Questions and Replies

MPs to ask the Minister of Economic Development

Source
Link

Reply:

QUESTION NO.: 1169

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 11 SEPTEMBER 2009

Mr M H Steele (DA) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

Whether his department uses temporary employment services and/or labour brokers; if so, (a) why, (b) how many positions have been filled by temporary employment services in the (i) 2006-07, (ii) 2007-08 and (iii) 2008-09 financial years, (c) what percentage of the total staff complement did temporary employment services contribute in each of these years and (d) how much money has been spent on temporary employment services in each year? NW1504E

REPLY

The Economic Development Department has not made use of temporary employment services or labour brokers.

QUESTION NO.: 1208

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 11 SEPTEMBER 2009

Mr M H Steele (DA) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

(1) Whether his Deputy Minister or his department purchased a new vehicle on the Deputy Minister's appointment to office; if so, (a) why, (b) what make and model is the vehicle, (c) what did the vehicle cost and (d)(i) what accessories were included in excess of the vehicle's purchase price and (ii) what was the cost of such accessories; if not,

(2) whether she inherited an existing vehicle; if so, (a) what was the make and model and (b) how old is the vehicle? NW1547E

REPLY

(1) The Deputy Minister has not purchased a new vehicle, she uses hired vehicles both in Pretoria and Cape Town.

(2) No. Economic Development is a new Ministry.

QUESTION NO.: 1223

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 11 SEPTEMBER 2009

Dr P J Rabie (DA) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

Whether a time-frame for the implementation of the State's response to the economic crisis has been formulated; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW1562E

REPLY

The response package consists of a number of different components. Each of these has its own timeframes. Two processes are taking place in parallel: while priorities where programmes have been agreed are being implemented, discussions are taking place in expanding the list of programmes.

For the initial list of priorities announced in parliament on 20 August 2009, the following details are relevant:

(a) The training layoff: the scheme is being launched in pilot form during September 2009. The first applications have now been received and are being processed. Subject to the progress made in the pilot phase, it is expected to be fully operational by November 2009.

(b) The IDC R6b Fund: this has been implemented and a number of applications have been approved and details were provided to the National Assembly on 20 August 2009. The IDC continues to receive more applications and will consider these on a case by case basis during the remainder of 2009 and during 2010.

(c) Distressed sector interventions: the non-fiscal components of the programmes are in the process of being implemented and those components requiring budget allocations will be dealt with through the Adjustment process. Subject to the outcome of the Adjustment process, it is planned that most of the programmes agreed to date will be implemented during the next two months.

(d) Customs fraud: the identified action is being implemented and prosecutions have been initiated in a number of cases. Details of the state of the process were provided in the Statement to the National Assembly made on 20 August 2009.

(e) Competition investigations in the food supply chain: the investigations have all commenced and some prosecutions have been initiated. Each area of the supply chain is at a different stage of progress.

(f) Debt management: Engagements with the banks are continuing. Banks reported to Nedlac that they have started implementing various measures to assist consumers in distress and these reportedly include increasing bridging loans, debt rescheduling, debt factoring, converting debt into equity and interbank lending guarantees.

In addition, as new areas of the Framework are finalised, they will have their specific time-frames for implementation. Details of these will be supplied to Parliament.

QUESTION NO.: 1208

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 11 SEPTEMBER 2009

Mr M H Steele (DA) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

(2) whether she inherited an existing vehicle; if so, (a) what was the make and model and (b) how old is the vehicle? NW1547E

REPLY

(1) The Deputy Minister has not purchased a new vehicle, she uses hired vehicles both in Pretoria and Cape Town.

(2) No. Economic Development is a new Ministry.

QUESTION NO.: 1271

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 11 SEPTEMBER 2009

Mr P D Dexter (Cope) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

Since the start of the recession, how many jobs have been (a) lost and (b) created? NW1618E

REPLY

Statistics South Africa (StatsSA) figures are the basis of tracking employment in the economy. There are two surveys, namely the Quarterly Employment Survey (QES) and the Labour Force Survey (LFS). These surveys reflect net employment, i.e. the difference between new jobs created and jobs lost.

The LFS is a household-based sample survey of both formal and informal labour activities of individuals above the age of 15 whereas the QES is a survey of enterprises in the formal non-agricultural business sector.

The data does not allow for a separation of jobs created and lost by sector, but rather for net changes in employment by sector. Certain sectors would therefore reflect net job losses and others net job gains. The aggregate data in turn reflects the net figures for the economy as a whole. The data reveals that job losses have been widespread across the economy. However, the government's response to the crisis, in particular the impact on the construction sector of pressing ahead with much needed infrastructure investment has been acting to counter the employment losses from the recession, although not sufficiently to outweigh them.

Much depends on the dates over which employment figures are compared and which survey is used.

The contraction of the economy started in the fourth quarter of 2008. The most significant impact was felt during the first two quarters of 2009.

Labour Force Survey

The following are the key findings of the LFS since the beginning of the recession, that is, from the fourth quarter of 2008.

For the six month period since 1 January 2009 to end June 2009, the position is as follows. At end December 2008, total employment stood at 13 844 000. By the end of June 2009, total employment was 13 369 000 which indicates 475 000 net job losses over the six-month period.

At the end of the third quarter of 2008 on 30 September 2008, ie the date prior to the contraction of the economy as measured by quarterly GDP figures, total employment stood at 13 655 000. By the end of June 2009, total employment was 13 369 000 which indicates 286 000 net job losses over the nine-month period.

Compared for a 12 month period, the total employment at the end of June 2008 was 13 729 000 and at the end of June 2009, it was 13 369 000 which indicates 360 000 net job losses over the 12 month period.

Quarterly Employment Survey

The following are the key findings of the QES since the beginning of the recession, that is, from the fourth quarter of 2008.

For the six month period since 1 January 2009 to end June 2009, the position is as follows. At end December 2008, total employment (excluding agriculture and the informal economy) stood at 8 512 000. By the end of June 2009, the corresponding employment was 8 259 000 which indicates 253 000 net job losses (excluding agriculture and the informal economy) over the six-month period.

At the end of the third quarter of 2008 on 30 September 2008, ie the date prior to the contraction of the economy as measured by quarterly GDP figures, total employment (excluding agriculture and the informal economy) stood at 8 492 000. By the end of June 2009, the corresponding figure stood at 8 259 000 which indicates 233 000 net job losses (excluding agriculture and the informal economy) over the 12 month period.

Compared for a 12 month period, the total employment (excluding agriculture and the informal economy) at the end of June 2008 was 8 457 000 and at the end of June 2009, it was 8 259 000 which indicates 198 000 net job losses (excluding agriculture and the informal economy) over the period.

QUESTION 141

141. Dr P J Rabie (DA) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

Whether there will be a future shift in investment by the Public Investment Corporation (PIC) and Independent Development Corporation (IDC) from equities to rural infrastructure listed companies; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

RESPONSE

The question of investment guidelines that covers rural infrastructure, as well as other priorities identified in government's programme will be reviewed, and results made public once a decision has been taken.

QUESTION NO.: 1461

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 25 SEPTEMBER 2009

Dr P J Rabie (DA) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

(1) Whether he envisages that the amount made available for rescue packages to overcome the economic recession will be depleted within two years; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

(2) whether additional funding will be made available; if not, why not; if so,

(3) whether any plans have been put in place to address the matter; if not, why not; if so, what plans? NW1819E

REPLY

It is envisage that funds will be fully utilised within the two year period. Initial indications from the IDC are that the IDC funding will be fully utilized. The IDC is monitoring the take-up on an ongoing basis. The Board of the IDC will then need to consider whether additional resources will be available. The take-up on the training lay-off will be monitored and subject to the take-up rate, the need for additional funding will be addressed. A committee drawn from the social partners and government will evaluate this on an on-going basis.

QUESTION NO.: 1913

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 23 OCTOBER 2009

Dr P J Rabie (DA) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

(1) Whether (a) he, (b) his deputy minister, (c) any specified officials and (d) any other persons have been issued with a government or official credit card; if so, what are the relevant details for him, his deputy minister and each holder of a credit card in respect of the (i) name, (ii) job title, (iii) credit limit, (iv) outstanding amount as at the latest specified date for which information is available, (v) monthly expenses incurred for each month since receiving the credit card, (vi) reason for such persons being issued with a credit card and (vii) uses that such a credit card is intended for;

(2) whether any such credit cards are over their credit limit; if so, (a) whose credit cards are over the limit and (b) what is the reason for the credit cards exceeding the limit;

(3) whether any action has been taken against such persons for exceeding their credit card limits; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW2477E

REPLY

No.

QUESTION NO.: 2002

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 2 November 2009

Dr P J Rabie (DA) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

(1) What total amount in respect of advertising has his department and all specified entities reporting to it (a) budgeted for and (b) spent during the period 1 April 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available;

(2) (a) what total number of advertisements for his department and each entity reporting to it (i) appeared in the print media and (ii) were broadcast on (aa) radio and (bb) television, (b) how much did each advertisement cost and (c) what was the purpose of each advertisement? NW2654E

REPLY

The Economic Development Department (EDD) has budgeted R600, 000 for advertising, mainly for recruitment and tender advertisements. No disbursements have been made and no advertisements have been placed.

4 NOVEMBER 2009

QUESTION NO.: 242

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 27 OCTOBER 2009

Dr P J Rabie (DA) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

(1) What is the nature of the broad-ranging economic policy changes (details furnished) that he intends to implement;

(2) whether he intends to propose any long-term changes to the exchange rate; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NO2560E

REPLY

The Honourable Member's question was prompted by a report that appeared on 22 October, in the local media. Let me start by noting that the media report was without factual basis and we have written to the media outlet concerned.

However, the broader question raised by the Honourable Member deserves a reply.

When the ruling party went to the electorate to seek a fresh mandate in the recent elections, its Manifesto set out a policy framework that contained 5 priorities. One of these relate to economic policy issues and decent work.

The President appointed a Cabinet and we adopted a Medium Term Strategic Framework that sets out the operational components of our economic programme.

So, Honourable Member, this does involve ensuring that we secure better employment outcomes principally through a more labour-absorbing growth path. This has been the theme of our public pronouncements.

I refer in this regard to the President's State of the Nation address on 3 June wherein he outlined government's economic priorities and the centrality of decent work – by which we refer to the need for more jobs and better jobs – to government's economic policies. Similarly, in a presentation I made to the Portfolio Committee on Economic Development on 19 June, these priorities and their linkages to an employment-absorbing growth path were elaborated upon. These sentiments were recently re-emphasised in the Honourable Minister of Finance's Medium-Term Budget Policy Statement (MTBPS) speech delivered to the House just over a week ago. Similarly, my colleague, the Honourable Minister of Trade & Industry noted 2 days ago the need to place the economy on a new growth path.

The guiding principles in looking at economic policy include the following:

1. Policy adjustments will be evidence-led. We will look at the facts and we let that guide us;

2. Economic outcomes must lead to better development outcomes: in reducing income inequality, fighting poverty and addressing unemployment;

3. Policy changes will be considered and approved by Cabinet. No single Ministry makes policy – we do so as a team and we place the results of our work before the President and Cabinet for consideration;

4. We will seek as far as possible the views of our social partners, i.e.of the business community and organised labour, of civil society – because they have insights and a knowledge base in the real economy that can be of enormous benefit to policy-making and they will be partners in a common vision we need to forge;

5. We learn from the experiences of countries elsewhere- both in what works and what does not work, but we have the confidence to develop a growth path appropriate to South Africa.

In respect of the exchange rate, we have expressed our goal of achieving a competitive value to the Rand. Since January this year the Rand has strengthened by about 15.5% against the US Dollar. Against the Chinese Renminbi, it has strengthened by about 16%.

The impact of this is significant. The exchange rate is a key economic variable which impacts on competitiveness, employment, industrial development, trade flows and export performance. We have become about 15% more expensive in our exports, and imports are 15% cheaper from these two major trading partners.

Private sector representatives and trade unionists have met with my Ministry to convey their concerns of the impact of the Rand on their businesses and on workers. We agreed that there is value in a Policy Platform that we will convene with economists and social partners to dialogue further on this matter.

QUESTION NO.: 2344

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 20 NOVEMBER 2009

Dr P J Rabie (DA) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

Whether, with reference to his reply to Question 366 on 17 July 2009, he has purchased a new vehicle; if not, when will he purchase a new vehicle; if so, (i) why, (ii) what make and model is the vehicle, (iii) what did the vehicle cost and (iv) what (aa) accessories were included in excess of the vehicle's purchase price and (bb) was the cost of such accessories? NW3057E

REPLY

An order and the necessary documentation for the purchase of a Toyota Fortuner is in the process of being finalised. A supplementary reply will be furnished once the final quotation has been received from the supplier.

QUESTION NO.: 275

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 27 OCTOBER 2009

Ms P Bhengu (ANC) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

What is the extent and nature of his interaction with the Minister of Rural Development and Land Reform? NO2600E

REPLY

The Economic Development Department (EDD) and the Department for Rural Development and Land Reform initiated a strong working relationship because of the significant connection between economic development and rural development.

To this end, the two Ministers together with senior officials have met and constituted a task team which is responsible for developing a joint work programme.

As a result, a Policy Platform was convened in September in Durban, Kwa Zulu-Natal. It considered the results of research on rural economic development in South Africa and policy insights from the international experience.

The Departments will work together on the formulation of a Rural Development Policy. It contains a number of specific proposals that will be considered.

QUESTION NO.: 254

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 27 OCTOBER 2009

Mr S N Swart (ACDP) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

(1) Whether his department has done an assessment of the impact of the proposed increase of 45% per annum over the following three years in the price of electricity on inflation and economic growth prospects; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details;

(2) whether he will make a statement on the matter? NO2575E

REPLY

Honourable Member, my Ministry is working closely with an Inter-Ministerial Committee that includes the Ministers of Finance, Energy and Public Enterprises, to consider the implications of the ESKOM application.

We are carefully considering three dimensions:

- first, the impact of different tariff increases on economic growth, employment, competitiveness and industrial performance, inflation and the impact on poor communities;

- second, the demand-management measures that can prudently be factored into the estimates of the country's energy needs;

- third, the need to ensure the resources for a programme to build additional energy-generating capacity, including different funding options that may be available.

The research as well as the work at interdepartmental level has not yet been concluded and thus any statement will be premature. The Minister of Finance will make a submission to the regulator by 9 November 2009 on behalf of government.

The decision on the tariff lies with the regulator. The challenge that the regulator will face in the months and years ahead is to find the optimum balance in the tariff structure that limits the negative social and economic impact and yet ensures the resources for an appropriate build-programme and the future energy-mix that provides for cleaner and renewable electricity-generation technologies.

QUESTION NO.: 276

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 27 OCTOBER 2009

Mrs D R Tsotetsi (ANC) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

How many of the fifteen companies which receive financial support from the Industrial Development Corporation (IDC) are owned by previously disadvantaged women and people with disabilities? NO2601E

REPLY

Since April to September 2009 the IDC has approved almost R 1 billion to 15 distressed firms from a dedicated facility that is in line with the Framework Agreement. These interventions are estimated to have saved over 3,000 direct jobs in six provinces.

Seven of these companies have black representation in ownership of between 20-100%; one has female representation of 8%. One company had shareholders which consist of a community trust and a workers' trust. Women form part of the beneficiaries of these trusts.

IDC support to enterprises owned by previously disadvantaged women and people with disabilities are also financed from other general and dedicated funds, details of which are as follows:-

The IDC advises that in the 2009 financial year, over 120 financing approvals (60% of IDC total) benefitted black empowered businesses. From April 2009, up to the end of September, the IDC had approved more than 70 transactions. Of these companies, 8 had more than 15% shareholding by black women.

As part of its commitment to assist entrepreneurial development, the IDC launched the Transformation and Entrepreneurship Scheme (TES) in the 2009 financial year. This R1 billion fund consists of the Women Entrepreneurial Fund (R400m), People with Disabilities Fund (R50m), Equity Contribution Fund (R150m), Development Fund (R250m – workers), and Community Fund (R150m). The purpose of establishing these funds is to increase access to finance to marginalised groups that still have difficulty in gaining access to capital in general and equity in particular.

4 NOVEMBER 2009

QUESTION NO.: 279

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 27 OCTOBER 2009

Mr S B Huang (ANC) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

Whether, in light of the signs that the economy is recovering from the international economic crisis, his department is preparing to make use of the accompanying opportunities of such recovery; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details? NO2604E

REPLY

Yes, the Department, working with other departments in government, is preparing to utilise the opportunity to prepare for economic recovery.

Recessions tend to weaken the productive base of economies. In the face of chronic demand shortages, firms have no incentive to invest in productive capacity and they tend to "scrap" existing capacity to meet whatever little demand exists. On the labour market front, the drop in aggregate demand leads to a drop in the demand for labour. The longer the recession runs, the greater the labour market damage: workers lose their productive capabilities and their skills and become discouraged from seeking jobs-the recession thereby creates a structural unemployment problem out of what was initially a cyclical problem.

The key interventions, details of which in respect of (a) to (d) were provided to the National Assembly on 28 August 2009, include:

(a) the training layoff scheme, intended to build skills during the period of industrial slack;

(b) support to distressed sectors and companies that are intended to address some of the structural problems of the companies concerned;

(c ) competition measures to address collusive practices in a number of sectors, in order to ensure that competition is enhanced, with the benefits that accrue in the long-term to the economy;

(d) addressing the problems of customs fraud that has eroded the market- share of legitimate manufacturers and retailers. The success of this effort will help to spur domestic economic activity;

(e) local procurement promotion to provide a long-term reorientation of

state procurement and provide the spur for private companies to invest in new capacity;

(f) local economic development initiatives to help generate strong growth and job creation.

QUESTION: 366

366. Dr P J Rabie (DA) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

(1) Whether he purchased a new vehicle on his appointment to office; if so, (a) why, (b) what make and model is the vehicle, (c) what did the vehicle cost and (d)(i) what accessories were included in excess of the vehicle's purchase price and (ii) what was the cost of such accessories; if not,

(2) whether he inherited an existing vehicle; if so, (a) what was the make and model and (b) how old is the vehicle?

NW426E

RESPONSE

The Minister of Economic Development has not purchased a new vehicle on his appointment to office, nor did the Minister inherit an existing vehicle. For the period since his appointment to office, he has utilised vehicles made available through the Department of Transport, the Government Garage, car rental agencies and his private vehicle. The Minister requires the use of vehicles in the performance of his duties and any vehicle purchased will be done within the guidelines applicable to Members of Cabinet.

QUESTION: 367

367. Dr P J Rabie (DA) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

(1) Whether a function was held by his department to celebrate his appointment as minister; if so, (a) how much did the function cost, (b) what is the breakdown of the cost and (c) how many guests attended the function;

(2) whether there were any related costs for the travel and accommodation of guests; if so, (a) what were the costs and (b) what was the breakdown of these costs? NW427E

RESPONSE

No.

QUESTION: 516

516. Dr P J Rabie (DA) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

Whether any function was organised to mark the occasion of the delivery of his budget vote in 2009; if so, (a) what total amount was spent on this function, (b) from which budget was the money allocated, (c) what amount was spent on (i) food and refreshments, (ii) venue, (iii) entertainment, (iv) staff and (v) transport and (d) how many persons were invited to attend this function? NW579E

RESPONSE

Economic Development has not been allocated a budget vote as yet. The Minister of Economic Development addressed Parliament on the occasion of the dti's budget vote. The function organised to mark the occasion was arranged by the dti, and accordingly the Hon Dr. PJ Rabie is referred to the dti.

QUESTION NO.: 1624

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 9 OCTOBER 2009

Mr S J F Marais (DA) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

(1). Whether his department developed and adopted a policy providing guidelines for the appointment of persons with a criminal record; if so, (a) when was the policy (i) developed and (ii) adopted and (b) where can a copy of the policy be obtained; if not,

(2). whether his department has any plans in place to develop and adopt such a policy; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

(3). whether his department does any pre-employment screening of potential employees for criminal records; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

(4). whether any employees with criminal records are currently employed by his department; if so, (a) how many and (b) what is their (i) job level and (ii) occupational category? NW2030E

REPLY

The Economic Development Department is a newly-created department and is in the process of developing staff guidelines. To date the Economic Development Department (EDD) has not developed nor adopted a written policy providing guidelines for the appointment of persons with a criminal record.

EDD has no plans at this stage to develop and adopt such a policy. Once it is more fully established, the development and adoption of such a policy will be considered.

At present, the dti assists EDD with the appointment of staff. The dti's human resources department verifies candidate's highest qualifications, confirms their South African citizenships, and checks that their criminal and credit records are clear.

In terms of the verification reports received to date, no employees have criminal records.

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

QUESTION FOR WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NO.: 1623

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 9 OCTOBER 2009

Mr S J F Marais (DA) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

(1). Whether all (a)(i) offices and (ii) sites of his department and (b) entities reporting to him adhere to the Occupational Health and Safety Act, Act 85 of 1993; if not, (aa) why not, (bb) which facilities fail to adhere to the Act, (cc) where are they situated and (dd) what (aaa) aspects of the Act does each such facility not comply with and (bbb) action has been taken in each case; if so, what are the relevant details;

(2). (a) how often should each facility be inspected and (b) when last was each facility inspected? NW2029E

REPLY

The Economic Development Department is currently accommodated within the office complex of the dti in Pretoria and in the facilities of the dti in Cape Town. The dti takes responsibility for all regulatory compliance issues. The honourable member is referred to the dti's response to question 1606 regarding the above matter.

QUESTION NO.: 1913

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 23 OCTOBER 2009

Dr P J Rabie (DA) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

(2) whether any such credit cards are over their credit limit; if so, (a) whose credit cards are over the limit and (b) what is the reason for the credit cards exceeding the limit;

(3) whether any action has been taken against such persons for exceeding their credit card limits; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW2477E

REPLY

No.

QUESTION NO.: 2002

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 2 November 2009

Dr P J Rabie (DA) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

REPLY

QUESTION NO.: 2344

DATE OF PUBLICATION: 20 NOVEMBER 2009

Dr P J Rabie (DA) to ask the Minister of Economic Development:

30 December 2009 - Questions: Minister of Basic Education

MPs to ask the Minister of Basic Education

Source
Link

Reply:

QUESTION 1664

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 16/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 22-2009)

Mrs P de Lille (ID) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) (a) How many (i) quintile 1 and (ii) 2 (aa) primary and (bb) high schools are on the National Feeding Scheme (NFS) and (b) what percentage of these schools receive it in each province;

(2) how many NFSs have been rolled out in quintile (a)(i)1 and (ii) 2 schools in each province in each year during the past five years up to the latest specified date for which information is available and (b) at what cost in each case;

(3) whether she intends rolling out the NFS to more quintile 1 and 2 schools; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

(4) whether the roll-out of the NFS has been experiencing any delays; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what delays? N2120E

REPLY:

A total of 6 769 (100%) Q1 and 4 571 (99.5%) Q2 primary schools as well as 2 902 (99.7%) secondary schools are currently on the programme. The numbers provided on Table A are based on national quintiles as gazetted.

Table A: Quintile 1 and 2 primary schools and Q1 secondary schools coverage

Province	Q1 Primary schools	Q2 Primary schools	Q1 Secondary schools
	Number of schools	% receiving	Number of schools	% receiving	Number of schools	% receiving
Eastern Cape	1 770	100	1 402	100	1 402	100
Free State1	856	100	140	95	89	100
Gauteng	202	100	378	100	42	100
KwaZulu-Natal	1 576	100	1 040	100	487	100
Limpopo	997	100	790	100	574	100
Mpumalanga2	438	100	389	100	76	97
Northern Cape	208	100	124	100	90	100
North West	461	100	203	100	132	100
Western Cape	261	100	105	100	10	100
Total	6 769	100	4 571	99.5	2 902	99.7

Explanatory notes for variances:

1. Free State

Seven Q2 primary schools are not covered. Two are former technical schools that have recently been converted to primary schools; two are schools that were closed in previous years and were reopened in 2009; two schools, whose quintile status was not stated, have been ranked Q2 in 2009; one school is a newly- built school. All these schools will be included in the 2010/11 financial year.

2. Mpumalanga

Two Q1 primary schools in Wakerstroom have been excluded upon request by Regional Management. The schools are fee-paying boarding schools that predominantly cater for learners from foreign countries.

According to the Conditional Grant Framework, it is a required that Q1-3 primary schools and Q1 secondary schools be included in the programme in terms of the official national quintiles as gazetted by the Minister. There are variances between provincial and national quintiles. As a result, provinces provide meals to more schools over and above national quintile

Number of learners in quintile 1 to 3 primary schools as at April 2009

The table below shows statistics on the number of quintile 1 to 3 primary and quintile

1 secondary schools that benefited from the programme from 2005/06 to 2009/10 financial years and the costs (expenditure) incurred.

Table B: Q1 to 3 primary and Q1 secondary schools and budget from 2005/06 to 2009/10

Province	2005/6	2006/7	2007/8	2008/9	2009/10
	Schools	Cost (R'000)	schools	Cost (R'000)	Schools	Cost (R'000)	Schools	Cost (R'000)	Schools	Budget (R'000)
EC	5 144	211 769	5 046	166 642	4 978	291,488	4 986	472 149	5 039	362 291
FS	1 416	60 628	1 643	80 078	1 472	68,004	1 472	80 907	1 427	87 082
GP	1 025	91 580	1 122	98 262	1 143	116,656	1 491	115 742	1 491	189 141
KZN	3 090	198 975	3 453	254 404	3 619	242,430	3 808	341 943	3 924	408 404
LP	2 753	191 072	2 711	212 363	2 622	192,901	2 601	253 199	2 601	287 065
MP	1 366	76 577	1 321	83 100	1 478	110,504	1 490	121 753	1 357	161 392
NC	311	28 706	445	29 199	440	37,132	440	58 991	440	41 147
NW	1 465	107 072	1425	120 635	1 154	88,254	1 092	117 093	1 057	115 562
WC	859	49 318	873	45 956	993	53,074	992	81 285	998	87 229
TOTAL	17 429	1 015 697*	18 039	979 324	17 899	1,200,443	18 372	1 643 062	18 334	1 739 313

* An adjusted budget of R200 million was received in the 2005/06 financial year, making the expenditure higher than 2006/07.

Table C: Quintile 1 Secondary schools as at 2009/10

Province	2009/10
	Schools	Budget (R'000)

Eastern Cape	182	81 420
Free State	90	23 221
Gauteng	42	38 329
KwaZulu-Natal	451	94 992
Limpopo	560	90 973
Mpumalanga	78	46 177
Northern Cape	60	9 357
North West	148	30 211
Western Cape	114	14 652
Total	1 725	429 332

3. Based on National Funding norms the programme has been rolled out to all quintile 1 to 3 primary schools and quintile 1 secondary schools. In the current financial year (2009/10), provinces received funds for preparation to extend feeding to quintile 2 secondary schools. Feeding will start in the next financial year.

4. The Department did not experience any delays in extending feeding to quintile 1 secondary schools, except for Free State Province which could not start feeding in April 2009. However all the provinces are currently feeding the required quintiles as planned.

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

FOR WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION 2319

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 29/11/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 29-2009)

Dr JC Kloppers- Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) Whether she intends implementing a longer school year for learners to resolve the problems in the education system; if not, why not; if so, when;

(2) whether the issue of school management and the many vacant posts for headmasters will be dealt with as a matter of urgency; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW3030E

REPLY:

The Minister does not intend implementing a longer school year. The current 200 day school year is in line with international practice. The Minister's focus is on ensuring that more effective us is made of the days we currently have in a school year. The Quality Learning and Teaching Campaign (QLTC) is aimed at achieving that.

On the issue of management, the Department is taking principals and aspiring principals through an Advanced Certificate in Education in School Leadership, to improve the quality of leadership in schools. Selected candidates receive full bursaries for the course. The department is planning to finance about 1330 principals in the ACE programme in 16 Higher Education institutions across the country.

(2) As at the end of October 2009, the Department of Basic Education recorded 5200 vacant principal posts.

[Source: PERSAL - October 2009]

The filling of such posts is a provincial competency since they are the employer. Provincial Department of Education advertises promotional posts on a regular basis.

It must however be noted that no Principal post remains vacant while the process of recruitment is underway. There is always an acting official who takes up the responsibilities and accountability of the principal position until the post is filled in a permanent capacity.

On the issue of management, the Department is taking principals and aspiring principals through the ACE School Leadership qualification to improve the quality of leadership in schools. Selected candidates receive full bursaries for the course. The department is planning to finance about 1330 principals in the ACE programme in 16 Higher Education institutions across the country.

Following on the Presidential interaction with school principals, the Minister has reconfigured the Council of Education Ministers (CEM) into 3 Clusters to deal effectively with most issue raised by the principals in order for the department to support them better.

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY
QUESTION FOR ORAL REPLY
QUESTION NUMBER 2317
DATE OF PUBLICATION: 20 November 2009

Mr P J C Pretorius (DA) to ask the Minister of Finance:

(1) Whether the Land Bank has changed its model of calculating interest on outstanding
loans since 1994; if so, (a) when was the model changed, (b) what are the details of
the changes and (c) why was it regarded necessary for the change;

(2) whether the debtors concerned were informed of the full details and implications of
such changes at the time when the decision was made; if not, why not; if so, how
were they informed;

(3) whether the decision to change the model was taken by the board; if not, who took
the decision; if so, on what date was the decision taken;

(4) whether existing loan agreements were amended upon the introduction of a new
model; if not, why not; if so,

(5) whether (a) such amendments were communicated to all debtors concerned and (b) it
is envisaged that the existing model will be amended further; if not, why not; if so,
what are the relevant details in each case?
REPLY

1. Yes.
(a) The model was changed in 1999 when the Bank changed its banking system.
(b) The change was in the methodology of calculating interest – from nominal annual
compounded annually (NACA) (simple) to nominal annual compounded monthly
NACM (compound).

2. Yes. The debtors were informed of the change by way of a letter. The interest rates
were reduced at that time to eliminate the impact of the change.

3. No. The decision was taken by the Lank Bank's Interest Rate Committee and signed
off by the Chief Executive Officer in 1999.

4. No. The existing loan agreements were not amended, nor were addendums prepared
for the existing agreements. This was as a result of a lack in administrative controls at
the time – once again a legacy issue.

5. (a) No. There were no amendments.
(b) No. The model complies with the normal market practice and an interest
recalculation model is being used to quantify possible differences where
claims are submitted.

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

FOR WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION 2319

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 29/11/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 29-2009)

Dr JC Kloppers- Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) Whether she intends implementing a longer school year for learners to resolve the problems in the education system; if not, why not; if so, when;

(2) whether the issue of school management and the many vacant posts for headmasters will be dealt with as a matter of urgency; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW3030E

REPLY:

(2) As at the end of October 2009, the Department of Basic Education recorded 5200 vacant principal posts.

[Source: PERSAL - October 2009]

The filling of such posts is a provincial competency since they are the employer. Provincial Department of Education advertises promotional posts on a regular basis.

QUESTION 1009

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 28/08/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 12-2009)

Dr JC Kloppers-Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) Whether any drug raids have been conducted on schools in any province since 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if so, (a) which schools were raided in each province and (b) what was the outcome of the raid in each case;

(2) whether any policies are in place to assist learners to cope with the psychological consequences of these raids; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the policies? NW1232E

REPLY:

(1) (a) Information on drug raids in schools is maintained at provincial level. A request has been made to provinces to avail information as requested. Provincial reports received thus far are outlined in Table 1 below, indicating a total of 172 schools in two provinces - Eastern Cape (4 schools) and Western Cape (168 schools). School level data is currently only available for the Eastern Cape (see Table 1).

(b) The outcome of the raids was as follows: Cannabis was found during the raids in the Eastern Cape schools. No drugs or substances were found in the Western Cape schools.

Table 1: Random search and seizure per province, January-September 2009

Province

No. of schools

Outcome

Assistance provided to learners

4 schools

· Green Point Senior Secondary

· Kei Road Comprehensive School

· Kuyasa Senior Secondary School

· Hector Peterson High School

Cannabis was found in all four schools

Counseling received from SANCA and a social worker

168 high risk schools*

No drugs or substances were found

Safe schools call centre offers counseling and debriefing

*School level data for WC not available

It is important to note that in accordance with the Education Law Amendment Act of 2007, random search and seizure procedures are only undertaken when fair and reasonable suspicion has been established that substances are being used on the school premises. In this regard, searches are conducted after taking into account all relevant factors, including:

(i) the best interest of the learner in question or of any learner at the

school;

(ii) the safety and health of the learner/s in question or of any learner at the school;

(iii) reasonable evidence of illegal activity; and

(iv) all relevant evidence received.

The Guidelines for the Management and Prevention of Drug Use/Abuse by Learners in all Public Schools and Further Education and Training Institutions have been designed to balance the privacy and psychological integrity of the child against the need to respond both reasonably and proportionally to suspected illegal activity. In this regard, random search and seizure procedures are conducted in a manner that does not traumatise learners. The Department also works in partnership with a wide range of stakeholders, including the SAPS and NGOs such as SANCA and FAMSA, in educating learners, educators and parents on the dangers of drug and substance use; and providing a supportive environment to enable those learners found using drugs to access treatment, care and support. At all times parental involvement is actively sought and encouraged

FOR WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION 1008

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 28/08/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 12-2009)

Dr JC Kloppers-Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) With regard to applications for learners to be expelled since 1 January 2008 up to the latest specified date for which information is available, (a) how many applications were made in each province, (b) for what alleged offences and (c) how many of these applications for each specified offence were accepted;

(2) (a) how many decisions to approve expulsions were made for the same period, (b) for what specified offences were they approved and (c) how many appeals with regard to each specified offence were successful? NW1232E

REPLY:

QUESTION 1

EASTERN CAPE PROVINCE

1 (a) Seven applications were received.

1(b) Alleged offences	1(c) Applications accepted
Consumption of liquor at a school function	Application was not approved
Physical abuse and bullying of another learner	Application was not approved
Assault	Application was not approved
Disrespectful to educators	Application was not approved
Possession of dagga	Application was not approved
Assault and attempt to stab another learner	Application was not approved
Assault grievous bodily harm on another learner	01
TOTAL	01

FREE STATE PROVINCE

1 (a) 30 applications were received.

1(b) Alleged offences	1(c) Applications accepted
Stabbing	02
Possession of pornographic materials	01
Possession and smoking of dagga during school hours	02
Consuming alcohol during school hours	02
Repeatedly leaving school without permission, failure to do and submit homework, displaying arrogant and disrespectful behaviour towards educators and failure to ware uniform	05
Assault	02
Assault on educator	01
Continuous disregard of school rules and disruptive behaviour	01
Theft of school property, possession of dangerous weapon and threatening an educator with a dangerous weapon	04
Possession knife	05
Endangering safety of other learner by attempting to throw another learner from second floor of the school	01
Robbing another learner cell phone	01
Sexual harassment against an educator	01
TOTAL	28

GAUTENG PROVINCE

1(a) 130 applications were received.

(b) Alleged offences	(c) Applications accepted
Assault	14
Theft	05
Drug related	01
Class disruptions	01
Sexual harassment	01
Carrying of illegal fire arm	01
TOTAL	23

KWAZULU-NATAL PROVINCE

1(a) 11 applications were received.

1(b) Alleged offences	1(c) Applications accepted
Assault and threatening a fellow learner with a dangerous weapon	02
Possession of dangerous weapon and peddling of banned substance	01
Deliberate and persistent defiance of authorities and possession of cigarettes	01
Use of habit–forming drug	02
Stabbing another learner	02
Substance abuse and breaking school rules	01
Possession, consumption of alcohol and sexual harassment of a learner	01
Attempted assault	01
TOTAL	11

LIMPOPO PROVINCE

1(a) Eleven applications were received.

1(b) Alleged offences	1(c) Applications accepted
Repeated use of dagga, cigarette and alcohol	01
Malicious damage to property, intimidation of educators, inciting other learners, and disruption of teaching and learning	03
Repeated use of dagga alcohol, cigarette, undisciplined	01
Alcohol abuse, vandalism to school property and disruptive behaviour	01
Disrespectful	01
Consistent misconduct, fighting, possession of dangerous weapon	04
TOTAL	11

MPUMALANGA PROVINCE

1(a) 23 applications were received.

1(b) Alleged offences	1(c) Applications accepted
Possession of dangerous weapons	02
Theft	02
Assault	06
Use of drugs	01
Disruptive behaviour	05
TOTAL	16

NORTHERN CAPE PROVINCE

1(a) 23 applications were received.

1(b) Alleged offences	1(c) Applications accepted
Possession of dangerous objects	06- 5 applications were not approved
Under influence of alcohol	06 applications were not approved
Possession of drugs	04 applications were not approved
Assault	04 applications were not approved
Intimidation and vandalism	01 application was not approved
Malicious damage to property	01 application was not approved
Insolence	01 application was not approved
TOTAL	01 application was approved (possession of dangerous objects)

NORTH WEST PROVINCE

1(a) Six applications were received.

1(b) Alleged offences	1(c) Applications accepted
Fighting with another learner	01
Bullying	01
Use of dangerous weapons, drugs and bullying	01
Bullying other learners	01
Involved in stabbing of another learner	01
Stabbing another learner with a pair of scissors	01
TOTAL	06

WESTERN CAPE PROVINCE

1(a) 337 applications were received.

1(b) Alleged offences	1(c) Applications accepted
Absenteeism/ truancy	02
Alcohol related	18
Arson bomb threats/ vandalism	05
Assault and violence	67
Assault with a weapon (physical harm)	48
Drug dealing and distribution	34
Drug possession and use (under influence)	68
Sexual harassment	06
Sexual misconduct and rape	13
Verbal abuse and threats	23
Disgraceful behaviour	09
Disregard of authority and instructions	04
Possession of dangerous weapons	20
Theft and fraud	20
TOTAL	337

QUESTION 2

EASTERN CAPE PROVINCE

2(a) One decision was made to approve expulsion.

2(b)

Offence	Number approved
Assault and attempt to stab another learner	01
TOTAL	01

2(c) No appeal was received.

FREE STATE PROVINCE

2 (a) 28 decisions were made to approve expulsions.

2(b)

Offences	Number approved
Stabbing	02
Possession of pornographic materials	01
Possession and smoking of dagga during school hours	02
Consuming alcohol during school hours	02
Repeatedly leaving school without permission, failure to do and submit homework, displaying arrogant and disrespectful behaviour towards educators and failure to ware uniform	05
Assault	02
Assault on educator	01
Continuous disregard of school rules and disruptive behaviour	01
Theft of school property, possession of dangerous weapon and threatening an educator with a dangerous weapon	04
Possession knife	05
Endangering safety of other learner by attempting to throw another learner from second floor of the school	01
Robbing another learner cell phone	01
Sexual harassment against an educator	01
TOTAL	28

2(c) No appeals were received.

GAUTENG PROVINCE

2(a) 23 decisions were made to approve expulsions.

2(b)

Offences	Number approved
Carrying of an unlicensed fire arm	01
Theft	05
Assault	14
Drugs	01
Sexual harassment	01
Class disruptions	01
TOTAL	23

2(c) One appeal was received and it was successful.

KWAZULU-NATAL PROVINCE

2(a) 11 decisions were made to approve expulsions.

2(b)

Offences	Number approved
Assault and threatening a fellow learner with a dangerous weapon	02
Possession of dangerous weapon and peddling of banned substance	01
Deliberate and persistent defiance of authorities and possession of cigarettes	01
Use of habit–forming drug	02
Stabbing another learner	02
Substance abuse and breaking school rules	01
Possession, consumption of alcohol and sexual harassment of a learner	01
Attempted assault	01
TOTAL	11

2(c) One appeal was received and it was successful.

LIMPOPO PROVINCE

2(a) Eleven decisions were made to approve expulsions.

2(b)

Offences	Number approved
Repeated use of dagga, cigarette and alcohol	01
Malicious damage to property, intimidation of educators, inciting other learners, and disruption of teaching and learning	03
Repeated use of dagga alcohol, cigarette, undisciplined	01
Alcohol abuse, vandalism to school property and disruptive behaviour	01
Disrespectful	01
Consistent misconduct, fighting, possession of dangerous weapon	04
TOTAL	11

2(c) No appeals were received.

MPUMALANGA PROVINCE

2(a) Sixteen decisions were made to approve expulsions.

2(b)

Offences	Number approved
Possession of dangerous weapons	02
Theft	02
Assault	06
Use of drugs	01
Disruptive behaviour	05
TOTAL	16

2(c) One appeal was received and it was successful.

NORTHERN CAPE PROVINCE

2(a) One decision was made to approve expulsion.

2(b)

Offence	Number approved
Possession of dangerous objects	01
TOTAL	01

2(c) No appeal was received.

NORTH WEST PROVINCE

2(a) Six decisions were made to approve expulsions.

2(b)

Offences	Number approved
Fighting with another learner	01
Bullying	01
Use of dangerous weapons, drugs and bullying	01
Bullying other learners	01
Involved in stabbing of another learner	01
Stabbing another learner with a pair of scissors	01
TOTAL	06

2(c) Two appeals were received and they were successful.

WESTERN CAPE PROVINCE

2(a) 337 decisions were made to approve expulsions.

2(b)

Offences	Number approved
Absenteeism/ truancy	02
Alcohol related	18
Arson bomb threats/ vandalism	05
Assault and violence	67
Assault with a weapon (physical harm)	48
Drug dealing and distribution	34
Drug possession and use (under influence)	68
Sexual harassment	06
Sexual misconduct and rape	13
Verbal abuse and threats	23
Unacceptable behaviour	09
Disregard of authority and instructions	04
Possession of dangerous weapons	20
Theft and fraud	20
TOTAL	337

2(c) No appeals were received.

QUESTION 1015

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 28/08/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 12-2009)

Mr MH Steele (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

Whether her department has provided any information to the KwaZulu-Natal Department of Education on the involvement of a certain official (details furnished) who did not disclose her directorship of a holding company and the fact that she has shares in a subsidiary of that company which did business with the department of education and received a tender from the department (details furnished); if not, why not; if so, what information was provided? NW1240E

REPLY:

The Department did communicate to the KwaZulu-Natal Department of Education regarding the case of Ms Mpati and provided the KwaZulu-Natal Department of Education with all the detail available regarding the Report of the Auditor-General. The province was requested to bring the matter to the attention of the official and take the necessary corrective action to ensure that her previous declarations are corrected accordingly. The gravity of the situation in terms of bringing the Department in disrepute was highlighted. A follow up discussion was held with the provincial department. It was indicated that there may be inaccuracies in the Report of the Auditor-General. This will be followed up by the provincial department.

QUESTION 1466

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 25/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 12-2009)

Mr D A Kganare(Cope) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) (a) What amount did her department budget for the implementation of the Occupation Specific Dispensation (OSD) and (b) what will it cost her department to implement the recently-signed OSD agreement;

(2) what amount (a) did her department budget for the laptop-for-every-educator project and (b) will be spent on this project in the 2009-10 financial year;

(3) whether any other programmes or projects were cancelled or postponed owing to the implementation of the OSD; if so, (a) which programmes or projects, (b) what was the estimated cost of each of these programmes or projects and (c) what impact will this postponement or cancellation have on delivery of quality education? NW1825E

REPLY:

(1) (a) My department does not budget for personnel costs in provinces. The projected cost for the Collective Agreement 1 of 2008, which catered for the Establishment of a Framework for the OSD for educators in public education amounted to R7 billion, which was made available to provinces through the equitable share.

(b) The projected cost for Collective Agreement 4 of 2009 which, caters for the finalisation of matters linked to the OSD in education amounts to R4, 135 billion.

(2) (a) R550 million has been projected for the lap top initiative for 2009/2010.

(b) Provincial Education Departments (PEDs) who have the resources available in this financial year may cover all educators who are eligible. Those PEDs who did not budget for this item because conclusion of the determination happened late in the financial year may phase in the initiative over two years starting 1 July 2009. My department is in a process of assessing which provinces will implement in the 2009/10 financial year to what amount.

(3) I am not aware of any programmes or projects that have been cancelled or postponed due to the implementation of OSD. The cost of the latest OSD will be funded from additional funds to be allocated to Provinces.

Lack of a feasible turnaround strategy
The applications were outside the legislative mandate of the IDC
Insufficient information
Contravention of minimum wage legislation
Funding was no longer required.

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

FOR WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION 1575

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 09/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 20-2009)

Mr D C Smiles (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education

(1) Whether her department organized or hosted (a) an imbizo, (b) a seminar, (c) conference and (d) any other function during the period 1 January 2006 up to the the latest specified date for which information is available; if so (i) on what date, (ii) what was the total amount spent on each, (iii) what is the breakdown of the cost in each case and (iv) how many guests attended in each case;

(2) Whether there were any related costs for the travel and accommodation of guests for each of the events; if so, in each case, (a) what were the costs and (b) what was the breakdown of these costs;

(3) Whether any member of the Cabinet was present at any of these events; if so, (a) who, (b) in what capacity and (c) why ? NW1981E

REPLY:

1. I was only appointed in May 2009, therefore I can only account for the period starting in May 2009. No IMBIZO was held in 2009.

2. The DoBE Teenage Pregnancy Report was launched at a seminar hosted by UNICEF; costs can be ascertained with UNICEF.

3. No conferences have been hosted by the DoBE during my term of office to date.

4. No functions have been hosted by the DoBE during my term of office to date.

5. The National Teacher Development summit was hosted by the ELRC and ETDP SETA.

6. The President's Interaction with principals was co-hosted by the DoBE, which contributed R 300,000.00 and by the private sector. The President was present in his capacity as President of South Africa. The MEC's for Education and the Premiers also attended as leaders of Government in their various capacities.

QUESTION 1544

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER : 09/10/09 (INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 20-2009

DR JC Kloppers-Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education :†

Whether the department has any plans to introduce political literacy as part of its broad curriculum; if not why; if so, what are the relevant details? NW1949E

Reply:

No. The National Curriculum Statement is a high knowledge curriculum that is informed by the principles of human rights, inclusivity, environmental and social justice. As an example, Life Orientation, a compulsory subject for all learners, deals with Citizenship in detail. It covers the following areas:

 Bill of Rights: Content, rights and responsibilities of South African citizens, role of government. Incidences of human rights violations and impact on individual and society.

 Diversity: Various contexts of citizenship; diversity in day-to-day relationships and society at large.

 Various political parties, interest groups, lobbying groups, etc. and their principles, processes and procedures in addressing the interests of civil society.

 Participation in and/or involvement in constitutions, elections, representation of constituencies, mandates, lobbying, advocacy, running of meetings.

 Participation in local community structures, such as non-governmental organisations (NGOs), community-based organisations (CBOs), faith-based organisations (FBOs), Community Police Forums, Representative Councils of Learners (RCLs), community clubs, etc.

QUESTION 52

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 8/06/2009

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 01-2009)

Ms JC Klopper- Lourens (DA) TO ASK THE Minister of Basic Education:

In respect of each of the seven most recent years for which information is available, (a) how many enquiries were conducted into educators for misconduct and (b) with regard to each enquiry whether the charges of misconduct was upheld, (i) what was the charge in each case, (ii) what was the penalty and (iii) what is the name of the educator concerned?

W54E

REPLY:

(a)

· In 2006, 484 enquiries were conducted into educators for misconduct where 452 of them were upheld;

· In 2007, 411 enquiries were conducted where 269 of them were upheld

· In 2008, 700 enquiries were conducted where 522 of them were upheld.

(b)

(i) The charges conducted against the educators consist mainly of theft, acts of corruption, fraud, negligence, absenteeism, assault, rape, working while under the influence of liquor or intoxicating substance, etc.

(ii) The penalties ranged from a written warning to dismissal.

(iii) I cannot provide the names of the perpetrators concerned as records are with SACE and the various provincial departments of education.

QUESTION 356

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 03/07/2009

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 05-2009)

Ms JC Kloppers- Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) Whether she purchased a new vehicle on her new appointment to office; if so, (a) why, (b) what make and model is the vehicle (c) what did the vehicle cost and (d) (i) what accessories were included in excess of the vehicle's purchase price and (ii) what was the cost of such accessories; if not,

(2) Whether she inherited an existing vehicle; if so, (a) what was the make and model (b) how old is the vehicle? NW416E

REPLY:

Pretoria	Cape Town
(1) Yes	Yes
(a) The vehicle was allocated as official vehicle in Cape Town to the Minister of Higher Education and Training.	To replace the existing vehicle which will reach its end of life in August 2009.
(b) Range Rover Sport TDV8	BMW 730D
(c) (c) R807 000.00	R894 500.00
(d)(i) Mudguards	Not applicable
(ii) R2 592.18	Not applicable
(2) No	Yes
(a) Not applicable	2004 Mercedes Benz E320
(b) -	5 Years

QUESTION 1140

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 04/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 12-2009)Mr D C Smiles (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

Whether her department provides (a) basic health, (b) hearing and/or (c) sight tests to school learners; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, (i) in what grades are these tests conducted and (ii) what budget was made available for the provision of such tests in each of the three most recent financial years for which information is available? NW1473E

REPLY:

(a) The Department has adopted a holistic approach to the early identification of barriers to learning by conducting provincial campaigns termed Lethimpilo Campaign. One of the key strength of the campaign is that it provides an integrated service delivery to school communities. Through this initiative, various potential barriers to learning, beyond health, are also identified and addressed through partnership with other government departments and civil society.

(b) and (c) Services provided include health screening of learners (visual, auditory, oral as well as assessing immunization status), birth registration (Department of Home Affairs), social security (Department of Social Development), food production (Department of Agriculture), and sports and recreation amongst others. Learners, as well as community members who are screened receive on-site treatment where possible. Referrals are also made to local institutions for further assessment and management.

(i) The programme has targeted at least 10,000 Grade 4 learners per province. In 2007, the campaign was conducted in FS, MP, LP and NW provinces. In 2008, the campaign was extended to NC and EC.

(ii) Table 1 depicts the budget allocations for the screening activities over the years 2007-2009 for which information is available.

Table 1: Budget allocations for school health screening, Health Promotion Directorate

Financial Year	2007/8	2008/9	2009/10
Amount	R5.6m	R2.8m	R2.5m

Budgetary challenges have limited the full reach of this initiative. Therefore, in an effort to increase the reach of, and to institutionalise health screening within the education system, the Department is presently working in collaboration with the Department of Health and other key stakeholders, to source further funds and to develop an implementation plan.

QUESTION 1139

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 04/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 12-2009)

Mr D C Smiles (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) How many educators were employed in each province in each of the three most recent financial years for which information is available;

(2) how many days in total were taken by educators as (a) ordinary leave, (b) special leave and (c) sick leave in each of the three most recent financial years for which information is available? NW1472E

REPLY:

(1) The number of educators employed in each province in each of the three most recent financial years for which information is available

Province	2006/07	2007/08	2008/09
EC	65 314	62 167	64 565
FS	23 275	22 734	23 295
GP	46 370	49 916	50 715
KZN	81 548	84 100	84 977
LP	55 128	56 546	56 432
MP	30 922	31 485	32 087
NW	31 346	26 117	25 428
NC	6 562	8 193	8 428
WC	28 654	24 895	25 522
Totals	369119	366 153	371 449

(2) The number days in total taken by educators as (a) ordinary leave, (b) special leave and (c) sick leave for which information is available at the time of this response is for 2008/09 financial year

Category Description	TOTAL
Sick-full pay (workdays)	79 848
Special (work days)	83 16
Vacation - full pay (work days)	131 83
Total	101 347

QUESTION 486

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 10/07/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 06-2009)

Mr D Smiles to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1.)Whether her department has conducted a diagnostic study of the Grade R sector across the provinces; if not, why not; if so, (a) what methodology was applied, (b) when will the findings and recommendations be released, (c) who conducted the study and (d) what was the cost;

(2) Whether all provinces participated in the study; if not, (a) which provinces did not participate and (b) what corrective measures were taken to make up for their non participation;

NW548E

REPLY:

(1) Yes

1 (a) A team of researchers and Technical Assistants (TA's) used the following methodology:

· Literature review – national legislation, policy, plans, enabling documentation etc, as well as provincial plans and reports

· National Interviews: Department of Education and stakeholders

· Provincial interviews and site visits: Provincial, district and school management and staff engaged in Grade R as well as teachers/practitioners and other stakeholders

· Focus groups/workshops in some provinces, and several national engagements, one involving provincial ECD managers

1(b)

The findings and recommendations of the reports were discussed with senior officials from the provinces at a meeting convened by the Department on the 28th and 29th July 2009. These have now been forwarded to the Minister for her consideration and advise.

1(c)

The Department of Education requested the Technical Assistance Unit of the National Treasury to contract the services of the Centre for Education Policy Development (CEPD) to conduct the diagnostic study.

1(d)

i. Professional fees R1 322 304.00

ii. Disbursement costs R 186 928.00

iii. Vat @14% R 185 122.56

Total costs R1 694 354.56

(2) All provinces participated in the study

QUESTION 488

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 10/07/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 06-2009)

Mr D Smiles to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) How many (a) students qualified as teachers and (b) newly-qualified teachers took up posts in schools in each of the past three academic years;

(2) how many grade 1 teachers are currently not qualified;

(3) how many (a) applications for admission to teacher training colleges were approved in each of the past three academic years and (b) of these applications were for the (i) mathematics, (ii) science, (iii) accounting and (iv) English language disciplines?

NW550E

REPLY:

1 (a) Total number of graduations of new teachers over the preceding four years for which data is available are shown in Table1 below.

Table 1: Number of new graduates entering teaching 2005 - 2008

Programme	2005	2006	2007	2008
B Ed	3590	4027	4112	3669
PGCE	1171	2049	1951	1942
Total Graduations	4761	6076	6063	5611

Source: Higher Education Information Management System (HEMIS

Note: Data for 2008 is preliminary, as final audited data for 2008 will only become available at the end of July 2009.

1 (b) 378 969 educators were employed in public schools either on a temporary or permanent basis as at the end of May 2009. Permanently employed educators constituted the majority (340 647). The number employed on a temporary basis stood at 38 322. Of this total, exactly 29 809 were appointed within the current year, with 25 775 appointed on a temporary basis and 4 034 on a permanent basis. The provincial breakdowns of 2009 appointments are shown in Table 2 below

Table 2: Number of educators appointed in 2009, either temporarily or on a permanent basis, per province

	*2009 APPOINTMENTS*
*Province*	*Temporary*	*Permanent*	*Total*
Eastern Cape	2 459	663	3 122
Free State	1 757	150	1 907
Gauteng	3 326	1 488	4 814
Kwazulu Natal	7 254	450	7 704
Limpopo Province	3 345	190	3 535
Mpumalanga	669	34	703
North West	1 819	50	1 869
Northern Cape	1 209	221	1 430
Western Cape	3 937	788	4 725
*TOTAL*	*25 775*	*4 034*	*29 809*
Source: PERSAL 200905

(2) Currently it is not possible to accurately provide this information on all Grade 1 teachers. PERSAL is able to provide us with the REQV classification of teachers employed within public schools, but we are not able to filter out the Grade R educators at this stage. EMIS forms, which are self reported, could be used to identify teachers teaching Grade 1 classes, however, they do not have accurate information about qualifications. The DoE is currently working on developing fields for the PERSAL system that would enable the drawing of reports on teachers' qualification type, teaching specializations and experience. Once the system has been developed we will be in a position to draw accurate reports on teacher qualifications in relation to specific grades and subject taught.

While we cannot provide accurate data with respect to Grade 1 teachers, recent research into teacher qualifications carried out by the HSRC for the Department of Education does give some insight into the qualifications of foundation phase teachers in a statistically significant sample of schools nationally. 7380 serving teachers in 580 public schools took past in the survey. There were 1424 Foundation Phase teachers in the sample, and of these 93% were professionally qualified.

3 (a) The first time registrations into teaching at Higher Education Institutions over the last four academic years are shown in Table 3

Table 3: First-time entrants at HEIs 2005 - 2008

Programme	2005	2006	2007	2008
B Ed	6 289	6 428	7 958	9082
PGCE	3 860	4 498	4421	4971
Total first time Registrations	9 049	10 026	12 379	14053
Source: Higher Education Information Management System (HEMIS)

Note: Data for 2008 is preliminary. Audited enrolment data for 2008 will only be available at the end of July 2009.

3 (b). Currently it is not possible to provide figures of registrations disaggregated to the various disciplines. Higher Education Institutions do not report the names of qualifications in a consistent manner, for example some abbreviate the name, some use the Latin name and some also use the Afrikaans name. There are some cases where a specialisation may be included. However in most education qualifications the specific phase, learning area or subject specialisation is not recorded. From 2010 all public institutions will report on registrations and graduations using the new classification of educational subject matter categories. This will enable us to disaggregate the data form HEMIS in terms of the specialisations. Institutions will also be required to use the approved designator and qualifier for a qualification in terms of the HEQF, which will enable accurate reports on students registered for education qualifications to be generated.

QUESTION 2062

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 02/11/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 26-2009)

Dr JC Kloppers- Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

Whether South Africa is moving towards conventional teaching with less emphasis on group work; if not, what is the position in this regard ; if so what are the relevant details;
What is her department's current approach to teaching? NW271E

REPLY:

1. 'Conventional' teaching requires the use of multiple approaches by teachers to respond to both the subject or skill being taught and the different learning styles of different children. No one approach is can be Different approaches will have value and relevance in a classroom.

2. There is no single teaching approach that is advocated by the Department of Education as this would go against all that is central to good teaching practice and good education. Different teaching styles are appropriate in different contexts, and all have a place in the classroom.

