Minister's briefing on Department's Objectives and Strategy for 2001/2

This premium content has been made freely available

Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs

08 May 2001
Share this page:

Meeting Summary

A summary of this committee meeting is not yet available.

Meeting report


8 May 2001

Chairperson: Mr Y I Carrim

Relevant Documents
2001 Estimates of Budget Expenditure
Budget Review - Chapter Seven: Provincial and Local Government
Department’s Report on Activities for the 2001/2 Financial Year (see Appendix)

The Minister of Provincial and Local Government addressed the Committees on the development objectives for the forthcoming financial year. Key issues addressed by the Minister were the future of traditional leaders as well as the future of the provinces after comments made in the press that provinces might be restructured. The Department of Provincial and Local Government briefed the Portfolio and Select Committee on its financial strategy for the forthcoming financial year. The main issues raised by members were the progress that the department had made in ensuring co-operative governance, the distribution of the Equitable Share as well as the identification of households in need of basic services.

The Chairperson welcomed the Minister of Provincial and Local Government, Mr S Mufamadi, the Director General, Mr Z Titus, as well as other members of the Department.

Minister’s Address
Mr Mufamadi, Minister of Local and Provincial Government, presented development objectives for the forthcoming financial year.

The Minister stated that the Ministries programmes aimed to address five main development objectives - stabilising and consolidating systems of Local Government; the integration of municipal systems under the Municipal Systems Act, support for newly established Local Government structures; strengthening of inter-governmental relations and the implementation of government strategies for urban renewal and integrated rural strategies.

Mr Mufamadi re-iterated the policy thrusts arising from the State President's State of the Nation address, namely development, establishing an economic growth path and urban renewal and rural development. He said that Local government was vital for these objectives and that the Portfolio Committee had played a vital role in this in helping the ministry thus far. He also said that the Department is indebted to other agencies such as the South African Local Government Association (SALGA), the Independent Electoral Commission, other national ministries, Municipal Demarcations Board, Independent Development Trust as well as the provinces. He said that it was the most recent SALGA conference that signposted the direction for Local Government transformation.

Mr Mufamadi said that a sphere of Local Government had been created that has its own functional integrity, rather than limited to an administrative role.

Mr Mufamadi said that the discussion of the day was likely to have an enduring affect on the shape of government. He said that the Department is structured to deal with the conditions and challenges facing the country and seek to work with the Portfolio Committee in achieving its objectives.

Mr P Smith (IFP) said that there is a need to consolidate and stabilise Local Government. He asked if the Minister sees a solution to the crisis between traditional authority and government structures.

Mrs G Borman (DP) asked how the minister sees the future of the provinces in the light of recent comments made by Premier Stofile of the Eastern Cape.

Mr M Bhabha (ANC) (Mpumalanga) reminded the minister that this was a joint meeting and that the Select Committee was present.

Mr B Solo (ANC) asked if the minister could enlighten the committee further on the vision and strategy planning for the Urban Renewal Strategy (URS) and the Integrated Rural Development Strategy (IRDS) and asked what budgetary provisions are being made to ensure the success of these programmes.

The Chair said that this was an important question and constitutes the theme for the next few days.

An NP member asked about the progress on the redrawing boundaries for B and C category municipalities.

The Chair said that this question could be put to the Demarcation Board when they address the Committee next week.

The Minister, in response to perceived tensions between traditional leaders and government said that he does not believe that there is a crisis. After meetings last year with the select committee and the portfolio committee, Cabinet established a cabinet Committee to address this matter. Once the Cabinet Committee had presented a draft bill to Cabinet, the Cabinet decided to consult stakeholders including a delegation of Traditional Leaders, National Land Commission, Commission for Gender Equality, Cosatu and Sanco. He said while not all stakeholders were completely happy about the bill, encouraging feedback was received from the stakeholders and that the draft bill will be refined in cabinet, taking all stakeholders into account.

The Minister added that this is a democratising society and that traditional leaders are by definition conservative as they are the custodians of tradition and culture. He said that they therefore have the potential to fetter democracy and that their authority would have to be transformed in order for democratisation to take place. This transformation is the collective responsibility of the executive and legislature, rather than just between the executive and traditional leadership.

He said that the matter was an important one in that it goes to the heart of democratising the country. He re-iterated however, that there is no crisis. He said that is it certainly not his wish for a crisis.

On the future of the provinces in the system of government, the minister said that he would be surprised if one sphere of government was chosen. He said that a multi-faceted system of government was chosen in keeping with global trends.He said that it was felt by some at CODESA that provinces were unnecessary. The old provinces were political boundaries, whereas the new provinces are developmental boundaries. He said that developmental considerations are asking us to rethink our boundaries as it is something of an anomaly that some Local Government boundaries straddle provincial boundaries. He said that this anomaly will be addressed. He added that while some may feel that the existing provincial boundaries are inimical for development, the idea of provincial sphere of government it self was not the issue. He added further that provincial as well as municipal boundaries were not cast in stone.

In response to Mr Bhabha, the minister said that he was mindful of the jointness of the meeting.

Mr P Smith (IFP) responded to the urging of the Minister that there was no crisis, saying that he was rather intrigued by the minister's comments. He said that promises made to traditional leaders had not been fulfilled. He quoted the statement of traditional leaders during the stakeholder consultaions mentioned by the minister that said that traditional leaders "reject this bill and are at the end of their tether". He said that the minister should be aware that this could lead municipal governemt to grind to a halt in some of the provinces. He added that if the Minister does not think that this precipitated a crisis, he would be fascinated to know what the Minster thinks is a crisis.

Mr C Ackerman (NNP) (Western Cape) said that the issue of boundaries is a highly political one and it was therefore necessary that all parties and stakeholders should be informed what decisions were being made in this regard.

An ANC member said that she does not see the matter as a crisis. She asked about the audit of Traditional Leaders as part of the perceived crisis is that we don't know who are traditional leaders and who are not.

Ms G Borman (DP) asked if the traditional leadership sructure will be completely re-worked.

Mr Mufamadi said that he is intrigued by the alarmism demonstrated by Mr Smith and repeated that there is no crisis. He said that while there is not agreement between traditional leaders on all issues, there is now a bill that seeks to address the role of traditional leaders while continuing with the process of formulating policy.

In respones to Mr Ackerman's comments on provincial and municipal boundaries, the Minister said that the matter is political, but the so is everything discussed here. He said that the government is doing work on the issue of the provinces and that he assumes that Mr Ackerman's party is also doing work on this. He said that other parties should not be waiting for government.

Mr Ackerman replied that he was asking for information, that is all.

The Chair ended the discussion by saying that the separation of powers needs to be enforced as well as constituencies. He thanked the Minister and suggested that Mr Bhabha (Chair of Select Committee) chair the second half of the meeting as he felt that it would be more productive for the two committees to work jointly. Mr Bhaba said that this would be inappropriate as the Constitution did not allow for Select Committee Chairs to chair joint meetings.

Budget presentation
The Director General of the Department of Provincial and Local Government, Mr Z Titus introduced representatives of the Department:
Deputy Director General- Mr E Africa (Governance and Development)
Deputy Director General- Ms J Manche (Institutional Reform and Support)
Deputy Director General- Mr G Mokate (Support Services)
Chief Director of Finance- Mr C Clerihew
Director of Intergovernmental Relations: Co-ordination and Implementation- Mr D Powell
Director of Intergovernmental Relations: Research- Dr A Botha
Director of Infrastructure Implementation- Mr R Kruger
Director of Development planning and Local Economic Development- Ms S Magwaza

Mr Titus said that the key issue being addressed was what it means to cut the budget. He said that it is not just about figures, but implementation of policy, government strategy plus a myriad of other issues. He handed over to Mr C Clerihew to take the committee through Budget vote 5.

Mr Clerihew went through the document (Report on Activities to Portfolio Committee for the 2000/01 financial year) explaining the budgetary strategy of the Department. (see appendix for document)

Ms G Borman (DP) thanked the Department for the amount of work put into the presentation. She said that the way that she understands equitable share is that it is designed to assist communities who cannot afford to pay for basic services. She asked if the equitable share figures were costed or if they were ad hoc figures.

