A summary of this committee meeting is not yet available.
SPORT AND RECREATION PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE
11 November 2003
UNITED CRICKET BOARD AND MINISTERIAL COMMITTEE ON TRANSFORMATION REPORT IN SOUTH AFRICAN CRICKET: BRIEFING
Chairperson: Ms N Bhengu (ANC)
Documents handed out:
Progress Report by United Cricket Board of South Africa (Appendix)
A Guide to Club Cricket Administration in South Africa
The Committee was briefed on the strategic planning workshops held by United Cricket Board of South Africa. UCBSA presenter stated that the purpose of the workshops was to introduce the key target groups being the development of women's cricket, the focus on club cricket especially in previously disadvantaged areas and a sports development strategy for disabled persons. The report produced adequate information that enabled the Committee to unanimously agree that UCBSA had fulfilled its duty of improving the transformation process in South African cricket. It was agreed that UCBSA and the Ministerial Committee Investigating Transformation in Cricket should work together to further enhance strategic planning structures that would benefit the positive growth in cricket transformation.
Mr Mali, President of UCBSA admitted to the growth of a flourishing relationship between UCBSA and the South African Government structures. He was proud of the launch focussing on the development of club cricket.
Mr Majola CEO of UCBSA presented the progress report and stated that on studying the Ministerial Committee report earlier that year, progress had been made. For example, focus was shifted from mainly concentrating on the development on the national level to development at club level.
Mr Majola said that UCBSA was grateful to the Ministerial Committee for drawing their attention to areas that needed more development in line with the transformation process.
Ms Lamani (ANC) congratulated both the MCITC and UCBSA for the progressive work that they had done. She was very proud of UCBSA for it interacted with people on ground level building a strong relationship with MCITC. Ms Lamani said that training was the key to transformation and that the maintenance of sports facilities was also important. She had observed much in the report which was encouraging.
The Chair was glad to hear that the relationship between UCBSA and government structures had improved.
Dr Nyoka (MCITC) thanked UCBSA for their promising report that represented the continuing progress of transformation in South African cricket. He was concerned that although transformation targets in cricket were reached most provinces never exceeded the minimal levels of transformation and that had to be addressed.
Both Mr Basson (General Manager: Cricket Affairs) and Dr Nyoka raised the issue that in the northern provinces such as Gauteng the black cricket players were relocated from the South and Eastern provinces. Therefore the development programme had not been effective in training the indigenous black members of those regions.
Mr Mali stated that the sickness of South African cricket could be cured with the development and training of competent administrators and coaches, that there should be strong club cricket structures in place. To include indigenous members of a particular region required education of the game of cricket where cricket could then become a development programme in schools. Thus a cricket culture must be born that would draw in indigenous persons to become cricketers.
Mr Lee (DA) congratulated Mr Mali on his new position as President of UCBSA. He said that he was happy that focus has been shifted to club cricket. Sponsorships should go to clubs that were really struggling financially and that there should be control over the granting of sponsorships.
Mr Majola said that sponsorships were currently awarded to all premier leagues for the upgrading of cricket grounds and facilities but that funding for other cricket clubs would not be ignored. He said that R3 million is contributed per annum to struggling clubs.
The Chair asked the presenters whether they had met with the MCITC to discuss the report prior to the committee meeting and Mr Majola said that they had not met beforehand but that he thought that it would be advantageous if they could meet with them.
Mr Smith (Chair of MCITC) expressed his relief at the rational response of UCBSA with their implementation of compelling workshop strategies and match by match statistics. He said that the progress thus far as stated in the presentation highlighted the commitment of UCBSA to ensure positive transformation in cricket. He agreed that this was a basis as Mr Majola had said to hold a meeting between his committee and UCBSA.
Mr Louw (ANC) enquired about the quota system and whether it was still used as part of addressing transformation in cricket. That question led to a debate amongst the members when the Chair and Dr Nyoka also asked what decision was taken when a recommendation was made for the quota system to be reapplied. Mr Mali said the UCBSA never spoke of quotas and that that angle came from the media. Targets were set to promote transformation and that the quota system was scrapped.