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

FOR WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION 1708

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 16/10/2009

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 22-2009)

Ms G G Boinamo (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) What amount was spent by her department on (a) hotel accommodation, (b) restaurant expenses and (c) travel costs (i) in the 2008-09 financial year and (ii) during the period 1 April 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available, for (aa) her, (bb) her deputy minister, (cc) specified officials of her department and (dd) any other specified individuals;

(2) Why did each individual use the specified accommodation in each case? NW2200E

REPLY:

(1) (i) (a) (b) (c) (aa) (bb) (cc) (dd) Not applicable for the 2008/09 financial year. The establishment of the Department of Basic Education and the subsequent appointment of the Minister of Basic Education occurred during May 2009.

(ii) During the period 1 April 2009 up to 30 September 2009

The breakdown of restaurant expenses for her, her Deputy Minister, and Officials in the offices of the Minister are included in the expenditure on accommodation.

Period 1 April 2009 up to 30 September 2009

(aa) Minister:

(a) & (b) Hotel accommodation & Restaurant (meal) expenses from 1 May 2009 – 30 September 2009: R 58 266.23

(bb) Deputy Minister:

(a) & (b) Hotel accommodation & Restaurant (meal) expenses from 1 May 2009 – 30 September 2009: R 34 236.11

(cc) Not applicable

(dd) Not applicable

(3) Accommodation includes hotel accommodation while an official residence was not yet ready for occupation. In each case it was the most cost effective and appropriate accommodation available when the bookings were made. Travel costs of the Minister include travel to Kenya (twice) and Tunisia as Chair of the Council of Ministers of Education in Africa (COMEDAF).

QUESTION 169

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 13/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 21-2009)

Mr D A Kganare (Cope) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) Whether any assessment has been done on the impact of Dinaledi schools; if not, why not; if so, when;

(2) whether she will make the findings available to the public; if not, why not; if so, when;

(3) whether there is a programme to increase the number of Dinaledi schools; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, which criteria will be applied to determine which schools qualify as Dinaledi schools;

(4) whether provinces play any role in identifying schools; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

(5) whether her department or provincial departments provide any support to ensure the success of these schools; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NO1294E

REPLY:

1) The preliminary assessment on the impact of Dinaledi schools has been positive. There are 500 Dinaledi schools, principally in rural and township areas, whose learner population makes up approximately 7% of the number of learners who sit for the Matric exam. These learners have, however, contributed to approximately 24% of the passes of 50% and more in mathematics. This clearly indicates a positive result. Furthermore, there has been an increased participation of girl learners in the learning areas of Mathematics and Science with girl learners achieving excellent results. This is in keeping with the objective of the Dinaledi (MST initiative) to promote participation in the areas of Mathematics and Science among girl learners. Given the positive results the Department has embarked on an in-depth study as to ascertain what were the positive aspects of the initiatives which contributed to its success and to what extent it could be expanded.

2) Yes. The final results of the study will be available to interested parties and stakeholders when the study has been concluded.

3) The Department has decided to retain the number of Dinaledi Schools at 500 and to increase the support of these schools. After the assessment has been completed, consideration will be given to the expansion of the initiative.

4) The selection of Dinaledi schools occurs in collaboration with the provinces. The Department of Education sets the criteria of schools to participate in the Dinaledi project. The criteria include the potential of the school in Maths and Science, the number of learners enrolled, consistent performance and access to opportunity.

5) Yes, there is a unit at the DoBE that provides support and oversight of Dinaledi schools. It monitors the schools and keeps a database of support for Dinaledi schools. Provincial coordinators for Maths, Science and Technology provide support to schools. The Department has provided, text books, study guides, scientific calculators and science kits to Dinaledi schools. In addition teacher training is conducted in Mathematics and Science content on an ongoing process. Over the past three years approximately 2200 teachers from Grades 11 – 12 received content knowledge training which has ostensibly impacted positively on schools.

Learners are also entered into the Mathematics Olympiads. Approximately 250 of the 500 schools have been adopted by the private sector and parastatal provided schools with extended support in terms of resources.

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

FOR ORAL REPLY

QUESTION 175

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 13/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 21-2009)

Mr DC Smiles (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

Whether her department intends implementing the recent recommendations made in the new guidelines on sex education by the UNESCO, if not why not; if so, (a) when, (b) to what extend will her department implement the recommendations in respect of five-year old to eight year old children and (c) what consultation plans will be followed with parents? N0 2074E

REPLY:

UNESCO's International Guidelines on Sexuality Education is based on research in 87 countries and input provided by experts in specialsed NGOs and other UN agencies. Education is recognised as one of the best weapons we have to reduce the HIV infection rate and to improving the sexual and reproduction health of young people across the world. Many young men and women do not have access to the knowledge that could help them make informed decisions about their bodies and their health. These guidelines aim to fill this gap.

The guidelines provide an explanation of what sexuality education is and why it is important to ensure that young people have access to it. They are organised around six key concepts:

· Relationships;

· Values, Attitudes and Skills;

· Culture, Society and Law;

· Human Development;

· Sexual behavior; and

· Sexual and reproductive health.

Each topic is linked to learning outcomes for four age categories: 5-8 years, 9-12 years, 12-15 years and 15-18 years.

The Department will consider the guidelines and then determine if any of them will be adopted for South Africa. If any of the guidelines will have implications for our Life Skills or Life Orientation Learning Programmes the department will consult all relevant stakeholders in this regard.

QUESTION 1505

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 09/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 20-2009)

Mr A P van der Westhuizen (DA ) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) What was the average of the raw marks achieved by candidates in the National Senior Certificate Examination in November 2008 before the inclusion of year marks and statistical adjustments by Umalusi, for (a) Mathematics (i) Paper 1, (ii) Paper 2 and (iii) Paper 3, (b) Accounting and (c) Physical Science (i) Paper 1 and (ii) Paper 2;

(2) what would have been the final mark per subject of a candidate who achieved a raw mark of 20% in the examination papers and for whom a year mark of 50% was submitted if both this year mark and the mark achieved in the examinations reflected the average of the marks for the learner cohort of a particular school for Mathematics Paper 1 and Paper 2, Accounting and Physical Science? NW1909E

REPLY:

(1) The raw marks achieved by candidates in the NSC, prior to the inclusion of school based assessment (SBA) marks and the statistical adjustments, are regarded as an incomplete measure of the learner's performance and are therefore not analysed or included in our reporting on learner performance. Both the inclusion of SBA marks and the statistical adjustment of marks are internationally recognized components in the summation of a learner's performance and there are sound educational reasons for the inclusion of both these components. Therefore, analyzing learner performance, with these two components excluded is a fruitless exercise.

(2) The practice of statistically adjusting the school based assessment (SBA) marks to the examination marks, is based on the principle that the SBA marks should not deviate significantly from the examination marks, in a cohort where all other conditions have remained relatively similar. Therefore, the SBA marks should not deviate by more than 5 -10% from the examination marks. In a subject where a learner obtained 20% in the examination and 50% in the SBA, the SBA will be adjusted to 25% so that it lies within the acceptable range. This practice is also based on the researched position that SBA marks have a lower reliability than examination marks. The centralized setting of the question papers and the controlled conditions relating to the writing and marking of examinations, accords examination marks a higher reliability and therefore in the absence of a more reliable benchmark, the examination is used as an anchor in this statistical adjustment process.

QUESTION 1577

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 09/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 20-2009)

Mr D C Smiles (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) Whether her department developed and adopted a policy providing guidelines for the appointment of persons with a criminal record; if so, (a) when was the policy (i) developed and (ii) adopted and (b) where can a copy of the policy be obtained; if not,

(2) whether her department has any plans in place to develop and adopt such a policy; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

(3) whether her department does any pre-employment screening of potential employees for criminal records; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

(4) whether any employees with criminal records are currently employed by her department; if so, (a) how many and (b) what is their (i) job level and (ii) occupational category? NW1983E

REPLY:

(1) No. The Department of Basic Education does not, as yet, have a policy providing guidelines for the appointment of persons with a criminal record.

(2) A policy providing guidelines for the appointment of persons with criminal records is currently under development and will be functional as soon as the Departments has satisfied itself with the legal aspects around it.

(3) Not applicable at the moment.

(4) Not applicable at the moment.

QUESTION 1296

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 18/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 17-2009)

Mr M H Steele(DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(a)(i)What is the (aa) identity number, (bb) Persal number and (cc) occupation each of the nominated members of her department's 2008-09 Audit Committee and (ii) by whom is each of the audit committee members employed, (b) on which dates did the audit committee meet in the 2008-09 financial year and (c) what records are there for each of these meetings? NW1643E

REPLY:

(a)(i) INFORMATION REGARDING AUDIT COMMITEE MEMBERS

(aa) Members

S Sithole

MC Ledwaba

MJ Froneman

Dr CP Madiba

C Mpati

(bb) Persal number

S Sithole 19475527

MC Ledwaba 18696589

MJ Froneman 12091260

Dr CP Madiba 15758761

C Mpati 61082341

(cc) Occupation

S Sithole Chartered Accountant

MC Ledwaba Chief Financial Officer

MJ Froneman Consultant

Dr CP Madiba Director District Development

C Mpati General Manager Adult Literacy Campaign

(ii) Employed

S Sithole Partner at Sithole Incorporated Chartered Accountants

MC Ledwaba City of Polokwane

MJ Froneman Government Finance Projects Cc

Dr CP Madiba National Department of Education (Temporary basis)

C Mpati Kwa Zulu Natal of Education

(b) Dates of Audit Committee Meetings for 2008/2009

8 May 2008

29 May 2008

28 July 2008

30 September 2008

1 December 2008

19 March 2009

(C) Records of Audit Committee Meetings

Minutes of each audit committee meeting are kept and also distributed to each audit committee member, external auditors and the accounting officer.

QUESTION 1278

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 18/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 17-2009)

Ms S P Lebenya-Ntanzi (IFP) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

Whether she intends introducing sign language as an official school subject; if not, why not; if so, (a) what is the timeframe for establishing a process to recognise sign language as a school subject and (b) what are the further relevant details? NW1299E

REPLY:

Yes.The Department of Basic Education in cooperation with PANSALB has already commenced with the development of Sign Language to be listed in the National Curriculum Statement Grades R-12.

The first step in the development process is to develop terminology for Sign Language. The terminology list, once finalised must be verified and authenticated by the National Language Board. PANSALB will assist the Department of Basic Education in this regard.

Furthermore, information must be obtained of the level at which the language subject will be offered. Languages are currently offered at three language levels, namely Home, First Additional and Second Additional Language levels.

Once Sign Language has been standardised, a Ministerial Task Team must be established with the aim of determining what expertise is needed and to invite experts in the identified fields of Sign Language to serve on a Subject Working Group.

It is imperative that all groupings in the aurally impaired community are identified because there must be consensus on what exactly Sign Language is and whether South African Sign Language is the only or best option. It is also important that all official languages will be accommodated in the chosen version of Sign Language.

The Subject Working Group will commence with its duty as spelt out in the Terms of Reference as developed by the Ministerial Committee. The Subject Working Group will develop the following required policy and guideline documents:

Ø Subject Statements which form the national education policy framework and stipulate the learning outcomes, assessment standards and content required for Sign Language;

Ø Learning Programme Guidelines to assist teachers with the interpretation of the Subject Statements, especially with regard to the conduct of School-Based Assessment; and

Ø Subject Assessment Guidelines to assist teachers with the composition of the School-Based Assessment and Practical Assessment Tasks of Sign Language as outlined in the Subject Assessment Guidelines.

Once the above policy and guideline documents have been developed, they must be published for public comment in the Government Gazette.

The above process takes approximately ten months.

The implementation date is to a large extent dependent on whether all groupings of the aurally impaired community have agreed to the curriculum.

Other factors that could influence the planned date for implementation, are the availability of qualified teachers in Sign Language and the availability of suitable and acceptable teaching and learning support material

Ø Subject Statements which form the national education policy framework and stipulate the learning outcomes, assessment standards and content required for Sign Language;

Ø Learning Programme Guidelines to assist teachers with the interpretation of the Subject Statements, especially with regard to the conduct of School-Based Assessment; and

Once the above policy and guideline documents have been developed, they must be published for public comment in the Government Gazette.

Other bodies/organisations to be involved are:

Ø The South African Qualifications Authority (SAQA) for the registration of qualifications on the National Qualifications Framework (NQF);

Ø Umalusi, the Council for General and Further Education and Training Quality Assurance as Quality Council, which must develop and implement policy and criteria for the development, registration and publication of qualifications; and the quality assurance thereof; and

Ø Higher Education South Africa (HESA), which must consider if a subject qualifies to be regarded as a gateway subject for entrance to a Bachelor's degree at a university. Currently there are only 18 of the 29 National Senior Certificate subjects identified for university admission. These gateway subjects are listed in paragraph 4 of the Minimum Admission Requirements for Higher Certificate, Diploma and Bachelor's Degree Programmes requiring a National Senior Certificate (NSC), published in Government Gazette, No, 31231 of 11 July 2008.

If Sign Language is to be developed at Home and First Additional Language level, the implementation thereof should commence at General Education and Training (GET) Level before there can be any implementation at Further Education and Training (FET) Level.

The duration of the National Senior Certificate qualification which is based on the National Curriculum Statement Grades 10-12 is three years, namely Grades 10, 11 and 12. A learner must offer all subjects selected, including Sign Language for all three grades, Grades 10-12. In view of this, the implementation of a newly developed subject should be incrementally, starting with Grade 10 in January of the year after approval of the subject.

Only Sign Language at Second Additional Language level can be directly implemented at FET level.

The above process takes approximately 10 months. The implementation date is to a large extent dependent on whether all groupings of the aurally impaired community have agreed to the curriculum.

QUESTION 506

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 10/07/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 06-2009)

Mr GG Boinamo to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

1. Whether any function was organised to mark the occasion of the delivery of her budget vote in 2009; if so, (a) what total amount was spent on this function, (b) from which budget was the money allocated, (c) what amount was spent on (i)food and refreshments, (ii) venue, (iii) entertainment, (iv) staff and (v) transport and (d) how many persons were invited to attend this function? NW569E

REPLY:

1. Yes

(a) R267 044.57

(b) The Communications budget

(ii) None

(iii) R20 500

(iv) None

(v) None

(d) 250

QUESTION 507

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 10/07/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 06-2009)

Mr G G Boinamo (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) Whether her department makes use of private security firms; if so, how much money was spent on such firms in 2008;

(2) whether these firms are used on a contractual basis; if so, (a) how many contracts did her department take out in this regard in 2008, (b) with which firms were these contracts taken out, (c) for what specific purpose was each contract taken out and (d) what was the value of the contract in each case;

(3) why is there a need for her department to use a private security firm as opposed to state security? NW570E

REPLY:

(1) No.

(2) Not applicable.

(3) Not applicable.

QUESTION 189

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 13/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 21-2009)

Ms N Gina (ANC) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

Whether any plans are in place to ensure that schools are not disrupted by service delivery protests at this critical period when learners need to prepare for examinations; if not, why not; if so, what plans? NO2095E

REPLY:

The Minister of Basic Education has taken all reasonable and necessary steps to ensure that learning and teaching takes place without disruption in our schools.

We share the concern that service delivery protests already may impact negatively on school activities. We are advised that in the areas affected by service delivery protests the Provincial Departments have measures in place.

Limpopo (Moutse)

Two camps were established to accommodate learners – boys were moved to Makhado Multipurpose Centre in Vhembe region and girls were moved to Tivumbeni Multipurpose Centre in Mopani. Since the establishment of the camps, the community expressed their commitment to support learners to write their exams.

However, in case there are any disruptions, the Provincial Department will set up a writing centre outside Moutse and provide the learners with transport to the centre.

Mpumalanga (Mathafeni and Sakhile)

The Circuit Managers are on high alert to move learners to other schools within the circuits in case there are any disruptions. The Provincial Legislature was briefed yesterday about the details of the planned intervention in order to afford learners an opportunity to write their exams

QUESTION 193

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 13/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 21-2009)

Mrs F F Mushwana (ANC) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

When will all schools be transformed into inclusive structures that will make them accessible to all learners, including those with disabilities? NO2099E

REPLY:

According to the implementation plan of the National Minimum Norms and Standards for School Infrastructure, provinces will apply Minimum Functionality norms and standards to all new schools, and where possible and when the budget is available, upgrading and maintenance to existing schools with the target to have all schools meeting the minimum functionality target.

This includes the programme to convert existing schools into full service schools as per White Paper 6 on Inclusive Education. The target for all schools to meet the optimum functionality is 2030 or earlier. This includes having all schools accessible to all learners. The achievement of this target, however, is dependent on the availability of sufficient funding.

QUESTION 194

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 13/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 21-2009)

Mrs M T Kubayi (ANC) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

What is her department's state of readiness with regard to the examinations? NO2100E

REPLY:

The Department of Education (DoE) is ready to implement the 2009 National Senior Certificate examinations. The DoE has used the first implementation of the NSC examination in 2008 as a platform on which to build and improve on the examination systems and processes. The challenges presented in the 2008 examination constituted the specific focus in the 2009 preparations. The DoE monitors and supports the PEDs on an ongoing basis and a dedicated state of readiness audit was conducted in each of the PEDs in July 09.

All question papers have been set and externally moderated by the Quality Assurance Council, Umalusi and have been submitted to provincial education departments for printing. PEDs are finalizing their printing and packing of question papers which will be delivered to examination centres on a daily basis in most of the PEDs, as a security measure. The registration of candidates has been finalized and the internal assessment marks are currently being moderated at the provincial level and will be collected and captured on the computer system by 15 November 09. The official commencement of the NSC examination will be on 02 November 09, by the time at which all non-official languages and practical subjects would have been completed.

The monitoring teams from the DoE and PED will visit examination centres during this stage to ensure that examinations are conducted in accordance with policy. Marking centres have been established and prospective markers have been screened and appointed.

Much progress has been made towards complete modernization of the administration system by introducing an Integrated Examination Computer System (IECS) which is already at its advance stages. In this regard multiple back-up systems run by SITA and monitored by Government Information Technology Office (GITO) have been put in place. The Minister of Basis Education will receive daily progress reports from all 10 130 national and international examination centres. Of the total number of examination centres 8 124 will be schools, 1 294 ABET, as well as 8 centres in Namibia and Swaziland. The Department is ready to provide examinations services to all South Africans travelling abroad. In this regard our embassies throughout the world play a significant part as emissaries of our national examination system. In respect of this we have received requests in Athens in Greece as well as in Perth in Australia. All processes are on track for the release of the results on 7 January 2010 and the DoE is confident that barring minor incidents which are expected in an examination of this magnitude, the 2009 examination will be successfully administered.

QUESTION 195

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 19/06/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 03-2009)

Ms JC Kloppers- Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(a) How many vacancies for school principal posts existed in each province as at the latest specified date for which information is available and (b) when will these vacancies be filled in each case? NW242E

REPLY:

(a) The number of vacant Principal posts as at the end of January 2009 is as follows:

Provincial breakdown of principal vacancy rates

Province	Vacancies	Total Principal posts
Eastern Cape	1 783	7 169
Free State	366	1 958
Gauteng	278	2 276
KwaZulu Natal	837	6 413
Limpopo Province	705	4 443
Mpumalanga	243	2 062
North West	235	2 149
Northern Cape	105	706
Western Cape	268	1 795
TOTAL	4 820	28 71

(b) The frequency of vacancy lists per province is as follows for this year:

Province	Report
Eastern Cape	Vacancy list will be released in the last term for appointment in January 2010
Free State	Vacancy list released in first and second term and assumption of duty on 1 October 2009
Gauteng	A vacancy list to be released in July 2009 for filling 1 October 2009
KwaZulu-Natal	No Report available at the time of response
Limpopo	No Report available at the time of response
Mpumalanga	A vacancy list to be released in July 2009
North West	Vacancy list released in the second term and appointments made for assumption of duty on first July 2009
Northern Cape	No confirmation of the issuing of further vacancy lists in 2009
Western Cape	The vacancy list will be released in August 2009 for possible filling of posts in January 2010

QUESTION 197

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 19/06/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 03-2009)

Ms JC Kloppers- Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) What was the backlog of textbooks in each province as at the latest specified date for which information is available;

(2) whether her department has taken any steps to rectify this situation; if not, (a) why not and (b) when will these backlogs be eliminated; if so; what steps;

(3) whether officials in her department have been held responsible for these backlogs; if not, why not; if so, (a) which officials and (b) what? NW243E

REPLY:

1 Although the procurement of textbooks is a provincial competence, the Department of Basic Education decided to conduct a survey in schools with the aim of determining the availability of textbooks in Grades 10-12. The number of school that responded and returned the survey back to the Department of Basic Education is 509, which represents 9% of secondary schools in South Africa. As indicated above only 509 surveys were returned and captured by the Department.

It is difficult to conclude that the budget given to schools is inadequate from the information provided by provinces. Not all schools provided information relating to budgets.

From the information gathered from schools, not many schools have retrieval systems in place. The table below shows the number of schools surveyed and the number of schools with retrieval systems in place.

Province	Number of schools	Number schools retrieval system
Eastern Cape	78	68
Free State	66	43
Gauteng	174	125
Kwa-Zulu Natal	24	18
Limpopo	50	35
Mpumalanga	28	15
Northern Cape	15	8
North West	53	41
Western Cape	21	16
Total	509	369

From the analysis of the survey, it is evident that many learners are not allowed to take textbooks home. The lack of textbooks impacts negatively on their performance. See table below.

Province	Number of schools	Number of schools allowing learners to take textbooks home
Eastern Cape	78	67
Free State	66	41
Gauteng	174	116
Kwa-Zulu Natal	24	15
Limpopo	50	35
Mpumalanga	28	15
Northern Cape	15	8
North West	53	42
Western Cape	21	17
Total	509	356

2. It is evident that textbook availability in schools is a problem and the Department of Education together with provincial education departments need to provide a solution to the shortage of textbooks in schools. The shortages maybe ascribed to the following:

· Inadequate budget.

· Number of subjects offered by schools.

· Procurement practices by schools.

· Lack of retrieval systems in schools.

The report was presented to provinces and their response was positive. The report allowed provinces to engage with the fact that not all learners have seven textbooks despite good intentions of provinces. From the analysis, it was agreed that proposal to draft a policy on the funding and procurement of textbooks should be developed.

3. The General Education and Training Branch has initiated a process of developing a national catalogue, which will also include an audit of LTSM in schools. However, as with FET, provincial Departments of Education are responsible for the procurement of LTSM.

4. The Department of Education is not directly involved in the procurement and dissemination of textbooks and therefore no officials could be held responsible.

QUESTION 199

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 13/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 21-2009)

Dr JC Kloppers (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) Whether any research has been done on the average amount of time spent by educators actively teaching the curriculum in classrooms per day; if not, why not; if so what are the relevant details;

(2) Whether any plans have been drawn up to improve the number of hours spent by educators in classrooms, if not; why not; if so what are the relevant details

NO2106E

REPLY:

(1) The last comprehensive study on teacher workload was conducted in 2005 by the HSRC for the Education Labour Relations Council (ELRC) entitled "Educator Workload in South Africa". In summary the study found that, on average, educators spent less time on teaching than required. The study made several recommendations which included, among others, improvement of administrative support to schools; reduction of class sizes and; reduction of learning areas in the curriculum; reduction of required assessment and recording and reporting.

(2) Measures in regards to teaching loads do exist and it is the responsibility of the Principal to allocate the minimum teaching time and Districts to monitor this. These measures are stipulated in section 3 of the Personnel Administration Measures (PAM) in (G.N. 222 of 1999 published in Government Gazzette No. 19767, as amended and updated on a regular basis). In summary the PAM stipulates that all post level one educators shall be at school for the minimum of seven hours per day. Out of that time 85%-92% and 85%-90% in primary and secondary school respectively shall be allocated to teaching. The Department has commissioned a report to review and reform the implementation of the curriculum, with a particular focus on the reduction of the administrative burden on teachers and an increase in teaching time.

A final draft report has been received and discussed in the Council of Education Ministers meeting and the final report is imminent. Among the preliminary recommendations is a reduction in administrative workload which the Department supports.

QUESTION 200

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 13/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 21-2009)

Rev K R J Meshoe (ACDP) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

Whether she has found that the poor matric results are as a result of outcomes-based education (OBE); if not, what is her conclusion based on; if so, what are the further relevant details? NO2108E

REPLY:

The National Senior Certificate (NSC) which is the new curriculum that replaces the old "matric" was implemented for the first time in 2008. The new curriculum which adopts an outcomes based approach to teaching, learning and assessment, incorporates the best practices that are designed to improve on the limitations of the old curriculum. Given that this curriculum was implemented for the first time in 2008, and that it is a significant change from the old, the performance in 2008 cannot be compared to previous years. The new NSC curriculum must be evaluated in the context of what this curriculum has produced and how does it better equip learners for further education and the world of work. The performance in 2008 will serve as a baseline for future comparative studies. However, one the biggest achievements of the new curriculum is that 343 000 learners have exited the system with either Mathematics or Mathematical literacy as part of their qualification, compared to the 184 000, that exited the system with Mathematics in 2007. Making Mathematical knowledge and skills available to the broader population of learners is certainly a remarkable gain.

The new curriculum is internationally comparable and therefore cannot be linked to poor performance. There are issues relating to the implementation of the new curriculum, which include, inter alia, effective advocacy of the new policy, teacher training, availability of appropriate learner and teacher support material, advisory and assessment support to teachers, which my Department is dealing with in a decisive manner. My Ministry is committed to improving learner performance in the education system and will therefore leave no stone un-turned in ensuring that this goal is achieved.

QUESTION 665

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 07/08/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 07-2009)

Mr DC Smiles (DA) to ask the Minister of basic Education:

Whether her department has any statistics on the breakdown of matric candidates in 2008 in terms of race; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, (a) how many (i) black, (ii) coloured, (iii) Indian, (iv) white, (v) Asian and (vi) other learners wrote the 2008 Senior Certificate examinations in each province and (b) how many of these learners (i) failed, (ii) passed, (iii) passed with matric exemption, (iv) passed with merit and (v) passed with distinction? NW751E

REPLY:

Statistics on the break down of candidates who wrote the Grade 12 NSC examination in 2008, in terms of race is available

(a) (i) to (vi) See table 1 column 1.

(b) (i) See table 1 column 3.

(b) (ii) See table 1 column 2.

(b) (iii) See table 1 columns 4, 5 and 6 for the types of passes which allows candidates admission to Higher Education.

(b) (iv) The NSC in 2008 did not make provision for "Pass with merit" in 2008.

(b) (v) The NSC in 2008 did not make provision for "Pass with distinction" in 2008.

TABLE 1 - NSC Nov 2008 - Race data per province

		1	2	3	4	5	6
Province Name	Race	Wrote	Passed	Failed	Pass Bachelor	Pass Diploma	Pass Higher Certificate
EASTERN CAPE	Asian	34	32	2	25	6	1
EASTERN CAPE	Black	52,998	24,120	28,878	5,401	8,796	9,722
EASTERN CAPE	Coloured	4,053	3,115	938	807	1,420	864
EASTERN CAPE	Indian	155	149	6	101	37	10
EASTERN CAPE	Unspecified	14	12	2	5	4	3
EASTERN CAPE	White	3,130	3,097	33	2,108	901	78
EASTERN CAPE Total		60,384	30,525	29,859	8,447	11,164	10,678
FREE STATE	Asian	114	92	22	43	24	23
FREE STATE	Black	26,050	17,728	8,322	3,865	7,418	6,373
FREE STATE	Coloured	743	550	193	147	273	122
FREE STATE	Indian	28	27	1	18	6	3
FREE STATE	Unspecified	1	1	0	1	0	0
FREE STATE	White	3,278	3,246	32	2,219	945	64
FREE STATE Total		30,214	21,644	8,570	6,293	8,666	6,585
GAUTENG	Asian	164	153	11	105	34	10
GAUTENG	Black	71,687	50,446	21,241	14,565	19,397	14,678
GAUTENG	Coloured	4,553	3,719	834	1,306	1,419	854
GAUTENG	Indian	2,367	2,306	61	1,567	476	172
GAUTENG	Unspecified	19	18	1	14	3	1
GAUTENG	White	15,291	15,155	136	10,051	4,488	449
GAUTENG Total		94,081	71,797	22,284	27,608	25,817	16,164
KWAZULU-NATAL	Asian	1,035	444	591	100	164	177
KWAZULU-NATAL	Black	126,090	67,238	58,852	16,657	25,697	24,447
KWAZULU-NATAL	Coloured	1,613	1,433	180	630	567	233
KWAZULU-NATAL	Indian	8,792	8,258	534	4,282	2,987	980
KWAZULU-NATAL	Unspecified	23	23	0	21	2	0
KWAZULU-NATAL	White	2,919	2,905	14	2,156	680	66
KWAZULU-NATAL Total		140,472	80,301	60,171	23,846	30,097	25,903
LIMPOPO	Asian	79	75	4	51	17	3
LIMPOPO	Black	87,171	46,981	40,190	10,041	16,743	19,677
LIMPOPO	Coloured	134	89	45	27	41	20
LIMPOPO	Indian	3	1	2	1	0	0
LIMPOPO	Unspecified	9	5	4	2	2	1
LIMPOPO	White	1,386	1,379	7	921	423	23
LIMPOPO Total		88,782	48,530	40,252	11,043	17,226	19,724
MPUMALANGA	Asian	599	237	362	60	77	94
MPUMALANGA	Black	50,563	24,910	25,653	4,815	9,327	10,376
MPUMALANGA	Coloured	243	197	46	76	78	42
MPUMALANGA	Indian	132	130	2	74	41	10
MPUMALANGA	Unspecified	10	4	6	0	2	2
MPUMALANGA	White	2,429	2,405	24	1,468	864	56
MPUMALANGA Total		53,976	27,883	26,093	6,493	10,389	10,580
NORTH WEST	Asian	24	20	4	14	4	1
NORTH WEST	Black	29,479	19,005	10,474	4,057	7,601	6,987
NORTH WEST	Coloured	511	399	112	115	174	97
NORTH WEST	Indian	104	99	5	81	15	1
NORTH WEST	Unspecified	5	4	1	2	0	1
NORTH WEST	White	2,962	2,943	19	1,944	896	83
NORTH WEST Total		33,085	22,470	10,615	6,213	8,690	7,170
NORTHERN CAPE	Asian	17	13	4	6	5	1
NORTHERN CAPE	Black	5,023	3,286	1,737	673	1,296	1,230
NORTHERN CAPE	Coloured	3,965	2,989	976	660	1,395	887
NORTHERN CAPE	Indian	16	15	1	12	2	1
NORTHERN CAPE	Unspecified	6	4	2	2	0	2
NORTHERN CAPE	White	950	944	6	584	329	26
NORTHERN CAPE Total		9,977	7,251	2,726	1,937	3,027	2,147
WESTERN CAPE	Asian	53	52	1	38	12	2
WESTERN CAPE	Black	11,767	7,051	4,716	1,815	2,602	2,286
WESTERN CAPE	Coloured	22,398	17,896	4,502	5,159	7,778	4,439
WESTERN CAPE	Indian	421	408	13	296	83	16
WESTERN CAPE	Unspecified	645	610	35	359	198	36
WESTERN CAPE	White	8,408	8,376	32	6,500	1,674	117
WESTERN CAPE Total	43,692	34,393	9,299	14,167	12,347	6,896
Grand Total		554,663	344,794	209,869	106,047	127,423	105,847

QUESTION 263

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 26/06/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 04-2009)

Mr GR Morgan (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

Whether her department has a policy on the use of South African Sign Language (SASL) as (a) language of study and (b) an examinable language; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what is the policy;
Whether the policy is reflected at provincial level; if not, why not; if so what are the relevant details,
How many learners (a) studied and (b) wrote matric exams on SASL in each of the most recent years? NW313E

REPLY:

1. Yes, the Department of Basic Education has several policies that have relevance to the South African Sign Language. Firstly, The Language in Education Policy (14 July 1997) published in terms of the National Education Policy Act (Act 27 of 1996) states that in terms of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, the government, and thus the Department of Education, recognizes that our cultural diversity is a valuable national asset and hence is tasked, among other things, to promote multilingualism, the development of the official languages, and respect for all languages used in the country, including South African Sign Language and the languages referred to in the South African Constitution.

The Revised National Curriculum Statement, Gr R – 9, 2002 states that the Languages Learning Area Statement includes all eleven official languages as well as languages approved by the Pan South African Language Board (PANSALB) such as South African Sign Language (p.19, Overview). It must however be noted that the process of standardising South African Sign Language, although far advanced, has not yet been completed by PANSALB.

Although Education White Paper 6 on Building an Inclusive Education and Training System, July, 2001, published in terms of the National Education Policy Act (Act 27 of 1996) does not make specific reference to SASL, it emphasises that language and medium of learning and teaching are critical barriers to learning that have to be addressed in education (Section 2.2.6.1). SASL is thus used as a medium of instruction in schools for deaf learners. Several Guidelines that have been developed to strengthen the implementation of the Departmental policies have emphasised the strengthening of SASL as a medium of instruction for Deaf learners (e.g. Guidelines to Ensure Quality Education and Support in Special Schools and Special School Resource Centres, 2007; the National Strategy on Screening, Identification, Assessment and Support, 2008; Guidelines for Inclusive Learning Programmes, 2005). The Department has also ensured that the capacity of teachers at schools for the Deaf are strengthened in the area of SASL by several nationally organised training programmes between 2006 and 2008.

SASL is not an examinable subject. The National Senior Certificate: A Qualification at Level 4 on the National Qualifications Framework (NQF), 2005, does not list SASL as a nationally approved subject that complies with the programme requirements of the NCS Grades 10 – 12 (General) under either Group A or Group B. Provision is made in the policy for the recognition of subjects not listed in the National Curriculum Statement Grades 10 – 12 (General) provided that formal application is made to the Department of Basic Education according to set procedures. Such a process has not yet been formally initiated by the SASL interest groups.

2. All the above-mentioned policies are carried out by Provincial Departments of Education. The Department of Basic Education identifies priority areas of development and monitors whether these are implemented. One of the priority areas has been the strengthening of educational standards in all special schools. This includes continued professional teacher development in the use of SASL as a medium of instruction. All curriculum policies are implemented at provincial level.

3. No learners have studied SASL as a subject, nor written the National Senior Certificate examination in SASL, as PANSALB has not finalised the development of the SASL as a language. A curriculum has therefore not yet been developed for the study and examination of SASL as a subject. SASL is used as a medium of instruction in a number of special schools.

QUESTION 262

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 26/06/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 04-2009)

Dr JC Kloppers - Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

Whether teachers are required to contribute towards the Unemployment Insurance Fund (UIF), if so, (a) what conditions apply to their joining and (b) what reasons might result in a teacher not contributing to the UIF; if not, (i) why not and (ii) what other provision is made for teachers who lose their jobs? NW312E

REPLY:

1 In terms of section 4 of the Unemployment Insurance Contributions Act, No. 4 of 2002 (the Act), the Act applies to all employers and employees, other than, inter alia, employers and employees in the national and provincial spheres of government.

1(a) They may not join at all

1(b) They are prohibited to join by law

1(b)(i) They are required to contribute towards the Government Employees' Pension Fund (GEPF)

1(b)(ii) Government employees contribute to the Government Employees Pension Fund (GEPF), and upon termination of service, pension benefits are paid to the former government employees.

QUESTION 995

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 28/08/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 12-2009)

Mr D Smiles to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

What (a) is the status of the recapitalisation plans for 100 technical schools as indicated in Budget Vote 13 (details furnished), (b) are the relevant frameworks, including timeframes, (c) is the relevant budget for the (i) 2009-10, (ii) 2010-11 and (iii) 2011-12 financial years and (d) are the names per province of each of the technical schools that will be the beneficiaries of this project? NW1218E

REPLY:

a) The Department of Basic Education (DoBE) has established an inter-provincial steering committee comprised of officials of the DoBE and provincial coordinators for technology subjects. The steering committee is responsible for coordinating the implementation of the recapitalization project. In addition, the Department has finalized the process to appoint a suitable provider to audit selected technical schools to be considered for recapitalization. The audit will assess infrastructure needs, equipment requirements, teacher and learner support and learning and teaching requirements in the selected schools.

b) The Department has developed a framework for the implementation of the recapitalization of technical schools. The first phase of the process will be used for planning purposes and will take place in 2009/10 financial year. This will include a report of the audit of schools and the development of business plans for the recapitalization process.

The second phase of the process will commence in 2010/11 financial year and will include the procurement and delivery of the relevant support to schools. The process will also include the monitoring of schools to ensure compliance with the business plans and the conditions for the recapitalization grant.

The third phase will take place in the 2011/12 financial year and will include the finalization of procurement and delivery of relevant support to schools.

c) The budget allocated for the recapitalization of technical schools is as follows:

2009-10: R4.6 million

2010-11: R80 million

2011-12: R200 million

d) The names of schools to be recapitalized will be informed by the outcomes of the audit process of technical schools.

QUESTION 687

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 07/08/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 07-2009)

Mrs AT Lovemore (DA) to ask the Minister of basic Education:

Whether, in light of the current recession and the consequent shortfall in state revenue, her department has introduced any austerity measures to reduce its expenditure with regard to (a) official vehicles, (b) travel, (c) travel by departmental officials, (d) accommodation and household help or (e) any other aspects of government business; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details? NW781E

REPLY:

The Department has the following austerity measures to reduce expenditure:

(a) Any official vehicle purchased is done in accordance with the Ministerial handbook for use in Pretoria and Cape Town.

(b) As far as travel is concerned, one has to take into account that travelling remains an unavoidable expense in order to effectively meet the many responsibilities of a National Department of Education. As indicated under (a) any expenses incurred for travel will be done within the official guidelines and parameters set by government.

(c) Travel by Departmental officials has been reduced substantially in order to reduce costs. Where possible the number of officials traveling is reduced. Overnight accommodation is limited and is only arranged if it is a necessity. Telephone/video conferencing is also utilised where possible to save costs on both travel and accommodation.

(d) Accommodation and household help is treated in accordance with the Ministerial handbook.

(e) Cost containment measures are applied with the normal operations of the Department. In support of cost containment measures and the Cost Containment Guidelines issued by National Treasury, the accounting officer issued a circular to senior managers to request them to ensure that spending plans should be closely interrogated in terms of the overall need and value of the programme, before proceeding. Managers were also requested to identify any possible savings/under-expenditure that could be utilised for unfunded areas.

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 13/11/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 28-2009)

QUESTION 2201

Mr PF Smith (IFP) asked the Minister of Basic Education:

Whether physical education and/or sport are a standard part of the curriculum in public schools; if not, (a) why not and (b) when will it be a standard part of the curriculum; if so, what are the relevant details? NW2762E

Minister of Basic Education: Mrs A Motshekga REPLY:

Yes, Physical Education forms an integral part of the public schools' curriculum and is part of the Life Orientation curriculum. Life Orientation is one of the eight learning Areas that all schools have to offer to Grade R-9 learners during the General Education and Training band and one of the fundamental (i.e. compulsory) subjects that all Grade 10-12 learners must offer as part of their 7 (seven) package for a National certificate.

Not applicable

QUESTION 1353

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 18/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 17-2009)

Dr J C Kloppers-Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

Whether she has taken any steps to release the results of the remarked scripts of November 2008 of the National Senior Certificates examinations; if not, why not; if so, what steps? NW1709E

REPLY:

The results of the re-marked scripts relating to the 2008 National Senior Certificate (NSC) examination were released on 27 February 2009. Subsequent to the release of the re-mark results, candidates were offered the opportunity of writing the supplementary examinations in February/March 09. The results of the supplementary examination were released on 28 April 09. The Department of Education monitors on a continuous basis the provincial education departments and I am not aware of any re-mark results that have not been released.

QUESTION 1352

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 18/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 17-2009)

Dr J C Kloppers-Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) What is the state of readiness of her department for the National Senior Certificate Examinations (NSCEs) for 2009;

(2) whether any problems are forseen for the upcoming NSCEs; if so, what problems;

(3) whether any plans are in place to avoid the problems which occurred with the 2008 NSCEs; if not, why not; if so, what plans? NW1708E

REPLY:

(1) The Department of Education is ready and confident that the 2009 National Senior Certificate examination will be successfully administered. The Department of Education supports and monitors the provincial education departments on an ongoing basis through on-site audits of examination systems and processes, regular reporting and feedback, inter-provincial meetings and teleconferences. This approach has assisted in identifying the shortcomings as they occur, and rectifying them immediately.

(2) There are no problems that are foreseen at this stage. All possible problems have been identified and plans have been put in place to address them effectively.

(3) Clear plans have been put in place to ensure that all candidates received their results timeously. The problem of not releasing the results all the candidates on the scheduled release date, in 2008, emanated from the new emphasis being placed on school based assessment (SBA) by the Department of Education. Improved control systems were put in place to ensure that candidates are not resulted if the SBA is outstanding, a process that was not in place in previous years. This year all Provincial Education Departments have established quarterly monitoring systems that will ensure that schools are assessing their learners on a continuous basis and defaulting schools will be identified and remedial measures will be initiated, to ensure that moderated SBA marks are collected. The computer system that was implemented for the first time, in the 2008 examination, has successfully processed the 2009 supplementary examination results and is being further enhanced and improved to ensure that there are no glitches in the 2009 NSC examination. The results of the 2009 examination will be released on 7 January 2010 an this will allow school principals and the officials in the Provincial Education Departments more time to verify and check all results before they are released.

QUESTION 1871

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 23/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 22-2009)

Dr JC Kloppers- Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

1. Whether (a) she, (b) her deputy minister, (c) any specified officials and (d) any other persons have been issued with a government or official credit card; if so, what are the relevant details for her, her deputy minister and holder of a credit card in respect of the name (i) name, (ii)job title, (iii) credit limit, (iv) outstanding amount as at the latest specified date for which information is available, (v) monthly expenses incurred for each month since receiving the credit card, (vi) reason for such persons being issued with credit card and (vii) uses that such a credit card is intended for;

2. whether any such credit cards are over their credit limit; if so (a) whose credit cards are over the limit and (b) what is the reason for the credit cards exceeding the limit;

3. Whether any action has been taken against such persons for exceeding their credit card limits; if not, why not, if so, what are the relevant details? NW2433E NW2286

REPLY:

(1) (a), (b) & (c) No

(1) (i) to (vii) Not applicable

(2) (a) and (b) Not applicable

(3) Not applicable

QUESTION 1870

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 23/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 22-2009)

Dr JC Kloppers- Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) In respect of each version of the 2008-09 annual report of the annual reports of each statutory and other entity reporting to his department, (a) what was the (i) budgeted cost, (ii) actual cost and (iii) breakdown of cost in respect of (aa) printing, (bb) graphic design, (cc) other costs and (dd) unit cost of each annual report and (b) how many copies of each were (i) produced and (ii) distributed;

(2) whether any version of the abovementioned reports was retracted or withdrawn; if so, (a) how many times were each annual report withdrawn or retracted, (b) what (i) were the reasons for each withdrawal or retraction and (ii) was the amount spent on each version and (c) how many copies were withdrawn in each case;

(3) how was the decision taken to award the contract to the (a) graphic design company and (b) printing company;

(4) whether (a) any of those public entities that fall under his department held a function on tabling their 2008-09 annual report; if so, in each case (i) what was the name of the public entity, (ii) how much did the function cost, (iii) what is the breakdown of that cost, (iv) where was the function held and (v) how many guests were invited?

QUESTION (1a)	i) Public Entity Budgeted cost of the Annual Report	ii) Actual cost of the Annual Report	iii) Breakdown of cost in respect of
PUBLIC ENTITY			Printing	Graphic Design	Other costs	Unit cost of each Annual Report
Education Labour Relations Council (ELRC)	269 500	216 734	153 085	0	63 649	84.00
South African Council for Educators (SACE)	100 000	79 309	79 309	0	0	51.83
Umalusi	214 671	91 081	52 611	40 470	0	46.54

Question (1b)	i) How many copies were produced?	ii) How many copies were distributed
Public Entity	2008/09	2008/09
ELRC	1 700	1 650
SACE	1 530	1 185
Umalusi	2 000	1 250

	ELRC	SACE	Umalusi
QUESTION 2 (b)	NO version retracted or withdrawn from Parliament	NO version retracted or withdrawn from Parliament	NO version retracted or withdrawn from Parliament

QUESTION 3	Through evaluation of competitive quotations.	The Council's procurement policy was applied in awarding the tender to design and printing company. In this case the work was done as a package for both design and printing.	The Graphic design and Printing contract was awarded to The Ideaology Communications & Design Company. Their quotation was compared with two competing companies.

QUESTION 4 (b)	No function held.	No function held.	No function held.

QUESTION 285

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 03/07/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 05-2009)

Mr DA Kganare (COPE) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(a) How many educators have been trained in the use of computers, (b) who trained them, (c) when they were trained, (d) how was the service provider appointed and (e) who paid them for training;
whether these service providers are accredited; if not, why were they were appointed;
when will the (a) roll-out of providing each educator with a laptop resume and (b) last educator get a laptop? NW337E

REPLY:

1.(a)

Teacher training in ICT

• training in basic ICT skills 52 915

• the use of ICT training for administration 31 091

• teacher training in ICT integration 23 980

• training in technical support 22 361

• teachers offering Computer Applications Technology 1 578

1(b)

Provinces are responsible for teacher development in schools. Each province has an ICT in Education Teacher Development Programme. They make use of a range of in-house e-learning specialists, Higher Education Institutions (Universities and universities of Technology), NGOs such as School Net SA and private sector such as Microsoft 'Partners in Learning' and Intel 'Teach to the Future 'and EduNova.

1(c)

Central to the implementation of ICT is the continuous development of managers, administrators and teachers. The National Department of Education is responsible for policy and support to provinces. In this regard the Department of Basic Education has implemented the following teacher development and support processes to support the attainment of the e-Education goals:

· Guidelines for teacher training and professional development in ICT were published (Department of Education, 2007). This document presents an important milestone, in that it attempts to adequately address the ICT training needs of teachers and managers.

· Module 12 of the Principals' ACE was developed by the Department of Education and focuses on the management of and with ICT in schools. The programme is currently being piloted with 400 school principals;

· An interactive CD containing Subject advisors training in the use of ICT was developed. This forms the basis for a programme for the integration of ICT into teaching and learning and the support thereof for Subject Advisors;

· Partnership programmes for the development of ICT skills of teachers through the Microsoft's Partners in Learning, Intel's Teach, the School Net SA Teacher Development Framework, and other programmes; and

· The Thutong Educational Portal was developed to provide a platform for teachers to access resources, communicate, collaborate and contribute to the resource pool of the portal.

1(d)

Provincial Education Departments remunerate service providers that have been tendered.

All service providers employed by provinces are at least accredited through the ISETT SETA. Teacher development is a continuous process.

3 (a)

The implementation of the teacher laptop initiative began 1 July 2009.

3 (b)

The initiative is phased in over two years according to the seniority of the educator. As this is a condition of service, it will continue indefinitely since we have teachers entering the profession on a daily basis.

QUESTION 288

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 03/07/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 05-2009)

Mr MH Hoosen (ID) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

1. Whether her department has, in terms of section 45(1) of the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences and Related Matters) Amendment Act, Act 32 of 2007, applied for clearance certificates for all educators from the Registrar of the National Register for Sex Offenders; if not, why not; if so, (a) what is the total number of educators whose particulars are contained in the register and (b) how often does her department apply to the Registrar for clearance certificates for educators? NW340E

REPLY:

My Department has not, in terms of section 45(1) of the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences and Related Matters) Amendment Act, Act 32 of 2007, applied for clearance certificates for all educators from the Registrar of the National Register for Sex Offenders.

The reason for not applying for clearance certificate is that the office of the Registrar for the National Register for Sex Offenders is currently capturing court orders that have been issued since June 2008. These orders are with regards to sexual offences committed by employees working directly or indirectly with children.

Only when the electronic capturing of court orders has been completed, will the office of the Registrar for the National Register for Sex Offenders start screening the orders in relation to which Department the offenders are employed.

Thereafter, the relevant Departments will be contacted and supplied with clearance certificates application forms that they have to complete on behalf of those employees that have committed sexual offences and returned to the above-mentioned office.

(b) Not applicable

QUESTION 201

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 13/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 21-2009)

Rev K R J Meshoe (ACDP) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

Whether her department intends replacing outcomes-based education (OBE); if not, why not; if so, when? NO2109E

REPLY:

In July 2009 the Minister of Education appointed a team of curriculum experts to review problems with the implementation of the National Curriculum Statement. Over 500 written submissions were received on this matter and the Review Team conducted hearings and interviews with over 200 teachers. The recommendations of teachers and the Review Team are being considered by the Department of Education and the Minister will make a statement on the National Curriculum Statement and support for its implementation by the end of October 2009.

QUESTION 220

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 26/06/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 04-2009)

Mr GR Morgan (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

How much capital expenditure has been devoted to the construction of university residences in each of the past 15 years, (b) how much has been spent on maintenance of existing residences in each of these years and (c) what are the current (i) occupation rates for student and (ii) management capacity in residences in each university;
Whether his department will conduct an audit of university residences; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW267E

REPLY:

1. The Department of Higher Education and Training will, during 2010, be undertaking a study of student housing in the public higher education system. The study will focus on the system's need for additional student housing, and on the ways in which expansion could be financed. The Department will draw on lessons learned from the 2010/11 to 2011/12 residence expansion process funded by government, institutions and the private sector. The implementation of these expansion plans will lead to the number of student housing places rising by 7 000 by the 2011 academic year, from the current total of 100 000. This expansion programme includes provision for the major renovation of 2 000 existing residence places, primarily in smaller rural universities.

2. Yes and relevant details are provided above (referred to -1).

QUESTION 907

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 21/08/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 10-2009)

Dr JC Klopper-Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of basic Education:

Whether her Director- General signed a performance contract with her; if not, why not; if so, when;
Whether all senior managers in her department signed performance contracts with the Director-General; if not, (a) which senior managers did not sign, (b) for what reason and (c) when will it be done; if so, on which date each senior manager sign a performance contract? NW1063E

REPLY:

1 Yes the Director-General did sign a performance agreement, on 25 August 2009.

2. No, not all senior managers signed performance agreements with the Director-General

(a) The following senior managers did not sign the performance contracts:

o Carelse VC

o Mabizela M

o Matlole A

o Hoyi NW

o Motaung N

(b) Performance Agreements of Carelse VC and Mabizela M are in the process of being signed and will be forwarded to the DPSA soon, and that of Matlole A, Hoyi NW and Motaung N are delayed owing to changes in their respective job descriptions.

(c ) As soon as the Director-General has taken a final decision on the matters raised in these three officials' new job descriptions, they will be finalised.

QUESTION 1629

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 09/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 20-2009)

Mr N D du Toit (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) Whether all (a)(i) offices and (ii) sites of his department and (b) entities reporting to him adhere to the Occupational Health and Safety Act, Act 85 of 1993; if not, (aa) why not, (bb) which facilities fail to adhere to the Act, (cc) where are they situated and (dd) what (aaa) aspects of the Act does each such facility not comply with and (bbb) action has been taken in each case; if so, what are the relevant details;

(2) (a) how often should each facility be inspected and (b) when last was each facility inspected?

NW2035 E

REPLY:

(1) (a) (i) and (ii) The Department of Basic Education is not functional yet and is currently making use of the facilities and resources of the Department of Education. The Department of Education is stationed in three buildings in central Pretoria and they all adhere to the Occupational Health and Safety Act.

(b) At the moment it is not clear if the public entities which report to the Minister adhere to the Occupational Health and Safety Act. This information will be obtained and submitted to you as soon as possible.

(2) The buildings of the Department of Education are checked on a monthly basis for compliance and any deviations from the Occupational Health and Safety Act are corrected immediately.

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 21/08/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 10-2009)

Mrs C Dudley (ACDP) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

What was the urgency that resulted in a last minute change of design to the 2008 National Senior Certificate delaying its distribution to August;
whether she has been informed of the difficulties experienced by learners as a result of the delay; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so,
whether she will take any steps in this regard; if not, why not; if so, what steps? NW1090E

REPLY:

The National Senior Certificate is being issued for the first time this year, following the first National Senior Certificate examinations in 2008. As a new qualification, this Certificate needed to be designed afresh, so there are no"last minute changes of design"as indicate in the question.

It may be recalled that the old Senior Certificates did not carry the Coat of Arms, and only reflected the Umalusi logo. This is inappropriate for a government issued, national certificate, and created problems for students who took the certificate oversea, only to be asked whether the certificate had any official status. It was therefore agreed that the new National Senior Certificate should indicate it is a properly endorsed and official certificate of the government of South Africa, by carrying the Coat of Arms of Republic.

The initial draft version of the new Certificate developed by Umalusi showed the Coat of Arms in the one Corner of the page- in clear contravention of the guidelines pertaining to the use of national symbols. The Department, working with Umalusi, therefore agreed on a new design which would place the Coat of Arms at the centre, in accordance with protocol. Umalusi would remain as the issuer of the Certificate, duly signed by the Chief Executive Officer Dr. Rakometsi. The acquisition of the high quality paper required has followed the approval of this design , and the new Certificates are being issued at present.

While the delay may be regrettable, I believe it would have been even more problematic to have issued this first cohort of Senior Certificate recipients with an inferior product. The new design is one that any matriculant would be proud to display, with international and national currency.

I am not aware of any difficulties being encountered in this regard, since all students have a full "Statement of Results", which is all that most employers and higher education institutions require. If any student is experiencing genuine difficulties they are welcome to contact the Department of Education, but none have been raised with us to date.

QUESTION 1174

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 04/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 12-2009)

Mr D C Smiles (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

Whether her department uses temporary employment services and/or labour brokers; if so, (a) why, (b) how many positions have been filled by temporary employment services in the (i) 2006-07, (ii) 2007-08 and (iii) 2008-09 financial years, (c) what percentage of the total staff complement did temporary employment services contribute in each of these years and (d) how much money has been spent on temporary employment services in each year? NW1509E

REPLY:

The Department of Basic Education does not make use of temporary employment services and/or labour brokers.

a. Not Applicable

b. Not Applicable

c. Not Applicable

d. Not Applicable

QUESTION 451

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 10/07/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 06-2009)

Dr CP Mulder (FF Plus) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) In respect of the latest specified date for which information is available; in how many (a) single medium schools was the medium of instruction (i) only one of the country's 11 indigenous languages and (ii) only English and (b) dual medium schools was the medium of instruction one of the 11 indigenous languages and English;

(2) How many (a) single medium schools were there in April 1994 which used (i) one of the 11 indigenous languages and ( ii)only English as medium of instruction and (b) dual medium schools were there in April 1994 which used an indigenous language and English as medium of instruction?

NW512E

REPLY:

1(ai and aii)

Table 1 below shows the number of single medium schools that used 11 South African official languages in 2008. Please note that a single medium school is defined as one that offers only one medium of instruction in every grade of the school.

Table 1: Number of single medium schools by language and by province in 2008

Province	Afrikaans	English	IsiNdebele	IsiXhosa	IsiZulu	SePedi	SeSotho	SeTswana	Sign Language	SiSwati	TshiVenda	XiTsonga
EC	212	1 772	0	269	4	0	1	0	0	0	0	0
FS	91	294	0	0	5	0	35	1	0	0	0	0
GT	254	1 198	0	1	16	3	9	6	0	0	4	0
KZ	31	2 243	1	4	128	0	0	0	0	0	0	0
LP	45	1 432	1	0	0	70	0	0	0	0	16	16
MP	95	599	10	0	34	11	0	2	0	33	0	25
NC	248	86	0	2	0	0	0	26	0	0	0	0
NW	95	520	0	0	0	0	0	62	0	0	0	0
WC	687	366	0	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0
SA	1 758	8 510	12	278	187	84	45	97	0	33	20	41

Source: DoE EMIS Annual School Survey 2008

1(b)

The term "dual medium of instruction" refers to the employment of two languages as media of instruction, wherein a teacher switches from one medium of instruction to another during a lesson on a 50:50 percent basis. In this instance, the teacher repeats the instruction in another language.

For a school to be classified as dual medium school, all learners of that school should be receiving the tuition through dual medium of instruction. Such information is not collected from schools as it is very difficult to collect.

The Department does however collect information on parallel medium schools. It defines a parallel medium school as one that offers more than medium of instruction in all grades of the school.

Table 2 below shows the number of parallel medium schools where English is one of the media of instruction in 2008.

Table 2: Number of parallel medium schools by languages and by province in 2008

Province	English\\Afrikaans	English\\IsiNdebele	English\\IsiXhosa	English\\IsiZulu	English\\SePedi	English\\SeSotho	English\\SeTswana	English\\SiSwati	English\\TshiVenda	English\\XiTsonga
EC	146	0	3 086	9	0	24	1	0	0	1
FS	84	0	7	56	2	732	69	0	0	14
GT	185	2	22	114	53	89	107	1	6	0
KZ	52	0	145	3 053	0	0	0	0	0	0
LP	41	3	0	3	1 456	0	45	2	469	283
MP	65	48	2	320	59	7	30	262	0	77
NC	70	0	7	0	0	0	139	0	1	0
NW	50	3	4	1	0	16	834	0	3	0
WC	372	0	123	0	0	2	0	0	0	0
SA	1 065	56	3 396	3 556	1 570	870	1 225	265	479	375

Source: DoE EMIS Annual School Survey 2008

2(ai and aii)

Please note that the information for 1994 is not readily available, however the earliest date for which data can be provided is 1998. The 1998 data should be treated with caution and should not be used for comparison with the 2008 data as it is not of very good quality.

