Questions and Replies
08 November 2016 - NW2424
Macpherson, Mr DW to ask the Minister of Trade and Industry
(1)Whether any application was made for a Special Economic Zone in the Ugu District Municipality in KwaZulu-Natal; if so, what are the relevant details; if not, (2) Whether any (a) formal and/or (b) informal interactions have taken place between (i) the specified district municipality, (ii) the Ugu South Coast Development Agency and (iii) his department in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details in each case?
Reply:
1. The Department of Trade and Industry has not received any application for a Special Economic Zone from the Ugu District Municipality in KwaZulu-Natal,
2. There has not been any interaction, formal or informal, between the dti and the Ugu District Municipality or with Ugu South Coast Development Agency.
08 November 2016 - NW2244
De Freitas, Mr MS to ask the Minister of Transport
(a) How many tenders were awarded by her department for scholar transport in the past three financial years to date, (b) to whom was each of the specified tenders awarded, (c) when was each tender awarded, (d) what were the time frames in each case, (e) what was the value of each tender, (f) what conditions were attached to each tender and (g) what mechanisms were put in place to ensure that the conditions of each tender were met by the successful tender recipients?
Reply:
The Department of Transport is not responsiblefor the procurement of scholar transport services. The responsibility to procure scholar transport services resides with provincial Departments of Transport and Education as contracting authorities.
No tenders were awarded by this department for scholar transport in the past three financial years
08 November 2016 - NW1977
Maynier, Mr D to ask the President of the Republic
Whether he has received any petitions concerning the Financial Intelligence Centre Amendment Bill [B33B-2015] sent to him for assent; if so, for each specified petition so received, (a) who furnished him with the specified petition, (b) when was the specified petition furnished and (c) what was the purpose of the petition?
Reply:
The Presidency continues with the processing of the Financial Intelligence Centre Amendment (FICA) Bill which has been passed by Parliament and referred to me for assent and signing into law.
Yes, I have received formal objections to the signing of the Bill from the Progressive Professionals Forum and the Black Business Council. When I am petitioned not to sign a bill, I have an obligation to consider the merits of such objection focusing mainly on whether the interested parties raise valid constitutional issues.
I have also received formal correspondence in support of the Bill from Honourable Floyd Shivambu, Economic Freedom Fighters Deputy President and Chief Whip and Mr Lawson Naidoo, Executive Secretary of CASAC, the Council for the Advancement of the South African Constitution.
08 November 2016 - NW2249
Hunsinger, Mr CH to ask the Minister of Transport
(1)Whether her department has complied with all court orders that were issued in respect of the Tasima matter; if not, (a) why not, in each case and (b) which court orders did her department not comply with; if so, what is the position in this regard; (2) (a) what amount did her department pay to Tasima since the last court order was issued, (b) on what date were the specified payments made and (c) what were the reasons for each payment made?
Reply:
(1) The Department has complied with all court orders in the Tasima matter.
(2) (a) The Department has paid the total amounts of R55 769 058.44.
(b) They were paid on 2 September 2016, 29 September 2016 and 26 October 2016.
(c) It was payment for services rendered by Tasima on the eNatis including payments to third parties amongst those Telkom and the South African Post Office.
08 November 2016 - NW2366
Steyn, Ms A to ask the Minister of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries
Whether, in light of the severe drought that the country is currently experiencing, his department (a) drilled and/or (b) refurbished any boreholes since 1 October 2015; if not, why not; if so, (i) how many boreholes did his department (aa) drill and/or (bb) refurbish during the specified period, (ii) what is the exact GPS location of each of the specified boreholes, (iii) what were the costs of (aa) drilling per meter and/or (bb) refurbishment in each case and (iv) was water found at each of the boreholes?
Reply:
DAFF Directorate Infrastructure Support from Food Security and Agrarian Reform has since 1 October 2015:
(a) The Department drilled 120 boreholes as of 1st October 2015 up to date
(b) The exact sub meter GPS locations can be viewed in the table below.
(c) The average cost per meter for boreholes amounted to R550 per meter
and
(d) Of the 120 boreholes drilled 70 were successful. A success rate of 58.33%.
(e) DAFF did not refurbish any boreholes as this is the mandate of the Provinces.
Farm Name |
DoA Number |
Latitude |
Longitude |
Depth |
Cost/m in R |
Succes/ Unsuccesful |
Dr Ruth Segmotsi Mompati |
||||||
Morna |
DoA 5073 |
-26.650079921 |
23.796603772 |
144 |
550 |
Dry |
Neuham |
DoA 5075 |
-26.680274337 |
23.873168729 |
|
550 |
Dry |
Eska |
DoA 5069 |
-26.653706954 |
23.825118906 |
|
550 |
Dry |
Eska |
DoA 5070 |
-26.658269451 |
23.826967198 |
210 |
550 |
Dry |
Eska |
DoA 5068 |
-26.657604287 |
23.826321731 |
204 |
550 |
Dry |
Eska |
DoA 5065 |
-26.658474593 |
23.840929778 |
|
550 |
Dry |
Eska |
DoA 5066 |
-26.658456770 |
23.841196252 |
234 |
550 |
Dry |
Neuham |
DoA 5102 |
-26.680421980 |
23.873204860 |
204 |
550 |
Dry |
Ethol |
DoA 5099 |
-26.808474606 |
23.837137083 |
156 |
550 |
Succesful |
Pouval |
DoA 5094 |
-26.831714061 |
23.839084155 |
150 |
550 |
Succesful |
Pouval |
DoA 5096 |
-26.829568787 |
23.848539999 |
180 |
550 |
Dry |
Eureka |
DoA 5063 |
-26.712948568 |
23.900974894 |
156 |
550 |
Dry |
Vergenoeg |
DoA 5086 |
-26.815468303 |
23.865724802 |
|
550 |
Dry |
Vergenoeg |
DoA 5090 |
-26.827669954 |
23.865023390 |
|
550 |
Succesful |
Vergenoeg |
DoA 5088 |
-26.792569022 |
23.876514232 |
156 |
550 |
Succesful |
Vragas |
DoA 5082 |
-26.828892918 |
23.933892324 |
192 |
550 |
Succesful |
Pouval |
DoA 5097 |
-26.831070961 |
23.849042165 |
150 |
550 |
Succesful |
Vragas |
DoA 5083 |
-26.829004532 |
23.934347927 |
156 |
550 |
Succesful |
Itereleng |
DoA 5080 |
-26.820922979 |
23.955469208 |
|
550 |
Dry |
Vragas |
DoA 5085 |
-26.848112540 |
23.921937375 |
150 |
550 |
Succesful |
Bulrand |
DoA 5111 |
-26.77390181 |
23.76560372 |
204 |
550 |
Dry |
Vragas |
DoA 5084 |
-26.848397305 |
23.921492775 |
162 |
550 |
Succesful |
Bulrand |
DoA 5113 |
-26.78775915 |
23.74059376 |
138 |
550 |
Succesful |
Bulrand |
DoA 5112 |
-26.77621059 |
23.76528867 |
90 |
550 |
Succesful |
Eckron |
DoA 5110 |
-26.81123583 |
23.75461683 |
198 |
550 |
Dry |
Eckron |
DoA 5109 |
-26.81597758 |
23.75843921 |
150 |
550 |
Dry |
Esdale |
DoA 5117 |
-26.77650574 |
23.69665331 |
150 |
550 |
Succesful |
Rusten |
DoA 5128 |
-26.81064048 |
23.77345716 |
85 |
550 |
Dry |
Rusten |
DoA 5129 |
-26.81107648 |
23.77349169 |
136 |
550 |
Succesful |
Esdale |
DoA 5116 |
-26.78475334 |
23.67516436 |
150 |
550 |
Succesful |
Rusten |
DoA 5106 |
-26.84617027 |
23.79236971 |
|
550 |
Dry |
Rusten |
DoA 5107 |
-26.84625568 |
23.79242892 |
90 |
550 |
Succesful |
Bulrand |
DoA 5114 |
-26.78765992 |
23.74012861 |
90 |
550 |
Succesful |
Southey |
DoA 5056 |
-26.804041686 |
23.994869627 |
78 |
550 |
Succesful |
Itireleng |
DoA 5143 |
-26.82077272 |
23.95555459 |
204 |
550 |
Succesful |
Morna |
DoA 5072 |
-26.651524251 |
23.804120100 |
204 |
550 |
Dry |
Eureka |
DoA 5060 |
-26.735488981 |
23.869412964 |
150 |
550 |
Succesful |
Magabue |
DoA 5133 |
-26.61780292 |
24.08917723 |
90 |
550 |
Succesful |
Austrey |
DoA 5152 |
-26.4627293 |
24.21066246 |
180 |
550 |
Succesful |
Austrey |
DoA 5153 |
-26.46247188 |
24.2115749 |
150 |
550 |
Dry |
Ainsley |
DoA 5119 |
-26.62521069 |
23.81533263 |
204 |
550 |
Succesful |
Austrey |
DoA 5144 |
-26.45091378 |
24.21182613 |
150 |
550 |
Succesful |
Goodwood |
DoA 5148 |
-26.43313475 |
24.27674439 |
90 |
550 |
Succesful |
Goodwood |
DoA 5150 |
-26.45614722 |
24.26238743 |
120 |
550 |
Dry |
Ainsley |
DoA 5121 |
-26.62267812 |
23.82093823 |
240 |
550 |
Succesful |
Goodwood |
DoA 5151 |
-26.45584175 |
24.26357312 |
60 |
550 |
Succesful |
Conningham |
DoA 5166 |
-26.55095302 |
23.62371483 |
252 |
550 |
Dry |
Conningham |
DoA 5163 |
-26.567222381 |
23.592646880 |
240 |
550 |
Dry |
Weddel |
DoA 5164 |
-26.552624342 |
23.622589299 |
210 |
550 |
Dry |
Weddel |
DoA 5165 |
-26.560766962 |
23.616546545 |
252 |
550 |
235 |
Neuham |
DoA 5152 |
-26.668230000 |
23.884420000 |
114 |
550 |
Dry |
Derdeplaas |
DoA 5168 |
-26.543892826 |
23.629693807 |
252 |
550 |
Dry |
Koeksebrake |
DoA 5162 |
-26.517433743 |
23.597726773 |
240 |
550 |
Succesful |
Derdeplaas |
DoA 5167 |
-26.547494873 |
23.628114028 |
252 |
550 |
Dry |
Ludick |
DoA 5159 |
-26.547914352 |
23.565951512 |
246 |
550 |
Succesful |
Vorster |
DoA 5180 |
-26.527859864 |
23.543749841 |
228 |
550 |
Succesful |
Koudslaap |
DoA 5172 |
-26.405470000 |
23.599070000 |
312 |
550 |
Dry |
Koudslaap |
DoA 5171 |
-26.418883810 |
23.596502880 |
192 |
550 |
Succesful |
marettlwa |
DoA 5175 |
-26.519317923 |
23.803126777 |
252 |
550 |
Dry |
Vierdeplaas |
DoA 5169 |
-26.451251060 |
23.577725110 |
180 |
550 |
Succesful |
Bardenhorst |
DoA 5186 |
-26.387954797 |
23.654847457 |
252 |
550 |
507 |
Horstbarden |
DoA 5173 |
-26.449082200 |
23.634378970 |
252 |
550 |
Succesful |
Maretllwa |
DoA 5176 |
-26.521721107 |
23.806226802 |
222 |
550 |
Succesful |
Horstbarden |
DoA 5174 |
-26.450246480 |
23.639113340 |
240 |
550 |
Succesful |
Lucas |
DoA 5177 |
-26.418862917 |
23.829789363 |
222 |
550 |
Dry |
Pepane |
DoA 5184 |
-26.302727947 |
23.781908369 |
252 |
550 |
Succesful |
lucas |
DoA 5178 |
-26.416875009 |
23.831787152 |
252 |
550 |
Succesful |
Groblersvreugde |
DoA 5188 |
-26.289152130 |
23.608805820 |
150 |
550 |
Succesful |
Pepane |
DoA 5185 |
-26.360336248 |
23.774762015 |
252 |
550 |
Succesful |
Serurubele |
DoA 5190 |
-26.536172430 |
23.001518680 |
252 |
550 |
Dry |
Ditsobotla |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Monamaladi |
DoA 5043 |
-26.295045211 |
26.460779478 |
40 |
550 |
Succesful |
Monamaladi |
DoA 5044 |
-26.289680260 |
26.462716825 |
57 |
550 |
Succesful |
Mafikeng |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Lokaleng |
DoA 5029 |
-25.809860698 |
25.558570584 |
60 |
550 |
Succesful |
Miga |
DoA 5031 |
-25.651711027 |
25.561691056 |
60 |
550 |
Succesful |
Mmagotsholwang |
DoA 5006 |
-25.756390678 |
25.051964380 |
150 |
550 |
Dry |
Mmagotsholwang |
DoA 5007 |
-25.756128397 |
25.051675960 |
150 |
550 |
Dry |
Mmutla Mogolo - Lokgaleng Village |
DoA 5026 |
-25.717673668 |
25.526186582 |
60 |
550 |
Succesful |
Mogosane |
DoA 5024 |
-25.748117056 |
25.556002152 |
42 |
550 |
Succesful |
Six Hundred |
DoA 5034 |
-25.705053337 |
25.599952106 |
72 |
550 |
Succesful |
Tlapeng Village |
DoA 5027 |
-25.718198066 |
25.474160861 |
48 |
550 |
Dry |
Tlapeng Village |
DoA 5053 |
-25.71845424 |
25.47407141 |
72 |
550 |
Succesful |
Tshunyane |
DoA 5022 |
-26.060761782 |
25.523186773 |
120 |
550 |
Succesful |
Ratlou |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Disaneng |
DoA 4998 |
-25.785158624 |
25.270704388 |
78 |
550 |
Succesful |
Garagetsalwe - Makgobistad |
DoA 4989 |
-25.743691753 |
25.084662531 |
86 |
550 |
Dry |
Garagetsalwe - Makgobistad |
DoA 5051 |
-25.74381601 |
25.08467642 |
90 |
550 |
Succesful |
Logagane Village |
DoA 4994 |
-25.831681183 |
24.860653399 |
44 |
550 |
Dry |
Logagane Village |
DoA 4995 |
-25.823182164 |
24.861857917 |
98 |
550 |
Succesful |
Logagane Village |
DoA 5050 |
-25.83168263 |
24.86087121 |
120 |
550 |
Dry |
Mabule Village |
DoA 5008 |
-25.797258152 |
24.553098543 |
156 |
550 |
Dry |
Phiring |
DoA 5001 |
-25.778942901 |
25.166288529 |
84 |
550 |
Succesful |
Sehatlhane Farm |
DoA 5002 |
-25.810451914 |
25.109651404 |
120 |
550 |
Dry |
Sehatlhane Farm |
DoA 5003 |
-25.810110378 |
25.109757055 |
120 |
550 |
Dry |
Sethatlhong Farm |
DoA 5004 |
-25.819885330 |
25.106905831 |
90 |
550 |
Succesful |
Logageng (Kingslope) |
DoA 5019 |
-25.925482921 |
24.727657816 |
42 |
550 |
Succesful |
Makgokgwane |
DoA 5039 |
-25.732788786 |
25.604598165 |
48 |
550 |
Succesful |
Ngaka Modiri Molema |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Disaneng |
DoA 4998 |
-25.785158624 |
25.270704388 |
78 |
550 |
Succesful |
Garagetsalwe - Makgobistad |
DoA 4989 |
-25.743691753 |
25.084662531 |
86 |
550 |
Dry |
Garagetsalwe - Makgobistad |
DoA 5051 |
-25.743816010 |
25.084676420 |
90 |
550 |
Succesful |
Logagane Village |
DoA 4994 |
-25.831681183 |
24.860653399 |
44 |
550 |
Dry |
Logagane Village |
DoA 4995 |
-25.823182164 |
24.861857917 |
98 |
550 |
Succesful |
Logagane Village |
DoA 5050 |
-25.831682630 |
24.860871210 |
120 |
150 |
Dry |
Logageng (Kingslope) |
DoA 5019 |
-25.925482921 |
24.727657816 |
121 |
550 |
Dry |
Lokaleng |
DoA 5029 |
-25.809860698 |
25.558570584 |
60 |
550 |
Succesful |
Mabule Village |
DoA 5008 |
-25.797258152 |
24.553098543 |
156 |
550 |
Dry |
Makgokgwane |
DoA 5039 |
-25.732788786 |
25.604598165 |
68 |
550 |
Succesful |
Miga |
DoA 5031 |
-25.651711027 |
25.561691056 |
60 |
550 |
Succesful |
Mmagotsholwang |
DoA 5006 |
-25.756390678 |
25.051964380 |
150 |
550 |
Dry |
Mmagotsholwang |
DoA 5007 |
-25.756128397 |
25.051675960 |
150 |
550 |
Dry |
Mmutla Mogolo - Lokgaleng Village |
DoA 5026 |
-25.717673668 |
25.526186582 |
60 |
550 |
Succesful |
Mogosane |
DoA 5024 |
-25.748117056 |
25.556002152 |
42 |
550 |
Succesful |
Monamaladi |
DoA 5043 |
-26.295045211 |
26.460779478 |
60 |
550 |
Succesful |
Monamaladi |
DoA 5044 |
-26.289680260 |
26.462716825 |
77 |
550 |
Succesful |
Phiring |
DoA 5001 |
-25.778942901 |
25.166288529 |
84 |
550 |
Succesful |
Sehatlhane Farm |
DoA 5002 |
-25.810451914 |
25.109651404 |
120 |
550 |
Dry |
Sehatlhane Farm |
DoA 5003 |
-25.810110378 |
25.109757055 |
120 |
550 |
Dry |
Sethatlhong Farm |
DoA 5004 |
-25.819885330 |
25.106905831 |
90 |
550 |
Succesful |
Six Hundred |
DoA 5034 |
-25.705053337 |
25.599952106 |
72 |
550 |
Succesful |
Tlapeng Village |
DoA 5027 |
-25.718198066 |
25.474160861 |
68 |
550 |
Dry |
Tlapeng Village |
DoA 5053 |
-25.718454240 |
25.474071410 |
72 |
550 |
Succesful |
Tshunyane |
DoA 5022 |
-26.060761782 |
25.523186773 |
120 |
550 |
Succesful |
08 November 2016 - NW2285
Bergman, Mr D to ask the Minister of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries
Whether any (a) internal and/or (b) external forensic reports pertaining to (i) his department and/or (ii) each entity reporting to him were completed from 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what is the (aa) name, (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of each of the specified forensic reports?