An ANC member asked how far the Department was in restructuring. She said that the all in the Committee were aware of the challenges of restructuring. She asked if the department could give the Committee an assessment of the Department. She also asked what the policy of gender equality was in the Department given that out of ten Department representatives introduced today only two were women.

An NP member asked why so much money was being given to Public Works.

An ANC member asked the progress of the Local Economic Development fund and asked what municipalities must do in order to access these funds.

Ms Manche, one of the Deputy Director Generals said that the current estimates for the equitable share are in a draft form. She said that the department had arrived at a figure off R86.00 per household.

The Chair asked if the Department could tell the committee on the progress of providing free electricity.

Mr Titus replied that as south Africa is a large country, pilot areas will be identified first to receive free electricity. He said that this issue resides in the Mineral and Energy affairs portfolio who had given the Department their workplan, indicating that everything is on course. He added that some municipalities have started already.

The Chair asked how many municipalities were to receive free basic services. He asked if it was just the poor who were entitled to the delivery of basic services or if everyone was. He also asked what the restructuring of Eskom meant for delivery.

Ms Borman (DP) asked if the department was in a position to know exactly which households were entitled to the R86.00.

Mr A Lyle (ANC) asked if the benefits to the poor were accumulative.

An ANC member said that development is only seen to be occurring in established or in other words, white areas. When people see an RDP house, they feel that development is being achieved even though it is not comparable to the development of white areas.

In response to Ms Borman's question, Ms Manche said that pilot areas had not been identified yet. She said that the delivery of water was more advanced than electricity at this stage. She said that it will be a staggered exercise and that capacity will be built in the weaker areas.

In response to the restructuring of the Department, Mr Titus said that the Department will release a document the following day to show how the Department is restructuring. He said that the Department is aware of the imbalances and that a clear policy framework had been developed to address this. He said however, that it is a simple fact that imbalance exists. He said that the issue should be deferred until tomorrow when the document is distributed.

In response to the money being spent on Public Works, Mr Clerihew said that a community-based Public Works programme will provide community based job creation and poverty alleviation. Mr Africa added that a Public Works programme is established and that the national Treasury makes the final decision in this regard. He said that new programmes are being monitored before they are fully implemented.

Mr M Bhabha (ANC) said that he feels that it is logical that municipal workers be brought into the public service sector and asked what developments were taking place in this regard. He also asked if there was any way of monitoring the manner in which grants are being spent.

Mr Titus said that there had been some debate over who should benefit from free basic services and whether well-off people should be brought into the net. He said that he was uncertain whether the debate had been finalised.

In response to municipal workers being brought under the umbrella of the Public Service Act, Mr Titus said that the issue had been misreported in the press. He said that the Cabinet had said that the pros and cons of putting municipal workers under the act should be investigated and suggested that members raise the issue with Cabinet.

Mr J Kgarimetsa (ANC) asked for clarity over municipalities applying for funds and asked what role the department plays in ensuring that a particular municipality gets help. He also asked the extent of the role that the Department plays in ensuring co-operative governance.

The Chair said that Mr Kgarimetsa's second question was particularly important and a question that vitally needs to be addressed. He said that a key question was the degree of progress that the department had made in securing co-operative government. The Chair also asked how the Public Finance Management Act had affected the department. The Chair added that this parliament was becoming one of the most user-friendly in the world thanks to the Treasury's guidelines on how budgets are presents to Committees.

An ANC member noted that there had been a reduction in funds for disaster management by 200%. He asked how the Department decided that disasters had become more manageable.

Ms Borman commented that attempting to locate the poor in every area would be a costly exercise and that it would be cheaper to provide water across the board.

Ms J Manche that the equitable share is monitored by the Department and that each provincial department has to report what it is used for. She said that each municipality is assessed by its population and a measurement of poverty, which is presently based on income per household, but may change to expenditure. At the moment hose-hols that earn less than R800 per month are defined as poor. Ms Manche said that it cost-effective to target municipal areas rather than individual households.

With regards to ensuring co-operative governance and municipalities applying for funds, Ms Manche said that sometimes municipalities do not respond which indicates capacity problems She said that the Department has however been able to identify such municipalities and put support programmes in place in over 170 municipalities.

The Chair said that there must be other ways of steering money into the right areas and that something needs to be done in this regard.

Mr Manche said that the Department is in the process of finalising guidelines for the delivery of the three basic services to be distributed to municipalities that will help them to formulate their budgets.

Mr Africa said that the problems in ensuring co-operative governance are in three broad areas. The first is in the area of policy and legislation. He said that the Department is looking at constitutional guidelines and reviewing legislation. The second problem is that there are different structures in government and it not always certain which structure is in the charge of which department. The third problem is in the area of identifying key delivery areas and programmes as some are duplicated.

Mr Titus added that the solution to co-operative governance is not in the constitution but rather in legislation such as the Systems Act. He added however that the Budget Review Document is a fantastic example of co-operative governance. With regards to disaster management, he said that the Department has been discouraged form budgeting for disasters, but that a framework document was being prepared to address this problem.

The Chair thanked the Department and adjourned the meeting.
1.1        Expenditure by Programme


Original Budget

Adjust-ments Budget

Total Budget









  1. Administration

23 477

3 075

26 552

23 159

3 393

·  Governance and Development

18 035

3 845

21 880

11 919

9 961

·  Institutional Reform and Support

3 496 413

168 825

3 665 238

3 579 433

85 805

·  Auxiliary and Associated Services

95 648

3 373

99 021

98 367



3 633 573

179 118

3 812 691

3 712 878

99 813

1.2        Expenditure by Standard Item


35 389

3 889

39 278

30 976

8 302


15 635

11 685

27 320

15 717

11 603


5 515

1 626

7 141

4 799

2 342


3 432

2 407

5 839

5 614


Professional and Special Services

41 248

26 335

67 583

46 718

20 865

Transfer payments

3 531 875

133 176

3 665 051

3 608 790

56 261








3 633 573

179 118

3 812 691

3 712 878

99 813

1.3        Expenditure by Economic Classification


99 181

43 535

142 716

99 688

43 028


2 517

2 407

4 924

4 400


Transfer Current

2 648 775

133 176

2 781 951

2 757 690

24 261

Transfer capital

883 100


883 100

851 100

32 000


3 633 573

179 118

3 812 691

3 712 878

99 813

2.1        Programme 1 – Administration
The current variance of R3,393 million is mainly due to:
Saving on personnel expenditure of R1 million due to vacant posts.
The anticipated level of travelling by the Ministry and Management was not realised and the moratorium on the filling of vacant posts due to the restructuring of the Department resulted in reduced activities. (R1 246 714)
The non-utilisation of funds provided for professional services to implement the new Public Service Regulations
2.2        Programme 2 – Governance and Development
The current variance of R9,961 million is mainly due to:
Saving on personnel expenditure of R1 million due to vacant posts.
A saving of R3,72 million on the provision for the White Paper on Traditional Leadership which was expected to be completed by March, but is now estimated to be November 2001.
No expenditure required in respect of boundary disputes (R264,000).
General reduction in the amounts utilised for administrative expenditure of R1,73 million through vacancies and delays in programmes.
The amounts expected to be required for professional services did not realise and a number of projects are being carried forward in the next financial year (R2,6 million).
The expected printing of reports and legislation did not materialise (R729,000).
2.3        Programme 3 – Institutional Reform and Support
The current variance of R85,805 million is mainly due to:
Saving on personnel expenditure of R5,2 million due to vacant posts.
The delays in LED Fund projects at municipalities occasioned mainly by the elections and the need for financial discipline (R23,576 million).
The transfers in respect of training initiatives reflect a R1,4 million saving.
The saving of R689,000 in respect of Y2K remediation.
The actual cost of consultancy services on Project Viability reflects a R2,47 million saving.
General reduction in the amounts required for administrative expenditure (R773,000).
The current saving is R15,839 million, however, there are a number of known commitments which still have to be brought to account. The original cessation date for the Centre was 31 March 2001, but due to a variety of reasons, this was not possible. A full report is to be submitted with a request to roll-over funds.
An amount of R31,9 million of the CMIP allocation was not spent by the Gauteng Province due to the fact that funds were committed to slow moving projects and the claims were not received on time from the implementing agents.
The project management costs of the CMIP project were very closely controlled which has resulted in a saving of R3,56 million.
2.4        Programme 4 – Auxiliary and Associated Services
The saving on Communication of R1,0 million is to be utilised in part to cover the additional requirement for the Municipal Demarcation Board.
The saving on the Section 185 Commission of R3,2 million due to the delay in the promulgation of required legislation, is to be utilised for the additional requirement of the Municipal Demarcation Board.
The shortfall in the Municipal Demarcation Board of R4,4 million is as a result of unfunded mandates, unforeseen litigation and publications in Gazettes.
The saving of R648,000 at the National House of Traditional Leaders is due to fewer meetings and the expected research was not realised.
3.1        Consolidate, Develop and Sustain an Integrated System of Intergovernmental Relations.
3.1.1     Financial Outturn by Component


