Question NW3681 to the Minister of Health

Share this page:

14 December 2017 - NW3681

Profile picture: Kopane, Ms SP

Kopane, Ms SP to ask the Minister of Health

(a) What number of health professionals were reported to the Health Professions Council of South Africa (i) in each of the past three financial years and (ii) since 1 April 2017, (b) what are the details of each health professional’s designation, (c) what breach was the health professional reported for in each case, (d) what was the outcome of each completed case, (e) what number of health professionals were suspended and (f) what number of memberships were terminated?

Reply:

The response is as follows, according to the Health Professions Council of South Africa (HPCSA):

(a) (i) The number of health professionals reported to the Health Professions Council of South Africa (HPCSA) in each of the past three financial years is as follows:

  • 2014/2015: 1 756
  • 2015/2016: 1 795
  • 2016/2017: 1 163

(ii) The number of health professional reported to the HPCSA for the period 01 April 2017 – to date is 94.

b) Details of each health professional’s designation: 4133 = Medical practitioners and Dentists

(c) breach of health professional reported in each case

(d) the outcome of each completed case

02 = abortion

02 = no evidence of unprofessional conduct

405 = incorrect accounts

11 = withdrawn

 

114 = due to time constraints the outcome in respect of the 114 matters could not be established.

 

237= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

31=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

02 =Deferred for consultation

 

10 = Cancelled

05 =Advertising

01 Withdrawn

 

04 = due to time constraints the outcome in respect of the 04 matters.

14 = Assault

01 cancelled

 

01 no evidence

 

04=ombudsman mediation

 

07 = due to time constraints the outcome in respect of the 07 matters could not be established.

 

01 =Withdrawn

166 - Bad communication

11=withdrawn

 

41= due to time constraints the outcome in respect of the 41matters could not be established.

 

94= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

15 =no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

05= Cancelled

03 = Breach of contract

01= due to time constraints the outcomein respect of the 01 matter could not be established.

 

02= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

142=Certificates

08=withdrawn

 

89= due to time constraints the outcome in respect of the 89matters could not be established.

 

16= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

19=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

01=Referred for inquiry

 

09= Cancelled

1129=competence

52=withdrawn

 

629= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

82= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

305=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

07=guilty

 

06 =duplicate

 

01=Deferred for consultation

 

47= Cancelled

12=Consulting rooms

01=withdrawn

 

01 =no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

09= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

01= Cancelled

55 =Practising without registration

03=withdrawn

 

32= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

02= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

13=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

01= guilty

 

04= Cancelled

16=Contraventions of the medicine and substance related Act 101 of 1965

03=withdrawn

 

07= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

02= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

03=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

01= Cancelled

03=Covering

01= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

02=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

02=Criminal convictions

01=withdrawn

 

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

23=Racial Discrimination

01=withdrawn

 

10= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

07= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

03=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

02= Cancelled

07=Exploitation

03= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

01= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

03=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

36=Exposing patient to danger

02=withdrawn

 

22 = due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

02 = Mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

06 = No evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

04 cancelled

440=Fees

24=withdrawn

 

121= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

234= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

42=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

01=duplicated

 

01=Deferred for consultation

 

17= Cancelled

99=Fraud

11=withdrawn

 

57= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

11= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

01=referred for inquiry

 

15 =no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

04= Cancelled

26=Withholding information

01=Withdrawn

 

09= Due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

10= Mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

04=No evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

01=Duplicated

 

01= Cancelled

519=Insufficient care/treatment

28=withdrawn

 

260= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

74= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

137=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

01=guilty

 

19= Cancelled

04=Itinerary practice

02= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

02= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

01=Kickbacks

01=withdrawn

03=Lost samples

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

01= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

01 =no evidence of unprofessional conduct

49=Operation without consent

03=withdrawn

 

23= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

10= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

10=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

03=Duplicated

48=Over service

04=withdrawn

 

12= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

27= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

04=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

01= Cancelled

17=Unethical prescription

06=withdrawn

 

09= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

01= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

01= Cancelled

181=Refuse assistant

05=withdrawn

 

81= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

60= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

01=referred for inquiry

 

25=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

09= Cancelled

364=Reports

18=withdrawn

 

98= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

183= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

46 =no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

03= duplicated

 

01= found guilty

 

15= Cancelled

41=Reputation of colleague

19= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

04= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

18=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

17= Contravening the specialist rules

02=withdrawn

 

12= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

01=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

02= Cancelled

49=secrecy

03=withdrawn

 

23= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

07= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

13=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

03= Cancelled

21=Section 51

17= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

01= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

01= Duplicated =Deferred for consultation

 