Reply:
KPMG conducted a forensic investigation in 2010 into the following allegations:
Forensic investigations by KPMG Services (Pty) Ltd. at DAFF.
Investigations into the following focus areas were conducted by KPMG Services (Pty) Ltd.:
- Female Farmer of the Year (Supply Chain Management process),
- Media World,
- Staff appointments,
- Land Care,
- Disaster Management,
- Disease Management,
- Debt Management,
- Female Farmer of the Year (Awards Event),
- Fruitless and Wasteful expenditure,
- Venue hire,
- CASP,
- Durban Quarantine Station,
- Knowledge Bank,
- Ilima/Letsema,
- Vehicle and Travel and Subsistence Claims, and
- 3P Consulting.
Each focus area has its own report and conclusion and documents can be made available on request.
08 November 2016 - NW2300
Mokgalapa, Mr S to ask the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services
Whether any (a) internal and/or (b) external forensic reports pertaining to (i) his department and/or (ii) each entity reporting to him were completed from 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what is the (aa) name, (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of each of the specified forensic reports?
Reply:
1.Department of Justice and Constitutional Development:
The Department of Justice and Constitutional Development does not have data of the forensic audit cases for the past four (4) financial years. However, the attached spreadsheet, attached as Annexure A, provides details of the forensic audit cases registered in the 2013/14, 2014/15, 2015/16 and 2015/16 financial years.
2. Entities:
2.1 National Prosecuting Authority (NPA):
The NPA has informed that there are no forensic reports pertaining to the NPA in the period from 1 January 2009 up to date.
2.2 Special Investigating Unit (SIU):
The SIU is not aware of any internal or external forensic reports pertaining to its affairs for the period specified.
2.3 Legal Aid South Africa:
(a) The Legal Aid SA‘s internal forensic reports completed from 1 January 2009 to September 2016 are tabulated below:
aa) Name |
bb)Subject matter |
cc) Date of conclusion |
(A) 2010/11 financial year |
||
1. Allegation on performing private work and utilising Legal Aid South Africa’s assets and stationery |
Allegations against a Justice Centre Executive for performing private work. It was alleged the Executive used Legal Aid SA’s stationery, printers and personnel to run his private business. |
4 October 2010 |
2. The alleged use of Ms. Martha Mbhele’s 3G by someone else |
Alleged use of a 3G card allocated to Legal Aid SA employee by someone else. |
27 September 2010 |
3. Half day leave review at Bloemfontein Justice Centre |
Review of half days leave taken at justice centre |
11 July 2011 |
4. Complaint by Ms Ntombikhona Emmaculate Dlamini |
An investigation of circumstances relating to the legal services rendered by Judicare practitioner to a legal Aid Sa client in an eviction matter |
February 2011 |
5. Fixed asset disposed off, but is still reflected in the asset Register |
Investigation of a suspicious deposit slip submitted as proof of payment for a disposed asset. |
8 October 2010 |
6. Break-in at second floor national office Finance Department and the conduct of the corporate services manager. |
An investigation of a break-in at National Office Finance Department second floor during the 2010 December year end closure. |
16 February 2011 |
7. Allegation on non-adherence to policies, theft, abuse of Power and conflict of interest |
|
30 September 2010 |
aa) Name |
bb)Subject matter |
cc) Date of conclusion |
(B) 2011/12 financial year |
||
1. Thembisa Justice Centre receptionist’s cash stolen from her hand bag. |
Investigation of circumstances in which cash was stolen from an employee’s hand bag at a Justice Centre. |
23 September 2011 |
2. Fraud suspected invoices and quotations at Soweto Justice Centre. |
Suspected fraudulent invoice and quotations at Justice Centre. |
3 June 2011 |
3. Irregularities relating to the disposal of fixed asset and the management of petty cash at Ermelo Justice Centre. |
Suspected irregularities relating to the disposal of fixed asset and the management of petty cash at a Justice Centre. |
11 October 2011 |
4. Agency agreement practitioner MB Popo & company |
Suspected fraudulent claim by an Agency Agreement practitioner. |
30 November 2011 |
5. Stolen cellphones at Procurement department. |
Disappearance of two cellphones from Procurement Manager’s office. The cellphones were delivered by Vodacom to be distributed to employees who had ordered the phones under the contract Legal Aid SA had with Vodacom |
12 October 2011 |
6. Alleged Soshanguve JCE improper conduct and poor managerial skills |
An alleged misconduct by Justice Centre Executive for ill-treating and undermining her subordinates. |
3 October 2011 |
7. Legal Aid SA Principal Attorney suspected of trying to pass work of other practitioners as that of his own for quality assessment purposes. |
An alleged attempted fraud by a Legal Aid SA Principal Attorney who tried to claim work of other practitioners as his for quality assessment purposes. |
14 July 2011 |
8. Mr. Makgape Sophia Rammala received R2,000.00 cash from the client’s sister Ms. Fengie Masha |
An allegation against a Legal Aid SA legal practitioner based at a Satellite Office for charging a member of public fees for legal assistance given to Legal Aid SA’s client. |
25 November 2011 |
aa) Name |
bb)Subject matter |
cc) Date of conclusion |
(C) 2012/13 financial year |
||
1. Retrieving evidence on 3 hard drives from Pietermaritzburg Justice Centre |
A complaint that alleged that a Legal Aid SA Principal Attorney’s computer hard drives contained pornographic files. |
9 May 2012 |
2. Interview questions sent to selected shortlisted job applicants. |
A complaint that alleged that a Justice Centre Executive emailed interview questions to the applicant. |
4 December 2012 |
3. Cover quoting from Creative Office Furniture and Impilo Lifestyle |
A suspected cover quoting by external bidders for Legal Aid SA work or contract. |
14 December 2012 |
4. Irregularities relating to the disposal of a Toyota Yaris at Ermelo Justice Centre |
An allegation that a Legal Aid SA pool vehicle was disposed at a value below the original reserve price. |
5 March 2013 |
5. Description of goods not specified on the invoices for procurement at Nelspruit Justice Centre. |
An alleged circumvention and or violation of Legal Aid SA Supply Chain policy and procedures in procuring office grocery. |
25 January 2013 |
(D) 2014/15 financial year |
||
|
A suspected existence of conflict of interest when a contract was awarded. |
29 July 2014 |
(E) 2015/16 financial year |
||
1. Forensic investigation on the missing computer at the Kwa-Zulu Natal regional office |
Investigation of circumstances in which a laptop computer got missing while it was allocated to and in custody of a Legal Aid employee, |
26 May 2015 |
2. Forensic potential conflict of interest at the Ermelo Justice Centre, Piet Retief satellite office |
A suspicion of existence of conflict of interest when a cleaning contract at Justice Centre was awarded. |
23 July 2015 |
3. Forensic report suspected irregular expenditure at Modimolle Justice Centre |
A suspicion of occurrence of irregularities in awarding a contract for office refurbishment at Justice Centre. |
22 January 2016 |
4. Forensic potential conflict of interest at the Soweto Justice Centre |
A suspected conflict of interest by a legal practitioner. |
28 September 2015 |
5. Alleged conflict of interest at Bloemfontein justice centre |
A Legal Aid SA Justice Centre Executive was alleged to owning a company that was doing with Legal Aid SA resulting in conflict of interest. |
29 March 2015 |
(F) 2016/17 financial year |
||
1. Alleged abuse of legal Aid resources |
A Legal Aid SA employee was accused of abusing Legal Aid SA resources (computer and photocopying facility) for private matters. |
2 June 2016 |
2. Alleged payment requested by a justice practitioner for legal representation services |
A former Legal Aid SA employee was accused of having requested payment for his services in representing a client on behalf of Legal Aid SA. The employee had retired when the accusations were made. |
6 June 2016 |
3. suspected overstatement of claims by a Judicare Practitioner at Vryheid Justice Centre |
A Judicare Practitioner was suspected to have submitted fraudulent and overstated claim for work that was done on behalf of Legal Aid SA. |
15 June 2016 |
4. Suspected use of pool vehicle without authorization at the Queenstown Justice Centre |
A Legal Aid SA employee was alleged to have used a pool vehicle for private business. |
27 June 2016 |
5. Client money received by a paralegal and not paid over to the client at Musina satellite office |
A Legal Aid SA Paralegal was alleged to have taken money that was meant for the client in the sale of an RDP house. |
15 August 2016 |
(b) There were no external forensic reports in the period 2009 to date.
3. Department of Correctional Services:
BOSASA contract investigation done by SIU and former CFO was criminally charged and during disciplinary hearing he resigned.
Medical Aid fraud (MEDCOR) investigation against 702 officials done by Special Investigation Unit. Officials were criminally charged and internally they were given final written warnings. The money fraudulently obtained was recovered from the doctors.
Social grant investigation against SASSA beneficiaries against the officials was done by SIU. Officials failed to cancel grant benefits from SASSA when employed by the department or SASSA failed to stop the grant immediately after the employment of the officials. All the money owed to SASSA was paid back and disciplinary steps were taken against the involved officials.
Fraudulent matric certificates. The SIU completed investigations of 22 Department of Correctional Services officials who submitted fraudulent matric certificates. Twenty of the said officials have been dismissed.
Electronic monitoring investigation was done by KPMG. The KPMG investigation report was forwarded to SIU for further investigation. The SIU is still pursuing the matter further.
The Masetlaoka Scott and Wilson (MSW) contract still under investigation. The investigation is in progress. SIU is pursuing the matter. One official is internally charged.
07 November 2016 - NW2319
Robinson, Ms D to ask the Minister in the Presidency
Whether any (a) internal and/or (b) external forensic reports pertaining to (i) her department and/or (ii) each entity reporting to her were completed from 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what is the (aa) name, (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of each of the specified forensic reports?
Reply:
(b) External forensic report.
(i) Department of Women.
(aa) Forensic investigation into various allegations of misconduct within the department.
(bb) Forensic investigation into various allegations of misconduct and irregularities relating to:
- the TIRISANO contract;
- performance contract of the Director-General; and
- procurement of Women’s Day goods and services.
(cc) 01 April 2016.
________________________
Approved by the Minister on
Date………………………..