Total Budget







Prog. 2 : Management




Prog 2 : Co-operative Governance

10 124

4 989

5 135

Prog. 3: Local Government Finance

4 927

3 112

1 815


15 762

8 620

7 142

3.1.2     Level of Achievement of Main Outputs



Policy and legislation on intergovernmental relations

During 2000, the Ministry and Department strategically re-evaluated its position on omnibus policy and legislation as part of the overall restructuring process. This legislation is not desirable during the current phase as the existing ad hoc legal measures do serve the purpose. Instead of free-standing omnibus legislation, the current strategy is to examine intergovernmental relations in the context of core government service-delivery priorities, such as the Integrated Sustainable Rural Development Strategy.
Certain chapters of the Municipal Systems Act provided for core monitoring aspects of intergovernmental relations involving provincial and local government.

Discussion document on intergovernmental relations

A discussion document was produced. In line with the Minister’s and the Department’s strategic re-evaluation of its intergovern-mental role, and the emphasis on stabilising local government, however, the discussion document will now inform a practical manual on intergovernmental relations aimed at local government councillors and officials for the 2001 financial year.

National framework for monitoring, support and supervision

This is an inter-directorate project. Substantial progress was made in that a national and provincial study for a monitoring framework has now been completed. The framework seeks to enhance service delivery through improving inter-governmental rela-tions and channels of accountability. This process further informs the necessary sup-port measures that the different spheres need.

Section 100 and 139 legislation

Draft legislation was produced, but as a basis for consultation with stakeholders. Any legislation will eventually form part of the Monitoring Framework.

Develop specific strategies to support intergovernmental and interdepartmental processes

Substantial progress on the government planning cycle was made in collaboration with the Department of Public Service and Administration and the Presidency, including developing priorities and a work plan for the Governance and Administration Cluster and reconfiguring the agenda of the President’s Co-ordinating Council to ensure greater integration with government priorities.




A manual on intergovernmental relations

The manual is to be produced during the 2001/2002 financial year as part of the Department’s capacity-building strategy for local government. A manual on section 189 was however produced.

Intergovernmental Planning Cycle

This project is driven by the Presidency. The Department serves on a cabinet approved task team with the Presidency, Treasury and GCIS. Substantial progress has been made towards finalising the planning cycle before the July 2001 Cabinet lekgotla.

Policy on intergovernmental disputes

The Intergovernmental Relations Audit Report had as one of its tasks the question whether this policy was required. The Report concluded that this policy was not needed in the short term, given that the intergovernmental system is evolving.

National intergovernmental data-centre

The Department supported the establishment of the PAIR centre at the University of Pretoria, which is now operational.

Audit on Provincial Institutional Capacity Needs

Substantial progress was made in that workshops in the areas of concurrent competency between national and provincial government departments determining institutional capacity needs were concluded by the end of March 2001. The draft report containing findings of the project is now being finalised and will be submitted to the Department at the end of May 2001.

Legislation on Property Rates

Draft Bill published in August 2000.
Comments on Property Tax Bill received from various stakeholders by 04 October 2000.
DPLG and National Treasury have met to manage the finalisation of the Bill as agreed to by the two Ministers.
A Task Team consisting of National Treasury and the Department of Provincial and Local Government was formed in January 2001 to process the Bill. The Task Team has been meeting twice a week since the beginning of February 2001.
The Task Team has met with the Department of Public Works, Department of Land Affairs, Institute and council of Valuers.
Consultations continued into the year 2001 as follows:
A meeting with NEDLAC took place on 3 April 2001.
A meeting with Traditional Leaders to take place by end of April 2001.
The Bill will be submitted to Cabinet in May and to the State Law advisors in July 2001.
A workshop is scheduled to take place in June 2001.


Bill to be tabled in Parliament in August 2001.
The processing of the comment on the Bill is almost 80% complete.

National Municipal Tariff Policy Statement and Guidelines

Final drafts on National Municipal Tariff Policy statement and guidelines to be published and distributed to all the councils before July 2001. The policy statement and guidelines are 90% complete.

Fiscal Reform Project
A policy study of Regional Council Services Levies- Now called "Financing District Councils"

Reference group had met for the fifth time on 29 March 2001.
Draft paper on the review of the RSC Levies was presented on 25 November 2000. A workshop on the final Draft paper on the review of the RSC Levy took place on 28 March 2001. A policy framework document to be completed before June 2001.

Establishment of a fiscal database for modelling finances and informing decision makers of options

First draft on fiscal database completed in November 2000. A presentation on fiscal database to take place end of April 2001. Final Draft to be completed before end of May 2001, and presented in the June 2001 workshop.

Analysis of the vertical split (quantum) of Equitable Share for Local Government and the determination of an overall performance criteria for the Equitable Shares system

Draft Policy framework on the options for closing the fiscal gap between expenditures and revenues of local government finances was presented to the reference group in November 2000. Draft Policy framework on the options for closing the gap between expenditures and revenues of local government finances must be completed before the end of May, and presented in the June 2001 workshop.

Determining the Fiscal Powers and Functions of Category B and C Municipalities

The first draft of the policy framework for the division of fiscal powers and functions for category B and C municipalities was presented to the reference group in October 2000. The draft policy framework for the division of fiscal powers and functions for category B and C municipalities was presented on 29 March 2001. Final Draft to be completed by May 2001, and presented in the June workshop.
Workshop on Local Government Fiscal Reform Project to be held on 4/5 June 2001.


3.2        Consolidate and Sustain an Integrated System of Planning and Delivery.
3.2.1     Financial outturn by component.


Total Budget







Programme 3




Infrastructure and Planning

5 980

5 133


Municipal Services Partnerships

8 000

7 450


Consolidated Municipal Infrastructure Programme

891 722

856 281

35 441

Social Plan Measures

2 978

3 003


Local Economic Development Fund

104 257

80 480

23 777

Equitable Share to Local Government

1 867 000

1 867 000


Local Government Support

150 000

150 000


R293 Towns

463 000

462 997


Local Government Transition Fund

100 000

100 000



3 592 937

3 532 344

60 593

3.2.2     Level of Achievement of Main Outputs


Level of Achievements

Analyse the current institutions and processes in all spheres of government that impact on development planning by March 2000

    Sector alignment document has been completed. The purpose of the document is to align municipal planning requirements of other sector departments.
    A report on poverty, gender and integrated development planning. The document will assist municipalities to focus on gender issues and poverty reduction during the IDP process.
    Work in this area is ongoing.




Develop a single regulatory framework for development planning by 2001.

A draft discussion policy paper on integrated development planning has been completed. Consultations with major stakeholders were held and the policy will be finalised and launched in July 2001.

Facilitate the use of IDP approach across all spheres of government over a five year period.

The above paper on integrated development planning incorporates issues on IGR planning approach across all spheres.

Monitor implementation of the regulatory framework on an annual basis.

The draft IDP monitoring system has been developed to ensure that the IDP process is monitored on an annual basis.

Develop and promote a common understanding of the outcomes of development planning and infrastructure delivery, i.e. community empowerment, integrated and sustainable environments, local economic development, meeting basic needs and infrastructure needs through workshops, information dissemination and various other training initiatives on an ongoing basis.

IDP process has been successfully linked to local economic development and infrastructure as delivery instruments in order to create sustainable communities and ensure implementation of plans, through CMIP and the LED Fund.

Develop a national planning implementation and management support system (PIMS) for provincial and municipal integrated development planning by December 2000

Established, equipped and trained staff for 12 Planning and Implementation Management Support Centres (PIMS – Centres) at district level to fulfil the municipal developmental function.

