MPUMALANGA PROVINCIAL GOVERNMENT

     Building No 6

     Extension 2          

     No 7 Government Boulevard

     Riverside Park

     Nelspruit

     Mpumalanga

     Republic of South Africa

 

 

 

Private Bag X11304

Nelspruit

1200

 

 

Department of Local Government and Housing

OFFICE OF THE HEAD OF DEPARTMENT

    Litiko

    LaHulumende

    We Ndzawo Netindlu

Department van

Plaaslike Regering

en Behuising

Umnyango

Wombuso we ze

Khaya neZindlu

 

 

STATUS QUO REPORT ON THABA CHWEU MUNICIPALITY AS AT 31 DECEMBER 2007

 

 

The Department visited Thaba Chweu Municipality to establish the readiness to perform their functions outside the section 139 intervention.

 

The following specific areas were investigated:

 

•           Availability of cash and investments to fund activities

•           Commitments towards statutory and contractual obligations and capital projects.

•           Status of creditors

•           External loans (DBSA)

•           Status of consumer and staff debtors

•           Credit control policy

•           Capacity of financial staff

·                     Internal Control

 

1.       Availability of cash and investments to fund activities

 

Council operated with not less than nine different bank accounts. These accounts were reduced to three accounts, primary bank account, MIG Grant account and an account for Traffic revenue.

 

Previously reported overdraft accounts were done away with and the Primary bank account balance reflects a positive of R16 mil. Due to the lack of an up to date bank reconciliation the amount regarding outstanding cheques could not been provided. The actual bank balance could not been establish.

 

All revenue is deposited in the primary account, which is an improvement from the previous situation where each business unit had its own revenue account.

 

All creditors are paid in time and internal control to prevent double payments was implemented. Council previously made payment of creditors when funds were available.

 

Investments to the amount of R758 673.00 could be verified, but the financial statements of 2006 indicated investments to the amount of R5mil.

 

The municipality approved the budget in time.

 

2.       Commitments towards statutory and contractual obligations.

 

All statutory obligations are honoured on an ongoing basis.  

 

3.       Status of creditors

 

All creditors are paid up to date.

 

4.       External loans (DBSA)

 

All payment towards external loans is honoured on time. The total outstanding loan in respect of INCA is R11 696 804.00 and the outstanding balance for DBSA is R6 636 658.37. The repayment is provided for in the current budget.

 

5.       Status of consumer and staff debtors

 

5.1        Consumer debtors

 

The Council did consolidate the two financial systems into one integrated system. Council is still experience problems with the new financial system. The financial system does reflect the roll-out of free basic services. The following billing and payments were recorded for 2 months:

 

Billed                                        Cash Received                           % Payment

R17 902 491,00                         R15 515 136.00                         86.66 %

 

All government institutions accounts are paid up to date except for Dept of Education who is in arrears to the amount of more than R1 mil. in consumer accounts.

 

According to Appendix A of the budget, Council has an accumulated provision for bad debt to the amount of R37 mil. The accumulating debtors is currently standing at R67 415 581.62.

 

5.2        Staff Advances

 

No new staff advances were approved since July 2004. The old staff loans to the amount of R125 456.44 were currently deducted from staff salaries. The deductions were verified and proof was obtained.

 

5.3               Councillors debtors (Cell phone)

 

The outstanding balances on Councillors cell phones were reduced from R332 834.28 to an amount of R44 631.04 as on July 2007.

 

Arrangements were made by certain Councillors to deduct the arrears on the cell phone accounts from their allowances.

 

5.4        Councillors debtors (consumer accounts)

 

With the information provided it appears that the councillors and management is up to date with regards to payment of consumer accounts.

 

6.       Credit control policy

 

       It was found that a uniform credit control policy was adopted. Revenue enhancement was outsourced and electricity is cut on a regular basis. The vacancies of meter readers and shortage of other revenue staff is currently supported and the functions performed by a service provider.

 

7.       Capacity of financial staff

 

All section 57 managers’ posts are filled and performance agreement signed.

 

The appointment of a qualified CFO is bearing fruits although training still needs to be provided on the financial system. More staff still needs to be appointed and trained in the financial department to ensure that all financial functions are performed by council.

 

The current outsourcing of revenue enhancement to a service provider contributed mainly to the improvement in the financial department. This is however not a good practice due to the fact that functions are performed by staff of the service provider and no skills are transferred. This is not only happening in the finance unit, but also in the electrical department as well as with the meter readers.

 

The bank reconciliations are up to date and the financial statements were submitted on time. The ledger account still needs to be reconciled and the investments need to be verified.