Table 3 shows the number of single medium schools that used 11 South African official languages in 1998

Table 3: Number of single medium schools by language and by province in 1998

Province	Afrikaans	English	IsiNdebele	IsiXhosa	IsiZulu	SePedi	SeSotho	SeTswana	Sign Language	SiSwati	TshiVenda	XiTsonga
EC	274	1 824	0	296	1	1	6	4	0	0	0	0
FS	115	465	2	0	2	0	44	4	0	0	0	0
GT	251	1 118	2	2	25	11	14	7	0	0	1	1
KZ	35	2 693	10	14	466	4	1	2	0	0	1	0
LP	61	2 034	3	0	2	210	6	8	0	0	73	41
MP	72	658	6	0	46	3	5	29	0	0	1	0
NC	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-
NW	87	667	0	1	0	0	3	72	0	0	0	0
WC	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-
SA	895	9 459	23	313	542	229	79	126	0	0	76	42

Source: DoE EMIS Annual School Survey 1998 (Please note that a "-" indicates that no information was received from the province

2(b)

Table 4 below shows the number of parallel medium schools where English is one of the media of instruction in 1998.

Table 4: Number of parallel medium schools by languages and by province in 1998

Province	English\\Afrikaans	English\\IsiNdebele	English\\IsiXhosa	English\\IsiZulu	English\\SePedi	English\\SeSotho	English\\SeTswana	English\\SiSwati	English\\TshiVenda	English\\XiTsonga
EC	143	0	3 214	1	0	30	1	0	0	0
FS	92	1	10	127	2	1 252	89	0	1	0
GT	175	0	19	131	61	96	48	0	10	13
KZ	70	1	34	1 914	0	7	1	0	0	0
LP	45	2	4	6	803	36	19	0	281	255
MP	55	45	1	423	65	22	165	0	0	0
NC	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0
NW	38	1	5	0	1	20	1 149	0	0	1
WC	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-
SA	618	50	3 287	2 602	932	1 463	1 472	0	292	269

Source: DoE EMIS Annual School Survey 1998 (Please note that a "-" means that no information was received from the province.

QUESTION 2200

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 13/11/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 28-2009)

Mr PF Smith (IFP) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

How many (a) non-model C schools have sports fields and (b) of these were built since 1994? NW2761E

REPLY:

(a) NEIMS (National Education Infrastructure Management System) does not make provision for model C or non-model C schools. Attached the number of public ordinary schools with and without sport fields.

(b) NEIMS also does not make provision for the progress of infrastructure delivery from 1994 but only indicate the number of public schools in the country as was assessed in 2006.

QUESTION 2244

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 13/11/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 28-2009)

Mr DC Smiles to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

Whether any plans are in place to ensure that the workbooks for the grade 1 to 7 learners are (a) delivered at the (i) right time and (ii) right place and (b) of the right (i) quality and (ii) quantity with specific reference to (aa) procurement process, (bb) distribution plans and (cc) the relevant timeframes to successfully complete the project; if not, why not; if so, what plans in each case? NW2953E

REPLY:

The Department of Basic Education has cancelled the order of Workbooks. The Department will provide further update on the matter as required.

QUESTION 86

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 08/06/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 01-2009)

Dr PWA Mulder (FF Plus) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

1. With reference to her reply to question 1990 of 23 November 2007, how many (a) Afrikaans single- medium schools and (b) Afrikaans parallel- medium schools and (c) Afrikaans dual-medium schools were there at the beginning of (i) 1994 and (ii) 2009;

2. (a) How many Afrikaans dual -medium schools have changed to English-medium schools since 1994, (b) in which provinces these schools are and (c) why the Afrikaans dual-medium schools changed to English-medium schools? NW89E

REPLY:

Question 1 (a and b).

The reply to question 1990 of 23 November 2007 is unfortunately not available to the Ministry and could not be obtained in the short period of time.

The information used to answer the above questions is extracted from the Annual School Survey raw data, hence it is provisional.

The following definitions were applied in answering the above questions:

Single-Medium School - It is a school that uses one language of learning and teaching for all learners in a school, in all grades.

Parallel-Medium School- It is a school that offers two or more media of instruction in different classes in the same grade, for all grades of the school.

Schools that have single-medium according to phases or grades are not included.

Schools that are Afrikaans parallel-medium for one phase or for particular grades are not included.

Please note that we do not have information for 1994. The earliest date for which we have reliable information is 2002. The latest date we have the information for is 2008.

The response to questions 1(a) and (b) is contained in table 1 and table 2.

Table 1: Afrikaans Single Medium Schools in 2002 and in 2008

Province	Number of Afrikaans Single Medium Schools in 2002	Number of Afrikaans Single Medium Schools in 2008
EC	221	213
FS	113	92
GT	266	255
KZ	45	32
LP	39	46
MP	27	96
NC	289	248
NW	78	98
WC	736	687
Grand Total	1814	1767

Source: 2002 and 2008 Annual Survey for Ordinary schools

Table 1 above shows the number of single medium schools that used Afrikaans in 2002 and in 2008.

Table 2: Afrikaans Parallel (Afrikaans/English) Medium Schools in 2002 and in 2008

Province	Parallel Medium schools in 2002	Parallel Medium schools in 2008
EC	133	146
FS	92	87
GT	194	185
KZ	50	56
LP	50	41
MP	29	65
NC	58	70
NW	52	50
WC	379	373
Total	1037	1073

Source: 2002 and 2008 Annual Survey for Ordinary schools

Table 2 above shows the number of parallel-medium schools that used Afrikaans and English as media of instruction in 2002 and in 2008. These are schools that used English and Afrikaans as the LOLTs for all Grades of the schools.

Question 1(c)

Afrikaans dual-medium schools that changed to English medium schools since 2002.

The term "dual medium of instruction" refers to the employment of two languages as media of instruction, by means of alternation, in a situation in which the same learner receives tuition in both languages. A teacher switches from one medium of instruction to other repeating the same instructions on a 50:50 percent basis.

For a school to be classified as a dual-medium school, all learners of that school should be receiving the tuition through dual-medium of instruction. Such information is not collected from schools as it is very difficult to collect.

Question 2(a) and 2(b)

Table 3: Afrikaans Single Medium Schools that changed to Dual (Afrikaans/English) Medium Schools or to English Single Medium Schools since 2002.

We do not have any information on dual medium schools as indicated in response to Question 1(c). The information relating to parallel medium of instruction schools is provided in table 3.

Province	2002	2008	Differences
EC	221	213	8
FS	113	92	21
GT	266	255	11
KZ	45	32	13
LP	39	46	-7
MP	27	96	-69
NC	289	248	41
NW	78	98	-20
WC	736	687	49
Total	1814	1767	47

Negative sign might mean that more Afrikaans schools were build since 2002 or some schools changed from parallel to single (Afrikaans) or the quality of 2002 data in some provinces was poor in 2002.

Question 2(c)

Reasons for change

The communities in the area of some of the schools have changed. English is more popular as a medium of instruction. In response to the growing number of learners wanting English as LOLT, the schools have introduced English as the second medium of instruction.

The declining number of Afrikaans speaking learners forces the schools to revert to parallel-medium (Afrikaans/English) schools.

Some parents preferred that their children be taught in English because:

- This could increase employment opportunities.

- To prepare their children for Higher Education.

- To prepare their children to be able to face challenges of modern life such as being able to complete banking forms, or any type of forms.

QUESTION 100

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 12/06/2009

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 02-2009)

Ms JC Klopper-Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) Whether there are any educators registered who are not South African citizens; if so, (a) how many and (b) which countries did they come from;

(2) Whether her department has any plans to increase the number of foreign teachers in our schools; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

NW106E

REPLY:

(1)

Yes there are educators employed who are not South Africans. According to PERSAL, there are about 2354 foreign educators employed by the Department of Education. The majority of foreign educators are from Zimbabwe, followed by India with a few spread amongst other countries, such as:

Democratic Republic of Congo, Ghana, Zambia, Nigeria, Ethiopia, Malawi, Botswana, Lesotho, Kenya, Uganda, Cameroon and Sudan.

TOTAL NUMBER PER COUNTRY OF FOREIGN EDUCATORS EMPLOYED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION

NAME OF COUNTRY	TOTAL PER COUNTRY
NAMIBIA	40
LESOTHO	62
BOTSWANA	33
SWAZILAND	38
ALGERIA	2
EGYPT	6
GHANA	310
KENYA	21
MADEIRA	2
MALAWI	9
MAURITIUS	3
MOSAMBIQUE	7
UGANDA	83
ZIMBABWE	793
REPUBLIC OF CONGO	4
TANZANIA	3
ZAMBIA	34
ALBANIA	1
BELGIUM	6
BULGARIA	1
DENMARK	1
WEST GERMANY	5
FRANCE	2
REPUBLIC OF IRELAND	3
ITALY	1
NETHERLANDS	12
AUSTRIA	1
PORTUGAL	1
RUMANIA	3
SPAIN	1
SWEDEN	1
UNITED KINGDOM	13
ENGLAND	18
WALES	1
SCOTLAND	10
USSR	1
CYPRUS	1
INDIA	711
INDONESIA	1
PAKISTAN	6
SRI-LANKA	3
CHINA	1
BRAZIL	1
CANADA	1
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA	5
AUSTRALIA	3
NEW ZEALAND	1
CUBA	2
CAMEROON	22
ETHIOPIA	4
NIGERIA	43
CENTRAL AFRICAN REPUBLIC	2
RWANDA	3
SENEGAL	1
SIERRA LEONE	1
BANGLADESH	4
IRAN	1
SOMALIA	2
GUIANA	1
PALESTINIAN	2

GRAND TOTAL	2354

(2)

Yes, the Department of Education has plans to increase the number of foreign teachers in our schools where it necessitates filling pots that cannot be filled with suitable qualified South Africans. The main aim of the Department will not be confined to having educators in class for delivery of the subject matter, but it is to ensure that there is a transfer of skills from foreign educators to the local educators and learners and/or vice versa.

As a point of departure, the process of Foreign Educator Recruitment must be seen as an intervention by our Government to address the shortage of skilled Mathematics, Science and Technology educators in the country. The shortage of Mathematics, Science and Technology educators in our country poses a serious challenge given the fact that these subjects are seen as key to driving our economic development as a country.

To justify this, in April 2007 the Minister of Home Affairs announced the specific occupational categories and professional classes as well as applicable quotas within which foreigners may apply for quota work permits in terms of section 21(1) of the Immigration Act, 19 of 2004. A quota of 1000 educators was allocated to the Department of Education for professionals teaching Mathematics, Science and Technology. Currently the Department of Home Affairs allocated a quota of 4000 work permits to our Department.

Interaction was made with about 50 countries requesting them to assist in the recruitment of educators specializing in Mathematics, Science and Technology. Countries like Egypt, India and Kenya showed interest in our request and they are prepared to assist with educators.

The Department also established a data base for unemployed educators and published an advertisement in the local news papers regarding the data base for unemployed educators, both local and foreign, specializing in Mathematics, Science and Technology. This advert did well for the Department in the sense that most of the CVs received were from the foreign educators.

The Department has also appointed a Service Provider to assist with the management of the recruitment and selection process of foreign educators.

QUESTION 1222

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 11/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 16-2009)

Dr J C Kloppers-Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:†

Whether her department intends establishing a physical science syllabus more aligned with engineering for learners who are interested in a technical field of study; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW1561E

REPLY:

No, the Department is not aware of any factors that require a change in the Physical Science Curriculum. The Subject Statement for Physical Sciences in the National Curriculum Statement (NCS) specifies the standards of knowledge and skills in science to be achieved at each grade. The content is organized around six core knowledge areas which would prepare learners to follow further studies in both the pure and applied sciences, like engineering, medicine, etc. The curriculum provides learners with the opportunity obtain a good foundation in scientific knowledge, skills and processes that is necessary for further studies in both the pure and applied sciences career pathways.

There is no need to change the curriculum for Physical Science at this stage.

QUESTION 1220

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 11/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 16-2009)

Mr J Schmidt (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) Whether she will consider revising or changing the current Morkel model used to determine the number of educators allocated per school; if not, why not; if so, (a) how will it be revised and (b) when will a revised model be in place;

(2) whether she will consider giving relief to principals and School Management Team (SMT) members so that they will have free periods to allow them to complete the increasing amount of administrative work expected of them; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW1559E

REPLY:

(1) The current post distribution model, that the member refers to as the "Morkel model", is merely a tool to distribute posts to schools, given an available budget. The available budget is appropriated via the Provincial Legislature.

Yes, I am in the process of considering an alternative model –

(a) which will distribute posts according to actual class size per grade per subject; the size of the school; curriculum requirements with regard to learner contact time per week, per phase per subject; language needs per grade; ensure that each phase has a post irrespective of the number of learners and lastly that schools serving the poorest learners are allocated proportionally more posts.

(b) Currently the model is being piloted to determine its impact on the current system as well as its financial implications.

The Council of Education Ministers (CEM), will in their meeting of 1 and 2 October 2009 consider a report on the testing of the model and consider recommendations on the outcomes made to it by the Heads of Education Committee (HEDCOM).

(2) The draft revised model will provide for the Principal of a school to be relieved from teaching, however the option to teach or not will be left to the individual Principal concerned. As for the remaining members of management, they will still be required to teach the required number of hours. If the post allocation to a school is managed correctly on the timetable of a school, then sufficient time could be made available for administrative duties.

QUESTION 1203

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 14/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 16-2009)

Mr GG Boinamo (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) Whether her Deputy Minister or her department purchased a new vehicle on the Deputy Minister's appointment to office; if so, (a) why, (b) what make and model is the vehicle, (c) what did the vehicle cost and (d)(i) what accessories were included in excess of the vehicle's purchase price and (ii) what was the cost of such accessories; if not,

(2) Whether he inherited an existing vehicle; if so, (a) what was the make and model and (b) how old is the vehicle? NW1542E

REPLY:

(1) No

(a) Not applicable

(b) Not applicable

(d) (i) Not applicable

(ii) Not applicable

PRETORIA

CAPE TOWN

(2) The vehicle which was used by the Deputy Minister when he was the Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development was transferred to the Department of Basic Education in Pretoria when he was appointed as Deputy Minister.

In Cape Town he inherit an existing vehicle which was used by the previous Deputy Minister

(a) BMW 750i

(b) 2008

Audi Q7

2008

QUESTION 577

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 10/07/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 06-2009)

Dr J C kloppers-Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

Whether there are any schools that had a zero matric pass rate in each of the past five years up to 31 December 2008; if so, (a) how many, (b) what are their names, (c) where are they situated, (d) what was the total number of (i) educators employed and (ii) educator posts available, (e) how many of these educators (i) resigned, (ii) died, (iii) retired, (iv) were dismissed and (v) were hired and (f) how many of these vacant posts were for (i) science, (ii) maths, (iii) biology, (iv) accountancy, (v) English first language and (vi) English second language?

NW643E

REPLY:

There are no schools that have consistently obtained zero pass rate in each of the past years up to 31 December 2008.

QUESTION 578

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 10/07/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 06-2009)

Dr J C Kloppers-Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of basic Education:

(a) What was the total number of schools in (i) 1995, (ii) 2000, (iii) 2005 and (iv) during the period 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available and (b) how many schools in each of these years had (i) running water, (ii) toilets, (iii) electricity, (iv) telephones, (v) sports fields and (vi) libraries? NW644E

REPLY:

(a) The total number of public schools from EMIS data in (i) 1995 (not available) (ii) 2000 was 27 760(iii) 2005 was 25570 and (iv) as at 11 June 2009 was 24693.

(b) Data is not available for the exact years as requested, however the following data is available:

Number of ordinary public schools	1996	2000	2007	1 June 2009
Total number of schools according to the SRN & NEIMS	26734	27 760	25154	24693
SRN (School Register of Needs - 1996 & 2000 NEIMS (National Education Infrastructure Management System – (2007 & 2009)	(i) Water (Municipal, boreholes, mobile water -tanker)	17366	19331	22254	22427
	(ii)Toilets	25981	*26319	*23827	23929
	(iii)Electricity(Grid, generators and solar)	11174	14891	19384	21252
	(iv)Telephones (cell, fax, internet, landlines & two way radio)	13076	18403	*24524	*24517
	(v)Sport fields	No record	20715	20807
	(vi)Libraries	4766	5108	5205	5260

*The decrease in number of schools with toilets and telephones is related to the decrease in number of schools from 2000 to 2009

QUESTION 579

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 10/07/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 06 - 2009)

Dr. W G James (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

What has been the (a) expected and (b) actual number of graduates at each (i) university, (ii) technikon and (iii) further education and training (FET) colleges, in each of the past five years up to and including 2008?

NW645E

REPLY:

UNIVERSITIES AND TECHNIKONS

INSTITUTION NAME	Actual 2003	Actual 2004
UNIVERSITIES
University of Cape Town	5.1	5.2
University of Durban Westville	1.9	(2)
University of Fort Hare	0.9	1.2
Medical University of South Africa	0.8	0.7
University of Natal	7.6	(2)
University of the North	1.1	1.5
University of the Free State	4.5	5.1
University of Port Elizabeth	2.9	4.2
Potchefstroom University	6.0	(3)
University of Pretoria	9.2	10.7
Rand Afrikaans University	5.8	7.1
Rhodes University	2.4	1.7
University of South Africa	10.6	14.5
University of Stellenbosch	5.3	5.3
University of the Western Cape	2.2	2.3
University of Witwatersrand	4.1	4.7
University of Zululand	1.9	2.1
Vista University	2.4	(4)
University of Transkei	1.4	1.1
University of the North West	1.1	(3)
University of Venda	1.3	1.3
University of KwaZulu-Natal		8.3
North West University		9.6
Sub Total: Universities	78.5	86.6

INSTITUTION NAME	Actual 2003	Actual 2004
TECHNIKONS
Cape Technikon	3.1	3.4
Technikon Northern Gauteng	1.6	(5)
Mangosuthu Technikon	0.9	0.9
ML Sultan Technikon	(1)	(1)
Natal Technikon	(1)	(1)
Technikon Free State	1.4	1.9
Peninsula Technikon	2.1	2.2
Port Elizabeth Technikon	2.0	1.9
Technikon Pretoria	6.0	(5)
Technikon SA	2.7	(6)
Vaal Triangle Technikon	2.1	2.3
Technikon Witwatersrand	1.9	2.1
Border Technikon	0.8	0.8
Technikon North West	0.6	(5)
Eastern Cape Technikon	1.5	1.2
Durban Institute of Technology	3.1	3.8
Tshwane University of Technology		9.8
Sub Total: Technikons	29.8	30.3
TOTAL: UNIVERSITIES AND TECHNIKONS	108.3	116.9

NUMBER OF GRADUATES AND OUTPUT TARGETS ( '000 )
Institution	Actual 2005	Actual 2006	Actual 2007	2010 target: approved October 2007 (A)
Cape Peninsula University of Technology	5.7	6.8	6.9	7.0
University of Cape Town	6.1	5.3	5.4	6.2
Central University of Technology	2.1	2.3	2.3	2.4
Durban University of Technology	4.3	4.4	4.7	4.7
University of Fort Hare	1.8	1.9	1.6	2.1
University of Free State	5.2	5.4	4.7	6.2
University of Johannesburg	10.1	10.2	9.5	10.2
University of KwaZulu-Natal	8.3	8.6	7.6	9.8
University of Limpopo	3.0	3.3	4.1	3.6
Mangosuthu Technikon	1.2	1.9	1.8	1.6
Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University	5.4	4.9	6.0	5.9
North West University	7.7	9.8	11.3	10.1
University of Pretoria	11.6	11.4	10.9	11.9
Rhodes University	2.1	1.9	1.8	2.1
University of South Africa	14.1	13.8	14.3	20.3
University of Stellenbosch	5.5	5.6	5.7	6.2
Tshwane University of Technology	9.4	9.1	9.8	10.1
Vaal University of Technology	2.3	2.4	2.7	3.0
University of Venda	1.6	1.8	1.9	1.9
Walter Sisulu University	2.7	3.5	3.0	3.6
University of the Western Cape	3.0	2.8	3.1	4.0
University of the Witwatersrand	5.0	4.9	5.4	6.4
University of Zululand	2.1	2.2	2.0	2.6
TOTAL	120.3	124.2	126.5	141.9

(A) NOTES: The graduate targets for 2010 are based on agreed upon targets with the institutions and approved by the Minister in 2007.

Notes:

(1) See Durban Institute of Technology

(2) See University of KwaZulu-Natal

(3) See North West University

(4) Campuses Incorporated into University of Pretoria, RAU

University of the Free State, University of Port Elizabeth, Technikon Free State,

Potchefstroom University and UNISA

(5) See Tshwane University of Technology

(6) See University of South Africa

FET COLLEGE GRADUATES: 2004 – 2008

Year	Nr of Passes
2004	135337
2005	138122
2006	152484
2007	132256
2008	127335

NOTES: The above figures reflect those students who passed 7 subjects. Students who passed 5 and 6 subjects out of the 7 were excluded.

QUESTION 580

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 10/07/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 06-2009)

Dr J C Kloppers-Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of basic Education:

(1) With reference to the senior certificate results for each of the past five years up to 31 December 2008, which have been the (a) six high performing districts, (b) 60 average districts and 13 districts that needed recovery intervention;

(2) Whether her department has implemented any recovery interventions; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW646E

REPLY:

Question 1

Education in South Africa is administered through 82 districts spread in 9 different provinces. With reference to this question the districts will be classified as follows:

(i) High performing districts: those that have consistently obtained between 75-100% pass rate over the last five years.

(ii) Average districts; those that have consistently obtained between 50 – 74.9% over the last five years.

(iii) Districts that needed recovery intervention: those that have consistently performed below 60% in the last five years. These districts are considered to be districts at risk, therefore require special intervention.

(a) The table below presents the list of the high performing districts over the last five years:

Province name	Disctrict name	2008	2007	2006	2005	2004
FREE STATE	XHARIEP	75.76	75.8	78.6	83.3	77.12
GAUTENG	GAUTENG WEST DISTRICT	82.2	78.9	87.5	77.95	81.66
GAUTENG	SEDIBENG EAST DISTRICT	81.91	86.8	82.5	80.09	79.77
KWAZULU-NATAL	UMLAZI	75.15	75.3	77	61.52	83.39
NORTHERN CAPE	NAMAQUA	90.38	85.5	84.3	88.27	90.17
NORTHERN CAPE	SIYANDA	76.26	72.8	74.5	80.94	86.66
WESTERN CAPE	BREEDE RIVIER/OVERBERG	87.23	79.7	83	85.82	85.86
WESTERN CAPE	CENTRAL METROPOLE	77.26	84.4	85.3	69.95	83.82
WESTERN CAPE	NORTHERN METROPOLE	76.79	82.8	87.5	86.43	87.66
WESTERN CAPE	SOUTH CAPE/KAROO	77.26	83.1	84.7	84.74	88..93
WESTERN CAPE	WESTCOAST	89.43	82	85.9	89.38	89.99

(b) The following districts as presented in the table below have consistently obtained between

50 – 74.9% over the last five years.

Province name	Disctrict name	2008	2007	2006	2005	2004
EASTERN CAPE	CRADOCK	63	65.6	64.1	62.1	58.58
EASTERN CAPE	EAST LONDON	60.52	56.2	65.2	58.5	58.79
EASTERN CAPE	GRAAFF-REINET	70.1	64.7	68.7	66.7	71.89
EASTERN CAPE	GRAHAMSTOWN	66.63	51.8	64.7	54.3	63.6
EASTERN CAPE	UMTHATHA	51.68	57.3	61.7	55.5	51.85
EASTERN CAPE	QUEENSTOWN	58.16	61.6	62.6	63.1	57.56
FREE STATE	THABO MAFUTSANYANA	68.44	64.8	73.3	70.7	71
KWAZULU-NATAL	ILLEMBE	51.14	63.6	62.6	66.06	68.31
KWAZULU-NATAL	OTHUKELA	58.98	62.5	61.9	55.7	68.16
KWAZULU-NATAL	VRYHEID	56.02	62	61.1	73.86	73.15
LIMPOPO	GREATER SIKHUKHUNE	54.96	52.5	51.3	58.37	67.16
LIMPOPO	MOPANI	69.22	55.2	55.9	68.91	72.67
LIMPOPO	VHEMBE	65.38	60	55.9	65.14	69.93
LIMPOPO	WATERBERG	70.11	55.8	55.7	62.04	69.51
NORTH WEST	BOJANALA EAST REGION	58.45	62.5	64.8	62.86	62.86
NORTH WEST	BOPHIRIMA REGION	66.88	62.1	61.9	51.47	56.28
NORTH WEST	CENTRAL REGION	59.42	57.1	58.5	54.53	60.3

It must be noted that there are several districts that are regarded as average in terms of their performance in that they have demonstrated fluctuating performances between the years. Annexure A provides a list of all districts performances in the last five years.

(c) In terms of the districts that required the recovery plan, the Department of Education declared that all districts should develop their district improvement plans and implement the recovery programmes to improve schools thereby the overall district performance. However, special attention would be given to all districts that have consistently performed below 60% in the last five years. There are only nine (9) districts that have consistently obtained below 60% over the last five years.

Province name	District name	2008	2007	2006	2005	2004
EASTERN CAPE	BUTTERWORTH	36.78	46.1	58.5	49	45.88
EASTERN CAPE	IDUTYWA	32.94	55	55	44.1	38.11
EASTERN CAPE	FORT BEAUFORT	43.25	51.5	53.1	55.2	53.97
EASTERN CAPE	KING WILLIAMS TOWN	47.75	52.6	51.5	47.7	47.12
EASTERN CAPE	LIBODE	51.95	58.3	53.6	43.9	39.81
EASTERN CAPE	LUSIKISIKI	37.05	44.5	44.5	42.7	38.2
EASTERN CAPE	MT FRERE	39.51	44.7	48.9	49.5	46.94
EASTERN CAPE	ENGCOBO	33.14	52.8	55.8	54.8	45.74
EASTERN CAPE	STERKSPRUIT	50.77	54.7	48.4	45.2	37.75

Question 2

The Department of Education is continuously engaged with programmes to improve the quality of learner achievement at all grades. The National Strategy for Learner Attainment (NSLA) has become the flagship programme in all provincial education departments. This strategy was launched by the Minister of Education, Ms Naledi Pandor, MP, in 2004, as a transversal programme, to raise the level of achievements of all learners across the system. The NSLA consists of planned and sustained sets of related operations, projects and activities, with short and long term objectives of raising learner performance and ensuring improved quality learner achievement in all schools

In keeping with the relevant prescripts of the National Education Policy Act (1996) as well as the Education Laws Amendment Act 31(2007), all provinces have identified underperforming schools and developed Provincial Improvement Plans which are aligned to the main objectives of the National Strategy for Learner Attainment (NSLA). The Education Laws Amendment Act, section 58 (b), which was promulgated in October 2007, specifically addresses the role of the Heads of Departments in identifying underperforming schools and developing provincial strategies to address under performance in schools. Provinces have ensured that all schools, particularly schools that have performed under 60% have developed their school improvement plans and the implementation of these plans are being monitored and supported by the districts. All provinces have allocated dedicated financial and human resources to address the objectives of the NSLA.

To support the implementation of the new curriculum and to ensure high levels of achievement in Grade 12, the Department of Education is also conducting, inter alia, the following activities:

(a) All schools that are underperforming have been visited by departmental officials including the senior management of the province. In many cases officials of the department including the senior management have been allocated a school to adopt and mentor.

(b) Capacity development workshops on management and leadership are being conducted for the principals of underperforming schools. In cases of schools that are serial underperformers mentorship programmes have been instituted.

(c) Provinces have appointed additional subject advisors to strengthen onsite support to teachers in the area of curriculum implementation with specific focus on content knowledge.

(d) The Department of Education are monitoring if the exemplar question papers provided to schools for all subjects to assist teachers and learners in their preparation for the examination are being used in their daily teaching and learning.

(e) Provincial education departments have successfully reduced the backlog in physical infrastructure and in the provision of textbooks. In many schools, each learner has a textbook for each subject.

(f) The first edition of Study Mate, which is free, was distributed to schools via the provincial and district offices at the beginning of the second term. This edition is a survival kit for Grade 12 learners and consists of tips by expert subject specialists on how to approach the examination. It also consists of the examination timetable and other hints and tips.

(g) The Department of Education and Independent Newspapers has produced the second edition of Study Mate which consist of examinations of November 2008 and the supplementary National Senior Certificate examination papers with memoranda. The tabloid books were made available in June 2009 directly from Independent Newspapers.

(h) DVDs with expert teacher and Department of Education curriculum specialists will assist learners with examination papers, explain common mistakes and give useful tips. These will be available as a package with Study Mate (Past papers).

(i) The Department of Education together with SABC launched Matrix Uploaded, a programme for Grade 11 and 12 learners in Mathematics, Mathematics Literacy, Physical Science, English (First Additional Language), Accounting, Life Orientation and Life Sciences on SABC 1, Monday to Friday, from 14h00 to 15h00 which started on 1 st June 2009.

(j) The Department of Education has collaborated with Liberty Life and Independent Newspapers to produce a new edition of Maths 911 for Grade 11 and 12 Learners. 125 000 of these books will be sponsored by Liberty Life and distributed free to 125 000 learners nationally. Parents can purchase these books directly from Independent Newspapers.

(k) Further support for the Maths 911 books will be available in the weekly Matric Matters which appears in the Independent Newspapers and on the Mindset Channel on DSTV.

(l) The Department of Education together with AVUSA media will publish a 48-page tabloid book comprising exemplar examination papers for Grade 12 learners. This will be available in October 2009 in the Sunday Times.

QUESTION 597

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 07/08/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 07-2009)

Mr AM Mpontshane (IFP) to ask the Minister of basic Education:

1) Whether her department contracted Jabulani Mabaso, owner of Indiza who supplied school text books and stationery to the KwaZulu-Natal Education Department; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details;

(2) who are the co-owners of the said company;

(3) whether her department has monitored the case where the said person was found to have defrauded the KwaZulu-Natal Education Department of R200 million; if not, why not; if so, what is the current state of affairs;

(4) whether she will make a statement on the matter? NW673E

REPLY:

1) No. The KwaZulu-Natal Education Department is responsible and accountable for their procurement processes and contracts and not the Department of Basic Education

2) I don't know

3) Not applicable

4) No

QUESTION 1786

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 16/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 22-2009)

Dr J C Kloppers-Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) (a) Why have some of the 2008 matriculants not yet received their certificates and (b) when is it expected that they will receive their certificates;

(2) whether she will make a statement on the matter? NW2286E

REPLY:

1. There has been a general delay in the release of all National Senior Certificates for the 2008 matriculants. This was caused by the re-designing of the certificate by the Quality Assurance Council, Umalusi, in light of the implementation of the new curriculum and qualification. The bulk of the certificates were issued to candidates by the end of September 2009. The only candidates that have not received their certificates, at this stage, are those that wrote the supplementary examination in March 2009. These candidates will receive their certificates by the beginning of November 2009. In cases where candidates have informed the Department of any difficulties with the Higher Education sector, the Department of Education has intervened on behalf of the candidates and no candidate should be disadvantaged because of this delay.

2. It is not necessary for the Minister to make a statement at this stage, given that the Quality Assurance Council, which is the certifying body did make a statement on this matter in July 09.

QUESTION 1785

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 16/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 22-2009)

Dr J C Kloppers-Lourens (DA ) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

Whether she intends taking any steps with regard to grade 12 learners who do not return to school after their final school examination, but only report to their respective schools to write their National Senior Certificate examination, if not, why not; if so, what steps? NW2285E

REPLY:

The Department of Education as part of its drive to ensure that maximum time is allocated to teaching and learning has since 2008, with the implementation of the new curriculum in the FET band, re-structured the commencement of the writing of the final NSC examinations, to commence early in November or late October. This decision was also taken in response to the previous practice of candidate's failure to return to school after the preparatory examinations. This new dispensation has been implemented in 2008 and in 2009 and PEDs have been requested to monitor the implementation of this new dispensation across all schools. There has been no reports of wide scale absenteeism of candidates from schools prior o the examination and my department will continue to monitor and support schools in this regard. If I am informed that absenteeism is on the increase then I will resort to punitive measures against candidates that refuse to maximize the teaching time made available to them.

QUESTION 1067

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 04/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 12-2009)

Dr J C Kloppers-Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

Whether transport has been provided for learners in each specified province in each of the three most recent financial years; if not, why not; if so, (a) what was the total budget allocated for transport, (b) which transport providers were awarded tenders to provide transport, (c) what was the value of each of the tenders, (d) how many learners were provided with transport in terms of each of these tenders and (e) what criteria do learners need to comply with in order to qualify for transport? NW1328E

REPLY:

(a) Yes, learner transport has been provided to the specified provinces and the budget allocated in the three financial years is as indicated in the table below:

Provincial Education Department
Scholar Transport
Province	CURRENT	2008 MTEF
	2007/2008	2008/2009	2009/2010	2010/2011
	R'000	R'000	R'000	R'000
Eastern Cape	257 732	250 000	231 000	622 033
Free State	37 500	40 800	44 800	-
Gauteng	46 165	34 080	91 307	37 754
KwaZulu-Natal	-	49000	87 000	139 940
Limpopo	44 000	44 500	44 500	48 401
Mpumalanga	145 269	157 670	164 718	185 380
Northern Cape	52 051	61 915	74 316	91 110
North West	-	68 445	75 000	80 000
Western Cape	100 241	105 253	112 439	140 629
TOTAL	682 958	811 663	925 080	1 345 247

Where no amounts reflected, the figures are not available.

(b) Procurement is a provincial competence and as a result the Department of Education does not have this information on hand.

(c ) See (b) above

(d) See (b) above

(e) Each province determines its own criteria as to who qualifies for transport. In terms of the National Norms and Standards for School Funding. Poor learners should be provided with hostel facilities if they live more than one and half hours walking distance from the nearest available school, and therefore each province determines its own criteria as to who qualifies for transport if the travelling distance to their nearest available school is less than one and half hours walking distance

QUESTION 1066

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 04/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 12-2009)

Dr JC Kloppers-Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

How many (a) primary and (b) secondary school teachers are qualified to teach (i) (aa) maths and (bb) mathematical literacy, (ii) English as (aa) first language and (bb) second language, (iii) religious studies, (iv) life science, (v) science and (vi) history in each province in each case and (c) learners in total were registered in 2009 at (i) primary and (ii) secondary schools.

REPLY

(a & b)(i - vi)

The recruitment process for educators is managed by Provincial Education Departments. The initial selection of educators, is in most cases, recommended by the School Governing Body to the Provincial Head of Department for approval. The utilization of educators in relation to the qualifications varies from year to year and even in the same year. The information being requested is thus not processed at the national Department of Education and may be sourced from the Provincial Education Department as the accountable employer.

Table 2: Number of learners in ordinary schools by province in 2009

Province	(i) Primary (Gr 1 - 7)	(ii) Secondary (Gr 8 – 12)
Eastern Cape	1 270 191	636 060
Free State	376 320	249 416
Gauteng	1 113 719	711 807
KwaZulu Natal	1 620 902	1 027 218
Limpopo Province	911 187	695 166
Mpumalanga	598 294	386 769
Northern Cape	164 887	90 193
North West	468 785	276 266
Western Cape	594 368	338 632
SA	7 118 653	4 411 527

QUESTION 1068

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 04/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 12-2009)

Dr J C Kloppers-Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) (a) What amount was budgeted for the national school nutrition scheme, (b) how many schools and learners benefited from the scheme and (c) what total amount was actually spent in each province in every year since the inception of the programme;

(2) whether any problems have been identified with regard to the nutrition programme in each province; if so, (a) what problems and (b) what action has been taken to address these problems? NW1329E

REPLY:

(1)

(a) The current budget for feeding both quintile 1 – 3 primary schools and quintile 1 secondary school is R2, 4 billion. This also includes preparation budget for quintile 2 secondary schools.

(b) In the current financial year at least 6,364,901 learners in 18,334 primary schools and 895,723 learners in 1,725 quintile 1 secondary schools benefit from the school nutrition programme.

Expenditure by province as at 2006/07 financial year:

Provinces	Allocation	Provincial roll-over	Total funds	Total transferred as at 31 March 2007	Actual expenditure to date	Balance	% spent of total funds
	R'000	R'000	R'000	R'000	R'000	R'000	R'000
Eastern Cape	233 882	32 225	266 107	233 882	166 642	99 465	62.62%
Free State	64 784	7 888	72 672	64 784	80 078	-7 406	110.19%
Gauteng	99 921	-	99 921	99 921	98 262	1 659	98.34%
Kwazulu Natal	239 372	76 000	315 372	239 372	254 404	60 968	80.67%
Limpopo	202 039		202 039	202 039	212 363	-10 324	105.11%
Mpumalanga	84 549		84 549	84 549	83 100	1 449	98.29%
Northern Cape	29 647	2 263	31 910	29 647	29 199	2 711	91.50%
North West	95 529	5 869	101 398	95 529	120 635	-19 237	118.97%
Western Cape	48 313		48 313	48 313	45 956	2 357	95.12%
Total	1 098 036	124 245	1 222 281	1 098 036	979 324	131 642	80.12%

EXPENDITURE	ANNUAL ALLOCATION	ROLL-OVER FROM 2006/07	TOTAL FUNDS	TOTAL TRANSFE-RED	ACTUAL EXPENDIT-RE	BALANCE	% SPENT OF ALLOCATION
	R'000	R'000	R'000	R'000	R'000	R'000	R'000
TOTALS	1 152 938	66 351	1 219 289	1 219 289	1,200,443	18,846	100%
Eastern Cape	237 885	63 726	301 611	301 611	291,488	10,123	96.6%
Free State	68 023		68 023	68 023	68,004	19	100.0%
Gauteng	114 574		114 574	114 574	116,656	-2,082	101.8%
Kwazulu Natal	260 006		260 006	260 006	242,430	17,576	93.2%
Limpopo	192 694		192 694	192 694	192,901	-207	100.1%
Mpumalanga	106 604		106 604	106 604	110,504	-3,900	103.7%
Northern Cape	34 507	2 625	37 132	37 132	37,132	-	100.0%
North West	87 916		87 916	87 916	88,254	-338	100.4%
Western Cape	50 729		50 729	50 729	53,074	-2,345	104.6%

EXPENDITURE BY PROVINCES AS AT 31 MARCH 2009

EXPENDITURE	ORIGINAL ALLOCATION	REVISED ALLOCATION	TOTAL TRANSFER-RED	AMOUNT SPENT TO DATE	BALANCE	% SPENT OF ALLOCATION
	R'000	R'000	R'000	R'000	R'000	%
TOTALS	1 583 103	1 927 109	1 927 109	1 643 062	284 047	85.26%
EASTERN CAPE	339 816	413 658	413 658	472 149	- 58 491	114.14%
FREE STATE	82 498	100 425	100 425	80 907	19 518	80.56%
GAUTENG	172 111	209 510	209 510	115 742	93 768	55.24%
KWAZULU-NATAL	376 435	458 233	458 233	341 943	116 290	74.62%
LIMPOPO	252 901	307 856	307 856	253 199	54 657	82.25%
MPUMALANGA	136 606	166 290	166 290	121 753	44 537	73.22%
NORTHERN CAPE	48 483	59 019	59 019	58 991	28	99.95%
NORTH-WEST	103 144	125 557	125 557	117 093	8 464	93.26%
WESTERN CAPE	71 109	86 561	86 561	81 285	5 276	93.90%

(2) In line with the Division of Revenue Act (DORA) provinces are required to submit business plans for analysis and approval of related activities. All business plans are supposed to meet the following minimum requirements as stipulated in the Grant Framework:

i) Provide meals to all Gazetted Quintile 1-3 primary school and quintile 1 secondary school learners for all school days;

ii) Comply with the recommended cost per meal per learner of the current year;

iii) Comply with recommended menus; and

iv) Feeding by 10:00 am

Summary of challenges per province:

Province	Challenges	Departmental Intervention
Eastern Cape	Province provided bread menu instead of a variety of meals	Province requested to submit a plan for phasing out bread menu with the final business plan; menu plan has been provided
Free State	Non compliance with grant framework (guidelines) in respect of meal costs at R1,35 and R1,90 for primary and secondary schools respectively	Withholding of funds due to non-submission of revised business plan
Gauteng	Only R4 million of the allocated R9, 015 million preparation budget (resources) for quintile 2 secondary schools was provided. The remaining was allocated for feeding.	Province was advised that allocation is a once-off budget and could not be used for feeding. Business plan was amended and funds transferred
Kwa Zulu Natal	The feeding cost per meal cost was allocated at R1, 50 for primary schools instead of R1.80 inclusive of the honorarium for volunteer food handlers.	Withholding of funds due to non-submission of revised business plan
Limpopo	Learner numbers were not in line with the gazetted numbers.	Requested amendment of business plan which was approved. Provincial department co-funded the programme with equitable share
Mpumalanga	Leaner numbers were not in line with the gazetted numbers.	Requested amendment of business plan which was approved.
Northern Cape	The province provides meals to quintile 1-5 primary and secondary schools learners from the conditional grant, which compromises the meal cost to R1,50 for both primary and secondary schools.	Requested amendment of business plan which was approved. Provincial department co-funded the programme with equitable share
North West	The meal cost was allocated at R1,61 instead of R1.80 inclusive of the honorarium for volunteer food handlers.	Requested amendment of business plan which was approved.
Western Cape	The meal cost was allocated at R1,74 for primary schools instead of R1.80 inclusive of the honorarium for volunteer food handlers.	Requested amendment of business plan which was approved.

After all the Department interventions, all business plans were finally approved as per Departmental Grant Framework. The Department further scheduled monitoring and support visits to all provinces to ensure compliance with NSNP guidelines.

Training and development workshops are also planned for the proper implementation of the programme in the current financial year.

EXPENDITURE

BY PROVINCES AS AT 31 MARCH 2008

QUESTION 11

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 08/06/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 01-2009)

Ms Kloppers- Lourens to ask the Minister of Basic Education :

1. Whether any teachers / facilitator has been charged and/or convicted of any crimes against any learner (a) in 2006, (b) in 2007, (c) in 2008 and (d) during the period 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if so, (i) how many in each case, (ii) what are their names and (iii) at which schools did they work;

2. whether any of the teachers/ facilitators are still employed or have been re-employed since being convicted; if so, (a) what are their names (b) which schools do they currently teach at and (c) what were they convicted of ? NW12E

REPLY:

Questions 1 and 2:

The following information has been received from the South African Council for Educators (SACE).

It was unfortunately not possible to obtain such detailed information from all the provinces, but we managed to get a response from Free State, Eastern Cape, North West, Western Cape province on such short notice. We are unable to provide names of these educators owing to the legal implications that might have, as decisions on some of these cases are challenged through judicial processes. I can however supply updated information for 4 Provinces. The relevant information pertaining to the remaining provinces will be provided when received from such provinces or you may obtain the information from them directly.

SACE : Offices in 4 Provinces

QUESTION 896

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 21/08/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 10-2009)

Mr GG Boinamo to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

Why are the results of learners who wrote their supplementary examinations in June 2009 delayed until January 2010;
Whether the results will be released, if not, why not; if so, when?

NW1052E

REPLY:

1. There is no delay in the release of the 2009 supplementary examination results. The 2009 National Senior Certificate (NSC) supplementary examination was written in February/March 2009 and all results were released on 30 April 09. In addition the Department of Education conducted the 2009 Senior Certificate examination that allows learners that failed to complete the Senior Certificate ("old matric") prior to 2008, to write their outstanding subjects in a special Senior Certificate examination in May/June 2009. The results of this examination were released on 31 July 2009. Results were available at examination centres where the candidates wrote the examination. Therefore, based on the information available to the Department of Education, there are no outstanding results.

2. Based on the explanation provided in (1), there are no results that are outstanding. However, if there are candidates that have not yet received their results, they are requested to make contact with the provincial education department, and these results will be made available to them, immediately.

QUESTION 1259

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 28/08/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 12-2009)

Dr J C Kloppers-Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:†

Whether her department is considering making mathematical literacy compulsary for al learners from grades 10 to 12; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW1601E

REPLY:

Yes.On 18 July 2005 the Minister of Education approved the new policy document, National Senior Certificate: A qualification at Level 4 on the National Qualifications Framework (NQF).

Learners opting for the National Senior Certificate must offer a minimum of seven subjects listed in the above policy document, of which two official languages, Mathematics or Mathematical Literacy; and Life Orientation are compulsory subjects.

The purpose of including Mathematical Literacy in the National Curriculum Statement (NCS) is three fold. Mathematical Literacy should enable the learner to become:

A self-managing person: There are mathematical demands that are encountered on a daily basis, demands which people should be able to handle with confidence. Such demands range from an ability to handle financial issues such as hire purchase, mortgage bonds and investments to an ability to read a map.

A contributing worker: The workplace requires the use of fundamental numerical and spatial skills in order to efficiently meet the demands of the job, for example, dealing with work-related formulae, reading statistical charts, dealing with schedules, etc.

A participating citizen: For the fact that statistics is so often (mis)used to support opposing arguments, Mathematical Literacy should help learners acquire a critical stance with regard to mathematical arguments presented in the media and other platforms.

There is no intention to make Mathematical Literacy compulsory for all learners. Learners all do some form of mathematics. Based on their post-school intentions they can choose between mathematics and mathematical literacy.

QUESTION 1258

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 28/08/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 12-2009)

Dr J C Kloppers-Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:†

Whether since the publication of White Paper 6 in 2001 any policy documents regarding the implementation of inclusive tuition have been published; if not, why not; if so, what are the (a) status and (b) relevant details of such documents?

NW1600E

REPLY:

The Department of Education is finalizing a field test on White Paper 6 Which started in 2004 and is ending in 2009. The field test is preparing the Department for a further rollout of Inclusive Education. In the process, the following guideline documents were developed and are at different stages of endorsement by the Department:

§ Guidelines for Full-service/Inclusive Schools

§ Guidelines to Ensure Quality Education and Support in Special Schools and Special School resource Centres

§ Guidelines on Inclusive Learning Programmes

§ Draft strategy for Screening, Identification, Assessment and Support

QUESTION 1257

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 11/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 16-2009)

Dr J C Kloppers-Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:†

Whether, in light of the Development Bank of South Africa's (DBSA's) statistics on schools ,she or her department has formulated a turnaround strategy to address inequalities in education without lowering the standard of education in any school; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW1599E

REPLY:

1. No fee schools - we have adopted a policy that ensures that poor learners are not expected to pay school fees. Currently there are over 14 000 no-fee schools in the country, benefiting over 5million (out of a total of about 12 million) learners.

2. Foundations for Learning Campaign (supply of workbooks, textbooks and teacher guides to schools - have begun improving and increasing this). The Presidency is supporting the Department to ensure that all learners and teachers receive the materials they need;

Quality Learning Campaign - focuses on a compact between teachers, parents and the government to improve teaching and learning (T&L)

4. Teacher Summit - for the first time Departments of Education spoke together with teachers via their Unions on what should be done to improve the quality of teaching and learning. The recommendations of the summit are being taken seriously by the Department. Mechanisms have been put in place to ensure that the Summit Declaration is not just a piece of paper.

5. Infrastructure - we have developed norms and standards that commit government to providing school buildings of a particular standard. The backlogs are great and will take many years to address - however we are committed to ensure that all schools are provided with the minimum infrastructure for them to work in an enabling environment. The Department is seeking creative ways to fund this backlog, especially that of libraries and laboratories. In the meanwhile, schools are encouraged to use science kits and to establish reading corners in classrooms.

6. In his research article (Building Education Beyond Crisis), Bloch indicates that the problems in education need to be worked on together with all stakeholders and role-players and proposes a "get-together" for this to occur. This recommendation is supported.

7. The Minister has commissioned a study to look into challenges facing the implementation of the curriculum.

QUESTION 1417

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 25/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 12-2009)

Dr J C Kloppers-Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

Whether her department has taken steps in order to ensure that every school is in possession of a well-formulated and approved policy on violence that incorporates, amongst others, a safety plan; if not, why not; if so, what steps? NW1773E

REPLY:

The development of School Safety Plans for schools has been one of the priorities for the Department of Basic Education.

The Department, in conjunction with provinces, has identified and prioritised 585 high-risk schools for intervention. The Department has provided provincial officials and some schools with training on the Hlayiseka Early Warning System. This system serves as a tool for identifying and responding to security issues and threats, how to report and manage incidents appropriately, and how to monitor school safety over time.

The Hlayiseka programme, which was developed in partnership with the Centre for Justice and Crime Prevention also helps schools to develop Safety Plans and developing Codes of Conduct. Provinces have rolled out training on the Hlayiseka Tool to the identified high priority schools. The training involved principals, SGB members, LRC representatives, and teachers in the 585 schools. The training encourages schools to use this tool to inform the drafting of context specific School Safety Plans.

Provinces have been requested to provide reports on the roll out of Hlayiseka.

QUESTION 1416

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 25/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 12-2009)

Dr J C Kloppers-Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) Whether it is compulsory for Grade 12 learners with Mathematics to write Question Paper 3 when they intend to enrol for engineering degrees; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

(2) how many learners with Mathematics were registered for the 2009 National Senior Certificate examination;

(3) what is the (a) percentage of registered learners and (b) statistical racial breakdown according to (i) black, (ii) white, (iii) coloured and (iv) Indian learners who opted to write Mathematics Question Paper 3? NW1772E

Reply

(1) It is not compulsory for Grade12 learners to write Paper 3 when they intend to enrol for engineering degrees. Learners who have passed Mathematics P1 and P2 are eligible for engineering degrees because the concepts covered in both papers sufficiently prepare learners for degree purposes. Learners who have written Paper 3 show potential for higher order Mathematics and may have an advantage for engineering studies.

(2) 297443 learners have enrolled for Mathematics in the 2009 National Senior Certificate examination.

(3) (a) 2.09% of the total registered candidates and 4.08% of those writing Mathematics. 12 136 of learners are registered to write Maths paper III.

(b) (i) 5 793 full time black learners are registered to write Maths paper III.

(b) (ii) 3 708 full time white learners are registered to write Maths paper III.

(b) (iii) 918 full time coloured learners are registered to write Maths paper III.

(b) (iv) 1 606 full time Indian learners are registered to write Maths paper III.

QUESTION 1418

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 25/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 12-2009)

Dr J C Kloppers-Lourens (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:†

Whether, with reference to the shortage of libraries, librarians at schools and the library manifesto, she has taken any steps to address this problem; if not, why not; if so, (a) what steps and (b) what is the current state of affairs? NW1774E

REPLY:

Access to library services is a priority for the Ministry. Since 2006 the Department of Education has worked to expand access to library services within a practical and implementable framework, and has not limited itself to building standalone library structures, given the historical neglect of such services particularly for schools serving the poorest communities. Although a large number of schools remain without libraries, this number has decreased by over 2 000 since the year 2000. This is with particular reference to stand-alone libraries, and not the range of activities the Department is engaging in to expand access.

The approach adopted by the Department of Education has been a developmental one, which has looked at expansion of library services at different levels, including:

A focus on providing classroom library collections to strengthen support for NCS implementation and reading at class and grade level;

Mobile libraries to serve a number of schools that have no access to libraries. Currently there are 21 of these mobile libraries operating in different communities across the country and serving just under 500 schools;

Strengthening school collections in community libraries and stand alone school libraries that serve clusters of schools; and

Providing library books to schools whose libraries have inappropriate or inadequate library collections.

Access to library services has therefore been expanded for a number of schools, using the approaches above. Key vehicles that the Department has used include:

The QIDS UP project, which has, since 2006, provided books and/or library furniture to 1060 schools;

Norms and standards for physical infrastructure approved by both the Council of Education Ministers and the Heads of Education Committee in 2008 make it obligatory for all new schools to only be considered complete if they make provision for library facilities. These are awaiting the concurrence of the Minister of Finance for finalisation. They do however provide for a school library as a standard.

The Department of Education has also recently finalised guidelines for school library services, with provincial participation, to provide practical guidance to provinces and schools on how to ensure access to such services for all schools. They provide guidance on matters such as

Staffing both in terms of dedicated library staff and utilising teacher librarians and/or library assistants;

The administration of a library;

Resourcing, including a proposed mix between fiction and non-fiction materials;

Managing access to services where the library is on school premises or outside school premises and therefore a shared resource e.g. access times; library rules; provision for different languages; access for learners with disabilities and other related matters.

QUESTION 1974

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 23/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 22-2009)

Ms A Mda (Cope) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) What (a) plans are in place to ensure that matric results will be announced timeously, (b) are targeted dates for issuing of final matric results in each province, (c) contingency plans for the exams prepared by her department; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW 2539E NW2286E

REPLY:

(1) (a)A comprehensive plan is in place to ensure that the National Senior Certificate (NSC) results are released timeoulsy. This plan has been developed in conjunction with the provincial education departments and has been communicated to all key participants in the examination process.The matric results will be announced on 7 January 2010 and the reason for the change in the date of the release of the results is to allow the national and provincial officials more time to ensure accurate capture of all marks, to verify the processing of the results and to allow for more intensive checking of the final results before they are released to candidates.

(b) The NSC results will be released at all schools in all provinces at 08:00 on 7 January 2010.

(c) As part of the normal planning for all public examinations there are contingency plans for every aspect of the examination process. These cover, inter alia, the setting of question papers, the printing, packing and distribution of question papers, the writing of the examination, the marking process and the resulting and release of results. The DoE is confident that the system is prepared to cater for any eventuality in the examination process, without compromising the credibility of the examinations.

QUESTION 2099

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 02/11/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 26-2009)

Mr PF Smith (IFP) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

Whether dedicated incetives are provided to suitably-qualified teachers to improve the teaching of maths and science in the public school system; if not, why not; if so, what incentives? NW2755E

REPLY:

The policy on Incentives for Educators was declared in December 2007 (Government Notice no. 25, Gazette no. 30678). The aim of the policy is attract and retain educators in areas of scarcity. The policy provides for four types of incentives, namely, posts in schools situated in remote geographical areas; posts in subject/learning areas/phases which are difficult to fill. The policy identifies mathematics, science, ICT and some languages but also allows for Provincial Education Departments (PEDs) to identify scarce subjects/learning areas in terms of their own needs; posts that are in schools situated in the difficult urban zones of the country or the so-called hard-to-teach schools and lastly; the policy also allows for incentives to attached to posts, based on the request from the Principal and the SGB of the school after providing evidence that identified posts are difficult to fill.

To ensure quality, the policy prescribes that for an educator who occupies an incentivized post to be eligible to receive payment he/she must be fully qualified (REQV 13). It is, however, up to each PED to identify its needs and prioritise the types of incentives it is going to pay accordingly. As the priorities could differ across PEDs, therefore it is possible that not all PEDs will prioritise the incentives for scarce subjects.

QUESTION 2107

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 06/11/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 27-2009)

Mr PF Smith (IFP) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

1. What her department (a) has done, (b) is doing and (c) will be doing to improve South Africa's ranking in the forseeable future with reference to the World Economic Forum's Global Information Technology Report of 2008-2009, ranking South Africa at 110 AND 132 respectively for the quality of its education system, mathematics and science education compared to Tunisia's ranking of 17 and 7 in global terms? NW2757E

REPLY:

1. The Department of Basic Education is committed to ensuring quality education for all children in schools. The National Curriculum Statement implemented in Grade R – 12 which has been internationally benchmarked to ensure that it is responsive and provides learners with the 21st century skills. With effect from 2010 the Department of Basic Education will strengthen the implementation of the NCS in schools by alleviating the administration burden on teachers and providing sufficient time on teaching and learning. In particular, the Department will continue to strengthen the support for the teaching of Literacy and Numeracy in the early Grades in schools through the expansion of the Foundations for Learning in all schools up to Grade 6. There will be an annual national assessment conducted for learners in Grades 1-6 and 9 in all schools to assess progress in numeracy and literacy which are foundational skills for learning. The Department will further consolidate the Dinaledi Schools Project to ensure that the teaching of and performance in mathematics and science are improved. The performance of the Dinaledi schools in 2008 NSC examinations has demonstrated the value of dedicated teacher training in subject contact knowledge, and the availability of textbooks and other LTSM in the promotion of mathematics and science. The Department will sustain this support in schools.

QUESTION 1107

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 04/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 12-2009)

Mr D C Smiles (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

In respect of each of the three most recent financial years for which information is available, what was the teacher learner ratio in each province? NW1368E

REPLY:

The leaner educator ratio for the three most recent financial years in each province:

Province	2007/08	2008/09	2009/10
EC	33.8	31.6	31.4
FS	29.3	28.1	28.8
GP	34.3	33.8	35.1
KZN	33.2	32.1	34.2
LP	31.5	30.8	30.1
MP	33.0	32.2	31.3
NW	28.2	30.1	31.5
NC	32.0	31.2	31.5
WC	38.0	36.7	37.7

QUESTION 1106

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 04/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 12-2009)

Mr D C Smiles (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education:

(1) In each of the three most recent years for which information is available in each province, (a) how many incidents of (i) vandalism and (ii) theft of school property were reported and (b) what total amount was spent on (i) repairing the damage caused by these acts and (ii) improving security to prevent further incidents in each case;

(2) whether any strategies have been adopted to reduce (a) vandalism and (b) theft of school property; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW1367E

REPLY:

1. In terms of the Public Finance Management Act, it is the responsibility of the Accounting officer of the Provincial Education Department to develop a risk assessment and mitigation strategy in regard to school property and other assets, and to manage these.