Seek greater alignment between the financial/budgetary planning cycles of all three spheres of government by December 2000.

The initial step was to ensure that the planning cycle /budgetary processes of local government are linked to the IDP process. The second phase was to develop the planning cycle for government processes and the process is now led by the Presidency.

Establish and manage a data and information system to support the preparation of provincial and municipal integrated development plans by July 2000.

The IT and monitoring system has been designed and it will finalised in July 2001.

Align the Provincial Development plans with national priorities through the Presidential Co-ordinating Council on an annual basis

The President, Minister for Provincial and Local Government and Provincial Premiers meet in the PCC to discuss governance and development issues that affect the three spheres of government on a regular basis.

Monitor and evaluate the performance of the IDP programme to ensure that the developmental outcome of government is addressed on a regular basis.

The monitoring system will be utilised to collect and analyse data on IDP progress. The findings will be used to feedback into the annual planning process.




Level of Achievements

Capacity building programme to support provincial government during the implementation of the system

A capacity building programme has been designed for both provincial and local government stakeholders that have a role to play in the IDP process. The tender amounting to R 10 million was advertised in November and service providers will be appointed soon.

Develop the capacity to promote a common understanding of the key development outcomes of national, provincial and local government by interacting with strategic delivery programmes by November 2000.

Completed a study on IGR/LED aimed at developing a common understanding of the roles and responsibilities of different spheres of government in contributing to the developmental role of local government.

Manage LED Fund and undertake all actions necessary that will ensure effective, efficient and unsustainable project delivery on an continuous basis.
Monitor and evaluate the performance of the LED Fund to ensure that the developmental outcome of government is addressed on a regular basis.

Effectively managed the LED fund resulting in the creation of both part- and full-time jobs, transference of facilities and assets to local communities and municipalities and ensured
the participation of provinces in the selection and approval of LED projects.
Site visits were undertaken, together with provinces, to LED projects in order to monitor and evaluate the performance and ensure that the developmental outcomes of government are achieved. In addition, monthly/quarterly reports are received on individual projects.

Ensure that provinces and municipalities have crafted strategic economic regeneration programmes and strategies to address economic decline in their areas of jurisdiction by July 2001

Out of 51 municipalities who qualified for the Social Plan Fund, 36 have completed their regeneration studies detailing strategies/projects to address economic decline in their areas of jurisdiction.

Develop and position the LED component appropriately in the national sphere of government in order to play an effective role within the overall system of co-operative government.

A fully functional LED component within the Department was established and maintained. Discussions are continuing on the need to establish an interdepartmental structure comprised of national departments implementing poverty alleviation programmes. A proposal has been made to MEC's for local government to establish LED units in provinces and municipalities (some have these in place already)

Produce an enabling national policy framework for LED to support the mandate of provincial and local government.

Completed a draft policy framework for LED to support the mandate of provincial and local government has been completed and consulted on during November/December 2000.

Engage in a range of targeted capacity building and support initiatives aimed at provincial and local government.

Designed a training programme for both provinces and municipalities. This will be rolled out in June/July 2001. The manuals and information booklets are at a printing stage.



Level of Achievements

Infrastructure Implementation.
Develop the capacity to promote and facilitate a common understanding of the key developmental outcomes of national, provincial and local government by interacting with strategic delivery programmes (such as CMIP).

By means of regular Municipal Infrastructure Task Team (MITT) meetings, co-ordination meetings with line function departments at provincial sphere and workshops and training sessions on provincial and local levels, a common understanding of the key developmental outcomes of national, provincial and local government have been promoted and facilitated.

Manage strategic delivery programmes and undertake all actions necessary that will ensure effective, efficient and sustainable project delivery.

Effective, efficient and sustainable project delivery have been achieved through the requirement that operation and maintenance plans (O&M) must be approved by municipal councils and provided for in project business plans. The training and capacity building of municipal officials further enhances this process.

Monitor and evaluate the performance of strategic delivery programmes to ensure that the developmental outcome of government is addressed.

CMIP is being monitored and evaluated on a monthly, quarterly and biannual basis to ensure that the developmental outcomes of government are adhered to.

Implementing the changes to CMIP as approved in the Cabinet Memorandum on 1 December 1999 in respect of rural infrastructure, capacity building, internal services and community facilities.

All changes to CMIP as approved in the Cabinet Memorandum dated 1 December 1999 in respect of rural infrastructure, capacity building, internal services and community facilities, have been implemented.

Upgrading the management system of CMIP. This included ensuring that provinces have the necessary capacity to implement the new changes to CMIP.

The upgrading of the management system of CMIP receives constant attention and regular workshops are held with provinces to ensure that they have the necessary capacity to implement changes.

Finalising the review of the Municipal Infrastructure Investment Framework (MIIF). This will provide the latest overview of municipal infrastructure backlogs in the country and recommend a financial, planning, delivery and institutional framework to address these backlogs.

The Municipal Infrastructure Investment Framework (MIIF) is in the process of being submitted to Cabinet. This framework document was finalised in January 2001.




Level of Achievements

Establishment of an enabling policy and regulatory framework for various forms of municipal service delivery.

1.       Cabinet approved a Draft White Paper on Municipal Service Partnerships (MSPs) for further consultation and input from stakeholders. This policy framework is due for a second presentation to Cabinet for final endorsement as a series of consultative workshops have already been convened with a wide spectrum of stakeholder.
A regulatory framework on MSP is in place in the form of Chapter 8 of the Municipal Systems Act as some of the provisions of the policy were converted into legislation.

Institutionalisation of Municipal Service Partnerships Capacity Building Programme.

1.       This is on track and at an advance stage as the Department has entered into a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with the two universities that have been identified to pilot this idea namely the Free State and Western Cape. Already Training of Trainers (TOT) drawn from 10 universities, 6 NGOs and 9 Provincial Programme Managers for MSPs has been conducted. Since this is a process other stages would be completed in September 2001.
To compliment this the Department is formalising a relationship with two provincial local government association such as the Eastern Cape Local Government Association and KwaZulu/Natal Local Government Association to mentor those municipal cadres that have received MSP training.

Design and implement municipal community partnerships (MCPs)

A business plan on MCPs has been designed. The Department is embarking on the implementation phase and the process of identifying pilot projects is underway.

Review the mandate of the Municipal Infrastructure Investment Unit (MIU)

A Directorate for municipal policy is created.

Regeneration policy guidelines by August 2000.

Guidelines on how to undertake regeneration studies were developed and distributed to all municipalities.

Policy implementation and Training Guidelines by December 2000.

Initiation workshops were held in municipalities that qualified for Social Plan Fund and guidelines were provided.

Monitoring and evaluation strategy by December 2000.

Monitoring study was commissioned to analyse submitted regeneration studies and assess their quality. The findings of the study were used to propose a structure and content of the regeneration study. Regular reports are also received from municipalities presenting performance on the expected outputs. Provincial Co-ordinating Committee (comprised of national, provinces and municipalities) meetings are held regularly to assess progress and deal with problems.


Level of Achievements

Determination of equitable share allocations to individual municipalities and organised local government for the 2001/02 financial year (and onwards)

Equitable share allocations to individual municipalities for the 2001/02 financial year finalised during April 2000.

Preparation and release of an annual report on the equitable share for local government, which includes a review of the impact of the equitable share on the various types of municipalities on an annual basis

Annual report on the equitable share for local government for the 1999/2000 was published and distributed to all CEOs/Town Clerks and Mayors early in May 2000. The allocations to individual municipalities for the 2000/01 municipal financial year formed part of the report.

Converting current municipal allocations to the new municipal boundaries resultant from the demarcation process

Joint process was established with the National Treasury and STATS SA to, amongst others:
Review poverty data for use in the re-modeling of the equitable share for the 2001/02 financial year;
Determine those modeling activities that can be undertaken by STATS SA and contracting out the remaining activities; and
Re-aligning Census 1996 municipal data to the newly established municipalities.
The data collection and manipulation activities required to undertake equitable share modeling for the 2001/02 to 2003/04 financial years were finalised during January 2001.
Produced draft local government equitable share model for discussion with National Treasury and SALGA by February 2001.
Allocations to individual municipalities for the 2001/02 to 2003/04 financial years will be finalised during April 2001.

