REPORT TO THE PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE OF HEALTH BUDGET HEARINGS FOR 2001/02

 

 

 

DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH: PROVINCE OF WESTERN CAPE

 

 

 

5 APRIL 2001

 

 

 

INDEX

Executive summary 2

Mission 2

Strategic objectives 3

Budget and expenditure review 5

Tables of MTEF 6-12

Explanations of 2001/01 budget by subprogram 13-18

Budget and expenditure for 2000/01 19-23

Revenue 24-27

Strategic service areas 28

Primary Health Care 29

District hospitals 30

Regional hospitals 31

Psychiatric hospitals 32

Academic hospitals 33

Nursing colleges 34

Emergency medical and rescue services 35

Personnel issues 39

Key health problems 40

HIV 41-44

Rape 45

TB 46-49

Cataracts 50

Termination of pregnancy 51-52

Legislation 53

 

 

 

 

 

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

In 2001/02 the Western Cape’s share of the equitable share decreases from 9.6% to 9.4%. The Departments budget increases by 4.2% which is less than the CPI of 7%. The department has downsized 9349 posts (28.1%) since May 1995 and this stringent action results in the department coming within budget for the 2000/01 year.

Features of the departmental budget include:

 

1. MISSION OF THE DEPARTMENT

The mission of the department is to promote and maintain the optimal health of all people in the Western Cape Province through the integration of health within the broad context of social reconstruction and development, and by ensuring the provision of a balanced health system and all related services.

 

3. STRATEGIC OBJECTIVES

Key strategic objectives for the MTEF period are:

  • To improve the quality of health care services
  • To improve control of the HIV and tuberculosis epidemic
  • To stabilise the department following a lengthy period of downsizing
  • To improve the health status of the population (e.g. reduce infant mortality rate, maternal mortality rate
  • To utilise and strengthen selected business approaches including optimising of revenue generation and retention; efficiency; marketing and public relations; decentralisation with accountability; and public private partnerships
  • To strengthen the primary health care approach and to make effective basic health care services accessible to all
  • To manage patients at the appropriate, most cost-effective level of care (e.g. to progressively shift from the tertiary towards the secondary and primary level)
  • To progressively rationalise hospital services, ensuring adequate admission rates (80-150 per 1000 per year), while progressively reducing beds per population and length of stay while increasing bed occupancy rates and day cases
  • To shape the service in accordance with budgetary allocations to ensure that it will be sustainable
  • To improve equity across regions and districts
  • To ensure effective interventions for priority areas such as tuberculosis, nutrition, maternal and child health, reproductive health, mental health, environmental and occupational health
  • To ensure community participation and accountability of health services to the provincial government and population
  • To progress towards a district health system and decentralise delivery of Primary Health Care services to local government

 

 

 

Particular priorities identified for 2001/02 include:

a) Decentralization

b) Quality of care

c) HIV/AIDS/TB

d) Optimise regional hospital level

e) appropriate staff mix

f) performance reporting

g) Revenue

h) Emergencies and trauma

 

 

 

4. BUDGET AND EXPENDITURE REVIEW

4.1. Budget and expenditure

Trends in the budget of the Western Cape Department of Health are shown in table 1.

Table 1. Budget trends

Year

98/99

99/00

00/01

01/02

02/03

03/04

Total Budget

3,019,998

3,072,888

3,391,224

3,535,037

3,692,050

3,898,385

Budget to budget Difference

52,890

318,336

143,813

157,013

206,335

Difference %

1.8%

10.4%

4.2%

4.4%

5.6%

 

Detail of the budget from 99/00 (actual expenditure), 2000/01 (adjustments estimate budget, estimated actual) through the MTEF and standard items by program are shown over the following 7 pages.

Explanations for changes in the 2001/02 budget compared to 2000/01 follow on the subsequent 6 pages. Some key objectives are also shown against the subprograms.

The department will come in budget in the 2000/01 year. This is an important achievement given previous deficits and the declining equitable share. Details of 2000/01 budget and projected expenditure by program and standard item showing reasons for deviations follow for a further 6 pages.

A longer and more detailed document showing explanations of standard item variations by subprogram is available on request (email: [email protected] or [email protected]).

 

4.2. Revenue

Details of revenue are shown in appendix 3 and are summarised below. The figures shown for 2001/02 merely reflect the revenue targets given to the Department by Treasury.

Revenue budget summary

R000

98/99 actual

99/00 actual

00/01 budget

00/01 projected

2001/02

Hospital fees

68 093

61 679

64 594

69 266

67 955

Total revenue

96 729

84 263

82 609

94 644

87 132

The department has embarked on a range of initiatives to generate additional revenue above these targets. These include:

a) 50% revenue retention operalisationed. Memo drafted to Provincial Executive Committee to authorise 100% retention but currently not resolved with Provincial Treasury.

b) Business manager appointed.

c) Revenue above target by R12mil for first time this year.

d) Revenue retention implemented internally for the first time in 2000/01 - has had major effect on turning around perceptions and culture around revenue.

e) Private wards and beds - interest shown by quite a number of hospitals - examples at Tygerberg (29 beds), GSH, Karl Bremer (77), False Bay (16), Clanwilliam, Vredendal (21) hospitals.