The department of Education therefore does not have the information requested, which should be obtained from the relevant Departments.

In terms of the Public Finance Management Act, it is the responsibility of the Accounting Officer of the Provincial Education Department to develop a risk assessment and mitigation strategy on the safety of school property.

2. A four - pronged strategy is used by the Department of Basic Education together with its provincial departments to address or limit vandalism and theft of school property. It does so by i) providing the required minimum security like fencing and security gates as stipulated in the Department's Minimum Norms and Standards for School Infrastructure, ii) deploying security personnel to schools, and iii) establishing sound working partnership with the South African Police Service (SAPS) which has seen the establishment of school safety teams and patrol of school vicinity which significantly reduces vandalism.

QUESTION 31

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 25/08/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 11-2009)

31.Ms N Gina (ANC) asked the Minister of Basic Education

Whether her department has rolled out the nutrition programme to high schools; if not, why not; if so, (a) to how many and (b) to which high schools? NO1104E.

REPLY:

Yes. The Department of Education has extended the school nutrition programme to quintile 1 secondary schools with effect from April 2009.

(a) The programme reaches 796 129 learners in 2 723 Quintile 1 secondary schools. Plans are afoot to further extend the programme to learners in Quintile 2 and 3 secondary schools in 2010 and 2011 respectively, subject to the availability of funds.

(b) All Quintile 1 high schools. The names of these schools are obtainable from the Department of Education' Education Management Information System (EMIS) and is accessible on the website (http//:www.education.gov.za).

QUESTION 32

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 08/06/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 01-2009)

Mr DC Smiles (DA) to ask the Minister of Basic Education :

1. Whether her department received reports from any of the provincial departments indicating shortages of staff and equipment at special schools in the 2008-09 financial year; if so, (a) from which provinces, (b) which special schools had such needs and (c) what was the extent of the shortages in each province;

2. Whether any corrective measures have been implemented to address the shortages; if so, what are the relevant details; if not;

3. Whether any corrective measures will be implemented in the future; if not, why not; if so, what measures? NW34E

REPLY:

The Department of Basic Education is in possession of a special schools audit report of 2002 as well as reports from provinces in response to the findings of the audit. A further situational analysis was conducted in the second half of 2008 to establish the type of assistive devices required by special schools per province, using a sample of 30 special schools, this as part of the Department's tender on material and assistive devices, tender EDO 374. A report has been developed and will be published. In addition, provinces such as the North West, KwaZulu-Natal and Limpopo have conducted their own situational analyses of special schools to identify needs.

a) The audit report of 2002 was conducted in all special schools across provinces.

b) The list of special schools that were identified to be in need of more resources is attached.

c) The table below (Table 49 from the audit report of 2002) shows types of equipments and the count of what was available at the time of the audit.

Table 49: Number of items of furniture and equipment available for school management and administration per province

Prov	Braille Printer	Chairs	Com- puter	Cup-boards	Desks/ Tables	Dupl. Machine	Fax	Intercom	Internet	Photo Copiers	Scanner	Tele Phone	Thermo form	Type Writer	Other
EC	2	2419	172	218	908	13	35	22	17	61	14	112	3	52	15
FS	1	1112	76	115	735	14	19	13	15	27	10	109	1	14	13
GP	5	4405	420	655	2971	45	93	103	78	141	46	623	3	63	96
KZN	1	1414	150	398	1205	15	55	31	28	63	12	178	4	47	55
LP	8	731	105	172	498	9	17	7	18	31	12	78	6	54	11
MP	1	432	53	76	196	7	13	5	5	19	2	49	0	15	0
NC	0	248	24	85	196	0	8	2	5	11	3	51	0	3	7
NW	2	899	60	107	422	8	16	8	12	36	12	50	0	27	14
WC	3	3358	274	591	1267	23	71	103	64	106	34	455	6	126	127
Total	23	15018	1334	2417	8398	134	327	294	242	495	145	1705	23	401	338

Approved Tender Number EDO 374 for the procurement of resources and assistive technology for a limited number of institutions by the Department of Basic Education provided a window of opportunity for Provincial Departments of Education to fast-track the procurement of equipment and assistive devices, using the 2008 MTEF allocations. KwaZulu-Natal, Limpopo and Western Cape have already submitted requests to the Department of Basic Education to participate in the national tender for procuring assistive devices and other equipments for their special schools. From the national tender, 7 special schools are in the process of receiving assistive devices.
The Department is currently engaged in monitoring the supply, installation and training of end-users of equipment and assistive devices procured for schools through tender EDO374. Two provinces, namely the Western Cape and KwaZulu-Natal, filled several posts in the financial year 2008/9, utilizing available budget from their 2008 MTEF allocations. Eastern Cape, Limpopo, Mpumalanga and North West are in a process of advertising posts to strengthen districts and schools. The Department is also coordinating and monitoring provincial business plans for implementing the 2008 MTEF funding for Expansion of Inclusive Education. As a way forward, the Department will develop a manual that will be used by provinces when they procure material and assistive devices.

29 December 2009 - Question:Minister of Higher Education

MPs to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training

Source
Link

Reply:

QUESTION 1672

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 16/10/2009

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 22-2009)

Dr W G James (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

Whether, since his appointment in May 2009 any renovations or alterations were done at state owned and private residences of him, or any other specified official of his department; if so, (a) where he and the occupants of each such residence were accommodated during the renovations and (b) at what cost to his department in each case? NW2128E

REPLY:

(a) N/A

(b) N/A

(i) Not applicable

(ii) Not applicable

QUESTION 546

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 10/07/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 06-2009)

Dr W G James (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

(1) Whether his department makes use of private security firms; if so, how much money was spent on such firms in 2008;

(2) Whether these firms are used on a contractual basis; if so, (a) how many contracts did his department take out in this regard in 2008, (b) with which firms were these contracts taken out, (c) for what specific purpose was each contract taken out and (d) what was the value of the contract in each case;

(3) Why is there a need for his department to use a private security firm as opposed to state security? NW610E

REPLY:

The Department of Higher Education is still in the process of being established and as yet has no contractual obligations at all. The Department of Education and its DG is responsible for the 2009/10 budget. Therefore the Department of Higher Education is not making use of any private security firm but uses in-house security.

Not applicable
Not applicable

QUESTION 375

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 03/07/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 05-2009)

Dr. WC James (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

(1) Whether he a purchased a new vehicle on his new appointment to office; if so , (a) why, (b) what make and model is the vehicle (c) what did the vehicle cost and (d) (i) what accessories were included in excess of the vehicle's purchase price and (ii)what was the cost of such accessories; if not,

(2) Whether he inherited an existing vehicle; if so, (a) what was the make and model (b) how old is the vehicle?

NW435E

REPLY:

Pretoria	Cape Town
(1) The Department purchased a vehicle for use by the Minister on 11th of June 2009.	No
(a) The vehicle used by the previous Minister of Education in Pretoria is used as official vehicle in Cape Town.	Not applicable
(b) BMW 750i	Not applicable
(c) (c) R1 110 750.00	Not applicable
(d)(i) Not applicable	Not applicable
(ii) Not applicable	Not applicable
(2) No	Yes
(a) Not applicable	2008 Mercedes Benz ML320 CDI
(b) Not applicable	16 Months

QUESTIONS FOR WRITTEN REPLY

FRIDAY, 16 OCTOBER 2009

1717. Dr W G James (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

(1) What amount was spent by his department on (a) hotel accommodation, (b) restaurant expenses and (c) travel costs (i) in the 2008-09 financial year and (ii) during the period 1 April 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available, for (aa) him, (bb) specified officials of his department and (cc) any other specified individuals;

(2) why did each individual use the specified accommodation in each case? NW2209E

REPLY:

(1) (i) (a) (b) (c) (aa) (bb) (cc) Not applicable for the 2008/09 financial year. The establishment of the Department of Higher Education and Training and the subsequent appointment of the Minister of Higher Education and Training occurred during May 2009.

(ii) During the period 1 April 2009 up to 30 September 2009

(a) Hotel accommodation for his department:

Officials: R 416 470.71

Conferences: R 616 867.43

(b) Restaurant (meal) expenses for his department:

Officials: R 43 810.84

Conferences: R 1 638.18

Officials R1 418 732.49

Conferences R 37 638.62

(ii) The breakdown of restaurant expenses for him and officials in the offices of the minister are not readily available and is included in the expenditure on accommodation.

(aa) minister:

(a) & (b) Hotel accommodation & Restaurant (meal) expenses from 1 May 2009 – 30 September 2009:

· R212 735.64

· R397 582.58

(bb) officials in the offices of the minister:

(a) & (b) Hotel accommodation & Restaurant (meal) expenses from 1 May 2009 – 30 September 2009:

· R172 332.77

· R773 645.77

(cc) Not applicable

(2) It was the most cost effective and appropriate accommodation available when the bookings were made.

QUESTION 170

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 13/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 21-2009)

Mrs L S Makhubela-Mashele (ANC) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

Whether he intends to increase the number of further education and training colleges to address the skills shortages that affect our global competitiveness; if not why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NO1442E

REPLY:

The Department does not envisage increasing the number of FET Colleges. The current FET College landscape of 50 colleges and 360 sites is adequate for the task. At present these sites are well placed to deliver skills and have spare capacity.

The key challenge is to increase the number of students at the colleges. This is being hampered by the current constraints in budget.

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

FOR WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION 1521

Dr W G James (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

(1) Whether, with reference to the statements made by the Minister of Health that the strengthening of colleges was the next focus of the Department of Health and that discussions with the Department of Higher Education and Training were at an advanced stage, copies of the report identifying the colleges which are to be strengthened will be made available to the public; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

(2) (a) what amount does his department envisage spending and (b)(i) when and (ii) on what specifically will it be used to rebuild these colleges;

(3) (a) what officials in his department will (i) lead and (ii) co-lead the project and (b) what is the projected completion date.

REPLY:

It is suggested that the Honourable member direct this question to the Minister of Health.

QUESTION 1591

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 09/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 20-2009)

Mr. G G Boinamo (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

(1) Whether his department developed and adopted a policy providing guidelines for the appointment of persons with a criminal record; if so, (a) when was the policy (i) developed and (ii) adopted and (b) where can a copy of the policy be obtained; if not,

(2) whether his department has any plans in place to develop and adopt such a policy; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

(3) whether his department does any pre-employment screening of potential employees for criminal records; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

(4) whether any employees with criminal records are currently employed by his department; if so, (a) how many and (b) what is their (i) job level and (ii) occupational category? NW1997E

REPLY:

(1) The Department of Higher Education and Training is not fully functional as yet and make use of resources of the Department of Education. Except for, Ministerial Staff and the Director-General no official appointments have been made in the Department of Higher Education and Training.

2. A policy providing guidelines for the appointment of persons with criminal records is currently under development and will be functional as soon as the Department starts to advertise and fill posts.

(3) Not applicable at the moment.

4. Not applicable at the moment.

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

WRITTEN TO ORAL REPLY

QUESTION 1293

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 11/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 16-2009)

Dr W G James (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

Whether his department has invested in a university that teaches in languages other than English and/or Afrikaans; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details? NW1640E

REPLY:

The Department of Education has published the Language in Education Policy (1997) and the Language Policy for Higher Education (2002) which, are designed to promote multilingualism in the education sector. Their aim is to ensure that all South African languages are "developed to their full capacity while at the same time ensuring that the existing languages of instruction (English and Afrikaans) do not serve as a barrier to access and success."

As part of our initiative to promote multilingualism in higher education, the Department of Education supports a number of pilot projects under the South African-Norway Tertiary Education Development programme. The focus of the pilot projects is promoting multilingual proficiency for academic staff and students registered in service disciplines such as social work, law, nursing, medicine and other health sciences. Support is also provided for academic tutorials conducted in indigenous languages.

ESTIONS FOR WRITTEN REPLY

FRIDAY, 23 OCTOBER 2009

[No 24 – 2009] First Session, Fourth Parliament

1922. Mr G G Boinamo (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

Whether his department has done a skills audit in order to identify scarce skills prior to formulating the curricular of Further Education and Training Colleges (FET); if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW2486E

RESPONSE:

The NC(V) curricula are the only curricula developed by the Department for FET colleges in the last 5 years. The initial 11 vocational programmes developed in 2005 under the NC (V) qualification were identified through the scarce skills and sector skills reports available from the Department of Labour at the time. The initial 11 programmes included:

v 3 Engineering programmes (Civil, Mechanical and Electrical)

v IT and Computer Science

v Hospitality and Tourism

v Primary Agriculture

v 3 Business- related programmes: Marketing, Office Administration, Management and Finance, Economics & Accounting

To date an additional 3 programmes (Mechatronics, Safety in Society and Education & Development) have been added in response to stakeholder demand, based on a formal application and approval process. Similarly, 3 additional programmes and 4 new subjects are currently under development. The latter are funded by stakeholders.

All programmes on offer respond to the objectives and , where indicated, targets contained in the HRDS. The point of caution is the interpretation of the term 'skills' which is often used in specific relation to occupational categories, which constitute a sub-set of the vocational offerings at FET colleges.

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

WRITTEN TO ORAL REPLY

QUESTION 523

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 10/07/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 06-2009)

Dr W G James (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

Whether any function was organised to mark the occasion of the delivery of his budget vote in 2009; if so, (a) what total amount was spent on this function, (b) from which budget was the money allocated, (c) what amount was spent on (i) food and refreshments, (ii) venue, (iii) entertainment, (iv) staff and (v) transport and (d) how many persons were invited to attend this function? NW587E

REPLY:

Yes, one function was held for the two departments namely the Department of Basic Education and the Department of Higher education and Training. The amounts spend and number of persons invited is as indicated below.

R267 044.57

The Communications budget

(i) R47 673.99

(ii) None

(iii) R20 500

(iv) None

(v) None

(d) 250

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

FOR ORAL REPLY

QUESTION 182

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 13/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 21-2009)

Mrs C Dudley (ACDP) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

Whether calendars issued by his department to Members of Parliament indicating only one extra day of holiday during the 2010 FIFA World Cup Soccer tournament is in accordance with Government's plans for school holidays around this event; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details? NO2081E

REPLY:

The school calendar is the responsibility of the Minister of Basic and the Question should be redirected to the Department of Basic Education.

QUESTION 191

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 13/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 21-2009)

Mr Z S Makhubele (ANC) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

(a) What steps has been taken to remove the burden of the cost of education from poor families especially in the light of the underspending by the National Student Financial Aid Scheme (NSFAS) and (b) to what degree is the further expansion of the services and the transformation of the NSFAS receiving priority? NO2097E

REPLY:

(a) .The NSFAS has requested institutions to provide information on under-spending in order to redistribute funds to needy students within the current academic year. The Department of Higher Education and Training has been monitoring this matter closely.

(b) I appointed a Ministerial Committee to review the NSFAS in July 2009. A report is expected at the end of this year. The overall purpose of the review is to assess the strengths and shortcomings of the current Scheme and to advise my office on the short, medium and long term needs for student financial aid in order to promote the twin goals of equity of access and providing free undergraduate education to students from working class and poor communities who cannot afford further or higher education. The review will evaluate different models of student financial aid and make recommendations on the policy and operational changes required to ensure the effective and efficient achievement of these goals, which will enable South Africa to produce graduates with the qualifications and skills required to build our developmental state.

QUESTION 195

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 13/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 21-2009)

Mrs M T Kubayi (ANC) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

What is his plan on dealing with the fee increment in institutions of higher education? NO2101E

REPLY:

The issues of student fees remain a concern to me and my Department. In this regards letters have been sent to all institutions requesting them to provide the Department with the following information amongst others:

 Institutional policies in respect of fees payable and regulations regarding the payment of fees.

 average increase in academic and residence fees for the 2010 academic year compared to the previous years

 The anticipated estimate in fee increases for the 2010 academic year, taking into account the MTEF allocation to higher education.

 The totals which institutions expect to raise from tuition, student housing and the proportions which these represents of the total income of the institutions for the 2010 financial year.

 The average increase in additional student levies i.e. ICT, transport library and catering separately for the 2010 academic year, compared to the previous years.

 The general guidelines and specific rules or requirements for the payment of academic, residence and other fees.

 Institutional processes followed in the determination of fees for the 2010 academic year.

 The provisions being made from institutional and other sources to assist financially disadvantaged and academically deserving students.

This information will then assist us to be able to analyze the trends so that we can make informed decisions in our discussions with different stakeholders. I am also going to meet with Higher Education South Africa (HESA) including all national student organisations to discuss strategies to deal with the tensions that may arise as a result of disagreements on fee increments taking into account that the Department does not determine fees.

QUESTION 435

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 10/07/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 06-2009)

Mr L W Greyling (ID) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

(1) Whether he will review the National Student Financial Aid Scheme of South Africa (NSFAS) in order for students to be awarded bursaries rather than loans; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

(2) Whether he will review other aspects of NSFAS; if so, which aspects? NW495E

REPLY:

1. I established a Ministerial Committee for the Review of the National Student Financial Aid Scheme on 10 June 2009 to review the efficacy of the Scheme. The overall purpose of the review is to assess the strengths and shortcomings of the current Scheme and to advise on the short, medium and long term needs for student financial aid in order to promote the twin goals of equity of access and providing free undergraduate education to students from poor communities who cannot afford further and higher education. The Committee will also conduct a needs analysis of students who currently do not qualify for NSFAS support but cannot obtain loans from commercial banks and make recommendations in this regard. The Terms of Reference are contained in Government Gazette, No 32317.

2. The Terms of Reference include but are not limited to assessing amongst others:

 Assess the strengths and shortcomings of the current National Student Financial Aid Scheme (NSFAS).

Conduct a needs analysis of students who will require financial aid in the short, medium and long terms, taking into account the Government's commitment to providing free undergraduate education to students from poor families who would otherwise not be able to pursue further or higher education.

Undertake a review of the Means Test and provide guidelines to determine the criteria for eligible students.
Make recommendations on appropriate mechanisms for raising and administering the required funds, including the parameters of the recapitalization of NSFAS and for the possible establishment of a student loan bank.
Investigate the feasibility of student financial aid being linked to priority fields of study and levels of academic performance.
Assess the viability of extending financial aid to students in not-for-profit private higher education institutions. Assess the nature and extent of former and current students blacklisted by NSFAS and universities, and recommend appropriate action to be taken to deal with the problem.
Recommend changes to the policy, regulations and operational framework of the NSFAS, including the distribution formula for the allocation of financial aid to institutions, the Means Test, the respective roles and the responsibilities of the institutional financial aid bureaus and the NSFAS.
Recommend changes to the governance, management, operational capacity and systems of the NSFAS to meet the needs of the new policy framework.

QUESTION 445

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 10/07/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 06-2009)

Ms N Y Vukuza-Linda (Cope) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

Whether the principle of commonalities that should have existed for mergers to occur between different institutions of higher learning has been upheld; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW506E

REPLY:

The Department released the "Guidelines for Mergers and Incorporations" document in April 2004 to assist merging institutions to map out the essentials and processes all merging institutions will have deal with on the way to creating new institutions. The Department made it very clear from the moment the Ministry released its proposals that the proposed mergers were "mergers of equals" and that throughout the various phases of the mergers all the affected institutions were to be treated equally.

Consequently, all the pre-merger processes and decisions were equally shared amongst the participating institutions and the 'interim' governance and management structures were set up in accordance with the "Standard Institutional Statute" and comprised equal numbers of personnel from the affected institutions irrespective of the size of the participating institution. In short, the principle of commonalities was upheld throughout the highly complex processes of merging diverse institutions of higher education in this country.

It is acknowledged that in practice the dynamics across merging institutions have been complex and that each merger has its own dynamics. The Merger Unit has assisted in contexts where the principles of commonalities needed to be asserted.

QUESTION 2260

13 November 2009

Publication No 28- 2009

Dr W G James (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

(a) Who were the members of the Transition Oversight Committee and the six technical task teams appointed to oversee the migration of the Further Education and Training Colleges to his department, (b) what budget was allocated for their work and (c) what are the (i) timelines and (ii) deadlines for the reports to be submitted? NW2969E

REPLY:

(a) The membersof the Transition Oversight Committee are:

Ø Mr J Pampalis

Ø Prof M Metcalfe

Ø Dr M Qhobela

Ø Mr F Patel

Ø Dr B Mahlobo

Ø Adv E Boshoff

Ø Mr S Mommen

Ø Mr T Tredoux

Ø Mr A Schoeman

Ø Ms T Futshane

Ø Ms A Singh

COMPOSITION OF THE SIX TECHNICAL TASK TEAMS ON THE TRANSFER OF COLLEGES

Name of Task Team	Composition
1. Legislation Matters	· Adv E Boshoff (Convenor) · Mr S Richter · Mr C Leukes · Dr BS Mahlobo

2. Institutional support: Governance, Management, IT Support, Information and Data Collection	· Mr S Mommen (Convenor) · Mr ATP Mpanza · Dr BS Mahlobo · Mr A Raubemheimer · Dr J van Rensburg · Ms S Swaratlhe · Mr J Mogale · Dr M Buthelezi · Dr N Nkoe
3. Finance and Funding	· Mr T Tredoux (Convenor) · Dr S Padayachee · Ms Masipa · Dr J van Rensburg · Ms S Swaratlhle · Mr S Mommen · Dr BS Mahlobo

4. Staffing and Human Resources	· Mr A Schoeman (Convenor) · Ms S Gear · Mr J Slater · Dr BS Mahlobo

5. Student Enrolment and Support	· Ms T Futshane (Convenor) · Ms Z Gungwa · Ms K Madumo · Mr S Ntuli

6. Qualifications, Programmes and Assessment	· Ms A Singh (Convenor) · Ms P Vinjevold · Ms R Burger · Ms N Pote · Ms M Koen · Ms M Swart

(b) No budget was allocated for their work.

ii) The Technical Task Teams submit their reports on monthly basis to the Transfer Oversight Committee.

QUESTION 854

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 21/08/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 10-2009)

Dr WG James to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

What budget was set aside for the work of the Ministerial Committee for the Review of the National Student Financial Aid Scheme;

Whether the committee is on schedule to report by the deadline of 10 December 2009; if not, why not; if so what are the relevant details? NW1004E

REPLY:

No specific budget was allocated for the work of the committee. The work of the committee is being supported through operational funds of the Higher Education branch of the Department of Education.

Yes, the committee is scheduled to provide my office with an initial report by December 2009.

QUESTION 977

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 28/08/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 12-2009)

Dr W G James (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

Whether he has taken any steps with regard to suspending import duties or on finding other means of reducing the cost of imported prescribed text books for university students, especially in the disciplines of science and medicine; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW1178E

REPLY:

I would like to recommend that the Minister of Trade and Industry be approached for a reply as tariffs and related duties are determined by the Ministry of Trade and Industry in consultation with the International Trade and Administration Commission. I will however explore this possibility in the near future and ask my officials to consult with the Department of Trade and Industry.

QUESTION 696

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 07/08/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 07-2009)

Mr. L L Bosman (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

Whether, in light of the current recession and the consequent shortfall in state revenue, his department has introduced any austerity measures to reduce its expenditure with regard to (a) official vehicles, (b) travel, (c) travel by departmental officials, (d) accommodation and household help or (e) any other aspects of government business; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details?

NW790E

REPLY:

This matter is being dealt with by Cabinet and guidelines are awaited. The Cabinet dealt with the aforementioned matter and the Department is currently waiting for the guidelines. Cabinet will soon announce measures in this regard, which all departments will be expected to implement. Please refer to the statement of the Cabinet meeting of 12 August 2009.

In light of the above, (a); (b); (c); (d); and (e) are not applicable.

QUESTION 1357

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 10/07/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 06-2009)

Dr W G James (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

Whether the results of the study of residences commissioned by his department are completed; if not, why not; if so, (a) when will it be released and (b) what are the further relevant details? NW1713E

REPLY:

The Department of Higher Education and Training will, during 2010, be undertaking a study of student housing in the public higher education system. The study will focus on the system's need for additional student housing, and on the ways in which expansion could be financed. The Department will draw on lessons learned from the 2010/11 to 2011/12 residence expansion process funded by government, institutions and the private sector. The implementation of these expansion plans will lead to the number of student housing places rising by 7 000 by the 2011 academic year, from the current total of 100 000. This expansion programme includes provision for the major renovation of 2 000 existing residence places, primarily in smaller rural universities.

QUESTION 124

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 12/06/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 02 - 2009):

Mr. G. G. Boinamo (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

Whether he has met with any stakeholders to discuss the problems pertaining to (a) students not permitted to write examinations if they have not paid their study fees, (b) the banning of student organisations and (c) the issuing of study material at Unisa; if not, why not; if so, (i) when and (ii) what were the outcomes of these meetings?

NW134E

REPLY:

Yes I have met with stakeholders. Assuming that the question relates to Unisa, I have met the Vice-chancellor.

(a) We agreed with the Vice-chancellor that this requirement will be waived and we are given to understand that this has been done.

(b) We are not aware of any student organisations being banned.

(i) Not applicable

(ii) Not applicable

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

WRITTEN TO ORAL REPLY

QUESTION 916

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 21/08/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 10-2009)

Dr WG James (DA) to ask the Minister of Minister of Higher Education and Training:

1. Whether his Director-General signed a performance contract with him; if not, why not; if so, when;

2. Whether all senior managers in his department signed performance contracts with the Director-General; if not, (a) which senior managers did not sign, (b) for what reason and (c) when will it be done; if so, on which date each senior manager sign a performance contract? NW1072E

REPLY:

1 No, the Director-General assumed duty on 1 September 2009, however, she is in the process of signing the performance agreement and it will still be finalised and submitted within three months from her date of assumption of duty.

2. No, not all senior managers signed performance agreements with the Director-General

(a) The following senior managers did not sign the performance contracts:

 Mabizela M

 Motaung N

(b) Performance Agreement of Mabizela M is in the process of being signed and will be forwarded to the DPSA soon, and that of Motaung N is delayed owing to changes in her job description.

(c) As soon as the Director-General has taken a final decision on the matters raised in the official's new job description, the contract will be finalised.

QUESTION 1648

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 09/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 20-2009)

Mr I M Ollis (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

(2) (a) how often should each facility be inspected and (b) when last was each facility inspected? NW2054E

REPLY:

(1) (a) (i) and (ii) The Department of Higher Education is not fully functional yet and is currently making use of the facilities and resources of the Department of Education. The Department of Education Higher is accommodated in one of the three buildings occupied by the Department of Education, in Central Pretoria and all these adhere to the Occupational Health and Safety Act.

(b) CHE, SAQA and UMALUSI, are entities that report to the Minister for Higher Education and Training. They all adhere to the Occupational Health and Safety Act.

(2). The Act does not specify how frequent inspections must take place.

The Landlord does inspect monthly and the internal Office Services at least weekly

QUESTION 1165

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 11/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 16-2009)

Dr W G James (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

Whether his department uses temporary employment services and/or labour brokers; if so, (a) why, (b) how many positions have been filled by temporary employment services in the (i) 2006- 07, (ii) 2007-08 and (iii) 2008-09 financial years, (c) what percentage of the total staff complement did temporary employment services contribute in each of these years and (d) how much money has been spent on temporary employment services in each year?NW1500E

REPLY:

The Department of Higher Education and Training does not make use of temporary employment services and/or labour brokers.

a. Not Applicable

b. Not Applicable

c. Not Applicable

d. Not Applicable

QUESTION 460

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 10/07/09 (INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 06 - 2009)

The Leader of the Opposition (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

In each of the past three years up to the latest specified date for which information is available, how many engineers (a) graduated and (b) registered with the Engineering Council of South Africa to increase the acquisition of priority skills as required by Joint Initiative on Priority Skills Acquisition (Jipsa) programmes?

NW521E

REPLY:

(a)

Year	2005	2006	2007
Total Engineering Graduates	6624	7714	8381

(b)

Year	2005	2006	2007
Total Engineering Registrations	5488	6090	6384
Source: Engineering Council SA

QUESTION 376

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 03/07/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 05-2009)

Dr. WG James (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

(2) Whether there were any related costs for the travel and accommodation of guests; if so, (a) what were the costs and (b) what was the breakdown of these costs?

NW436E

REPLY:

(1) There was no function held by the Department to celebrate the appointment of the Minister of Higher Education and Training

(a) Not applicable. (b) Not applicable. (c) Not applicable.

(2) Not applicable. (a) Not applicable. (b) Not applicable

QUESTION 977
DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 28/08/09
(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 12-2009)
Dr W G James (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

Whether he has taken any steps with regard to suspending import duties or on finding other means of reducing the cost of imported prescribed text books for university students, especially in the disciplines of science and medicine; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW1178E

REPLY:

I would like to recommend that the Minister of Trade and Industry be approached for a reply as tariffs and related duties are determined by the Ministry of Trade and Industry in consultation with the International Trade and Administration Commission. I will however explore this possibility in the near future and ask my officials to consult with the Department of Trade and Industry

QUESTIONS FOR WRITTEN REPLY

FRIDAY, 23 OCTOBER 2009

[No 24 – 2009] First Session, Fourth Parliament

1841. Dr W G James (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

Whether there are any plans to re-open the Giyani College of Education in Limpopo; if not, why not; if so, what plans?

REPLY:

The facilities of the former Giyani College of Education are currently being used by the Limpopo Department of Education for purposes other than teacher education. The Department of Higher Education and Training and the Limpopo Department of Education have not discussed the future use of these facilities as a site for training teachers.

However, given the importance of increasing the number of quality teachers trained by universities, and colleges previously incorporated into universities, the Ministry of Higher Education and Training has approved a range of projects designed to increase the intake and output of teacher training graduates. In this regard, funding of R474 million has been allocated to 19 universities for the 2010/11 and 2011/12 financial years, while a further R139 million will be added by institutions, making the total available for this initiative R 613 million. The commitment made by universities is to increase, by 2012 compared to their 2007, their enrolments of new (or first time entering) Bachelor of Education enrolments by 1 000, and their new Postgraduate Certificate in Education enrolments by 700. This annual total of 1 700 additional new students would, over a 4 year period, raise the total of students in teacher training in universities by a total of over 4 000, compared to the 2007 enrolment total.

QUESTIONS FOR WRITTEN REPLY

FRIDAY, 23 OCTOBER 2009

[No 24 – 2009] First Session, Fourth Parliament

1840. Dr W G James (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

(1) In respect of each version of the 2008-09 annual report of his department and the annual reports of each statutory and other entity reporting to his department, (a) what was the (i) budgeted cost, (ii) actual cost and (iii) breakdown of cost in respect of (aa) printing, (bb) graphic design, (cc) other costs and (dd) unit cost of each annual report and (b) how many copies of each were (i) produced and (ii) distributed;

(3) how was the decision taken to award the contract to the (a) graphic design company and (b) printing company;

(4) whether (a) his department or (b) any of those public entities that fall under his department held a function on tabling their 2008-09 annual report; if so, in each case (i) what was the name of the public entity, (ii) how much did the function cost, (iii) what is the breakdown of that cost, (iv) where was the function held and (v) how many guests were invited?

(1) The Department of Higher Education and Training only came into effect in May 2009, therefore no Annual Report has been developed or tabled during the period mentioned. Therefore questions 2-4 are not applicable to DoHET

REPLY regarding entities that report to the Minister of Higher Education and Training.

QUESTION (1a)	i) Public Entity Budgeted cost of the Annual Report	ii) Actual cost of the Annual Report	iii) Breakdown of cost in respect of
PUBLIC ENTITY			Printing	Graphic Design	Other costs	Unit cost of each Annual Report
Council on Higher Education (CHE)	140 000	139 701	92 545	20 000	27 156	139,70
National Student Financial Aid Scheme (NSFAS)	367 382	228 601	154 200	39 923	34 478	226,00
South African Qualifications Authority (SAQA)	250 000	209 833	125 416	71 980	12 437	67,78

Question (1b)	i) How many copies were produced?	ii) How many copies were distributed
Public Entity	2008/09	2008/09
CHE	1 000	1 000
NSFAS	1 010	510
SAQA	3 000	2 505

	CHE	NSFAS	SAQA
QUESTION 2 (b)	NO version retracted or withdrawn from Parliament	NO version retracted or withdrawn from Parliament	NO version retracted or withdrawn from Parliament

QUESTION 3	Tender Evaluation Method: Price, HDI, WE, Disability, SMME, Skills Emp, HR, Community, Locality, Rural Area	For graphic design, a request for proposals were sent out to suppliers on the supplier database and for printing quotations were requested through design companies	One company was contracted to do design, layout, editing and printing. The contract was awarded after an open tender was advertised. 21 companies sent in bids and the contract was awarded to the company that scored the highest points in the tender evaluation process.

QUESTION 4 (b)	No function held.	No function held.	No function held.

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

FOR WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION 1839

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 23/10/2009

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 22-2009)

Dr W G James (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

(1) Whether (a) he, (b) any specified officials and (c) any other persons have been issued with a government or official credit card; if so, what are the relevant details for him and each holder of a credit card in respect of the (i) name, (ii) job title, (iii) credit limit, (iv) outstanding amount as at the latest specified date for which information is available, (v) monthly expenses incurred for each month since receiving the credit card, (vi) reason for such persons being issued with a credit card and (vii) uses that such a credit card is intended for;

(2) whether any such credit cards are over their credit limit; if so, (a) whose credit cards are over the limit and (b) what is the reason for the credit cards exceeding the limit;

(3) whether any action has been taken against such persons for exceeding their credit card limits; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW2398E

REPLY:

(1) (a), (b) & (c): No

(1) (i) to (vii): Not applicable

(2) (a) and (b): Not applicable

(3) Not applicable.

QUESTION 92

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 08/06/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 01-2009)

Mr AM Mpontshane (IFP) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

Whether his department has taken any steps with regard to the high number of outstanding loans owed to the National Student Financial Aid Scheme (NSFAS) and the impact this is having on both students and administrators; if not, why not; if so, what steps?

NW95E

REPLY:

The National Student Financial Aid Scheme (NSFAS) is currently recovering approximately R40 million per month in loan repayments from past student debtors. The total recovered from loans, including interest in 2008 was R616 million. The recovered funds are reallocated to fund new students in the subsequent year. The amount is significant against the total budget of R2.496 billion for 2009.

The scheme has however identified the need to responsibly maximize the recovery of outstanding loans from all eligible debtors. Through its partnership with the South African Revenue Services, NSFAS is able to track students who secure formal employment and who are then registered on the Pay-As-You-Earn (PAYE) taxpayer register. In this regard, one of the strategic goals of the NSFAS for the period 2009 to 2011 is to review its loan recovery strategy.

As part of the terms of reference of the review of the Scheme, the committee will also assess the nature and extent of former and current students indebted and blacklisted by NSFAS and universities, and to recommend appropriate action to be taken to deal with the problem. This Committee has commenced its work and will provide the Minister of Higher Education and Training with a report before the end of 2009. The report will be published for public comment.

QUESTION 579

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 10/07/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 06 - 2009)

Dr. W G James (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

NW645E

REPLY:

UNIVERSITIES AND TECHNIKONS

INSTITUTION NAME	Actual 2003	Actual 2004
UNIVERSITIES
University of Cape Town	5.1	5.2
University of Durban Westville	1.9	(2)
University of Fort Hare	0.9	1.2
Medical University of South Africa	0.8	0.7
University of Natal	7.6	(2)
University of the North	1.1	1.5
University of the Free State	4.5	5.1
University of Port Elizabeth	2.9	4.2
Potchefstroom University	6.0	(3)
University of Pretoria	9.2	10.7
Rand Afrikaans University	5.8	7.1
Rhodes University	2.4	1.7
University of South Africa	10.6	14.5
University of Stellenbosch	5.3	5.3
University of the Western Cape	2.2	2.3
University of Witwatersrand	4.1	4.7
University of Zululand	1.9	2.1
Vista University	2.4	(4)
University of Transkei	1.4	1.1
University of the North West	1.1	(3)
University of Venda	1.3	1.3
University of KwaZulu-Natal		8.3
North West University		9.6
Sub Total: Universities	78.5	86.6

INSTITUTION NAME	Actual 2003	Actual 2004
TECHNIKONS
Cape Technikon	3.1	3.4
Technikon Northern Gauteng	1.6	(5)
Mangosuthu Technikon	0.9	0.9
ML Sultan Technikon	(1)	(1)
Natal Technikon	(1)	(1)
Technikon Free State	1.4	1.9
Peninsula Technikon	2.1	2.2
Port Elizabeth Technikon	2.0	1.9
Technikon Pretoria	6.0	(5)
Technikon SA	2.7	(6)
Vaal Triangle Technikon	2.1	2.3
Technikon Witwatersrand	1.9	2.1
Border Technikon	0.8	0.8
Technikon North West	0.6	(5)
Eastern Cape Technikon	1.5	1.2
Durban Institute of Technology	3.1	3.8
Tshwane University of Technology		9.8
Sub Total: Technikons	29.8	30.3
TOTAL: UNIVERSITIES AND TECHNIKONS	108.3	116.9

NUMBER OF GRADUATES AND OUTPUT TARGETS ( '000 )
Institution	Actual 2005	Actual 2006	Actual 2007	2010 target: approved October 2007 (A)
Cape Peninsula University of Technology	5.7	6.8	6.9	7.0
University of Cape Town	6.1	5.3	5.4	6.2
Central University of Technology	2.1	2.3	2.3	2.4
Durban University of Technology	4.3	4.4	4.7	4.7
University of Fort Hare	1.8	1.9	1.6	2.1
University of Free State	5.2	5.4	4.7	6.2
University of Johannesburg	10.1	10.2	9.5	10.2
University of KwaZulu-Natal	8.3	8.6	7.6	9.8
University of Limpopo	3.0	3.3	4.1	3.6
Mangosuthu Technikon	1.2	1.9	1.8	1.6
Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University	5.4	4.9	6.0	5.9
North West University	7.7	9.8	11.3	10.1
University of Pretoria	11.6	11.4	10.9	11.9
Rhodes University	2.1	1.9	1.8	2.1
University of South Africa	14.1	13.8	14.3	20.3
University of Stellenbosch	5.5	5.6	5.7	6.2
Tshwane University of Technology	9.4	9.1	9.8	10.1
Vaal University of Technology	2.3	2.4	2.7	3.0
University of Venda	1.6	1.8	1.9	1.9
Walter Sisulu University	2.7	3.5	3.0	3.6
University of the Western Cape	3.0	2.8	3.1	4.0
University of the Witwatersrand	5.0	4.9	5.4	6.4
University of Zululand	2.1	2.2	2.0	2.6
TOTAL	120.3	124.2	126.5	141.9

(A) NOTES: The graduate targets for 2010 are based on agreed upon targets with the institutions and approved by the Minister in 2007.

Notes:

(1) See Durban Institute of Technology

(2) See University of KwaZulu-Natal

(3) See North West University

(4) Campuses Incorporated into University of Pretoria, RAU

University of the Free State, University of Port Elizabeth, Technikon Free State,

Potchefstroom University and UNISA

(5) See Tshwane University of Technology

(6) See University of South Africa

FET COLLEGE GRADUATES: 2004 – 2008

Year	Nr of Passes
2004	135337
2005	138122
2006	152484
2007	132256
2008	127335

NOTES: The above figures reflect those students who passed 7 subjects. Students who passed 5 and 6 subjects out of the 7 were excluded.

QUESTION 588

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 07/08/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 07-2009)

Mr M J Ellis (DA) to the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

(1) Whether the SA Qualifications Authority Standards Generating Body (SGB) task team has been constituted; if not, why not; if so, (a) who was appointed to the task team and (b) what are their qualifications;

(2) whether the task team has commenced with the standards generating body process; if not, why not; if so, (a) what are the relevant details and (b) when will the process be completed? NW650E

REPLY:

(1) The South African Qualifications Authority (SAQA) has not constituted any Standards Generating Body (SGB) task team, as these structures are already established in terms of the National Standards Body Regulations. In terms of these regulations 12 National Standards Bodies and 152 Standards Generating Bodies were established and are operational since 1999. Some of the SGBs have since been disestablished upon completion of their tasks.

(2) This is not applicable as there no task team has been established as per the response above.

QUESTION 1799

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 16/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 22-2009)

Mr J H van der Merwe (IFP) to ask the Minister of Higher Education:

1. Whether remedial action will be taken with regard to Unisa's policy of only (a) issuing degree and diploma certificates in English and (b) hosting graduation ceremonies in English; if not, why not, in each case; if so, what are the relevant details in each case;

2. Whether he will make a statement on the matter? NW2300E

REPLY:

1. Unisa recognizes that the country has eleven official languages, and English is but one of them. However, fiscal constraints militate against the University hosting graduation ceremonies in all eleven languages and for practical and operational purposes, Unisa graduation ceremonies are hosted in English. For internal purposes, Unisa has a Language Policy that we, believe, will eventually lead to practical multi-lingualism. As a matter of interest, Unisa is in the process of establishing an Academy of African Languages and Science, the aim being to give practical effect to the use of languages other than English and Afrikaans, to be used as languages of science.

However, with specific reference to the award for doctoral degrees, where the thesis has been submitted in Afrikaans and the student indicates a preference for Afrikaans, the citation which accompanies the award of the degree, is read by the supervisor in Afrikaans during the graduation ceremony. (To date, Unisa has not had any doctoral thesis submitted in languages other than English and Afrikaans). In the event any student presents in Afrikaans, the awards is also presented in Afrikaans (This has not happened with other languages). This is easily and usually the case, where such students have received their degrees with distinction.

In addition, Unisa will prepare and award a graduation certificate in any of the eleven languages if a request for same were made by any of the graduation students. Again, however, to date, Unisa has not received a request of such a nature.

2. The issue of the language used on certificates and at graduation ceremonies is part of the wider debate on language policy at higher education institutions. The Department of Education has published policy to give effect to the provisions of the Constitution. The Language in Education Policy (1997) and the Language Policy for Higher Education (2002) were designed to promote multilingualism in the education sector.

Their aim is to ensure that all South African languages are "developed to their full capacity while at the same time ensuring that the existing languages of instruction (English and Afrikaans) do not serve as a barrier to access and success." Amongst other matters receiving my attention, close monitoring of the implementation of the above forms part of the work of the Department.

QUESTION 1065

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 04/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 14-2009)

Dr W G James (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

What is the present staff establishment of his department;

Whether any new positions have been or will be created; if so, (a) when, (b) how many and (c) which positions;

Whether there are any vacancies that need to be filled; if so, (a) how many, (b) at what level and (c) when will they be filled? NW1326E

REPLY:

1. The staff establishment of the Department of Higher Education and Training is currently under consideration.

2. It is envisaged that new positions will have to be created especially in the field of the corporate services function.

According to the Department of Public Service and Administration staff establishments of newly created departments should be finalised by the end of October 2009.

It is not yet clear how many new positions need to be created as the staff establishment is still under consideration.

Please see explanation under 2 (b).

It is envisaged that vacancies will occur that need to be filled. It is however at this stage not clear how many and at what level.

QUESTION 24

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 08/06/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 01-2009)

Mr GG Boinamo (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Education:

1. Whether is department's initiative of merging institutions of higher learning has produced the desired outcomes; if so, what is the breakdown of the (a) success of each of these tertiary institutions mergers and (b) impact it has had on (i) transformation and (ii) restructuring of higher education; if not, what is the breakdown of all institutions of higher learning that have emerged and failed to produce desired outcomes,

2. Whether his department has taken any steps to rectify this situation, if not, why not; if so, what steps? NW25E

REPLY:

The Department of Education has been supporting, monitoring and evaluating the progress of mergers and incorporations to ensure the goals and objectives of the restructuring process are realised. A recent priority has been to provide technical and financial assistance to develop and rehabilitate the physical infrastructure of institutions. In this regard, I allocated for the triennium 2007/08 to 2009/10, R3 856 million, for infrastructure development and efficiency gains to higher education institutions. These funds are being used to build or renovate student residences, lecture theaters, libraries and laboratories, as well as improve enrolments and graduation rates in scarce and critical skills.

While the outcomes of mergers are generally long term, the mergers have necessitated different approaches in the context of individual institutional requirements and adjustments have had to be made in light of the continuous monitoring and evaluation of the process. As an example, the former MEDUNSA will be retained as a separate campus of the University of Limpopo in Ga-Rankuwa and not re-locate to Polokwane as initially proposed. Currently, the Department is providing technical support and advice to the Universityof Limpopo in the physical development of the respective campuses.

Although progress toward the merger goals has not always been even during the past five years, by August 2009 all the institutions had achieved the desired levels of integration as depicted in the indicative table below. Other areas of successful integration include ICT, finance, student administration and facilities.

QUESTION 1404

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 25/09/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 18-2009)

Mr AP van der Westhuizen (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

(1) When will the funding model for further education and training (FET) colleges be implemented in full;

(2) Whether the funding model will enable FET colleges to expand their offering of more courses, such as those needed for the training of technicians; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

(3) Whether he will make a statement on the matter?

REPLY:

In terms of Gazette 32010 of 16 March 2009, the funding model for FET Colleges will be implemented in full from 1 April 2010.

(2) The colleges will be able to expand their offering of more courses. The funding norms are focussed on the division of State funding into approved programmes. The current list of approved programmes consists of the NC(V) programmes, NQF Levels 2 to 4. These programmes were developed based on the priority skills areas as identified in 2006 and 2007 via the ASGISA and JIPSA processes. The approval of new programmes is an annual cycle which is initiated by the FET Colleges. The approved programme list with the relevant funding weights and programme costs is then circulated to the colleges by July of each year.

(3) The content of these replies are already in the public domain and no statement is necessary. QUESTION 1956

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 23/10/2009

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 22-2009)

Dr A Lotriet (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

(1) Whether his department provides additional financial support to higher education institutions where more than one language has to be provided for as a language of instruction; if so, what are the relevant details; if not,

(2) whether he intends providing such financial support; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

(3) whether only historically Afrikaans universities are expected to provide education in more than one medium of instruction; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the (a) reasons in this regard and (b) further relevant details? NW2520E

REPLY:

The funding formula that distributes public funding to public higher education institutions currently does not allocate funds to institutions that provide tuition in more than one language of teaching and learning. The Department of Higher Education and Training however has funded, through donor support a number of projects that support multi-lingualism in higher education institutions.

There are currently no plans to revise the subsidy allocation formula to the delivery of teaching and learning in more than one language.

The Ministry of Education published the Language in Education Policy (1997) and the Language Policy for Higher Education (2002), which are designed to promote multilingualism in the education sector. Their aim is to ensure that all South African languages are "developed to their full capacity while at the same time ensuring that the existing languages of instruction (English and Afrikaans) do not serve as a barrier to access and success." Universities have the prerogative to develop and determine their language policies, consistent with the above policies in terms of the Higher Education Act. It is thus the choice of individual institutions to have more than one language of teaching and learning.

QUESTIONS FOR WRITTEN REPLY

FRIDAY, 23 OCTOBER 2009

[No 24 – 2009] First Session, Fourth Parliament

1956. Dr A Lotriet (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

(2) whether he intends providing such financial support; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

(1) The funding formula that distributes public funding to public higher education institutions currently does not allocate funds to institutions that provide tuition in more than one language of teaching and learning. The Department of Higher Education and Training however has funded, through donor support a number of projects that support multi-lingualism in higher education institutions.

(2) There are currently no plans to revise the subsidy allocation formula to the delivery of teaching and learning in more than one language. However, the Ministerial Statement on Higher Education Funding for 2010/11 does indicate a review of the subsidy allocation formula.

(3) The Ministry of Education published the Language in Education Policy (1997) and the Language Policy for Higher Education (2002), which are designed to promote multilingualism in the education sector. Their aim is to ensure that all South African languages are "developed to their full capacity while at the same time ensuring that the existing languages of instruction (English and Afrikaans) do not serve as a barrier to access and success." Universities have the prerogative to develop and determine their language policies, consistent with the above policies in terms of the Higher Education Act. It is thus the choice of individual institutions to have more than one language of teaching and learning.

QUESTION 1672

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 16/10/09

(INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER 22-2009)

Dr W G James (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training:

REPLY:

(i) Not applicable

(ii) Not applicable

(a) Not applicable

(b) Not applicable

25 December 2009 - NW2009

McGluwa, Mr JJ to ask the Minister of Human Settlements

(1) (a) What is the 2009-10 (i) business plan and (ii) budget breakdown for the Housing Development Agency (HDA) and (b) what projects were assigned to the HDA for 2009;

Source
Link

Reply:

(1) Yes, there are plans to develop and implement a policy based on the National Vetting Strategy by the end of the financial year (2009/10).

(2) Yes, only at executive level through NIA. However the department is in the process of putting mechanisms in place to ensure that pre-employment screening of potential employees for criminal records is done to specific identified posts.

(4) In terms of records based on the info provided on application forms, the department does not have any employees with criminal records.

QUESTION FOR WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION No 1904

Question

Mr A C Steyn (DA) to ask the Minister of Human Settlements:

1. Whether there are any plans to introduce energy saving initiatives in the building of new subsidised homes: if so, what are the relevant details; if not, why not?

2. Whether there are any plans to introduce policy or legislation to encourage future private homeowners and/or developers to make use of energy saving initiatives in the construction of their homes; if so, what are the relevant details; if not, why not?

Answer

1. Yes, the National Housing Code contains detailed guidelines to promote environmentally and energy efficient housing in the subsidy sector. The Department of Human Settlements has been working with the NHBRC to cost various measures to enhance the thermal performance of houses in the subsidy market. The most promising and cost effective of these is the installation of a ceiling and the provision of above ceiling insulation. Other measures include plastering of the external walls of the houses, under floor insulation and sealing of windows and doors. The cost implications of introducing energy efficient measures in the subsidy housing market will be considered, once the NHBRC have finalised their research report.

2. Yes, the Department of Energy has instructed the South African Bureau of Standards (SABS) to develop national standards for energy efficiency in naturally ventilated building. Theses standards will form part of the National Building Regulations and is referred to as the SANS 204 Standard. The Department of Human Settlements participated in the working group process and the draft standards have been published for comments. The standards are currently being refined in terms of the comments received and will then be presented for approval.

QUESTION 672

QUESTION

672. Mr M M Swathe (DA) to ask the Minister of Human Settlements:

Whether he and his department will implement a programme to eradicate the housing backlog in all the provinces; if not, why not; if so, (a) when will the programme start and (b) what is the set target to achieve?

REPLY

Section 26 (1) and (2) of the Constitution determines that The State must take reasonable legislative and other measures, within its available resources, to achieve the progressive realisation of the right to have access to adequate housing.

The aim of Government's Human Settlement Programme therefor is to provide housing to all qualifying beneficiaries in an integrated manner within the context of sustainable human settlements. This implies that Government aims to eradicate the housing backlog over time, depending on the availability of resources.

Based on provincial allocations of the Integrated Housing and Human Settlement Grant, Provincial MECs responsible for Human Settlements prepare annual provincial plans which indicate the spending priorities within a particular province. These priorities are determined according to housing demand in a province with a view to the eradication of backlogs.

Therefor, Government's Human Settlement Programme since 1994 has been aimed at eradicating the housing backlog.

a) Falls away

b) Government has decided not to set targets based on the eradication of backlogs per se, but rather to pursue the establishment of integrated, sustainable human settlements based on the availability of financial resources being made available in terms of the Integrated Housing and Human Settlement Grant.

QUESTIONS 870

FOR WRITTEN REPLY

870. Mr A C Steyn (DA) to ask the Minister of Human Settlements:

(1) Whether the customer service hotline where the public can report corruption or fraud in housing is in operation; if not, why not; if so, (a) how many cases of irregularities have been reported and (b) what is the nature of the irregularities;

Answer: The customer services hotline in the Department of Human Settlements is in operation, and the operational hour's starts from 06:00-22:00

(a) The cases of irregularities reported is 3

(b) The nature of irregularities is as follows:

· Councillors selling houses to their relatives

· Housing demand database not transparent

· People are being pushed at a certain prize to be on the Housing Demand databaselist

· Title deed in somebody's else name

(2) Whether any cases has been referred to the SA Police Service; if not, why not; if so, how many (a) cases have been referred and (b) suspects have been (i) arrested and (ii) charged thus far?

(a) Three (3) cases received from call centre since August 2009.Those cases are still under investigation by our internal forensic team and can only be referred to SAPS after we have concluded our investigation. However there is no automatic referral to SAPS .We gather more facts and conduct case analysis , in order to establish whether these cases would warrant a criminal investigation or not.

(b) No suspect arrested as the matter is still under investigation

QUESTION No 1754

Question

1754.Mr AC Steyn, MP (DA) to asked the Minister of Human Settlements:

What progress has been made with the policy development regarding the Farm Worker/Farm Occupier Housing Assistance Programme?

Reply

The policy and implementation guidelines for the National Housing Programme: Farm Residents Housing Assistance was approved and my Department is currently acquiring the services of legal expertise to develop pro-forma contractual agreements to facilitate the implementation of the programme. Where feasible, provinces and municipalities may already implement the programme.

QUESTION NO: 1753

Mr A C STEYN (DA) to ask the Minister of Human Settlements:

(1) What (a) are the closing-down costs of (i) Thubelisha Homes, (ii) Servcon Housing Solutions (Pty) Ltd and (iii) the Social Housing Foundation and (b) is the exact breakdown of the costs involved in closing down each of these entities;

(2) what (a) are the outstanding amounts owed by service providers to (i) Thubelisha Homes, (ii) Servcon Housing Solutions (Pty) Ltd and (iii) the Social Housing Foundation and (b) (i) are the names of these service providers and (ii) is the amount owed by them in respect of each entity and (c) steps has the department taken to recover these amounts?

ANSWER

(1) (a)

(i) The costs of closing Thubelisha were estimated at the time of preparing the closure plan in August 2008. These costs were revised with improved estimates on 29 January 2009. At that stage, the estimated cost of the closure of Thubelisha was given as R 241,5m. This included a combination of actual closure costs, settlement of the deficit in the company and a provision for possible claims from creditors and clients (Provinces). The total known costs of closing Thubelisha is R24,4 m, significantly less than the R130,4 m estimate at 31 December 2009. The actual costs of closing the company have been reduced to R 23, 9 m.

(ii) The cost of closing Servcon totals R 54,205,490.78.

(iii) In terms of the Social Housing Foundation (SHF), closure costs cannot yet be stated since this information is currently not available.

(b)

Thubelisha

The exact breakdown of the costs involved in closing down Thubelisha is as follows:

The actual costs of closing the company have been reduced to R 23,9 M (Reference A)

There are still two amounts relating to VAT from Contractors (R12,8M) and MIG debtors from the City of Cape Town (R40,8) that have not yet been recovered and may have to be written off (Reference B)

Mainly as a result of the release of un required provisions and the recognition of income resulting from project reconciliations, the expected deficit in the company has been reduced from an accumulated loss of R 12,7 M to a surplus of R 53,1 M (Reference C)

This brings the total known costs of closure to R 24,4 M, significantly less than the R130,4 M estimate at 31 December 2008.

A provision for additional claims and contingencies made in December 2008 has been retained amounting to an addition R 111M (reference D), which may or may not be required.

Servcon

The exact breakdown of the costs involved in closing down Servcon are as follows:

· Provision for staff cost from September to March 2010: R16,316,571.16

· Provision for severance expenses : R32,888,919.62

· Consulting expenses, including audit fees, liquidation fee and other related fees : R5,000,000.00

(2) (a)

(i) The basis for this question is uncertain. If the question relates to money owed to service providers the submission is that Thubelisha owes money to service providers and not the other way round. In this regard, Thubelisha is in the process of settling all valid creditors that are outstanding. However, if the question relates to claims and potential write offs, then the outstanding amounts owed by service providers is R53, 6 m. It must be noted however that there are claims and counter claims against major consortia that have worked mainly on the N2 Gateway project that still need to be resolved. The nature of these claims are discussed below (2(b)) in detail.

(ii) Servcon Housing Solutions (Pty) Ltd outstanding amount due from from the clients is R197,324,994.49.

(b)

(i) The names of service providers owing monies to Thubelisha are as follows:

· City of Cape Town for Municipal Infrastructure Grants (MIG) on the N2 project: R40, 8 m

· There are still amounts not yet recovered from service providers for VAT incorrectly paid to them. For this to be recovered, the service provider would in turn claim the amount from SARS and additional input tax. The recovery or not of this amount is thus neutral to Government as a whole. The cost of pursuing these old service providers is likely to be significant with no significant value to Treasury. Recovery efforts are still underway but likelihood of recovery is considered remote for the final amounts: R12, 8 m

· There are claims and counter claims against major consortia that have worked mainly on the N2 Gateway project such as Ibuyile and Sobambisana. With regards to Ibuyile, there is a provision in the books of Thubelisha for R 61m for this claim which is also included in the claim of R 133 million indicated below. Thubelisha believes it has a claim of R 43 million. The Consortium believes it has a claim of an amount of R 133 million. Sobambisana on the other hand has indicated that they would be making counter claims which at header date we have not received as yet.