Equitable share payments to those municipalities which are primarily responsible for the provision of services and with sufficient treasury capabilities to receive such transfers

Equitable share payments to municipalities (approximately 550) and organised local government for the 2000/01 financial year were effected quarterly within the first month of these quarters.

Updating database on municipalities as required (addresses, names of CEOs/town clerks, banking details)

The Finance Section is informed of any changes to banking details of municipalities in order to ensure that payments are made to the right banking account – continuous activity.

Quarterly reconciliation to ensure actual and accurate transfers to municipalities

Equitable share payments for the 2000/01 financial year were reconciled with the payment schedule approved by the Director-General.




Level of Achievements

Devising implementation strategy for incorporating DWAF operating subsidies into the equitable share

Meetings are held every fourth Thursday of every month between the Department, DWAF, National Treasury and SALGA to develop an appropriate strategy for incorporating DWAF operating subsidies into the equitable share.

Review of the appropriateness of the equitable share formula after demarcation process of municipalities

Issues impacting on the formula as a result of the demarcation were identified during August 2000. Simulations will be done during end 2000/early 2001 to determine most appropriate alternatives. Longer-term reforms to the equitable share formula will only start in 2001 (also refer to Local Government Finance Reform Project).

Monitoring municipalities with a view to detect mismanagement or financial misconduct

Withholding of equitable share payments to selective municipalities were investigated due to possible financial misconduct at these municipalities. It was, however, identified that corrective steps are being taken by these municipalities and payments were accordingly effected.

Monitoring other operating transfers administered by other national government departments for possible transfer to this department in future years

Departmental activity through MTEF processes.

Dealing with enquiries from municipalities regarding the equitable share

Telephonic inquiries are dealt with immediately (approximately 60 to 90 telephonic queries per month).
Approximately 15 to 30 written responses are dealt with per month. The response rate to inquiries approximately two months after receipt of letter due to lack of sufficient staff.

Assist in determining allocations to provinces, and conditions in respect of the R293 towns personnel grant for the Division of Revenue

Original division completed in February 2000. Various amendments were made to the payment schedule to effect direct payments to various municipalities.



Level of Achievements

Transfer of R293 town personnel grant to provinces and municipalities on a monthly basis

R293 personnel transfers were made to six provinces and fifty-four municipalities on a monthly basis for the 2000/01 financial year.
After monitoring monthly reports for the 2000/01 financial year, it was determined that there are surpluses at the KwaZulu-Natal and Mpumalanga Provinces. Submission in this regard was made to the National Treasury during March 2001.
Due to incorrect capturing of payment advice during January 2001, there is an under expenditure of R3 000 on the R293 town personnel grant during the 2000/01 financial year.

Continued assistance to provinces and municipalities to assist them in the transfer of R293 staff before the stipulated deadline

A workshop was held with all provinces during beginning July 2000 to assist them in resolving issues hampering the transfer of R293 staff to municipalities.
A circular was sent to all provinces and municipalities during August 2000 to inform them of the deadline for transfer and to assist in issues hampering the transfer process.
Regular discussions were held with provinces and municipalities to solve individual problems regarding the transfer of R293 town staff.


The deadline for the transfer of R293 staff to municipalities was the end of September 2000 and the deadline for submission of final transfer lists by provinces middle October 2000. The following submissions were made:
Eastern Cape                            98
Free State                                             1 051 (provisional)
KwaZulu-Natal                           835
Mpumalanga                             406
North West                                723
Northern Province                                  2 326
Total                                         5 439
The above-mentioned information received by provinces were captured and follow-up was done to clarify various anomalies in the reports submitted by provinces.
The total number of R293 staff to municipalities by the stipulated deadline amounted to 8 579, or 66 percent of the original
± 14 000 R293 staff.
Further extension was granted up to the middle January 2001 to enable provinces to effect those transfers that were far advanced but not finalised by the deadline (a further 12 transfers were finalised – KwaZulu-Natal and North West Provinces).
Follow-up was done to determine the status of transfer of R293 staff in the Free State Province (these transfers were not finalised by the stipulated deadline of the end of September 2000).
From the 2001/02 financial year, the division of the R293 town personnel allocation between provinces and municipalities is based on the number of R293 town staff transferred to municipalities and those retained by provinces. The allocation for local government is based on 100 percent of the provincial salary as at transfer and is guaranteed for three years. The remainder of the funds was allocated to provinces based on the projected annual expenditure for retained staff and was proportionally scaled down according to available resources.
Further outstanding issues regarding the transfer of R293 town staff to municipalities will also be dealt with during the 2001/02 financial year, such as the transfer of pension benefits to municipal pension funds.

Obtain monthly reports from provinces in respect of R293 town staff

The necessary follow-up was done to obtain outstanding expenditure reports from provinces for the 2000/01 financial year. On average, provincial compliance was unsatisfactory and numerous follow-ups were required.

From monthly reports obtained from provinces, compile consolidated quarterly reports to the DG of Finance

The monthly information as stipulated in the Division of Revenue Act, 2000 provided by provinces was used by the Department to prepare a consolidated quarterly expenditure reports for the 2000/01 financial year – July 2000, October 2000 and December 2000 respectively.
Quarterly report for January to March 2001 due in April 2001.

Other R293 town related issues:
East London TLC legal case

Various responses were prepared on legal documentation in the legal case instituted by the East London TLC against various parties, including the Department.
Various meetings were also held during January to March 2001 in order to resolve the issue through negotiation rather than litigation.
Buffalo City Municipality (East London TLC) subsequently withdrew legal case on 12 March 2001.



Level of Achievements



Possible establishment of a transitional fund for local government for the 2001/02 and 2002/03 financial years

A survey of the once-off and incidental costs related to the restructuring process and the proposed size of the transitional fund was completed in August 2000.
MTEF submissions were made during June 2000 to request the establishment of a transitional fund for local government.
A follow-up memo was made during December 2000 to inform Cabinet of the once-off and incidental costs related to the demarcation and to propose that a transitional fund be allocated to local government for the 20001/02 and 2002/03 financial years.


An amount of R100 million was allocated on the Adjustments Budget for the 2000/01 financial year to cater for the costs related to the demarcation process.


The proposed framework on the criteria for allocation, conditions, reporting and monitoring requirements in respect of the Local Government Transitional Fund was prepared during November 2000. Various discussions were held with SALGA and the National Treasury during November 2000 to March 2001 to finalise these issues.
A draft payment schedule was prepared for the appropriate division of the Local Government Transitional Fund for the 2000/01 financial year. The National Treasury and SALGA were also consulted in this regard.
A draft letter of allocation to municipalities was prepared to inform municipalities of their allocation for the 2000/01 financial year and the criteria/conditions for accessing allocations for the 2001/02 financial year. Draft guidelines to assist municipalities in preparing amalgamation plans were also prepared and formed part of the allocation letter. The letter was approved during end February 2001 and forwarded to all municipalities.
Payments were effected to all newly demarcated municipalities according to the approved payment schedule during March 2001.

3.2.3     Other activities Accomplished


Level of Achievements

Consolidation of Interim IDPs for newly established municipalities.

Stemming out of the demarcation process municipalities were requested to prepare interim IDPs and link these plans to their 2001/2002 budgeting process. More than 80% municipalities have completed their interim IDPs with the rest due by the end of April 2001.

Sharing of information and best practices

Distributed best practise newsletters to all relevant stakeholders with the view to share lessons learned during the implementation phase of the LED programme.

Showcasing LED projects

Hosted a successful Trade Fair to showcase 32 completed LED projects.

Improvements on the LEDF for better planning outputs and maximum impact.

The LED Fund is now located within MTEF enable municipalities to effect multi-year planning. The increase in the LED Fund allocation is a positive step towards addressing poverty and job creation.