f) Trading account concept successfully piloted at Karl Bremer Hospital. Revenue retention at 100% through administrative route is preferable for widespread implementation.

g) UPFS (uniform patient fee system) implemented successfully in Northern Cape. We will be piloting soon.

h) Our new billing systems are being developed as part of HIS.

i) Significant initiatives with medical schemes.

j) Developing contract for Preferred Provider agreements with medical schemes. Required to set up a number of good pilots where private funders can be convinced their patients will get quality care, not wait in endless queues etc.

k) Developing new post of case managers to facilitate interaction with medical schemes and manage issues such as authorisation, length of stay etc.

l) Medical schemes have expressed willingness to fund IT aspects in pilot hospitals.

m) Debt collection has been partially out-sourced.

 

STRATEGIC SERVICE AREAS

These areas are covered in summative sheets comparing 2000/01 attainment of objectives and 2001/02 plans. The areas covered in the sheets are per page:

 

6. PERSONNEL

a) Background

The Department has downsized over the last five years and lost approximately 9349 staff since 1995, which is approximately 28.1% of the workforce in the Department. This was done mainly through the Voluntary Service Process (VSP) and of necessity exacerbated human resource distortions into the services. The situation has stabilised considerably and only 67 posts have been shed in the course of 2000/01 till 1 February 2001.

Reductions in personnel

Date

Filled posts

Decrease since

Decrease since

Decrease

May-95

May 95 (%)

per year

1-May-95

33295

0

0

1-Apr-96

32557

738

2.2%

738

1-Apr-97

29564

3731

11.2%

2993

1-Apr-98

26988

6307

18.9%

2576

1-Apr-99

24661

8634

25.9%

2327

1-Apr-00

24013

9282

27.9%

648

1-Feb-01

23946

9349

28.1%

67

 

b) Current status :

The Department currently has 24011 staff in total (1/2/01). 22,9% of the posts are vacant. The reasons for the vacancies vary from financial stringency to inability to recruit certain categories of personnel e.g. pharmacists, psychiatric nurses.

Community service posts are shown below:

Compulsory community service posts

Year

Doctors

Interns

Doctors

CCS

Pharmacists

Dentists

1999

192

120

-

-

2000

160

132

-

-

2001

156

135

51

10

 

 

 

 

c) Norms

The Department has developed a normative approach to providing staffing guidelines for our institutions especially the hospitals. The norms are revised on an ongoing basis.

The model we use analyses all categories of staff in different proportions to each other within a health team to obtain the best skills mix for the different levels of the service. The norms are based on workloads.

The strategy of the department is to strive to correct these distortions in staff mix over the medium to long term within affordability limits.

d) Shortages of Staff

The main shortage is in the nursing categories. We have a shortage of 1495 nurses against norm (Professional nurses: 784; staff nurses: 434; nursing assistants: 277) and a shortage of pharmacists (24). The tertiary hospitals and the metropolitan region bear the brunt of the shortages. These are global figures for the province. There are categories where excesses and deficiencies occur across institutions and the appropriate redeployment of staff needs to be considered. The shortages described above can only be addressed through deployment or through decreases of personnel in other categories where numbers exceed the norms utilised.

e) Training :

The main emphasis for 2000/01 has been generic training with a focus on Batho Pele and Computer training.

A Workplace Skills Plan for the department is being completed currently. Skills Development Facilitators are being trained per region to assist with the process.

The Department has increased the intake of nurses at the Nursing College to 300 in 2001 and 400 in 2002 from 245 in 2000 to partially address the shortages described above. Post-basic courses (47 students) and bridging courses (11 students) will be expanded.

A focus area will be the accredited training of pharmacy assistants to dispense medicines. This will be a major boost in relieving pharmacists as well as reducing the waiting times of patients for medicines. We aim to train 200 pharmacy assistants. A funding request for R528 000 is being evaluated.

0.5% of personnel expenditure will be spent on training.

Some example of numbers of persons trained are given in the following 2 tables.

Primary Health Care Nurses trained

Year

Total trained

1998

147

1999

85

2000

85

2001

85 (target)

 

Training courses given

Field of Training

Total Attendance

Information Technology

3330

Personal Development

1255

Management / Supervision

1172

Service Improvement

376

Finance

237

Orientation

155

Health Functional

105

Maternal, Child & Women's Health

34

Chronic Care, Care of the Elderly & Rehabilitation

33

TOTAL

6697

 

 

 

 

f) Key Challenges :

  1. Correcting the staff mix and the appropriate deployment of staff at the right levels of care.
  2. Improving the morale of staff :

  1. Addressing the skills gap that will be identified by the Skills Plan eg. doctors at CHCs and District Hospitals to have capacity to deliver a wider package of care at these levels as opposed to referring patients to higher levels.

4. Reduce Personnel expenditure to bring a greater balance and allow for more funding to drugs, consumables and equipment.

