University of Witwatersrand	1549	1455	1266	1174	1126	1051	1099	1002	981	956	1022	1306
University of Zululand	455	328	405	317	230	618	576	411	432	428	627	552
Vista University	872	975	1171	1404	1549	1890	2121	1860	1640	1377	1229	n.a.
University of Transkei	n.a.	n.a.	514	497	511	n.a.	485	334	327	221	192	205
University of North West	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	561	389	258	367	n.a.
University of Venda	n.a.	n.a.	493	661	517	495	720	501	382	283	457	521
TOTAL	19795	21948	23797	24753	25733	24938	22149	23360	21667	21862	23182	24267

3 Year Degree Graduates (POST MERGER)
Institution	2005	2006	2007	2008	2009	2010	2011	2012	2013	2014	2015	2016	2017
Central University of Technology, Free State	119	146	149	185	100	46	2	0	4	0	1	0	0
Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University	916	875	869	916	853	884	954	983	992	1057	989	1163	1191
North West University	2068	2424	2380	2454	2613	2711	2796	3003	3599	3610	3840	4011	3872
Rhodes University	799	807	844	745	797	854	950	1036	1026	1009	956	1090	1146
University of  Fort Hare	531	416	450	557	568	635	719	943	932	969	960	988	1121
University of Cape Town	1789	1589	1732	1556	1544	1686	1738	1942	1870	1833	1786	1791	1802
University of Free State	951	1320	1299	1442	1535	1713	1834	2058	2352	2368	2303	2187	1978
University of Johannesburg	2373	2794	2568	2653	2671	2944	3015	3304	3423	3600	3524	3563	3525
University of KwaZulu-Natal	2661	3500	3155	2931	2757	2717	2905	3324	3646	3321	3283	3726	3885
University of Limpopo	723	990	1359	1447	1128	1219	1315	1828	1970	2137	2040	1971	2200
University of Pretoria	3121	3324	3179	3225	3291	3235	3432	3400	3836	3519	3791	3976	3856
University of South Africa	3310	4153	4157	4448	5275	5725	6031	5745	8289	9079	9198	9729	8189
University of Stellenbosch	1555	1833	1851	1979	2012	2113	2097	2276	2220	2100	2152	2412	2570
University of Venda	631	723	841	997	1003	980	681	561	522	832	913	906	1107
University of Western Cape	840	1015	1054	985	990	1162	1182	1269	1420	1537	1764	1698	1691
University of Witwatersrand	1441	1495	1689	1688	1549	1672	1735	1995	2106	2159	2172	2416	2637
University of Zululand	459	669	575	724	680	600	739	1445	1264	1212	1444	1500	1424
Walter Sisulu University	193	282	308	477	419	557	532	504	456	302	370	491	484
Sefako Makgatho University	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	270	205	269
University of Mpumalanga	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	25	35
Sol Plaatje University, Northern Cape	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	13
TOTAL	24480	28355	28459	29409	29785	31453	32657	35616	39927	40644	41756	43848	42995

4 Year Degree Graduates
Institution	1993	1994	1995	1996	1997	1998	1999	2000	2001	2002	2003	2004
University of Cape Town	771	827	833	817	793	931	1013	871	997	1157	1126	1110
University of Durban-Westville	360	500	645	608	557	506	462	525	423	467	432	n.a.
University of KwaZulu-Natal	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	1175
University of Fort Hare	171	249	170	178	174	176	133	180	133	338	352	433
Medical Uni. of South Africa	142	150	266	299	350	362	449	362	368	397	448	422
University of Natal	647	592	582	549	595	542	0	642	664	601	769	n.a.
University of the North	221	363	388	537	683	596	412	382	281	285	271	277
University of the Free State	547	549	536	498	458	458	470	455	391	408	378	546
University of Port Elizabeth	133	143	177	191	232	212	242	523	499	518	699	883
Potchefstroom University	348	410	405	415	481	454	508	513	407	433	584	n.a.
North West University	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	1000
University of Pretoria	1538	1600	1578	1575	1520	1532	1450	1528	1566	1417	1398	1746
Rand Afrikaans University	338	361	407	341	443	469	435	506	266	324	303	410
Rhodes University	87	101	147	125	140	167	158	196	207	356	286	206
University of South Africa	882	1030	1184	1098	1105	1054	1172	557	659	690	580	1717
University of Stellenbosch	762	842	770	817	783	776	754	864	906	960	984	970
University of Western Cape	255	308	340	397	403	367	379	453	511	493	428	546
University of Witwatersrand	1194	1210	1162	954	1015	968	914	960	875	903	958	1019
University of Zululand	426	142	318	144	133	323	365	211	205	126	203	347
Vista University	249	283	431	627	563	733	741	357	281	257	175	n.a.
University of Transkei	n.a.	n.a.	341	513	377	n.a.	518	417	362	263	205	258
University of North West	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	n.a.	659	285	162	154	n.a.
University of Venda	n.a.	n.a.	122	193	212	133	154	147	187	198	189	222
TOTAL	9071	9660	10802	10876	11017	10759	10729	11308	10473	10753	10922	13287

Institution	2005	2006	2007	2008	2009	2010	2011	2012	2013	2014	2015	2016
University of Cape Town	1278	1341	1312	1362	1267	1295	1339	1389	1440	1471	1503	1528
Cape Peninsula University of Technology	0	0	0	0	398	491	567	572	661	654	648	733
Central University of Technology, Free State	25	18	49	85	87	108	218	301	301	292	278	449
Durban University of Technology	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	23	320	24
Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University	759	663	672	514	529	463	493	543	677	649	738	760
North West University	1167	1295	1266	1244	1289	1451	1453	1768	2025	2015	2229	2236
Rhodes University	219	233	237	231	232	212	224	250	263	230	270	234
Tshwane University of Technology	98	70	57	126	311	370	486	362	485	490	537	577
University of Fort Hare	648	694	707	529	749	844	900	697	805	909	789	826
University of Free State	819	686	640	691	635	687	798	792	912	1065	1187	1118
University of Johannesburg	459	553	507	534	523	516	637	682	850	1078	1094	1177
University of KwaZulu Natal	1765	1523	1525	1602	1464	1540	1651	1912	1897	1882	2095	2184
University of Limpopo	799	838	882	986	1070	1017	1041	1193	1335	1673	1342	1468
University of Pretoria	1870	1893	2021	2081	1981	2061	2127	2204	2534	2391	2637	2866
University of South Africa	1815	808	917	1054	1186	1360	1654	2227	3549	5079	6665	8517
University of Stellenbosch	1047	1083	1056	938	1073	1085	1131	1201	1310	1335	1397	1513
University of Venda	291	300	345	566	828	1084	883	819	820	928	957	1375
University of Western Cape	658	589	690	763	771	807	925	853	965	1141	1159	1222
University of Witwatersrand	1210	1208	1432	1301	1291	1415	1448	1550	1861	1794	1948	2064
University of Zululand	306	510	577	732	681	808	739	1602	1144	1273	1298	1526
Vaal University of Technology	0	12	28	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0
Walter Sisulu University	236	270	319	432	512	460	762	1011	1072	1100	1319	1117
Sefako Makgatho Health Science University	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	469	432
TOTAL	15469	14587	15239	15771	16877	18074	19476	21928	24906	27472	30879	33946