07 November 2016 - NW2200
Chance, Mr R to ask the Minister of Small Business Development
(1)With reference to the contract signed between her department and a certain company (name furnished) for the provision of services to a group of agricultural co-operatives in KwaZulu-Natal, (a) how many of the specified co-operatives are receiving services from the specified company and (b) what amount has been allocated to (i) each of the co-operatives and (ii) the company from (aa) the Co-operatives Incentive Scheme and/or (bb) any of her department’s other budgets since 1 April 2015;
Reply:
The department does not have a contract with Kohwa Holdings but a memorandum of understanding (a) All 12 Cooperatives have received services from Kohwa Holdings at various levels and (b) Each Cooperative has received grant funding to the tune of (i) R 350 000 and (ii) the company received R35 000 per cooperative which is R35 000 X 12 = R 420 000-00 from (aa) the Cooperatives Incentive Scheme and/or (bb) No support from other budgets since 1 April 2015
(2) what is the (a) detailed breakdown of the costs of implementing the agricultural plans for each of the co-operatives and (b) company’s fees for providing services to the co-operatives;
Reply,
For each of the 12 Cooperatives the total amount of R350 000 per cooperative was spent as follows:
Wayhans Group which supplied Irrigation Scheme |
||||
Description and Deliverables |
Qty |
Excl |
Total Amount |
|
Main pump diesel pump/generator combo |
1 |
96 150 |
96 150 |
|
PVC main line, elbow,t-fittings, PVC cement |
1 |
30 700 |
30 700 |
|
Fertigation unit and 20 foot container with |
1 |
42 167.2 |
42 167.2 |
|
Galvanised steel 50m3 resevoir tank |
1 |
47 624 |
47 624 |
|
Drip network |
1 |
44 341 |
44 341 |
|
Valves links |
1 |
10 495 |
10 495 |
|
Transport |
1 |
3760 |
3760 |
|
Installation and engineering supervision |
1 |
- |
- |
|
|
Sub Total |
275 237.7 |
275 237.7 |
|
|
|
|
||
|
|
|
||
Wayhans Group which supplied fencing material |
||||
Description and Deliverables |
Qty |
Excl |
Total Amount |
|
110m x 110 x 1.8m high bonnax fencing roll |
5 |
4 700 |
4 700 |
|
100mm gum poles & accessories included |
159 |
9 620 |
9 620 |
|
Gumpoles stays 75/100/1.8m |
18 |
990 |
990 |
|
Fence U-tack |
9 |
1 170 |
1 170 |
|
Rolls of fence wire galvanised 2.5mm 130m |
9 |
2 430 |
2 430 |
|
Bags cement & balast |
62 |
3 952 |
3 952 |
|
Gate |
1 |
3 500 |
3 500 |
|
Labour |
1 |
10 500 |
10 500 |
|
Transport |
1 |
2 900 |
2 900 |
|
|
Sub Total |
39 762 |
39 762 |
|
|
|
|
||
|
|
|
||
Kohwa Holdings |
||||
Sweet corn seed |
1 |
1210 |
1210 |
|
Spinach seedling |
1 |
515 |
515 |
|
Beetroot seedling |
1 |
1246.7 |
1246.7 |
|
Cabbage seedling |
1 |
650 |
650 |
|
Soil preparation |
3 |
1500 |
1500 |
|
Fertilisers |
3 |
1950 |
1950 |
|
Chemicals |
3 |
3759 |
3759 |
|
Lime treatment |
3 |
9 171 |
9 171 |
|
Project Management |
1 |
14 998 |
14 998 |
|
|
Sub Total |
35 000 |
35 000 |
|
|
|
|
||
|
|
|
||
|
Grand Total |
350 000 |
350 000 |
|
(3) whether the company has provided her department with a full breakdown of (a) monies spent and (b) services delivered to each of the co-operatives during the specified period; if not, in each case, why not; if so, in each case, what are the relevant details?NW2522E
Reply
The department has undertaken a post disbursement inspection as per the standard procedure to follow up and verify if all approved items have been delivered to applicants and are in order and functional. During the follow up visits, it was established that most of the items approved and paid for by the department were not delivered to almost all the 12 cooperatives. The department is in the process of commissioning a full investigation into the 12 cooperatives to ascertain the reasons for the non-delivery of the items referred to above.
07 November 2016 - NW2302
Mokgalapa, Mr S to ask the Minister of Mineral Resources
Whether any (a) internal and/or (b) external forensic reports pertaining to (i) his department and/or (ii) each entity reporting to him were completed from 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what is the (aa) name, (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of each of the specified forensic reports?
Reply:
Department of Mineral Resources |
aa) |
bb) |
cc) |
|
1 |
Mining permit application |
Objection of mining permit application |
11/10/2016 |
|
i)Dept |
2 |
Prospecting right application |
Unfair administrative procedures in processing mining right application |
11/10/2016 |
3 |
Corruption on the issuing of mining permit |
Investigation into allegations of corruption on the issuing of mining permit |
23/02/2016 |
|
4 |
Stationery procurement |
Irregular expenditure relating to procurement of stationery |
15/12/2015 |
|
5 |
Mining permit |
Incorrectly allocated mining permit |
13/10/2015 |
|
6 |
Mining permit application |
Irregular proof of submission of documents |
13/10/2015 |
|
7 |
Mining permit application |
Alleged conflict of interest |
13/10/2015 |
|
8 |
Fraud and corruption |
Fraudulent blasting certificates. |
28/07/2015 |
|
9 |
Mine Managers Certificate of Competency (MMCC) |
|
07/11/2014 |
|
10 |
Corruption |
Allegations of irregular appointment |
10/06/2014 |
|
11 |
Corruption |
Abuse of GG vehicles |
12/05/2014 |
|
12 |
Theft |
Theft and loss of cash |
12/03/2014 |
|
13 |
Irregular award of ICT Infrastructure |
Allegations of irregular award of ICT Infrastructure |
20/01/2012 |
|
aa) |
bb) |
cc) |
||
ii)Entities |
Council for Geoscience |
Fraud |
Recruitment process (mispresentation of qualifications) |
30/10/2014 |
Contravention of Supply Chain Management regulations |
Procurement irregularities |
28/02/2014 |
||
Contravention of Supply Chain Management Practice Note |
Collusion of suppliers |
18/05/2016 |
||
South African Diamond and Precious Metal Regulator |
Report on the contravention of ICT policy |
Misconduct |
31/12/2011 |
|
Corruption/fraud investigation |
Alleged misconduct |
24/03/2014 |
||
Disclosure of confidential information |
Misconduct |
28/05/2015 |
||
Mine Health and Safety Council |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
MINTEK |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
South African Diamond Trader |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
Mr MJ Zwane, MP
Minister of Mineral Resources
Date Submitted:-………………/………………/2016
07 November 2016 - NW2199
Chance, Mr R to ask the Minister of Small Business Development
(1)Does a certain person (name furnished) have any shares in a certain company (name furnished), which is a service provider of the National Gazelles Programme; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what percentage shareholding does the specified person have in the specified service provider; (2) what amount did her department pay to the service provider for consulting fees in the (a) 2014-15 and (b) 2015-16 financial years?
Reply:
- Yes the person (name furnished) has shares in the company mentioned and the company is the service provider of the Gazelles Programme. The person concerned has 40% shares in the company concerned which are in the process of being disposed.
- There was no expenditure for 2014-15 financial year. For 2015-16 financial year the department incurred the costs to the tune of R22 085 000.00 towards the implementation of the programme, broken down into the following expenditure items:
07 November 2016 - NW2214
Carter, Ms D to ask the Minister of Mineral Resources
Whether, in light of the approval that he granted for the transfer of funds from the Optimum Mine Rehabilitation Trust, he will provide details of (a) the request made to him, (b) the rationale which he applied in giving favourable consideration to the request, (c) details of the approval granted and (d) any conditions attached thereto; if not, why not?
Reply:
As the question relates to a matter which is now the subject of ongoing legal proceedings, the Minister is constrained from providing any details or information in this regard.
In view of the above, paragraphs (a) to (d) falls away.
Mr MJ Zwane, MP
Minister of Mineral Resources
Date Submitted:-………………/………………/2016
07 November 2016 - NW2201
Chance, Mr R to ask the Minister of Small Business Development
(a) What is the line item breakdown of all goods and services above R500 000 that were procured without inviting competitive bids as required by Treasury Regulation 16A6.1, as identified on page 89 of her department’s 2015-16 annual report and (b) who were the suppliers in each case?
Reply:
The goods and services above R500 000 that were procured without inviting competitive bids for the Bavumile Skills Development Project are broken down as follows:
SUPPLIER NAME |
Date of training |
Service area |
R(Total amount of contract/quotation) |
R(Amount paid) |
Aranda Learnership College |
16/02 to 19/03/2015 |
Hammanskraal, Gauteng |
293 742,66 |
44 061,00 |
16/02 to 19/03/2015 |
Mamelodi, Gauteng |
277 782,66 |
41 667,00 |
|
16/02 to 19/03/2015 |
Mamelodi, Gauteng |
138 992,66 |
||
16/02 to 19/03/2015 |
Kimberly, Northern Cape |
360 008,58 |
180 004,58 |
|
Total |
931 533,90 |
404 725,24 |
||
Kaoz Afric Design |
15/02 to 11/03/2016 |
Lephanane, Limpopo |
339 000,00 |
339 000,00 |
15/02 to 11/03/2016 |
Nelspruit, Mpumalanga |
349 000,00 |
349 000,00 |
|
Total |
688 000,00 |
688 000,00 |
||
Injiya Trading and Projects |
29/02 to 26/03/2016 |
Khayelitsha, Western Cape |
376 000,00 |
376 000,00 |
20/07 to 14/08/2015 |
Harrismith, Free State |
364 725,00 |
364 725,00 |
|
Total |
740 725,00 |
740 725,00 |
||
Grand total |
2 360 258.90 |
1 833 450 .24 |
07 November 2016 - NW2230
Lorimer, Mr JR to ask the Minister of Mineral Resources
(1)(a) What were the detailed outcomes of the discussions on Mining Operation Phakisa held in 2015, (b) how long did the specified discussions take, (c) where were the specified discussions held, (d) who attended the specified discussions and (e) what did the specified discussions cost; (2) whether the specified outcomes were published in a report; if not, why not; if so, (a) on what date was the specified report published and (b) will he furnish Mr J R B Lorimer with a copy of the specified report? NW2560E
Reply:
1. The Mining Operation Phakisa is a programme of the President assigned to the Department of Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation (DPME) as a lead department with the Department of Mineral Resources providing substantive support. The DPME would be better placed to respond to these questions.
(a– (e) – Refer to (1)
2. Refer to (1)
Mr MJ Zwane, MP
Minister of Mineral Resources
Date Submitted:-………………/………………/2016
07 November 2016 - NW2299
Tarabella - Marchesi, Ms NI to ask the MINISTER OF INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS AND COOPERATION:
(1) Whether any (a) internal and/or (b) external forensic reports pertaining to (i) her department and/or (ii) each entity reporting to her were completed from 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what is the (aa) name, (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of each of the specified forensic reports?
Reply:
1. No. Neither (a) an internal nor (b) an external forensic investigation pertaining to either (i) the department and/or (ii) entity were conducted during the said period. As a result, there is no report to that effect.
UNQUOTE
04 November 2016 - NW2251
Shinn, Ms MR to ask the Minister of Communications
Has her department concluded drawing up a comprehensive budget for submission to the National Treasury of all the anticipated costs to be incurred by (a) her department and (b) (i) government entities and (ii) their suppliers for the completion of the digital migration process until analogue switch-off; if not, what is the reason for the delay in the completion of the specified budget; if so, (aa) on what date was it submitted to the National Treasury and (bb) what are the further relevant details?
Reply:
(a) The department has together with entities, namely, Universal Service Access Agency of South Africa (USAASA) and South African Post Office (SAPO) accompanied by the Department of Telecommunications and Postal Services (DTPS) in August and September 2016 approached National Treasury to discuss the funding issues of the project. Funding is required for the Programme Management Office (PMO), Public and Consumer Awareness, Contact Centre, Dual Illumination, Set-top-boxes and related accessories such as antennae and satellite dishes as well as for installations. The department is in the process of facilitating the compilation of funding requirements with entities to submit to National Treasury in November 2016.
(b) (ii) Suppliers are not involved in the submission of funding requirements to National Treasury.
MR NN MUNZHELELE
DIRECTOR GENERAL [ACTING]
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATIONS
DATE:
MS AF MUTHAMBI (MP)
MINISTER OF COMMUNICATIONS
DATE
04 November 2016 - NW2253
Hunsinger, Mr CH to ask the Minister of Communications
a) How many government-sponsored set-top boxes have been installed since her reply to question 685 on 24 May 2016 to date, and (b) what is the detailed breakdown of the (i) municipal areas and (ii) provinces where the specified set-top boxes were installed; (2) Whether all of the specified set-top boxes that were installed are Direct to the Home set-top boxes; if not, what is the total number of the specified set-top boxes that are Digital Terrestrial Television set-top boxes; if so, what are the relevant details?
Reply:
(1)
(a) A total of 22,387 STBs have been issued, installed and service activated as at 31 October 2016
(b) (i) (ii) Attached is a spreadsheet showing the municipal areas and provinces.
(2) A total of Direct To Home (DTH) STBs installed as at 31 October 2016 is 14,143 and Digital Terrestrial Television (DTT) are 8,244. Refer to attached spreadsheet for details.
MR NN MUNZHELELE
DIRECTOR GENERAL [ACTING]
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATIONS
DATE:
MS AF MUTHAMBI (MP)
MINISTER OF COMMUNICATIONS
DATE
04 November 2016 - NW2281
Van Damme, Ms PT to ask the Minister of Communications
Whether the (a) Chief Financial Officer, (b) Chief Operations Officer and (c) Chief Executive Officer of the SA Broadcasting Corporation received performance bonuses in the (i) 2013-14, (ii) 2014-15 and (iii) 2015-16 financial years; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what amount did each of the specified officers receive in each of the specified financial years?
Reply:
The information regarding the performance bonuses can be referred to the Annual Reports for the respective years.
Note that the SABC has not yet implemented the performance management review therefore would not be in a position to pay performance bonuses.
MR NN MUNZHELELE
DIRECTOR GENERAL [ACTING]
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATIONS
DATE:
MS AF MUTHAMBI (MP)
MINISTER OF COMMUNICATIONS
DATE
04 November 2016 - NW2292
Vos, Mr J to ask the Minister of Energy
Whether any (a) internal and/or (b) external forensic reports pertaining to (i) her department and/or (ii) each entity reporting to her were completed from 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what is the (aa) name, (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of each of the specified forensic reports?
Reply:
(a)(b)(i)(ii) Since 1 January 2009 to date the Department and all its entities with the exception of CEF reported no forensic investigation conducted for both internally and externally.
(ii) CEF, Yes
(aa) Name |
(bb) Subject Matter |
(cc) Date of Conclusion |
PetroSA |
i. Forensic Accounting Investigation into alleged irregular activities or misconduct by certain top ranking officials which include allegations about irregular tender practices at PetroSA. |
4 March 2010 |
ii. Forensics Investigation into possible irregularities and/or fraud within the Corporate Social Investment (“CSI”) department. |
18 October 2010 |
|
iii. Probity final report PetroSA. |
April 2013 |
|
iv. Review of a possible fruitless and wasteful and/or irregular expenditure |
October 2013 |
|
v. Scope extension: Review of a possible fruitless and wasteful and/or irregular expenditure. |
June 2013 |
|
vi. Investigation into allegations of irregularities regarding the acquisition by PetroSA of the shares of Sabre Oil and Gas. |
November 2013 |
|
vii. Forensic Investigation into the circumstances behind the decision to continue drilling the FO-12 pilot well in the Ikhwezi field development plan. |
September 2015 |
|
viii. Independent investigation into the performance of PetroSA for the financial year ended 31 March 2015; and more specifically PetroSA’s R14.5 billion impairment charge. |
November 2015 |
|
Petroleum Agency of South Africa (PASA) |
ix. Forensic Investigation into allegations arising from a whistle blower report |
11 November 2010 |
04 November 2016 - NW2252
Shinn, Ms MR to ask the Minister of Communications
Whether, with reference to her reply to question 126 on 27 February 2016, any plans have been put in place to issue a regulation to amend the Broadcasting Act, Act 4 of 1999, as amended, to waive the requirement for recipients of government set-top boxes to be in possession of valid television licences; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details of the specified plans?