 

8.       Infrastructure and MIG fund

 

The municipality did appoint a qualified Town Engineer during May 2005. For the first time council could make an allocation out of own revenue to the amount of R32 mil for capital projects. Council did also spend 100% of the 2006/07 financial years MIG allocation and have already by August 2007 spend 66% of the 2007/08 financial years MIG allocation.

 

The water services Development Plan has been finalised approved and adopted by Council. The municipality does have a operating and maintenance programme for the electricity supply, which is addressing and solving previous problems.

 

9.       Recommendations

 

·         The general management of Thaba Chweu municipality did improve to such an extend that the department recommends the withdrawal of Section 139 intervention by the Provincial Executive.

That the Department of Local Government and Housing obtain the Provincial and Executive council approval to terminate the intervention and inform all relevant stakeholders of such an approval.












































 

 

 

 

THABA CHEU

 

P O Box 61

Lydenburg

1120



 

All correspondence to be directed to The Municipal Manager

 

 

 

Municipality

Head Office Lydenburg

 

Enquiries:        I M Moshoadiba                                                    30 July 2007                        

Ref No:                                                                                    

 

 

The Acting HOD – DLG&H

Mr C Dlamini

P O Box 11304

NELSPRUIT

1200

 

 

Attention: Bassie Strauss

                  Director – Municipal Finance

 

 

Sir

PROGRESS REPORT ON SECTION 139(1)(B) OF THE CONSTITUTION OF RSA

 

REPORT OF THE MUNICIPAL MANAGER ON THE VISIT BY SCOPA –

 08 FEBRUARY 2007

 

 

1.             Progress since the commencement of the intervention in 2005

 

Three of our Section 56 & 57 Managers (including the Municipal Manager) had the pleasure and opportunity of working with the Administrator’s team.  A road map was clearly set out and was followed in this manner.

 

Finalization of Section 56 & 57 Managers Posts

 

o  To date all five (5) Section 56 & 57 posts have been filled.

o  Municipal Manager, Mr Isaac Moshoadiba was appointed on 1 September 2006

o  CFO, Mr Paul Mpele was appointed 1 January 2007

o  Director Safety and Community Services, Ms Lindi Dube was appointed 1 January 2007

o  Director Corporate Services, Mr Noko Seanego was appointed 10 May 2005

o  Director Technical Services, Mr Nick van Rensburg was appointed 10- May 2005.

o  All Section 56 & 57 Managers have signed Fixed Term Employment Contracts and have signed three (3) Performance Contracts.  Chief Financial Officer and Director Safety and Community Services’ Performance Contracts will be finalized by 31 July 2007.

 

Financial State of the Municipality

 

o  A manually verified debtor’s book amounted to R48 million including the Pre – 1994 debt) as of September 2005.

o  A private service provider (Revenue Management and Debt Collection – Shining Star Management Consulting) was appointed in October 2005

o  To date an amount of R69 million marks council’s electronically verified debtor’s book.  This increase is due to:

 

(a)     accumulated interest charged at 18% per annum, compounded.

(b)     Increasing number of indigents

(c)     A high suspense account due to unidentified deposits.

 

o  The SEBATA Financial System is now able to give the accurate figure of the debtor’s book.

 

Finalization of Financial Statements

 

o  The Auditor General has audited Thaba Chweu Municipal for the years 2003, 2004 and 2005.  A final report is still awaited from the Auditor General.

o  Annual Financial Statements for the year ended 30 June 2006 have been compiled and sent to the Auditor General in January 2007.  An Audit Report is still awaited hereof.

o  There is certainty that the AFS – 2006/07 will meet the 31 August 2007 timeline.

 

Municipality’s Banking Accounts and Financial Systems

 

o  Thaba Chweu Municipality is currently operating on (1) one primary bank account and (2) two sub accounts as is consistent with MFMA for ring fenced amounts.

o  Thaba Chweu Municipality is also operating with SEBATA Financial System since February 2006.

o  The inconsistency/or changing the Chief Finance Officer’s and Acting Chief Financial Officer’s four (4) times in one year contributed adversely in the migration from the two financial systems (Finstel and Munsoft) to SEBATA.  This situation caused the municipality a crisis with rate payers.  A recovery plan was put into place and it is working satisfactorily.

o  However, there is a significant improvement in the Sebata Financial System regarding “data accuracy”.  There is still room for improvement.

o  Thaba Chweu Municipality already has approved and implemented Cash Management and Investment Policy.

o  Proper reports regarding Bank Accounts have already been sent to relevant authorities, i.e. Provincial and National Treasury.