Mr Louw continued to argue that it was unfair to blame the media and that in the previous committee meeting in May of that year, UCBSA spoke about quotas. A press conference should be called to rectify public opinion that the quota system was still in use.
Dr Nyoka said that he was satisfied with the explanation given by UCBSA and that the public should be notified.
Mr Mali stated that the committee was approached to discuss the transformation in cricket and to judge whether those matters of concern raised by MCITC earlier in that year were dealt with. He said that everyone present was happy with UCBSA's progress and that room should not be given to widen the gap between MCITC and UCBSA.
Mr Smith was in agreement with Mr Mali and said that a meeting should take place between MCITC and UCBSA. His committee's briefing was to put the Minister of Sport's mind at ease and surely he was satisfied with the key transformation strategies developed by UCBSA.
Mr Lucas (DA) said that much time had been wasted and that the two committees should get together to resolve grey areas and work together to ensure the continuous progress in cricket transformation more efficiently.
The Chair's final words were that she found the meeting to be satisfying and was happy with the mannerisms of UCBSA because in the previous committee meeting in May 2003, their attitudes had been terrible. She had confidence in the new leadership of Mr Mali as President of UCBSA. However, confusion over the decision taken about the quota system should be corrected.
The Chair said that whenever meetings took place between UCBSA and MCITC the Committee as well as the public should be notified of the discussions and decisions that were taken. The Chair wanted UCBSA to meet with the Minister of Sport and keep him informed of the progress and challenges experienced by the cricket board.
Meeting was adjourned.
PRESENTATION TO THE PARLIAMENTARY PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE FOR SPORT AND RECREATION BY THE UNITED CRICKET BOARD OF SOUTH AFRICA
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 11, 2003
Since our last presentation to the Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Sport and Recreation on 20th of May this year, the United Cricket Board of South Africa has had a series of Strategic Planning Workshops with its 11 Affiliates.
A Task Committee comprising Messrs Ray Mali (Chair: Development Sub-Committee and now President of the UCBSA); Brian Basson (General Manager: Cricket Affairs), Chris Day (UCBSA Transformation Consultant) and myself, held strategic planning meetings with Affiliates during the months of July and August 2003.
During these workshops, the Affiliates were represented by the President, CEO, Amateur Cricket Manager, Professional Cricket Manager, Transformation Representative, Convenor of Selectors, Senior Coach, Senior Captain, Women's Cricket Representative and any other relevant officials elected by the respective boards.
Sport and Recreation MECs, or their representatives in each Province were also invited to attend these workshops and we had an excellent response from these representatives.
THE PURPOSE OF THE WORKSHOPS
- Have hands-on, two-way communication between the UCBSA office and Affiliates across the board.
- Outline the UCBSA's new structures and domestic competition formats under review.
- Launch the UCBSA's focus on club cricket this season.
- Development of Women's Cricket.
- Overview of Affiliates' strategic planning for the next three years.
- Review transformation targets for 2002/2003 and set new ones for 2003/2004.
- Review the report of the Ministerial Task Committee on Cricket Transformation.
- Report back to General Council on the above issues.
MINISTERIAL COMMITTEE REPORT & UCBSA'S NEW FOCUS ON CLUB CRICKET
We had studied the Ministerial Committee's report before the workshops began, and our conclusion was that many of the findings coincided with the challenges that have been identified by the UCBSA and we are grateful to the Committee for drawing attention once again to the need to focus on these areas.
A study of the report, coupled to our own findings, pointed the finger squarely again on the need to focus on the development of club cricket - especially in previously disadvantaged communities.
When we applied our transformation policy to our own research and that of the Ministerial Committee, we saw that if we are going to bring about representivity through capacity building we have to do it at club level.
As the ministerial report pointed out, and as we know only too well, we have been concentrating in the main on the development of cricket at school level and at national team level.
The development at club level, has consequently marked time, and not gone forward at the required rate.