Reply:
I would like to draw your attention, honourable Shinn, to my Budget Vote speech where I mentioned that “together with the SABC management we have since resolved to delink the TV license requirement from the STB subsidy registration process”. No mention was made of a decision to waive the law.
MR NN MUNZHELELE
DIRECTOR GENERAL [ACTING]
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATIONS
DATE:
MS AF MUTHAMBI (MP)
MINISTER OF COMMUNICATIONS
DATE:
04 November 2016 - NW2279
Van Damme, Ms PT to ask the Minister of Communications
Whether she has met with the (a) board of the SA Broadcasting Corporation (SABC) and/or (b) senior executives of the SABC to discuss the (i) redeployment of the former chief operating officer of the SABC, Mr H Motsoeneng, to the position of Group Executive of Corporate Affairs and (ii) current affairs of the SABC; if not, why not; if so, what was the (aa) date and (bb) contents of the specified meetings?
Reply:
No, the Minister has not met with the Board of the SABC to discuss the redeployment of Mr Motsoeneng.
MR NN MUNZHELELE
DIRECTOR GENERAL [ACTING]
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATIONS
DATE:
MS AF MUTHAMBI (MP)
MINISTER OF COMMUNICATIONS
DATE
04 November 2016 - NW2282
Van Dyk, Ms V to ask the Minister of Communications
(1)(a) On what date was Mr Hlaudi Motsoeneng reappointed as the Group Executive of Corporate Affairs of the SA Broadcasting Corporation, (b) who held the specified position before the reappointment of the specified person, (c) to which position was the former group executive of corporate affairs moved and (d) what are the full details of all processes followed to make both of the specified appointments; (2) Whether the position of group executive of corporate affairs was advertised prior to the person’s reappointment; if not, why not; if so, will she furnish Ms V van Dyk with a copy of all advertisements in this regard? NW2614E
Reply:
The questions relate to questions that are part of the terms of reference into the parliamentary hearing in terms of section 15A (b) and therefore dealing with the question now will be tantamount to anticipating the said inquiry which is led by Parliament.
MR NN MUNZHELELE
DIRECTOR GENERAL [ACTING]
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATIONS
DATE:
MS AF MUTHAMBI (MP)
MINISTER OF COMMUNICATIONS
DATE
04 November 2016 - NW2262
Rabotapi, Mr MW to ask the Minister of Communications
With reference to her reply to question 2002 on 6 October 2016, did her department pledge an amount of R3 million to support the Thank You SABC music concert held at the Orlando Stadium on 10 September 2016; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details?
Reply:
The Department of Communications did not pledge any amount to support the Thank You SABC music concert held at the Orlando Stadium on 10 September 2016.
MR NN MUNZHELELE
DIRECTOR GENERAL [ACTING]
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATIONS
DATE:
MS AF MUTHAMBI (MP)
MINISTER OF COMMUNICATIONS
DATE
04 November 2016 - NW2226
Kohler-Barnard, Ms D to ask the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services
(a) How many Special Investigating Unit investigations are currently being conducted into the Department of Public Works in each province, (b) what is the reason for each of the specified investigations and (c) by what date is each of the specified investigations expected to be finalised?
Reply:
- The Special Investigating Unit (SIU) is currently conducting investigations authorised under four (4) proclamations involving the Department of Public Works (DPW). Details of the investigations are provided in the table below:
PROCLAMATION |
PROVINCE |
REASONS FOR THE INVESTIGATIONS |
EXPECTED DATE TO BE FINALISED |
|
Western Cape |
The Investigation relates to the refurbishment of ministerial homes in and around Cape Town at allegedly vastly inflated costs. The Proclamation concerned confines the investigation to: (i) the procurement of goods and services; and (ii) unauthorized, irregular and/or fruitless and wasteful expenditure incurred in relation to the DPW projects listed in the two (2) Proclamations. |
31 March 2017 |
2. Proclamation No. R59 of 2014 dated 27 August 2014 |
National Department of Public Works |
1. Procurement and Administration of leases which is not fair, competitive, transparent, equitable or cost effective; 2. Irregularities, malpractices or mal-administration in the affairs of DPW; 3. Any related unauthorized, irregular or fruitless and wasteful expenditure; 4. Theft, fraud and/or corruption by private individuals/landlords; and 5. Procurement irregularities relating to service providers. Currently, 649 leases are under investigation out of a total of 2 176 leases. The provincial breakdown is as follows: (i) Eastern Cape – 142; (ii) Western Cape – 48; (iii) Mpumalanga – 105; (iv) Free State – 100; (v) Kwa-Zulu Natal – 54; (vi) Gauteng – 136; (vii) North-West – 37; and (viii) Mthatha – 27. |
March 2018 |
3.Proclamation No. R38 of 2010 |
Gauteng |
(i) Allegations of irregular Supply Chain Management award in terms of Section 217 of the Constitution as well as fruitless and wasteful expenditure; and (ii) A lease investigation where we are in negotiations with the current landlord and DPW on overpayments to the landlord both in Gauteng. |
Based on these matters (civil proceedings), SIU cannot anticipate the end date. |
4. Proclamation No. R27 of 2015 |
Kwa-Zulu Natal |
(i) Allegations of irregular appointment of service provider - 4 matters; (ii) Allegations of fruitless and wasteful expenditure - 1 matter; (iii) Allegations of fraud and corruption - 3 matters; and (iv) Allegations of conflict of interest - 420 matters. |
September 2017 |
Western Cape |
(i) Allegations of fraud and corruption - 2 matters; and (ii) Allegations of conflict of interest - 230 matters. |
||
Eastern Cape |
Allegations of conflict of interest - 344 matters |
||
Pretoria Office |
(i) Allegations of "cover quoting" - 7 matters; (ii) Allegations of irregularities in the Security Project - 1 matter; (iii) Allegations of irregular expenditures during the 2014/15 regularity audit - 1 matter; (iv) Allegations of fraud and corruption - 2 matters; and (v) Allegations of conflict of interest – 2 705 matters. |
||
Bloemfontein Office |
(i) Allegations of poor service and non-delivery by service providers - 23 matters; (ii) Fraud and corruption - 1 matter; (iii) Allegations of conflict of interest - 677 matters; and (iv) Assisting the Hawks on 6 matters. |
04 November 2016 - NW2250
Shinn, Ms MR to ask the Minister of Communications
Whether any criminal charges have been laid against any (a) employee and/or (b) former employee of the Universal Service Access Agency of South Africa for (i) supply chain management irregularities and/or (ii) any other irregularity in the procurement process of government subsidised set-top boxes; if not, why not; if so, what are the (aa) names of each person charged to date and (bb) charges in each case?
Reply:
The Department of Communications commissioned an investigation conducted by the National Treasury on the procurement process of Set Top Boxes (STBs) and other associated accessories. No criminal charges have been laid against any employee and/or former employee of the Universal Service Access Agency of South Africa as the report is being processed. The department is, however, working with the Department of Telecommunications and Postal Services (DTPS), as USAASA reports to Parliament via the DTPS, in considering actions to be taken based on the recommendations entailed in the report. .
MR NN MUNZHELELE
DIRECTOR GENERAL [ACTING]
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATIONS
DATE:
MS AF MUTHAMBI (MP)
MINISTER OF COMMUNICATIONS
DATE:
04 November 2016 - NW2288
Cassim, Mr Y to ask the Minister of Communications
Whether any (a) internal and/or (b) external forensic reports pertaining to (i) her department and/or (ii) each entity reporting to her were completed from 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what is the (aa) name, (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of each of the specified forensic reports?
Reply:
(i) Department of Communications (DoC)
(a) N/A
(b) External forensic audit initiated in the 2015/16 financial year.
(bb) The DoC commissioned an investigation through the National Treasury on the procurement processes of set top boxes.
(cc) The investigation has been concluded in March 2016.
Government Communications and Information System
(a) Internal audit investigation into subsistence and travel claims for one of its employees, June 2011.
(b) National Treasury (external to GCIS), forensic investigation into the appointment of a service providers for the census 2011 campaign, November 2012.
(ii) Entities
Brand South Africa (BSA)
(a) N/A
(b) External forensic audit in the 2014/15 financial year.
(aa) N/A
(bb) To investigate whether any fraudulent activities took place on the reported irregular expenditure of R10 738 735.
(cc) 11 November 2014.
Film and Publication Board (FPB)
(a) N/A
(b) N/A
(aa) N/A
(bb) N/A
(cc) N/A
Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (ICASA)
(a) N/A
(b) An external forensic investigator was appointed.
(aa) N/A
(bb) To investigate the bid administration functions and processes followed at ICASA in the 2011/12 and 2012/13 financial years.
(cc) The report was successfully concluded and adopted by Council of the Authority on 31 March 2015.
Media Development and Diversity Agency (MDDA)
(a) No
(b) Yes
(aa) N/A
(bb) Corruption and Maladministration
(cc) 2013
South African Broadcasting Corporation (SABC)
The SABC is unfortunately not at liberty to disclose such information as it either refers to personal information of the SABC employees and or commercial transactions of third parties.
MR NN MUNZHELELE
[A] DIRECTOR GENERAL
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATIONS
DATE:
MS AF MUTHAMBI (MP)
MINISTER OF COMMUNICATIONS
DATE
03 November 2016 - NW2377
Mulder, Dr CP to ask the Minister of Trade and Industry
Whether, given the sluggish South African economy and low projected growth, he will consider collecting evidence-based data around economic models that work and that do not work, from some special economic zones, in collaboration with the Minisiter of Labour, attempting to relax labour regulations and in that limited geographic space to determine whether it does not result in more job opportunities; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
Reply:
Since the introduction of the new Special Economic Zones Policy and the introduction of a new package of incentives for SEZ investments; the overall investment performance of South Africa’s special economic zones has improved significantly. For example, total secured investments in the 4 operational IDZs increased from R19, 7 billion at the beginning of the 2016 to R41, 2 billion at the end of October 2016. In addition, the total investment commitments from the not yet operational zones (including the newly designated) stands at over R70 billion. The dti is confident that this improved investment performance of South Africa’s special economic zones will soon translate into a stronger contribution to GDP, value-added exports and employment.
In implementing the SEZ Programme, the dti is aware that continuous learning and innovation have to be, and are; central to our efforts to improve the performance of all special economic zones. Therefore, there are lessons from both the domestic and international experiences in the planning, design, development, management and operations of special economic zones. When the time is right, department will review both the SEZ Policy and its instruments; taking into account all the lessons from both the domestic and international experiences.
However, the dti does not have any intention to introduce a different labour market policy in special economic zones. There are no indications that the current labour market policy has negative impact on the performance of our special economic zones.
03 November 2016 - NW2315
Kopane, Ms SP to ask the Minister of Tourism
Whether any (a) internal and/or (b) external forensic reports pertaining to (i) his department and/or (ii) each entity reporting to him were completed from 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what is the (aa) name, (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of each of the specified forensic reports?
Reply:
(i) Department of Tourism
(a) None
(b) External forensic reports as indicated below:
(aa) Investigated Project Name |
(bb)Subject Matter |
(cc) Date of Conclusion |
Tshakuma Heritage and Conference Centre |
Forensic and Financial Investigation |
19 July 2011; further bank account analysis report issued on 2 September 2013 |
Wild Coast Tourism Development |
Forensic and Financial Investigation |
25 July 2011 |
KZN King Matiwane |
Forensic and Financial Investigation |
19 July 2011 |
Free State and Northern Cape training |
Forensic and Financial Investigation |
7 July 2011 |
FS- Guest House Building in Qwaqwa |
Forensic and Financial Investigation |
28 November 2014 |
FS- Information and Business Centre Project |
Forensic and Financial Investigation |
28 November 2014 |
EC-Lake Gariep Development Project |
Forensic and Financial Investigation |
9 October 2014 |
EC-Lake Gariep and PK Le Roux dam |
Forensic and Financial Investigation |
9 October 2014 |
EC- Rock Art Tourism |
Forensic and Financial Investigation |
9 October 2014 |
EC- Motherwell Eco Tourism Development Project |
Forensic and Financial Investigation |
9 October 2014 |
LP-Mnisi Resort project |
Forensic and Financial Investigation |
9 October 2014 |
Vha Tsonga Cultural Village Project |
Forensic and Financial Investigation |
9 October 2014 |
(ii) South Africa Tourism
(a) None
(b) External forensic report as indicated below:
(aa) Name |
(bb) Subject Matter |
(cc)Date of Conclusion |
Fraud India Office Case |
Fraud case against Country Manager and Finance Manager in India Office |
25 May 2011 |
Local and International South African Tourism Warehouses Case |
Exhibition Stands and Warehouses |
24 May 2012 |
Fraud and Corruption Case |
Irregularities in awarding the Lead Agency Tender in 2010 |
14 January 2015 |
Fraud and Corruption Case |
Possible collusion between suppliers in Nigeria |
6 July 2016 |
02 November 2016 - NW2304
Mhlongo, Mr TW to ask the Minister in the Presidency
Whether any (a) internal and/or (b) external forensic reports pertaining to (i) his department and/or (ii) each entity reporting to him were completed from 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what is the (aa) name, (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of each of the specified forensic reports?
Reply:
The Department of Planning Monitoring and Evaluation did not have (a) internal or (b) external forensic investigations from the period 1 January 2009 to date. There were no cases that required forensic investigations and therefore there is no (aa) name (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of forensic reports.