 

Instituting and finalizing disciplinary proceedings

 

o  All pending disciplinary cases have been finalized and resolved.

o  Thaba Chweu Municipality is in the process of establishing an Employee Assistance Program (EAP) to deal with Social Problems of Employees.  This will be fully functional in the month of August 2007.

 

Finalization of Policies and Systems

 

o  The old By-laws and Policies are currently undergoing reviewal one by one.

o  Since February 2007 the following policies were reviewed and By-Laws passed  by Council:

(i)       Delegation of Authority

(ii)       Fleet Management Policy

(iii)     Transfer and Promotion Policy

(iv)      Occupational Health and Safety

(v)       Land Alienation and Integration of Communities Policy (Policy and Procedures)

(vi)      Developer Bulk Service Contributions Policy.

(vii)    Property Rates By-Law (passed)

(viii)   Street Trading By-Law  (passed)

(ix)     Outdoor Advertisement By-law (passed)

(x)      Electricity By-Law (passed)

(xi)     Storm Water Management By-Law (passed)

 Functioning of Portfolio Committee’s

 

o  The four (4) Portfolio Committee’s established by Council Resolution in April 2006 are fully functional.

o  These Committees hold monthly meetings and recommend to the Mayoral Committee. The Mayoral Committee is fully functional and holds its meetings on monthly basis and when the need arises.

o  The Mayoral Committee which consists of full time councilors has added a lot of value in the day to day running of the municipality.

o  Full Council holds its quarterly meetings exactly as required by law.  Items are no longer deferred without substantive reasons.

 

Land invasions

 

o  The land audit was conducted and it proved that ample land in Thaba Chweu Municipality is in private hands as well as registered in the name of Public Works Department.  (Province).

o  Illegal Land invasion/informal settlement are curbed on a daily basis through the services of squatter control officers in Mashishing Unit.  A transitional area was earmarked and developed with municipal services for 150 individual households that were occupying land illegally. This plan worked as it assisted the municipality to control illegal land invasion.

o  The same plan will be used for Sabie and Graskop areas as of 1 July 2007 (Budget Purposes).

o  Quarterly Report will be sent to SCOPA in this regard.

o  The Department of Local Government and Housing has funded Thaba Chweu Municipality to the tune of R25 million to service 525 stands in Mashishing and Sabie.

o  The Department Local Government & Housing is also in the process of funding Thaba Chweu Municipality for further township establishment in Mashishing.  This support has assisted Thaba Chweu Municipality remarkably

 

Relationship of Thaba Chweu Municipality  with SALGA

 

·         It is good.

 

Relationship between the Mayor and the Speaker

 

·         Was at its best until the time of the Speaker’s untimely death in April 2007.

·         The new Speaker of Council will assume office during the month of August 2007.

 

Relationship between Thaba Chweu Municipality  and the District Municipality

 

·            Currently at its best. 

·            The first Municipal Managers Forum Meeting of Ehlanzeni District was held in Thaba Chweu on 25 January 2007.

·            Thaba Chweu Municipality receives the necessary support from EDM, e.g. the recent purchase of one Refuse Compactor Truck to the tune of R760 000 by EDM for Thaba Chweu Municipality.

 

Budget of the Municipality

 

o  The 2006/7 budget was compiled successfully and the same happened

   for 2007/2008 budget.

o  For the first time Thaba Chweu Municipality operated its MIG budget directly in 2006/2007 Financial Year.  Our reporting indicates that 100% of our R8.8 million was spent before the end of March 2007 as planned.  A major break-through!

o  Thaba Chweu Municipality has for the past 12 months operated at NO Bank overdraft.

o  The Municipal Systems Improvement Grant 2006/2007 (MSIG –

   R734 000) has been used for the Municipal Valuation Roll

o  The Finance Management Grant (FMG – R500 000) has been used for the SEBATA Financial System.

o  Monthly Reports are sent to both Provincial and National Treasury on these grants.

 

 

Political Environment

 

·            Nothing critical can be reported at this stage.  Only individual councilors’ interference problems are still experienced and administration is handling them on an ongoing basis.  This is however not so serious.

 

Repayment of cellular phone accounts and advances to council

 

·           See attached schedule herewith, marked as Annexure A.

·           It is remarkable that the outstanding debt of R167 009.99 as of February 2007 has been reduced to R44 631.04 to date.  Only two (2) Councillors are still owing.

·           The cell phone allowances are now being paid in line with the existing prescribed practices and laws,.

 

Technical component of the municipality

 

·            A Qualified Town Engineer was appointed in May 2005.

·            A Water Services Development Plan has been finalized, approved and adopted by council in July 2006.

·            Lydenburg still experiences minor power outages due to over stretching of electricity caused by a busy housing development.  Thaba Chweu Municipality’s operating and, maintenance program solves these on an ongoing basis.

·           The current billing system does reflect the roll-out of free basic services and consumers are no longer complaining about this.

It is remarkable that the outstanding debt of R167 009.99 as of February 2007 has been reduced to R44 631.04 to date.  Only two (2) Councillors are still owing.

·           The cell phone allowances are now being paid in line with the existing prescribed practices and laws.

 

Payment Rates

 

·           Mashishing Unit payment rate has improved from 80% to 90%.

·           Sabie Unit has increased from 60% to 80%.

·           Graskop Unit has increased from 40% to 70%.

·           Thaba Chweu Municipality was collecting a total amount of R5.5 million per month from its average billing of between R6 million and R8 million up to August 2006 when an escalation to R8 million per month was realized, as a result of the engagement of a private service provider (Shining Star).  Negative media reports alleging that only 8.8% of the rate payers are paying for services is unfounded.

·            Currently an average amount of R8.2 million is consistently received every month from the total billing since September 2006 to date.

 

MEETING WITH WARD COMMITTEES

 

v      Eleven (11) of the twelve (12) Ward Committees have been established and are fully functional.  The one ward is a rural ward which has transient residents (Zimbabwean, Mozambican, etc. nationals) who live in compounds and do not seem to have any interest in human settlement issues.

v      The municipal budget is supportive of Ward Committees and Community Development Worker’s functionality, i.e. 2% of the operating budget is allocated for the functionality of Ward Committees.

v      The 14 Community Development Worker’s are all functional and are fully supported by municipal administration and politicians.  They report monthly to the province as required.

v      Management team was invited to a meeting of the Mashishing Rate Payers Association to give administrative clarity on issues.  This meeting was constructive and fruitful (NB. March 2007).

 

MEETING WITH AFFECTED STAKEHOLDERS

 

v      The Local Labour Forum has been established and it runs as scheduled.  Labour issues of critical importance are tackled as laid down by the Bargaining Council.

v      The Employment Equity Plan has been jointly compiled, ratified by Council and sent to the Department of Labour as regulated.

v      There is labour stability in the institution.

 

VIEWS ON THE INTERVENTION

 

v      It has certainly added value in the administration of Thaba Chweu Municipality, and such is quantifiable from an admin perspective.

 

RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE MUNICIPAL MANAGER

 

Ψ       That a credible internal audit be conducted throughout the municipality to finally clear up all administrative intricacies and political environment to enable operations from a clean slate.

Ψ       That further financial support be offered to fully stabilize the finance department of Thaba Chweu Municipality.

Ψ       That Thaba Chweu Municipality is now ready to administer its affairs outside Section 139(1)(b) of the RSA Constitution.

 

6.                  LED OPPORTUNITIES AND DEVELOPMENT PLANS FOR THABA CHWEU MUNICIPALITY AS EMANATING FROM THE IDP

 

ACTIVITY

TIME FRAME

ANTICIPATED IMPACT

1. The IDP Process Itself

  • 2006 – 2011
  • Common Master Plan informed by all Stakeholders from the Communities.
  • Ownership of Development Priorities by all progressive forces in Thaba Chweu Municipality.
  •  

 

2. The Establishment of the Thaba Chweu Economic Development Agency.

 

Council Resolution still awaited in this regard.

June 2008 and to be Reviewed Annually. Ongoing Development Process Guided by the Dynamics of the Times.

  • Direct concentration on LED instead of ad hoc basis operations.
  • Increased Specialized Capacity and Efficiency of LED.
  • Quick decision making as opposed to bureaucratic order of events.

 

3. Development of the LED Strategy and Tourism Plan

August 2007. Province has offered Grant Funding of the Strategy to the tune of R500 000 and the DBSA & Ehlanzeni District Municipality have also Granted Funding of the Tourism Strategy to the tune of R300 000.

  • Researched and Properly Investigated Inputs & Outputs (Information)
  • Organized and Informed Development of the Local Economy.
  • Common Vision and Expectation of Similar results.

4. Development of the Spatial Development Plan (Framework) and Land Use Management System

July 2007. The DBSA has issued a Grant Funding of the Lydenburg SDP/SDF to the Tune of R400 000, as a result of the Sustainable Communities Project currently underway for the Mashishing Area only. Some more applications have been made to cover Sabie & Graskop areas of Thaba Chweu Municipality. This is a start.