The amounts allocated per province on rural and urban projects are as follows:




Eastern Cape



Free State












Northern Cape



Northern Province



North West



Western Cape




Outputs for the 2000/01 financial year

Level of Achievements

Projects approved


Projects in design and tender phase


Projects in construction phase


Projects completed



2 461 467

Women and youth employed (person days)

3 025 910

Training provided (training days)

304 507

SMME’s used on projects


Outputs since inception of programme

Projects approved

2 040

Projects in design and tender phase


Projects in construction phase


Projects completed

1 087


10 605 672

Women and youth employed (person days)

3 067 163

Training provided (training days)

318 555

SMME’s used on projects


3.3        Support Provincial and Local Government as well as Institutions of Traditional Leadership in Order to Facilitate Delivery.
3.3.1     Financial outturn by component


Total Budget







Prog 2: Traditional Affairs

11 045

6 411

4 634

Prog 3: Management




Prog 3: Development and Support (Portion)

3 061

2 144


Prog 4: National House of Traditional Leaders

3 506

2 901


Prog 4: Khoisan Communities





19 120

12 207

6 913

3.3.2     Level of Achievement of Main Outputs


Level of Achievements

Draft a Discussion Document on Traditional Leadership and Institutions


Develop a Green Paper and White Paper on Traditional Leadership and Institutions

Chapters of the Green Paper have been completed and three are outstanding. It is expected that the Green Paper will be finalised by June/July 2001.

Review of existing legislation and drafting new legislation.

Review and rationalisation of all existing legislation pertaining to traditional leadership has been finalised. A skeletal framework for National legislation has also been drafted. The final version will be completed after completion of the White Paper.

Establishment of an Independent Commission on Disputes and Claims on traditional leadership

The necessary preparatory work has been done. A proposal has been submitted to form part of the Green Paper. Implementation will take place after the completion of the White Paper.



Level of Achievements

Conduct research on historical and anthropological dimensions of the Khoisan communities

A report with recommendations has been finalised and submitted to form part of the Green Paper. This will be finalised simultaneously with the White Paper.

Develop and maintain capacity building programmes for traditional leaders and institutions

A paper on capacity building was commissioned to lay a foundation for the development of an effective programme.

Render support to the National House of Traditional Leaders

A Code of Ethics was formulated for the National House. The appointment of two additional officials for the National House has been approved.

Attend to ad hoc traditional leadership disputes and claims

Disputes and claims that do not require the attention of the Commission have been handled on a continuous basis.

Support the implementation of the Demarcation (MDA) and Structures (MSA) on an on-going basis.

·         Determined formulae for the number of councillors for each municipality, in terms of section 20 of the MSA.
Determined a policy framework in terms of section 18(4) of the MSA for full-time members of municipal councils.
Developed a policy framework for the adjustment of powers and functions between district and local municipalities, in terms of section 85(1) of the MSA.
Determined a policy framework for the exemption of municipalities from those sections of the MSA, as contained in section 91 of the MSA.
Promulgated legislation authorising the establishment of cross-boundary municipalities.
Called and set the date for municipal elections, in terms of section 24 of the MSA.



Level of Achievements

Re-assess capacity of all newly elected councils with a view to finalise the division of Powers and Functions between category B and C municipalities.

·         Provide inputs at fora represented by the National Departments of Finance, Water Affairs and Forestry, Mineral and Energy Affairs, Health, and the Municipal Demarcation Board.

The Implementation of the Municipal Systems Act.

·         After consulting the relevant line managers, ensured that the legal requirements for the implementation of the Act were in place.
Ascertained which provisions of the Act should be phased in and which should be made applicable to all municipalities on the same date that the Act took effect.
Promulgation of the relevant Notice to authorise implementation of the relevant sections of the Act.

Administer the Remuneration of Public Office Bearers Act.

·         Consulted with MECs, and the Commission for the Remuneration of Public Office Bearers on determining upper limits for salaries and allowances for councillors and traditional leaders.
Promulgated the relevant Notices to give effect to the relevant provisions of the Act.

Provide support to municipalities and provinces.

  • Provide municipalities and provinces with the necessary advice and support regarding the problems being experienced at both spheres of government pertaining to the implementation of the new local government dispensation.
    The successful disposal of enquiries received from provinces and municipalities.

3.4        Development and Implement Targeted Capacity Building Programmes.
3.4.1     Financial outturn by component


Total Budget







Prog 3: Development and Support (Portion)

4 726

3 241

1 485

Prog 3: Project Viability

16 400

13 933

2 467

3.4.2     Level of Achievement of Main Outputs


Level of Achievements

Develop a system to address capacity needs assessment.


  • Design appropriate methodology for assessing needs

Methodology designed and agreed to for usage.

  • Identify and assess capacity needs.
  • Capacity needs assessment for the provinces at high level for strategy development purposes done but an in-depth analysis not yet complete.
    An in-depth analysis is currently being done and is due for completion before the end of June 2001.
    A high level desk top capacity needs assessment for municipalities done, using the World Bank, Municipal Demarcation Board and provincial visits data for the purpose of developing strategy.
  • Analyse and categorise needs according to municipal, provincial and traditional authorities
  • Process to implement this has been put in place and work to be completed before September 2001.

·         Develop an institutional capacity building strategy

A 1st Draft Local Government Capacity Building Strategy done and completed for discussion purposes with stakeholders.
            A stakeholders committee has been established to co-ordinate the involvement of provinces, national departments, SALGA and other key stakeholders in the strategy development process.
            Consultation with all role players is underway through workshops in all the nine provinces.
            A final draft Strategy document will be completed before the end of June 2001

·         Assess the performance of provincial institutions in terms of their functions and in supporting local government.

·         Process to start in May 2001.

·         Identify and document "best practices" and new methods within provinces.

·         A system is being developed to document best practices and will be in place by September 2001.

  • Develop evaluation mechanisms for provinces to continuously assess their performance and capacity building needs.

·         Process to start once the capacity building strategy is being implemented by October 2001.

Develop and implement targeted Capacity Building programmes


  • Develop framework on capacity building.
  • Draft completed
  • Finalise framework and development program.

·         A draft development Programme is included in the Draft Strategy document.

  • Pilot projects in selected provinces and municipalities
  • Process to start before end of August 2001.
  • Develop an evaluation mechanism for capacity building
  • Process to start before end of June 2001.

·         Develop and implement capacity building programmes on an ongoing basis (in line with our programmes)
Establish co-ordination structure comprised of relevant or transversal national departments and donor agencies for targeted capacity building in provinces
Mobilise funding for capacity building on an ongoing basis

·         A targeted Training Programme for Councillors was developed, implemented and completed at the end of March 2001.
Done and agreed to for the purpose of developing a Capacity Building Strategy.
Being done on an ongoing bases.

·         Evaluate the effectiveness, efficiency, responsiveness and impact of the capacity building programmes
Monitor and evaluate the implementation and impact of capacity building programmes on the effectiveness of governance and support given to local government annually.

A monitoring and evaluation system is due to be developed by the end of October 2001.

·         Normalisation/stabilisation of municipal finances
Monitor the financial and administrative status in order to assess the stability of municipal finances in South Africa
Assist in building up financial administrative capacity of financially compromised municipalities in order to bring them back to a state of financial viability that will ensure delivery of essential services to local communities
Promote the implementation and maintenance of sound financial management practices at municipal level

Being done on an ongoing basis.
Being done on an ongoing basis.
Being done on an ongoing basis.

The main outputs, presented at the previous portfolio hearing for the 2000/01 financial year, were as follows:


Quarterly reports on the status of municipalities to be available within 2 months after the end of each quarter and submitted to MINMEC.

Extensions were given to municipalities to submit their responses to the Department. This was due to the low response rate of just over 50% experienced. Thus, reports were only obtainable after approximately 3 months.

Publish at least one status report on municipalities each year

Due to the delay in the submissions of the reports to MINMEC, no reports have been published, however, reports have been made available electronically on request.

Information on the status of municipalities to be published on the website

All reports approved by MINMEC were forwarded for publication on the website.

Ensure that each province can utilise the database

A pilot project was undertaken where one province was trained on the database. Due to the lack of interest this process was terminated. Provinces were supplied with the relevant data applicable to their province through the quarterly reports.

Refine the early warning system to timeously identify municipalities heading towards a financial crisis

The early warning system was enhanced to include financial as well as administrative factors that could indicate the possibility of a municipality facing a financial crisis

Develop and implement a strategic plan for the collection of data at provincial level in order for provinces to meet the requirement stipulated in Section 155(6)(a) of the Constitution

A process has been identified and will be introduced once monitoring of the newly established municipalities takes place.