The names of service providers owing monies to Servcon are as follows:

· Gauteng Department of Human Settlements : R82,550,535.37

· Eastern Cape Department of Human Settlements : R14, 420,103.00

· National Department of Public Works : R99,744,288.00

· Others (rent ect.): R610,068.12

(c)

· In relation to the City of Cape Town, Thubelisha is continuing with the recovery of this amount with the assistance of the staff of the Housing Development Agency (HDA). Furthermore, the pursuit of old service providers for VAT incorrectly paid to them is likely to be significant with no great value to the National Treasury. Recovery efforts however, are still underway but likelihood of recovery is considered remote for the final amounts. Both claims are with Thubelisha's attorneys. The entity has received responses from the consortiums and is currently looking at them. Once the entity has completed their reports, this will proceed to arbitration or litigation in the next 14 days.

· With regards to Servcon and the recovery of amounts due to them, the Department will work with Servcon with a view to assist with the recovery of monies due from the provinces.

QUESTION 1499

FOR REPLY

1499. MR A C STEYN (DA) to ask the Minister of Human Settlements:

Whether his department is taking any steps to offset its carbon footprint; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

REPLY

1. The Department has complied with the requirements set out by the Department of Energy and has installed energy efficient lighting within the facilities. Furthermore the Department of Public Works has appointed a service provider that will ensure and maintain the lighting within government owned and leased buildings with a view to promoting savings towards carbon footprint.

QUESTION 1500

FOR WRITTEN REPLY

1500. Mr A C Steyn (DA) to ask the Minister of Human Settlements:

Whether there are any plans to introduce energy saving initiatives in the building of new subsidised homes: if so, what are the relevant details; if not, why not?
Whether there are any plans to introduce policy or legislation to encourage future private homeowners and/or developers to make use of energy saving initiatives in the construction of their homes; if so, what are the relevant details; if not, why not?

REPLY

QUESTIONS 1387

FRIDAY, 25 SEPTEMBER 2009

1387. Mr A C Steyn (DA) to ask the Minister of Human Settlements:

(1) (a) What are the (i) names and (ii) qualifications of the persons who formed part of the management team that was sent to assist the Eastern Cape housing department in 2008 and (b) where were they seconded from;

(2) what was the (a) duration of their secondment and (b) description of their individual responsibility within the management team;

(3) what are the details of the (a) progress and (b) skills transferred to date;

(4) (a) what is the total cost to his department of the intervention and (b) how is the cost made up with regard to (i) travelling, (ii) accommodation, (iii) remuneration and (iv) other specified expenses?

REPLY

NAME	QUALIFICATIONS	PERIOD OF ENGAGEMENT
Leshabe Sam Rampedi	B.com (accounting) , Masters in Development studies	April 2008 to date
Thomas Ntshengedzeni Ramovha	B. Tech management services Diploma in Municipality Management	April 2008 to date
Siphumedze Mndze	Msc Dev planning, BA degree, Dipll PR.	July to Nov 2008 Sept 2008 to date
Lorraine S. M. Makola	B. Com Computer Science Dipl. Human Rights	01 May 2008 to date
Thanyani Ramatsea	Professional Engineer. B. Sc (Civil) Eng Masters in Engineering	01 Oct 2008 to date
Rudzani Percy Mamphaga	Professional Engineer. BSc (Civil) Eng. Graduate Diploma in Engineering.	01 Sept 2008 to date
Wellington Didibhuku Thwala	B.sc Quantity Surveyor	01 Sept 2008 to Nov 2009
Sam Johannes Du Preez	Professional engineer. B Sc (civil) Eng	01 June 2009 to date
Sifiso Sibanyoni	B.Sc Eng Civil Hons	01 Sep 2008 to 31 Oct 2008
Tsikadzashe Nemato	Professional Engineer. B.Sc Eng Civil Hons.	01 Nov 2008 to 31 March 2009
William Chitsa	Professional Engineer. B. Sc Eng Civil Hons. MBA	01 Nov 2008 to date
Tsholofelo Diale	B. Sc Eng Civil Hons	01 Sep 2008 to 31 Oct 2008
Ferdinand C. Fester	B. Sc Quantity Surveyor	01 Sept 2008 to 31 Nov 2008
Jan G Fourie	Professional Engineer. B. Sc Eng Civil B. Com LLB Msc. Eng	Nov 2008 to March 2009
Sthembiso Ndlovu	B. Tech In Construction Management Masters in Project Management	01 September 2009
Thabo Wahls Mathibeli	Professional Engineer B. Sc Eng Civil B. SC Maths & Physics MBA	01 July 2009 to date
Thamsamqa Patrick Skele	Professional Engineer Technologist - Civil GCE Civil Eng B. Tech Civil Eng N.H.D. Civil Eng N. Dipl Civil Eng	01 July 2009 to date
Letta Mokgotsi	B.A.	April 2008 to Oct 2008
Bahle Precious Sitaba	BA Environmental and Development	01 Nov 2009 to 31 Jan 2009
David Victor Hatton Hall	Profesional engineer B. Sc Eng Civil Hons MBA Dipl Prof Construction Project Manager	25 Nov 2009 to Feb 2009
Kamlesh Naran Bhana	B Tech: Town planning	01 Sept 2008 to 31 March 2009
Brenda Mvula	Post Graduate Diploma: Project management	01 Nov 2008 to date
Dave Awogu	Masters In Town & Regional Planning Post Grad Dipl In Computer Science B.sc Hons Urban & Regional Planning	01 June 2009 to date
Sindile Bidla	Masters Geo Information Sc A& Earth Observation B.sc Agriculture	01 May 2009 to date
Abraham van der Berg	Professional Land Surveyor Bachelor Degree Land Surveying Masters Town & Regional Planning B.A. Public Admin Hons	June 2009 to date
Calvin Sehlapelo	B. Com Hons Acc & CA B. Comm Acc	July 2009 to date

1(b) The officials were seconded from National and other Provinces. Other officials were sourced from the private sector and were appointed as independent contractors (consultants).

2(a) The duration of secondment is captured above in the last column.

2(b) Mr Rampedi is the team leader of the Eastern Cape Intervention.

Ms Makola is the office manager that ensures necessary arrangements and control of the team.

Mr Ramovha is responsible for the oversight role within the team and monitors progress.

3(a) The province has improved in the overall system of housing delivery in the areas of project management, quality assurance, multi-year planning, financial management and reporting.

3 (b) As part of capacity building the National Department deployed skills

in the areas of strategic management, financial management, engineering, town planning and information management. These professionals have worked closely with the province to ensure that skills are transferred to provincial officials. This has manifested in improved conditional grant expenditure, planning, increased number of units completed, quality management and reporting.

4 R 6.177 million

(b) (i) R1.7 million

(ii) R912 000

(iii) R3.5 million

(iv) Telephones: R30 733

Office equipment: R3 600

Lease payments: R30 806

QUESTION NO. 1385

WRITTEN REPLY

Mr A C Steyn (DA) MP to ask the Minister of Human Settlements:

(a) Who were the managing agents after the completion of the rental units at Phase 1 of the N2 Gateway project;

(b) What are the relevant details of the agreement entered into with the managing agents, including;

(i) the date that the agreement was entered into,

(ii) the duration of the agreement

(iii) details of the

(aa) responsible

(bb) remuneration of the managing agents and;

(i) maintenance and;

(ii) collection of rentals for these units?

REPLY

(a) Thubelisha Homes have a lease agreement with the City of Cape Town (owners of the rental portion of Joe Slovo Phase 1).

(b) (i) The original lease agreement was signed in 2006.

(ii) The lease was for a period of five years, with a 30 year renewable option.

(iii) (aa) Maintenance and rental collection.

(bb) In terms of the lease agreement, no payment is made Thubelisha Homes as it was envisaged they would recoup costs from rental income received. Trafalgar Property Management Services were appointed to maintain a billing service. This service merely records payments made and sends out accounts to the tenants. Trafalgar Property Management are paid an amount of R 8 037.00 monthly for this service.

(c) (i) Currently the maintenance falls under Thubelisha Homes as the as the lease with the City of Cape Town is still in force.

(ii) Currently rental payments which are made by tenants are paid into Thubelisha Homes' bank account.

QUESTION NO: 278

WRITTEN REPLY

DATE OF PUBLICATION:

Mr M M Swathe (DA) to ask the Minister of Human Settlements:

Whether he will review the housing needs, allocations, lists and qualifications of all those who 'applied for RDP houses; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

REPLY

Housing Needs

No. The Government remains committed towards housing assistance to household who cannot independently resolve their own housing needs. The bulk of housing funding allocation is still channelled towards the upgrading of informal settlements as the highest priority.

The Government is, however, in the process to broaden the application scope of the National Housing Programmes as part of the implementation of the mandate contained in the Comprehensive Plan for the Creation of Sustainable Human Settlements, also referred to as the "BNG" policy framework. In this process and to achieve a holistic planning and development orientation a framework for the establishment of a National Housing Demand Database was approved and submitted to the provincial departments.

The main objective of the National Housing Demand Database is to establish a single integrated database from which all housing departments will draw housing need data. The establishment of the actual housing demands per development or region may warrant investigations into the possible enhancement of the definition of the housing needs and such will be subject to the normal policy decision-making process.

Allocations

No. The principles for the allocation of housing opportunities created through the various National Housing Programmes remain the unchanged. Applications are still considered on the basis of first came first served and in terms of compliance with the standard qualification criteria.

Allocations for housing opportunities in informal settlement upgrading projects differ in that the development is planned with and for the specific inhabitants of the relevant area.

The implementation of the National Housing Demand Database will further enhance the allocation process in that developers will be able to establish needs and invite prospective housing subsidy applicants to apply for subsidies where housing opportunities are available from the data base.

Lists

No. It is assumed that this sub-section of the questions relate to so called "waiting lists".

Although the introduction and maintenance of housing demand lists or ~waiting lists" is not prescribed by national policy, all such existing municipal and provincial lists were incorporated, or are in the process of being incorporated, into the National Housing Demand Data Base.

Qualification Criteria

No. The qualification criteria to obtain access to the housing assistance measures instituted by Government are not under review at this moment.

It is important to note that in addition to the general qualification criteria, each National Housing Programme is governed by programme specific criteria, tailored to achieve the goals of the relevant programmes. The current qualification criteria of the various National Housing

Programmes are regarded adequate and effective. However as policy evolves and new programmes are developed that warrant changes to the existing criteria, such will be subject to the normal policy decision-making process before approval and implementation.

PARLIAMENTARY QUESTION NO 918

FROM MR AC STEYN OF THE DEMOCRATIC ALLIANCE (DA): WRITTEN REPLY

DEPUTY MINISTER

1. PURPOSE

To submit a draft reply in respect of Parliamentary Question no 918 received from Mr. A C Steynof the Democratic Alliance (DA).

2. DETAILS OF THE QUESTION 918.

Mr A C Steyn (DA) to ask the Minister of Human Settlements:

1. Whether his Director-General signed a performance contract with him, if not, why not, if so, when;

2. whether all senior managers in his department signed performance contracts with the Director-General; if not, (a) which senior managers did not sign, (b) for what reason and (c) when will it be done; if so; on which date each senior manager sign a performance contract?

3. REPLY

1. The performance agreement of the Director General is awaiting endorsement by the Minister. This is to be filed with the Public Service Commission on the due date of 31 August 2009.

2. Only 33 of the 63 senior managers have concluded performance agreements with their respective supervisors. The Performance Agreements were concluded before 31 July 2009 as required.

(a) The following senior managers did not conclude the Performance Agreements for the year 2009/10:

1. Kraba KMS

2. Werner L M

3. Damane S F

4. Mngomezulu M

5. Mashabane T

6. Mthembu J T

7. Mbanjwa Z N

8. Thembani N

9. Ramovha T

10. Mirembe J

11. Muthige M

12. Mohale A

13. Mabalane I

14. Mokalapa P

15. Nxumalo S

16. Lelosa M

17. Ngxongo EM

18. Von Broembsen DJ

19. Jolobe LM

20. Bayat J

21. Arendse A

22. Maclean M

23. Jiyana W

24. Minnie J

25. Gaesale RK

26. Kabagambe K

27. Dlabantu M

28. Letsholonyane N

29. Maphisa M

30. Wallis J

(b) The reasons for non compliance vary. In most of the cases, the agreements are signed by one party and are awaiting concurrence by the supervisors. In other instances, there is no reason given.

(c) The Department issued communiqué to senior managers to give them a period of grace until 31 August 2009. This was a final reminder and the necessary correction steps will be taken for non-compliance.

4. RECOMMENDATION

It is recommended that you approve the draft reply to written question no. 918, should you concur with the content thereof.

QUESTION: 948

Ms B N Dambuza (ANC) to ask the Minister of Human Settlements:

Whether, with regard to an increased need for urban housing against the demographic trend towards urbanization and the growing scarcity in and increased cost of urban housing, his department is promoting the regulation and protection of sectional title holder, if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

REPLY:

The Sectional Titles Act, 1986 (Act No. 95 of 1986) ("the Sectional Titles Act") which regulate the sectional tittles industry is currently administered by the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform. The Department of Human Settlements is currently in the process of taking over certain provisions from the Sectional Titles Act. However, until this process has been finalized by Parliament, the Department does not have any legislative or Constitutional authority to promote the regulation and protection of sectional title holders since these functions currently still fall within the ambit of the mandate of the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform through the Sectional Tittles Regulatory Board established under the Act.

QUESTION 947

Ms B N Dambuza, MP (ANC) to ask the Minister of Human Settlements:

Whether his department has a programme on its own, or in collaboration with other departments, to provide housing for child-headed households; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

Reply

No. However, my Department is a process of finalising a new National Programme that will address the housing needs of orphans and vulnerable children. The programme will be finalised in consultation with the Department of Social Development.

The Programme will provide grant funding to registered care-givers to enhance their current houses by adding a room, or rooms as the case may be, to ensure that they provide adequate shelter to the orphans and/or vulnerable children placed under their care. The additional rooms could be attached to existing houses or could be constructed as stand alone units on the stand. It will also be possible to adjust the designs of new dwellings to be constructed as part of approved housing subsidy projects.

In the case of child-headed households living in the houses of their deceased guardians, the proposed Programme will provide similar relief. The difference being that the property will belong to the deceased estate of the guardians and not to the care-givers. Such properties will later be transferred to the children in terms of the law of succession and as instructed by the Master of the Supreme Court.

The Programme is subject to the conditions that care-givers must be legally appointed by the Department of Social Development and orphans and/or vulnerable children must be legally placed under the care of the legally registered care giver through a Court order.

The Department of Social Development will be required to certify the need for additional living space, administer the appointment of care-givers and the Court procedures to place children with care-givers. The said Department will also be required to ensure that the living space so provided, is utilised for the intended purpose.

My Department is in the process to consult the Sector Departments through the Directors-General Social Protection and Community Development Cluster to ensure all aspects of the proposed programme are supported where after the matter will be submitted for final approval.

In terms of planning, the new Programme will be implemented with effect from 1 April 2010.

QUESTION NO. 929

QUESTION

Dr CP Mulder (FF Plus), to ask the Minister of Human Settlements:

(1) With regard to each financial year since 2004 until the latest specified date for which information is available, (a) how many (i) developers and (ii) construction firms in (aa) each province and (bb) countrywide were responsible for the construction of Government housing projects and (b) what amounts for each of the projects has the Government paid out to each of the (i) developers and (ii) construction firms;

(2) whether the Government has used any of the (a) developers and (b) construction firms more than once; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, (i) which (aa) construction firms and (bb) developers were used for which projects and (ii) how much were they paid for each project;

(3) how many of the (a) developers and (b) construction firms (i) experienced financial problems or (ii) were declared insolvent prior to the completion of the Government housing projects;

(4) how many of the (a) developers and (b) construction firms who erected Government housing projects were involved in corruption and fraud in respect of the Government projects?

REPLY:

1 (a) Number of developers and construction firms.

(i) (aa)

Number of developers in each province

PROVINCE	Number of Developers
EASTERN CAPE	133
FREE STATE	206
GAUTENG	108
KWAZULU NATAL	111
LIMPOPO	209
MPUMALANGA	77
NORTHERN CAPE	47
NORTH WEST	90
WESTERN CAPE	143
TOTAL	1124

(i) (bb)

The number of developers country wide is 1124

(ii) (aa)

Number of Construction firms (Contractorsl Builders) in each province

PROVINCE	Number of Developers
EASTERN CAPE	8
FREE STATE	109
GAUTENG
KWAZULU NATAL	5
LIMPOPO	7
MPUMALANGA
NORTHERN CAPE	70
NORTH WEST	1
WESTERN CAPE	2
TOTAL	202

Gauteng and Mpumalanga have classified construction firms and municipalities in the Housing Subsidy System (HSS) data as developers.

(ii) (bb)

There are 202 construction firms country wide.

(b) The amounts paid by government for each project in respect of:

(i) Developers, refer to list A and D - Projects and payments

(ii) Construction firms, refer to list Band C - Projects and payment

2 (a) Yes, Government has used developers and

(b) Yes, Construction firms

(i) (aa) Lists Band C contain Construction firms used for each housing project: .

(bb) Lists A and D contain Developers used for each housing project

(ii) (aa) Amounts paid to construction firms for each housing project are as listed in lists Band C.

(bb) Amounts paid to developers for each housing project are contained in lists A and D.

3 (a) (i) As the Information Systems at the disposal of the Department does not incorporate information relating to the financial status of developers and construction firms, this information had to be requested from Provincial Human Settlements Departments who at this stage only two have indicated as follows:

Gauteng

Northern Cape: 11 contractors have experienced financial problems and did not complete the projects.

Further information regarding the other province will be provided as soon as it is received in full

(ii) The information regarding insolvency and liquidation of construction and development companies is not kept by the Department, therefore no information is available in this regard.

None

(b) (i) and (ii)

Information Systems at the disposal of the Department does not incorporate information relating to the financial status of developers and contraction firms. The Information was requested from Provincial Departments and they have not been able to provide such details.

4 (a) and (b) There were 289 developers and construction firms who were allegedly involved in corruption and fraud in respect of the Government projects.

QUESTION NUMBER 1163

Mr A C Steyn (DA) to ask the Minister of Human Settlements:

REPLY

Yes. The Department utilises the services of employment agencies in the acquisition of temporary workers.

(a) The Department makes use of agencies for the appointment of staff on a short term or temporary basis.

The Department also utilises temporary staff to fill positions while the recruitment for permanent staff is in progress. This ensures that service delivery on critical functions is not hampered while the recruitment process is in progress.

(b) (i) 1

(ii) 9

(iii) 15

2007/08 = 2.1% (419 posts)

2008/09 = 3.2% (457 posts)

(d) 2006/07 = R131 700

2007/08 = R757 855

2008/09 = R1 203 420

PARLIAMENTARY QUESTION NO 383

FROM MR AC STEYN OF THE DEMOCRATIC ALLIANCE (DA): WRITTEN REPLY

TO: THE MINISTER OF HUMAN SETTLEMENTS

1. Purpose

To submit a draft reply in respect of Parliamentary Question no 383, received from Mr. A C Steyn of the Democratic Alliance (DA).

2. Background

The Minister has received a Parliamentary Question (attached below) from a Member of Parliament. Mr. A C Steyn of the DA who enquires on the following issue/s:

Whether a function was held by his department to celebrate his appointment as minister; if so,

(1) (a) How much did the function cost?

(b) What is the breakdown of the cost?

(c) How many guests attended the function?

(2) Whether there were any related costs for the travel and accommodation of guests: if so,

(a) What were the costs? And

(b) What was the breakdown of these costs?

3. Discussion

The Department of Human Settlement did not hold any function to celebrate the appointment of the Minister and Deputy Ministers. Instead, an internal introductory meeting of the Minister and Deputy Minister to staff was held.

The introduction meeting of the Ministers cost the Department 1 (a) R25 433.40; (b) see (4) below; and (c) the staff complement of the Department of Human Settlement.

For question 2 (a) & (b), please refer to (4) below.

4. Financial implications

The introduction of Ministers to staff was done a minimal cost of R25433.40 for the hiring of chairs, decor and public sound address system.

5. Recommendation

It is recommended that the attached draft reply to Parliamentary Question 383 be noted and approved should you concur with the contents thereof.

Recommended/Not recommended

DR. CLARENCE TSHITEREKE

ACTING CHIEF DIRECTOR: COMMUNCATION SERVICES

DATE:

Supported/Not Supported

MR. NYAMEKO MBENGO

CHIEF DIRECTOR: FINANCIAL SERVICES DATE:

Supported/Not Supported

MR. MZIWONKE DLABANTU

DEPUTY DIRECTOR.(GENERAL: CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER DATE:

Approved/ Not Approved

MR. ITUMELENG KOTSOANE

DIRECTOR GENERAL: HUMAN SETTLEMENTS

DATE:

MR. MG SEXWALE

MINISTER: HUMAN SETTLEMENTS

DATE:

QUESTION NO: 1719

QUESTION

Mr A M Figlan (DA) to ask the Minister of Human Settlements:

(1) What amount was spent by his department on (a) hotel accommodation, (b) restaurant expenses and (c) travel costs (i) in the 2008-09 financial year and (ii) during the period 1 April 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available, for (aa) him, (bb) his deputy minister, (cc) specified officials of his department and (dd) any other specified individuals;

(2) Why did each individual use the specified accommodation in each case?

REPLY:

1(i) The amount spent by the Department of Human Settlements for the financial year 2008/09 is as follows:

(a) Hotel accommodation is R19, 989, 296.17.

(b) Restaurant expenses are R372, 729.06.

(ii) The amount spent by the Department of Human Settlements for the current financial year up to 20 October 2009 is as follows:

(aa) The former Minister and current Minister have spent R1, 310, 972.05 for hotel accommodation, R9,999.10 for restaurant expenses and R 2, 172, 125.98 on travel costs.

(bb) The Deputy Minister has spent R199, 994.55 for hotel accommodation, R0, 00. for restaurant expenses and R479, 467.16 for travel costs

(cc) The Director General has spent R655, 980. 52 for hotel accommodation, R29, 482.93 for restaurant expenses and R1, 084 372.37

(dd) The Deputy Director General's have spent R662, 650.29 for hotel accommodation, R7, 321.43 for restaurant expenses and R879,513.67 for travel costs.

2. The Minister and the Deputy Minister used the specified accommodation when attending Ministerial duties while each specified individuals have used the specified accommodation in the execution of their duties.

QUESTION NO. 1212

QUESTION

Mr B Steyn (DA) to ask the Minister the Minister of Human Settlements:

1. Whether, on appointment to office, the department purchased a new vehicle for the Deputy Minister, or did the Deputy Minister inherent an existing vehicle; if a new vehicle was purchased, (a) what make and model was that vehicle,(c) how much did the vehicle cost, (b) (i) what extras, above and beyond the vehicle's purchase price, were bought with the vehicle and (ii) at what cost and (d) what was the motivation for the purchase; if a new vehicle was not purchased (a) what was the make and model of the car inherited by the Deputy Minister and(b) how old is the vehicle?

REPLY:

The Deputy Minister inherited extsting vehicles: Audi A8 of 2006 and Mercedes Benz E-300 of 2007, used for Pretoria and Cape Town respectively.

The Audi A8 is due for disposal and a new BMW was ordered as a replacement vehicle. The particulars of the vehicle ordered are as follows;

(a) a BMW 530d of 2009.

(b) the price of the vehicle is R 576 444.14 VAT. Inclusive.

(ii) no cost for the extras as the vehicle was bought without extras.

QUESTION 877

DATE OF PUBLICATION IN INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: 21 AUGUST 2009; INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO. 10-2009

Ms A.T. Lovemore (DA) to ask the Minister of Human Settlements:

a) Whether, with reference to the need to conserve scarce water resources, an assessment of the ability of municipalities to supply treated water and waterborne sewerage systems to the population they serve on a sustainable basis is carried out before any new housing development is approved; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

b) whether, in instances where a municipality is unable to provide sustainable water and wastewater services to the population it serves, houses provided by the Government will, in future, be provided with rainwater collection systems, including guttering, the necessary pipes and storage tans; if not, (a) why not and (b) what alternative water supply facilities will be provided; if so, what are the relevant details;

c) whether, in instances where a municipality is unable to provide long-terms sustainable waterborne sewerage facilities to the population it serves, new housing developments will be provided with alternative ablution facilities; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

REPLY:

a) It is a prerequisite of the National Housing Programme that the approval of so-called "Greenfield" housing development projects are subject to the confirmation by the applicable services providers that the services [and amenities] planned for the residential development are sustainable and feasible and that it will be able to provide the required services on a sustainable basis. Therefore, in circumstances where developers are not able to provide the required services, the Members of the Executive Councils responsible for Human Settlements will not approve the project and/or township applications.

b) Effective and efficient resource-use is an issue wholly endorsed, not only by the Department, but by government as a whole. It should, however, be borne in mind that the limited fiscus coupled with the ever-increasing demand for shelter, demands that there be prioritization insofar as funding is concerned. While this does not negate the need to think creatively around the application of funding allocations set aside for shelter provision, it should be remembered that shelter provision – as set out in the Housing Act – is an incremental programme; more specifically, this allows for the provision of basic shelter which can be improved upon over time.

Where feasible and practicable, project developers may consider alternative water provision and sanitation systems, on condition that such alternative solutions are sustainable for the future, is acceptable to the community and complies with environmental sustainability requirements for the said areas.

c) The Ministerial National Norms and Standards in respect of Permanent Residential Structures that directs minimum standards for the housing subsidy programme, already provides for the use of alternative sanitation systems on condition that these sanitation systems are acceptable to the community, are environmentally acceptable and can be sustained. The nature of the alternative systems that might be considered will be determined at project level and will be directed by environmental considerations, geotechnical conditions, etc.

The deployment of such alternative systems is not necessarily linked to the capacity of the municipality to provide the required services. Alternative sanitation systems have become necessary to ensure that the country complies with the urgent need for environmental sustainable development, especially in regions where water is scarce commodity.

QUESTION NO: 1965

QUESTION

1965. Mr A C Steyn (DA) to ask the Minister of Human Settlements:

(2) whether any such credit cards are over their credit limit; if so, (a) whose credit cards are over the limit and (b) what is the reason for the credit cards exceeding the limit;

(3) whether any action has been taken against such persons for exceeding their credit card limits; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

REPLY:

1(a) The former Minister of Housing was issued with a government credit card, the current Minister of Human Settlements has not been issued with a government credit card.

(b) The Deputy Minister was issued with a government credit card.

(d) No other persons have been issued with a government credit card.

RELEVANT DETAILS

(i) Name	(ii) Job title	(iii) Credit Limit	(iv)Outstanding amount on 29/09/2009
Ms ZA Kota-Fredericks	Deputy Minister	R20,000.00	R14, 634. 47
Mr IW Kotsoane	Director General	R10,000.00	R10, 570.35

In addition to the above there is a total corporate limit of R50, 000.00 which should not be exceeded in a month. In this way where an individual card credit limit is reached special approval is given to exceed the individual limit on condition that the corporate limit is not exceeded. This is to avoid embarrassing circumstances, situations which may compromise security as well as during foreign trips.

(v) Monthly expenses since receiving the card:

Ms Z A Kota-Fredericks Deputy Minister

July 2009	R 319.98
August 2009	R1,037.60
September 2009	R14,634.47

Mr I W Kotsoane Director General Issued May 2006

May 2006	R 216.69
June 2006	R8,261.48
July 2006	R3,534.65
August 2006	R2,351.05
September 2006	R3,084.29
October 2006	R5,626.34
November 2006	R3,400.25
December 2006	R7,170.63
January 2007	R 751.63
February 2007	R2,182.95
March 2007	R1,593.28
April 2007	R7,720.09
May 2007	R1,942.70
June 2007	R4,881.20
July 2007	R3,291.00
August 2007	R 388.68
September 2007	R6,048.57
October 2007	R4,609.79
November 2007	R 978.00
December 2007	R10,004.56
January 2008	R0.00
February 2008	R2,946.60
March 2008	R7,060.04
April 2008	R 337.00
May 2008	R3,519.25
June 2008	R1,950.00
July 2008	R5,307.74
August 2008	R4,469.85
September 2008	R11,477.20
October 2008	R2,250.59
November 2008	R6,152.50
December 2008	R8,475.80
January 2009	R10,082.50
February 2009	R15,749.60
March 2009	R2,318.20
April 2009	R5,937.00
May 2009	R8,549.00
June 2009	R9,285.15
July 2009	R6,451.91
August 2009	R6,760.27
September 2009	R10,570.35

(vi) A Corporate credit card was issued to these officials for official purposes and with the approval of the Director-General in terms of the Cabinet decision on the 4th of November 1998.

(vii) Official domestic and overseas transport;

Official domestic and overseas accommodation;

Official domestic and overseas telephone expenditure;

International cellular phone rental expenditure;

International conference and registration fees;

Parking fees;

Tollgate fees;

Domestic and overseas subsistence; and

Official personal entertainment

2. (a)The Director General's credit card has exceeded the individual credit

card limit although the corporate limit has not been exceeded

(b) The Director General had to use the credit card to pay for a special

meeting he had with the provincial Heads of Departments.

3. The Director General has arranged to settle the amount.

QUESTION NO. 2122

QUESTION

Dr LL Bosman (DA), to ask the Minister of Human Settlements:

(1) Whether his department has a record of the (a) number and (b) details of the beneficiaries that have benefited from the Farm Worker and Occupier Housing Assistance programme; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW2790E

REPLY:

1 (a) Yes, 1 119 beneficiaries have benefited from Farm Worker related housing assistance.

(b) The details of the beneficiaries are available and can be obtained from Mr. Johan Minnie on the telephone number 012 421 1778 within our Department.

QUESTION NO: 573

PARLAMENTARY QUESTION NO NW637E: INCIDENCE OF BLOCKED PROJECTS AND PROGRESS MADE IN UNBLOCKING THEM

REFERENCE: BP/PQ/NW637E

MINISTER

1. PURPOSE

To obtain approval of the draft reply to parliamentary question NW637E

2. DETAILS OF THE QUESTION

Mr A C Steyn (DA) to ask the Minister of Human Settlements:

1. Whether any housing projects have been blocked in each province during each of the past five (5) years up to the latest specified date for which information is available.

If so:

(a) how many government housing projects were blocked; and. (b) for each project that has been blocked:

(i) where is situated?

(ii) when was it blocked?

(iii) why was it blocked?

(iv) how much was spent on the project?

2. Whether these projects are still blocked?

If so, why?

If not:

(a) when was the project; and,

(b) when was or will it be completed?

3. Discussion

The relevant question was received by the Department on Monday, 13 July 2009. The information required to provide Mr Steyn with a comprehensive reply is not readily available in the Department and needs to be obtained from and verified by Provinces.

The question also requires sourcing additional historical information from the Provincial Human Settlement Departments which is no longer contained in the Housing Subsidy System (HSS), such as the following:

Identification of projects that have been blocked during the past five years, but have since been unblocked;
to establish the various reasons for the blockages; and,
to establish the dates on which the projects were unblocked, and have since been completed or are projected to be completed.

4. RECOMMENDATION

In view of the above it is recommended that Hon. Steyn be provided with a comprehensive reply once all the information has been obtained from the Provinces, and that an interim reply be provided as follows:

The information required to provide Mr Steyn with a comprehensive reply is not readily available in the Department and needs to be obtained from and verified by Provinces. A detailed response will be tabled once all the required information has been obtained and verified with the nine Provincial Human Settlement Departments.

QUESTION NO.: 110

Mr A C Steyn (DA) to ask the Minister of Housing:

(1) What is the current status of (a) Servcon, (b) Thubelisha and (c) the proposed Housing Development Agency;

(2) whether her department has set any timelines with regard to the proposed Housing Development Agency; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

Reply:

1. (a) Servcon: The Closure Plan of Servcon has been approved. As such the business of Servcon is currently being wound up. The Department has constituted a Steering Committee comprising of officials from the National Departments of Housing, Public Service & Administration and National Treasury to facilitate the closure process in consultation with the Board. The Steering Committee meets regularly to assess progress and report to the Board. All business pertaining to the Service Level Agreements with Provincial Housing Departments will be finalised before final closure of the entity.

(b) Thubelisha: The Closure Plan of Thubelisha has been approved. As such the business of Thubelisha is currently being wound up. The Department has constituted a Steering Committee comprising of officials from the National Departments of Housing, Public Service & Administration and National Treasury to facilitate the closure process in consultation with the Board. The Steering Committee meets regularly to assess progress and report to the Board.

(c) HDA: The HDA Board was constituted in February 2009 and the positions of the CEO and CFO were also filled in February 2009.

2. Yes there are set timelines. All deliverables, as set out in the project implementation plan, have been achieved within and earlier than the set timeframe.

ANNEXURE A: HDA ESTABLSIHMENT PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION PLAN:

Item Description	Deliverable	Indicator	Time	Achieved
Business Case	Finalise the preparation of the Business case and the consultative processes with key stakeholders	Business Case prepared and approved	February 2008	Done
Approval of the Housing Development Agency Bill	Seek approval of the Housing Development Agency Bill	Housing Development Agency Bill approved	March 2008	Done
Briefing of the Portfolio Committee on Bill and Business Case	Brief the Portfolio Committee on Bill and Business Case and Obtain approval for Business Case	Portfolio Committee briefed of the Business Case and Bill	April 2008	Done
Submitting the Bill and Business Case to Cabinet	Submit Bill and Business Case to Cabinet - Draft SPV Bill OR Revised Housing Amendment Bill; - A Bill which creates a new entity; and - The Publication of the Bill prior to its introduction in Parliament	Bill submitted to Cabinet	July 2008	Done
Publication of the Bill in the Gazette	Bill published in Gazette for comment (A minimum of 30 days must be allowed for public comment. Engage DPLG regarding the Municipal Systems Act consultation processes).	Bill published in the Gazette	September 2008	Done
Resubmission of the Bill to Minister and Cabinet	Resubmit revised Bill to Minister and Cabinet for Approval	Bill resubmitted to Minister and Cabinet for approval	October 2008	Done
State Law Advisors	Refer Bill to Sate Law Advisors for Certification (6 weeks allowed for State Law Advisors)	Bill referred to State Law Advisors	October 2008	Done
Translation of the Bill	Bill returned to Department and submitted for translation	Translated Bill returned to the Department	November 2008	Done
Rule 159/241 Notice	Rule 159/241 Notice published in the Gazette	Rule 159/241 Notice published in the gazette	November 2008	Done
National Assembly and Chair of the NCOP	Bill and Copy of Notice to Speaker of National Assembly (NA) and Chair of the National Council of Provinces (NCOP)	Bill and Copy of Notice submitted to the Speaker of National Assembly and Chair of the NCOP	November 2008	Done
Bill introduced to parliament	Introduction of the Bill to Parliament Bill introduced in Parliament	Bill introduced to Parliament	November 2008	Done
Printing of the Bill	Bill printed and tagged	Bill printed and tagged	November 2008	Done
Portfolio Committee Briefing	Brief Portfolio Committee	Portfolio Committee briefed	November 2008	Done
Passing of the Bill by National Assembly	Deliberation and passing of Bill by NA	Bill deliberated and passed by the NA	January 2009	Done
NCOP and Select Committee Briefing	Bill to NCOP and briefing of Select Committee	Bill submitted to NCOP and Select Committee briefed	February 2009	Done
Declaration and passing of the Bill by the NCOP	Declaration and passing of Bill by NCOP	Bill declared and passed by the NCOP	February 2009	Done
Approval and promulgation of the Act	Bill signed by President and promulgated	Signed and Approved Bill	February 2009	Done
Establishment of the Legal Entity	Establish Legal Entity	Legal Entity established	March 2009	Done
Criteria and advertising for Board Nominations	Develop criteria & Advertise for Board nomination	Criteria for Board Nominations developed	February 2009	Done
Criteria and Advertising for CEO position	Develop Criteria & Advertise for CEO appointment by the Board	Criteria for CEO appointment developed	February 2009	Done
Criteria and Advertising for CFO position	Develop Criteria & Advertise for CFO appointment by the Board	Criteria for CFO appointment developed	February 2009	Done

QUESTION NO 86

Mr A C Steyn (DA) to ask the Minister of Housing:

(1) Whether her department placed an advertisement (a) in newspapers, (b) in magazines, (c) on radio and (d) on television during the period 1 January 2008 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, in each case, (i) in which (aa) newspapers, (bb) magazines, (ii) on which (aa) radio stations and (bb) television stations did it appear and (iii) what was the (aa) cost and (bb) purpose of placing the advertisement;

(2) whether advertising from her department will be curtailed from the day on which the election is declared to the day on which the results of the election are determined; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

Reply

Communications is part of the responsibility of delivery. The Department of Housing's communication campaign has been on-going and is independent of election process. As such, it will continue in each financial year as the need to educate the public about the criteria for benefiting from the national housing programme and options available for beneficiaries will surely exist beyond the elections.

QUESTION 1732

Question 1732: Mr E W Trent (DA) to ask the Minister of Housing:

1. In respect of each of the past five years up to the latest specified date for which information is available, (a) how many houses have been built with funds allocated in terms of the capital subsidy grant scheme in the municipalities of (i) Makana

QUESTION 1732

Question 1732: Mr E W Trent (DA) to ask the Minister of Housing:

- 1. In respect of each of the past five years up to the latest specified date for which information is available, (a) how many houses have been built with funds allocated in terms of the capital subsidy grant scheme in the municipalities of (i) Makana and (ii) Vollanlie and (b) what is the current backlog in housing delivery in each case:
  2. Whether a survey has been conducted to establish the number of defective houses that have been built; if not, why not, if so, how many houses were found to be defective;

3. Whether her department will repair the defective houses; if not, why not; if so,

4. Whether she will take any action against the responsible contractors; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

The information will be provided to the Honourable Member as soon as it is available.

QUESTION NO.: 1705

Mr A C Steyn, DA to ask the Minister of Housing:

1. In respect of the 2006-07 and 2007-08 annual rep

QUESTION NO.: 1705

Mr A C Steyn, DA to ask the Minister of Housing:

1. In respect of the 2006-07 and 2007-08 annual reports of her Department and the annual reports of each statutory and other entities reporting to her,

(a) what was the (i) budgeted cost, (ii) actual cost and (iii) unit cost of each annual report;

(b) how many copies of each were (i) produced and (ii) distributed?

Reply:

The information will be provided to the Honourable Member as soon as it is available.

QUESTION No. 30

Mr A C Steyn (DA) to ask the Minister of Housing:

Whether her department commissioned a certain television show (name and details furnished); if not, who commissioned this show; if so, (a) what is the purpose of commissioning the show, (b) how much (i) is each television channel paid for broadcasting the series and (ii) has been (aa) budgeted and (bb) spent on this show, (c) from which budget was this amount allocated and (d) what is the running period of the show?

Reply

In view of the fact that the Honourable Member lodged an official complaint with the Public Protector on this matter, I am unable to provide him with the information until the investigation is completed.

It must be pointed out for the record that the programme has been running for the last 18 months. It is interesting that the conscientious member is only now complaining about it.

24 December 2009 - Question:Minister of Home Affairs

MPs to ask the Minister of Home Affairs

Source
Link

Reply:

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

FOR WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION 1673

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 16 October 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 22 OF 2009

Mr M Mnqasela (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

Whether, since her appointment in May 2009 any renovations or alterations were done at state owned and private residences of her, her deputy minister or any other specified official of her department; if so, (a) where she and the occupants of each such residence were accommodated during the renovations and (b) at what cost to his department in each case?

NW2129E

REPLY

Please, refer the question to the Minister of Public Works.

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

FOR WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION 1670

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 16 October 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 22 OF 2009

Mr J J Mc Gluwa (ID) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

Whether the forensic audit into the "Who am I online" tender process has been completed; if not, why not; if so, (a) what has been the reason for the delay in making the report of the audit available and (b) when will the report be made available?

NW2126E

REPLY

No. The reason is that I do not have the report. The Auditors have not, yet, given it to us.

QUESTION 547

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 10 July 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 6 of 2009

Mrs J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) Whether her department makes use of private security firms; if so, how much money was spent on such firms in 2008;

(3) why is there a need for her department to use a private security firm as opposed to state security?

NW611E

REPLY

(1) Yes. A total of R37,560,145.76 was spent on private security firms in the 2008/09 financial year.

(2) (a) Yes. The Department of Home Affairs signed contracts with 3 private security firms.

(b) The contracts were signed with: (i) Khulani Fidelity, (ii) Double Barrel Security and (iii) Night Watchers Security. However, the contract with Night Watchers Security was terminated due to its non-performance and non-compliance with the Service Level Agreement which was signed. Approval was also granted to Departmental offices in the North West and Free State Provinces to make use of other private security firms on a quotation basis. No formal contracts were signed with these firms. These firms are as follows:

· Atlie Project

· Thulanang Security Services

· MBS Security

· SSE Security Services

· Davidson Security Services

· Molefe Security Services

· SPE Security Services

· Motheo Security Services

· Fidelity Springbok

· Fidelity Cash Security

· Double Barrel Security

· G4 S Cash Services

(c) Due to a current lack of capacity regarding security officers employed in the Department, the utilisation of the private security firms are to provide sufficient guarding services of all the premises of the Department of Home Affairs. Khulani Fidelity also provides cash-in-transit services to the Department.

(d) A total of R37,560,145.76 were paid to private security firms which rendered services to the Department of Home Affairs. The amounts paid to each private security firm are as follows:

· In the North West and Free State Provinces:

- Atlie Project : R372,696.39

- Thulanang Security Services : R293,320.00

- MBS Security : R312,796.94

- SSE Security Services : R741,137.43

- Molefe Security Services : R19,502.25

- Motheo Security Services : R257,101.12

- Fidelity Cash : R2,334.72

- Fidelity Springbok : R63,758.97

- G4 S Cash Services : R11,185.13

TOTAL R2,073,832.95

· At the Department's Head Office and other Provinces:

- Double Barrel Security : R1,653,566.07

- Khulani Fidelity : R33,832,746.74

TOTAL R35,486,312.81

(3) The utilisation of private security companies is necessitated by the fact that the Department currently does not have the internal capacity to provide security, at all of its offices, in all 9 Provinces. Based on different appraisals and audits which have been conducted by both the National Intelligence Agency (NIA) and the South African Police Service (SAPS), it is more cost effective, at this point in time, for the Department to outsource physical security.

QUESTION 2059

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Monday, 2 November 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 26 OF 2009

Mrs J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) What measures will her department implement at all ports of entry to deal with the issue of human trafficking;

(2) whether officials will receive training on how to identify behaviour common to criminal activities; if not, why not; if so, (a) when will training (i) commence and (ii) conclude and (b) how many officials will be trained?

NW2713E

REPLY

(1) The Department is in the process of establishing Inspectorate Units at the main Ports of Entry. An Inspectorate Unit is, currently, established at the O. R. Tambo International Airport. The Department of Home Affairs, also, forms part of the National Task Team on Human Trafficking, which is led by the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA). Provincial Task Teams, comprising the Department of Home Affairs, the South African Police, the Department of Social Services, the Department of Health, and the NPA, have been established in all nine Provinces.

(2) Yes. The Department, in conjunction with the International Organisation for Migration (IOM), has, already, commenced a training programme for immigration officials on combating, and to sensitize staff to the issue of Human Trafficking. A curriculum on Human Trafficking is, also, being developed, which includes training on how to detect common criminal behaviour, in terms of departmental legislation, and to detect cases of trafficking for referral to the appropriate law enforcement authorities, and the support organizations for victims. The Department, in conjunction with the IOM, is, also, currently, training facilitators, and assessors within the Department's Directorates: Central Law Enforcement and Inspectorate, respectively, to roll out training to officials on implementation of the Prevention and Combating of Trafficking in Persons Bill, once, it has been enacted.

(2)(a)(i) – (ii) & (b)

The dates on which the training was offered, as well as, the number of officials involved, are listed below:

· 24 to 28 August 2009: Facilitators course - 15 officials

· 07 to 11 September 2009: Assessors course - 8 officials

· 05 to 09 October 2009: Advance course – 7 officials

The next training for moderators will be from 09 to 11 November 2009 and 10 officials will be attending.

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

FOR WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION 1718

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 16 October 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 22 OF 2009

Mr M Mnqasela (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) What amount was spent by her department on (a) hotel accommodation, (b) restaurant expenses and (c) travel costs (i) in the 2008-09 financial year and (ii) during the period 1 April 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available, for (aa) her,
(bb) her deputy minister, (cc) specified officials of her department and (dd) any other specified individuals;

(2) why did each individual use the specified accommodation in each case?

NW2210E

REPLY

The costs were according to the rules, and the Ministerial Handbook.

QUESTION 164

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Tuesday, 06 October 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 19 OF 2009

Ms H N Makhuba (IFP) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) How many non-attorney Immigration Practitioners are registered with her department;

(2) whether any Immigration Practitioners' Certificates have been withdrawn on disciplinary or other grounds; if so, what are the relevant details;

(3) whether disciplinary action is currently pending against any Immigration Practitioners; if so, what are the relevant details;

(4) whether her department has taken any measures to prevent and stop unregistered street agents from operating around regional offices; if not, why not; if so, (a) what measures and (b) what are the further relevant details?

NO1877E

REPLY:

(1) A total of three hundred and seventy eight (378) Immigration Practitioners are registered with the Department of Home Affairs. Practising Attorneys do not need to register as Immigration Practitioners with the Department of Home Affairs.

(2) No. The Department has not withdrawn any Immigration Practitioners' Certificates on disciplinary or other grounds.

(3) No. There is currently no disciplinary action pending against any Immigration Practitioners.

(4)(a) & (b) Yes, but to a limited extent. The Department of Home Affairs does not have the necessary jurisdiction to control, or regulate the operating of any business in the streets, surrounding its premises, as this does not fall within the mandate of the Department. However, all offices of the Department are restrained from accepting any applications from street agents. All applications submitted by registered Immigration Practitioners must be accompanied by a copy of the practitioner's Identity Document, and his, or her registration certificate.

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

FOR WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION 1896

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 23 October 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 24 OF 2009

Mr M J Ellis (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) Whether (a) she, (b) her deputy minister, (c) any specified officials and (d) any other persons have been issued with a government or official credit card; if so, what are the relevant details for her, her deputy minister and each holder of a credit card in respect of the (i) name,
(ii) job title, (iii) credit limit, (iv) outstanding amount as at the latest specified date for which information is available, (v) monthly expenses incurred for each month since receiving the credit card, (vi) reason for such persons being issued with a credit card and (vii) uses that such a credit card is intended for;

(2) whether any such credit cards are over their credit limit; if so, (a) whose credit cards are over the limit and (b) what is the reason for the credit cards exceeding the limit;

(3) whether any action has been taken against such persons for exceeding their credit card limits; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

NW2458E

REPLY

(1)(a) & (b) The information is provided in the table below:

(i)

Person issued to

(ii)

Job title

(iii)

Credit limit

(iv)

Outstanding amount

(v)

Monthly expenses

(vi)

Reasons for issue

(vii)

Uses intended for

Dr N C Dlamini-Zuma

Minister

R20,000.00

To date there is no expenditure charged to the credit card account

As per a Cabinet decision dated
4 November 1998 – to defray subsistence and travel expenses

For purposes of official transport, accommodation and subsistence

Mr M K N Gigaba

Deputy Minister

R20,000.00

Monthly expenses range from R1674,00 to R5606.00

As per a Cabinet decision dated
4 November 1998 – to defray subsistence and travel expenses

For purposes of official transport, accommodation and subsistence

(1)(c) & (d) No other officials have been issued with such cards.

(2)(a) & (b) None of the two credit cards are over the limit.

(3) No action necessary as no credit cards are over the limit.

QUESTION 1592

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 9 October 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 20 OF 2009

Mrs J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) Whether her department organised or hosted (a) an imbizo, (b) a seminar, (c) conference and (d) any other function during the period
1 January 2006 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if so, (i) on what date, (ii) what was the total amount spent on each, (iii) what is the breakdown of the cost in each case and (iv) how many guests attended in each case;

(2) whether there were any related costs for the travel and accommodation of guests for each of the events; if so, in each case, (a) what were the costs and (b) what was the breakdown of these costs;

(3) whether any member of the Cabinet was present at any of these events; if so, (a) who, (b) in what capacity and (c) why?

NW1998E

REPLY

(1)(2)(3) The expenditure of these events forms part of the overall expenditure

of the Department which is found in the Department's reports.

QUESTION 1299

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 18 September 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 17 OF 2009

Mrs J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) Whether the official at her department's office in Pinetown accused of allegedly tearing up the application for an identity document of a certain person (name furnished) has been identified; if not, why not; if so, who is the person;

(2) whether any action has been taken against this official; if not, why not; if so, what action;

(3) whether she has sent a delegation to investigate the situation at that office of her department; if not, why not; if so, what (a) are the outcomes of the investigation and (b) action is being taken there;

(4) whether she has taken any steps to change the public's perception and experience of her department as uncaring, unhelpful and unfriendly public servants; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

NW1646E

REPLY

(1) Yes. After the investigation, she was charged for misconduct.

(2) Yes. The official was suspended, and a disciplinary hearing was held on 25 September 2009. On request of the official, as well as, the number of witnesses to be cross-examined, the hearing was postponed, and will resume on 15 to 18 October 2009.

(3) Yes. A delegation was sent to the Pinetown Office of the Department, and an investigation was conducted.

(3)(a) The outcome of the investigation was that the head of the office in Pinetown, as well as, the offender,

be charged with misconduct.

(3)(b) Both officials in question were charged with misconduct. Their disciplinary hearings took place on 23 and 25 September 2009, respectively. Following requested postponement, as earlier, alluded to in (2), possible action is awaited on resumption of the hearing on 15 to 18 October 2009.

(4) Yes. The following measures were put in place:

· The re-enforced wearing of nametags by all officials of the Department.

· On Talk Show on Radio 702, every first Thursday of every month, between 21:00 and 22:00, where we interact with members of the public.

· We are, also, trying to enhance the Batho Pele principles in our offices.

· Plans are underway to start training for the front line office staff.

· Managers' visibility in all offices is made a pre-condition.

QUESTION 2128

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 6 November 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 27 OF 2009

Mr E J Marais (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) Whether any measures are in place to ensure that passenger's basic human rights are not violated during luggage searches at airports; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

(2) whether custom officials receive training to ensure that passenger's dignity and right to privacy are not violated during these searches at airports; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

(3) whether any processes are in place for passengers who feel that their rights have been violated during these searches at national airports to file complaints; if not, why not; if so, (a) what are the relevant details and (b) how many of such complaints were filed?

NW2802E

REPLY

(1) to (3) It is suggested that the Honourable Member directs this Question to the Ministers of Finance, and Police, as searching of passengers and, or their luggage, at airports is not the function of the Department, nor of the Customs.

QUESTION 1921

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 23 October 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 24 OF 2009

Mr G R Krumbock (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) Whether there have been any incidents of vehicles crashing through the Maseru Bridge port of entry in the past five years; if so, how many;

(2) whether any of these incidents were accompanied by violence including the discharge of firearms; if so, what are the relevant details;

(3) whether there are any vehicle arrester spikes or systems in place to prevent such incidents; if not, why not;

(4) whether she intends installing such a system; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

NW2485E

REPLY

(1) to (4) The questions posed, refer to Border Control, and not Immigration Control. It is suggested that the Honourable Member directs his request, for the specific information, to the Minister of Finance, as the South African Revenue Service (SARS) is, currently, chairing the Border Control Operational Co-ordinating Committee (BCOCC).

QUESTION 1919

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 23 October 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 24 OF 2009

Mr G R Krumbock (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

What (a) period of time elapsed within which she found that the controls at the Beit Bridge port of entry was not adequate, (b) were the reasons for proper controls not being implemented from inception and (c) is the total loss of revenue to the State that resulted over this period?

NW2483E

REPLY

(a) It came to my attention during my fact finding mission when I was appointed Minister of Home Affairs.

(b) A proper management system was not in place at the Beit Bridge port of entry, due to capacity constraints.

QUESTION 524

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 10 July 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 6 of 2009

Mrs J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

Whether any function was organised to mark the occasion of the delivery of her budget vote in 2009; if so, (a) what total amount was spent on this function, (b) from which budget was the money allocated, (c) what amount was spent on (i) food and refreshments,
(ii) venue, (iii) entertainment, (iv) staff and (v) transport and (d) how many persons were invited to attend this function?

NW588E

REPLY

(1)(a)(b) Yes. The total amount spent on the function was R52 365.30, and it was taken

out of the Minister's budget.

(c)(i) Money spent on food was R50 000.00, and refreshments (non-alcoholic drinks)

was R2 365.30.

(ii) The venue hire is included in the above-mentioned amount.

(iii)(iv)(v) No money was spent on entertainment, staff, and transport.

(d) About 100 persons were invited from a range of stakeholders, namely, the

Portfolio Committee, Refugees Appeal Board, Standing Committee, Department of Home Affairs (DHA) agencies (IEC,FPB, and GPW), Disabled persons, DHA management, Members of Parliament, etc. However, a total of 200 persons attended, hence the inflated amount on food.

QUESTION 190

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 19 June 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 3 of 2009

Ms J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

How many vacancies were there as at 30 April 2009 for (a) counter staff, (b) supervisors and (c) management at each office in Mpumalanga?

NW236E

REPLY

Acronyms: RO: Regional Office

DO: District Office

BP: Border Post

The number of vacant posts relating to Civic Services at each office in the Mpumalanga Province as at 30 April 2009 – as per the table below:


OFFICE	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGEMENT	TOTAL
RO Nelspruit	11	7	6	24
DO Barberton	2	0	0	2
DO Hazyview	3	1	0	4
DO Mapulaneng	7	0	0	7
DO Komatipoort	1	2	0	3
DO Mashishing (Lydenburg)	5	2	1	8
DO Mhlala	8	2	0	10
DO Nkomazi	3	2	0	5
DO White River (Nsikazi)	7	0	0	7
RO Ermelo	4	4	0	8
DO Bethal	2	1	1	4
PSP Standerton	0	0	0	0
DO Eerstehoek	4	1	0	5
DO Piet Retief	4	1	1	6
DO Secunda	8	0	2	10
RO Witbank	4	3	3	10

OFFICE	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGEMENT	TOTAL

DO Belfast	0	0	0	0
DO Kwa-Mhlanga	3	2	0	5
DO Middelburg (MP)	6	1	0	7
DO Mkobolo (Kwaggafontein)	3	0	0	3
DO Siyabuswa	6	0	0	6
TOTAL	91	29	14	134

The number of vacant posts relating to Immigration Services at each office in the Mpumalanga Province as at 30 April 2009 – as per the table below:

OFFICE	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGEMENT	TOTAL
RO Nelspruit	3	2	1	6
DO Barberton	1	1	0	2
DO Hazyview	0	0	0	0
DO Mapulaneng	0	0	0	0
DO Komatipoort	0	0	0	0
DO Mashishing (Lydenburg)	0	0	0	0
DO Mhlala	0	0	0	0
DO Nkomazi	0	0	0	0
DO White River (Nsikazi)	0	0	0	0
BP Mananga	8	0	0	8
BP Lebombo	45	2	1	48
BP Josefdal	1	0	0	1
BP Jeppesreff	9	0	0	9
BP Kruger Mpumalanga	6	1	0	7
RO Ermelo	2	1	1	4
DO Bethal	2	1	0	3
PSP Standerton	0	0	0	0
DO Eerstehoek	2	0	0	2
DO Piet Retief	3	0	0	3
DO Secunda	2	0	0	2
BP Oshoek	19	3	1	23
BP Neston	3	1	0	4
BP Mahamba	12	1	0	13
BP Emahlathini	6	2	0	8

OFFICE	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGEMENT	TOTAL
RO Witbank	2	2	0	4
DO Belfast	0	0	0	0
DO Kwa-Mhlanga	0	0	0	0
DO Middelburg (MP)	0	0	0	0
DO Mkobolo (Kwaggafontein)	0	0	0	0
DO Siyabuswa	5	0	0	5
TOTAL	131	17	4	152

* Please note that all of the above-mentioned vacancies are funded in the current financial year i.e. 2009/10.

QUESTION 191

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 19 June 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 3 of 2009

Ms J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

How many vacancies were there as at 30 April 2009 for (a) counter staff, (b) supervisors and (c) management at each office in North West?

NW237E

REPLY

Acronyms: RO: Regional Office

DO: District Office

BP: Border Post

The number of vacant posts relating to Civic Services at each office in the North West Province as at 30 April 2009 – as per the table below:

OFFICE	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGEMENT	TOTAL
RO Mmabatho	0	3	3	6
DO Atamelang	5	2	0	7
DO Itsoseng	0	0	0	0
DO Lehurutshe	5	2	0	7
DO Lichtenburg	7	2	0	9
DO Molopo	5	0	0	5
DO Ganyesa	4	2	0	6
DO Taung	9	0	0	9
DO Vryburg	5	0	1	6
RO Klerksdorp	21	0	1	22
DO Potchefstroom	7	1	0	8
DO Wolmaransstad	3	1	0	4
RO Rustenburg (Tlhabane)	17	6	1	24
DO Brits	4	2	0	6
DO Madikwe	5	1	0	6
DO Mankwe	5	2	0	7
DO Garankuwa	13	0	0	13

OFFICE	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGEMENT	TOTAL
DO Mabopane	7	0	0	7
DO Temba	7	1	0	8
TOTAL	129	25	6	160

The number of vacant posts relating to Immigration Services at each office in the North West Province as at 30 April 2009 – as per the table below:

OFFICE	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGEMENT	TOTAL
RO Mmabatho	0	3	1	4
DO Atamelang	0	0	0	0
DO Itsoseng	0	0	0	0
DO Lehurutshe	0	0	0	0
DO Lichtenburg	0	0	0	0
DO Molopo	0	0	0	0
DO Ganyesa	1	0	0	1
DO Taung	0	0	0	0
DO Vryburg	0	0	0	0
BP Brey	4	0	0	4
BP Derdepoort	4	1	0	5
BP Kopfontein	11	3	0	14
BP Magobistad	3	0	0	3
BP Mokopong	3	1	0	4
BP Ramatlabama	9	0	0	9
BP Skilpadhek	7	0	0	7
BP Swartkopfontein	7	0	0	7
RO Klerksdorp	4	2	0	6
DO Potchefstroom	1	1	0	2
DO Wolmaransstad	0	0	0	0
RO Rustenburg (Tlhabane)	8	0	1	9
DO Brits	0	0	0	0
DO Madikwe	0	0	0	0
DO Mankwe	0	0	0	0
DO Garankuwa	0	0	0	0
DO Mabopane	0	0	0	0
DO Temba	2	0	0	2
TOTAL	64	11	2	77

* Please note that all the vacancies mentioned above are funded for the current financial year i.e. 2009/10.

QUESTION 192

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 19 June 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 3 of 2009

Ms J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

How many vacancies were there as at 30 April 2009 for (a) counter staff, (b) supervisors and (c) management at each office in the Northern Cape?

NW238E

REPLY

Acronyms: RO: Regional Office

DO: District Office

BP: Border Post

The number of vacant posts relating to Civic Services at each office in the Northern Cape Province as at 30 April 2009 – as per the table below:

OFFICE	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGEMENT	TOTAL
RO Springbok	12	7	1	20
DO De Aar	1	1	0	2
DO Prieska	0	1	0	1
RO Upington	6	3	0	9
DO Kuruman	4	1	3	8
DO Postmansburg	0	2	0	2
RO Kimberley	17	6	2	25
DO Calvinia	1	3	0	4
DO Pampierstad	1	0	0	1
DO Jan Kempdorp	2	0	0	2
TOTAL	44	24	6	74

The number of vacant posts relating to Immigration Services at each office in the Northern Cape Province as at 30 April 2009 – as per the table below:

OFFICE	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGEMENT	TOTAL
RO Springbok	1	0	1	2
DO De Aar	1	1	0	2
DO Prieska	0	0	0	0
RO Upington	5	2	0	7
DO Kuruman	3	1	0	4
DO Postmansburg	0	0	0	0
BP Twee Riviersnek	1	0	0	1
BP Rietfontein	1	0	0	1
BP Noenieput	2	1	0	3
BP Nakop	7	1	0	8
BP Middleputs	1	1	0	2
BP Mccarthy's Rust	2	1	0	3
BP Gemsbok	2	0	0	2
RO Kimberley	0	3	1	4
DO Calvinia	0	0	0	0
BP Sindelingsdrift	3	1	0	4
Bp Onseepkans	1	1	0	2
BP Alexanderbay	3	1	0	4
DO Pampierstad	0	0	0	0
DO Jan Kempdorp	0	0	0	0
TOTAL	33	14	2	49

* Please note that all vacancies mentioned above are funded for the current financial year i.e. 2009/10.

QUESTION 193

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 19 June 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 3 of 2009

Mr M Mnqasela (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

How many vacancies were there as at 30 April 2009 for (a) counter staff, (b) supervisors and (c) management at each office in the Free State?

NW239E

REPLY

Acronyms: RO: Regional Office

DO: District Office

BP: Border Post

The number of vacant posts relating to Civic Services at each office in the Free State Province as at 30 April 2009 – as per the table below:

OFFICE	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGEMENT	TOTAL
RO Bloemfontein	18	3	2	23
DO Botshabelo	3	0	0	3
DO Thaba Nchu	0	0	0	0
DO Koffiefontein	0	0	0	0
DO Zastron	3	0	0	3
RO Welkom	8	3	2	13
DO Bultfontein	0	0	0	0
DO Kroonstad	8	0	0	8
RO Phuthaditjhaba	9	2	1	12
DO Bethlehem	6	1	0	7
DO Harrismith	2	0	0	2
DO Sasolburg	1	0	0	1
TOTAL	58	9	5	72

The number of vacant posts relating to Immigration Services at each office in the Free State Province as at 30 April 2009 – as per the table below:

OFFICE	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGEMENT	TOTAL
RO Bloemfontein	0	4	1	5
DO Botshabelo	1	1	0	2
DO Thaba Nchu	0	0	0	0
DO Koffiefontein	0	0	0	0
BP Maserubridge	4	0	1	5
BP Ficksburg	1	3	1	5
BP Caledonspoort	1	1	0	2
DO Zastron	0	0	0	0
RO Welkom	1	1	1	3
DO Bultfontein	0	0	0	0
DO Kroonstad	1	0	0	1
RO Phuthaditjhaba	0	0	1	1
DO Bethlehem	1	0	0	1
DO Harrismith	0	0	0	0
DO Sasolburg	0	0	0	0
TOTAL	10	10	5	25

* Please note that all the vacancies mentioned above are funded for the current financial year i.e. 2009/10.

QUESTION 194

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 19 June 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 3 of 2009

Mr M Mnqasela (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

How many vacancies were there as at 30 April 2009 for (a) counter staff, (b) supervisors and (c) management at each office in the Eastern Cape?

NW240E

REPLY

Acronyms: RO: Regional Office

DO: District Office

BP: Border Post

The number of vacant posts relating to Civic Services at each office in the Eastern Cape Province as at 30 April 2009 – as per the table below:

OFFICE	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGEMENT	TOTAL
RO Mthatha	1	9	2	12
DO Qumbu	2	0	0	2
RO Lusikisiki	0	0	1	1
DO Bizana	2	3	0	5
DO Libode	1	0	0	1
DO Port ST Johns	0	0	0	0
DO Tabankulu	0	0	0	0
RO Mount Frere	0	0	1	1
DO Aliwal North	1	0	0	1
DO Burgersdorp	3	0	0	3
DO MT Fletcher	1	0	0	1
DO Sterkspruit	0	1	1	2
RO Queenstown	2	5	1	8
TH Cofimvaba	1	0	0	1
DO Cradock	2		1	3
DO Engcobo	3	0	1	4
OFFICE	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGEMENT	TOTAL
DO Lady Frere	1	0	0	1
RO King Williams Town	24	3	2	29
PSP Keikammahoek	1	2	0	3
DO Alice	7	2	1	10
DO Butterworth	1	1	0	2
DO Willowvale	1	0	0	1
DO East London	6	0	0	6
DO Mdantsane	3	1	0	4
DO Peddie	1	0	0	1
RO Port Elizabeth	10	7	1	18
DO Cleary Park	1	0	0	1
DO Uitenhage	3	0	0	3
DO Graaff Reinet	3	0	0	3
DO Grahamstown	5	2	0	7
DO Humansdorp	2	0	0	2
DO Somerset East	4	0	0	4
TOTAL	92	36	12	140

The number of vacant posts relating to Immigration Services at each office in the Eastern Cape Province as at 30 April 2009 – as per the table below:

OFFICE	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGEMENT	TOTAL
RO Mthatha	5	0	1	6
DO Qumbu	0	0	0	0
RO Lusikisiki	2	0	1	3
DO Bizana	0	0	0	0
DO Libode	0	0	0	0
DO Port ST Johns	0	0	0	0
DO Tabankulu	0	0	0	0
RO Mount Frere	2	0	1	3
DO Aliwal North	0	0	0	0
DO Burgersdorp	0	0	0	0
DO MT Fletcher	3	0	0	3
DO Sterkspruit	2	0	0	2
RO Queenstown	3	1	1	5
TH Cofimvaba	0	0	0	0
DO Cradock	0	0	0	0
DO Engcobo	2	1	0	3
OFFICE	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGEMENT	TOTAL
DO Lady Frere	0	0	0	0
RO King Williams Town	3	3	1	7
PSP Keikammahoek	0	0	0	0
DO Alice	0	0	0	0
DO Butterworth	3	0	0	3
DO Willowvale	0	0	0	0
DO East London	2	2	0	4
DO Mdantsane	0	0	0	0
DO Peddie	0	0	0	0
RO Port Elizabeth	2	1	1	4
DO Cleary Park	0	0	0	0
DO Uitenhage	0	0	0	0
DO Graaff Reinet	0	0	0	0
DO Grahamstown	1	0	0	1
DO Humansdorp	0	0	0	0
DO Somerset East	0	0	0	0
BP Telebrug	2	0	0	2
RRO Port Elizabeth	0	0	0	0
TOTAL	32	8	6	46

* Please note that all vacancies mentioned above are funded for the current financial year i.e. 2009/10.

QUESTION 962

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 28 August 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 12 of 2009

Ms J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) (a) How many security guards are employed at each office of her department in each province and (b) which security companies are used at each of these offices;

whether any mechanisms are in place to prevent these security guards from
(a) requesting or taking bribes from people in queues and (b) handling any official documentation; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

NW1161E

REPLY

(1)(a) & (b) The number of security guards employed at each office of the Department of Home Affairs in each Province as well as the security companies utilised – as per the table below:

Province and Office	Number of security guards	Security Company
Northern Cape	7
Kimberley	2	Fidelity Security Services
Upington	1	Fidelity Security Services
Kuruman	1	Fidelity Security Services
Pampierstad	1	Fidelity Security Services
Jan Kempdorp	1	Fidelity Security Services
De Aar	1	Fidelity Security Services

Free State	39
Provincial Manager's Office	2	SSE Security Services
Ficksburg	2	SSE Security Services
ThabaNchu	2	SSE Security Services
Koffiefontein	2	SSE Security Services
Ladybrand	2	SSE Security Services
Botshabelo	4	SSE Security Services
Bloemfontein	6	SPE Security Services
Brandford	1	Molefe Security Services
Welkom	2	Davidson Security Services
Bothaville	1	Davidson Security Services
Kroonstad	2	Davidson Security Services
Heilbron	2	Davidson Security Services
Bultfontein	2	Davidson Security Services
Parys	2	Davidson Security Services
Wesselsbron	2	M2M Security Services
Viljoenskroon	2	Motheo Security Services
Phuthaditjhaba	2	Fidelity Security Services
Bethlehem	1	Fidelity Security Services

Western Cape	58	Fidelity Security Services
Cape Town	4	Fidelity Security Services
Bellville	3	Fidelity Security Services
Wynberg	3	Fidelity Security Services
Langa	1	Fidelity Security Services
Paarl	1	Fidelity Security Services
Worcester	1	Fidelity Security Services
Malmesbury	1	Fidelity Security Services
Vredendal	1	Fidelity Security Services
Khayelitsha	4	Fidelity Security Services
Caledon	1	Fidelity Security Services
Nyanga	4	Fidelity Security Services
Mitchell's Plain	2	Fidelity Security Services
Grabouw	1	Fidelity Security Services
Somerset West	1	Fidelity Security Services
George	3	Fidelity Security Services
Beaufort West	2	Fidelity Security Services
Oudtshoorn	1	Fidelity Security Services
Plettenberg Bay	1	Fidelity Security Services
Nyanga Refugee Reception Office	23	Fidelity Security Services

Eastern Cape	49	Fidelity Security Services
Mthatha	6	Fidelity Security Services
Mqanduli	2	Fidelity Security Services
Qumbu	2	Fidelity Security Services
Tsolo	2	Fidelity Security Services
Ngcobo	4	Fidelity Security Services
Elliot	3	Fidelity Security Services
Cala	3	Fidelity Security Services
Dutywa	2	Fidelity Security Services
Butterworth	4	Fidelity Security Services
Nqamakwe	2	Fidelity Security Services
Centane	2	Fidelity Security Services
Willowsvale	3	Fidelity Security Services
Elliotdale	1	Fidelity Security Services
Lusikisiki	2	Fidelity Security Services
Bizana	2	Fidelity Security Services
Port St Johns	2	Fidelity Security Services
Ngqeleni	2	Fidelity Security Services
Libode	2	Fidelity Security Services
Flagstaff	3	Fidelity Security Services

Kwazulu-Natal	37	Fidelity Security Services
Thekwini	8	Fidelity Security Services
Ugu	1	Fidelity Security Services
Umgungundlovu	2	Fidelity Security Services
Amajuba	2	Fidelity Security Services
Commercial Road	2	Fidelity Security Services
Prospecton	2	Fidelity Security Services
Pinetown	3	Fidelity Security Services
Tongaat	2	Fidelity Security Services
Kokstad	1	Fidelity Security Services
Ixopo	1	Fidelity Security Services
Nongoma	1	Fidelity Security Services
Mthubathuba	1	Fidelity Security Services
Empangeni	3	Fidelity Security Services
Eshowe	1	Fidelity Security Services
Vryheid	1	Fidelity Security Services
Ladysmith	1	Fidelity Security Services
Durban Harbour	1	Fidelity Security Services
Bamshela	1	Fidelity Security Services
Harding	1	Fidelity Security Services
Umzimkhulu	1	Fidelity Security Services
Richards Bay	1	Fidelity Security Services

Gauteng	149	Fidelity Security Services
Provincial Manager's Office	2	Fidelity Security Services
Area Manager: West	2	Fidelity Security Services
Soweto	4	Fidelity Security Services
Carletonville	2	Fidelity Security Services
Randfontein	2	Fidelity Security Services
Krugersdorp	2	Fidelity Security Services
Roodepoort	3	Fidelity Security Services
Wynberg	4	Fidelity Security Services
Johannesburg	7	Fidelity Security Services
Market Street	7	Fidelity Security Services
Heidelberg	3	Fidelity Security Services
Vereeniging	3	Fidelity Security Services
Randburg	4	Fidelity Security Services
Vanderbijlpark	4	Fidelity Security Services
Crown Mines Refugee Reception Centre	30	Fidelity Security Services
Sebokeng	4	Fidelity Security Services
Area Manager: East	2	Fidelity Security Services
Alberton	3	Fidelity Security Services
Kempton Park	3	Fidelity Security Services
Benoni	3	Fidelity Security Services
Pretoria	9	Fidelity Security Services
Boksburg	2	Fidelity Security Services
Brakpan	3	Fidelity Security Services
Marabastad	11	Fidelity Security Services
Nigel	3	Fidelity Security Services
Germiston	5	Fidelity Security Services
Edenvale	3	Fidelity Security Services
Centurion	5	Fidelity Security Services
Soshanguve	3	Fidelity Security Services
Cullinan	4	Fidelity Security Services
Akasia	4	Fidelity Security Services
Ga-Rankuwa	1	Fidelity Security Services
Moretele	2	Fidelity Security Services

North West	23
Provincial Manager's Office	2	Thulanang Security Services
Molopo	2	Thulanang Security Services
Lehurutshe	1	Thulanang Security Services
Ganyesa	1	Thulanang Security Services
Taung	2	Thulanang Security Services
Itsoseng	2	Thulanang Security Services
Atamelang	1	Thulanang Security Services
Klerksdorp	4	MBS Security
Lichtenburg	1	MBS Security
Wolmaranstad	1	MBS Security
Rustenburg	2	Atlie Project
Mogwase	1	Atlie Project
Moretele	2	Atlie Project
Brits	1	Atlie Project

Mpumalanga	17
Nelspruit	4	Double Barrel Security
Witbank	4	Double Barrel Security
Ermelo	4	Double Barrel Security
Eerstehoek	3	Double Barrel Security
Mhala	2	Double Barrel Security

Limpopo	19	Double Barrel Security
Provincial Manager's Office	2	Double Barrel Security
Polokwane	2	Double Barrel Security
Giyani	4	Double Barrel Security
Mokopane	2	Double Barrel Security
Thohoyandou	2	Double Barrel Security
Makhado	1	Double Barrel Security
Dzanani	2	Double Barrel Security
Molemole	1	Double Barrel Security
Lephalale	1	Double Barrel Security
Tzaneen	2	Double Barrel Security

(2)(b) Security guards are barred, in terms of their job descriptions, to handle official documentation. In instances where it emerged that official documentation was handled by a security guard, the Department has instructed the service provider to have the specific security guard permanently removed from rendering services at any office of the Department.

QUESTION 962

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 28 August 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 12 of 2009

Ms J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) (a) How many security guards are employed at each office of her department in each province and (b) which security companies are used at each of these offices;

whether any mechanisms are in place to prevent these security guards from
(a) requesting or taking bribes from people in queues and (b) handling any official documentation; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

NW1161E

REPLY

(1)(a) & (b) The number of security guards employed at each office of the Department of Home Affairs in each Province as well as the security companies utilised – as per the table below:

Province and Office	Number of security guards	Security Company
Northern Cape	7
Kimberley	2	Fidelity Security Services
Upington	1	Fidelity Security Services
Kuruman	1	Fidelity Security Services
Pampierstad	1	Fidelity Security Services
Jan Kempdorp	1	Fidelity Security Services
De Aar	1	Fidelity Security Services

Free State	39
Provincial Manager's Office	2	SSE Security Services
Ficksburg	2	SSE Security Services
ThabaNchu	2	SSE Security Services
Koffiefontein	2	SSE Security Services
Ladybrand	2	SSE Security Services
Botshabelo	4	SSE Security Services
Bloemfontein	6	SPE Security Services
Brandford	1	Molefe Security Services
Welkom	2	Davidson Security Services
Bothaville	1	Davidson Security Services
Kroonstad	2	Davidson Security Services
Heilbron	2	Davidson Security Services
Bultfontein	2	Davidson Security Services
Parys	2	Davidson Security Services
Wesselsbron	2	M2M Security Services
Viljoenskroon	2	Motheo Security Services
Phuthaditjhaba	2	Fidelity Security Services
Bethlehem	1	Fidelity Security Services

Western Cape	58	Fidelity Security Services
Cape Town	4	Fidelity Security Services
Bellville	3	Fidelity Security Services
Wynberg	3	Fidelity Security Services
Langa	1	Fidelity Security Services
Paarl	1	Fidelity Security Services
Worcester	1	Fidelity Security Services
Malmesbury	1	Fidelity Security Services
Vredendal	1	Fidelity Security Services
Khayelitsha	4	Fidelity Security Services
Caledon	1	Fidelity Security Services
Nyanga	4	Fidelity Security Services
Mitchell's Plain	2	Fidelity Security Services
Grabouw	1	Fidelity Security Services
Somerset West	1	Fidelity Security Services
George	3	Fidelity Security Services
Beaufort West	2	Fidelity Security Services
Oudtshoorn	1	Fidelity Security Services
Plettenberg Bay	1	Fidelity Security Services
Nyanga Refugee Reception Office	23	Fidelity Security Services

Eastern Cape	49	Fidelity Security Services
Mthatha	6	Fidelity Security Services
Mqanduli	2	Fidelity Security Services
Qumbu	2	Fidelity Security Services
Tsolo	2	Fidelity Security Services
Ngcobo	4	Fidelity Security Services
Elliot	3	Fidelity Security Services
Cala	3	Fidelity Security Services
Dutywa	2	Fidelity Security Services
Butterworth	4	Fidelity Security Services
Nqamakwe	2	Fidelity Security Services
Centane	2	Fidelity Security Services
Willowsvale	3	Fidelity Security Services
Elliotdale	1	Fidelity Security Services
Lusikisiki	2	Fidelity Security Services
Bizana	2	Fidelity Security Services
Port St Johns	2	Fidelity Security Services
Ngqeleni	2	Fidelity Security Services
Libode	2	Fidelity Security Services
Flagstaff	3	Fidelity Security Services

Kwazulu-Natal	37	Fidelity Security Services
Thekwini	8	Fidelity Security Services
Ugu	1	Fidelity Security Services
Umgungundlovu	2	Fidelity Security Services
Amajuba	2	Fidelity Security Services
Commercial Road	2	Fidelity Security Services
Prospecton	2	Fidelity Security Services
Pinetown	3	Fidelity Security Services
Tongaat	2	Fidelity Security Services
Kokstad	1	Fidelity Security Services
Ixopo	1	Fidelity Security Services
Nongoma	1	Fidelity Security Services
Mthubathuba	1	Fidelity Security Services
Empangeni	3	Fidelity Security Services
Eshowe	1	Fidelity Security Services
Vryheid	1	Fidelity Security Services
Ladysmith	1	Fidelity Security Services
Durban Harbour	1	Fidelity Security Services
Bamshela	1	Fidelity Security Services
Harding	1	Fidelity Security Services
Umzimkhulu	1	Fidelity Security Services
Richards Bay	1	Fidelity Security Services

Gauteng	149	Fidelity Security Services
Provincial Manager's Office	2	Fidelity Security Services
Area Manager: West	2	Fidelity Security Services
Soweto	4	Fidelity Security Services
Carletonville	2	Fidelity Security Services
Randfontein	2	Fidelity Security Services
Krugersdorp	2	Fidelity Security Services
Roodepoort	3	Fidelity Security Services
Wynberg	4	Fidelity Security Services
Johannesburg	7	Fidelity Security Services
Market Street	7	Fidelity Security Services
Heidelberg	3	Fidelity Security Services
Vereeniging	3	Fidelity Security Services
Randburg	4	Fidelity Security Services
Vanderbijlpark	4	Fidelity Security Services
Crown Mines Refugee Reception Centre	30	Fidelity Security Services
Sebokeng	4	Fidelity Security Services
Area Manager: East	2	Fidelity Security Services
Alberton	3	Fidelity Security Services
Kempton Park	3	Fidelity Security Services
Benoni	3	Fidelity Security Services
Pretoria	9	Fidelity Security Services
Boksburg	2	Fidelity Security Services
Brakpan	3	Fidelity Security Services
Marabastad	11	Fidelity Security Services
Nigel	3	Fidelity Security Services
Germiston	5	Fidelity Security Services
Edenvale	3	Fidelity Security Services
Centurion	5	Fidelity Security Services
Soshanguve	3	Fidelity Security Services
Cullinan	4	Fidelity Security Services
Akasia	4	Fidelity Security Services
Ga-Rankuwa	1	Fidelity Security Services
Moretele	2	Fidelity Security Services

North West	23
Provincial Manager's Office	2	Thulanang Security Services
Molopo	2	Thulanang Security Services
Lehurutshe	1	Thulanang Security Services
Ganyesa	1	Thulanang Security Services
Taung	2	Thulanang Security Services
Itsoseng	2	Thulanang Security Services
Atamelang	1	Thulanang Security Services
Klerksdorp	4	MBS Security
Lichtenburg	1	MBS Security
Wolmaranstad	1	MBS Security
Rustenburg	2	Atlie Project
Mogwase	1	Atlie Project
Moretele	2	Atlie Project
Brits	1	Atlie Project

Mpumalanga	17
Nelspruit	4	Double Barrel Security
Witbank	4	Double Barrel Security
Ermelo	4	Double Barrel Security
Eerstehoek	3	Double Barrel Security
Mhala	2	Double Barrel Security

Limpopo	19	Double Barrel Security
Provincial Manager's Office	2	Double Barrel Security
Polokwane	2	Double Barrel Security
Giyani	4	Double Barrel Security
Mokopane	2	Double Barrel Security
Thohoyandou	2	Double Barrel Security
Makhado	1	Double Barrel Security
Dzanani	2	Double Barrel Security
Molemole	1	Double Barrel Security
Lephalale	1	Double Barrel Security
Tzaneen	2	Double Barrel Security

(2)(a) Currently, there is limited capacity to prevent private security guards from taking bribes from people in queues. The Department is installing integrated electronic security systems in all its offices with Closed Circuit Television Cameras (CCTV). These will be monitored by Departmental security personnel in the control rooms. These systems have, already, been installed in twenty seven (27) frontline offices, and four (4) of the Refugee Reception Centres. Due to a lack of capacity, there are no Departmental personnel, yet, to monitor these systems. Additional installations are envisaged to continue over the next three years, and the Department will appoint its own security supervisors, during this period, to manage security, at all its offices, which will be periodically vetted.

(2)(b) Security guards are barred, in terms of their job descriptions, to handle official documentation. In instances where it emerged that official documentation was handled by a security guard, the Department has instructed the service provider to have the specific security guard permanently removed from rendering services at any office of the Department.

QUESTION 960

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 28 August 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 12 of 2009

Mrs J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) Whether a new site for the Nyanga refugee centre has been identified; if not, why not; if so, (a) where is the new site, (b) when will a public announcement be made on the locality of the new site and (c) how will the public be informed of the locality of the new site;

(2) (a) what is the current situation on the move to the new site and (b) when will the intended move take place;

(3) whether interim arrangements will be made in order to still assist asylum seekers as well as people wanting to renew their permits; if not, why not; if so, (a) what are the relevant details and (b)(i) how and (ii) when will this be communicated to the public;

(4) whether she will take steps to reduce the (a) high vacancy rate and (b) absenteeism rate at the Nyanga refugee centre; if not, why not; if so, (i) when and (ii) what steps?

NW1159E

REPLY

(1)(a) Yes. The new premises are in Maitland, Cape Town.

(1)(b) Clients will be kept informed as the process to relocate the Centre unfolds. Other stakeholders are being informed on an ongoing basis through meetings. The last such meeting took place on 23 September 2009.

(1)(c) The public will be informed through adverts on regional radio stations, and in regional newspapers, the distribution of pamphlets and posters, as well as, through NGO's operating in the refugee environment.

(2)(a) The Cape High Court has given the Department a reprieve from
30 September 2009, until 23 October 2009, to ensure that the new premises are refurbished, and renovated in time.

(2)(b) The relocation has, since, taken place, and the office is in a new site.

(3)(a) No. Everything has been relocated to the new office.

(3)(b)(i) & (ii) As per (1)(b) and (1)(c) above.

(4)(a)(i) & (ii) Yes. Capacitating of Immigration Services is a strategically driven process, informed by specific transformation requirements that are identified through the restructuring of critical service delivery points, including Refugee Affairs. Where possible, critical placements are addressed by the re-allocation of available human resources. Where suitable candidates are not available, the normal recruitment procedures will be undertaken, once the migration process from the Department's old structure to the new structure is completed by the end of November 2009. Additional posts can only, then, be created on the new structure.

(4)(b)(i) & (ii) All officials at the Nyanga Refugee Reception Centre attended a course on the management of absenteeism. Further, the issue of absenteeism is, also, being addressed through disciplinary measures.

QUESTION 961

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 28 August 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 12 of 2009

Mrs J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) Whether, with regard to the Nyanga refugee centre, any mechanisms are in place to ensure that refugees are assisted in an organized manner; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

(2) what is the reason for her officials not being able to (a) assist and (b) manage the entrance to the centre;

(3) whether any action will be taken to upgrade the current filing system from which applications can be tracked and followed up on and to ensure that it becomes more workable and efficient; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

NW1160E

REPLY

(1) Yes. The following arrangements are in place at the centre to manage the large number of people who visit the office:

(i) The office is supposed to open is at 07:00 to segregate the crowd into queues according to the specific service(s) they require, namely:

· First time applications for asylum (Countries of origin are allocated specific days for the taking in of new applications)

· Extension of section 22 (asylum seeker) permits

· Refugee Identity Card Applications

· United Nations Travel Document applications

(ii) The queues are supposed to be directed to designated areas according to the specific service(s) required. Women and children should be prioritised in the queues. However, due to the long queues of first time applicants, and limited office space, queues, sometimes, extend outside the premises. All new applicants for asylum are issued with Section 22 permits on the same day, but many others may not make it to the registration desk, due to the length of the queue.

(iii) In terms of the Cape Town High Court ruling in June 2009, the Department was ordered to vacate the premises by the end of September 2009. However, the High Court has given the Department a reprieve from
30 September 2009, until 23 October 2009 to vacate the premises.

(2) Management of the entrance, to the centre, has been outsourced to a private security company. The staffing capacity at the centre is inadequate to deal with the large crowds. The Department is considering appointing additional workers to assist with managing the entrance, and assisting people in the queues.

(3) Yes. The Department is in the process of overhauling its refugee management system including, the current filing system. The Department has invited service providers to tender for the creation of a master file system that will link all Refugee Reception Centres across the country.

QUESTION 973

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 28 August 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 12 of 2009

Mr M Mnqasela (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) What (a) was the rate of absenteeism in her department (i) in (aa) 2006, (bb) 2007, (cc) 2008 and (ii) during the period 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available, (b) were the main reasons for and (c) effects of these absenteeism during the said periods in each case;

(2) whether she has taken any steps with regard to absenteeism in her department; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

NW1173E

REPLY

(1)(a)(i) The absenteeism rate, based on the number of work days lost through absence, taking into consideration the number of employees and the total number of days to be worked by all employees, is as follows:

(aa) 2006 - 1.74%.

(bb) 2007 - 2.59%

(cc) 2008 - 2.12%

(1)(a)(ii) The absenteeism rate in the Department from 1 January 2009 to 31 August 2009 stands at 1.51%.

(1)(b) The following were the main reasons for absenteeism as observed by the Department:

§ Personal problems

§ Unsupportive work environment

§ Addiction to alcohol and / or narcotics

§ Lack of motivation

§ Ill health

(1)(c) The Department has observed that the following effects can be attributed to absenteeism:

§ Disruption in service delivery

§ Shortage of staff at working stations / service counters

§ Work overload to employees present at work

§ Poor image to the Public due to slow service delivery

§ Increased conflict with Management on attendance issues and work performance

§ Reduced work performance

§ Decline in staff morale who witness ongoing absenteeism

§ Cost of alternative Labour Sources

§ Increased overtime

(2) Yes. Since the beginning of the 2009/10 financial year, a total of 916 supervisors attended a compulsory course (which was presented by the Department) on Absenteeism Management. These supervisors were instructed to monitor absenteeism meticulously and to take disciplinary action against officials who do not comply with the current policy regarding all aspects of leave.

QUESTION 1250

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 11 September 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 16 of 2009

Mrs M Wenger (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(a) How many outstanding applications for identity documents that are two years and older still awaits processing, (b) how many applications for identity documents are outstanding in total as at the latest specified date for which information is available and (c) what steps will she take to fast-track such applications?

NW1592E

REPLY:

(a) & (b) The specific information regarding outstanding applications for identity documents that are two years, and older, which, still, await processing, is, unfortunately, not available, at present. However, a program is, currently, being run to determine the said information.

QUESTION 1240

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 11 September 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 16 OF 2009

Mrs J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

Whether refugees have to renew permits at the centre where the permit was initially issued; if not, what procedures are in place to prevent officials from giving the wrong information to people trying to renew their permits?

NW1582E

REPLY

There are Standard Operating Procedures in place which oblige all officials to know what is expected of them, as well as, to give correct information, when requested. In addition, managers are in place to ensure that these procedures are implemented, and they have monitoring tools in place to ensure that no deviation from procedures occurs.

However, delays do occur, if the permits are not renewed at the initial office.

QUESTION 128

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Tuesday, 6 October 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 19 OF 2009

Mrs M M Maunye (ANC) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) Whether her department is experiencing an increase in applications for emigration documents as a consequence of the current economic recession; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details;

(2) whether the global economic situation has led to expatriates returning; if so, what are the relevant details?

NO1096E

REPLY:

(1) & (2) The Department of Home Affairs does not record the requested information, as the Department of Home Affairs' Movement Control System (MCS) only records the departures of persons from the RSA, through the Port of Entry they have departed. Places of destination, or, reason for the departure are not recorded. For this reason, it is, kindly, suggested that the Honourable Member directs her request for the information to the Honourable Minister of Finance, as this information is kept by Statistics South Africa (StatsSA).

QUESTION 131

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Tuesday, 6 October 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 19 OF 2009

Mrs C Dudley (ACDP) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

What progress has been made in (a) increasing efficiency, (b) speeding up the applications process and (c) reducing queues of foreign nationals applying for temporary permits?

NO1282E

REPLY:

(a) The Department of Home Affairs (DHA) primarily assists foreign nationals with the issuance of temporary permits as a client of a Refugee Reception Centre, or through application being made at a Permitting Office for enabling documentation. In both instances, the efficiency, and, or the application process, has been improved as part of the Department's overall transformation programme.

To this end, the Department is progressively expanding its footprint across the Republic with the establishment of additional offices during this current financial year, comprising of a permanent office in Musina, and a temporary office in Gauteng (Tshwane Show ground). This ensures that seven national service points are now provided for Refugee Status Determination. The management of these centres has also been improved, and the department recently commissioned job evaluation that resulted in senior appointments being made at the level of Director for the large centres, and Deputy-Director at the smaller centres. Operational efficiencies were also improved following a detailed study of process, and systems management. Training programmes for officials on Salary Levels 8- 13 have been instituted with a view to harnessing improved skills levels. Despite, all these measures, there is, still, a challenge in reducing the queries.

Similarly, the Department is also reviewing the efficiencies of Permitting Offices, particularly around the issuance of study and work permits. The decoupling of front and back offices processes is being evaluated as this would improve the management of applications, and limit possibilities for interference and, or, mismanagement to arise with such applications. Adherence to turnaround times for the management of Permit applications is, also, assessed on a weekly basis to ensure that service levels can be maintained.

(b) In respect of applicants applying for other temporary permits under the Immigration Act, 2002 (Act No 13 of 2002), a track and trace system is, currently, being piloted. This system is designed to keep clients informed on the process, and the outcome of their permit applications, ultimately, reducing the need to queue at domestic offices for enquiry purposes. A value-added benefit for the Department is that this system, also, provides a monitoring tool to assess whether service delivery timeframes are being adhered to.

QUESTION 136

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 12 June 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 2 of 2009

Mr M Mnqasela (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

How many vacancies were there as at 30 April 2009 for (a) counter staff, (b) supervisors and (c) management at each office in Limpopo?

NW146E

REPLY

Acronyms: RO: Regional Office

DO: District Office

BP: Border Post

The number of vacant posts relating to Civic Services at each office in the Limpopo Province as at 30 April 2009 – as per the table below:

OFFICE	CIVIC SERVICES
	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGEMENT
RO Mokopane (Potgietersrus)	6	2	0
DO Lephalale (Ellisras)	2	0	0
DO Taueatswala	3	0	0
DO Modimolle	4	1	0
BP Platjan	0	0	0
BP Zanzibar	0	0	0
BP Groblersbrug	0	0	0
BP Stockpoort	0	0	0
DO Thabazimbi	6	0	0
RO Polokwane (Pietersburg)	4	2	0
DO Lebowakgomo	4	0	0
DO Jane Furse	0	0	0
DO Bochum	0	1	0
DO Molemole	0	2	0
DO Matlala	0	0	0
Gateway International Airport	0	0	0
DO Mankweng	0	0	0
DO Nebo	0	0	0
DO Seshego	0	1	01
DO Groblersdal	0	0	0
SEKHUKHUNE HOSPITALS	25	0	00
DO Burgersfort	0	0	0
RO Thohoyandou	3	1	0
Refugee Reception Office Musina	0	0	0
DO Louis Trichardt	3	2	0
DO Musina	1	1	0
DO Dzanani	3	1	0
DO Mutale	4	1	0
DO Hlanganani	1	0	0
DO Malamulele	1	0	0
DO Vuwani	0	0	0
BP Beit Bridge	0	0	0
BP Pontdrift	0	0	0
DO Mulamula	0	0	0
DO Mhinga	0	0	0
RO Giyani	2	0	0
DO Tzaneen	2	1	01
DO Phalaborwa	7	0	0
DO Raphahlela	0	0	0
DO Sekororo	0	0	0
DO Maphulaneng	0	0	0
BP Pafuri	0	0	0
BP Giriyondo	0	0	0
TOTAL	81	16	2

The number of vacant posts relating to Immigration Services at each office in the Limpopo as at 30 April 2009 – as per the table below:

OFFICE	IMMIGRATION SERVICES
	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGEMENT
RO Mokopane (Potgietersrus)	6	0	0
DO Lephalale (Ellisras)	1	0	0
DO Taueatswala	0	0	0
DO Modimolle	0	0	0
BP Platjan	0	0	0
BP Zanzibar	0	0	0
BP Groblersbrug	2	1	0
BP Stockpoort	1	0	0
DO Thabazimbi	0	0	0
RO Polokwane (Pietersburg)	6	1	0
DO Lebowakgomo	0	0	0
DO Jane Furse	5	0	0
DO Bochum	0	0	0
DO Molemole	0	0	0
DO Matlala	0	0	0
Gateway International Airport	0	0	0
DO Mankweng	0	0	0
DO Nebo	0	0	0
DO Seshego	0	0	0
DO Groblersdal	0	1	0
DO Burgersfort	0	0	0
RO Thohoyandou	0	0	1
Refugee Reception Office Musina	5	10	2
DO Louis Trichardt	0	1	0
DO Musina	1	0	0
DO Dzanani	0	0	0
DO Mutale	0	0	0
DO Hlanganani	0	0	0
DO Malamulele	3	1	0
DO Vuwani	0	0	0
BP Beit Bridge	60	15	1
BP Pontdrift	2	1	0
DO Mulamula	0	0	0
DO Mhinga	0	0	0
RO Giyani	2	0	1
DO Tzaneen	2	0	0
DO Phalaborwa	0	1	0
DO Raphahlela	0	0	0
DO Sekororo	0	0	0
DO Maphulaneng	0	0	0
BP Pafuri	1	1	0
BP Giriyondo	1	0	0
TOTAL	98	33	5

QUESTION 137

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 12 JUNE 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 2 OF 2009

Mr J Terblanche to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

How many vacancies were there for (a) counter staff, (b) supervisors and (c) management at each Home Affairs office in the Western Cape as at 30 April 2009?

NW147E

REPLY

Acronyms: PMO: WC Provincial Managers Office: Western Cape

RO: Regional Office

DO: District Office

The number of vacant posts relating to Civic Services at each office in the Western Cape Province as at 30 April 2009 – as per the table below:

OFFICE	CIVIC SERVICES
	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGEMENT

PMO: WC	2	11	9
RO: Cape Town	38	18	0
DO: Wynberg	26	3	0
DO: Bellville	25	6	0
RO: Paarl	32	9	1
DO: Worcester	8	6	0
DO: Vredendal	7	1	0
DO: Malmesbury	6	3	0
RO: George	17	11	0
DO: Oudtshoorn	6	2	0
DO: Beaufort West	7	4	0
RO: Khayelitsha	16	8	0
DO: Nyanga	15	4	0
DO: Caledon	11	1	0
D DO: M/Plain	10	3	0
TOTAL	226	90	10

The number of vacant posts relating to Immigration Services at each office in the Western Cape Province as at 30 April 2009 – as per the table below:

OFFICE	IMMIGRATION SERVICES
	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGEMENT
RO Cape Town	31	9	1
Refugee Reception Office Cape Town	10	1	0
DO Bellville	0	0	0
DO Wynberg	0	0	0
Cape Town International Airport	14	1	0
Cape Town Harbour	2	1	0
Saldanha Bay Harbour	5	1	0
RO Khayelitsha	5	3	1
DO Mitchell's Plain	0	0	0
DO Nyanga	0	0	0
DO Caledon	0	0	0
RO Paarl	5	1	1
DO Malmesbury	1	0	0
DO Worcester	0	0	0
DO Vredendal	0	0	0
DO Stellenbosch	0	0	0
RO George	9	3	0
DO Oudtshoorn	0	0	0
DO Knysna	0	0	0
DO Beaufort West	0	0	0
Mosselbay Harbour	5	1	0
TOTAL	87	21	3

QUESTION 138

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 12 June 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 2 of 2009

Ms J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

How many vacancies for (a) counter staff, (b) supervisors and (c) managers existed on
30 April 2009 at each office in Gauteng?

NW148E

Acronyms: RO: Regional Office

DO: District Office

BP: Border Post

The number of vacant posts relating to Civic Services at each office in the Gauteng Province as at 30 April 2009 – as per the table below:

OFFICE	CIVIC SERVICES
	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGEMENT
OR Tambo International Airport	0	0	0
RO Germiston	7	1	0
DO Alberton	6	1	0
DO Boksburg	0	1	0
DO Edenvale	1	1	0
DO Katlehong	0	0	0
DO Vosloorus	0	0	0
RO Springs	6	0	0
DO Benoni	1	0	0
DO Brakpan	2	1	1
DO Daveyton	0	0	0
DO Kemptonpark	0	1	0
DO Nigel	2	0	1
DO Tembisa	0	0	0
DO Ivory Park	0	0	0
RO Marabastad	9	2	2
Refugee Reception Office Pretoria	0	0	0
DO Centurion	3	1	0
DO Pretoria	4	2	0
DO Garsfontein	0	0	0
DO Atteridgeville	0	0	0
DO Midrand	0	0	0
RO Akasia	2	2	2
DO Mamelodi	0	0	0
DO Bronkhorstspruit	2	1	0
DO Soshanguve	0	1	1
DO Eersterust	0	0	0
RO Soweto	13	2	1
DO Lenasia	4	1	0
DO Roodepoort	3	2	0
DO Soweto	0	0	0
DO Naledi	0	0	0
RO Johannesburg	19	4	1
Refugee Reception Office Rosettonville	3	8	1
DO Alexandra	4	2	0
DO Marketstreet	14	5	1
DO Randburg	14	2	1
DO Sandton	7	0	0
RO Vereeniging	5	1	0
DO Evaton	0	0	0
DO Heidelberg	1	2	0
DO Orange Farms	0	0	0
DO Van Der Bijlpark	5	4	0
DO Sebokeng	4	1	0
RO Randfontein	10	0	0
DO Carletonville	9	0	0
DO Krugersdorp	7	2	0
Lanseria International Airport	0	0	0
DO Kagiso	0	0	0
TOTAL	167	51	12

The number of vacant posts relating to Immigration Services at each office in the Gauteng Province as at 30 April 2009 – as per the table below:

OFFICE	IMMIGRATION SERVICES
	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGEMENT
Johannesburg International Airport	7	5	3
Lanseria International Airport	7	1	0
RO Germiston	7	1	1
DO Alberton	6	1	0
DO Boksburg	0	1	0
DO Edenvale	0	0	0
DO Katlehong	0	0	0
DO Vosloorus	0	0	0
RO Springs	6	0	0
DO Benoni	1	0	0
DO Brakpan	2	1	1
DO Daveyton	0	0	0
DO Kemptonpark	0	1	0
DO Nigel	2	0	1
DO Tembisa	0	0	0
DO Ivory Park	0	0	0
RO Marabastad	24	3	1
Refugee Reception office Pretoria	9	4	1
Ga-rankua	6	1	0
DO Centurion	3	1	0
DO Pretoria	4	2	0
DO Garsfontein	0	0	0
DO Atteridgeville	0	0	0
DO Midrand	0	0	0
RO Akasia	2	2	2
DO Mamelodi	0	0	0
DO Bronkhorstspruit	2	1	0
DO Soshanguve	0	1	1
DO Eersterust	0	0	0
RO Soweto	13	2	1
DO Lenasia	4	2	0
DO Roodepoort	3	2	0
DO Soweto	0	0	0
DO Naledi	0	0	0
RO Johannesburg	19	4	1
Refugee Reception Office Crown Mines	8	0	1
DO Alexandra	4	2	0
DO Marketstreet	14	5	1
DO Randburg	14	2	1
DO Sandton	7	0	0
RO Vereeniging	5	1	1
DO Evaton	0	0	0
DO Heidelberg	1	2	0
DO Orange Farms	0	0	0
DO Van Der Bijlpark	5	4	0
DO Sebokeng	4	1	0
RO Randfontein	10	0	0
DO Carletonville	9	0	0
DO Krugersdorp	7	2	0
Lanseria International Airport	7	1	0
DO Kagiso	0	0	0
TOTAL	138	55	17

QUESTION 148

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 12 June 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 2 of 2009

Ms A Mda (Cope) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) Whether any steps were taken to improve the security of documents; if not, why not; if so,

(2) whether the sale of fraudulent passports were curtailed by such steps; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

NW189E

REPLY

(1) Yes. New measures have been implemented to secure the Identity Documents (IDs) issued by the Department. The ID work flow process has been re-engineered to ensure that all ID books are accounted for, and the changes are, also, ensured of responsibility and accountability for individual ID books.

The Track and Trace system enables the Department to track and trace an ID application from the time of acceptance, up until the ID book is collected by the applicant. It, also, helps to detect when an ID application, or book was tampered with, or got lost during processing. The system can identify, who was the last official, who dealt with the case.

On-Line Verification was implemented to ensure that the person who is applying for a re-issue of an ID is the correct person. The fingerprint, and the ID number are verified against the HANIS data base, before an ID application is accepted, and the ID book is issued. This prevents illegal applications being accepted at front offices.

The Department is, also, currently, looking at improving the current format of the ID book. New technology will be introduced to make the Identity Document more secure from tampering. The tampering with the photograph on the ID books, is one of the major causes of fraud and identity theft.

With regards to passports, a high security new passport was developed, and implemented with effect from 8 April 2009. The new passport incorporates a number of security features that make external reproduction by unauthorised individuals difficult. These features were developed in collaboration with State security agencies. In addition, production of our passports has moved to a new secure site at GPW, where there is tighter access control to the production environment. The Department has, also, streamlined the end to end passport process, incorporating more controls, and monitoring to ensure that fraudulent activities are detected and minimised. Live capture, and on-line verification of applicants are being rolled out to front offices.

The Department is, also, improving measures to secure our Birth, Marriages, and Death documents. There is a Birth, Marriages, and Death Process re-design, which is , underway, looking at the capturing of births, marriages, and deaths information at the front office, and, thereby, securing the accuracy of information required, as well as, improving the information system that is used to capture such required information.

In addition, efforts are, underway, to improve the security features on all certificates. Currently, the certificates have a watermark, a unique serial number, and the User-id of the official that issued the certificate, is reflected.

In terms of the late registration of Birth, the process has been de-linked from the Identity Document (ID) application process. The identity of, both, the informant, and the applicant is tested, and verified against the fingerprints database. There is a thorough screening process by specialised committees, which determine the validity of the application for the late registration of birth. The Track and Trace system for the late registration of birth has been implemented, to trace the application, from the time of acceptance, up until the finalization.

(2) No reports, compromising the new passport, have been received, thus far.

QUESTION 699

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 7 August 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 7 of 2009

Mr I O Davidson (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

Whether, in light of the current recession and the consequent shortfall in state revenue, her department has introduced any austerity measures to reduce its expenditure with regard to (a) official vehicles, (b) travel, (c) travel by departmental officials,
(d) accommodation and household help or (e) any other aspects of government business; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details?

NW793E

REPLY

The South African Government has decided to appoint a Ministerial Task Team to develop a proposal on how the whole of government could respond to the economic meltdown by, among other things, identifying areas in which expenditure could be reduced with a view to diverted resources to the provision of essential services.

The Task Team, which is led by the Minister of Finance, will make specific recommendations on how government could implement austerity measures in all the three spheres of government in a structured and coordinated manner. All government departments will be required to comply with these measures as soon as they are approved by Cabinet. These measures will be made available as soon as possible. The department will be in a better position to respond to your questions as soon as this matter is finalised by Cabinet.

QUESTION 1868

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 23 October 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 24 OF 2009

Mrs J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

Whether the Department of Health is exempted from applying for scarce skills quotas; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, why?

NW2430E

REPLY

No. Government Departments are not exempted from any of the statutory requirements of the Immigration Act, 2002 (Act No 13 of 2002), or, any of the Immigration Regulations incorporated, in terms of the said Act.

However, Government Departments wanting to employ foreigners may apply, in terms of section 31(2)(c), of the said Act, to have certain prescribed requirements waived, in respect of the specific category in which the foreigners must submit applications for work permits.

QUESTION 287

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 3 July 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 5 of 2009

Mr L W Greyling (ID) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) What is the current status of the special exemption permits for Zimbabweans that were announced recently;

(2) whether the Government will introduce these permits; if not, why not; if so, when?

NW339E

REPLY

(1) Whilst the special dispensation for Zimbabwean nationals has been announced in the media, the Department of Home Affairs is, currently, investigating the technicalities surrounding the implementation, thereof. Consultations are also taking place within the Justice, Crime Prevention, and Security Cluster.

(2) A formal briefing session with Cabinet will take place, as soon as, the Department is ready to introduce the special dispensation for Zimbabwean nationals.

QUESTION 208

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 19 JUNE 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 3 OF 2009

208. Mr R B Bhoola (MF) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) How many (a) Indians, (b) coloureds, (c) blacks and (d) whites are employed in the (i) immigration and (ii) passport sections at the OR Tambo Airport;

(2) whether the Employment Equity Act, Act 55 of 1998, is being complied with; if not, why not; if so,

(3) whether her department is representing the diversity of South Africa; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW255E

REPLY

(1) (i) The racial composition of Immigrations Services staff at OR Tambo is classified, here-under:

(a) Indians - 2

(b) Coloureds - 6

(d) Whites - 8

TOTAL: 272

(ii) All immigration officers deal with passport issues, as well.

2. The Department of Home Affairs complies with the provisions of Employment Equity Act, 1998 in that:

§ An Employment Equity Plan for the period 2008 to 2011, is in place, which is a requirement, in terms of the Act, in order to achieve reasonable progress towards employment equity in the Department.

§ The Department submits Employment Equity Report, annually, to the Department of Labour in compliance with Section 21 (2).

§ The Employment Equity Forum has been established.

§ Employment Equity Plan, and the Report have been displayed on notice boards. The plan, and the Report are, also, accessible to the public.

§ Acting Deputy Director – General: Human Resources is the designated Senior Manager responsible for monitoring, and evaluation of the Employment Equity Plan.

3. No. There are a number of challenges, including that of the high mobility of employees.

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

FOR WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION 917

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 21 August 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 10 of 2009

Mrs J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1). Whether the Director-General signed a performance contract with her; if not, why not; if so, when; whether all senior managers in her department signed performance contracts with the Director-General; if not, (a) which senior managers did not sign, (b) for what reason and (c) when will it be done; if so, on which date did each senior manager sign a performance contract?

REPLY

(1). The Director General, Mr Mavuso Msimang, entered into a Performance Agreement with me on 30 July 2009 for the 2009/10 performance cycle. The original Performance Agreement was also submitted to The Office of the Public Service Commission, as stipulated in the Guidelines for the Evaluation of Heads of Departments, as well as, per the Cabinet Lekgotla's Apex Resolution 15 of 2007.

No. Out of the seventy one (71) members of the Senior Management Service (SMS) on the fixed establishment of the Department, only sixty two (62) members have entered into a Performance Agreement with the Director-General / their respective supervisors for the 2009/10 performance cycle.

The information, in this regard, is attached, here, as Annexure A.

(2). (a) to (c). Of the nine (9) SMS members who have not entered into a Performance Agreement with their respective supervisors for the 2009/10 performance cycle, two (2) SMS members are newly appointed employees who have three (3) months to enter into a Performance Agreement with their supervisors, three (3) SMS members are newly transferred employees from the Department of International Relations & Cooperation and are in the process of structuring their performance agreements. The remaining four (4) SMS members were issued with Audi Alterem Partem letters, affording them the opportunity to provide reasons why the Department should not institute disciplinary measures against them for non compliance. The table below indicates the information in respect of each of the nine (9) SMS members concerned:

Name of the Member	Reason	Corrective Measure
Joseph: GB	Member failed to comply with provisions of Chapter 4 of the SMS Handbook	Corrective measures initiated, Audi Alterem Partem letter issued
Mnyaka: N	Member failed to comply with provisions of Chapter 4 of the SMS Handbook	Corrective measures initiated, Audi Alterem Partem letter issued
Ngoie: EC	Member failed to comply with provisions of Chapter 4 of the SMS Handbook	Corrective measures initiated, Audi Alterem Partem letter issued
Khuzwayo Z R Date of Appointment: 1 August 2009	Less than 3 months in a rank, Performance Agreement to be submitted on 31 October 2009	HR currently providing technical assistance.
Khumalo: N	Transferred from the Department of International Relations and Co-operation on 9 May 2009	Member going through induction and orientation to the new environment (DHA) to enable judgements about what it will take to deliver a good service for the current performance cycle.
Mamoepa: MRE	Transferred from the Department of International Relations and Co-operation on 16 May 2009	Member going through induction and orientation to the new environment (DHA) to enable judgements about what it will take to deliver a good service for the current performance cycle.
Maya: L	Transferred from the Department of International Relations and Co-operation on 1 June 2009	Member going through induction and orientation to the new environment (DHA) to enable judgements about what it will take to deliver a good service for the current performance cycle.
Msomi: TJ	Member failed to comply with provisions of Chapter 4 of the SMS Handbook	Corrective measures initiated, Audi Alterem Partem letter issued
Apleni M Date of appointment 1 October 2009	Less than 3 months in rank Performance agreement to be submitted no later than 31 January 2010	Branch: Human Resources providing technical assistance in the development of the Performance Agreement.

QUESTION 1164

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 11 September 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 14 of 2009

Mr M Mnqasela (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

Whether her department uses temporary employment services and/or labour brokers; if so, (a) why, (b) how many positions have been filled by temporary employment services in the (i) 2006-07, (ii) 2007-08 and
(iii) 2008-09 financial years, (c) what percentage of the total staff complement did temporary employment services contribute in each of these years and (d) how much money has been spent on temporary employment services per year?

NW1499E

REPLY:

No. The Department of Home Affairs does not utilise the services of temporary employment services and, or labour brokers.

QUESTION 452

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 10 July 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 6 of 2009

Dr C P Mulder (FF Plus) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:†

(1) How many (a) black, (b) brown, (c) Indian and (d) white officials were in her department's employ in (i) April 1994 and (ii) April 2009;

(2) how many of the (a) black, (b) brown, (c) Indian and (d) white officials (i) resigned, (ii) retired, (iii) took an early package and (iv) were dismissed during the period from 1 April 1994 to 1 April 2009;

(3) how many of the (a) black, (b) brown, (c) Indian and (d) white officials who
(i) resigned, (ii) retired, (iii) took an early package and (iv) were dismissed were replaced with an official from the same race group;

(4) how many posts in her department have been reserved for persons from the designated groups for affirmative action in terms of the Employment Equity Act, Act 55 of 1998;

(5) how many of these posts (a) are vacant and (b) have been filled with persons from the designated groups since the commencement of the Employment Equity Act, Act 55 of 1998?

NW513E

REPLY

(1)(i) There were a total of 7 236 employees in the Department of Home Affairs in April 1994. The breakdown is specified in the table, below:

Racial group	Number
(a) African	2554
(b) Coloured	563
(c) Indian	113
(d) White	4006
Total	7236

(1)(ii) There were a total of 7 435 employees in the Department of Home Affairs in April 2009. The breakdown is specified in the table, below:

Racial group	Number
(a) African	6071
(b) Coloured	447
(c) Indian	71
(d) White	846
Total	7435

(2) A total of 10 517 employees left the employ of the Department between April 1994 and April 2009. The number of officials (5 076) who left the employ of the Department for the reasons as specified in (i) to (iv) of the Question is specified in the table, below:

Racial group	(i) Resigned	(ii) Retired	(iii) Took an early package	(iv) Dismissed	Total
(a) African	980	411	1	751	2 143
(b) Coloured	266	14	0	101	381
(c) Indian	50	11	0	9	70
(d) White	1 542	819	5	116	2 482
Total	2 838	1 255	6	977	5 076

Please note: The Honourable Member's attention is invited to the fact that there are eleven (11) types / categories of resignations in the Public Service. The categories as well as the number of officials who left the employ of the Department are specified, below:

· Contract expiry : 4 378

· Death / demise : 596

· Dismissal: Ill health : 447

· Dismissal: Incapacity : 42

· Dismissal: Misconduct : 538

· Dismissal: Retrenchments : 53

· Not categorised : 344

· Resignation : 2 838

· Retirement : 1 255

· Transfer : 20

· Early package : 6

TOTAL : 10 517

(3) For the period April 1994 to April 2009, the Department replaced all 5 076 officials with officials of the same racial group. An additional 482 officials of the same racial group were, also, appointed during this period. The breakdown is specified in the table, below:

Racial group	Number
African	4,872
Coloured	385
Indian	49
White	252
Total	5 558

(4) In terms of the Employment Equity Plan (2008-2011) of the Department, the posts reserved for people from designated groups for affirmative action, as required by the Employment Equity Act, 1998 (Act no 55 of 1998), are as follows:

Abbreviations: AM African Male

AF African Female

CM Coloured Male

CF Coloured Female

IM Indian Male

IF Indian Female

WF White Female

Senior Management Services (SMS)

As per the table, below:

Year	AM	AF	CM	CF	IM	IF	WF
2008/09	12	19	11	14	10	14	0
2009/10	12	15	11	14	11	13	0
2010/11	11	12	5	6	5	4	0

The projection of the SMS has been done in accordance with a Cabinet decision that 50/50 representation must be achieved by March 2009.

Positions below Senior Management Services:

As per the table, below:

Year	AM	AF	CM	CF	IM	IF	WM	WF
2008/09	569	347	203	151	86	87	118	140
2009/10	530	312	250	149	92	103	214	131
2010/11	613	309	256	145	89	84	205	86

People with disabilities' targets to be achieved by March 2010

As per the table, below:

2008	2009	2010	Total
43	39	20	102

These employment equity targets are, currently, being revised in accordance with the new organisational structure of the Department. It, also, stands to reason, as to whether they do apply for these posts with the necessary required skills, and qualifications.

(5) (a) The Department is, currently, busy with the migration process from the old structure to the newly approved structure. Therefore, it is not possible to determine the current number of vacancies with regards to persons from the designated groups.

(5) (b) The following are the number of positions filled by people from designated groups.

RACE	GENDER	NUMBER
African	Female	3 308
African	Male	2 763
Sub-Total	6 071

Race	Gender	Number
Coloured	Female	257
Coloured	Male	190
Sub-Total	447

Race	Gender	Number
Indian	Female	38
Indian	Male	33
Subtotal		71

Race	Gender	Number
White	Female	675

People with Disabilities	35
GRAND TOTAL	7 299

QUESTION 377

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 3 July 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 5 of 2009

Mrs J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) Whether she purchased a new vehicle on her appointment to office; if so, (a) why, (b) what make and model is the vehicle, (c) what did the vehicle cost and (d)(i) what accessories were included in excess of the vehicle's purchase price and (ii) what was the cost of such accessories; if not,

(2) whether she inherited an existing vehicle; if so, (a) what was the make and model and (b) how old is the vehicle?

NW437E

REPLY

(1)(2) No. The Minister of Home Affairs did not purchase a new vehicle on her appointment

to the new office, nor did she inherit any vehicle.

QUESTION 378

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 3 July 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 5 of 2009

Mrs J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) Whether a function was held by her department to celebrate her appointment as minister; if so, (a) how much did the function cost, (b) what is the breakdown of the cost and (c) how many guests attended the function;

(2) whether there were any related costs for the travel and accommodation of guests; if so, (a) what were the costs and (b) what was the breakdown of these costs?

NW438E

REPLY

(1)(2) No celebration was held by the Department to celebrate my appointment as the new

Minister of Home affairs. All I had, was a teleconference on 24 June 2009, in Cape

Town to link with all Home Affairs offices, so as to communicate the StratPlan to the

staff and management, and to respond to questions raised by the staff.

QUESTION 1211

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 11 September 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 16 of 2009

Mrs J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) Whether her Deputy Minister or her department purchased a new vehicle on the Deputy Minister's appointment to office; if so,
(a) why, (b) what make and model is the vehicle, (c) what did the vehicle cost and (d)(i) what accessories were included in excess of the vehicle's purchase price and (ii) what was the cost of such accessories; if not,

(2) whether he inherited an existing vehicle; if so, (a) what was the make and model and (b) how old is the vehicle?

NW1550E

REPLY:

(1) No. The Department did not purchase a new vehicle on the Deputy Minister's appointment to office.

(2) Yes. The Deputy Minister inherited an existing vehicle.

(2)(a) The make is a BMW 530i, and it is a 2008 model.

(2)(b) The vehicle is one year old.

QUESTION 1804

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 16 October 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 22 OF 2009

Dr C P Mulder (FF Plus) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:†

(1) How many applications for work permits from people with critical skills have been received (a) in total and (b) from each country until the latest specified date for which information is available;

(2) how many (a) work permits have been issued (i) in total and (ii) per category in terms of the schedule of critical skills since publication of the schedule on 15 April 2008, (b) countries do the persons who have received work permits in terms of the critical skills work permit system hail from and (c) persons who have obtained such work permits hail from each of these countries; and

(3) how many of the work permits for persons with scarce skills have already been renewed since they were issued for the first time?

NW2305E

REPLY

(1)(a) Since the publication of the first Work Permit Quota List on
1 April 2006 (which made provision for the different types of categories) up to 31 August 2009, the Department of Home Affairs has received a total of 9 123 applications for quota work permits.

(1)(b) Statistics are not kept in respect of the number of work permits received, or issued per nationality.

(2)(a)(i) A total of 2 874 quota work permits have been issued, since
15 April 2008.

(2)(a)(ii) During the 2008/09 financial year, 1 380 quota permits were issued. Annexure A contains the breakdown. Since 1 April 2009, until 20 October 2009, 1 494 quota permits were issued. Annexure B provides a breakdown for this period.

(2)(b) & (c) The Department of Home Affairs does not keep statistics in respect of the number of work permits received, or issued per nationality, or country.

(3) The Department of Home Affairs does not keep statistics in respect of the type of category of work permits, which have been renewed.

Pease see the Annexure as attached.

QUESTION 1805

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 16 October 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 22 OF 2009

Dr C P Mulder (FF Plus) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(a) How many economic migrants are currently in South Africa and (b) what is their average period of stay in South Africa, (c) in which sectors of the economy are they employed and (d) what is their annual financial contribution to the economy? NW2306E

REPLY

We do not know. The Immigration Act, 2002 (Act No 13 of 2002), does not make provision for economic migrants. The said Act does not cater for a specific permit to be issued to such migrants, which implies that such migrants do not qualify to apply for work permits.

That is why we have asked the Cabinet to allow us to consult, first.

QUESTION 419

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 3 July 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 5 of 2009

Dr C P Mulder (FF Plus) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:†

(1) Whether it has been established that the new personal information processing system which she referred to in the National Assembly on 26 June 2009 has contributed to the safeguarding of passports in order to meet international safety standards; if not, why not; if so, (a) who came to this conclusion and (b) what were the details of this finding;

(2) (a) how much did this system cost, (b) how many officials have been trained to use the new system and (c) how much did this training cost?

NW480E

REPLY

(1)(a) & (b) The new personal information processing system referred to, entails the upgrading of the passport capturing, and enrolment processes to ensure higher standards of security to the passport application process, by ensuring that potential fraudulent activities are minimised. That includes enhancements with the likes of Live Capture, Biometric Access Control, and Photo Enhancement processes.

The benchmarking against the international standards, as enshrined in the

prescripts of the International Aviation Organisation (ICAO), and more and

above, the known weaknesses of the document, convinced us that our

passport security features require extensive upgrading.

There were various loopholes that inadvertently allow fraudulent activities with the passport capturing process, namely:

1.1 The two paper based photographs required with every application submission, allowed: (a) The swapping of photos of legitimate applicants with illegitimate ones. Photos of applicants were laminated onto the passport; of which fraudsters were able to remove, and paste illegal ones onto the passport document. (b) Photos submitted were often of poor quality, and didn't conform to the international requirements of picture quality, as stipulated in the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO). In effect, the Live Capture process was introduced to solve this problem. This ensures that photos are captured live onto the system at the time of application. That is, in the presence of the citizen, allowing recapturing, if needs be, to correct any quality and compliance, immediately, online, with automated software through digital cameras. Photos are digitally printed onto the passport. The applicant's record, together with pictures, is, then, transferred for printing to Government Printing Works (GPW). There is less intervention by officials, and this has resulted in minimising possible fraudulent activities.

During the transition from old passport system to the new one, the Department had to develop a solution (enhancement module) to deal with the bad quality pictures that were, already, captured in the old system which were not compliant to the ICAO standards. The enhancement module functionality was developed and introduced. This functionality enhances the photograph by fine tuning it, until it is at the correct resolution (colour, clarity etc). Progressively, the backlog, which was caused by bad quality pictures, has been reduced without asking applicants to have their pictures taken, again. In effect, the Live Capture has dramatically decreased the time to produce the Travel Document with a marked increase in quality.

Following these vital developments, we are in the process of rolling out the Live Capture system. Already, we have installed it in forty (40) Home Affairs offices, with one (1) station, in each of them, and we are hoping to have more, before the end of the financial year. However, because of financial constraints, we may not have it in every office.

1.2. Users within the Department, with the rights to perform activities, on the passport application system, were accessing the system using password authentication. With this mechanism, users would swap passwords, leave their workstations unattended, and, then, fraudsters would get an opportunity to tamper with the system. Even though, there was audit trail, it was not easy to link the fraudulent action to the owner of the password, as there was no conclusive proof that they, indeed, performed the transaction.

The Biometric Access login was, then, introduced for the passport application process. This solution uses the fingerprint authentication, and the Smart Card mechanism. Each time, a user has to perform critical functions on the system, they are required to authenticate themselves, using their fingerprints. The system does not allow progression to another step in the process, until authentication has been performed.

A non-repudiation database is kept for all transactions performed during the process of issuing passports, the specific user doing the transaction is linked, date, or time of the transaction. This is, in fact, admissible evidence in a court of law.

(2)(a)(b)(c) Cost of the Live Capture system:-R10 Million (for the recently completed 40

offices). Training costs are included.

Cost of Biometric Log - on system:–R29 million. (with 850 enrolled users)

Training costs are included.

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

FOR WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION 1789

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 16 October 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 22 OF 2009

Mrs J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

How many, (a) same sex marriages and (b) civil unions have there been since the Civil Unions, Act, Act 17 of 2006, was passed into law to allow such marriages? NW2289E

REPLY

We do not know. This will take too long to establish. If there is any particular one of interest, we could check that.

QUESTION 1788

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 16 October 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 22 OF 2009

Mrs J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) Whether her department has put any measures in place to address human trafficking; if not, why not; if so, what measures;

(2) whether any plans are to be implemented during the 2010 Fifa World Cup Soccer tournament to address human trafficking; if not, why not; if so, what plans?

NW2288E

REPLY

(1) Yes. The following measures were put in place:

All Immigration Officials have received training on Human Trafficking, offered by the International Organisation for Migration (IOM).
The Department, in conjunction with the IOM, is, also, currently, training facilitators, and assessors within the Department's Directorates: Central Law Enforcement, and Inspectorate, respectively, to roll out training to officials on implementation, once the Prevention and Combating of Trafficking in Persons Bill is enacted.
The Department of Home Affairs forms part of the National Task Team on Human Trafficking, which is led by the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA).

(2) Yes. The following measures are in place:

Perpetrators of Human Trafficking will be prosecuted, and dealt with in terms of the Immigration Act, 2002 (Act No 13 of 2002).
Provincial Tasks Teams have been established, in all nine Provinces. The Tasks Teams comprise the Department of Home Affairs, the South African Police, the Department of Social Services, the Department of Health, and the NPA.

QUESTION 742

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 14 August 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 9 of 2009

Mr J J McGluwa (ID) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

Whether her department will no longer issue smart card identity documents; if not, why not; if so, (a) when and (b) what are the further relevant details?

NW830E

REPLY

(a) & (b) No. The Smart Card Identity Document initiative remains one of the crucial plans of the Department. Cabinet mandated the Department of Home Affairs to replace the RSA National Identity Document with a Smart Identity Card (Smart ID Card). To this end, the Department initiated an open tender process for the supply of the Smart ID Card, which was managed by the State Information Technology Agency (SITA).

In the ensuing tender process, the Department was, subsequently, advised by SITA, in April 2009, that a forensic audit of the tender process was being carried out to investigate apparent irregularities. As at the end of August 2009, the Department had not been advised of the outcome of the forensic audit.

The Department has, since, cancelled the tender. Currently, we are in discussions with National Treasury to possibly allow us to start the process from scratch.

QUESTION 1737

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 10 October 2008

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 30 of 2008

Mr C M Lowe (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

For each of the past five years up to the latest specified date for which information is available, (a) what was the total amount spent by her department on bonuses or performance awards and (b) in each case, (i) how much was paid and (ii) what were the reasons for the bonus / performance award?

NW2521E

REPLY

2003/04 Performance Cycle:

(a) A total of R2,785,864.00 was paid to employees in lieu of performance/bonuses during this specific performance cycle.

(b)(i) A total number of 235 employees received bonuses / performance awards in this performance cycle. Due to the number of officials who qualified, the specific information can be made available separately to the Honourable Member at his request.

(b)(ii) The payment of incentive bonuses is granted to employees with twelve months continuous service in their specific ranks – at the end of March of each financial year. These incentive bonuses are only paid to officials with above and / or exceptional performance in terms of the agreed performance standard.

2004/05 Performance Cycle:

(a) A total of R15,710,338.48 was paid to employees in lieu of performance/bonuses during this specific performance cycle.

(b)(i) A total number of 2385 employees received bonuses / performance awards in this performance cycle. Due to the number of officials who qualified, the specific information can be made available separately to the Honourable Member at his request.

2005/06 Performance Cycle:

(a) A total of R20,628,249.63 was paid to employees in lieu of performance/bonuses during this specific performance cycle.

(b)(i) A total number of 2823 employees received bonuses / performance awards in this performance cycle. Due to the number of officials who qualified, the specific information can be made available separately to the Honourable Member at his request.

2006/07 Performance Cycle:

(a) A total of R12,112,346.42 was paid to employees paid to employees in lieu of performance/bonuses during this specific performance cycle.

(b)(i) A total number of 2411 employees received bonuses / performance awards in this performance cycle. Due to the number of officials who qualified, the specific information can be made available separately to the Honourable Member at his request.

2007/08 Performance Cycle:

(a) & (b) (i) The Department of Home Affairs is still in the process of processing the performance awards for this specific performance cycle and a final amount and the number of officials who were awarded performance awards can, at this stage, not yet be provided.

QUESTION 1738

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 10 October 2008

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 30 of 2008

Mr C M Lowe (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) Whether her department's turnaround strategy has had any successes with regard to its financial management in view of the fact that her department has not achieved a clean audit report from the Auditor-General since its introduction; if so, what are the relevant details on which this conclusion is based;

(2) what are some of the other major policy (a) successes and (b) failures of her department under her leadership?

NW2522E

REPLY

(1) Yes. Listed below are the major improvements being put in place to ensure better financial management.

(i) A specific organisational structure has been established in the Department. Its main function is aimed to better current financial management in the Department and to facilitate effective financial management. This will ensure proper accountability.

(ii) The new structure will also ensure that effective financial management structures are put in place in the Provinces / Zones in terms of revenue administration and expenditure management as well as sound procurement systems.

(iii) Various governance structures, which include amongst others, a Compliance Unit, a Loss Control Committee and a Monitoring and Evaluation Unit have also been established within the Chief Directorate: Finance and Supply Chain Management. The purpose of these units is to ensure proper compliance with the Public Finance Management Act as well as to correctly enforce Treasury Regulations.

(iv) The Department's Asset Management system has also been revisited and a proper Asset Register now exists. All the necessary measures are implemented to ensure that asset management in the Department is compliant with the National Treasury's requirements in this regard.

(v) A Receipting Solution is also being piloted to address revenue management in the Department.

(vi) All delegations regarding financial management / authority as well as financial policies and procedures have been updated.

(vii) A five year Immigration Control Account Financial Statement has been compiled according to general accepted audit practices. It has been submitted to the Auditor General for auditing purposes.

(viii) A Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) has been drafted between the Department and the Department of Foreign Affairs and is awaiting final signature between the two Departments. The purpose of this MOU is to better facilitate accounting for financial transactions taking place abroad at the SA Foreign Offices. To date, all vouchers received from the Department of Foreign Affairs have been verified and the Department is awaiting final payment from the Department of Foreign Affairs to post these transactions to the relevant items on the Department's budget.

(2)The Public Finance Management Act provides the policy framework with regard to management of finances in the department. To the extent that we are addressing the compliance issues relating to the PFMA as stated in (1) above, we are certain that this represents policy success in this regard.

QUESTION 1704

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 26 September 2008

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 29 of 2008

Mr C M Lowe (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

In respect of the 2006-07 and 2007-08 annual reports of her department and the annual reports of each statutory and other entity reporting to her, (a) what was the (i) budgeted cost, (ii) actual cost and (iii) unit cost of each annual report and (b) how many copies of each were (i) produced and (ii) distributed?

NW2484E

REPLY

Department of Home Affairs:

Entity

(a)(i)

Budgeted cost

(a)(ii)

Actual cost

(a)(iii)

Unit cost

(b)(i)

Produced

(b)(ii)

Distributed

Department of Home Affairs – 2006/07

R257 062.20

Design and layout

R65 817.90

Printing

R191 244.30

Total

R257 062.20

R51.41

5000

+/- 4870 copies were distributed.

The remaining number will be transferred to Knowledge and Information Management Directorate (KIM)

Department of Home Affairs – 2007/08

R363 753.80

Design and layout

R87 780.00

Printing

R275 973.80

Total

R363 753.80

R121.25

3000

Copies of the document have not yet been distributed

Independent Electoral Commission:

Entity

(a)(i)

Budgeted cost

(a)(ii)

Actual cost

(a)(iii)

Unit cost

(b)(i)

Produced

(b)(ii)

Distributed

Electoral Commission – 2006/07

145 000.00

Design and layout

R33 585

Printing

R66 415.23

Total

R100 000

R49.99

2 000

1 700. Balance for archiving

Electoral Commission – 2007/08

R145 000.00

Design and layout

R28 000.00

Printing

R133 540.00

Total

R161 540.00

R80.77

2,000

1,990. Balance for archiving.

Film and Publication Board:

Entity

(a)(i)

Budgeted cost

(a)(ii)

Actual cost

(a)(iii)

Unit cost

(b)(i)

Produced

(b)(ii)

Distributed

Film and Publication Board

– 2006/07

R120 000

Design and layout

R33 500.00

Printing

R57 666.00

Total Incl vat

R103 929.24

R51.96

2000

+/-1500

The remaining will be distributed to various stakeholders before financial year end.

Department of Home Affairs – 2007/08

R150 000

Total

R148 000

R74.00

2000

500 copies sent to parliament.

The balance have not yet been distributed

QUESTION 1266

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 11 September 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 16 of 2009

Mrs J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(a) How many mobile units does her department currently own in each province,
(b) in which provinces do they operate, (c) what are the operating times and (d) how many officials man a unit at any given time?
NW1611E

REPLY:

The Department currently owns and operates one hundred and seventeen (117) Mobile Units. The information for (a) to (d) is provided in the table, below:

Zone / Province	Number of Units	Operating time start	Operating time end	Number of officials
Zone 1 Kwazulu-Natal	16	09:30 or depending on the distance travelled per Unit	15:00 or until the last applicant / client has been attended to	Three (3) – the driver and two (2) administration clerks
Zone 1 Mpumalanga	12	09:00 or depending on the distance travelled per Unit	15:00 or depending on the distance travelled between the service point and the office of departure	Three (3) – the driver and two (2) administration clerks
Zone 2 Free State	11	08:00	Until all applicants / clients have been attended to	Three (3) – the driver and two (2) administration clerks
Zone 2 Northern Cape	12	10:00 or depending on the distance travelled per Unit	Until all applicants / clients have been attended to	Three (3) – the driver and two (2) administration clerks
Zone 2 North West	11	08:00	Until all applicants / clients have been attended to	Three (3) – the driver and two (2) administration clerks
Zone 3 Western Cape	12	09:00 or depending on the distance travelled per Unit	15:00 or until the last applicant / client has been attended to	Three (3) – the driver and two (2) administration clerks
Zone 3 Eastern Cape	17	09:00 or depending on the distance travelled per Unit	15:00 or until the last applicant / client has been attended to	Three (3) – the driver and two (2) administration clerks
Zone 4 Gauteng	10	08:30	15:00 or until the last applicant / client has been attended to	Three (3) – the driver and two (2) administration clerks
Zone 4 Limpopo	16	09:00 or depending on the distance travelled per Unit	15:00 or until the last applicant / client has been attended to	Three (3) – the driver and two (2) administration clerks

QUESTION 1264

Mr. A Louw (DA) to ask the Minister of Labour:

(1) Whether the practice of labour brokering has been outlawed; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

(2) whether he has formulated a plan to address the reduction of training opportunities that would follow the outlawing of labour brokering; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW1609E

WRITTEN REPLY

No, there is nothing in our law that refers to the concept of labour broking. The so-called labour brokers legitimised themselves through the use of the provisions of the law that regulate temporary employment services.

In terms of our skills development legislation workplace skills could be accessed by any other employer or workplace. Therefore, employers could still make use of workplace skills training to develop their personnel.

QUESTION 1423

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 11 September 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 16 OF 2009

Dr H C van Schalkwyk (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) Whether the persons from the State Information Technology Agency (Sita) responsible for the leaks which led to the cancelling of a tender to issue smart identity cards have been identified; if not, why not; if so,

(2) whether they have been investigated; if not, why not; if so, what steps were taken against them;

(3) whether the Auditor-General's report on procurement practices will be made available; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, when?

NW1780E

REPLY

(1) to (3) It is suggested that the Honourable Member directs his request for the information to the Honourable Minister of Public Service and Administration, as the State Information Technology Agency resorts under his jurisdiction.

QUESTION 2086

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Monday, 2 November 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 26 OF 2009

Mrs S V Kalyan (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

Whether her department has a strategy in place to deal with the impacts of climate change on migration within Southern Africa; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

NW2742E

REPLY

No.

QUESTION 1111

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 4 September 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 13 of 2009

Mrs J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

How many vacancies were there as at 30 April 2009 for (a) counter staff, (b) supervisors and (c) management at each office in KwaZulu-Natal?

NW1374E

REPLY

Abbreviations: RO: Regional Office

DO: District Office

BP: Border Post

The number of vacant posts relating to Civic Services at each office in KwaZulu-Natal:

OFFICE	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGERS
RO: UMLAZI	0	0	1
PORT OF ENTRY: DURBAN HARBOUR	0	0	0
INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DURBAN	1	0	0
DO: PROSPECTON	12	1	1
DO: UMBUMBULU	0	1	0
RO: ETHEKWINI	15	0	0
DO: COMMERCIAL ROAD	4	1	1
DO: PINETOWN	12	1	0
RO: NDWEDWE	0	0	1
DO: TONGAAT	2	0	0
DO: KWADUKUZA	4	0	0
DO: PHOENIX	1	2	0
DO: MAPHUMULO	2	0	0
DO: KWAMASHU	2	0	0
RO: UGU	4	2	1
DO: KOKSTAD	1	1	0
DO: SCOTTBURGH	4	2	0
DO: IXOPO	4	1	0
DO: UMZIMKULU.	1	0	0
RO: AMAJUBA	7	2	1
DO: LADYSMITH	10	1	0
DO: ESTCOURT	2	2	0
DO MSINGA	1	0	0
DO: NQUTU	1	0	0
DO: DUNDEE	1	0	0
RO: ZULULAND	17	3	0
DO: NGOTSHANE	2	0	0
DO: NONGOMA	4	0	0
DO: VRYHEID	9	1	1
DO: NKANDLA	2	0	0
RO: UTHUNGULU	2	3	1
DO: EMPANGENI	3	1	0
DO: MTUBATUBA	11	0	0
DO: HLUHLUWE	5	1	0
DO: INGWAVUMA	2	0	0
DO: ESHOWE	5	1	0
BP: GOLELA	2	0	0
BP: KOSI BAY	0	0	0
BP: ONVERWACHT	0	0	0
BP: SANI PASS	0	0	0
BP: BOESMANSNEK	0	0	0
RO: UMGUNGUNDLOVU	15	3	1
DO: GREYTOWN	3	0	0
TOTAL	173	30	9

The number of vacant posts relating to Immigration Services at each office in
KwaZulu-Natal:

OFFICE	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGERS
RO: UMLAZI	0	1	1
PORT OF ENTRY: DURBAN HARBOUR	5	2	0
INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DURBAN	4	1	0
DO: PROSPECTON	0	0	0
DO: UMBUMBULU	0	0	0
RO: ETHEKWINI	3	1	1
DO: COMMERCIAL ROAD	0	0	0
DO: PINETOWN	0	0	0
RO: NDWEDWE	0	1	0
DO: TONGAAT	0	0	0
DO: KWADUKUZA	0	0	0
DO: PHOENIX	0	0	0
DO: MAPHUMULO	0	0	0
DO: KWAMASHU	0	0	0
RO: UGU	1	0	1
DO: KOKSTAD	0	0	0
DO: SCOTTBURGH	0	0	0
DO: IXOPO	0	0	0
DO UMZIMKULU.	2	1	0
RO: AMAJUBA	2	1	1
DO: LADYSMITH	0	0	0
DO: ESTCOURT	0	0	0
DO MSINGA	0	0	0
DO: NQUTU	0	0	0
DO: DUNDEE	0	0	0
RO: ZULULAND	0	1	1
DO: NGOTSHANE	0	1	0
DO: NONGOMA	0	0	0
DO: VRYHEID	0	0	0
DO: NKANDLA	0	0	0
RO: UTHUNGULU	5	1	1
DO: EMPANGENI	0	0	0
DO: MTUBATUBA	0	0	0
DO: HLUHLUWE	0	0	0
DO: INGWAVUMA	1	1	0
DO: ESHOWE	0	0	0
BP: GOLELA	5	1	0
BP: KOSI BAY	0	0	0
BP: ONVERWACHT	0	0	0
BP: SANI PASS	0	0	0
BP: BOESMANSNEK	0	0	0
RO: UMGUNGUNDLOVU	0	0	1
DO: GREYTOWN	0	0	0
TOTAL	28	13	7

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

FOR WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION 1111

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 4 September 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 13 of 2009

Mrs J F Terblanche (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

How many vacancies were there as at 30 April 2009 for (a) counter staff, (b) supervisors and (c) management at each office in KwaZulu-Natal?
NW1374E

REPLY

Abbreviations: RO: Regional Office
DO: District Office
BP: Border Post

The number of vacant posts relating to Civic Services at each office in KwaZulu-Natal:

OFFICE	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGERS
RO: UMLAZI	0	0	1
PORT OF ENTRY: DURBAN HARBOUR	0	0	0
INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DURBAN	1	0	0
DO: PROSPECTON	12	1	1
DO: UMBUMBULU	0	1	0
RO: ETHEKWINI	15	0	0
DO: COMMERCIAL ROAD	4	1	1
DO: PINETOWN	12	1	0
RO: NDWEDWE	0	0	1
DO: TONGAAT	2	0	0
DO: KWADUKUZA	4	0	0
DO: PHOENIX	1	2	0
DO: MAPHUMULO	2	0	0
DO: KWAMASHU	2	0	0
RO: UGU	4	2	1
DO: KOKSTAD	1	1	0
DO: SCOTTBURGH	4	2	0
DO: IXOPO	4	1	0
DO: UMZIMKULU.	1	0	0
RO: AMAJUBA	7	2	1
DO: LADYSMITH	10	1	0
DO: ESTCOURT	2	2	0
DO MSINGA	1	0	0
DO: NQUTU	1	0	0
DO: DUNDEE	1	0	0
RO: ZULULAND	17	3	0
DO: NGOTSHANE	2	0	0
DO: NONGOMA	4	0	0
DO: VRYHEID	9	1	1
DO: NKANDLA	2	0	0
RO: UTHUNGULU	2	3	1
DO: EMPANGENI	3	1	0
DO: MTUBATUBA	11	0	0
DO: HLUHLUWE	5	1	0
DO: INGWAVUMA	2	0	0
DO: ESHOWE	5	1	0
BP: GOLELA	2	0	0
BP: KOSI BAY	0	0	0
BP: ONVERWACHT	0	0	0
BP: SANI PASS	0	0	0
BP: BOESMANSNEK	0	0	0
RO: UMGUNGUNDLOVU	15	3	1
DO: GREYTOWN	3	0	0
TOTAL	173	30	9

The number of vacant posts relating to Immigration Services at each office in
KwaZulu-Natal:

OFFICE	COUNTER STAFF	SUPERVISORS	MANAGERS
RO: UMLAZI	0	1	1
PORT OF ENTRY: DURBAN HARBOUR	5	2	0
INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DURBAN	4	1	0
DO: PROSPECTON	0	0	0
DO: UMBUMBULU	0	0	0
RO: ETHEKWINI	3	1	1
DO: COMMERCIAL ROAD	0	0	0
DO: PINETOWN	0	0	0
RO: NDWEDWE	0	1	0
DO: TONGAAT	0	0	0
DO: KWADUKUZA	0	0	0
DO: PHOENIX	0	0	0
DO: MAPHUMULO	0	0	0
DO: KWAMASHU	0	0	0
RO: UGU	1	0	1
DO: KOKSTAD	0	0	0
DO: SCOTTBURGH	0	0	0
DO: IXOPO	0	0	0
DO UMZIMKULU.	2	1	0
RO: AMAJUBA	2	1	1
DO: LADYSMITH	0	0	0
DO: ESTCOURT	0	0	0
DO MSINGA	0	0	0
DO: NQUTU	0	0	0
DO: DUNDEE	0	0	0
RO: ZULULAND	0	1	1
DO: NGOTSHANE	0	1	0
DO: NONGOMA	0	0	0
DO: VRYHEID	0	0	0
DO: NKANDLA	0	0	0
RO: UTHUNGULU	5	1	1
DO: EMPANGENI	0	0	0
DO: MTUBATUBA	0	0	0
DO: HLUHLUWE	0	0	0
DO: INGWAVUMA	1	1	0
DO: ESHOWE	0	0	0
BP: GOLELA	5	1	0
BP: KOSI BAY	0	0	0
BP: ONVERWACHT	0	0	0
BP: SANI PASS	0	0	0
BP: BOESMANSNEK	0	0	0
RO: UMGUNGUNDLOVU	0	0	1
DO: GREYTOWN	0	0	0
TOTAL	28	13	7

QUESTION 1104

DATE OF PUBLICATION: Friday, 4 September 2009

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER NO 14 of 2009

Ms M R Shinn (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs:

(1) Whether, with reference to the expected increased tourist traffic for the Fifa 2010 World Cup Soccer tournament, her department will recruit and train additional immigration officials to process visitors on arrival and departure; if not, why not; if so, (a) what plans are in place in this regard and (b) how many additional officials will be recruited and trained;

(2) whether any budget has been allocated for (a) training and (b) salaries of such officials; if not, why not; if so, what are the amounts?

NW1365E

REPLY

(1)(a)&(b) Yes. A total of 143 critical posts have been advertised by the Chief Directorate: Port Control to improve immigration capacity at Ports of Entry. These additional recruited, and trained immigration officials will be deployed to support immigration operations at selected Ports of Entry during the FIFA 2010 World Cup, but will, also, ensure sustainable operations, and improved service delivery to the public, beyond the FIFA 2010 World Cup tournament.

(2)(a) & (b) An amount of ±R25,700,000.00 has been allocated for the filling of these positions, and training of the successful candidates.

02 December 2009 - Question:Minister of Cooperative Governance

MPs to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and TraditionalAffairs

Source
Link

Reply:

NATIONAL COUNCIL OF PROVINCES

WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NO 827

(Internal Question Paper No 29 - 2009)

Mr M H Hoosen (ID) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional

Affairs:

What amounts were paid in constituency/party funding by municipalities to each (a) party and (b) councillor in the 2008-09 financial year?

ANSWER

The Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs does not monitor constituency/party funding by municipalities. As a result the department does not have this information at its disposal.

QUESTION 828

FOR WRITTEN REPLY

Date of publication on internal question paper: 21 August 2009

Internal question paper no: 10

Interdepartmental transfer from Health on 11 September 2009

QUESTION NO 2305

(Internal Question Paper No 29 - 2009)

Mr A P van der Westhuizen (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

Whether his department has taken any steps to ensure that the original allocation and the extra allocation of R288 million for the 2009-10 financial year will be spent on municipal infrastructure only and not on running costs; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW3011E

Answer

Yes. The department has the following monitoring systems in place to ensure that the Municipal Infrastructure Grant (MIG) funds allocated to municipalities are spent for the intended purpose:

Project Registration

Municipalities are required to register the projects that will be implemented utilizing the MIG allocation. Projects are registered on the MIS system and are evaluated to ensure that they meet the MIG conditions.

Division of Revenue Act (DORA) Expenditure Report

The municipalities are required to submit monthly DORA expenditure reports. The expenditure of municipalities is monitored on a monthly basis and where a municipality is under-spending the funds for the following month will be withheld.

Project List

On the monthly project list municipalities are required to report on expenditure against each project that is implemented utilizing the MIG allocation.

Furthermore the monitoring role of the provinces will be strengthened to provide random site visits to the projects that are being implemented. The Department is also in a process of finalizing the partnership with the Special Investigation Unit (SIU). The SIU will assist the department in strengthening the monitoring systems by site visits and verification of expenditure against the implemented projects.

NATIONAL COUNCIL OF PROVINCES

WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NO 1546

(Internal Question Paper No 29 - 2009)

Mrs M Wenger (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional

Affairs:

1. What is the (a) name of each of the 17 municipalities that have not implemented the Local Government: Municipal Property Rates Act, Act 6 of 2004, and (b) reason for the non-implementation;

2. whether he will provide any assistance to ensure that these municipalities comply; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

3. whether there will be any financial implications in this regard; if so, from which Budget will this be funded?

Answer

1. According to the Department's records, there are 13 municipalities that have not complied with the implementation of the Local Government: Municipal Property Rates Act, Act 6 of 2004. This figure represents statistics provided to the Department by the provincial departments responsible for local government as at 30 July 2009.

NATIONAL COUNCIL OF PROVINCES

WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NO 2031

(Internal Question Paper No 29 - 2009)

Dr A Lotriet (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

1. Whether his department has determined the extent of the damage caused during the protests in lntabazwe in the Eastern Free State; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

2. whether his department has determined the reasons for these protests; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

3. Whether he has taken any steps to deal with the reasons; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW2683E

Answer

1. The department has not done assessment of the damages caused by any protests in Intabazwe in the Maluti a Phofung municipality

2. The department is supporting the task team in the determination of the actual reasons for the protest

3. The Free State Government is attending the grievances of the Intabazwe community and has formed a task team comprising of members of the community and government representatives.

QUESTION NO. 57

(Internal Question Paper No 57- 2009)

Ms M Wenger (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

(1) How many people have been charged with the practice of Ukuthwalwa in each of the past five years;

(2) whether any measures have been put in place to avoid further occurrences of this practice; if not, why not; if so, what measures;

(3) whether he has had or will have any interaction with traditional leaders in an attempt to prevent it from happening again; if not, why not: if so, what are the relevant details?

Answer

(1) According to information provided by Office of the Cluster Commander of SAPS in Port St Johns, cases presently reported at Mtontsasa Police Station are eleven (11). Four (4) cases are for abduction and seven (7) for abduction and rape. A task team has been established to deal with these cases. There are no statistics available at this police station that similar cases were reported or people were charged in the past five years on this practice (report from Mtontsasa Police Station is attached for ease of reference)

(2) Measures taken by the Eastern Cape Government include an ongoing outreach program led by the Human Rights Commission in the province to educate the community about this practice.

(3) YES, there was Interaction amongst the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs, Mr S Shiceka. Minister of Women, Children and Persons with Disability Ms N Mayende-Sibiya. Minister of Police, Mr N Mthethwa and the Traditional Leaders at Qaukeni Great Place on 26 June 2009. It was resolved to clamp down on the practice and for Traditional Leaders to work jointly with government. This decision was supported by the Provincial House and CONTRALESA.

QUESTION NO. 75
(Internal Question Paper No 75- 2009)

Mr M H Steele (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

(1) Whether he has been informed about the delay in publishing the findings of the forensic investigation of the uMngeni Municipality by the KwaZulu-Natal member of the executive committee (MEC) for local Government in 2007; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details;

(2) whether he has been informed about the delay in acting upon the recommendations of the findings of the said MEC's forensic investigation of the Msunduzi Municipality, which were tabled before that council in 2007; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details;

(3) whether he will take any steps to achieve a resolution of the issues identified in these forensic investigations; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW77E

Answer

(1) No. The MEC for Local Government in KwaZulu-Natal is engaging the Executive Committee of uMngeni Municipality to ensure that the findings and recommendations of the forensic investigation report are implement~d.

(2) No. The KwaZulu-Natal Department of Local Government and Traditional Affairs is engaging the municipality on this matter. The Municipal Manager of Msunduzi Municipality has committed that the matters raised are being addressed.

(3) The MEC will be engaging the provincial executive to ensure that the municipalities comply and implement the recommendations of the forensic reports. Should municipalities not comply accordingly, legal action would be considered against them.

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY (WRITTEN REPLY): PARLIAMENTARY QUESTION NO. 75/2009: MR M H STEELE (DA) TO ASK THE: MINISTER OF COOPERATIVE GOVERNANCE AND TRADITIONAL AFFAIRS

QUESTION 1

Whether he has been informed about the delay in publishing the findings of the forensic Investigation of the uMngeni Municipality by the KwaZulu-Natal member of the executive committee (MEC) for Local Government In 2007; If not, what Is the position In this regard: If so, what are the relevant details:

ANSWER 1

No. the MEC is engaging the EXCO of Umngeni Municipality in order to ensure that the findings and recommendations on the forensic investigation report are implemented.

QUESTION 2

Whether he has been informed about the delay in acting upon the recommendations of the findings of the said MEC's forensic investigation of the Msunduzi Municipality, which were tabled before that council in 2007; If not, what is the position In this regard; if so, what are the relevant details;

ANSWER 2

No. the Department-of Local Government and Traditional Affairs - KZN is engaging the municipality on this matter. The Municipal Manager has committed that the matters highlighted in the Investigation report are being addressed.

QUESTION 3

Whether he will take any steps to achieve a resolution of the Issues Identified in these forensic investigations; If not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

ANSWER 3

The MEC will be engaging the Provincial Executive to ensure that the Municipalities comply. Should Municipalities not comply, legal measures will be considered.

QUESTION NO 68

(Internal Question Paper No XXX - 2009)

Mrs N M Mdaka (ANC) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

What measures does his department have in place to improve the capacity of provincial departments to monitor municipalities in their jurisdiction?

ANSWER

Provincial supervision, monitoring and support of local government is a constitutional obligation in terms of sections 154 (1) and Section 155 (6) and (7) of the Constitution. To give effect to these obligations, the departments for local government were established with the specific mandate to oversee and support municipalities. However, as increasing performance challenges build up within the local sphere, government initiated a comprehensive assessment of these departments' capabilities as well as those of the Offices of the Premiers.

The Department needed to get an understanding of the pressure points in these provincial departments, and investigated each entities' capacity, organisational structure, resource base, management of intergovernmental relations and coordination capacity. Findings demonstrated wide provincial variations among the capacity of these departments to manage their constitutional obligations. Most local government departments were found to be underresourced, receiving only, on average, 3.5% of the provincial budget (excluding Health, Education and Social Development).

Further, only 2% (average result) of staff are above salary grade 11, making these departments extremely 'bottom-heavy' with the result that the required skills and knowledge in these departments is largely lacking. With low budgets, low skills levels, and no specific internal structure dedicated to the monitoring and oversight of municipalities, it became clear that monitoring and support has been poorly resourced, and has received insufficient focus from national government.

Thus, while the previously constituted Department of Provincial and Local Government (dplg) had a very limited focus on Provincial Government, the new Department of Co-operative Governance and Traditional Affairs (CGTA) has recognised the need to fully engage with provincial government. It has now adopted an extended mandate to support and monitor the full scope of provincial functions.

In this context, CGT A has made it one of its key priorities to build the developmental state in provincial and local government by making the execution of mandates by these levels of government more effective, efficient, accountable and responsive.

The following measures are set out in the Strategic Plan of CGT A (2009-2014) to ensure better provincial and municipal capacity:

· Review and strengthen the current IGR Act and other legislation;

· Strengthen legislative provisions to intervene directly in provincial and local government;

· Re-organise the department to better provide hands-on support to provinces and municipalities;

· Strengthen and support institutional and co-operative governance capacity;

· Enhance monitoring and oversight of provincial and local government; and

· Strengthening of the capacity of provinces to achieve clean audits and to support and oversee municipalities in relation to financial management.

The Turn-Around Strategy for Local Government which will be finalized in December 2009 will bring Provinces centre stage in their revived role of municipal support and oversight. All sector departments, the Offices of the Premiers and the Provincial Treasuries will work cooperatively with local and national spheres of government to strengthen and stabilise our municipalities.

Finally, the national Department intends to establish offices in each province which enable the Department to playa stronger complementary support and monitoring role with regard to the support that must be given to provinces and municipalities

NATIONAL COUNCIL OF PROVINCES

WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NO 1892
(Internal Question Paper No 29 - 2009)

Mrs M Wenger (DA) to ask the Minister for Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

1. Whether he will take any steps with regard to the Sedibeng Local municipality's inability to prevent spillages from the regional sewerage works due to a lack of funds; if not, (a) why not and (b) who will be held responsible; if so, what steps;

2. whether he and or his department intends giving assistance to the communities of Emfuleni and Midvaal if the target is not met and spillages occur; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

3. Where and (b) when will the funding for the project be sourced from? NW2454E

Answer

1. (a) The Minister of cooperative government and traditional Affairs has conducted a Water and Sanitation Audit, to establish the state of infrastructure in the country. In terms of the National Water Act and Water Services Act, the Minister of Water and Environmental Affairs has already taken legal action against both Emfuleni Local Municipality and Midvaal Local Municipalities to enforce legislative compliance at affected Waste Water treatment Works in the region.

2. (b)This process is running parallel to the support programme to these municipalities to ensure that sustainable compliance is attained to protect the natural water resource (Vaal River and Vaal Barrage) in this area.2.1 The Gauteng Department and the Department of Water Affairs in collaboration with the CoGT A have provided technical experts to support the municipality to:

 Conduct root cause analysis at all regional water care works and to identify priority short term measures to arrest non compliance in terms of effluent, plant status and staff compliance.

 Implement all priority measures as a matter of emergency procurement, where necessary

 Assist Emfuleni Local Municipality to procure the services of Rand Water to take over the operations and management of all non compliant waste water treatment plants to compliment the human capacity of Emfuleni as well as providing expertise to implement interim priority measures required

3. (a) and (b) The Department of Water and Environmental Affairs Department has provided funding to both Emfuleni and Midvaal in the amount of R17m to implement priority measures necessary in the short term to arrest the situation, with necessary support from Rand Water and experts referred to above.

The Gauteng Provincial Governmental provided an amount of R50m in last financial year to assist the Municipalities to procure expertise to implement a long term solution in accordance with applicable legislation (MFMA, MSA, Water Services Act, etc.). This process is currently in progress with the following being the key deliverables:

NATIONAL COUNCIL OF PROVINCES

WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NO 1891

(Internal Question Paper No 29 - 2009)

Mrs M Wenger (DA) to ask the Minister for Cooperative Governance and Traditional

Affairs:

1. Whether, with reference to his reply to Question 1323 on 14 October 2009, he has been informed of the report on the visit of the Minister of Human Settlements to Thokoza on the East Rand; if so, what (a) action will be taken and (b) are the further relevant details;

2. whether he has been informed of the conditions under which these individuals are living; if so,

3. whether any action will be taken to address the situation; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW2453E

Answer

1. The Minister is aware of the report on the visit of the Minister of Human Settlements in Thokoza and it is the jurisdiction of the Minister of Human Settlement to implement the recommendations of the report and actions.
2. The report entails the state of affairs in as far as hostel settlement is concerned;

3. The Minister of Human Settlement is well positioned to address the situation and such details reside with the Ministry.

NATIONAL COUNCIL OF PROVINCES

WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NO 1890

(Internal Question Paper No 29 - 2009)

Mrs M Wenger (DA) to ask the Minister for Cooperative Governance and Traditional

Affairs:

1. (a) Who were the members of the task team that was sent to Sakhile township in Mpumalanga after the violent demonstrations in September and October 2009 and (b) on what basis was every individual included in the task team;

2. (a) what did the task team investigate, (b) who did the task team report back to, (c)

when did they report back and (d) what were their findings;

3. whether any of the rioters have been identified; if not, why not; if so,

4. whether any action will be taken against them; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

5. whether he has visited the area and addressed the community; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW2452E

Answer

1. (a) The Department of Co-operative Governance and Traditional, following the unrest in Sakhile township of Lekwa Municipality, comprised a team of experts comprising of senior officials in the national and provincial government to support the municipality to Acting Municipal Manager and Chief Financial Officer (CFO). The Department further appointed a Financial Task Team which was led by the Chief Financial Officer (CFO) to do a financial analysis of the municipality. (b) The members of the task team were chosen based on their expertise dictated by the situation in the Municipality.

2. (a) Investigate and resolve the challenges arising from the reported highly misstated consumer accounts. (b) The task team reported to the Department of Co-operative Governance and Traditional Affairs. (c) The ask Team reported during the Month of October.

3. The SAPS is investigating the riots and they are currently dealing with the rioters in terms of the law.

4. The response on question 3 addresses the concern on question 4.

5. No visit was undertaken specifically by the Minister to address the community but this was done by the Premier and the ruling party with the support of the Minister.

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NO 510

(Internal Question Paper No 6 - 2009)

Mrs M Wenger (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

Whether any function was organised to mark the occasion of the delivery of his budget vote in 2009; if so, (a) what total amount was spent on this function, (b) from which budget was the money allocated, (c) what amount was spent on (i) food and refreshments, (ii) venue, (iii) entertainment, (iv) staff and (v) transport and (d) how many persons were invited to attend this function? NW573E

ANSWER

A function was organised to mark the occasion of the delivery of the Minister's budget vote in 2009.

(a) Total amount spent on the function: R 67 768.70

(b) The amount was allocated from departmental activities budget. (c) Amount spent on:-

(i) Food and refreshments: R 42 812.50

(ii) Venue: R 2 169.70

(iii) Entertainment: R 22 786.50

(iv) Staff: N/A

(v) Transport: N/A

(d) 125 persons were invited to attend the function.

NATIONAL COUNCIL OF PROVINCES

WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NO 444

(Internal Question Paper No 29 - 2009)

Mr T Botha (Cope) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

(a) What were the achievements of the urban renewal programme in the cities that were targeted for renewal and (b) what monetary support was given to each approved site? NW505E

Answer

(a) There have been significant achievements in the nodal areas. Eight urban nodes were established in 2001 with the intention to "conduct a sustained campaign against urban poverty and underdevelopment, bringing in the resources of all three spheres of government in a co-ordinated manner' (State of the Nation Address, 2001). In 2008, a survey 1 done by the Department of Social Development (DSD) found that poverty levels in the urban nodes (with the exception of Kwa Mashu, where demarcation is impacting on the data) dropped significantly, compared to Census information from 1996 and 2001.

The poverty index on which this finding was based included 10 variables namely, incidence of female-headed households, illiteracy, unemployment, lack of household income, over-crowding, informal or traditional dwellings, lack of sanitation, water below RDP standards, lack of electricity for lighting purposes, and lack of refuse removal. The following graph illustrates the drop in poverty levels found in the urban nodes:

Khayelitsha	31.8	31.5	22.3
Galeshewe	23.2	23.4	20
Inanda*	55.4	40.5	26.9
Mdantsane	32.8	28.6	17.6
Alexandra	26.5	24.4	18.2
Mitchell's Plain*	22.6	20.3	8.6
Motherwell	22.4	30.7	16.3
Kwa Mashu*	18.2	24.5	18.7
ALL URP nodes	29.2	27.1	18.7

*Demarcation impacting on data

For an example, in Alexandra, City of Johannesburg, the percentage of households:

living in informal dwellings were reduced from 32.3% in 2001 to 14.8% by 2008
without flush or chemical toilets were reduced from 12.6% in 2001 to 3.6% by 2008
without tap water inside their dwellings or on site were reduced from 27.3% in 2001 to 9.2% by 2008
without electricity for lighting purposes were reduced from 27.9% in 2001 to 1.2% by 2008 .
dwellings or on site were reduced from 68.3% in 2001 to 24.8% by 2008
without electricity for lighting purposes were reduced from 29.7% in 2001 to 8.4% by 2008

In Khayelitsha, City of Cape Town, the percentage of households

living in informal dwellings were reduced from 66.6% in 2001 to 50% by 2008
without flush or chemical toilets were reduced from 35% in 2001 to 15.6% by 2008
without tap water inside their dwellings or on site were reduced from 38.5% in 2001 to 18.4% by 2008 .
without electricity for lighting purposes were reduced from 23.9% in 2001 to 8.4% by 2008
without regular refuse removal by the local authority from 5% in 2001 to 2.8% by 2008

(b) The urban nodes have over the years attracted some funding despite the programme not having a dedicated fund. The socio-economic projects were funded from different sources including Municipal Infrastructure Grant, Neighbourhood Partnership Development Grant and the European Union. Some examples of funding flows are depicted in the Tables hereTables

NATIONAL COUNCIL OF PROVINCES

WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NO 449

(Internal Question Paper No 29 - 2009)

Mr P J Groenewald (FF Plus) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

1. How many municipalities against which protest actions were launched between 1 June 2004 and 30 June 2009 (a) were incorporated in Project Consolidated and (b) remain part of the Five-year Strategic Agenda for Local Government

;

2. which of the municipalities where incidents of rioting, demonstrations and protest actions because of no or poor service delivery took place is experiencing a shortage of municipal staff and (b) what is the shortage in each municipality;

3. at which of the municipalities where incidents of rioting, demonstrations and protest actions because of no or poor service delivery took place (a) did service delivery improve or (b) were services delivered regarding which protest actions took place in order to prevent new incidents? NW510E

Answer

1. A total of about 14 municipalities were part of Project Consolidate and the same number still remains part of the 5Year Strategic Agenda for Local Government,

2. The department has not conducted a comprehensive analysis of the municipal organizational structures in terms of funded and filled posts at municipal level. Currently the department does not possess information on whether the 14 municipalities are experiencing shortage of municipal staff.

3. Services continue to be provided by these municipalities and where there were deficiencies municipalities are managing communication with communities to prevent re-occurrence or occurrence of protests. Most of these issues will guide and form part of the municipal specific turn-around strategies.

Question 266

28 OCTOBER 2009

266. Mr W P Doman (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Government and Traditional Affairs: [Written Question No 482]

(a) How much was spent by his department on consultants in the 2008-09 financial year and (b) what was the brief of each consultant contract? NW544E

ANSWER

(a) The department spent R45.8 million on consultants in the 2008/09 financial year. Refer to note 5.3 of the financial statements on page 213 of the 2008/09 Annual Report.

(b) The detail of the brief of each consultant contract is reflected in Chapter 4, pages 366 to 376 of the 2008/09 Annual Report.

Question 265

28 OCTOBER 2009

265. Mr W P Doman (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: [Written Question No 481]

(a) How many professionals and experts were deployed under programmes of his department at municipalities as at 31 March 2009 and (b) what is the total number of municipalities for each province they were deployed in? NW543E

ANSWER

(a) As of March 2009, about 1283 technical expert and/or professionals had been deployed to 268 municipalities (including the 139 Project Consolidate municipalities). This is the cumulative number since the launch of Project Consolidate in 2004 and includes all associated programmes, e.g. Siyenza Manje & Ilima Trust.

(b) The total number of municipalities that received support through deployments per province can be broken down as follows:

Province	Number of Municipalities received support
Easter Cape	42
Free State	23
Gauteng	20
KwaZulu Natal	54
Limpopo	31
Mpumalanga	22
North West	25
Northern Cape	21
Western Cape	30

Some municipalities received two or three deployees covering expert areas of Development Planning, Financial Management, Civil Engineering and Project Management. This includes Young Professionals and Artisans.

QUESTION NO 807

(Internal Question Paper No 9 - 2009)

Mr P J Groenewald (FF Plus) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

(1) (a) In how many municipalities (i) have qualified engineers been appointed in the works department and (ii) have no engineers been appointed and (b) why no engineers have been appointed:

(2) Whether he will make a statement on the matter?

ANSWER

(1) (a) (i) In 244 municipalities qualified engineers have been appointed.

(ii) About 33 municipalities currently do not have qualified engineers.

(b) There is a general lack of technical skills in the country. This is further exacerbated by the fact some Engineers join the consulting industry. However, municipalities are engaged in a process of recruiting and attracting qualified engineers.

(2) Since the Minister took over, he has identified the challenge of attracting scarce professional skills as fundamental towards strengthening service delivery capacity. The Minister has engaged other line ministries in order to coordinate programmes and resources in particular, Department of Water Affairs and Environment. National Treasury, Human Settlements, Public Works etc. the Local Government Recovery Plan to be informed by current assessment of the state of local government in South Africa shall provide a structured and sustainable strategy to address this matter.

QUESTION NO 689

(Internal Question Paper No 7 - 2009)

Mr S Mokgalapa (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

Whether, in light of the current recession and the consequent shortfall in state revenue, his department has introduced any austerity measures to reduce its expenditure with regard to (a) official vehicles, (b) travel, (c) travel by departmental officials, (d) accommodation and household help or (e) any other aspects of government business; if not, what is the position in

this regard; if so, what are the relevant details?

ANSWER

Yes

The Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs has planned workshops on travel matters to implement the travel cost containment strategy by end of September 2009. This covers the use of hired vehicles, air travel, venue hiring, hotel accommodation and other travel related matters.

(a) Considering group travel instead of hiring individual vehicles

(b) Introducing advance booking for travel to cut costs on flights tickets.

(c) To reduce the number of officials to travel when attending meetings

(d) Consider the cost-effective graded hotel accommodation by officials.

(e) Utilising internal venues for meetings and teleconferencing facilities is the first priority before considering external conference venues.

Question 281

28 OCTOBER 2009

281. Mr W P Doman (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: [Written Question No 909]

(1) Whether his Director-General signed a performance contract with him; if not, why not; if so, when;

(2) whether all senior managers in his department signed performance contracts with the Director-General; if not, (a) which senior managers did not sign, (b) for what reason and (c) when will it be done; if so, on which date did each senior manager sign a performance contract? NW1065E

ANSWER

(1) No, the Director-General left the Department on 30 June 2009. The Acting Director-General however signed a Performance Agreement on 1 July 2009.

(a) Director: Youth HIV and Aids Programmes/Director: Local Government Organisational Development Systems. (b) Resignation/Maternity leave. (c) October 2009 for senior manager, who was on maternity leave, the other 103 Performance Agreements were signed by senior managers on dates varying between 1 April to 31 July 2009.

Question 282

282. Ms M Wenger (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: [Written Question No 925]

(1) Whether, with reference to the salary negotiations between the SA Local Government Association (Salga) and municipal workers, municipalities will receive additional funding; if not, how will the salary increase be funded; if so, (a) who will provide the additional funding and (b) what will be the impact of the allocation of additional funding;

(2) whether implementation of the salary increase will result in further strains on service delivery; if not, (a) why not and (b) from which municipal budgets will funds be allocated to fund the increase in salaries and wages; if so, (a) what action will be taken to reduce the impact on service delivery as a result of the increase of salaries and wages, (b) from which municipal budgets will funds be allocated for the increase and (c) who mandated Salga to negotiate up to a 13% salary and wage increase? NW1081E

ANSWER

(1) Municipalities do not, as a norm, get funding for salaries from National Fiscus. They fund these from their own revenue. There is no evidence of necessity for additional funding than what Municipalities have budgeted for in this respect.

The increases are funded from the general revenue of each municipality.

(2) (a) Strains that may be there on service delivery would not have been caused solely by salary increases. The inadequate nature of the Equitable Share, as it relies on 2001 Census data, contribute to a greater degree to the insufficient funding of local government. (b) As indicated above, Municipalities budget, normally under personnel administration, for salary increases and that is the budget they use for this purpose. (c) To start with, the agreement is not a direct 13% as the question says but a 10.5% normal increase with a non - pensionable allowance of 2,5%. There is a huge financial difference between the two with 13 % the bill would have gone up by R5,522,400.000 while the current formulation makes a saving of R162,000,000 as the bill increases by about R5,360,400,000. The sum total of the current formulation is an overall average increase of about 11.75%.

SALGA followed a vigorous mandating process with its members, the Municipalities on every step of this sensitive matter. Key highlights of such mandating process were, where 66% of its members agreed to the mediators proposal where the increases had to be 11.5% for 2009/2010, CPI + 2010/11 and CPI 2011/12.

When that did not result in an agreement and a strike ensued, a revised Mediator Proposal was for payment of 11.5% with an additional 1.5% in January 2010. SALGA again sought a mandate and a majority responded favorably thereto.

Of the 283 Municipalities, only one has applied for exemption from the provisions of this agreement on basis that it may not afford to pay same. All others have not. Lastly and by comparison, Local government salary increases were at 8.3% in 2008/09 while other employers were at double digit percentages.

A comparison of local government and Public Service for 2008/09 ( 8.3% Local Government and 10.5% Public Service) and 2009/10 ( average 11.75% local Government and 11.5% public Service reveals that local government salaries are conservative by about 1%. The minimum wage for both is fairly comparable.

Question 284

28 OCTOBER 2009

284. Mrs M Wenger (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: [Written Question No 1003]

Whether any municipalities were placed under administration (a) in (i) 2006, (ii) 2007 and (iii) 2008 and (b) during the period 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if so, (aa) which municipalities, (bb) what are the reasons for being placed under administration in each case and (cc) what actions has been or will be taken against officials and councillors for creating this situation in each case? NW1226E

ANSWER

In 2006 no municipality was placed under administration; and

In 2007, 5 municipalities were placed under administration that included Amajuba District Municipality, Umzinyathi, Newcastle, Uthrecht and Oudtshoorn Local Municipalities; and

For the year 2008, five municipalities were placed under administration that included Xhariep District Municipality, Ditsobotla, Mohokare, Mbombela and Mkondo Local Municipalities; and (b)(aa) 1 January 2009 to date, seven municipalities were placed under administration that included Ngaka Modiri Molema and Alfred Nzo District Municipalities, Kou-Kamma, Mnquma, Pixley ka Seme, Lekwa and Nokeng Tsa Taemane Local Municipalities.

The cross cutting reasons were challenges in terms of (1) Governance that included political infightings, conflict between top management and councillors, HR management; (2) Financial - that included fraud and misuse of municipal funds and property, lack of proper financial systems, revenue collections, A-G disclaimers; and (3) Service delivery related to section 152/153 of the Constitution that clearly set out the service delivery obligations of municipalities.

Actions taken in each municipality ranged from taking away executive powers of the officials in the municipalities, suspensions to dismissals of officials in certain municipalities.

Question 287

28 OCTOBER 2009

287. Mr T Botha (Cope) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: [Written Question No 1029]

(1) Whether the monitoring of intergovernmental relations and the performance of provincial government had allowed his department to discover problems early enough for quick and timely remedial actions; if so, (a) which problems were discovered in each province through the monitoring programmes and (b)(i) how, (ii) when and (iii) to what extent were these problems corrected and resolved; if not,

(2) whether he has taken any steps to ensure the value of having such a monitoring service in his department; if not, why not; if so, what steps? NW1267E

ANSWER

The Constitution gives national government the power to monitor the performance of provinces and municipalities, intervene when it is necessary to correct institutional failures, and a duty to support these spheres to develop their capacity. We recognized that this area was not fully exercised to enable us to better monitor and support provinces with challenges they encounter.

The Department will be partnering with both the Ministry on Performance Monitoring to build a stronger system of intergovernmental supervision. Part of the problem has been that there has been no national legislation regulating monitoring and intervention powers and this has led to inconsistent approaches, with no clear links between monitoring frameworks and programmes of support.

The expanded mandate of the department to focus on cooperative governance means that we will be presenting a Green Paper on Cooperative Governance during the course of next year. This Green Paper will propose how improved monitoring of provinces will be conducted in respect to intergovernmental performance.

Preliminary performance indicators for the practice of effective intergovernmental relations have been drafted, and these will be further developed in relation to the strengthening of sector coordination and oversight. The 'voluntarism' in the IGR system has allowed for the situation where provincial 'discretion' in the management of government budgets and programmes has allowed for a problematic in how monitoring of performance is intergovernmentally conceptualized.

Question 288

28 OCTOBER 2009

288. Mr T Botha (Cope) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: [Written Question No 1030]

Whether the management, coordination and monitoring of the effectiveness of the integrated implementation of the urban renewal programme has resulted in improvements in the urban landscape; if not, why not; if so, (a) what improvements were achieved, (b) what monetary support was given to each approved site and (c) to what extent had the programme achieved its objectives? NW1268E

ANSWER

(a) (c) Certainly the urban renewal programme made its impact in the urban landscape. The anchor projects were identified to attract and mobilise a range of multi-sectoral developments with government creating enabling conditions. Let me cite two of the projects as examples that improved the urban landscape and demonstrate of programme achievements.

In Alexandra a London Road and Bridge project is an example:

Vehicle and pedestrian connectivity both within Alexandra and to the greater regional economy has substantially improved through the construction of major roads and bridges. Some 95% of the formal road infrastructure has been upgraded and tarred, with 22 km of sidewalks (pavements) created and paved. The construction of London Road linking Alexandra to both the N3 and M2 highways in particular and the upgrading of the road network in general have increased the linkage into the regional economy of sidewalks (pavements) created and paved. The construction of London Road linking Alexandra to both the N3 and M2 highways in particular and the upgrading of the road network in general have increased the linkage into the regional economy.

The Khayelitsha Central Business District is also a case in point.

The 17 500m² retail centre was completed in December 2006 at a total capital cost of R86,5 million. This project is establishing a mixed-use, viable and vibrant Central Business District (CBD) for the residents of Khayelitsha, in which the local community participates and is empowered to take up economic opportunities.

(b) Significant funding from various sources including Municipal Infrastructure Grant, Neighborhood Partnership Grant, European Union contributed in monetary terms to the programme.

Question 289

28 OCTOBER 2009

289 Mr T Botha (Cope) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: [Written Question No 1031]

Whether his department's programmes of support and capacity building to local government over 15 years have achieved the objective of sound Intergovernmental fiscal relations; if not, why not; if so, what are the statistics informing his response? NW1269E

ANSWER

Intergovernmental fiscal relations (IGFR) is one part of the larger framework of Intergovernmental Relations.

The department had and has a number of programmes to mention a few – Masakhane Campaign, Project Viability, Project Consolidate, Municipal Infrastructure Programme, MIG, Local Government Equitable Share, 5 Year Local Government Strategic Agenda, Operation Clean Audit and the Revenue Enhancement and Debt Collection Programme.

The Department is presently preparing a discussion document on key reforms that need to addressed in the area of IGFR. Key challenges in this regard include:

Resource allocation does not take spatial differences & realities into account, e.g. topography, vastness
Vertical allocation: steady increase, but limited slice of the national fiscus to local government
Misaligned budgeting and planning across the three spheres of government
Equitable share and its formula does not address the real needs of small, rural municipalities with limited revenue base
Grants coordination, management and compliance is weak. Limited provincial role.

Some areas of proposed reform include:

 Consider long term fiscal planning (5-15 years) to be balanced with the current skills base; this will give even greater predictability to local government

DORA: Address non-compliance; review grant conditionalities & improve coordination
Explore specific target financial instruments to support (smaller rural) municipalities with a limited revenue base

Question 290

28 OCTOBER 2009

290. Mr W P Doman (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: [Written Question No 1057]

(a) Which local municipalities are being considered for becoming metros, (b) what are the considerations in each case, (c) what are the processes for affecting such a change and (d) for when is it planned in each case? NW1317E

ANSWER

I am aware that the Municipal Demarcation Board (MDB) has taken a decision last year considering the municipalities of Mangaung, Buffalo City and Msunduzi as metros by year 2011. As part of the engagements with MDB, we are assessing the circumstances closely and will make a statement when appropriate and necessary.

Question 295

28 OCTOBER 2009

295. Mr M J Ellis (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: [Written Question No 1118]

(1) With regard to a certain tender (details furnished) for the management of 21 water and 10 waste water treatment facilities and associated bulk infrastructure, what is the average lead time for (a) advertising, (b) receiving, (c) accepting and (d) finalizing tender bids;

(2) whether there are any reasons for the lead time of the said tender being short; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details;

(3) (a) who were the bidders for the said tender, (b) to whom was the said tender awarded, (c) who are the (i) owners/directors and (ii) subsidiaries of the successful bid company and (iii) owners/directors of these subsidiaries, (d) what are the details of the contract of the said tender and (e) what is the total amount of this contract? NW1383E

ANSWER

I am currently verifying the details associated to this question and will be ready to provide a comprehensive response once completed and satisfied in due course.

QUESTION NO. 297

(Internal Question Paper No 5- 2009)

Mr W P Doman (DA) to ask the Minister for Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

Whether his department is playing a role in the planning for disaster management of the host cities for the 2010 Fifa World Cup Soccer tournament; if not; why not; if so; what are the relevant details?

ANSWER

Yes, the Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs is playing a role in the planning for disaster management of the host cities for the 2010 Fifa World Cup Soccer tournament through the National Disaster Management Centre (NOMC) as part of the Safety and Security Workstream of the Local Organising Committee (LOC).

The involvement of the NDMC revolves mainly around the strategic level and not so much at a tactical and/or operational level.

The NOMC is supporting the provinces and host cities in developing disaster management plans as well as contingency plans for identified risks related to the 2010 FIFA World Cup Tournament.

Question 298

28 OCTOBER 2009

298. Mr W P Doman (DA) to ask the Minister for Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: [Written Question No 1172]

ANSWER

(a) Temporary support staff is appointed through temporary employment services in cases where permanent staff is on long leave due to incapacity, maternity leave, special leave, etc and in cases where support staff is temporarily needed for special projects.

(b) None, temporary staff is not appointed in permanent positions since their services are only needed for specific periods and projects.

(d) 2006/07 R1 441 609

2007/08 R2 110 401

2008/09 R2 552 027

Question 299

28 OCTOBER 2009

299.Ms M Wenger (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: [Written Question No 1194]

Whether, in each of the 216 municipalities in the country, in each of the past three years, the mayors of each municipality purchased a new official vehicle; if not, what vehicle is each mayor using; if so, (a) what is the (i) make, (ii) model and (iii) year and (b) at what (i) cost and (ii) what accessories, including extras, were included at an additional cost? NW1533E

ANSWER

Due to the extensive information required, the Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs is currently conducting research in this respect and details regarding the above question will be provided to the Honourable Member once the required information has been obtained.

Question 280

28 OCTOBER 2009

280. Ms M Wenger (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: [Written Question No 890]

(1) Whether any assessments were done by him or his predecessor on municipalities around the country; if so, (a) what was the nature of each assessment, (b) when was each done, (c) what was the cost involved in each assessment, (d) who were the stakeholders in each assessment and (e) what steps were taken regarding the (i) outcomes and (ii) recommendations of each assessment;

(2) whether opposition parties were involved in (a) previous and (b) current assessments; if not, why not; if so, which opposition parties? NW1043E

ANSWER

(1) Yes. (a) The then dplg undertook assessments on the status of Local Government prior to the inception of Project Consolidate in 2004 and the 5 year Strategic Local Government Agenda in 2006. These previous assessments relied on information gathered by existing reporting systems and therefore were unable to unearth the acuteness and scope of challenges at Municipal level.

On the 7th of July 2009 I wrote a letter to provincial MECs responsible for Local Government, communicating the need to undertake a comprehensive assessment of the state of governance and service delivery in municipalities. These assessments focussed on the following categories:

· Governance;

· Financial Management;

· Service Delivery;

· Labour related matters.

The following elements were identified as key to the assessment process:

· The provinces must lead the process;

· Provincial Task Teams must be established to undertake the assessment;

· The assessment must take place through interactive sessions and direct engagements, and not through desktop research;

· All key stakeholders at municipal level must be engaged with: caucus/councils, senior management, unions, traditional leaders, opposition parties and communities;

· A report must be submitted on the engagements covering the underlying causes of the challenges and weaknesses in governance and service delivery, as well as the development of a support plan that identifies the actions and required support measures from national and provincial government, and other stakeholders; and

· The report with recommendations must be signed off by the Provincial Executive Council and finally be submitted to the National Minister.

(b) From late July 2009 until the end of August 2009, teams composed of officials from COGTA and the Provincial Departments of Local Government visited the provinces to conduct in-depth municipal assessments per province. In the case of the North West, an assessment was already completed during March and April 2009 by the Task Team lead by myself, while the Western Cape commenced with their assessment only in September 2009.

(c) The assessments were conducted within the normal budget for interaction between the three (3) spheres of government. No external service providers were used during these assessments.

(d) All key stakeholders at municipal level were engaged e.g. caucus/councils, senior management, unions, traditional leaders, opposition parties and communities.

(e)(i) Reports compiled by each provincial team and the provincial departments were submitted to COGTA. Theses reports investigated the underlying causes of the challenges and weaknesses of governance and service delivery in terms of the institutional capacity and capability financial challenges and the political environment. Provinces also reported on the State of Local Government in each province and the process undertaken at the COGTA Technical Minmec held on 22 September 2009. These Reports are now being assessed and consolidated into a draft report by COGTA. A National Indaba on Local Government was held on 21 and 22 October 2009. At this Indaba government a draft 'State of Local Government Report was presented.

(e)(ii) The outcomes of these provincial municipal assessments will culminate in the development of a national Local Government Turn Around Strategy (2009-2011). The turn around strategy will be based on objective conditions and evidence-based assessment that highlights weaknesses and challenges and what needs to be done to reverse the dire situation in our municipalities. COGTA will partner with key stakeholders to develop and implement the Turn Around Strategy. The National Indaba on Local Government received inputs for the Turn Around of Local Government.

(2) (a) Not applicable. (b) Provincial assessment teams were specifically requested to engage with all key stakeholders including opposition parties.

NATIONAL COUNCIL OF PROVINCES

WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NO 1634

(Internal Question Paper No 29 - 2009)

Mr S Mokgalapa (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

(1) Whether his department developed and adopted a policy providing guidelines for the

appointment of persons with a criminal record; if so, (a) when was the policy (i) developed and (ii) adopted and (b) where can a copy of the policy be obtained; if not,

(2) whether his department has any plans in place to develop and adopt such a policy; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

(3) whether his department does any pre-employment screening of potential employees for criminal records; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details;

(4) whether any employees with criminal records are currently employed by his department; if so, (a) how many and (b) what is their (i) job level and (ii) occupational category? NW2040E

Answer

1. The department does not have an approved policy on criminal record checks.

2. The department will be re-enforcing the pre-screening to include SAPS criminal records and will be implementing the policy from 1 April 2010 as part of Minimum Information Requirements.

3. The department currently conducts reference checks criminal check and disciplinary cases checks in the case of posts of HoDs and DOGs.

4. Since the department has not implemented the criminal record checks, it is not aware of any person employed with criminal record in the current establishment.

QUESTION NO 1038

(Internal Question Paper No XXX - 2009)

Ms H N Ndude (Cope) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

Whether he has been informed of the concerns of environmentalists with regard to the impact of municipal pollution and sewer spillages on our natural resources; if so, what steps has he taken to ring fence intergovernmental grants for maintaining and extending municipal infrastructure?

ANSWER / REPL Y

Yes, both the Ministry and the Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs are informed of the concerns of environmentalists with regard to the impact of municipal pollution and sewer spillages on our natural resources.

In fact, the Department has already undertaken a national audit of bulk water and sanitation in the country together with Department of Water and Environmental Affairs in Limpopo Province. This study has assessed, inter alia, the maintenance needs for this bulk infrastructure.

At present there are no ring-fenced intergovernmental grants for maintenance. However, the Department is finalizing its local government assessment to inform a turn around strategy that will include amongst other things, a review of the fiscal environment impacting on municipalities including infrastructure maintenance.

Currently, municipalities have access to the local government equitable share and own revenue for infrastructure maintenance. The Department has also mobilized numerous support initiatives to assist municipalities with infrastructure management.

With regard to infrastructure extension, national government is contributing through the following intergovernmental grants:

 Municipal Infrastructure Grant which is managed by the Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs;

Regional Bulk Infrastructure Grant which is managed by Department of Water and Environmental Affairs;
Neighbourhood Development Partnership Grant which is managed by the National Treasury; and
Integrated National Electrification Programme Grant which is managed by the Department of Energy.

QUESTION NO 1037
(Internal Question Paper No - 2009)
Mrs M Wenger (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

How many municipalities did not get their valuation rolls done by 31 July 2009 in order to implement the Local Government: Municipal Property Rates Act, Act 6 of 2004?

ORAL REPLY

Based on the information provided by the provincial departments responsible for local government, as at 29 May 2009, there were seventeen (17) municipalities that would not successfully implement the Act on 1 July 2009 due to the fact that they did not appropriately compile new valuation rolls in terms of the Act. Of these, twelve (12) municipalities had previously levied rates in terms of old provincial ordinances. Five (5) municipalities had never rated before.

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NO 1036

(Internal Question Paper No XXX - 2009)

Mr J H van der Merwe (lFP) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

(a) How many strikes caused by an alleged lack of service delivery took place during the period 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available, (b) what were the demands made during each strike and (c) what was the estimated loss suffered by the State during this period?

REPLY / ANSWER

To our knowledge a strike will refer to workers protesting for particular demands. This being our interpretation, we haven't yet received a reported case about workers striking because their municipality is not providing services or because of alleged lack of service delivery.

We however, have established the task team inclusive of the two main municipal unions launched on the 5th of August 2009 referred to as Ministerial Strategic Team. The MST comprise of South African Municipal Workers Union ["SAMWU], Independent Municipal and Allied Trade Union ["IMATU"], SALGA, National Treasury [NT], Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs and Department of Public Services & Administration [DPSA].

The Strategic Team is guided by the terms of reference that essentially call for:

conducting impact assessment of the global economic meltdown on the viability of the Municipalities;
investigation of the genesis of the current service delivery challenges;
assisting the stakeholders to develop the turnaround strategy in the local government;
enhancement of the relationship between SALGA and organised labour both nationally and provincially; and
Undertaking the comparative assessment of the wage gap between the highest paid employee and lowest salaried worker in Municipalities.

QUESTION NO 786

(Internal Question Paper No 9 - 2009)

Mr W P Doman (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

(a) Which municipalities were in arrears with their levies to the SA Local Government Association for the 2008-09 financial year and (b) how are the levies currently calculated?

ANSWER

(a)

1. EASTERN CAPE = 26

2. FREE STATE = 11

3. GAUTENG = Nil

4. KWAZULU NATAL = n/a

5. LIMPOPO = 6

6. MPUMALANGA = 2 7

7. NORTHERN CAPE = 18

8. NORTH WEST = 7

9. WESTERN CAPE = 9

TOTAL = 79

(B) The levy formula is as follows for the 2009/10 financial year:

Local Municipalities = 0,05% of its salary budget (minimum threshold of R100, 000) District Municipalities = 0.6% of its salary budget (minimum threshold of R120, 000) Metropolitan Municipalities = R8, 500 000 Flat rate

QUESTION NO 785

(Internal Question Paper No 9 - 2009)

Mr W P Doman (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

(a) Which 32 municipalities and (b) in which provinces had funds stopped in terms of section 27 of the Division of Revenue Act, Act 2 of 2008, in the 2008-09 financial year as part of their municipal infrastructure grant

ANSWER

Funds were stopped in 33 and not 32 municipalities in terms of section 27 of the Division of Revenue Act, Act 2 of 2008, in the 2008-09 financial year as part of their municipal infrastructure grant. Funds were stopped in 33 municipalities in 9 Provinces as per the table below:

b) PROVINCE	a) MUNICIPALITY
EASTERN CAPE	1. Ikwezi
	2. Makana
	3. Koukamma
	4. Nkonkobe
FREE STATE	5. Mohokare
	6. Matjhabeng
	7. Nala
	8. Ngwathe
	9. Mafube
GAUTENG	10. City of Johannesburg
	11. West Rand DM
KWAZULU-NATAL	12. Umtshezi
	13. Newcastle
	14. Umhlabuyalingana
LIMPOPO	15. Makhuduthamaga
	16. Molemole
	17. Capricorn DM
	18. Modimolle
MPUMALANGA	19. Govan Mbeki
	20. Emalahleni
	21. Emakhazeni
	22. Mbombela
NORTHERN CAPE	23. Kamiesberg
	24. Khai-Ma

b) PROVINCE	a) MUNICIPALITY
	25. Ubuntu
	26. Umsobomvu
	27. Emthanjeni
	28. Thembelihle
	29.Sivancuma
	30. Sol Plaatie
	31. Frances Baard DM
NORTH WEST	32. Naledi
WESTERN CAPE	33. Hessequa

QUESTION NO 784

(Internal Question Paper No 9 - 2009)

Mr W P Doman (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

(1) Whether the chief executive officer (CEO) of the Commission for the Promotion and Protection of the Rights of Cultural, Religious and Linguistic Communities have been suspended; if so, for what reasons;

(2) whether any steps have been or will be taken against the CEO; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

ANSWER

(1) No, the CEO's was never suspended, but the contract lapsed on 31 July 2009.

(2) No steps will be taken as the contract legally came to an end and a new process of appointing new CEO is in place.

NATIONAL COUNCIL OF PROVINCES

WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NO 1545

(Internal Question Paper No 29 - 2009)

Mrs M Wenger (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

1. Whether he will put any mechanisms in place to monitor the establishment of Municipal Public Accounts Committees in all municipalities that will be chaired by a member of the opposition party; if not, why not; if so, what mechanisms;

2. Whether any action will be taken against municipalities that do not comply in this regard; if not, why not; if so, what action?

Answer

1. The department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs together with SALGA and Provincial Departments of Local Government have developed draft framework for establishment of Municipal Public Accounts Committees in municipalities. The support and monitoring of the establishment of MPACs will be done as part of the provincial and national programme i.e. Monthly quarterly reports submitted by Councils

2. All municipalities that will not comply will be engaged and supported to ensure establishment of MPACs through intervention of the provinces and national government working together.

QUESTION NO 751

(Internal Question Paper No 9 - 2009)

Ms A T Lovemore (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

(1) Whether all provinces have established disaster management centres in accordance with section 29 of the Disaster Management Act, Act 57 of 2002; if not, (a) which provinces have not yet done so and (b) what action is being taken to ensure that such centres are established; if so, what are the relevant details per province;

(2) whether all municipalities have established disaster management centres in accordance with section 43 of the Act; if not, (a) which municipalities have not yet done so and (b) what action is being taken to ensure that such centres are established;

(3) whether all provinces have submitted acceptable and appropriate disaster management plans to the national centre in accordance with section 38 of the Act; if not, (a) which provinces have not submitted acceptable and appropriate plans to the national centre and (b) what action is being taken to ensure that such acceptable and appropriate disaster management plans are in place; if so, what are the relevant details per province;

(4) whether all municipalities have submitted acceptable and appropriate disaster management plans to the national centre in accordance with section 53 of the Act; if not, which municipalities have not submitted acceptable and appropriate plans to the national centre; if so, what are the relevant details;

(5) whether all (a) provinces and (b) municipalities have submitted annual reports to the national centre in accordance with sections 36 and 50 of the Act; if not, which (i) provinces and (ii) municipalities have not submitted acceptable and appropriate plans to the national centre; if so, what are the relevant details in each case?

ANSWER

(1) Not all provinces have established disaster management centres in accordance with section 29 of the Disaster Management Act, Act 57 of 2002.

(a) The Northern Cape is the only province that has not yet established a disaster management centre. The reason being financial and capacity constraints. Mpumalanga Province currently operates a satellite centre. The permanent centre is under construction and will be completed at the end of November 2009.

(b) Several discussions have been held and submissions have been made to National Treasury in an attempt to secure funds to assist provinces to establish fully operational disaster management centres.

(c) The relevant details of the Provincial Disaster Management Centres that have been established are as follows:

Province	Physical Address	Tel/Cell	e-mail address	Head of Centre/Comments

Eastern Cape	Department of Local Government and Traditional Affairs Ground Floor Tyamzashe Buiding Bisho	0824953107	[email protected]	Mr Peter Hlazo The Department is also intending to establish a stand alone Disaster Management Centre. The Department of Public Works is assisting in this regard.








Free State	Provincial Disaster Management Centre MANCOFS Building Dr. Belcher Road Pelonomi Hospital Bloemfontein	0828256514	[email protected]	Ms Princess Sekulisa





Gauteng	Cnr Tonnetti / Old Pretoria Road Continuity SA Unit 4 Midrand	082 785 1950	[email protected]	Mr Colin Deiner




KwaZulu- Natal	Wadley House 115 Jabu Ndlovu Street Pietermaritzbura	033-897 5670 082 955 1056	[email protected]	Mr Mthokozisi Duze



Limpopo Province	20th -12 Avenue Industria Polokwane 0701	015-284 5270 083 290 3570	[email protected]	Ms MG Makhurupelje
					I


Mpumalanga	Satellite Centre: Mbombela Station Fire 150 Henshall Street Nelspruit	082476001	[email protected]	Mr Slykie Dhludhlu The permanent Centre is under construction. The project will be completed in November 2009.






North West	Temporary Centre: 36 James Watt Crescent Mafikeng	083 654 8946	[email protected]	Acting Head: Mr T Watson-Thomas Land has been secured. Awaiting capital funds to build the permanent disaster manaaement centre.







Western Cape	Tygerberg Hospital Francie van Zijl Avenue Parow 7500	021-9370809	[email protected]	Acting Head: Ms J Pandaram

(2) In terms of section 43 of the Disaster Management Act, 2002) only Metropolitan and District Municipalities must establish a disaster management centre.

(a) The following municipalities have not done so due to financial constraints:

Alfred Nzo District Municipality, Eastern Cape

Xhariep District Municipality, Free State

Sedibeng District Municipality, Gauteng

Metsweding Distirct Municipality, Gauteng

Ethekwini Metroplitan Municipality, KwaZulu-Natal

Uthukela District Municipality, KwaZulu-Natal

Amajuba District Municipality, KwaZulu-Natal

Umkhanyakude District Municipality, KwaZulu-Natal

Sisonke District Municipality, KwaZulu-Natal

Vhembe District Municipality, Limpopo

Capricorn District Municipality, Limpopo

Greater Sekhukhune District Municipality, Limpopo

Gert Sibande District Municipality, Mpumalanga

Ehlanzeni District Municipality, Mpumalanga

John Taolo Gaetsewe District Municipality, Northern Cape

Namakwa District Municipality, Northern Cape

Cape Winelands District Municipality, Western Cape

Central Karoo District Municipality, Western Cape

No information is available with regard to the following municipalities:

Motheo District Municipality, Free State

Lejweleputswa District Municipality, Free State

Thabo Mofutsanyane District Municipality, Free State

Fezile Dabi District Municipality, Free State

City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality, Gauteng

Mopani District Municipality, Limpopo

Nkangala District Municipality, Mpumalanga

Frances Baard District Municipality, Northern Cape

Pixley Ka Seme District Municipality, Northern Cape

Central District Municipality, North West

(b) In view of the fact that the discussions with National Treasury on various occasions to support municipalities to establish disaster management centres by means of a start-up grant have had no positive result, the municipalities have been encouraged to rather make provision in their own budgets for this purpose or approach their relevant province for assistance.

(3) Gauteng Province is the only province that has submitted a disaster management planto the national centre in accordance with section 38 of the Act.

(a) The following provinces have not yet submitted plans:

Province		Reasons
Eastern Cape		Work is still in progress. The process is linked to the current Disaster Management Policy Development process
Free State		Plan is complete. Will submit it to the NDMC
Kwa Zulu-Natal		Plan still to be completed
Limpopo Province		Draft disaster management plan submitted to the Executive Management for approval prior to submitting it to the NDMC.
Mpumalanga		A draft disaster management plan is available
North West		Plan still to be completed
Northern Cape		In process of appointing a Service Provider to assist the PDMC to develop a plan
Western Cape		Plan is complete. Will submit it to the NDMC

(b) Provinces have again been requested to ensure that they submit disaster management plans to the National Disaster Management Centre in terms of section 38 of the Act. Guidelines will also be completed by the NDMC at the end of September 2009 to assist provinces in this regard.

(4) Not all metropolitan and district municipalities have submitted acceptable and appropriate disaster management plans to the national centre in accordance with section 53 of the Act.

The following metropolitan and district municipalities have not submitted acceptable and appropriate disaster management plans to the national centre:

Nelson Mandela Bay Metropolitan Municipality

Cacadu District Municipality

Amathole District Municipality

Chris Hani District Municipality

Ukhahlama District Municipality

OR Tambo District Municipality

Alfred Nzo District Municipality

Xhariep District Municipality

City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality

Sedibeng District Municipality

Metsweding District Municipality

West Rand District Municipality

Ethekwini Metropolity Municipality

Ugu District Municipality

Umgungundlovu District Municipality

Uthukela District Municipality

Umzinyathi District Municipality

Amajuba District Municipality

Zululand District Municipality

Umkhanyakude District Municipality

Uthungulu District Municipality

lIembe District Municipality

Sisonke District Municipality

Vhembe District Municipality

Capricorn District Municipality

Waterbeg District Municipality

Greater Sekhukhune Municipality

Gert Sibande District Municipality

Nkangala District Municipality

Ehlanzeni District Municipality

John Taolo Gaetsewe District Municipality

Frances Baard District Municipality

Namakwa District Municipality

Pixley Ka Seme District Municipality

Siyanda District Municipality

Bojanala Platinum District Municipality

Central District Municipality

Dr Kenneth Kaunda District Municipality

West Coast District Municipality

Cape Wine lands District Municipality

Overberg District Municipality

Eden District Municipality

Central Karoo District Municipality

All the municipalities gave similar reasons, i.e. they have either omitted to submit their plan to the NDMC or the plan has not yet been finalised.

(5) (a) (i) Not all provinces have submitted annual reports to the national centre in accordance with section 36 of the Act.

(ii) The following provinces have not yet submitted their annual reports to the national centre:

Eastern Cape Free State Limpopo Mpumalanga Northern Cape North West Western Cape
(b) (i) Not all metropolitan and district municipalities have submitted annual reports to the national centre in accordance with section 50 of the Act.

(ii) The following municipalities have not yet submitted their annual reports to the national centre:

Cacadu District Municipality

Amathole District Municipality

Chris Hani District Municipality

OR Tambo District Municipality

Alfred Nzo District Municipality

Motheo District Municipality

Lejweleputswa District Municipality

Thabo Mofutsanyane District Municipality

Fezile Dabi District Municipality

City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality

Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality

Metsweding District Municipality

West Rand District Municipality

Ugu District Municipality

Uthungulu District Municipality

Mopani District Municipality

Greater Sekhukhune Municipality

Gert Sibande District Municipality

Nkangala District Municipality

Ehlanzeni District Municipality

John Taolo Gaetsewe District Municipality

Frances Baard District Municipality

Namakwa District Municipality

Pixley Ka Seme District Municipality

Siyanda District Municipality

Bojanala Platinum District Municipality

Central District Municipality

Dr Kenneth Kaunda District Municipality

West Coast District Municipality

Cape Winelands District Municipality

Central Karoo District Municipality

The reason why the majority of the provinces and municipalities have not yet been in a position to submit their annual reports for the 2008/2009 Financial Year is because their financial year only ends on 31 July 2009. The process of preparing and finalising their annual reports and having them approved before submission to the national centre is a lengthy process.

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NO 888

(Internal Question Paper No 10 - 2009)

Adv H C Schmidt (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

Whether he has issued (a) guidelines and/or (b) any other form of guidance to municipalities regarding the permissible or otherwise increase in the overall amount budgeted for

municipalities for the 2009-10 financial year compared to the 2008-09 financial year; if 50, what are the relevant details? NW1039E

ANSWER NO.

Guidance to municipalities on overall budget increases is dealt with through the Municipal Finance Management Act (MFMA) Municipal Budget Circulars. Please refer to the MFMA Circular No 48 of 2 March 2009 regarding the guidance to municipalities on the 2009/10 financial year budget preparation.

QUESTION NO 624

(Internal Question Paper No 7 - 2009)

Dr D T George (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

Whether any funds were allocated to remedy the flood damages in the UGU District along the south coast of KwaZulu-Natal in June 2008; if not, why not; if so, what amount was allocated?

ANSWER

Yes, an amount of R114, 762, 899. 00 was allocated to remedy the flood damages in Ugu District Municipality.

NATIONAL COUNCIL OF PROVINCES WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NO 2092

(Internal Question Paper No 29 - 2009)

Mr W P Doman (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional

Affairs:

What (a) is the (i) purpose and (ii) location of each Thusong centre and (b) services are envisaged to be delivered at such centres? NW2748E

Answer

(a) (i) The purpose of each Thusong Centre is to provide government services and Information about opportunities closer to communities in an integrated, efficient and professional way. (ii) About 139 Thusong Service Centre are located across municipalities in the country and the plan is to ensure established Thusong Centres for each municipality by 2014. (b) Thusong Service Centres link communities to the government's distribution network of publications and products about government programmes such as social grants, identity documents, and activities. Community participation events, campaigns, exhibition and road shows at Thusong Service Centres provide communities with information they can use to improve their lives and develop the community.

NATIONAL COUNCIL OF PROVINCES

WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NO 2091

(Internal Question Paper No 29 - 2009)

Mr W P Doman (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

(1) What, with the exception of the municipalities and metros referred to in Question 615 is the remuneration for (a) municipal managers and (b) chief financial officers with regard to (i) basic packages and (Ii) bonuses for each specified municipality;

(2) whether performance agreement contracts have been signed with each of the current (a) municipal managers and (b) chief financial officers (i) in each of the specified municipalities; if not, who do not have signed performance agreements? NW2747E

Answer

Due to the extensive nature of the information required, the department has sent the request to all municipalities to provide information.

NATIONAL COUNCIL OF PROVINCES

WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NO 2090

(Internal Question Paper No 29 - 2009)

Mr W P Doman (DA) to ask the Minister for Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

Why did the Gauteng Provincial legislature not pay the full amount of the loss of office gratuity to the members who exited after the 2004 general elections (details furnished)? NW2746E

Answer

According to the information received from the Legislature's Finance Unit, there are no outstanding payments due to former MPLs. All payments to individual MPLs were paid in full.

QUESTION NO. 30

(Internal Question Paper No 30- 2009)

Mr W P Doman (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

What was the (a) total amount of debt owed to municipalities as at the latest specified date for which information is available and (b) breakdown of this amount in terms of (i) rates and taxes, (ii) water, (iii) electricity and (Iv) other items as at that date? NW32E

ANSWER

ANALYSIS OF DEBT OWED TO MUNICIPALITIES FOR ALL PROVINCES PER CATEGORY - 31 MARCH 2009
Province	Water	Electricity	Property rates	Other	Total
Eastern cape	1 166 525	410,815	862, 632	1,352,512	R3,792,484
Free State	1,533,219	328,462	806, 741	1,157,881	R3,826,303
Gauteng	8,737,171	3, 515,919	5,711,0286	6,947,516	R24,911 ,634
kwaZulu Natal	1, 831,573	780, 596	3,112,995	1,294, 157	R7, 019, 321
Limpopo	396, 772	89, 487	207,023	818,125	R1,511,407
Mpumalanga	370, 654	196,963	367,182	679,117	R1,613,916
Northern Cape	293,744	140,799	159,131	436,346	R1,030,020
North West	1,029,974	438, 680	519,918	2,086,110	R4 074 682
Western Cape	2,623, 548	589, 605	1,431,149	1,273, 610	R5,917,912
TOTAL	R17,983,180	R6,491,326	R13,177,799	R16,045,374	R53,697,679

Source: Municipalities MFMA Section 71 reports 31 March 2009

(a). The total amount of debt owed to municipalities as at 31. March 2009 stood at R53, 697,679.

(b). i) Rates and Taxes contribute 25% (R13. 177,799) of the total debt.

ii) Water constitutes the highest at 33% (R17, 983,180) of the total debt.

iii). Electricity constitutes 12% (R6. 491,326) of the total debt.

iv). Other items constitute the second highest at 30% (R16. 945.377) of the total debt.

QUESTION NO. 31

(Internal Question Paper No 31- 2009)

Mr W P Doman (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs:

Whether any municipalities were under administration in terms of Section 139 of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, Act 108 of 1996, during the period 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available: if so, (a) which municipalities and (b) what was the main reason for imposing administration in each case?

Answer

WRITTEN REPLY

QUESTION NO. 31 (Internal Question Paper No 31- 2009)

Mr W P Doman (DA) to ask the Minister for Provincial and Local Government:

Whether any municipalities were under administration in terms of Section 139 of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, Act 108 of 1996, during the period 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if so, (a) which municipalities and (b) what was the main reason for imposing administration in each case?

ANSWER

Name of municipality	Year of Intervention	End of intervention	Nature of Problem
Eastern Ca pe
1. Alfred Nzo DM	1 April 200	Still under intervention	Financial, service delivery and governance
2. Kou-Kamma LM	1 April 2009	Still under intervention	Financial and governance
Mpumalanga
1. Pixley ka Seme Local Municipality	2 March 2009	Still under intervention	Governance, financial and administration
Mkhondo Local Municipality	1 July 2009	Still under intervention	Financial and service delivery

Categories of the nature of problems experienced by municipalities

1. Governance	Political infightings, conflict between top management and councillors, HR management
2. Financial	Fraud and misuse of municipal funds and property, lack of proper financial systems. revenue collections, A-G disclaimers, lack of compliance in terms of the Municipal Finance Management Act
3. Service delivery	Related to section 152/153 of the constitution that clearly set out the service delivery obligations of municipalities

QUESTION NO 301

(Internal Question Paper No 7 - 2009)

The Leader of the Opposition (DA) to ask the Minister of Co-operative Governance and Traditional Affairs: (Interdepartmental transfer on 7 August 2009)

(1) Whether the Government intends abolishing or reducing the number of provinces; if so,

(a) why and (b) when is this process envisaged to begin;

(2) whether the constitutional imperative of three independent spheres of government has been considered; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

ANSWER

(1) No decision has been taken by Government on provincial re-configuration. The policy review on provincial and local government which was initiated by the previous government, identified a range of issues for consideration to improve the governance system as a whole including the structure of government, the allocation of functions between spheres, systems of representative and accountable government, the mechanisms for service delivery and integrated development. These are currently being considered.

(2) The Constitution clearly sets out in section 40(1) that the national, provincial and local spheres of government are not independent, but rather "distinctive, interdependent and interrelated." This is the reason why Chapter 3 of the Constitution sets out principles of co-operative government and intergovernmental relations which all spheres of government and all organs of state must adhere to.

Question 302

28 OCTOBER 2009

302. Mr W P Doman (DA) to ask the Minister for Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: [Written Question No 1205]

(2) whether he inherited an existing vehicle; if so, (a) what was the make and model and (b) how old is the vehicle? NW1544E

ANSWER

(1) No. The Deputy Minister currently uses, as are available, a Nissan X-Trail, Toyota Prado, Toyota Verso and his personal cars. He is to get a VW Touareg for use in Cape Town and another for use in Tshwane. The cost of each vehicle is R342 688. The Ministerial Handbook provides for a car of up to R1,1 28 437. The accessory is a Bluetooth device worth R3 647, which is included in the above price.

(2) He inherited a four-year old Mercedes-Benz E240 and a three-year old Mercedes-Benz E500.

Question 303

28 OCTOBER 2009

303. Mr M Swart (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: [Written Question No 1226]

(1) Whether the National Treasury made an intervention in Mbombela; if not, why not; if so,

(2) whether the intervention achieved the objective; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW1565E

ANSWER

The member must redirect his question to National Treasury as intervention was undertaken by the National Treasury.

Question 305

28 OCTOBER 2009

305. Mrs M Wenger (DA) to ask the Minister for Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: [Written Question No 1324]

Whether the Demarcation Board is suggesting an increase in the number of councillors in municipalities with regard to the recent service delivery protests; if not, why not; if so, (a) for how many additional councillors (b) what is the cost implications for these additional positions and (c) where will the additional costs be funded from? NW1672E

ANSWER

In terms of section 20 of the Local Government: Municipal Structures Act, 1998 (Act No.117 of 1998) the number of councillors of municipal council (a) must be determined in accordance with a formula determined by the Minister by notice in the Government Gazette, which formula must be based on the number of voters registered on that municipalities segment of the national common voters roll on a date determined in the notice and not in any way influenced by service delivery protests.

The current number of councillors, according to the statistics used in the Local Government Equitable Share Formula is 9267. However, the formula published projects a total of 10, 238 councillors for the 2011 municipal elections. This total number increases the number of councillors by 971, amounting to a percentage increase of 10.47%. This increase is primarily driven by the number of registered voters used in the formula which totalled 23, 181, 997 for the 2009 general elections as against a recorded number of 20 674, 926 registered voters for the 2004 general elections.

Additional costs may vary, depending on Councillors status as full-time or part-time and the grade of the municipality. The additional cost may be between R 625m to R344m. These cost will be borne by municipalities using own revenue including their equitable share allocation.

Question 307

28 OCTOBER 2009

307. Mrs M Wenger (DA) to ask the Minister of Co-operative Governance and Traditional Affairs: [Written Question No1397]

(1) (a) What is the total debt owed to each municipality by each specified (i) national and (ii) provincial government department as at the latest specified date for which information is available, (b) for how long has each amount been outstanding and (c) by what date does each of these outstanding amounts have to be settled for each municipality;

(2) whether his department will be taking any steps in the case where the cash-flow of the municipality is affected by this outstanding debt, resulting in an inability to deliver basic services; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details; (3) whether interest will be added on outstanding amounts; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details? NW1752E

ANSWER

(1) The total debt owed to municipalities by government departments as at 30 June 2009, is R2 411 207 000. The breakdown according to municipalities is attached in table (Source: National Treasury Local Government Database). The amount may be more than R2.4b because some of the municipalities have not disaggregated their debt according to customer group. Furthermore the figures have not been broken down according provincial and national departments. (a) See attached table. (b) The debt has to be paid within 30 days upon acknowledgement of debt by national and provincial departments

(2) The department collectively with National Treasury and Provincial Departments of Local Government and Treasuries are in discussions with the Department of Public Works to resolve the problems and getting the data cleansing and invoicing sorted for payment.

(3) The matter of interest is handled by each municipality in accordance with their credit control and debt collection policy.

How much are municipalities owed by Government as at 30 June 2009
	0 -	31 -	61 -	91 -	121 -	151 -	181 Days -	Over 1	Total
	30 Days	60 Days	90 Days	120 Days	150 Days	180 Days	1 Year	Year	-
Location Description	R 000	R 000	R 000	R 000	R 000	R 000	R 000	R 000	R 000
Cape Town	61 514	24 675	17 393	17 779	16 187	11 277	55 416	107 625	311 867
City Of Johannesburg	1 014 460	3 985	3 754	350	76	361	656	519	1 024 161
City Of Tshwane	51 472	8 272	6 894	4 609	-561	20 230	4 711	0	95 627
Ekurhuleni Metro	13 684	7 937	8 092	6 490	7 336	5 871	39 032	87 050	175 494
eThekwini	3 783	4 428	1 469	765	562	369	2 308	34 035	47 720
Nelson Mandela Bay	18 312	5 112	1 733	51 831	0	0	0	0	76 987
Cacadu	2 180	62	150	2	51	23	-2	3 145	5 612
Cape Winelands DM	814	1 367	44	1	28	0	8	8 637	10 899
Eden	71	4	5	152	0	0	0	0	233
Frances Baard	39	3	3	42	0	0	0	0	87
Greater Sekhukhune	14 301	9 951	7 168	0	4 667	0	0	0	36 086
John Taolo Gaetsewe	166	256	173	22	0	0	0	0	617
Metsweding	413	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	413
Nkangala	3 302	0	0	0	0	0	0	3 231	6 534
O .R. Tambo	1 265	997	825	486	105	101	1 388	7 160	12 327
Ugu	1 302	359	42	52	575	0	0	0	2 331
Umzinyathi	4 099	0	2 202	0	0	0	1 720	915	8 936
Uthukela	0	2 855	1 448	2 521	3 449	32 342	0	569	43 183
uThungulu	704	457	273	1 311	0	0	0	0	2 746
Blue Crane Route	254	122	1	1	8	3	16	21	425
Buffalo City	4 873	1 063	905	554	456	442	1 314	817	10 424
King Sabata Dalindyebo	-3 231	1 050	620	315	145	119	3 541	0	2 559
Lukhanji	1 391	701	460	7 070	0	0	0	0	9 622
Matatiele	41	6	5	5	5	6	196	89	355
Mangaung	8 149	9 828	5 339	4 607	4 457	4 352	4 155	73 553	114 439
Metsimaholo	143	140	1 387	3 791	0	0	0	0	5 461
Moqhaka	291	124	102	3 923	0	0	0	0	4 440
Emfuleni	3 773	2 180	1 359	24 461	0	0	0	0	31 773
Kungwini	602	903	556	27 014	0	0	0	0	29 075
Lesedi	1 478	405	118	138	90	2 406	0	0	4 636
Midvaal	343	166	139	155	4 174	0	0	0	4 976
Mogale City	9 425	1 259	577	6 331	0	0	0	0	17 592
Nokeng Tsa Taemane	491	213	147	3 670	0	0	0	0	4 521
Randfontein	2 739	661	923	801	584	415	666	1 636	8 425
Dannhauser	40	27	25	24	22	886	0	0	1 024
eDumbe	28	5	9	7	11	0	0	0	61
Endumeni	807	549	466	469	285	2 175	0	0	4 751
Hibiscus Coast	552	125	602	378	369	5 649	0	0	7 674
Impendle	21	6	2	1	24	39	0	0	93
Ingwe	8	1	3	3	37	0	1 491	0	1 542
Jozini	3	6	6	6	4	3 011	0	0	3 035
Kwa Sani	0	20	18	16	18	0	58	0	129
Mpofana	139	149	130	2 727	0	0	0	0	3 145
Msunduzi	10 153	4 579	4 157	2 437	2 686	62 704	0	0	86 717
Mtubatuba	142	155	172	186	205	4 299	0	0	5 159
Ndwedwe	55	0	0	0	0	0	37	0	92
Newcastle	801	651	638	640	24 199	0	0	0	26 929
Nongoma	-593	10	19	9	9	499	0	0	-46
Nquthu	66	212	1 105	488	1 005	0	0	0	2 876
Okhahlamba	0	27	25	19	324	0	0	0	396
Richmond	-42	11	11	6	4	140	0	0	129
The Big Five False Bay	24	81	13	32	302	0	0	0	453
Umdoni	0	0	0	0	541	0	0	0	541
uMhlathuze	4 987	653	473	478	396	195	1 391	3 057	11 629
Umlalazi	-45	146	26	19	16	30	0	0	191
uMngeni	23	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	23
uPhongolo	28	23	15	14	13	146	344	0	583
Aganang	492	492	983	3 260	1 259	492	492	0	7 469
Bela Bela	169	824	10	288	0	0	0	0	1 291
Greater Giyani	105	233	324	48	25	142	82	246	1 206
Greater Letaba	20	143	19	15	16	2 883	0	0	3 097
Greater Tubatse	314	315	210	4 694	0	0	0	0	5 533
Greater Tzaneen	14	711	185	219	209	164	5 715	0	7 217
Lepelle-Nkumpi	946	470	463	474	6 439	0	0	0	8 791
Makhado	33	870	758	618	600	8 259	0	0	11 138
Maruleng	130	108	-41	206	462	-44	0	0	821
Modimolle	-490	220	255	100	1 473	0	0	0	1 558
Molemole	15	14	14	48	0	0	0	0	90
Musina	6	6	2	2	78	0	0	0	94
Polokwane	4 758	1 765	2 174	1 068	17 354	0	0	0	27 119
Emalahleni (Mp)	1 068	712	455	172	126	101	1 666	2 128	6 427
Mbombela	892	0	859	914	928	2 191	0	0	5 784
Steve Tshwete	68	32	28	29	26	140	0	0	323
City Of Matlosana	1 173	371	230	2 737	0	0	0	0	4 511
Greater Taung	34	25	24	24	19	18	181	282	607
Madibeng	764	902	719	13 824	0	0	0	0	16 209
Ramotshere Moiloa	-1 618	427	416	423	516	5 420	0	0	5 585
Tlokwe	3 104	449	126	120	1 816	0	0	0	5 614
Ventersdorp	162	56	48	41	34	33	102	844	1 319
Emthanjeni	0	231	160	148	140	136	1 412	0	2 226
Hantam	183	121	230	1 400	0	0	0	0	1 933
Kareeberg	43	29	9	0	0	0	138	0	220
Khai-Ma	14	1	0	2	0	0	0	0	17
Magareng	4	85	82	20	0	0	0	0	192
Mier	10	10	8	7	7	15	25	74	156
Renosterberg	189	16	16	276	13	0	0	0	510
Richtersveld	4	3	2	2	2	3	18	27	61
Siyathemba	42	30	1	1	6	68	0	0	149
Thembelihle	1	1	1	0	0	0	0	3	6
Ubuntu	10	10	9	257	286	0	0	0	571
Breede River Winelands	-90	31	21	33	15	14	154	96	272
Breede Valley	1	0	0	0	0	0	2	14	18
Drakenstein	720	259	76	726	0	0	0	0	1 781
George	-28	21	2	4	76	2	420	103	600
Knysna	267	74	37	40	18	53	155	117	762
Mossel Bay	265	41	35	35	33	32	527	256	1 224
Overstrand	145	52	30	38	1 624	0	0	0	1 890
Saldanha Bay	750	38	24	23	8	6	681	803	2 333
Stellenbosch	410	23	5	5	1 780	0	0	0	2 222
Swartland	495	64	60	12	12	9	93	56	802
Theewaterskloof	-260	71	0	0	0	0	0	3 939	3 750
Total	1 255 174	107 333	81 290	209 561	108 264	178 227	130 309	341 047	2 411 207

Question 309

309. Mr W P Doman (DA) to ask the Minister for Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: [Written Question No 1420]

(a) How many positions for (i) municipal managers and (ii) chief financial officers were vacant and (b) how many (i) municipal managers and (ii) chief financial officers were suspended at municipalities in each province on 31 August 2009? NW1776E

ANSWER

(a) The information acquired is as at 30 September 2009:

(i) Municipal Managers: 33 vacancies

(ii) Chief Financial Officers: 34 vacancies

Province	(i) Municipality with Municipal Manager vacancy	(ii) Municipality with Chief Fiancial Officer vacancy
Eastern Cape	Mbashe Local Municipality	Buffalo City Local Municipality
	Buffalo City Local Municipality	Nkonkobe Local Municipality
	Alfred Nzo District Municipality	Elundini Local Municipality
	Matatiele Local Municipality	Ntabankulu Local Municipality

Kwa Zulu Natal	Ilembe Local Municipality	uPhongolo Local Municipality
	Ezingoleni Local Municipality	Sisonke District Municipality
	Richmond Local Municipality	Mkhabathini Local Municipality
	Umkhanyakude Local Municipality	Emnambithi Local Municipality
		Emahlangeni Local Municipality

Limpopo	Sekhukhune District Municipality	Thabazimbi Local Municipality
	Makhado Local Municipality	Greater Marble Hall
	Waterberg District Municipality	Greater Tzaneen Local Municipality
	Modimolle Local Municipality	Capricon District Municipality
		Molemole Local Municipality
		Modimolle Local Municipality
		Bela Bela Local Municipality
		Magalakwena Local Municipality

North West	Naledi Local Municipality	Ditsobotla Local Municipality
	Tlokwe Local Municipality	Mamusa Local Municipality
	Ngaka Local Municipality	Greater Taung Local Municipality
		Molopo Local Municipality
		Dr Kenneth Kaunda District Municipality
		City of Local Tlokwe Municipality

Northern Cape	John Taolo District Municipality	Richtersveld Local Municipality
	Nama Khoi Local Municipality	Sol Plaatjie Local Municipality
	Nama Khoi Local Municipality	Ubuntu Local Municipality
	Nama Khoi Local Municipality	Ubuntu Local Municipality
	Khai-Ma Local Municipality	Katelopele Local Municipality
	Siyancuma Local Municipality	Phokwane Local Municipality
	Mier Local Municipality

Western Cape	Central Karoo District Municipality	Breede Valley Local Municipality
	Overberg Local Municipality	Eden District Municipality
	Prince Albert District Municipality	Cape Agulhas

Free State	Moqhaka Local Municipality	Letsemeng Local Municipality
	Nala Local Municipality	Motheo Local Municipality
	Masilonyana Local Municipality
	Maluti-a-Phofong
	Dihlabeng Local Municipality

Mpumalanga	Lekwa Local Municipality

Gauteng	Emfuleni Local Municipality
	Ekurhuleni Metropolitan

(b) Suspension of Municipal Managers & CFOs:

Province	(i) Municipality with suspended Municipal Manager	(ii) Municipality with suspended Chief Fiancial Officer
Eastern Cape	Sunday's River Valley
	Kou-Kamma Local Municipality
	Great Kei Local Municipality
	Engcobo Local Municipality
	Nyandeni Local Municipality

Kwa Zulu Natal	Newcastle Local Municipality	Nongoma Local Municipality
	Indaka Local Municipality
	Umkhanyakude Local Municipality
	Nkandla Local Municipality
	Umhlathuze Local Municipality

Limpopo	Blouberg Local Municipality
	Molemole Local Municipality
	Polokwane Local Municipality

Northern Cape	No suspensions

North West	Mafikeng Local Municipality	Ngaka Modiri Molema
	Rustenburg Local Municipality	Kgetleng Rivier Local Municipality
	Greater Taung Local Municipality
	Madibeng Local Municipality

Free State	Letsemeng Local Municipality	Motheo District Municipality

Mpumalanga	Msukalingwa Local Municipality
	Nkomazi Local Municipality
	Mbombela Local Municipality

Western Cape	Bitou Local Municipality
	Oudtshoorn Local Municipality
	Saldanha Bay Local Municipality
	Drakenstein Local Municipality
	Witzenberg Local Municipality
	Eden District Municipality

Gauteng	No suspensions

Question 310

310. Mr W P Doman (DA) to ask the Minister for Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: [Written Question No 1421]

(a) Which municipalities do not supply any free basic services relating to (i) water, (ii) electricity and (iii) refuse removal and (b) what is the position with regard to free basic electricity services by Eskom to the areas where they take responsibility for reticulation? NW1777E

ANSWER

(a) All municipalities within the Republic of South Africa provide Free Basic Services (i.e Free Basic Energy, Free Basic Water and Refuse) policies and programs in place. The department has released a report on the extent to which indigent households are benefiting. Eskom continues to provide Free Basic Electricity in local municipalities with whom they have a service level agreement. Eskom provides to 241 municipalities, with an exception of Matzikama and Nama –Khoi municipalities.

(b) In Eskom areas of supply a Funding agreement is signed between municipalities and Eskom. Municipalities submit to Eskom an approved list of qualifying households. Eskom provides 50Kwh of Free Basic Electricity (FBE) to qualifying households on a monthly basis.

Question 308

308. Mrs M Wenger (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: [Written Question No 1398]

(1) Whether all the municipalities in which demonstrations took place are receiving free basic (a) water, (b) electricity and (c) sanitation; if not, (i) why not and (ii) which municipalities do not receive each of the specified services; if so, what are the relevant details in each case;

(2) whether any of these municipalities receive more than the minimum requirement; if so, (a) which municipalities and (b) what are the relevant details in each case? NW1753E

ANSWER

(1) All municipalities in which demonstrations took place do have free basic services policies and programmes in place for water and electricity. These municipalities purchase bulk water and electricity and provide a portion of this for free to Indigent households. Sanitation is not included since there is no national policy on free basic sanitation. The extent to which Indigent households benefit from these programmes differs across municipalities. Last week, the Department has released a report on Free Basic Services.

(2) In terms of the policies set by DWAF and DME, the service level for FBE is 50 KW/hand for FBW it is 6 kl. All the municipalities in question comply with the policy in the provision of FBE and FBW.

Municipalities affected by Service Delivery Protests: June 2009-September 2009

(See table on the following page)

Annexure A

*Province*	*Municipality*	*Place*	*Community Issues*	*Periods of protests*
Mpumalanga	1. Thaba Chweu Municipality	Lydenburg	Corruption within Local Government	June 2009
	2. Lekwa Local Municipality	Siyathemba	Poor roads, lock of access to water, electricity, housing and job opportunities.	July 2009
		Sakhile Township	Alleged acts of fraud by officials, maladministration and corruption.	September 2009
	3. Mbombela Local Municipality	Nelspruit	Residents demanded service delivery from the local municipality.	September 2009
	4. Dipaleseng Local Municipality	Balfour	Allegation that leaders ignore the community and do not listen to them.	July 2009
	5. Emalahleni Local Municipality	Witbank (Mpumalanga)	Poor service delivery, maladministration, fraud and corruption.	July 2009
Gauteng	6. City of Johannesburg	Diepsloot	Relocation of informal settlement dwellers	July 2009
	7. Emfuleni Local Municipality	Rust – de –vaal	There was a complaint that local municipality and government failed to provide residents with RDP houses.	August 2009
	8. City of Ekhuruleni	Thokoza	Poor sanitation and housing.	July 2009
		Ramaphosa informal settlement	Approximately 6000 residents handed a memorandum of grievances to the local councilor.	July 2009
	9. Midvaal Local Municipality	Vereeniging	Better service delivery.	July 2009
		Mayerton	Better service delivery	July 2009
Kwazulu Natal	10. Msunduzi Municipality	Edenvale	Youth demanded removal of Ward 22 councillors	July 2009
Eastern Cape	11. Nelson Mandela Bay Metro	Uitenhage	Poor municipal service delivery.	August 2009
	12. Buffalo City	Duncan Village	Poor service delivery.	July 2009
Western Cape	13. City of Cape Town	Khayelitsha	Housing	August 2009
		Masiphumelele	Anger over poor municipal service delivery.	July 2009
	14. Knysna Local Municipality	Hlalani Settlement	Allegation that the municipality ignored communities need for proper housing.	July 2009
North West	15. Maquassi Hills Local Municipality	Kgakala Township	Lack of municipal services	July 2009

Questions and Replies

21 January 2010 - Questions asked to Minister of Questions & Replies No 151 to 200

20 January 2010 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 2276 to 2300

19 January 2010 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 2401 to 2425

19 January 2010 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 2376 to 2400

19 January 2010 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 2426 to 2450

31 December 2009 - Questions: Minister of Economic Development

MPs to ask the Minister of Economic Development

Reply:

30 December 2009 - Questions: Minister of Basic Education

MPs to ask the Minister of Basic Education

Reply:

29 December 2009 - Question:Minister of Higher Education

MPs to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training

Reply:

25 December 2009 - NW2009

McGluwa, Mr JJ to ask the Minister of Human Settlements

Reply:

24 December 2009 - Question:Minister of Home Affairs

MPs to ask the Minister of Home Affairs

Reply:

02 December 2009 - Question:Minister of Cooperative Governance

MPs to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and TraditionalAffairs

Reply:

01 December 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 2301 to 2325

27 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 2351 to 2375

27 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 2326 to 2350

27 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 2251 to 2275

26 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 2126 to 2150

26 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 2201 to 2225

26 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No. 2101 to 2125

26 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 2026 to 2055

26 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 2226 to 2250

25 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 2071 to 2100

25 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 1976 to 2000

25 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 2056 to 2070

25 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 2151 to 2175

25 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies NO 1851 to 1875

25 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 2176 to 2200

25 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 2001 to 2025

25 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 1876 to 1900

24 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 1826 to 1850

17 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 1926 to 1950

16 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No. 1901 to 1925

16 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No. 1526 to 1575

05 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Repiles No 1726 to 1750

05 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 1951 to 1975

05 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Repiles No 1601 to 1625

05 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Repiles No 1751 to 1775

05 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Repiles No 1801 to 1825

04 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Repiles No 1651 to 1675

04 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 1501 to 1525

03 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 1626 to 1650

03 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 1776 to 1800

02 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 1701 to 1725

02 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 1676 to 1700

02 November 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 1576 to 1600

21 October 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Questions & Replies No 1476 to 1500

16 October 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 1376 to 1400

12 October 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 1451 to 1475

12 October 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 1326 to 1350

09 October 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 1401 to 1425

07 October 2009 - Questions asked to Minister of Question & Replies No 1301 to 1325

What's wrong with this page?