SekelaXabiso Consulting (Pty) Ltd was appointed by National Treasury on 12 September 2013 to do Forensic Investigation into the tender process and subsequent appointment of the successful bidder pertaining to tender number 12/09 for Statistics South Africa (Stats SA). The response in regard to NYDA is as follows:
Forensic Report - Nature |
Internal / External |
(aa) Name of the Investigation |
(bb) Subject Matter |
(cc) Date of Conclusion of the Forensic Report |
During the 2011 financial year, an investigation was initiated by the Public Protector to probe whether the hosting of the World Festival of Youth and Students held in December 2010 had been within the NYDA’s mandate, whether the allocated funds had not been misappropriated and whether the relevant supply chain management prescripts had been followed. |
External |
World Festival of Youth and Students |
Hosting of the World Festival of Youth and Students event had been within the NYDA’s mandate, whether the allocated funds had not been misappropriated and whether the relevant supply chain management prescripts had been followed. |
To date, a final report had not been released by the Public Protector. |
Account Payable Manager Fraud |
Internal |
Account Payable Fraud |
Diverting funds to her accounts – fraud detection and funds recovery done. |
30 September 2016 Case closed |
Economic Development DJ project |
Internal |
DJ project |
Supply of young DJ’s with DJ equipment, working capital and related branding |
31 December 2013 Case closed |
Qualification review |
Internal |
Qualification Audit |
Review of qualification listed on employees CVs |
31 December 2015 Case closed |
Fraudulent activity in the Group Lending Programme at the East London Branch Office. The report named two specific group loans (Masiqandane and Khanya Group Loans). |
Internal |
Group Loan |
Fraudulent loan |
05 November 2013 Case closed |
02 November 2016 - NW2172
Maimane, Mr MA to ask the Minister in the Presidency
What was the total financial cost to the State for all litigation involving the non-security upgrades at the President, Mr Jacob G Zuma’s, private homestead in Nkandla in KwaZulu-Natal?
Reply:
The total financial cost to the State for all litigation involving the non-security upgrades at the President, Mr Jacob G Zuma’s, private homestead in Nkandla in KwaZulu-Natal is R3 915 625.03
01 November 2016 - NW2370
Steenhuisen, Mr JH to ask the Minister of Trade and Industry
(1)Whether the Cultural and Creative Industries Federation of South Africa (CCIFSA) submitted a copy of its constitution to him; if not, why not; if so, (a) on what date and (b) what are the further relevant details in this regard; (2) whether the CCIFSA submitted annual financial statements for the (a) 2014-15 and (b) 2015-16 financial years; if not, in each case, why not; if so, in each case, on what date(s) were the specified annual financial statements submitted to him; (3) whether his department provided any form of funding, assistance, sponsorships and/or assets to the CCIFSA since the establishment of the federation in 2014; if not, in each case, what is the position in this regard; if so, in each case, (a) what was the value of the funding, assistance, sponsorships and/or assets provided to the CCIFSA, (b) for what purposes and (c) has he found that the specified purposes were met? NW2705E
Reply:
According to the information received from National Lotteries Commission (NLC) and the dti: CCRD -
The Consumer and Corporate Regulation Division together with the NLC have never funded the Cultural and Creative Industries Federation of South Africa (CCIFSA), as a result
(1) Not applicable.
(2) Not applicable.
(3) Not applicable.
According to the information received from National Lotteries Commission (NLC) and the dti: CCRD -
The Consumer and Corporate Regulation Division together with the NLC have never funded the Cultural and Creative Industries Federation of South Africa (CCIFSA), as a result
(1) Not applicable.
(2) Not applicable.
(3) Not applicable.
01 November 2016 - NW2127
Alberts, Mr ADW to ask the Minister of Transport
Whether (a) she and/or (b) any provincial Member of the Executive Council has issued any authorisations in terms of section 81(1) of the National Road Traffic Act, Act 93 of 1996, since the commencement of the Act; if not, how is authorisation given for vehicles that do not comply with the Act to travel on roads legally; if so, what are the relevant details?
Reply:
(a) Since the commencement of the National Road Traffic Act, Act 93 of 1996; the powers to authorise abnormal vehicles were within the Provincial Member of the Executive Council. In 2010 the National Road Traffic Amendment Act, 2008 (Act No.64 of 2008) was proclaimed. This Amendment Act transferred the functions to issue authorisations for abnormal vehicles to be operated on the public roads from the Provincial Member of the Executive Council to the Minister of Transport.
In terms of Section 81(1), every vehicle that is not compliant with the provisions of the National Road Traffic Act in terms of vehicular dimensions and axle masses must be issued with a principle approval by the Minister of Transport before it is manufactured, purchased or imported. Approvals are granted on a letter from the Department of Transport detailing the vehicle identification number, dimensions and masses of the vehicle concerned.
01 November 2016 - NW2089
Lees, Mr RA to ask the Minister of Environmental Affairs
What amount did (a) her Department and (b) each entity reporting to her spent on advertising on the (i) Africa News Network 7 channel, (ii) SA Broadcasting Corporation (aa) television channels and (bb) radio stations, (iii) national commercial radio stations and (iv) community (aa) television and (bb) radio stations (aaa) in the 2015-16 financial year and (bbb) since 1 April 2016?
Reply:
Currently the department’s above-the-line advertising campaigns are placed through the Government Communication and Information System (GCIS), in compliance with the Cabinet Memorandum No. 1 of 2011 which was adopted on 8 June 2011.
GCIS uses an independent tool to assist in determining the best mediums to procure from for any specific media campaign request. The mediums chosen are based on the Telmar software tools which guide on the best option to propose to a department making the request. This tool is supported by Independent media research analysis based on South African Advertising Research Foundation, TAMS and RAMS complemented by Audit Bureau of circulation data.
From the time the GCIS brought the in-house media buying, it has reaped considerable savings and discounts for Government.
Although the question asks for advertising costs incurred from financial years 2015/16 and from April 2016 to date, advertising is a standard line item in each department’s / entity’s budget, which is approved by Parliament annually.
Government departments and its entities accounts for expenditure by tabling annual reports every year and this document, inclusive of this line item (i.e. advertising) are audited by the Auditor-General, who makes recommendations on any findings. Annual Reports are widely available to the public.
---ooOoo---
01 November 2016 - NW2316
Kopane, Ms SP to ask the Minister of Trade and Industry
Whether any (a) internal and/or (b) external forensic reports pertaining to (i) his department and/or (ii) each entity reporting to him were completed from 1 January 2009 up to the latest specified date for which information is available; if not, in each case, why not; if so, what is the (aa) name, (bb) subject matter and (cc) date of conclusion of each of the specified forensic reports?
Reply:
(a)(b) (aa) The Department of Trade and Industry received and completed two hundred and fifty five (255) investigations since 1 January 2009 to date. Of the 255 investigations, sixty one (61) related to the Entities of the dti.
Period |
the dti Cases |
Entity Cases |
Total Cases |
Jan-Dec 2009 |
37 |
17 |
54 |
Jan-Dec 2010 |
49 |
5 |
54 |
Jan-Dec 2011 |
26 |
10 |
36 |
Jan-Dec 2012 |
23 |
5 |
28 |
Jan-Dec 2013 |
20 |
9 |
29 |
Jan-Dec 2014 |
19 |
5 |
24 |
Jan-Dec 2015 |
13 |
7 |
20 |
Jan-Oct 2016 |
7 |
3 |
10 |
Total cases |
255 |
(bb) The subject of the forensic audits varied from conflict of interest, fraud, corruption and bribery, irregular and unauthorised expenditure, procurement irregularities, incentive scheme fraud, and alleged unethical behaviour.
(ccc) Two hundred and forty nine (249) cases relating to the period 01 January 2009 to date have been finalised. Six cases relating to the period 01 January 2016 to date are in progress. Certain investigations were outsourced to Grant Thornton, Nexus Forensics, Ubuntu Business Advisory Services (UBAC) and Gobodo Forensic and Investigative Accounting (GFIA). The majority of investigations were conducted by the in-house forensic audit unit within the Internal Audit Chief Directorate at the dti.
(ii)
(ii) ENTITY |
(aa) Name |
(bb) Subject matter |
(cc) Dates of conclusion |
(a) Internal |
(b) External |
NRCS |
|||||
1. Investigation into possible conflict of interest |
Investigation into possible conflict of interest |
March 2013 |
- |
External |
|
2. Investigation report into the taxed bill of costs |
Investigation report into the taxed bill of costs |
June 2014 |
Internal |
- |
|
3. Preliminary Investigation to determine compliance with the NRCS subsistence and travel policy |
Preliminary Investigation to determine compliance with the NRCS subsistence and travel policy |
June 2014 |
Internal |
- |
|
4. Preliminary investigation report into staff concerns |
Preliminary investigation report into staff concerns |
Feb 2016 |
Internal |
- |
|
5. Independent assessment on recruitment and selection process |
Independent assessment on recruitment and selection process |
Sept 2015 |
Internal |
- |
|
6. Investigation towards costs relating to services rendered |
Investigation towards costs relating to services rendered |
Aug 2014 |
Internal |
- |
|
7. Investigation into the matters relating to technical specialist |
investigation into the matters relating to technical specialist |
March 2015 In Progress |
- |
External |
|
8. Preliminary-investigation report into the matter of the approval of audit payment |
Preliminary-investigation report into the matter of the approval of audit payment |
Sept 2015 |
Internal |
- |
|
9. Preliminary Investigation of the allegations relating to the electrotechnical inspector |
Preliminary Investigation of the allegations relating to the electrotechnical inspector |
April 2015 |
Internal |
- |
|
10. Independent assessment on an appointment |
independent assessment on an appointment |
May 2016 |
Internal |
- |
|
11. Industry trading without LOA |
Industry trading without LOA |
Oct 2015 In progress |
- |
External |
|
12. Inspector disclosure of confidential information |
Inspector disclosure of confidential information |
Jan 2016 In progress |
- |
External |
|
13. Industry defrauding NRCS with regard to testing of weighbridges |
Industry defrauding NRCS with regard to testing of weighbridges |
Feb 2016 In progress |
- |
External |
|
14. Products not complying with NRCS Compulsory Specifications |
Products not complying with NRCS Compulsory Specifications |
March 2016 In progress |
- |
External |
|
15. Alleged corruption / unethical behavior by inspector |
Alleged corruption / unethical behavior by inspector |
Sept 2015 In progress |
- |
External |
|
16. Investigation of two members of staff |
Investigation of two members of staff |
Aug 2015 |
- |
External |
|
17. Grant Thornton Report- JDE Fraud Case |
Grant Thornton Report- JDE Fraud Case |
May 2012 Follow up being made with SAPS with regard to prosecution and arrest of suspect. Currently await SAPS |
- |
External |
|
18. Provision of forensic investigation services in relation to the allegations of irregularities and mismanagement at NRCS |
Provision of forensic investigation services in relation to the allegations of irregularities and mismanagement at NRCS |
March 2013 |
- |
External |
|
19. Investigation of possible irregularities with regard to procurement practices in the corporate services department of the NRCS |
Investigation of possible irregularities with regard to procurement practices in the corporate services department of the NRCS |
March 2010 |
- |
External |
|
20. Forensic Investigations into alleged irregularities in the tendering process at NRCS |
Forensic Investigations into alleged irregularities in the tendering process at NRCS |
February 2011 |
- |
External |
|
21. Forensic Investigation into allegations of irregularities |
Investigation into allegations of irregularities |
January 2011 |
- |
External |
|
22. Investigation into donor funding |
Investigation into donor funding |
November 2015 |
- |
External |
|
NMISA, ECIC, NCC, CT and NCT |
|||||
NIL |
- |
- |
- |
- |
|
NEF |
|||||
1. Investigation into possible fraudulent payments |
Staff member of a NEF funded entity made certain fraudulent payments into accounts |
May 2015 |
Internal |
- |
|
2. Facilities |
Staff member extorting payments/services from a service provider |
April 2014 |
Internal |
- |
|
3. Forensic investigation into various allegations made by an anonymous whistle-blower |
Allegations of improper conduct and irregularities relating to decisions made by the organisation and some of its employees |
November 2013 |
- |
External |
|
4. Allegations of misconduct by a staff member |
Review of allegations of improper/unlawful sms sent to a client. |
September 2011 |
- |
External |
|
5. Corruption & misconduct by two employees |
Irregularities concerning allegations relating to two staff members |
August 2011 |
- |
External |
|
6. Corruption & misconduct by an employee |
Allegations regarding certain unethical behaviour by an employee |
June 2011 |
- |
External |
|
NCR |
|||||
1. Allegations of misconduct levelled against a Senior Manager |
Breach of National Treasury Regulations, specifically with regards to supply chain management; Fraud; Misrepresentation; non-compliance with procurement policy; conflict of interest; gross negligence in the performance of duties |
November 2011 |
- |
External |
|
2. Allegations of misconduct |
Corruption, racism, nepotism, unethical conduct and inappropriate relations with a service provider |
February 2013 |
- |
External |
|
SANAS |
|||||
|
Fraudulent bank account details |
September 2014 |
- |
External |
|
NGB |
|||||
1. Unauthorised Amendments to a tender document |
Investigation into unauthorised changes effected to a tender document |
August 2014 |
Internal |
- |
|
2. Conflict of interest |
Unauthorised work conducted by an official within the NGB that was not disclosed and/or approved by the NGB |
September 2014 |
Internal |
- |
|
NLC |
|||||
1. Corporate Business Insight Awareness cc report |
Technical Surveillance Countermeasures Urgency and sensitivity - as recommended by SARS |
August 2012 |
- |
External |
|
2. Fraud unit reports |
Beneficiary related alleged fraud investigations. |
July, August |
Internal |
- |
|
3. Ens Forensics & Ra Russel Adviser report |
Forensic Investigation of the leak and Destruction of Confidential Documents |
August 2013 |
- |
External |
|
4. Nexus reports |
Beneficiary related forensic investigation. |
December 2013 |
- |
External |
|
5. Sizwe Ntsaluba Gobodo( SNG) reports |
Beneficiary related forensic investigation. |
November 2013 |
- |
External |
|
6. Kwinana reports |
Beneficiary related forensic investigation |
November 2013 |
- |
External |
|
7. Gobodo Forensic Investigative Accounting(GFIA) report |
Beneficiary related forensic investigation |
April 2013 |
- |
External |
|
8. KPMG reports |
Beneficiary related forensic investigation |
June 2013 |
- |
External |
|
9. Fraud unit reports |
Beneficiary related alleged fraud investigations. |
July, August 2013 |
Internal |
- |
|
10. Nexus reports |
Beneficiary related forensic investigation |
April 2014 |
- |
External |
|
11. Nexus report |
Forensic report on conflict of interest between beneficiary and junior staff member Conflict of interest between beneficiary and junior staff member Beneficiary related forensic investigation. |
September 2014 September 2014 August2014 |
- |
External |
|
12. Kwinana report |
Beneficiary related forensic investigation |
January ,February, April 2014 |
- |
External |
|
13. Sizwe Ntsaluba Gobodo( SNG) reports |
Beneficiary related forensic investigation |
April, March, May 2014 |
- |
External |
|
14. Gobodo Forensic Investigative Accounting(GFIA) report |
Forensic report on conflict of interest between beneficiary and junior staff member |
April 2014 |
- |
External |
|
15. KPMG reports |
Beneficiary related forensic investigation |
April, May, June 2014 |
- |
External |
|
16. Fraud unit reports |
Beneficiary related forensic investigation |
Jan to Dec 2014 |
Internal |
- |
|
17. Sizwe Ntsaluba report |
Beneficiary related forensic investigation |
July2015 |
- |
External |
|
18. Forensic unit reports |
Beneficiary related forensic investigation |
February-December 2015 |
Internal |
- |
|
19. Gobodo Forensic Investigative Accounting(GFIA) report |
Beneficiary related forensic investigation |
April 2015 |
- |
External |
|
20. Nexus reports |
Beneficiary related forensic investigation |
April 2015 |
- |
External |
|
21. Forensic unit report |
Beneficiary related forensic investigation |
January 2016 to date |
Internal |
- |
|
22. Sam Ledwaba attorneys report |
Forensic investigation on a key management staff member received from the Hotline |
June 2016 |
- |
External |
|
SABS |
|||||
1. Investigation on the alleged loss of documents at the SABS |
An investigation into the alleged loss of documents at the SABS premises. |
August 2016 |
- |
External |
|
2. Investigation on the alleged misconduct and non-adherence to the SABS policies |
An investigation into the alleged appointment of suppliers without following SABS policies and procedures regarding contract management |
July 2016 |
- |
External |
|
3. Investigation on the process followed pertaining to the renewal/re-issue of permits to one of the SABS client |
An investigation into the alleged lack of due diligence by SABS staff members when issuing SABS permit to the client. |
September 2015 |
- |
External |
|
4. Investigation on the allegations of bribery and manipulation of data results |
Investigation into allegation of bribery and manipulation of data results or test reports |
February 2015 |
- |
External |
|
5. Investigation into allegations of unethical conduct |
Investigation on the alleged unethical conduct by one of the SABS employees |
February 2015 |
- |
External |
|
6. Investigation into possible fraud in the procurement practices at the SABS |
Investigation into allegations of possible fraud regarding suppliers registrations process |
May 2013 |
- |
External |
|
7. Investigation on the allegations of conflict of interest at the SABS. |
Investigation conducted into the alleged conflict of interest and corporate governance |
July 2013 |
- |
External |
|
8. Investigation on the alleged manipulation of supplier bank accounts |
Investigation into fraudulent activities by SABS staff member. |
December 2011 |
- |
External |
|
CIPC |
|||||
Investigation launched by the dti |
Investigation into possible procurement irregularities |
Sub Judice |
- |
External |
01 November 2016 - NW2123
Singh, Mr N to ask the Minister of Environmental Affairs
With regard to the trial of the alleged rhino poaching kingpin (name and details furnished), why has the syndicate of the specified person never been acknowledged at any of her department’s quarterly rhino poaching briefings presented by her?