02= Cancelled

05=practising outside scope of practice

04= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

01=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

08= Supersession

05= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

01= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

01=guilty

 

01= Cancelled

03=Trade medicine

01=withdrawn

 

02= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

37=Unacceptable relationship

04=withdrawn

 

19= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

04= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

05 =no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

01=guilty

 

01=referred for inquiry

 

03= Cancelled

92=Unprofessional conduct

02=withdrawn

 

48= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

13= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

21=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

01=guilty

 

07= Cancelled

19=Unregistered

01=withdrawn

 

13= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

05= Cancelled

67=Unsatisfactory dentures

02=withdrawn

 

61= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

01= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

03=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

b) Details of each health professional’s designation: 25=Dental therapists and oral hygiene

(c) breach of health professional reported in each case

(d) the outcome of each completed case

02 =Advertising

02 = due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in terms of the matter.

   

01 = Assault

01 = due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

01 - Bad communication

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

01=Certificates

01= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

05=incompetence

05= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

01=Exposing patient to danger

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

03=Fees

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

 

02= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

05=Fraud

05= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

01=Insufficient care/treatment

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

01=Refuse assistant

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

01=practicing outside scope of practice

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

01= Failure to refer to Specialist

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

02=unsatisfied dentures

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

 

01= Cancelled

b) Details of each health professional’s designation: 15=Dietetics

(c) breach of health professional reported in each case

(d) the outcome of each completed case

01= bad communication

01= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

01 =breach of contract

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

01= incompetence

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

01=Expose patient to danger

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

05 fees

02= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

03=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

01= fraud

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

01=Insufficient treatment

01= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

01 =Over-service

01= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

01 = reports

01= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

01=Section 51

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

01=unprofessional conduct

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

b) Details of each health professional’s designation: 72=Emergency Care

(c) breach of health professional reported in each case

(d) the outcome of each completed case

02=Accounts

01=ombudsman mediation

 

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

01 =Advertising

01 = due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

02 = Assault

02 = due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

01=Certificates

01 = due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

11=incompetence

11 = due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

04=Contraventions of the medicine and substance related Act 101 of 1965

04 = due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

01=Control medicine

01 = due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

03=Discrimination

03 = due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

05=Exposing patient to danger

05= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

01=Fees

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

02=Fraud

02 = due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

02=Withholding information

02= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

14=Insufficient care/treatment

12= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

 

02 = cancelled

03=Refuse assistant

03= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

01=Reports

01 = due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

04=Reputation of colleague

04= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

10=Contravening the specialist rules

10= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

03=Specialist

03 = due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

01=Unacceptable relationship

01 = due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

01=Unprofessional conduct

01 = due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

b) Details of each health professional’s designation: 01=Environmental health

(c) breach of health professional reported in each case

(d) the outcome of each completed case

01=Unregistered practitioner

01=due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

b) Details of each health professional’s designation: 02 =Medical Technology

(c) breach of health professional reported in each case

(d) the outcome of each completed case

01=insufficient care treatment

01 = due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

01=Exploitation

01 = due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

b) Details of each health professional’s designation: 59=Medical orthotics and prosthetics and Occupational therapists

(c) breach of health professional reported in each case

(d) the outcome of each completed case

14=incorrect accounts

05= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

 

08= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

01= Withdrawn

01=Advertising

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

03=Bad communication

03= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

10=Incompetence

09= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

 

01= Cancelled

01=Consulting rooms

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

01=Practicing without registration

01 =withdrawn

14=fees

01=withdrawn

 

06= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

 

07= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

05=Fraud

01=withdrawn

 

03= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

 

01= Cancelled

05=Insufficient care treatment

05= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

04=Reports

01= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

01=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

02= Cancelled

01=Unprofessional conduct

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

(b) Details of each health professional’s designation:84=Optometrist and Dispensing Opticians

(c) breach of health professional reported in each case

(d) the outcome of each completed case

06=incorrect accounts

04= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

 

02= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

01=Advertising

01 = due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

01=assault

01= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

02=Bad communication

02= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

01=Breach of contract

01 = withdrawn.

24=Incompetence

13 = due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

 

11= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

04=Practicing without registration

01=ombudsman

 

03= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

01 = Contravention of medicine and substance related Act 101 of 1965

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

01=Exploitation

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

02=Expose patient to danger

02= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

14=fees

09= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

 

04=referred to Ombudsman

 

01=withdrawn

02=Fraud

02= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

07=Insufficient care treatment

06= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

 

01= cancelled

01=Operation without consent

01=referred to Ombudsman

02=Over servicing

01= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

01=Unethical prescription

01 due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

03=Refuse assistant

01 due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

 

02= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

02=Reports

02= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

03=Practicing out of scope

03= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

01=Unacceptable relationship

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

04=Unprofessional conduct

04= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matters.

01=Employing an unregistered person

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established in respect of the matter.

(b) Details of each professional’s designation: 77=Physiotherapy, Podiatry and Biokinetics

(c) breach of health professional reported in each case

(d) the outcome of each completed case

17=Incorrect accounts

01= withdrawn

 

07= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

09= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

01=Advertising

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

02=Bad communication

01= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

01= Cancelled

01=Breach of contract

01= Cancelled

09=Incompetence

09=due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

05=Practicing without registration

04= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

01=guilty

01= Racial discrimination

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

12=fees

04= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

07= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

01= Cancelled

07=Fraud

05= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

02= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

05=Insufficient care treatment

02= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

03= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

01=Operation without consent

01= withdrawn

06=Overservicing

04= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

02= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

01=Refuse assistant

01 -due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

02=Reports

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

01 = referred to ombudsman

01=Reputation of colleagues

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

01=secrecy

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

01=Supersession

01=withdrawn

01=Touting

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

01=Unacceptable relationship

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

02=Unprofessional conduct

02= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

(b) Details of each health professional’s designation:280= Psychologist

(c) breach of health professional reported in each case

(d) the outcome of each completed case

08=Incorrect accounts

03= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

04= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

01=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

01=Advertising

01= withdrawn

02=Assault

02= No evidence of unprofessional conduct

09=Bad communication

06= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

03= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

03=Certificate

03= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

16=Incompetence

13= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

02= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

01= Cancelled

11=Practicing without registration

07= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

01= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

02=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

01= Cancelled

01=Racial discrimination

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

02=Exploitation

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

01= Cancelled

05=Expose patient to danger

05= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

11=fees

02= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

09= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

06=Fraud

06= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

01=Impeding a patient

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

03=Withholding information

02= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

01=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

10=Insufficient care treatment

01= withdrawn

 

06= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

02 =no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

01= Cancelled

10=providing treatment without consent

09= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

01= Cancelled

5= Refuse assistant

02= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

03= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

132=Reports

07= withdrawn

 

97= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

08= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

17 =no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

01= guilty

 

02= Cancelled

01=Reputation of colleagues

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

07=Rule Spec contravening

06= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

01=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

07=Secrecy

07= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

01=Section 51

01= Cancelled

02=Specialist

02= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

01=Supersession

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

05=Unacceptable relationship

01=withdrawn

 

03= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

01=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

18=Unprofessional conduct

15= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

01=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

 

02= Cancelled

02=Unregistered

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

01= Cancelled

b) Details of each health professional’s designation: 39=Radiography and Clinical Technology

(c) breach of health professional reported in each case

(d) the outcome of each completed case

04=Incorrect accounts

03= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

 

01=no evidence of unprofessional conduct

01=breach of contract

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

01=Incompetence

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

02=Practicing without registration

01= guilty

 

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

01=Racial discrimination

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

01=Expose patient to danger

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

03=fees

03= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

04=Fraud

04= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

01=Insufficient care treatment

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

02=providing treatment without consent

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

01=referred to ombudsman

05Refuse assistant

05 due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

01=Reports

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

01=Reputation of colleagues

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

01=Supersession

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

01=Unacceptable relationship

01= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

10=Unprofessional conduct

10= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

(b) Details of each health professional’s designation:24=Speech, Language and Hearing

(c) breach of health professional reported in each case

(d) the outcome of each completed case

02=Incorrect accounts

02= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

03=Incompetence

03= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

07=fees

04= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

03= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

02=Fraud

02= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

01=Withholding information

01=cancelled

01=Insufficient care treatment

01= Cancelled

01Refuse assistant

01= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

02=Reports

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

 

01= mediated upon by the Ombudsman

02=Unprofessional conduct

02= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

01=Unregistered

01= due to time constraints the outcome could not be established.

(e) The following represent the number of health professional that were suspended from the register of practicing health professionals as a result of unprofessional conduct: –

2014/15 FY

2015/2016 FY

2016/17 FY

01 April 2017 to 31 October 2017

73 health professionals suspended

28 health professionals suspended

10 health professionals suspended

03 health professionals suspended

(f) The following represent the number of health professionals that were removed from the register of practicing health professionals (membership terminated) as a result of unprofessional conduct: –

2014/15 FY

2015/2016 FY

2016/17 FY

01 April 2017 to 31 October 2017

04 health professionals removed

09 health professionals removed

03 health professionals removed

02 health professionals removed

END

Source file