Establish Management Support Teams and stabilise at least 100 municipalities throughout the country

At least 170 municipalities have been assisted through the management support programme.

Monitor the technical support provided through quarterly meetings with the Steering Committee and Provincial Programme Managers in order to ensure that the objectives of the programme are met

Regular quarterly meetings were held during the year.

Develop a strategy for the implementation of the structural adjustment programmes developed through the Management Support Programme

Funding was provided to over 125 municipalities for the implementation or various projects that would have a positive impact on the cash flow of the municipality. R60 million was provided for this purpose. Requests were received for over R300 million worth of projects.

Through technical support and liaison with Section 14(5) committees, ensure that municipalities are adjusted to take the development envisaged within the new boundaries, as determined through the demarcation process, into account.

Regular communication was established at provincial level with Section 14(5) or transitional committees. The work of the management support teams was adjusted to take into consideration the new municipal boundaries.

Provide progress reports to MINMEC and make Cabinet submissions as required

Regular reports were provided to MINMEC, input was provided to joint submissions to Cabinet on municipal and related matters.

Develop a user-friendly manual on customer care, credit control and debt management that is suitable for use in all municipalities.

This manual has now been completed. It is expected that final comments will be received and incorporated and the manual will be published and forwarded to all municipalities during the first half of the 2001/02 municipal financial year.

Develop a mentoring programme for implementation through the Management Support Teams for financial council officials in liaison with the SETA dealing with Project Viability Training

A mentoring programme was designed but not implemented by the Training Board (now dissolved and replaced by the Local Government SETA). Management Support Teams were instructed to provide mentoring to municipal officials as they assisted the municipalities involved in the management support programme.

3.5        Disaster Management
3.5.1     Financial outturn by component


Total Budget







Prog 3 Disaster Management

40 130

22 658

17 472

3.5.2     Level of Achievement of Main Outputs


Level of Achievements

Developing a new regulatory framework
Disaster management legislation

·         The revised Disaster Management Bill was distributed to all Cabinet Ministers, Premiers and Directors-General of the National Departments and the Provinces.
A special IMC meeting was arranged (28 March 2001) to discuss the Disaster Management Bill.


·         Unfortunately the meeting had to be cancelled due to a lack of attendance.


·         The Minister indicated that he will submit the Bill to Cabinet as soon as possible.


Letters were sent to all IMC/ERC members requesting them to submit their final comments on the Bill before 2 April 2001.

Developing a national disaster management policy.

A draft Disaster Management Manual has been completed. The Department has decided that the Disaster Management Manual will not be finalised before the Disaster Management Act has been promulgated.

Promoting the establishment of a functional institutional framework.

  • The Interdepartmental Disaster Management Committee (IDMC) has been augmented to include all possible role players (also the private sector) and meets on a regular basis to deal with disaster management related issues. The following fifteen Working Groups have been established and each Working Group has been assigned to a particular government department who must take responsibility in accordance with its roles and responsibilities re disaster management:
    Floods : Department of Water Affairs and Forestry
    Drought : Department of Agriculture
    Veld and Forest Fires : Department of Water
    Affairs and Forestry
    Environmental Emergencies: : Department of
    Environmental Affairs
    Epidemics : Department of Health
    Weather Warnings : DEAT (SA Weather Bureau)
    Urgent Response : Department of Provincial and Local Government
    Disaster Relief : Department of Social
    Displaced Persons : Department of Home Affairs
    Mine Disasters : Department of Minerals and Energy
    International Aspects : Department of Foreign
    Policy and Legislation : Department of Provincial
    and Local Government
    Training and Capacity Building : Department of
    Provincial and Local Government
    Radiation-related Incidents : Nuclear Regulator
    Telecommunications : SANDF

Training and Capacity Building.

The Norwegian Government donated R706 000-00 for an informal training programme for disaster management. The Chief Directorate: Disaster Management has appointed the ML Sultan Technikon in Durban to undertake such a programme in the four provinces where the need for training is the greatest, namely, Mpumalanga the Northern Province, Eastern Cape and KwaZulu-Natal. The ML Sultan Technikon has finalised and submitted their proposed workplan, strategy, timeframes, needs analysis budget, etc. The programme will also be monitored by a representative of the Norwegian Government.

Implementation of Strategies to establish and maintain an integrated Information Management System for Disaster Management.

As far as the development of an IT database is concerned, the following can be reported:
Flood Damage and Reinstatement System
The business requirement specification is still under development and due to time constraints from an application development point of view to deliver a workable system, it was decided to follow an incremental system development approach. All known business requirements will be taken into account and development will start from there.
Web Development
A few significant developments took place:
The Command Centre - BIGEN web development will continue and be hosted at an Independent Service Provider until the SITA bandwidth problems are solved. Once the bandwidth problems are solved, the Command Centre – BIGEN web site will be transferred to the NDMC web site.
NDMC web hosting on DWAF infrastructure will be terminated before the end of November 2000. A new more user friendly NDMC home page is already under development and will initially include:
Links to the Weather Bureau, the Department of Water Affairs and Forestry, the National Department of Agriculture and other participating structures.


  • A "WHAT’S NEW(S)" to cover topics of immediate relevance such as the fight against Foot and Mouth disease
    Regular media releases on cholera outbreak in KZN highlighted with graphical and tabular presentations.
    All media reports on the cholera outbreak have been published on the NDMC web site. The presentation is in graphical format and is supported by a tabular presentation with an overview as supplied by the provincial structures in KZN. See

Developing a monitoring and evaluation system to measure the overall impact of the implementation of disaster management.

The development of such a system is closely linked to the implementation of the strategies and activities mentioned under 5 supra,

Alleged collapse and deterioration of emergency services (fire brigade and ambulance services).

Based on the report by SAIA in this regard, a technical task team was established to address the issues of uniform norms and standards for fire brigade services and the effective funding thereof.
The said technical task team has held several meetings and the work is nearing finalisation. Uniform norms and standards have been established and it is envisaged that the funding aspect will be finalised by the end of February 2001, whereafter the matter will be submitted to Cabinet.
Since the establishment of the Fire Services Working Group mentioned in the previous report, several meetings have taken place.
Uniform norms and standards have been established and it is envisaged that the funding aspect will be finalised by the end of May 2001, whereafter the matter will be submitted to Cabinet.
A letter regarding the functioning of emergency medical services was received from the Minister of Health. The said Minister indicated:
That the Department of Health is urgently attending to the deficiencies in the functioning of these services; and
That the Health MINMEC supports the separation of Fire and Emergency and Medical Services and believes that the latter will operate more efficiently as a link within the health care chain.

3.5.3     Other Activities Accomplished.
Establishment of a SADC Disaster Management Unit
At a meeting of the SADC Council of Ministers during August 2000 it was resolved that the SADC Disaster Management Working Group (chaired by Mr LJ Buys) be disbanded and a SADC Disaster Management Committee be established. The first meeting of the SADC Disaster Management Committee and Technical Planning Seminar was held in Harare on 6 – 9 December 2000 where Mr Buys reported on the work done by the SADC Disaster Management Working Group and in terms of protocol formally handed over the chairpersonship to Namibia.
3.6        Develop and Implement a Performance Management System Appropriate to Provincial and Local Government.
3.6.1     Financial outturn by component.


Total Budget







Prog 3: Development and Support (Portion)

2 210

1 598


3.6.2     Level of Achievement of Main Outputs


Level of Achievements

3 Research reports on PMS

A report on " international review of approaches to the implementation of local government Performance Management" is completed
A report on the National Key Performance Indicators Framework and proposed set of national KPIs has been developed and is 80% complete
A study investigating the feasibility, the nature of and cost implications for establishing and managing an incentive scheme for performance management system is 50% complete and will be finalised by end of April 2001

A written policy framework on PMS

A manual that defines the policy and legislative framework and explains core components of the system as articulated in the MSA has been developed. The manual is 80% complete

Host a conference to receive input on the policy framework

The conference will convened in early June 2001 to launch PMS support framework (manuals/guidelines, national KPIs and PMS training programme

A set of regulation \ guidelines on implementing the PMS

Draft regulations on PMS have been developed, and a workshop convened with stakeholders to discuss the regulations. They are currently being revised and are almost 75 % complete.