Reply:
During these media briefings, law enforcement matters are usually covered by my colleagues from the Security Cluster, particularly as it is the mandate of the South African Police Service to investigate and disrupt syndicates. Where law enforcement aspects are included in the briefings, this information is provided by the Security Cluster and there may be various reasons why sensitive information is not included.
---ooOoo---
01 November 2016 - NW2159
De Freitas, Mr MS to ask the Minister of Transport
What (a) were the gross annual salaries of each chief executive officer (CEO) of each entity reporting to her, (b) (i) benefits of any description and (ii) monetary value in each case that the specified CEOs enjoyed and (c) increases in (i) gross annual salary and (ii) benefits awarded in the past three financial years?
Reply:
PORTS REGULATOR OF SOUTH AFRICA (PRSA)
Chief Executive Officer |
Earnings |
2013/14 (000) |
2014/15 (000) |
2015/16 (000) |
Mahesh Fakir (appointed 01 May 2014) |
Basic salary |
- |
1568 |
1591 |
Taxable allowance |
- |
565 |
668 |
|
Performance bonus |
- |
- |
334 |
|
Total |
2133 |
2593 |
||
Marissa Damons (Acting CEO effective August 2013 to 30 April 2014) |
Basic salary |
524 |
691 |
- |
Taxable allowance |
204 |
250 |
- |
|
Performance bonus |
253 |
- |
||
Medical aid allowance* |
28 |
38 |
- |
|
Acting allowance |
255 |
33 |
- |
|
Total |
1 011 |
1265 |
- |
|
Riad Khan (CEO contract expired on 15 July 2013) |
Basic salary |
594 |
- |
- |
Leave pay |
362 |
- |
- |
|
Total |
956 |
- |
- |
(a) The table above details the gross remuneration that was paid to each CEO for the past three financial years. Note that Mr Khan and Ms Damons were only employed for part of the year in 2013/14 and 2014/15 respectively.
(b) (i) In terms of the conditions of service of the Ports Regulator, senior employees do not get any benefits except for the UIF, (ii) which is included in gross income and not paid over and above the amounts in the table.
(c) (i) The salary increases that were received by the CEO’s were in line with the PSCBC resolutions for sms employees. (ii) there were no increases in benefits awarded as there were no benefits awarded.
*The medical aid allowance for Marissa Damons was not a benefit but rather part of her gross remuneration based on how she structured her package.
RAILWAY SAFETY REGULATOR (RSR)
Year |
Basic Salary (R) |
Performance bonus (R) |
Allowances (R) |
Other: Pension & Medical Aid (R) |
Total (R) |
2013/14 |
1 688 133 |
- |
16 945 |
45 701 |
1 750 779 |
2014/15 |
2 126 729 |
112 800 |
36 675 |
66 409 |
2 342 613 |
2015/16 |
3 227 874 |
313 594 |
36 646 |
72 659 |
3 650 773 |
Total |
7 042 736 |
426 394 |
90 266 |
184 768 |
7 744 164 |
ROAD ACCIDENT FUND (RAF)
In the past three financial years, |
|
(b) (i) which included the following benefits enjoyed by the CEO, |
and (ii) with the following monetary value in each case, |
and was awarded the following increases in(c)(i) gross annual salary, |
and (c)(ii), benefits |
2013-2014 |
R4 170 044.00 |
|
R75 840.00 R0 R60 000 per financial year R1 849 414.51 |
Mid increase 8.76% Annual increase 6% |
Medical Aid: 9% |
2014-2015 |
R4 703 247.00 |
|
R82 818.00 R0 R60 000 per financial year R1 900 706.07 |
6.4% |
Medical Aid: 9% Performance Bonus: 2.77% |
2015-2016 |
R4 985 331.00 |
|
R90 831.00 R0 R60 000 per financial year R1 918 882.13 |
6% |
Medical Aid: 9% Performance Bonus: 0.95% |
AIRPORTS COMPANY SOUTH AFRICA (ACSA)
What:
(a) were the gross annual salaries of your chief executive officer (CEO) of each entity reporting to her,
Answer: The annual gross salary for Airports Company South Africa CEO is R3,929,502
(b) (i) benefits of any description; and
Answer: The CEO qualified for medical aid and pension fund benefits. These benefits are included in the above mentioned gross annual salary of R 3,929,520
(ii) monetary value in each case that the specified CEOs enjoyed and
Answer: There is no additional monetary value that the CEO received
(c) increases in
(i) gross annual salary and
2014: Answer: The CEO received a 5.4% (new salary R3,478,212) salary increase as approved by the Board of ACSA and the decision was implemented with effect from the 1st of September 2014.
2015: Answer: The CEO received a 6,58% (new salary R 3,707,078) salary increase as approved by the Board of ACSA and the decision was implemented with effect from the 1st of September 2015.
2016: Answer: The CEO received a 6% (new salary R3,929,502) salary increase as approved by the Board of ACSA and the decision was implemented with effect from the 1st of September 2016.
(ii) benefits awarded in the past three financial years?
2014: Answer: No additional benefits were awarded other than the above mentioned benefits, i.e medical aid and pension fund.
A variable performance bonus amounting to R1,570,573 was paid to the CEO in 2014.
2015: Answer: No additional benefits were awarded other than the above mentioned benefits, i.e medical aid and pension fund.
A variable performance bonus amounting to R1,826,061 was paid to the CEO in 2015. Further in lieu of closed Long Term Incentive Scheme (LTIS), the Board approved the deferred accumulated LTI amounting to R1,723,534 to be paid to the CEO in 2015.
2016: Answer: No additional benefits were awarded other than the above mentioned benefits, i.e medical aid and pension fund. No performance bonus was paid to the CEO in 2016.
AIR TRAFFIC AND NAVIGATION SERVICES (ATNS)
What:
(a) were the gross annual salaries of your chief executive officer (CEO) of each entity reporting to her,
- 2013/14 - R3,000,000-00
- 2014/15 - R3,201,000-00
- 2015/16 - R3,457,080-00
- 2016/17 - R3,699,076-00
(b) (i) Benefits of any description; and
- Pension Fund; Medical Aid; 25 working days annual leave; R2500-00 cellphone allowance and Business Class Travel
- Performance Bonus
(ii) Monetary value in each case that the specified CEOs enjoyed.
- 2015/16 Statutory Benefits R452,358.1
- Performance Bonus R841,695-00
(c) Increases in
(i) Gross annual salary; and
2014/15 - 6,7%
2015/16 - 8%
2016/17 - 7%
(ii) Benefits awarded in the past three financial years?
Pension Fund; Medical Aid; Performance Bonus; 25 working days annual leave; R2500-00 cellphone allowance and Business-Class Travel
ROAD TRAFFIC MANAGEMENT CORPORATION (RTMC)
Period |
Basic Salary |
Non Pensionable Allowance |
Package |
Increase Percentage |
Performance Bonus |
Total |
2016/2017 |
2700 000.00 |
1800 000.00 |
4 500 000.00 |
0% |
|
4 500 000.00 |
2015/2016 |
2700 000.00 |
1800 000.00 |
4 500 000.00 |
55% |
1 450 000.00 |
5 950 000.00 |
2014/2015 |
1 740 000.00 |
1 160 000.00 |
2 900 000.00 |
0% |
208 634.00 |
3 108 634.00 |
2013/2014 |
435 000.00 |
233 450.00 |
2 900 000.00 |
|
- |
668 450.00 |
Response |
(b) (ii) |
(b) (i), (b) (ii) |
(a) @(i) |
@ |
(b) (ii) |
|
Narrative :
2013/2014
Pro rata payment for the fourth quarter (Date of assumption of duties 1st of January 2014.)
2014/2015
Package was subject to performance and re-determination pending Negotiations.
2015/2016
Included the re-determination of the salary negotiations and performance as per employment contract.
2016/2017
Awaiting performance assessment and salary increment/negotiations.
SOUTH AFRICAN CIVIL AVIATION AUTHORITY (SACAA)
1. Gross Annual salaries
The Gross annual salaries paid to the Director of Civil Aviation A for the past 3 financial years were as follows
2013/14 Financial Year: R2,500,000.00
2014/15 Financial Year: R2,500,000.00
2015/16 Financial Year: R2,677,500.00
The above salaries includes basic salary, provident fund and medical aid.
2. Salary Increase
The DCA was appointed on 1 December 2013 and there was no increase paid for the financial year ending 2014/2015. The DCA received her first increase of 7% in 2015/2016 Financial year.
3. Performance Bonus
The performance bonus was paid as follows
2013/14 Financial Year : R290,969.00
2014/15 Financial Year : R585,109.60
2015/16 Financial Year : R840,779.99
SOUTH AFRICAN NATIONAL ROADS AGENCY SOC LIMITED (SANRAL)
SANRAL CEO: Mr Nazir Alli – Annual Remuneration
(a) and (b): SANRAL operates on a cost to company (CTC) basis. The gross amount paid includes the company’s contribution to medical aid and provident fund. The table below gives a breakdown as reported in the Annual Reports for the respective financial years:
REMUNERATION |
Gross Salary |
Performance Payments & long service awards |
Other contributions (Travel and medical allowances) |
Pension contributions |
Total R ‘000 |
FY 2013/14 |
2 016 |
1 067 |
121 |
405 |
3 609 |
FY 2014/15 |
2 214 |
1 270 |
103 |
445 |
4 032 |
FY 2015/16 |
2 502 |
1 280 |
46 |
185 |
4 013 |
(c) The CEO’s salary has not been adjusted for the financial years 2015/2016 and 2016/2017
ROAD TRAFFIC INFRINGEMENT AGENCY (RTIA)
(a)
- 2013/2014 Gross Annual salaries –R894 045
- 2014/2015 Gross Annual salaries –R939 248
- 2015/2016 Gross Annual salaries –R1 010 121
(b)
(i) Benefits –Non pensionable allowance, Car Allowance, Housing Allowance, Pension Fund, Medical Aid, Bonus.
(ii)
- 2013/2014 Total Benefits R742 923
- 2014/2015 Total Benefits R780 758
- 2015/2016 Total Benefits R2 370 076
(c) (i)
- 2013/2014 Increase in gross annual salary R26 994
- 2013/2014 Increase in gross annual salary R45 203
- 2013/2014 Increase in gross annual salary R70 873
(ii)
- 2013/2014 Total increase benefits R49 519
- 2014/2015 Total increase benefits R37 835
- 2015/2016 Total increase benefits R1 589 318
SOUTH AFRICAN MARITIME SAFETY AUTHORITY (SAMSA)
(a) The annual salaries of the SAMSA CEO were as follows:
2013/14 R2 858 000
2014/15 R3 040 912
2015/16 R3 199 544
(b) i.The benefits for the SAMSA CEO were as follows:
Benefits |
13th cheque |
Provident Fund |
Travel Allowance |
Bonus |
b.ii Monetary value in each case that the specified CEOs enjoyed
Benefit |
2013/14 |
2014/15 |
2015/16 |
13th cheque |
218 000 |
238 000 |
267 000 |
Provident Fund |
417 000 |
446 000 |
493 000 |
Travel Allowance |
0 |
0 |
22 000 |
Bonus |
1 089 000 |
0 |
0 |
NB: The bonus amount paid in the 2013/14 financial year was for two financial years (2011/12 and 2012/13)
(c) i.The following increases were awarded to the SAMSA CEO over the period:
Year |
Percentage Increase |
2014/15 |
6.4% |
2015/16 |
5.2% |
ii. Benefits awarded in the past three financial years
Benefit |
2013/14 |
2014/15 |
2015/16 |
13th cheque |
218 000 |
238 000 |
267 000 |
Provident Fund |
417 000 |
446 000 |
493 000 |
Travel Allowance |
0 |
0 |
22 000 |
Bonus |
1 089 000 |
0 |
0 |
NB: The bonus amount paid in the 2013/14 financial year was for two financial years (2011/12 and 2012/13)
CROSS-BORDER ROAD TRANSPORT AGENCY (C-BRTA)
For the Cross-Border Road Transport Agency, (a) the gross annual salaries for the Chief Executive Officer with (b) benefits, (ii) monetary values and (c) increases in (i) gross annual salary and benefits awarded in the past three financial years (2015/2016; 2014/2015 and 2013/2014) are depicted in the table below:
Year |
Increase Date |
(a) Gross Annual Salary |
(b) (i) Annual Cellphone Allowance |
(b) (ii) Performance Bonus |
(c) (i) Increase % |
(c)(ii) Reimbursive Expenditure |
(c)(ii) 5 Year Long Service Award |
Total |
2015 / 2016 |
01-Apr-16 |
2 366 117,16 |
65 316,00 |
155 681,33 |
5,90% |
86 382,46 |
2 542,45 |
2 676 039,40 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
2014 /2015 |
01-Apr-14 |
2 234 293,92 |
65 316,00 |
144 149,39 |
7,90% |
29 268,80 |
- |
2 473 028,11 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
2013 / 2014 |
01-Apr-13 |
2 070 708,04 |
65 316,00 |
- |
8,00% |
47 199,94 |
- |
2 183 223,98 |
PASSENGER RAIL AGENCY OF SOUTH AFRICA (PRASA)
(a) PRASA pays Total Guaranteed Pay Packages inclusive of all benefits:
Entity |
Name |
2013 |
2014 |
2015 |
2016 (Prorata) |
Comments |
PRASA Group |
TL Montana |
R5 343 063 |
R5 623 531 |
R5 903 999 |
0 |
The GCEO has been with PRASA for the past 10 years and thus enjoyed annual increases over the period. |
N Khena |
R2 753 902 |
Received an Acting allowance as the Acting Group CEO following the resignation of the GCEO |
||||
RAIL |
EM Mofi |
R3 159 000 |
R3 348 540 |
R3 542 755 |
R1 877 659 |
|
CRES |
PT Ngubane |
R116 883 |
R2 500 000 |
R2 650 000 |
R1 324 999 |
|
TECH |
S Zamxaka |
R2 527 200 |
R2 678 832 |
R2 839 561 |
0 |
|
D Kekana |
R2 640 942 |
Is the Acting CEO, but has not yet been paid the Acting Allowance |
||||
Intersite |
M Ngoye |
R2 448 600 |
||||
PA Gombert |
R1 855 927 |
R1 967 793 |
||||
NC Molepo |
R3 901 027 |
|||||
Autopax |
TR Kgaboesele |
R2 893 800 |
||||
N Khena |
R2 316 600 |
R2 455 596 |
||||
BB Kupe |
R2 337 200 |
(b)(i)(ii) Mr Nathi Khena was the Acting Group CEO from July 2015 – July 2016 and received an acting allowance of R277 920 for 2015 and R294 671 for 2016.
Ms Tara Ngubane was appointed the CEO of PRASA CRES and received a 28% increase on her salary. David Kekana is the Acting CEO of PRASA Tech, but is not yet receiving an allowance for his acting.
Mr Patrick Gombert was the Acting CEO from 2015 – 2016 and received an acting allowance of R222 711 for 2015 and R236 135 for 2016.
(c)(i)
Entity |
Name |
2013 |
2014 |
2015 |
2016 (Prorata) |
Comments |
PRASA Group |
TL Montana |
320,583.78 6% |
R280 468 5% |
R280 468 5% |
0 |
The GCEO had been with PRASA for the past 10 years and thus enjoyed annual increases over the period. |
N Khena |
R2 753 902 |
Received an Acting allowance as Acting Group CEO following the resignation of the CEO |
||||
RAIL |
EM Mofi |
R189 540 6% |
R183 222 5.8 % |
R200 912 6% |
R212 565 6% |
|
CRES |
PT Ngubane 6% |
R116 883 6% |
R551 950 5.8% |
R150 000 6% |
R159 000 6% |
|
TECH |
S Zamxaka |
R151 632 |
R 151 632 |
R160 577 |
0 |
|
Intersite |
M Ngoye |
R146 916 6% |
||||
NC Molepo |
R1 300 342 |
|||||
Autopax |
TR Kgaboesele |
R173 628 6% |
||||
BB Kupe |
R1 188 600 |
(ii) There were no additional benefits that the CEOs enjoyed except the annual increases that are specified above.
01 November 2016 - NW2198
Steenkamp, Ms J to ask the Minister of Environmental Affairs
(a) What are the latest numbers of (i) rhinos and (ii) elephants that were poached in each (aa) province and (bb) national game park from 1 April 2015 to 31 March 2016, (b) how many poachers were (i) caught and (ii) successfully prosecuted and (c) what punishments were enacted in each case?
Reply:
(a) (i) (aa) and (bb) It should be noted that statistics related to rhino are reported in line with calendar years rather than financial years in order to align with international reporting mechanisms.
From April 2015 to March 2016, 1 131 rhinos were poached, with 35 Elephants in each province, as reflected below:
MONTH & YEAR |
PROVINCE |
TOTAL |
|||||||||
GP |
LP |
KZN |
NW |
WC |
NC |
MP |
FS |
EC |
SANParks |
||
Total for 2015/16 Elephant |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
35 |
35 |
Total for 2015/16 Rhino |
2 |
87 |
118 |
50 |
1 |
2 |
59 |
13 |
17 |
782 |
1131 |
(b) From January 2015 to December 2015, a total of 432 arrests were made in relation to rhino poaching. From January 2016 to August 2016, a total of 414 arrests were made in relation to rhino poaching.
At this time we are working with the South African Police Service in relation to the SAPS CAS System and the related crime codes in order to enable more specific analysis of the cases and reporting over different periods for rhino and elephant poaching arrests and convictions as well as wildlife trafficking cases.
---ooOoo---
01 November 2016 - NW2118
Mbatha, Mr MS to ask the Minister of Higher Education and Training
(a) How is the role of the National Institute for the Humanities and Social Services different from that of the (i) Council for Higher Education, (ii) Academy of Science of South Africa, (iii) Universities South Africa, (iv) Human Sciences Research Council and (v) National Research Foundation and other institutions which advance research, teaching and learning and (b) what process was followed with regard to the allocation of funds to (i) catalytic projects, (ii) humanities hubs and (iii) BRICS collaborations?
Reply:
(a) The National Institute for the Humanities and Social Services (NIHSS) is a complementary institute to existing institutions but focuses specifically on advancing and strengthening Human and Social Science disciplines in South African universities. This includes assisting universities to realise their potential contribution to the ongoing project of post-colonial and post-apartheid nation-building, national development, the building of a democratic culture and the development of a strong tradition of progressive, empirical and theoretical research. The NIHSS seeks to build relationships with academics in South Africa, Africa and BRICS. Some of the areas of research of the NIHSS may coincide with the interests of other statutory institutions. Practically, the principle of complementarity requires ongoing sustained and regular consultation and cooperation with these institutions. Taking into consideration the mandates, roles and functions of stakeholders such as the Council on Higher Education, Academy of Science of South Africa, Universities South Africa (USAf), Human Sciences Research Council and National Research Foundation, it is the Department’s view that our higher education and research system needs diversity based on a differentiation of visions, focuses and priorities.
USAf is a body that has been established by university management representing South African Universities. Its mandate amongst others is to influence and contribute to policy positions regarding higher education. USAf itself does not conduct research but delegates this function to various stakeholders within the system.
(b) (i) For the 2015/16 financial year, the NIHSS issued a call for Catalytic Research Project proposals on 19 November 2015, with a submission deadline of 18 December 2015. The call was advertised in the Mail & Guardian and on the NIHSS website. Notification was sent to the South African Humanities Deans' Association (SAHUDA) to disseminate to participating institutions. Fifty-three research grant proposals were received from academics in South African higher education institutions. Proposals were internally screened for project and administrative compliance. Internal and external committees reviewed the research proposals against set criteria. The Academic Committee of the Board also reviewed all research proposals.
The outcomes of the review processes were as follows:
- 8 proposals were awarded full funding under the Catalytic Research Programme;
- 10 proposals that showed some potential for becoming catalytic were recommended for seed funding;
- 5 of the successful proposals were considered to be Working Groups and will be funded under the Working Groups for Academic Collaboration programme;
- 9 proposals showed some potential but required further discussions and approval; and
- 21 proposals were not approved for funding.
(ii) Liliesleaf Farm Pilot Humanities Hub was identified in 2014, as part of the Ministerial Special Project phase of the Institute. A closed call for proposals for new Humanities Hubs will be issued in the 2016/17 financial year to heritage sites in South Africa or similar sites. All proposals will be reviewed internally and externally by independent experts in the field.
(iii) All BRICS related collaborations with member countries are discussed at the BRICS Think Tank Council meetings. Research projects funded by the NIHSS in the various BRICS countries are done through an open call and in partnership with similar organisations in the respective BRICS countries.
For the 2015/16 financial year, the NIHSS and Indian Council of Social Science Research (ICSSR) issued a joint call for research proposals between South African and Indian researchers in Social Sciences and Humanities. The call for research proposals was advertised on the NIHSS website and sent to universities (Deans Association). The advertisement closed on 15 June 2015 and 16 applications were received in South Africa and 14 in India. The applications were screened for administrative, project compliance and prepared for review. The NIHSS-ICSSR Joint Advisory Committee (JAC) meeting was held on 3 November 2015 in Cape Town, South Africa. The NIHSS/ICSSR Joint Research Programme approved 13 projects of which 11 are fully funded projects and 2 will receive seed funding. Five ICSSR applications were approved for funding.
The NIHSS has also been working closely with the Human Sciences Research Council (HSRC) to establish the South African BRICS Think Tank.
COMPILER/CONTACT PERSONS: Ms P Whittle and Dr D Parker
EXT: 5248/6214
DIRECTOR – GENERAL
STATUS:
DATE:
QUESTION 2118 APPROVED/NOT APPROVED/AMENDED
Dr BE NZIMANDE, MP
MINISTER OF HIGHER EDUCATION AND TRAINING
STATUS:
DATE:
01 November 2016 - NW2176
Mazzone, Ms NW to ask the Minister of Public Enterprises
Whether she will provide Ms N W A Mazzone with Eskom’s detailed strategic plan of action to generate R15 billion in cash reserve revenue for each of the next 10 years to be utilised for Government’s nuclear build programme; if not, why not; if so, by when; (2) how will Eskom manage to generate the total R 150 billion cash reserve revenue in the next 10 years to fund Government’s nuclear build programme, given that Eskom’s current and non-current borrowings is R 322 billion?
Reply:
- ESKOM has not finalised its strategic plan for each of the next ten years. However, it is expected that its EBITDA margins will continue to improve, capital expenditure will decrease over the next ten years as the current built programme winds down, costs continue to be reduced and debt repayments become lower.
- The measures mentioned in (1) will result in an increase in available free cash.
01 November 2016 - NW2160
De Freitas, Mr MS to ask the Minister of Transport
What (a) is being done to improve road safety in preparation for the anticipated high volume of vehicles expected on the roads in all provinces during the upcoming 2016 festive season, (b) coordination is being done with other levels of Government in this regard and (c) targets have been set?
Reply:
a) The National Road Safety Steering Committee (NRSSC) as a Coordinating structure for Road Safety in the Republic and as mandated by the Minister of Transport has in collaboration with Provinces collected and analyzed Road Traffic information consisting of a 5 year historic information on traffic flows, fatalities and fatal crashes for purposes of 2016/2017 Festive Season Strategic Operational Planning with the following focus areas amongst others:
- Pedestrian management and enforcement;
- Drinking and driving;
- Speed enforcement;
- Vehicle roadworthy testing
- Public transport;
- Passenger safety;
- Fatigue management and
- Moving violations.
The Strategic Operational Plan will also focus on key high traffic volume routes like the N1, N3, N4 etc. Built up areas will be prioritized particularly during days and times that have been identified to be responsible for high fatality rate.
b) The Law Enforcement Technical Committee (LETCOM) as a subcommittee of NRSSC is in the process of coordinating the development and consolidation of both national, provincial and municipal road safety plans in order to produce one Integrated Festive Season Road Safety and Traffic Law Enforcement Plan for 2016.
c) The National Road Safety Steering Committee has adopted a 50% reduction of reported fatalities as compared to figure reported in the previous festive season period. This target is informed by the target set in the United Nations Decade of Action 2020 and the draft National Road Safety Strategy 2016-2030 target.
31 October 2016 - NW1778
Davis, Mr GR to ask the Minister of Basic Education
(1)With reference to her reply to oral question 117 on 26 August 2016, (a) when will she introduce Bills to amend the (i) SA Schools Act, Act 84 of 1996, as amended and (ii) Employment of Educators Act, Act 76 of 1998, as amended and (b) why has there been a delay in amending the specified legislations; (2) where can the draft Bill referred to in the specified reply be accessed?
Reply:
(1)(a)(i)(ii) Before the publication thereof for public comment, I deemed it necessary to present the Bill to some stakeholders, which included School Governing Body Associations and Education Sector Unions. Some of these stakeholders commented on the Bill during the presentations, and some subsequently provided the Department with written comments on the Bill. After all the options had been weighed up, it was decided that the comments submitted by these stakeholders should be considered and, where there was merit, incorporated into the draft Bill before the Bill is published for public comment.
The Bill must further be subjected to the Socio-Economic Impact Assessment System (SEIAS). This is a new requirement that was introduced by the Presidency this year for all new legislation and policy as well as amendments to existing legislation and policy.
(b) Some of the recommendations in the Ministerial Task team report that require legislative changes are still being considered and is subjected to a sector intensive internal review such as consultation with key stakeholders in the sector.
(2) The Bill is still an internal document.
31 October 2016 - NW2067
Horn, Mr W to ask the MINISTER OF PUBLIC WORKS
(1) Whether each Head of Department (HOD) of his department signed a performance agreement since their appointment; if not, (a) what is the total number of HODs who have not signed performance agreements, (b) what is the reason in each case, (c) what action has he taken to rectify the situation and (d) what consequences will the specified HOD face for failing to sign the performance agreements; if so, (i) when was the last performance assessment of each HOD conducted and (ii) what were the results in each case; (2) Whether any of the HODs who failed to sign a performance agreement received a performance bonus since their appointment; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, (a) at what rate and (b) what criteria were used to determine the specified rate; (3) Whether any of the HODs who signed a performance agreement received a performance bonus since their appointment; if so, (a) at what rate and (b) what criteria were used to determine the rate?
Reply:
The Minister of Public Works
(1) Yes
(a) None.
(b) Falls away.
(c) Falls away.
(d) (i) and (ii) Fall away.
(2) All HODs have signed performance agreements.
(a) Falls away.
(b) Falls away.
(3) No. All HODs have signed performance agreements, but no performance bonuses were paid due to the fact that the Department of Public Works is still undergoing a 7-year Turnaround programme that started in 2012.
(a) Falls away.
(b) Falls away.
______________________________________________________________________________
31 October 2016 - NW2203
Mbhele, Mr ZN to ask the Minister of Police
(a) What was the fixed establishment for the Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation in the (i) 2009-10, (ii) 2010-11, (iii) 2011-12, (iv) 2012-13, (v) 2013-14, (vi) 2014-15 and (vii) 2015-16 financial years and (b) which of the specified positions were vacant in each of the specified financial years?
Reply:
The information required is already solicited by other sections for consolidation which will be ready soon , can the member therefore afford us an opportunity to come up with an accurate product.
31 October 2016 - NW2048
Figlan, Mr AM to ask the Minister of Basic Education
(1)Whether each Head of Department (HOD) of her department signed a performance agreement since their appointment; if not, (a) what is the total number of HODs who have not signed performance agreements, (b) what is the reason in each case, (c) what action has she taken to rectify the situation and (d) what consequences will the specified HOD face for failing to sign the performance agreements; if so, (i) when was the last performance assessment of each HOD conducted and (ii) what were the results in each case; (2) whether any of the HODs who failed to sign a performance agreement received a performance bonus since their appointment; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, (a) at what rate and (b) what criteria were used to determine the specified rate; (3) whether any of the HODs who signed a performance agreement received a performance bonus since their appointment; if so, (a) at what rate and (b) what criteria were used to determine the rate?
Reply:
Whether each Head of Department (HOD) of her department signed a performance agreement since their appointment; if not, (a) what is the total number of HODs who have not signed performance agreements, (b) what is the reason in each case, (c) what action has she taken to rectify the situation and (d) what consequences will the specified HOD face for failing to sign the performance agreements; (e) if so, (i) when was the last performance assessment of each HOD conducted and (ii) what were the results in each case?
ANSWER
(a) The Director-General of Basic Education has signed and submitted a Performance agreement. The HOD of Gauteng Department of Education, the Mpumalanga Department of Education and the Acting HOD of the KZN Department of Education have signed performance agreements. Only three Provincial Education Departments have responded..
(b) Still awaiting the other Provincial Education Departments’ responses for the Minister to respond to this question.
(c) Still awaiting the other Provincial Education Departments’ responses for the Minister to respond to this question.
(d) Still awaiting the other Provincial Education Departments’ responses for the Minister to respond to this question.
(e) i. The Director-General of the Basic Education Department of Basic Education’s last assessment was conducted on 15 August 2016. The HOD of the Gauteng Department of Education’s last performance assessment was at the end of March 2016. The HOD of Mpumalanga Education Department has not been assessed for the 2015/16 financial year. No responses from the other Provincial Education Departments on this matter to date.
ii. The Director General of Basic Education Department was rated as excellent. The HOD of the Gauteng Department of Education’s performance was rated as excellent. The HOD of the Mpumalanga Education Department has not been assessed for the financial year 2015/16. No responses from the other Provincial Education Departments on this matter to date.
QUESTION 2
Whether any of the HODs who failed to sign a performance agreement received a performance bonus since their appointment; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, (a) at what rate and (b) what criteria were used to determine the specified rate?
ANSWER
(a) No responses from the other Provincial Education Departments on this matter to date.
(b) No responses from the other Provincial Education Departments on this matter to date.
QUESTION 3
Whether any of the HODs who signed a performance agreement received a performance bonus since their appointment; if so, (a) at what rate and (b) what criteria were used to determine the rate?
ANSWER
(a) The Director-General of the Department of Basic Education had not received a performance bonus as he will be considered in the next cycle only because of his appointment in August 2015. The HOD of the Gauteng Department of Education did not receive a performance bonus for 2015/16 cycle, as he had completed a year in this position. The Acting HOD of the KZN Education department has not been assessed for the 2015/16 financial year. No responses from other Education Departments on this matter to date.
(b) No responses from the other Provincial Education Departments on this matter to date.
31 October 2016 - NW2146
Hoosen, Mr MH to ask the Minister of Home Affairs
With reference to his reply to question 1007 on 25 April 2016, what are the full details of the exceptional circumstances under which he granted citizenship to certain persons (names and details furnished)?
Reply:
Section 5(9) of the South African Citizenship, 1995 (Act No. 88 of 1995) (‘the Citizenship Act”) stipulates that the Minister may under exceptional circumstances grant a certificate of naturalisation as a South African citizen to an applicant who does not comply with the requirements of subsection (1)(c) relating to the residence or ordinary residence in the Republic. Furthermore, subsequent to the refusal of an application for naturalisation, an applicant may approach the Minister and submit a motivation containing material information for consideration as to the existence of exceptional circumstances justifying the granting of citizenship by means of naturalisation.
Mr Gupta and family submitted their motivation which presented exceptional circumstances for the consideration of the applications. This included presenting the company Oakbay Investments (Pty) Ltd which has interests in various sectors such as media, information technology, real estate, mining and related activities. The supporting documents submitted included the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) company registration, as well as the formal registration and shareholding coupled with tax payments to and registration with the South African Revenue Services (SARS). The company also submitted supporting documents reflecting employment of approximately 7000 permanent employees.
The fact that Mr Gupta and family contribute to the economy of South Africa, provided substantive grounds for consideration of their application for naturalisation under exceptional circumstances as stipulated in section 5(9) of the Citizenship Act.
31 October 2016 - NW1933
Waters, Mr M to ask the Minister of Social Development
Whether her department provided any support to disadvantaged learners of a certain high school (name furnished) in Johannesburg in the (a) 2015 and (b) 2016 academic years; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what (i) was the nature of the support and (ii) are the relevant details in each of the specified academic years?
Reply:
(a), (b) No.
(i) and (ii) The reason therefore is that neither the Department nor SASSA has been made aware or approached for assistance. If the Honourable Member can furnish me with relevant details of the school and the leaners that need assistance.
The Department will liaise with the Provincial Department of Social Development to check if they have rendered any form of assistance to the school as provincial departments have their own Social Relief of Distress programmes.
31 October 2016 - NW1999
Kopane, Ms SP to ask the Minister of Public Works
(1) What is the current status of the case that is before the Labour Court involving an employee of the Construction Industry Development Board (CIDB) who was dismissed in February 2015; (2) what (a) is the current status of the CIDB’s three-year review of the Infrastructure Delivery Management Tool which it has failed to achieve to date and (b) steps are being taken to ensure that this does not recur in the future; (3) what are the full details of the CIDB’s plans to address the six top areas of concern as identified by its organisation culture study?
Reply:
The Minister of Public Works
(1) In May 2015, the Construction Industry Development Board (CIDB) filed a review application challenging the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA) decision.
- On 25 November 2015 the CIDB filed its heads of arguments followed by the lawyers of the employee in question a week later.
- The matter is ready for hearing and both parties are waiting for the Registrar of the Labour Court to allocate a hearing date.
(2)(a) The Infrastructure Delivery Management Toolkit (IDMT) has its origins in 2001 when the National Treasury commissioned a review of the poor performance of provincial infrastructure delivery systems resulting in the establishment of the Infrastructure Delivery Improvement Programme (IDIP) and the Toolkit. The National Treasury enlisted the support of the National Department of Public Works (NDPW), the Development Bank South Africa (DBSA) and the CIDB as partners to the IDIP. The CIDB was responsible for the management of the content of the Toolkit, the hosting of the Toolkit on the CIDB website, and providing support and training on its implementation and rollout, where necessary.
The idea underlying the imperative of having the IDMT was to address the need for a documented body of knowledge and set of processes that represent generally recognised best practices in the delivery of infrastructure. It was to be focused on the delivery and life cycle management of public sector infrastructure. The Toolkit was therefore designed as a valuable resource to provide a national common knowledge base and set of practices to assist in delivering these services in a manner that is effective, efficient and consistent across provinces and departments. The Infrastructure Delivery Management System (IDMS) and the Toolkit have evolved over the years since their inception in 2004.
(b) In the past the IDMS and the Toolkit were revised and enhanced every three to four years, but National Treasury identified a need to separate the supply chain for goods and services from the supply chain for infrastructure to unblock some of the infrastructure delivery management chain challenges. As a result, the revision and enhancements of the IDMS and Toolkit had to be delayed to allow for the development of the Standard for Infrastructure Procurement and Delivery Management (SIPDM). The SIPDM is a National Treasury regulatory instruction issued in terms of the Public Finance Management Act, 1999 [Act No. 1 of 1999] (PFMA), and it will assist in ensuring support for the implementation of the IDMS.
The current 2010 edition of the Toolkit enhancement and revision is being reviewed under the auspices of National Treasury. The enhancements and revisions will focus on the following:
- aligning the existing 2010 IDMS with the Standard for Infrastructure Procurement and Delivery Management (SIPDM);
- aligning the current linear depiction of the IDMS to the new IDMS Control Framework, which emphasises the linkages between core delivery processes;
- incorporate institutional capacity building approaches, methodologies and toolkits;
- simplify existing delivery management processes and deliverables;
- provide for the development and incorporation of Standard Operating Procedures from provinces;
- standardise the ‘Supporting Information’ requirements;
- capture and incorporate best practice methodologies and examples;
- develop an information technology platform to serve as the single source for infrastructure delivery related information (i.e. an Infrastructure Delivery Management Body of Knowledge (IDMBOK));
- incorporate local government infrastructure delivery requirements (where possible).
Once the enhanced IDMS and Toolkit are complete, they will be hosted on the CIDB website until such time that the prototype information technology platform is developed by National Treasury.
(3) The top six areas of the CIDB culture study are as follows:
- Remuneration
- Learning and Development
- Leadership
- Structure
- Service Orientation
- Innovation
The CIDB’s plans to address the above are as follows:
CIDB has embarked on an organisational development methodology (OD exercise) which is a step-by-step process for assessing and re-shaping the structure and positions within the CIDB to better meet its strategic and operational goals. The integrative OD project plan is made up of 12 phases aimed at addressing not only the six top areas of concern as identified by the organisation culture study, but also areas for development as identified in the organisational architecture pilot study, CIDB five year review, 2016 employee engagement survey, etc.
Dimensional areas such as structure, leadership, learning and development and remuneration form the pivotal points of the organisation-wide OD exercise. CIDB had to first align the ‘hard issues’, i.e. mandate, strategy, processes, systems, structure and harmonise them with ‘soft issues’, i.e. culture, values, leadership, management style, communications, creativity and innovation. All these dimensions are addressed in the detailed OD project plan. For example, there is an exercise to review the existing processes and to develop the recommended business processes, dysfunctional aspects of work flow, structures and systems, and realignment with the envisaged operational realities/goals are aspects which are being attended to. There are also plans to digitise core business processes. Once this is done, it will assist the CIDB flow of communication, productivity and innovation as well as alleviate fraud and corruption.
In addressing learning and development issues, CIDB is in a process to finalise a new competency framework in order to be able to design the most appropriate competency assessment tools matching the competency framework for each level of employees. Once the competency gaps have been identified, the most appropriate training strategy based on the assessment gaps and outcomes will be developed. The development of the career-pathing framework is part of the training strategy design. It will further improve employee satisfaction, client satisfaction and service excellence. Furthermore, the newly developed training and development policy is also used as a vehicle by employees to continuously improve their competencies and academic up skilling.
In addressing some of the structure related soft issues, plans are also ahead to allocate tasks, reporting relationships and levels to provide means of achieving full CIDB alignment between people aspects and functions, or technical aspects. This will be addressed in the implementation of the structure design criteria and the new CIDB operating model.
Other related areas being addressed are job profiles, job evaluation and remuneration.
The OD exercise is seen by CIDB as a systematic approach for fundamental rethinking and radical redesign of business processes, eliminating non-value adding activities to achieve improvements in performance and productivity, efficiency in operational costs and turnaround times, customer service, quality and alignment of processes with the strategy.
31 October 2016 - NW1785
Boshoff, Ms SH to ask the Minister of Basic Education
What steps has her department taken, in line with recommendation 4 of the Report of the Ministerial Task Team to Investigate Allegations into the Selling of Posts of Educators by Members of Teachers Unions and Departmental Officials in Provincial Education Departments, dated 18 May 2016, to regain control of administering the education system in all provinces so that clear distinctions are established between the roles and functions of her department and the concerns of teacher unions?
Reply:
The Department of Basic Education (DBE) has not lost over the administration of the education system. However, the Department has recommendations that require short-term interventions and those that could be achieved in the long term. The Department has resumed the following actions on the recommendations that need short term intervention:
1. Performance Management:
The introduction of performance contracts for principals and deputy principals, in line with the DBE policy, in order to enhance accountability of educators. The Quality Management System (QMS) for assessing the performance of school-based educators was adopted at the Education Labour Relations Council (ELRC) in November 2014. It will be implemented in January 2017 after further consultation.
2. Amendment to Legislation:
The starting point of the reforms should be the amendment to the South African Schools Act and the Employment of Educators Act, in so far as it relates to the powers of the School Governing Bodies in appointment procedures. A draft Bill has been developed to deal with these amendments.
3. Amendments to current appointment procedures:
Amendment to current appointment procedures contained in Collective Agreements and the role Teacher Unions are being negotiated at the ELRC.
4. Introduction of Competency Assessment for School Principals:
Consultation on the guidelines for Competency Assessment is being finalised at the ELRC.
31 October 2016 - NW2151
Mileham, Mr K to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs
Whether any tenders have been awarded by the Buffalo City Metropolitan Municipality for fleet maintenance since 1 July 2016; if so, (a) when was each such tender awarded, (b) what were the (i) names and (ii) amounts tendered by each successful bidder, (c) what criteria were used to award the specified tenders, (d) how many bidders were considered for each of the specified tenders and (e) on what basis was each successful bidder awarded the specified tenders?
Reply:
The response below was provided by the municipality:
Question |
Responses |
Whether any tenders have been awarded by the Buffalo City Metropolitan Municipality for fleet maintenance since 1 July 2016; |
No tender for fleet maintenance has been awarded by the municipality since 01 July 2016. |
(a) when was each tender awarded |
Not applicable |
(b) what were the (i) names and (ii) amounts tendered by each successful bidder |
Not applicable |
(c) what criteria were used to award the specified tenders, |
Not applicable |
(d) how many bidders were considered for each of the specified tenders |
Not applicable |
(e) On what basis was each successful bidder awarded the specified tenders? |
Not applicable |
31 October 2016 - NW1896
Davis, Mr GR to ask the Minister of Public Works
With reference to his reply to question 1675 on 12 September 2016, (a) what is the name of the specified Member of the Executive Council that makes use of the specified property as an official residence, (b) from which date has the specified property been used as an official residence for the specified person, (c) what is the market value of the specified property, (d) on what date was the specified property acquired by the Government and (e) what was the total price paid for the specified property by the Government?
Reply:
The Minister of Public Works:
(a) For security reasons I cannot provide the name of the Member of the Executive Council in this Parliamentary reply. I however can provide the name to the Honourable Member in confidence. Please get in touch with my office as indicated in the letterhead. Information relating to addresses of Members of the Executive is considered as confidential for purposes of making it easy for the South African Police Service to provide an unfettered protection service to the office bearers.
(b) The occupant started to use the specified residence in April 2010.
(c) The market value of the specified property is currently R8 000 000.00.
(d) The specified property was acquired by the Government on 24 December 2009.
(e) The total price paid for the property is R6 270 000.00.