Key Problem Areas for Government as a whole :

  1. The public service needs to consider flexibility in creating attractive packages to recruit and retain certain categories of professional staff e.g. pharmacists.
  2. The possible exemption from the BCOE act for government departments needs to be resolved by the Departments of Labor /DPSA and the unions. Departments cannot financially afford to comply.
  3. Introduction of performance agreements through all levels of the service and appropriate incentives for achievement.
  4. Wage Creep on an annual basis which makes it difficult to reduce personnel expenditure. Our personnel expenditure will go up from 62,9% in 2000/01 to 63,7% in 2001/02.

The table below shows large escalations in average cost per post over several years.

Trends in average cost per post

Average filled Posts

Personnel expenditure

Average cost per post (R)

Change since 95/96

Real cost per post

% change in real cost

1995/96

32,860

1,480,448

45,053

62,018

1996/97

31,161

1,840,705

59,071

31.1%

75,711

22.1%

1997/98

28,241

1,975,630

69,956

55.3%

82,588

33.2%

1998/99

25,676

2,003,255

78,021

73.2%

86,195

39.0%

1999/00

23,682

1,953,673

82,497

83.1%

86,622

39.7%

 

7. KEY HEALTH PROBLEMS

These are covered in the following sheets pertaining to:

8. OTHER

Progress on drafting provincial legislation and implementing recent national legislation is attached.


Appendix:
Program 1: Administration

Subprogram

Budget 00/01

R000

Budget 2001/02

R000

Diff.

R000

Comment

1.Total

Administration

124,915

166,360

41,445

1.1. Minister

1,501

2,132

631

Ministers salary shifted from Vote 2

1.2. Provincial

Management

76,786

117,275

40,489

  • Contingency fund R43.9 mil 2001/02 to address funding dip in 02/03.
  • ICS R1.9m
  • Transformation posts R2.9 mil
  • PSNP R3.7 m temporary location
  • Exceptional payments in 00/01 R10.1 mil
  • AIDS transfers to NGOs –temp location
  • Medico-legal claims provision

1.3. Regional

Management

46,628

46,953

325

Program 2: District services

Subprogram

Budget 00/01

R000

Budget 2001/02

R000

Diff.

R000

Comment

District Total

1,032,893

1,034,721

1,828

2.1. District Management

21,606

22,263

657

2.2.Primary Health Care

588,149

618,074

29,925

  • R15.5 debt paid in 00/01
  • Increase is 5.1% (R29.2 mil) when exceptional items removed
  • Dedicated HIV/AIDS funding doubles and will double again in 02/03
  • HIV MTCT expand to 6 sites (R2mil)
  • PHC has increased from R346 mil in 1995/96
  • Funding per capita R254 exceeds national core package of R183 by 38%.

2.3. Emergency Medical Services

151,697

126,769

-24,928

  • R35.7 mil debt paid in 2000/01.
  • 9.3% (R10.7mil) increase when this is included.

2.4. District Hospitals

271,441

267,615

-3,826

  • TC Newman Hospital (R16.2 mil) shifted to 2.2.
  • Increase with adjustment is 4.6% (12.2 mil).

Program 3: Provincial Hospital Services

Subprogram

Budget 00/01

R000

Budget 2001/02

R000

Diff.

R000

Comment

3.

Provincial hospitals total

804,314

853,025

48,711

3.1.

Regional Hospitals

500,785

533,394

32,609

  • ICS R19.7mil.
  • Karl Bremer AIDS care centre (R1.3mil)
  • Karl Bremer additional ward (R3.5mil)
  • Specialist OPD at GF Jooste commissioned (R3m increase)
  • Increase 6.5%

3.2.

Specialised Hospitals

303,528

319,630

16,102

  • ICS R12.2mil.
  • Re-open 136 beds at Brewelskloof (R1.1mil increase)
  • Increase is 5.3%

 

Program 4. Academic health services

Subprogram

Budget 00/01

R000

Budget 2001/02

R000

Diff.

R000

Comment

4. Academic health services total

1,316,924

1,360,481

43,557

4.1. Academic Medical

1,277,581

1,320,197

42,616

  • Exceptional items in 2000/01 -R30.9 mil. deferments from 99/00 (R14.6mil), exceptional bonus payments (R9 mil), finance management grant (R1.2 mil) stabilisation account (R6.2 mil)
  • Adjusting for these increase is 5.8% (R74.5 mil).
  • Inventories budget at Groote Schuur to be investigated

4.2 Academic dental

39,343

40,284

941

Increase is 8.7% from projected expenditure of R37.1 mil

 

Program 5. Health Sciences

Subprogram

Budget 00/01

R000

Budget 2001/02

R000

Diff.

R000

Comment

5. Health Sciences total

51,389

56,942

5,553

5.1.

Nursing colleges

50,977

56,530

5,553

  • Additional nurses (R3.8 mil)
  • Additional post-basic and bridging program nurses (0.8 mil),
  • ICS (2.9 mil)

 

 

Program 6. Support services

Subprogram

Budget 00/01

R000

Budget 2001/02

R000

Diff.

R000

Comment

6. Support services Total

60,789

63,508

2,719

6.1.Clinical support services

10,643

11,815

1,172

Additional posts at O+P centre

6.2. Non clinical support services

50,145

51,692

1,547