A set of National KPIs for municipalities

As reported earlier, a report on the National Key Performance Indicators Framework and proposed set of national KPIs has been developed and is 80% complete

A number of training guides/ management guides developed on PMS

As reported earlier the first manual - that defines the policy and legislative framework and explains core components of the system as articulated in the MSA has been developed. The manual is 80% complete
The second manual give step- by- step guide to municipalities on implementing the core components of PMS. The manual is 80% complete
The third manual defines the PMS models and recommends elements thereof that could assist municipalities in linking PMS to IDPs, employee PMS and the budgetary process.

Developed training curricula and training materials for PMS training

The Directorate has advertised a tender to procure the services of service- providers to develop and deliver PMS training programme to municipalities. It is planned that the programme will be ready by the end of May.

Running PMS Pilot training programme

The Directorate has advertised a tender to procure the services of service- providers to develop and deliver PMS training programme to municipalities. It is planned that the PMS training programme will be delivered from July 2001.

An established research Agency on PMS

A PMS comes in operation from 1 July 2001 and the research agency could be established then to monitor how municipalities are establishing their PMS, develop best-practice reports and facilitate shared learning among municipalities.

Established PMS Technical Support Team for PMS Pilot

The Directorate has advertised a tender to procure the services of PMS / monitoring and evaluation experts to provide technical support on various aspects of PMS to DPLG and pilot municipalities.

Implementation of Policy Framework on Municipal International Relations for South Africa

The Directorate conducted six Provincial Workshops on the Implementation Policy Framework Municipal International Relations for South Africa. The workshops were successful. Most municipalities are conducting their international relations activities within the policy framework.

SADC Local Government Forum

The Directorate in consultation with Mozambique, Zambia and Zimbabwe successfully lobbied, for the acceptance and recognition of SADC Local Government Forum within SADC structures. The Local Government is now represented within the newly restructured SADC. This is a major achievement by the Department and South Africa in general.
The Directorate also successfully supported the Ministerial, and Technical Task Teams and the SADC Local Government Forum. Several meetings were successfully organised and generated several acceptable decisions.

Africities 2000 Summit

The Directorate successfully co-ordinated the attendance of the Minister, several members of the Executive Committee responsible for Local Government, Mayors, Councillors and officials to the Africities 2000 Summit held in Namibia during May 2000. The Minister chaired an important meeting, which adopted several resolutions. The officials compiled an informative report, which was distributed to Provinces, Municipalities and National departments.

SADC Heads of State/Government Summit

The Department attended the SADC Heads of State/Government Summit held in Windhoek, Namibia from 1-7 August 2000. The Department and fellow colleagues from Mozambique, Zambia and South Africa successfully lobbied for acceptance and recognition of the SADC Local Government.

Forum meetings of the SADC Local Government Forum and Task Teams

The Directorate successfully organised, co-ordinated and supported meetings of the SADC Technical and Ministerial Task Teams held on 24 March 2000 and 10 July 2000 in Pretoria

MIR Co-ordination Group

The Directorate co-ordinated and supported several meetings of the MIR co-ordination Group. Ongoing advice was given to municipalities on their twinning proposals

Database on twinning arrangements by municipalities

The Directorate developed a draft manual database on twinning arrangements by South African municipalities. The foundation for expansion of this project has been laid.

3.6.3     Other Activities Accomplished.
At a 'Post-Demarcation Challenges' conference in October 2000 the Minister alluded to the urgent need of developing a monitoring instrument for the interim IDP and the establishment processes for the new local government system. Subsequently, at a meeting between the Minister and the PMS directorate the need for such a monitoring instrument was re-confirmed.
The Directorate duly developed a concept paper on monitoring the implementation of the new system of local government. The primary objectives of the monitoring instrument are:
Monitor progress of the establishment/change process;
Keep the Minister/ MECs/Departments updated on developments;
Pick early warning signals for support and interventions; and
Develop a database.
High level indicators on the focus areas namely - financial issues, human resources, institutional, strategic and administrative infrastructure were developed as articulated in the Guidelines for transformation of local government. An accompanying reporting format was developed. Provinces duly submitted composite provincial status quo reports, which were analysed and developed into a National Status Quo Report on the new system of Local Government. The report has been forwarded to senior management and the Minister. A second report is being developed.
3.7        Support Services
3.7.1     Financial outturn by component


Total Budget







Prog 1: Minister




Prog 1: Management

2 265

1 619


Prog 1: Corporate Services

23 769

20 942

2 827

Prog 4: Communication Services

8 486

7 664


Prog 4: Government Motor Transport




Prog 4: PSETA





35 181

30 865

4 316

3.7.2     Level of Achievement of Main Outputs


Level of Achievements

Maintenance of standard of reporting in terms of the PFMA and Division of Revenue Act.

All reports were submitted timeously and resulted in no over-expenditure and the effective movement of funds in the Adjustment Estimate.

Consolidation and presentation of budget inputs.

Budget inputs were submitted timeously to the National Treasury and the results from the Medium Term Expenditure Committee were satisfactory.

Review of current system of financial administration.

A new system of expenditure commitment and budget control at programme manager level introduced.

Improvement in the administration of the system of procurement of supplies and services.

The application of the tendering procedures was reviewed which led to a reduction in lead times and improvement in tender adjudication.

Provision of a media liaison service for the Ministry and the Department.

All media requirements of the Minister and the Director-General were met. A revised communication strategy has been prepared.

Co-ordination of public relation campaigns.

There have been a number of very successful campaigns, such as local government transformation, local economic development, disaster relief and the anti cholera campaign.

Preparation of departmental legislation.

All legislation prepared timeously and amendments brought about by Portfolio Committee incorporated immediately. In some very urgent cases the assistance of a consultant is acknowledged.

Administration of court cases.

All court cases threatening the local government elections were resolved before the elections. Further developments in respect of these court cases depends on political interaction.
The major commercial-type cases have been concluded with real benefits to the Government.

Restructure the Department in line with its new focus and objectives.

Successfully completed the restructuring processes in the Department in co-operation with a task team appointed for this purpose.

Render human resource management and development services.

Continue to successfully administer human resource management and development processes in the Department.


Effected the appointment of personnel for the Command Centre: Emergency Reconstruction and administered the relevant staff's salaries etc.


Implemented the new all-inclusive remuneration system for senior managers in the Department.

4.1        Summary of the Process
4.1.1     As the Portfolio Committee is aware, the Department embarked on a major restructuring exercise in order to align the Department’s organisation and post structure with its new focus and objectives. This project, which has recently been finalised, was dealt with on the following basis:
Pursuant to strategic planning and the finalisation of a strategic plan, the revised organisation and post structure on senior management level was finalised as a first step.
After wide consultation with the employee unions and serving staff, agreement was reached with the said stake holders on the principles and criteria to be applied for purposes of the absorption of serving staff in the revised post structure.
Based on the outcome of a further business planning exercise, the revised post structure below senior management level was finalised during October 2000.
Serving senior managers were absorbed in the revised post structure on senior management level with effect from 22 November 2000.
The absorption of serving Deputy Directors and lower ranks in the revised post structure below senior management level was finalised at the end of February 2001 and came into effect on 1 April 2001. All serving staff on these levels have been absorbed in the revised structure.
4.1.2     As far as the filling of the remaining vacant posts are concerned, attention is invited to the following:
Vacant posts on senior management level were subjected to job evaluation and advertised. The three vacant Deputy Director-General posts have already been filled. The selection processes in respect of the other advertised senior management posts are presently receiving priority attention.
Other vacant posts will be subjected to job evaluation, where appropriate, and advertised as soon as possible. This process will be dealt with in phases and on a priority basis.

Post Level

Approved Establishment

Posts filled

Posts vacant



























































































Total Other posts



































Total SMS







All posts







Note:    Senior Management Service (SMS) is reflected in post levels 13 – 16.
            Middle management is reflected in post levels 9-12.


No related


No related documents


  • We don't have attendance info for this committee meeting

Download as PDF

You can download this page as a PDF using your browser's print functionality. Click on the "Print" button below and select the "PDF" option under destinations/printers.

See detailed instructions for your browser here.

Share this page: