ATC230829: Report of the Ad Hoc Committee to Nominate a Person for Appointment as Public Protector, Dated 29 August 2023
Report of the Ad Hoc Committee to Nominate a Person for Appointment as Public Protector, Dated 29 August 2023
The ad hoc Committee to Nominate a Person for Appointment as Public Protector (the Committee), having considered the request by the National Assembly to nominate a person for appointment as Public Protector, reports as follows:
1. On 25 May 2023, having noted that the term of office of the Public Protector expires on 14 October 2023, the National Assembly resolved, in accordance with section 193(5) of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996, to establish an ad hoc committee to nominate a person for appointment as Public Protector. The Committee to -
(a) Consist of eleven members as follows: African National Congress (ANC) 6, Democratic Alliance (DA) 2, Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) 1 and other parties 2;
(b) Consist further of fourteen non-voting members of the Assembly as follows: ANC 2, DA 1, EFF 1 and other parties 10;
(c) Exercise the powers in Rule 167 that it may deem necessary to perform its task; and
(d) Report to the House by 31 August 2023.
2. The following members were nominated by their parties to serve on the Committee:
- ANC: Magwanishe, Mr G; Xaba, Mr VC; Lesoma, Ms RMM; Tlhape, Ms ME; Mananiso, Ms JS; Dyantyi, Mr QR.
- DA: Ms. G Breytenbach; Mr. W Horn; Dr MM Gondwe (Non-voting member).
- EFF: Maotwe, Ms OMC; Yako, Ms Y (Non-voting member).
- Inkatha Freedom Party (IFP): Buthelezi, Mr EM.
- Freedom Front Plus: Wessels, Mr WW.
- National Freedom Party: Shaik-Emam, Mr AM (Non-voting member).
- African Christian Democratic Party: Swart, Mr S (Non-voting member).
- AL JAMA-AH: Hendricks, Mr MGE (Non-voting member).
- African Independent Congress: Jaftha, Mr SM (Non-voting member).
- African Transformation Movement: Zungula, Mr V (Non-voting member).
- Congress of the People: Madisha, Mr WM (Non-voting member).
- GOOD: Herron, Mr BN (Non-voting member).
- United Democratic Movement: Kwankwa, Mr NLS (Non-voting member).
- Pan Africanist Congress of Azania: Nyhontso, Mr M (Non-voting member).
3. The Committee met for the first time on 6 June 2023, electing Mr VC Xaba (ANC) as the Chairperson of the Committee.
4. The Committee held further meetings, as follows:
- 8 June 2023 to consider its process.
- 12 July 2023 to further consider its process, having received nominations and applications for the position.
- 26 July 2023 to conduct shortlisting.
- 22 August 2023 to further consider its process, including the results of the various screening processes.
- 23 and 24 August 2023 to conduct interviews.
- 29 August 2023 to conduct deliberations and to adopt the report.
5. Legal framework and process
5.1. The Committee’s process is guided by the relevant constitutional and statutory provisions, as well as the Rules of the National Assembly.
5.2. In terms of section 193(4) of the Constitution, 1996, the President must appoint a Public Protector on the recommendation of the National Assembly. Regarding the role of the National Assembly, section 193(5) of the Constitution, 1996, provides that:
“The National Assembly must recommend persons -
(a) nominated by a Committee of the Assembly proportionally composed of members of all parties represented in the Assembly; and
(b) approved by the Assembly by a resolution adopted with the supporting vote of at least 60 per cent of the members of the Assembly if the recommendation concerns the appointment of the Public Protector …’.
6. Public participation
6.1. Section 193(2) of the Constitution provides that the involvement of civil society in the recommendation process may be provided for as envisaged in section 59(1) of the Constitution. Section 59(1) provides for public access to and involvement in the National Assembly. Broadly, the provision states that the Assembly must facilitate public involvement in its legislative and other processes and conduct its business in an open manner and hold its sittings, and those of its committees, in public.
6.2. To facilitate public participation, the Committee agreed to an open and transparent process:
6.2.1. The advertisement requesting nominations or applications for the position of Public Protector from members of the public appeared in all official languages in various newspapers throughout the country. The advertisement also appeared on Parliament’s website. The closing date for nominations or applications was 7 July 2023.
6.2.2. The Committee received a total of 53 nominations and 17 applications. Of the 53 nominations, 32 did not meet the nomination requirements as set out in the advertisement. Two candidates subsequently withdrew from the process.
6.2.3. The Committee published the names of all candidates, with their accompanying curriculum vitae on Parliament’s website, providing members of the public with the opportunity to make submissions on the candidates. The period for public comment closed on 21 July 2023. The Committee considered the submissions, noting that there were no adverse remarks about any of the candidates.
7. Selection criteria and shortlisting
7.1. Section 193 of the Constitution, 1996, and section 1A of the Public Protector Act 23 of 1994 set out the applicable criteria for appointment as Public Protector: The Public Protector must be a South African citizen and a fit and proper person to hold the position. Section 1A(3) of the Public Protector Act 23 of 1994, adds that the Public Protector shall be:
“…a South African citizen who is a fit and proper person to hold such office, and who-
(a) is a Judge of a High Court; or
(b) is admitted as an advocate or an attorney and has, for a cumulative period of at least 10 years after having been so admitted, practised as an advocate or an attorney; or
(c) is qualified to be admitted as an advocate or an attorney and has, for a cumulative period of at least 10 years after having so qualified, lectured in law at a university; or
(d) has specialised knowledge of or experience, for a cumulative period of at least 10 years, in the administration of justice, public administration or public finance; or
(e) has, for a cumulative period of at least 10 years, been a member of Parliament; or
(f) has acquired any combination of experience mentioned in paragraphs (b) to (e), for a cumulative period of at least 10 years”.
7.2. All candidates were requested to complete a questionnaire, which also contained disclosure provisions.
7.3. In addition, the Committee agreed that the academic qualifications of those shortlisted would be verified and that Parliament should be asked to facilitate screening of the candidates.
7.4. The results of these processes were made available to the Committee on 22 August 2023 prior to the interviews being conducted. There were no adverse findings in the reports provided.
8. Shortlisting and Interviewing
8.1. On 26 July 2023, the Committee met to shortlist the candidates. When considering the meaning of ‘fit and proper’ the Committee agreed to be guided by case law, which points to attributes such as character, experience, knowledge, and skills, among others.
8.2. A total of eight (8) candidates were shortlisted, as follows:
- Adv. Kholeka Gcaleka.
- Adv. Oliver Josie.
- Ms Johanna Kwenadi Ledwaba.
- Ms Muvhango Lukhaimane.
- Adv. Lynn Marais.
- Prof. Boitumelo Mmusinyane.
- Adv. Kwena Thomas Ntsewa.
- Adv. Tseliso Thipanyane.
8.3. The interviews were conducted at Parliament at S12A on 23 and 24 August 2023.
9. The Committee met to deliberate on 29 August 2023 and agreed to nominate Adv. Kholeka Gcaleka for appointment as Public Protector, with the Democratic Alliance, Economic Freedom Fighters and Freedom Front Plus dissenting.
10. Having considered the National Assembly’s request for the Committee to nominate a person for appointment as Public Protector, the Committee recommends that the House recommends Adv. Kholeka Gcaleka to the President for appointment as Public Protector.
11.1. The Committee would like to thank all candidates for making themselves available to be considered for appointment.
11.2. Further, the Committee would like to acknowledge the active involvement of members of the public in this process.
Report to be considered.