If we want to keep good schoolboys and girls in the game and develop them into international stars, then we have to use clubs to keep them in the game - and to launch them forward into first class and international cricket.
If we want to produce better administrators, better players, better coaches, and more spectators then we have to do it though club structures.
As the Ministerial report so aptly pointed out, representivity on its own is not enough - representivity has to be coupled to capacity building.
Again, if we are going to build capacity across the cricketing spectrum then the best place to do it is at club level.
HOW ARE WE GOING TO IMPLEMENT THIS FOCUS ON CLUB CRICKET?
Firstly, we have to look at our transformation policy.
The UCBSA's Transformation policy is based on that of the South African Sports Commission, and we see affirmative action as a programme of action that is designed to redress the imbalances of past discriminatory policies.
Within this framework, we have designated groups on whose behalf specific intervention is made because of historical imbalances based on discrimination.
In our case, the designated target groups are Blacks, Women and the Disabled. It is also recognised that within this group Black Africans were the worst historically disadvantaged, and advancement needs to be accelerated for this designated group.
Again, we are at one with the Ministerial Committee on these issues, and so when we apply them to the focus on club cricket then this accelerated advancement for this designated group must take place.
If capacity building is the solution, then education and training is the key to unlock the solution.
And so we have begun an excellent operational partnership with the South African Sports Commission, in conjunction with the relevant THETA, to run club administration courses throughout South Africa.
This education and training relationship with the Sports Commission will shortly become a formal agreement so there can be an exchange of training skills across the spectrum and implemented across the nation through cricket.
This is a very exciting progression, and has come about because of the in-put of our own people, the Sports Commission officers and the report of the Ministerial Committee.
We are also building other partnerships with Government at local, provincial and national level to address issues such as the provision of facilities, and most importantly, the maintenance of these facilities.
These are complex issues because community and school facilities fall under a myriad of regulatory factors controlled by different bodies and so we are seeking a way with our partners to break through the red tape and get the job done.
These are the club cricket development issues that we work-shopped with our Affiliates on our national strategic planning tour, and on each occasion we discussed regional issues raised by the Ministerial Committee's report.
And, as we have said, most of these issues revolved around club development in previously disadvantaged areas and so this reinforced our programme.
The standard of club cricket had deteriorated considerably over the past few years, and it was now imperative to rectify the situation.
Emphasis in the past few years had been placed on schools and first class cricket, with the gap widening considerably between the two through the neglect of club cricket.
There was also a dearth of good administrators coming through the system, particularly in Black African communities and club development, will address this.
Lack of funding, poor facilities and weak administration at club level were areas that needed to be addressed, and the UCBSA is to initiate the following as a matter of urgency:
- Seek a national sponsor for Provincial Club Premier Leagues.
Incentives will also be provided to keep non-contracted players in cricket club structures through:
- Selecting a combined national club team from non-contracted players at the MTN Club Championships to represent South Africa at the Africa Zone 6 Tournament.
- The MTN Club Champions playing a touring team "A" team, or touring abroad.
We are going to have follow up club development workshops with the Provinces and draw up a plan of action for each region and again the relevant information in the Ministerial Committee's report will be a reference. The draft club administration training document, which will form the basis of the workshops has been given to you.
Representatives from the all the relevant Government departments, including Sport and Recreation, will be part of this programme.
Initially, the Cricket World Cup Legacy Projects in the townships we be the main focus, and then we will look at other regions based on funding.
From 1995 to 2003, the United Cricket Board of SA have qualified more than
6 000 coaches from Bakers Mini Cricket to Level 4, which is one of the highest courses in the world. The UCB is going to direct this pool on coaching into club cricket to raise standards and to provide a bridge from junior cricket into first class cricket. Coaching at club level was highlighted in the Ministerial Committee's report as one of the biggest challenges facing SA cricket. We believe our response to this challenge will address this critical issue.