  • All Development is centered on and occurs on land.
  • Thus LUMS and SDP/SDF will guide the direction of Towns’ Development.
  • Land Audit will be easily quantifiable.
  • The sale of land will follow a systematic process as opposed to haphazard alienation. 

5. Global Forest Products (SABIE) has unlocked over 30 hectares of Barren Land for Housing and Business Development on PPP basis in October2006. Their gesture is clearly defined and specific this time around.

Acceptance of the offer by Global Forest Products in October2006.The Roll-Out of the Implementation Plan as envisaged in the PPP to commence in January2007 and Ongoing depending of the availability of funds for Township Establishment and to Put Services in the  earmarked Land 

  • To respond to the long time need for Housing and Business Land in the Sabie Area.
  • To respond to the demands of growth in the Sabie Area.

6. Servicing of 400 stands in Mashishing Area and 125 stands in the Sabie Area for the Middle Income Group of the population of Thaba Chweu Municipality.

Process of services to be completed by June2008.

The DLG&H –MP has pledged a support grant amount of R5 775 000 for the current financial year subject to Thaba Chweu Municipality’s compliance to the conditions that: *Social Integration is achieved,

* Middle income group is targeted* and Township establishment has been done on the earmarked land.  

  • To respond to the challenges of land alienation facing Thaba Chweu Municipality.
  • To deliver on the mandate of Human Settlement as is the Core-Function of the Municipality.
  • To cater for the middle income group as this seemed to be neglected for some time.
  • To respond to the continual requests of the mining houses in the Thaba Chweu Municipality area.

 

7. Proposals have been called for the development of the Shopping Mall in the Mashishing Area.

Completion of the Mall anticipated by December 2009.

  • To harness the business and commercial activities into the central Mashishing area of Thaba Chweu Municipality.
  • To provide an alternative for the buying power that comes from all neighboring areas such as Burgersfort, Belfast, Machadodorp, Steelpoort, Northern Rural Villages, etc.

8. Proposals have been called for the development of the Hotel or Lodge in the Gustav Klingbiel Game Reserve of Thaba Chweu Municipality following a research that was conducted in 2002/3, by EDM.

Completion and commencement to operate anticipated by December2009.

  • To provide a stop station alternative for Tourists who have always used Mashishing area as a “passer-by route” to other areas.
  • To provide a standard / conventional accommodation in the Mashishing area.

9. Council Resolution still awaited for the PPP arrangements with the Business entities of the Thaba Chweu Municipality such as Graskop & Sabie Caravan Parks.

Completion of process anticipated by July 2009.

  • To maximize the potential of these cost centers and salvage council the risk of running all such cost centers at a great.

10. Proposals have already been called for the Re-development of the Taxi Rank in Lydenburg Town. A PPP arrangement is envisaged.

Completion and commencement to operate anticipated by December2008

ό       To ensure that proper transport service is delivered.

ό       To develop the image of the town.

ό       To enhance Business activity.

ό       To encourage the idea of PPP. This has enough potential and is not yet fully explored in Thaba Chweu Municipality.

 

 

 

 

 

Faithfully,

 

 

 

 

 

……………………………………..                                                 27 JULY 2007

ISAAC MOSHOADIBA

MUNICIPAL MANGER

 

 

 

Ratified by

 

 

 

 

……………………………………

CLR. CLARA NDLOVU

EXECUTIVE MAYOR

 

 

 


COUNCILORS CELL PHONE DEDUCTIONS AS FROM

JULY 2006 – JULY 2007

 

 

 

VOTE               NAME                           BALANCE                     DEBIT               CREDITS          BALANCE

 

001                   M E MASHEGO     0.00                            0.00                    0.00                  0.00

002                   B D DUBE                         0.00                            0.00                    0.00                  0.00

003                   M MABELANE       0.00                            0.00                    0.00                  0.00

004                   J MASILELA                     0.00                            0.00                    0.00                  0.00

005                   B MOHLALA                 20 214.29                      20 214.29            -7 800.00         12 414.29

006                   C KHUMALO                    0.00                             0.00                    0.00                  0.00

007                   C MOKONE                     5 277.09                        5 277.09            -5 277.09             0.00

008                   L MANZINI                      7 034.49                        7 034.49             7 034.00             0.00

009                   E N MASHEGO 52 818.07                      52 818.07          -20 601.32         32 216.75

010                   B DU PLESSIS    0.00                               0.00                   0.00                0.00       

                                                            85 343.94                      85 343.94          26 643.92         44 631.04