REPRESENTIVITY AND ACHIEVING TRANSFORMATION TARGETS
In terms of the UCBSA's policy, the implementation of transformation targets is the responsibility of Provincial Presidents and CEOs, with the National President and National CEO having ultimate responsibility to the UCBSA's General Council which sets the policy in the first place.
On wider representivity issues, we have in place a new monitoring system that is now going into its second season.
On the field representivity monitoring is done on a match-by-match, and CEOs are responsible for filling in forms that are sent to my office before matches begin.
In this way, we know exactly what is going to happen on the field from this point of view and we can intervene immediately if targets are not met.
In a recent case, we did not allow a women's match to take place between Easterns and KwaZulu-Natal because Easterns did not have the required target of a minimum of 50/50. This was picked up by the Easterns' CEO and we were able to take joint action.
However, we are most pleased to report that players' representivity targets are being more than met on the field at all levels and we would like to show you a few examples of this and how the system is monitored.
Free State Country Districts team report
Northerns women's team report
Griquas B team
SA team to Pakistan
On wider representivity issues, it must be noted since our last meeting that a new General Council has been elected and the number of Black representatives has increased even further and now stands at 11 out of 17
We also now have our first Black African President, Boet Ray Mali, and this is true recognition for those many people who fought the good fight for cricket in the dark years of discrimination.
The development of Women's Cricket has also become a priority, and this, too, was a challenge highlighted by the Ministerial Committee's report.
The development of women's cricket is essential because:
- It is a designated target area for transformation according to the UCBSA's Transformation Policy.
- The SA Women's Cricket Association had been granted Associate Member status by the UCBSA.
- South Africa had been asked to host the 2005 Women's Cricket World Cup.
All Affiliates committed themselves to the development of women's cricket. However there remain challenges and these include the need for:
- A uniform development structure.
- Streamlined communication and action systems.
- Increased funding.
- More facilities in most regions.
- Integration into club structures.
- Improved coaching.
- Developing girls from Bakers Mini Cricket into women's hardball cricket.
Women's cricket will also form part of the club cricket workshops, and many of the above issues will be addressed at this forum.
Lotto funding has been made available to women's cricket, and all 11 Affiliates benefited from this funding. Once again we are most greatful to the ministry of Sport & Recreation for their assistance in this regard.
PROGRESS ON TRANSFORMATION TARGETS SET FOR THE SEASON 2003/2004
The report on the implementation of transformation targets by the UCBSA and its Affiliates for this season was contained in the UCBSA presentation to the Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Sport and Recreation on May 20, 2003.
Gains had been made across the transformation spectrum, especially in designated target areas such as the advancement of Black Africans, women and the disabled. However, these remain major challenges and will require continued commitment and focus.
Targets for the new season have been advanced on the previous season, with special attention being given to representivity levels with coaching, umpiring, scoring, employment equity and capacity building of Black administrators.
Challenges that remain are the Black representivity levels at senior provincial coaching and captaincy, but these are improving.
Statistics for the new season are showing a trend of an increase of 10% across the board of Black representivity, and this translates into an expected average of 40% for professional cricket and above 60% for amateur cricket.
There are two graphic examples of this representivity trend. Firstly, the SuperSport match between Border & Western Province this week had 11 out of 22 black players on the field.
Secondly, the SuperSport player rankings for the season shows that black cricketers are in the forefront.
We would like to assure the members of Portfolio Committee and the Ministerial Committee that we appreciate your keen interest in the transformation process of South African cricket, and that we will continue to do the job in the best interest of cricket and South African sport.
Our President, Mr. Ray Mali, at the beginning of these proceedings recommitted the United Cricket Board of South Africa to working with the Portfolio Committee for Sport & Recreation and this commitment is fully endorsed by all structures of South African cricket.
Thank you for affording us this opportunity to have further dialogue with this committee.
My President and I will be happy to take any questions.
I thank you.
No related documents
- We don't have attendance info for this committee meeting
Download as PDF
You can download this page as a PDF using your browser's print functionality. Click on the "Print" button below and select the "PDF" option under destinations/printers.
See detailed instructions for your browser here.